The Launch of The Centre for Welfare
              Reform

             24th March 2011
     with thanks to Bircham Dyson Bell
Phillip Collins:
The Prospects for Radical Welfare
Reform?
Reform?
Aren’t things bad enough
already?
The Poverty Net
From a ‘professional gift’
          to Citizenship
and some solutions are
• Integrated tax-benefit
    system - with
    guaranteed minimum
    family incomes

•   Personalisation in
    health, care and
    education

•   Effective system of
    constitutional rights
    to support and
    control

•   Restoration of local
    communities and
    meaningful local
    autonomy
But resistance is




•   Public confused and suspicious

•   Producers threatened by accountability

•   Politicians enjoy their patronage of the welfare
    system

•   Civil servants are experts in protecting the
    status quo
So howfor change still needs to be made
           will change happen
• The case

•   People need to be engaged and involved

•   More thought, research and debate is
    required

•   Further action, experiment and innovation is
    needed

Create a community of
passionate, thoughtful
and practical people -
committed to equality &
diversity
The Centre for
Welfare Reform is:

A growing
community
of Fellows working
independently and
together...
to implement
practical
innovations within
the current system...
to share what we
learn...
quietly, without
fuss or competition.
                  •    Values - human equality,
                       and the value of diversity

                  •    R&D - focused research,
                       practical development
                       and publication

                  •    Network - partners,
                       Fellows, subscribers

                  •    Tiny hub - low cost,
                       small, private, social
                       enterprise


          Do good work and lie low - Lao Tzu
Clare Hyde MBE
Local Justice: family-focused
•   72% of male and 70% of female sentenced prisoners suffer
    from 2 or more mental health disorders. 20% of prisoners
    have 4 of the 5 major mental health disorders.

•   71% of children in custody have been involved with, or in
    the care of, social services before entering custody.

•   74% of children released from custody in 2008 reoffended
    within a year.

•   83,000 in prison: 47% of adults are re-convicted within 1
    year of being released (for those serving sentences of less
    than 1 year this increases to 60%). For those who have
    served more than 10 previous custodial sentences the rate
    of reoffending rises to 76%

•   Over half the women in prison report having suffered
to the power of 4
1. Women and Children First - Start
   with a focus on women, children
   and families.
2. Local Justice Reinvestment - Create
   a new financial system where local
   areas have an incentive to invest in
   their own communities.
3. Total Place - Change the way
   funding is used locally.
4. Personalisation - Use
   personalisation as the key to
   unlock family problems.
Family Justice...
Vidhya Alakeson
Active Patient: the real power shift in the
• Effective chronic disease
  management depends more
  on people than doctors
• Individual preferences matter
  to the outcomes of healthcare
• Healthcare should be about
  improving people’s lives not
  just providing a service
• Current evidence for more
  individual control in health is
  limited but positive
Craig Dearden-Phillips MBE
Outside the State: the civil society


My first social
business was about
helping people repair
the damage done to
them by public
services
My second social business is about
helping to liberate people inside public
services

...to ‘step out’ into the needs-
marketplace
We have reached
    peak state:

 The era of ever-
  more politically
directed spend is
             over
This is what
public
services feel
like to a
great many
people who
depend on
them
Question

So how do we
provide
personalised
services for
all these
people?
Answer

plurality of
provision

AND

robust protection
for diverse,
inclusive public
service markets
Coalition’s
     Dilemma

 Big Society =

    Small Scale
          Local
        Diverse
 Co-produced,
     Innovative
Entrepreneurial
Coalition’s Dilemma

Reality could =

Efficiency agenda
Private Monopoly
Low innovation
Low levels
of social capital
Which will Prevail?

                                 Right to
Any Willing
Provider
Public Services
                  Vs.     Challenge and
                            Right to Run
                         (in the Localism
White Paper
                                      Bill)
                         Social Value Bill
• Support the emergence of
  genuine - social enterprise
  providers
• Provide a bulwark against
  private monopolies
• Create for mutual
  ownership to show its
  benefits
• Demand higher levels of
  social capital and co-
  production
Dr Pippa Murray
A Fair Start: a personalised pathway for
disabled children and their families
Personalised Pathway
I am
       excited about
    personalisation as I
 think it can really change
things for disabled people.
  Personal budgets have
 allowed me to have more
    control over my own
        support and
But, what do we need to consider


• What do we mean by
  fairness?
• What are our core
  values?
• How do keep our values
  at the centre of our
  innovations?
Simon Duffy
Family Security: reforming tax and

    The Current tax-benefit system:

•   Poor incentives - undermines citizenship,
    earning, saving, personal development and risk-
    taking

•   Wrong focus - undermines family life, women and
    children

•   No rights - does not establish clear and
    transparent securities that are essential for
    citizenship
The current system panders to critical
voters and abandons any universal
We need a new deal - one we understand
1. Focus on family security - remove stigma and
   complexity

2. Integrate tax and benefits - remove stigma and
   complexity

3. Take means-testing out of benefits - we’ve
   already paid our taxes

4. Define minimum level of eligibility for all -
   transparently define a level sufficient for citizenship

5. Constitutional rights to support and control -
   clear law that can be tested and protected

6. Robust organisational framework - escape the era
   of ‘organisational fixes’ and the on-going fiddling
We will do the right thing
-
eventually -
after we’ve tried every
feasible alternative




                                      Honour can exist
                              anywhere, love can exist
                                              anywhere,
                             but justice can exist only
                             among people who found
                               their relationships upon
                                                     it.
Emails for Fellows:                   A Big Thank
                                  You to everyone
pippa@ibkinitiatives.com
                                         at BDB for
clare@foundationforfamilies.org.uk supporting this
                                            event -
craig@stepping-out.biz              especially Liz,
                                        Alexandra,
vidhya.alakeson@resolutionfoundatio
                                  Angela, David &
n.org
                                              Nigel
                    The Centre for Welfare Reform
                    The Quadrant, 99 Parkway Avenue, Parkway Business Park
                    Sheffield, S9 4WG
                    T +44 114 251 1790 | M +44 7729 7729 41
                    admin@centreforwelfarereform.org
                    Get a free subscription at: www.centreforwelfarereform.org

 © 2011 Rights Reserved. Full copyright details at www.centreforwelfarereform.org

(166) launch of the centre (westminster, march 2011)

  • 1.
    The Launch ofThe Centre for Welfare Reform 24th March 2011 with thanks to Bircham Dyson Bell
  • 2.
    Phillip Collins: The Prospectsfor Radical Welfare
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
    From a ‘professionalgift’ to Citizenship
  • 6.
    and some solutionsare • Integrated tax-benefit system - with guaranteed minimum family incomes • Personalisation in health, care and education • Effective system of constitutional rights to support and control • Restoration of local communities and meaningful local autonomy
  • 7.
    But resistance is • Public confused and suspicious • Producers threatened by accountability • Politicians enjoy their patronage of the welfare system • Civil servants are experts in protecting the status quo
  • 8.
    So howfor changestill needs to be made will change happen • The case • People need to be engaged and involved • More thought, research and debate is required • Further action, experiment and innovation is needed Create a community of passionate, thoughtful and practical people - committed to equality & diversity
  • 9.
    The Centre for WelfareReform is: A growing community of Fellows working independently and together...
  • 10.
  • 11.
    to share whatwe learn...
  • 12.
    quietly, without fuss orcompetition. • Values - human equality, and the value of diversity • R&D - focused research, practical development and publication • Network - partners, Fellows, subscribers • Tiny hub - low cost, small, private, social enterprise Do good work and lie low - Lao Tzu
  • 13.
    Clare Hyde MBE LocalJustice: family-focused • 72% of male and 70% of female sentenced prisoners suffer from 2 or more mental health disorders. 20% of prisoners have 4 of the 5 major mental health disorders. • 71% of children in custody have been involved with, or in the care of, social services before entering custody. • 74% of children released from custody in 2008 reoffended within a year. • 83,000 in prison: 47% of adults are re-convicted within 1 year of being released (for those serving sentences of less than 1 year this increases to 60%). For those who have served more than 10 previous custodial sentences the rate of reoffending rises to 76% • Over half the women in prison report having suffered
  • 14.
    to the powerof 4 1. Women and Children First - Start with a focus on women, children and families. 2. Local Justice Reinvestment - Create a new financial system where local areas have an incentive to invest in their own communities. 3. Total Place - Change the way funding is used locally. 4. Personalisation - Use personalisation as the key to unlock family problems.
  • 15.
  • 17.
    Vidhya Alakeson Active Patient:the real power shift in the • Effective chronic disease management depends more on people than doctors • Individual preferences matter to the outcomes of healthcare • Healthcare should be about improving people’s lives not just providing a service • Current evidence for more individual control in health is limited but positive
  • 20.
    Craig Dearden-Phillips MBE Outsidethe State: the civil society My first social business was about helping people repair the damage done to them by public services
  • 21.
    My second socialbusiness is about helping to liberate people inside public services ...to ‘step out’ into the needs- marketplace
  • 22.
    We have reached peak state: The era of ever- more politically directed spend is over
  • 23.
    This is what public servicesfeel like to a great many people who depend on them
  • 24.
    Question So how dowe provide personalised services for all these people?
  • 25.
    Answer plurality of provision AND robust protection fordiverse, inclusive public service markets
  • 26.
    Coalition’s Dilemma Big Society = Small Scale Local Diverse Co-produced, Innovative Entrepreneurial
  • 27.
    Coalition’s Dilemma Reality could= Efficiency agenda Private Monopoly Low innovation Low levels of social capital
  • 28.
    Which will Prevail? Right to Any Willing Provider Public Services Vs. Challenge and Right to Run (in the Localism White Paper Bill) Social Value Bill
  • 29.
    • Support theemergence of genuine - social enterprise providers • Provide a bulwark against private monopolies • Create for mutual ownership to show its benefits • Demand higher levels of social capital and co- production
  • 30.
    Dr Pippa Murray AFair Start: a personalised pathway for disabled children and their families
  • 31.
  • 32.
    I am excited about personalisation as I think it can really change things for disabled people. Personal budgets have allowed me to have more control over my own support and
  • 33.
    But, what dowe need to consider • What do we mean by fairness? • What are our core values? • How do keep our values at the centre of our innovations?
  • 34.
    Simon Duffy Family Security:reforming tax and The Current tax-benefit system: • Poor incentives - undermines citizenship, earning, saving, personal development and risk- taking • Wrong focus - undermines family life, women and children • No rights - does not establish clear and transparent securities that are essential for citizenship
  • 35.
    The current systempanders to critical voters and abandons any universal
  • 37.
    We need anew deal - one we understand 1. Focus on family security - remove stigma and complexity 2. Integrate tax and benefits - remove stigma and complexity 3. Take means-testing out of benefits - we’ve already paid our taxes 4. Define minimum level of eligibility for all - transparently define a level sufficient for citizenship 5. Constitutional rights to support and control - clear law that can be tested and protected 6. Robust organisational framework - escape the era of ‘organisational fixes’ and the on-going fiddling
  • 38.
    We will dothe right thing - eventually - after we’ve tried every feasible alternative Honour can exist anywhere, love can exist anywhere, but justice can exist only among people who found their relationships upon it.
  • 39.
    Emails for Fellows: A Big Thank You to everyone [email protected] at BDB for [email protected] supporting this event - [email protected] especially Liz, Alexandra, vidhya.alakeson@resolutionfoundatio Angela, David & n.org Nigel The Centre for Welfare Reform The Quadrant, 99 Parkway Avenue, Parkway Business Park Sheffield, S9 4WG T +44 114 251 1790 | M +44 7729 7729 41 [email protected] Get a free subscription at: www.centreforwelfarereform.org © 2011 Rights Reserved. Full copyright details at www.centreforwelfarereform.org

Editor's Notes

  • #2 \n
  • #3 \n
  • #4 \n
  • #5 \n
  • #6 \n
  • #7 \n
  • #8 \n
  • #9 \n
  • #10 \n
  • #11 \n
  • #12 \n
  • #13 \n
  • #14 \n
  • #15 \n
  • #16 \n
  • #17 \n
  • #18 \n
  • #19 \n
  • #20 \n
  • #21 \n
  • #22 \n
  • #23 \n
  • #24 \n
  • #25 \n
  • #26 \n
  • #27 \n
  • #28 \n
  • #29 \n
  • #30 \n
  • #31 The inability of current services, health, education and social care to make a sustained difference to the lives of disabled children and their families results in distress and inequality. The way that support to disabled families is part and parcel of safeguarding and child protection takes away from the simple fact that most disabled families simply want help to get on with the business of family life. Parents want to give their children the best childhood they can and, in doing that, equip them for adulthood. Parents are looking for straightforward solutions to the pressures they face: an extra pair of hands to help out with household chores, a night’s sleep, someone to help their disabled son go to cubs or their disabled daughter go to a dance class, flexibility to use support when they need it most. Disabled children want opportunities for friendship and fun; their brothers and sisters want to hang out with their friends and have quality family time. The Personalised Pathway offers the opportunity for these things to happen in a way that transforms family life; provides greater equity; makes things fairer, and allows scarce resources to go further. \n\n
  • #32 The inability of current services, health, education and social care to make a sustained difference to the lives of disabled children and their families results in distress and inequality. The way that support to disabled families is part and parcel of safeguarding and child protection takes away from the simple fact that most disabled families simply want help to get on with the business of family life. Parents want to give their children the best childhood they can and, in doing that, equip them for adulthood. Parents are looking for straightforward solutions to the pressures they face: an extra pair of hands to help out with household chores, a night’s sleep, someone to help their disabled son go to cubs or their disabled daughter go to a dance class, flexibility to use support when they need it most. Disabled children want opportunities for friendship and fun; their brothers and sisters want to hang out with their friends and have quality family time. The Personalised Pathway offers the opportunity for these things to happen in a way that transforms family life; provides greater equity; makes things fairer, and allows scarce resources to go further. \n\n
  • #33 Nadia is a young woman whose family have ensured she has been included in the mainstream – in the family and in the local community. Nadia has been brought up to believe in herself – she has high aspirations. At the age of 18 she has a team of personal assistants and has plans to study, travel and work. \n\n
  • #34 In order to work towards giving vulnerable families a fair start we have to begin thinking and talking about what we mean by fairness? What are the values we – as citizens – want our society to be built on? We live at a time when our global political system is rife with unethical practice and a lack of integrity. Values have been replaced by doctrines. What goes for political dialogue is actually a hostile exchange of blame and one up-manship. Political rhetoric is shown to be no more than empty promises as time and again our leaders fail to lead by example. \n\nA Fair Start for disabled children and their families will only be possible when we engage with some of these fundamental issues. And we have to start with ourselves. As we innovate we have to do so with honesty, integrity, love and humility. As leaders we have to believe in ourselves, be prepared to make ourselves vulnerable, and let others see who we are. It is only when we have compassion for ourselves that we will show true compassion to others. When individuals doing this come together, we cannot help but create the conditions necessary for a fair society. \n\nThat is why I am so pleased that Simon has set up the Centre for Welfare Reform, and proud to be associated with it.\n\n
  • #35 \n
  • #36 \n
  • #37 \n
  • #38 \n
  • #39 \n
  • #40 \n