Evidence for Recombination of
Sr2 and Fhb1
#bgri2014 #Borlaug100
R.M. DePauw, R.D. Cuthbert, R.E. Knox, S.
Kumar, A. Singh, A.K. Singh, H. Campbell, S.
Bhavani, D. Singh, F.R. Clarke, and T. Fetch
Outline
•  Background on genes Sr2 and Fhb1
•  Objective: to generate evidence of recombination of
Sr2 and Fhb1 resistance from repulsion to coupling
•  Genetic Materials: Carberry/AC Cadillac
•  Evidence:
–  Pedigree
–  Phenotype
–  FHB resistance with PBC and stem rust resistance
–  Haplotype
2
Background: Sr2
–  Durable adult plant stem rust resistant gene
–  Partial resistance
–  Enhances expression of other Lr and Yr rust resistance genes
–  3BS (Yaroslav emmer to Hope and H.44-24 etc)
–  QTL analysis of stem rust co-segregation with (microsatellite)
markers in the region of gwm533 and gwm493
–  SNP marker XcsSr2 co-segregated with Sr2which is closest
reported marker to date (Mago et al. 2011)
–  Tightly linked to PBC (Kota et al. 2006)
–  Fine mapping studies have identified recombinants in the region
of gwm533 and gwm493 (Kota et al. 2006, McNeil et al. 2008)
Background: Fhb1
–  Confers resistance to FHB, a major fungal disease causing loss
of yield and grain quality (mycotoxins harmful to human and
animal health).
–  Resistance on 3BS (from landrace Taiwan wheat to Sumai 3).
–  QTL analysis of FHB detected co-segregation with
(microsatellite) markers in the region of gwm533 and gwm493.
–  Current most tightly linked markers are Xsnp7 and Xsnp11,
Xsts256, and Xsts3B-138 (Bernardo et al. 2012)
–  Fine mapping studies have identified recombinants in the
region of gwm533 and gwm493 (Cuthbert et al. 2006, Bernardo et al. 2012).
Background:
•  Sr2 and Fhb1 are linked with QTL in the Sr2/Fhb1 region
of gwm533 and gwm493 on 3BS.
•  ~ 5 cM apart (Bernardo et al. 2012)
•  Sr2 and Fhb1 are currently reported only in repulsion.
6
3B
3BL-2 0.22
3BL-3 0.41
3BS-1 0.33
3BS-8 0.78
3BS-3 0.87
3BS-2 0.56
3BS-5 0.20
3BL-11 0.81
3BL-7 0.63
3BL-10 0.50
3BL-8 0.25
3BS-6 0.54
Marker	
   Start	
  (bp)	
   End	
  (bp)	
   Amplicon	
  
csSr2	
   -­‐	
   -­‐	
   172/112	
  
225/112	
  
gwm389	
   -­‐	
   -­‐	
   139/115	
  
gwm533	
   -­‐	
   -­‐	
   118/142	
  
Sr2/Pbc	
  
ctg0011	
  (1.2	
  Mb)	
  
CA746621	
   393632	
   394412	
   761	
  
3B042G11	
   398244	
   398079	
   183	
  
CD882879	
   468666	
   468473	
   213	
  
BEX_2	
   562544	
   562042	
   522	
  
3B028F08	
   564671	
   564447	
   243	
  
CA640157	
   1013696	
   1014177	
   482	
  
Xsnp3BS-­‐2	
   1103249	
   1102799	
   470	
  
Fhb1	
  
ctg0954	
  (3.1	
  Mb)	
  
STS3B-­‐142	
   1579003	
   1578866	
   157	
  
STS3B-­‐206	
   1794973	
   1795201	
   247	
  
cA6078	
   2162814	
   2162981	
   187	
  
STS3B-­‐138	
   2193637	
   2193343	
   314	
  
snp3BS-­‐4	
   2460842	
   2460286	
   578	
  
STS3B-­‐80	
   2461261	
   2461081	
   200	
  
cA6059	
   2463669	
   2463870	
   221	
  
umn10	
  (snp3BS-­‐11)	
   2467047	
   2466838	
   229	
  
cA6061	
   2839954	
   2840202	
   268	
  
gwm493	
   -­‐	
   -­‐	
   195/138	
  
Norman Borlaug,
1970Combine Sr2 and FHB
Norman Borlaug,
Objective:
•  To identify a recombinant of Sr2 and Fhb1 in
coupling from the doubled haploid population of
Carberry/AC Cadillac
•  Null Hypothesis: PBC(Sr2) and low FHB will not be
expressed together in a DH line
•  Evidence for recombination: a DH line which
expresses both PBC and low FHB symptoms
Parental Materials
•  AC Cadillac
–  resistant to stem rust
–  moderately susceptible to FHB
–  expresses molecular marker products linked to Sr2
but not to Fhb1 resistance
•  Carberry
–  resistant to stem rust
–  moderately resistant to FHB
–  displays molecular marker products linked to Fhb1
but not to Sr2 resistance
•  Both parents have gene Lr34/Yr18/Sr57/Pm38/Ltn1 (7DS)
Genotyping of the population
•  Carberry/AC Cadillac
–  Phenotyped 261 DH line subset of doubled haploid
population of 812 lines
•  Genotyped with DArT® (578), SSR (54), BAC-derived
(3), CAPS (3), and STS (3) molecular markers
including:
•  SSR marker Xumn10 (SNP: Xsnp3BS-11) is reported to be
most diagnostic for Fhb1 (Bernardo et al. 2012)
•  XcsSr2 is reported to be most diagnostic for Sr2 (Mago et al.
2011)
Evidence: Pedigree
	
   AC Cadillac	
   Carberry	
   Thatcher	
   Hope	
   H44-24	
   Marquis	
  
Yaroslav
Emmer	
  
Sumai
#3	
  
AC Cadillac	
   1.00	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
  
Carberry	
   0.16	
   1.00	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
  
Thatcher	
   0.60	
   0.23	
   1.00	
   	
   	
   	
   	
   	
  
Hope	
   0.16	
   0.15	
   0.25	
   1.00	
   	
   	
   	
   	
  
H44-24	
   0.16	
   0.12	
   0.25	
   0.50	
   1.00	
   	
   	
   	
  
Marquis	
   0.31	
   0.18	
   0.50	
   0.50	
   0.50	
   1.00	
   	
   	
  
Yaroslav
Emmer	
   0.01	
   0.05	
   0.00	
   0.50	
   0.50	
   0.00	
   1.00	
   	
  
Sumai #3	
   0.01	
   0.03	
   0.00	
   0.00	
   0.00	
   0.00	
   0.00	
   1.00	
  
•  Both AC Cadillac and Carberry have Yaroslav emmer in their
genealogy
•  Only Carberry has Sumai #3 in genealogy
Sr2 potential sources
Fhb1 potential source
Evidence: Stem Rust and Genetic analysis
Stem rust field nurseries:
• Njoro, Kenya: 2010, 11, 12, 13
• Swift Current, Canada: 2011 and 2012, and 2013
Stem Rust QTL (Singh et al. TAG 2013)
• AC Cadillac contributed stem rust resistance QTL on
chromosomes 2B, 3B, 5B, 6D, 7B and 7D
• Carberry contributed resistance QTL on 4B and 5A.
• Epistatic interactions were observed between loci on
6D and 3B
Yellow Rust
•  Swift Current, Canada in 2011
•  Lincoln, NZ: 2012, 2013
•  Njoro, Kenya: 2009, 2011
Yellow Rust QTL
•  AC Cadillac was a source of yellow rust resistance
QTL on chromosomes 2A, 2B, 3A, 3B, 5B, and 7B
•  Carberry was a source of resistance on
chromosomes 2B, 4B, and 7A. (Singh et al. 2014)
Evidence: Yellow Rust and Genetic Analysis
Co-location:
•  Yellow rust resistance QTL co-localized with stem
rust resistance QTL on 2B, 3B, and 7B.
•  Sr2 and Yr30 reported in same region 3BS
Evidence: Genetic analysis
Epistatic Interactions:
•  Several epistatic interactions were identified both
for yellow and leaf rust resistance QTL
Trait Environment QTLa
1 QTLb
2
Yr severity Kenya QYr.spa-3B .1 QYr.spa-2B
Lr severity Canada QLr.spa-3B QLr.spa-4B
Yr infection response New Zealand QYr.spa-3B.1 QYr.spa-2A
Yr infection response New Zealand QYr.spa-3B.1 QYr.spa-7B.2
First QTL1
Second QTL2
Source: Singh et al. TAG 2014 (in press)
Evidence:
Evidence: Fusarium Head Blight
•  FHB nurseries
•  PLP 2010, 2011, 2013
•  Variables: Incidence, Severity:
Disease Index = (Incidence * Severity)/100
•  QTL in AC Cadillac 4B
•  QTL in Carberry 3B, 5A, 6D
Evidence: Pseudo Black Chaff
•  PBC is a dark pigmentation that may occur on the
glumes, peduncle and below stem internodes, but its
level of expression varies with genetic background and
environment.
•  Linkage of Sr2 and PBC has not been broken in about 90
yrs
•  PBC scoring: an expression in 6 nurseries out of 12
•  QTL for pseudo-black chaff:
–  AC Cadillac 2B and 3B
–  Carberry 6A
Pseudo Black Chaff
Carberry/AC Cadillac
DH line B0767&AB019
6
4
2
0
0 25	
   50	
   75	
   100	
  
FHB	
  Index	
  
Pseudo	
  black	
  chaff	
  (#Environment)	
  
	
  
	
  
	
  
	
  
	
  
	
  
	
  
	
  
1	
  	
  	
  2	
  	
  	
  3	
  	
  	
  4	
  	
  	
  5	
  	
  	
  6	
  	
  	
  7	
  	
  	
  8	
  	
  9	
  	
  11	
  	
  12	
  	
  	
  
	
  Color	
  code	
  
No.	
  of	
  lines	
  
Carberry	
  
AC	
  Cadillac	
  
B0767&: Scatter plot of 261 DH lines
Pseudo Black Chaff and low FHB
Genotypic Data Phenotyping
Carberry/AC Cadillac: Haplotpye + Phenotype
Sr2/Pbc	
   Fhb1	
  
gwm389
csSr2
3B028F08
3B042G11
gwm533
wPt-7341
wPt-8855
wPt-2757
wPt-8446
wPt-1620
wPt-7984
BArc75
wPt-3260
wPt-744251
wPt-1484
wPt-10972
wPt-9066
Barc147
sts3B-142
UMN10
FhbIndex
PBC(#Environment)
SeveritySr
InfectiontypeSr
AC Cadillac
A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A 31 6 3 R
Carberry
B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B 22 1 5 R
B0767&AT073
B B B A A - B B B B B B B B B B B B B B 15 1 3 R
B0767&BF021
B B B A A B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B 12 2 10 R
B0767&BF115
B B A A A B B B B - B B B B B B B B B B 5 1 15 R
Summary of evidence
•  Carberry/AC Cadillac: 261 DH phenotyped
•  Evidence provided for Sr2 and FHB1: pedigree,
phenotype, genotype
•  DH lines expressed variation for: FHB; Stem, Yellow, &
Leaf rust resistance; PBC
•  QTL on 3B detected for FHB; Stem, Yellow, & Leaf rust
resistance; PBC
•  Co-location of QTL for Sr and Yr and Epistatic
interactions Sr and Yr, and Sr and Lr
•  Recovered recombinants with PBC and FHB resistance
•  Haplotype recombination in Sr2/Fbh1 region based on
markers reported to be closest linked
Acknowledgements
•  Colleagues and Support Staff at:
•  AAFC, Swift Current, Lethbridge and Winnipeg,
Canada
•  CIMMYT, Kenya
•  KARI, Njoro, Kenya
•  Plant and Food Research, Lincoln, New Zealand
•  Funders:
–  levy by Farmers of western Canada administered by
Western Grains Research Foundation
–  AAFC: Growing Forward and core funding
Yield trial plots,
KARI, Njoro,
Kenya, 1971
Photo Credit: R. M. DePauw

2014 bgri de pauw presentation

  • 1.
    Evidence for Recombinationof Sr2 and Fhb1 #bgri2014 #Borlaug100 R.M. DePauw, R.D. Cuthbert, R.E. Knox, S. Kumar, A. Singh, A.K. Singh, H. Campbell, S. Bhavani, D. Singh, F.R. Clarke, and T. Fetch
  • 2.
    Outline •  Background ongenes Sr2 and Fhb1 •  Objective: to generate evidence of recombination of Sr2 and Fhb1 resistance from repulsion to coupling •  Genetic Materials: Carberry/AC Cadillac •  Evidence: –  Pedigree –  Phenotype –  FHB resistance with PBC and stem rust resistance –  Haplotype 2
  • 3.
    Background: Sr2 –  Durableadult plant stem rust resistant gene –  Partial resistance –  Enhances expression of other Lr and Yr rust resistance genes –  3BS (Yaroslav emmer to Hope and H.44-24 etc) –  QTL analysis of stem rust co-segregation with (microsatellite) markers in the region of gwm533 and gwm493 –  SNP marker XcsSr2 co-segregated with Sr2which is closest reported marker to date (Mago et al. 2011) –  Tightly linked to PBC (Kota et al. 2006) –  Fine mapping studies have identified recombinants in the region of gwm533 and gwm493 (Kota et al. 2006, McNeil et al. 2008)
  • 4.
    Background: Fhb1 –  Confersresistance to FHB, a major fungal disease causing loss of yield and grain quality (mycotoxins harmful to human and animal health). –  Resistance on 3BS (from landrace Taiwan wheat to Sumai 3). –  QTL analysis of FHB detected co-segregation with (microsatellite) markers in the region of gwm533 and gwm493. –  Current most tightly linked markers are Xsnp7 and Xsnp11, Xsts256, and Xsts3B-138 (Bernardo et al. 2012) –  Fine mapping studies have identified recombinants in the region of gwm533 and gwm493 (Cuthbert et al. 2006, Bernardo et al. 2012).
  • 5.
    Background: •  Sr2 andFhb1 are linked with QTL in the Sr2/Fhb1 region of gwm533 and gwm493 on 3BS. •  ~ 5 cM apart (Bernardo et al. 2012) •  Sr2 and Fhb1 are currently reported only in repulsion.
  • 6.
    6 3B 3BL-2 0.22 3BL-3 0.41 3BS-10.33 3BS-8 0.78 3BS-3 0.87 3BS-2 0.56 3BS-5 0.20 3BL-11 0.81 3BL-7 0.63 3BL-10 0.50 3BL-8 0.25 3BS-6 0.54 Marker   Start  (bp)   End  (bp)   Amplicon   csSr2   -­‐   -­‐   172/112   225/112   gwm389   -­‐   -­‐   139/115   gwm533   -­‐   -­‐   118/142   Sr2/Pbc   ctg0011  (1.2  Mb)   CA746621   393632   394412   761   3B042G11   398244   398079   183   CD882879   468666   468473   213   BEX_2   562544   562042   522   3B028F08   564671   564447   243   CA640157   1013696   1014177   482   Xsnp3BS-­‐2   1103249   1102799   470   Fhb1   ctg0954  (3.1  Mb)   STS3B-­‐142   1579003   1578866   157   STS3B-­‐206   1794973   1795201   247   cA6078   2162814   2162981   187   STS3B-­‐138   2193637   2193343   314   snp3BS-­‐4   2460842   2460286   578   STS3B-­‐80   2461261   2461081   200   cA6059   2463669   2463870   221   umn10  (snp3BS-­‐11)   2467047   2466838   229   cA6061   2839954   2840202   268   gwm493   -­‐   -­‐   195/138  
  • 7.
    Norman Borlaug, 1970Combine Sr2and FHB Norman Borlaug,
  • 8.
    Objective: •  To identifya recombinant of Sr2 and Fhb1 in coupling from the doubled haploid population of Carberry/AC Cadillac •  Null Hypothesis: PBC(Sr2) and low FHB will not be expressed together in a DH line •  Evidence for recombination: a DH line which expresses both PBC and low FHB symptoms
  • 9.
    Parental Materials •  ACCadillac –  resistant to stem rust –  moderately susceptible to FHB –  expresses molecular marker products linked to Sr2 but not to Fhb1 resistance •  Carberry –  resistant to stem rust –  moderately resistant to FHB –  displays molecular marker products linked to Fhb1 but not to Sr2 resistance •  Both parents have gene Lr34/Yr18/Sr57/Pm38/Ltn1 (7DS)
  • 10.
    Genotyping of thepopulation •  Carberry/AC Cadillac –  Phenotyped 261 DH line subset of doubled haploid population of 812 lines •  Genotyped with DArT® (578), SSR (54), BAC-derived (3), CAPS (3), and STS (3) molecular markers including: •  SSR marker Xumn10 (SNP: Xsnp3BS-11) is reported to be most diagnostic for Fhb1 (Bernardo et al. 2012) •  XcsSr2 is reported to be most diagnostic for Sr2 (Mago et al. 2011)
  • 11.
    Evidence: Pedigree  AC Cadillac   Carberry   Thatcher   Hope   H44-24   Marquis   Yaroslav Emmer   Sumai #3   AC Cadillac   1.00                 Carberry   0.16   1.00               Thatcher   0.60   0.23   1.00             Hope   0.16   0.15   0.25   1.00           H44-24   0.16   0.12   0.25   0.50   1.00         Marquis   0.31   0.18   0.50   0.50   0.50   1.00       Yaroslav Emmer   0.01   0.05   0.00   0.50   0.50   0.00   1.00     Sumai #3   0.01   0.03   0.00   0.00   0.00   0.00   0.00   1.00   •  Both AC Cadillac and Carberry have Yaroslav emmer in their genealogy •  Only Carberry has Sumai #3 in genealogy
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
    Evidence: Stem Rustand Genetic analysis Stem rust field nurseries: • Njoro, Kenya: 2010, 11, 12, 13 • Swift Current, Canada: 2011 and 2012, and 2013 Stem Rust QTL (Singh et al. TAG 2013) • AC Cadillac contributed stem rust resistance QTL on chromosomes 2B, 3B, 5B, 6D, 7B and 7D • Carberry contributed resistance QTL on 4B and 5A. • Epistatic interactions were observed between loci on 6D and 3B
  • 15.
    Yellow Rust •  SwiftCurrent, Canada in 2011 •  Lincoln, NZ: 2012, 2013 •  Njoro, Kenya: 2009, 2011 Yellow Rust QTL •  AC Cadillac was a source of yellow rust resistance QTL on chromosomes 2A, 2B, 3A, 3B, 5B, and 7B •  Carberry was a source of resistance on chromosomes 2B, 4B, and 7A. (Singh et al. 2014) Evidence: Yellow Rust and Genetic Analysis
  • 16.
    Co-location: •  Yellow rustresistance QTL co-localized with stem rust resistance QTL on 2B, 3B, and 7B. •  Sr2 and Yr30 reported in same region 3BS Evidence: Genetic analysis
  • 17.
    Epistatic Interactions: •  Severalepistatic interactions were identified both for yellow and leaf rust resistance QTL Trait Environment QTLa 1 QTLb 2 Yr severity Kenya QYr.spa-3B .1 QYr.spa-2B Lr severity Canada QLr.spa-3B QLr.spa-4B Yr infection response New Zealand QYr.spa-3B.1 QYr.spa-2A Yr infection response New Zealand QYr.spa-3B.1 QYr.spa-7B.2 First QTL1 Second QTL2 Source: Singh et al. TAG 2014 (in press) Evidence:
  • 18.
    Evidence: Fusarium HeadBlight •  FHB nurseries •  PLP 2010, 2011, 2013 •  Variables: Incidence, Severity: Disease Index = (Incidence * Severity)/100 •  QTL in AC Cadillac 4B •  QTL in Carberry 3B, 5A, 6D
  • 19.
    Evidence: Pseudo BlackChaff •  PBC is a dark pigmentation that may occur on the glumes, peduncle and below stem internodes, but its level of expression varies with genetic background and environment. •  Linkage of Sr2 and PBC has not been broken in about 90 yrs •  PBC scoring: an expression in 6 nurseries out of 12 •  QTL for pseudo-black chaff: –  AC Cadillac 2B and 3B –  Carberry 6A
  • 20.
    Pseudo Black Chaff Carberry/ACCadillac DH line B0767&AB019
  • 21.
    6 4 2 0 0 25  50   75   100   FHB  Index   Pseudo  black  chaff  (#Environment)                   1      2      3      4      5      6      7      8    9    11    12        Color  code   No.  of  lines   Carberry   AC  Cadillac   B0767&: Scatter plot of 261 DH lines
  • 22.
    Pseudo Black Chaffand low FHB
  • 23.
    Genotypic Data Phenotyping Carberry/ACCadillac: Haplotpye + Phenotype Sr2/Pbc   Fhb1   gwm389 csSr2 3B028F08 3B042G11 gwm533 wPt-7341 wPt-8855 wPt-2757 wPt-8446 wPt-1620 wPt-7984 BArc75 wPt-3260 wPt-744251 wPt-1484 wPt-10972 wPt-9066 Barc147 sts3B-142 UMN10 FhbIndex PBC(#Environment) SeveritySr InfectiontypeSr AC Cadillac A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A 31 6 3 R Carberry B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B 22 1 5 R B0767&AT073 B B B A A - B B B B B B B B B B B B B B 15 1 3 R B0767&BF021 B B B A A B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B 12 2 10 R B0767&BF115 B B A A A B B B B - B B B B B B B B B B 5 1 15 R
  • 24.
    Summary of evidence • Carberry/AC Cadillac: 261 DH phenotyped •  Evidence provided for Sr2 and FHB1: pedigree, phenotype, genotype •  DH lines expressed variation for: FHB; Stem, Yellow, & Leaf rust resistance; PBC •  QTL on 3B detected for FHB; Stem, Yellow, & Leaf rust resistance; PBC •  Co-location of QTL for Sr and Yr and Epistatic interactions Sr and Yr, and Sr and Lr •  Recovered recombinants with PBC and FHB resistance •  Haplotype recombination in Sr2/Fbh1 region based on markers reported to be closest linked
  • 25.
    Acknowledgements •  Colleagues andSupport Staff at: •  AAFC, Swift Current, Lethbridge and Winnipeg, Canada •  CIMMYT, Kenya •  KARI, Njoro, Kenya •  Plant and Food Research, Lincoln, New Zealand •  Funders: –  levy by Farmers of western Canada administered by Western Grains Research Foundation –  AAFC: Growing Forward and core funding
  • 26.
    Yield trial plots, KARI,Njoro, Kenya, 1971 Photo Credit: R. M. DePauw