#C3NY
CREATIVE INNOVATION
#C3NY
WALKING A TIGHTROPE:
BALANCING ORGANIC TRAFFIC GROWTH WITH
CONTENT MONETIZATION REQUIREMENTS
Sr. Director of Optimized Services,
MoreVisibility
Matt Crowley
Clinical Editor, NursingCenter
Lisa Bonsall, MSN, RN, CRNP
#C3NY 2
Lisa Bonsall, MSN, RN, CRNP
Presenters
Matt Crowley
Sr. Director of Optimized Services, MoreVisibilityClinical Editor, NursingCenter
#C3NY 3
Walking on a tightrope
Heading for the twilight zone
Where the future never makes it
Until the past has gone
--”Walking on a Tightrope” by Percy Mayfield
Source: https://www.discogs.com/Percy-Mayfield-Walking-On-A-Tightrope/release/3177405
#C3NY
Revenue (Registrations)
#C3NY 5
Do you publish content?
#C3NY 6
How do you monetize content?
#C3NY 7
Do you focus on growing
organic traffic?
#C3NY 8
Do you focus on growing
organic revenue?
#C3NY 9
Have you thought about
gating your content?
#C3NY
#C3NY
#C3NY
#C3NY
#C3NY
#C3NY 15
Created by nurses, for nurses
#C3NY
#C3NY
Revenue (Registrations)
#C3NY 18
#C3NY 19
Content gating vs. organic traffic growth
Duplicate content issues
#C3NY
Dealing with Duplicate Content
#C3NY
This includes more than 70 peer-reviewed
journals and 6,000 nursing articles
Nursing articles and publications are a main
focus of Lippincott NursingCenter.com.
#C3NY 22
Journal Articles on NursingCenter were being out-
ranked (and often filtered out of search results)
because of the same content being contained on
other Wolters Kluwer sites.
Challenge
#C3NY 23
1. Remove the duplicate content
2. Noindex meta tag
3. Robots.txt directives
4. Cross-domain rel=“canonical” link elements
Some Common Solutions
#C3NY 24
1. Articles on NursingCenter were being crawled
and indexed in both Google and Bing.
2. Bing was ranking non-PPV results
significantly more highly than Google.
Other Findings
#C3NY
Google is likely identifying NursingCenter as a
non-original source for this content, negatively
impacting the visibility of the articles in organic
search results.
#C3NY
Duplicate
Content
Registrations
&
Organic
Traffic
#C3NY
#C3NY
Hypothesis: Limit the amount of duplicate
content that is accessible to search engines by
further gating the content.
#C3NY 29
#C3NY 30
1. Focus on content KPIs beyond just organic
traffic, such as registrations.
2. Understand the impact on engagement and
conversions related to increasing
registrations.
Content Gating Test Needs
#C3NY
Identify issue
Develop hypothesis
Develop potential tests
Choose tests
Run POC tests
Analyze impact
Run additional style variants
Analyze impact
The Process
#C3NY 32
1. Test Gating On/Off
2. Test style variants, such as “Pinterest” (on
scroll) vs. “New York Times” (metered)
style
Initial Test Ideas – Start Simple
#C3NY 33
Initial Test – Simple Content Gating On/Off
Baseline Full Gating Test A Full Gating Test B
#C3NY 34
Full Gating Test B
Initial Test Results
N/A
211%
improvement in
registrations
887%
improvement in
registrations
Baseline Full Gating Test A
#C3NY 35
Secondary Test
“Pinterest” Style “NYT” Style
#C3NY 36
Secondary Test
“Pinterest” Style “NYT” Style
Winner Loser
#C3NY 37
Secondary Test
“Pinterest” Style “NYT” Style
+166% Conv. Rate
+8% session duration
Loser
#C3NY 38
Where Can We
Look for Growth?
#C3NY
Options & Variety
#C3NY
New Content Without Gates
#C3NY
#C3NY
#C3NY 43
Results? (Organic, YoY)
#C3NY 44
+51% growth in sessions
+42% growth in new users
+19% growth in goal completions
+19% growth in goal value
#C3NY
Takeaways
#C3NY
Think beyond
standard
wisdom - find
unconventional
ways to get
results.
#C3NY
Test a variety of content types first,
before you test gates.
#C3NY
Don’t put all of
your content
eggs in one
basket.
#C3NY
Test gates, but start slow to win.
#C3NY
Avoid a myopic
focus on organic
traffic.
#C3NY 51

A Trail Map to Content Marketing Success

Editor's Notes

  • #4 Walking on a tightrope, with an uncertain and changing future, needing to test new ideas to move beyond the past.
  • #15 https://www.blog.google/topics/journalism-news/driving-future-digital-subscriptions/ Changes are underway with news publishers, but what about the rest of us?
  • #16 Discuss brand, and lead into the core goal – provide nurses with what they need to succeed in today’s challenging healthcare environment. Lippincott NursingCenter.com is the premier online destination for peer-reviewed nursing journals and continuing education resources based on the best evidence available. A host of more than 70 nursing journals, Lippincott is committed to providing credible, current, authoritative, evidence-based resources to help you in your practice.  Along with peer-reviewed journals, more than 1,900 continuing education activities, including your own CE planner tool, are right at your fingertips. Use NursingCenter to interact with other nursing professionals over social channels; and follow our blog section to stay up-to-date on the important issues in the nursing community.
  • #17 Lippincott NursingCenter delivers an audience of highly-engaged nurses of all specialties within a trusted environment of peer-reviewed, evidence-based content.
  • #19 Duplicate content challenges within the Walters Kluwer Family of websites hindering organic traffic growth Less gating = more traffic/less registrations, more gating = less traffic/more registrations
  • #20 Duplicate content challenges within the Walters Kluwer Family of websites hindering organic traffic growth Less gating = more traffic/less registrations, more gating = less traffic/more registrations
  • #22 Most of this content is found across a number of other Walters Kluwer sites, providing value to unique audiences. This presented a challenge, because organic traffic growth to this content began to stall and was no longer going to provide meaningful gains in the future.
  • #23 However, remember that these articles serve an important purpose for the audience of NursingCenter.
  • #24 However, remember that these articles serve an important purpose for the audience of NursingCenter.
  • #25 However, remember that these articles serve an important purpose for the audience of NursingCenter.
  • #26 Most of this content is found across a number of other Walters Kluwer sites, providing value to unique audiences. This presented a challenge, because organic traffic growth to this content began to stall and was no longer going to provide meaningful gains in the future.
  • #30 That brings us to content gating.
  • #31 However, remember that these articles serve an important purpose for the audience of NursingCenter.
  • #34 Our test only effect FREE journal articles and CE articles We are evenly splitting traffic three ways Email Traffic is not permitted
  • #35 Results held steady throughout the entire length of the experiment.
  • #38 Other Data: Both NY Times and Pinterest style gates have similar return behavior for their users. Both NY Times and Pinterest style have most of their traffic occur on one day.
  • #39 Showcase all of the new content formats and strength of content developed by experts. Discuss collaboration on making content search engine friendly.