1
Barbara Walters, Consortial Faculty,
             CUNY Online Baccalaureate

 Ellen Smiley, Academic Director of the CUNY Online

Sarah Morgano, ePortfolio Communication Coordinator

       William Bernhardt, Consortial Faculty,
            CUNY Online Baccalaureate




                                                      2
Web 2.0 tools facilitate shared knowledge,
reflection, and metacognition among CUNY
Online Baccalaureate students in a research
methods learning community. E-Portfolio
modeling encourages ownership transfer and
thoughtful self-navigation of program learning
goals, targeted in course objectives and
assignments. Examples highlight tiers in a
scaffolded series of competencies that are pre-
requisites to capstone projects in our
Communication and Culture concentration.
                                                  3
   Steering Committee for Online Resources and
    Education (S.C.O.R.E.) 2005
   CUNY Online Baccalaureate: Fall 2006
     Designed for “degree completers”
     Single cross-disciplinary concentration: Communication
      and Culture
     Expanded in initial year from 250 students in 30 sections
      of 17 courses to 400 students in 62 sections of 50 courses
   B.S. in Business, Spring 2008; M.S. in Business
    Management and Leadership, Fall 2009
   Spring 2010, over 750 students enrolled in 67
    classes across three degree programs

                                                                   4
   Clear Goals
       Institutional Mission
       Program Goals
       Curriculum Development
       Course Objectives
   Pedagogy
       Deep learning – non-content teaching and learning goals
        (Keith Roberts)
         Constructivist learning -- WAC and WID (Bloom, Perry and
          Bean)
         Reflection and Self-Navigation (John Dewey and Lev S.
          Vygotsky)
         Communities of Practice – Learning Communities
   Assessment and Evaluation
                                                                     5
   Goal:
       Inclusion of all students in the program
       Use of ePortfolios to mirror, map and communicate
        progress
         Reflection and Social Networking
   ePortfolios and Communities of Practice
       Blogs
       Wikis
       Expo
       Digication

                                                            6
Intentional Teaching and Learning*



“If you don’t know where
you want to go, you might
end up somewhere else.”


             Yogi Berra


Photo Credit: Yogi Berra’s game-worn jersey,
Photography Collection, The Glory Days: New
York Baseball 1947-1957, and exhibit from
Museum of the City of New York, which ran from
June 27 to December 31, 2007. Used under a
Creative Commons “Attribution/Noncommercial/
No-Derivative Works”




*Cf. Andrea Leskes, AACU, 2005, CUNY Research Seminar   7
Program
            Mission           Goals/Outcomes/
                                 Objectives
                                                                   Double
                                                                   Loop
                                                                   Learning
                        We are here
          Assessment/                                Curricular
          Reflection                                  Design




                                                       Course
                                                      Objectives

                                  Pedagogy




* Adapted from Andrea Leskes, AACU, 2005, CUNY Research Seminar


                                                                              8
This course title
and sequence have
changed as a result
of this double-loop
      learning.




                      9
TEACHERS AND
    ADMINISTRATORS                          LEARNERS

   Clear program goals               Self-directed
   Clear learning goals              Aware of the process
   Alignment between                 Integrative
    mission, guiding
    principles, goals,                Adaptive
    assignments and
    assessments

                        Open system

Adapted from Andrea Leskes, AACU, 2005, CUNY Research Seminar

                                                                10
Visible Knowledge




                    11
   Basic Competencies: Fall 2008
       Course redesign
       Assessment
   Course Goals and Objectives: meetings in
    teams
   Transparent assignments and assessments
   Faculty Development or Community Building
    around Basic Principles



                                                12
I. Inquiry and Critical Thinking
II. Communication
III. Cultural Diversity and Social
     Responsibility
IV. Creativity
V. Teamwork and Leadership
VI. Knowledge Base
                                     13
Basic      CC         CC    CC    CC    CC    CC    CC    CC    CC    CC
Competenci 401        403   404   405   406   407   408   409   411   499
es
I. Inquiry &      X
C. Thinking
II. Comm.         X

III. Cult. Div.   X
& Soc. Resp.
IV. Creativity    X

V. Teamwork       X
&
Leadership
VI.               X
Knowledge                                                              14
Base
15
   Fall 2008 Expo Pilot
   Summer 2009 Digication Pilot
   Ongoing Communities of Practice
       Discussion Forums
       Blogs
       Wikis
       Expo
       ePortfolios



                                      16
   Blackboard has always had the discussion
    board, but new tools allow new outlets for
    student contributions in online courses: blogs
    (collective or individual) and wikis. How can
    these tools be used effectively (and non-
    redundantly) in the Blackboard environment?




                                                     17
   Enables journal style entries separated and
    tagged by name, date, and time, appearing in
    reverse chronological order
   Allows students to create web-based diaries or
    other types of web records
   Possibilities include documents, links, images,
    plus a comments feature
   Journal, viewing, and comments can be open to
    individual students, groups, or entire class
   Tool for reflection

                                                  18
19
   An effective tool for collaborative student
    website authoring: think Wikipedia
   Provides a venue for teamwork and reflection
   Facilitates text, image, or other media links
    and/or displays
   Assessment tools available
   Wiki editing, viewing, and comments can be
    available to class or team


                                                    20
21
22
   110 Students in Five Courses
       COM 110 Digital Information in the Contemporary
        World
       ART 210 Modern Art in the City
       ENG 102
       CC 410 Introduction to Research Methods
       CC 409 Studies in Communication and Cultural Change
       CC 499 Senior Research
   Evaluation
   Model ePortfolio
   Student Resource Site

                                                              23
Sample Student ePortfolio:
                              Created for students to
                                     mirror.




Basic Academic ePortfolio
  Template: Created for
    students to model.
                                                         24
25
Ownership Transfer




Social Networking




                                         26
   CC 499 Senior Research
       Initially a contract and guidelines
       Double loop adjustment
   Skills students should have at registration for CC 499: Fall
    2009
       Literature searches and review
       Creating theory and hypotheses from literature
       Statistical Skills
         SPSS
         Basic descriptive statistics
         Tests of significance
       Basic research
         Ethnography
         Content Analysis


                                                                   27
28
A direct result of
NOT evaluating
    evidence
  (reflecting).




                     29
30
31
This course was
revised as a result
of this double-loop
      learning.




                      32
   CC 401 and Deep Learning
   Transition to Four-Year College
       Pre-Reflective:
         Knowledge exists absolutely and can be ascertained by direct
          observation
       Quasi-Reflective:
         Knowledge is uncertain; evidence is used but it is
          idiosyncratic
       Reflective
         Knowledge is constructed by evaluating evidence
   Change in Research Methods sequence and course
    numbers
   Introduction of Write-from-the-Start
   Learning Community: COM 110 and CC 401
                                                                   33
Shared
Knowledge




            34
35
Reflection




             36
Thanks to SPS Deans George Otte and Brian Peterson; Sylvie
Richards, SPS Media and Technology Specialist; B.Loerinc-Helft,
Academic Director of the CUNY Online Programs in Business;
Washington Hernandez, Operations Manager, Ericke Wong,
Operations Assistant; Phil Pecorino, Howard Wach, Jordi Getman,
Carl Grindley, Joe Ugoretz and Rob Whittaker, Colleagues in the
CUNY Online Baccalaureate; Bret Eynon, Assistant Dean and
Executive Director of the Teaching and Learning Center at
LaGuardia; and all of our mentors and colleagues at LaGuardia
Community College and in Cohort A at Making Connections.




                                                                  37

AAEEBL 2010

  • 1.
  • 2.
    Barbara Walters, ConsortialFaculty, CUNY Online Baccalaureate Ellen Smiley, Academic Director of the CUNY Online Sarah Morgano, ePortfolio Communication Coordinator William Bernhardt, Consortial Faculty, CUNY Online Baccalaureate 2
  • 3.
    Web 2.0 toolsfacilitate shared knowledge, reflection, and metacognition among CUNY Online Baccalaureate students in a research methods learning community. E-Portfolio modeling encourages ownership transfer and thoughtful self-navigation of program learning goals, targeted in course objectives and assignments. Examples highlight tiers in a scaffolded series of competencies that are pre- requisites to capstone projects in our Communication and Culture concentration. 3
  • 4.
    Steering Committee for Online Resources and Education (S.C.O.R.E.) 2005  CUNY Online Baccalaureate: Fall 2006  Designed for “degree completers”  Single cross-disciplinary concentration: Communication and Culture  Expanded in initial year from 250 students in 30 sections of 17 courses to 400 students in 62 sections of 50 courses  B.S. in Business, Spring 2008; M.S. in Business Management and Leadership, Fall 2009  Spring 2010, over 750 students enrolled in 67 classes across three degree programs 4
  • 5.
    Clear Goals  Institutional Mission  Program Goals  Curriculum Development  Course Objectives  Pedagogy  Deep learning – non-content teaching and learning goals (Keith Roberts)  Constructivist learning -- WAC and WID (Bloom, Perry and Bean)  Reflection and Self-Navigation (John Dewey and Lev S. Vygotsky)  Communities of Practice – Learning Communities  Assessment and Evaluation 5
  • 6.
    Goal:  Inclusion of all students in the program  Use of ePortfolios to mirror, map and communicate progress  Reflection and Social Networking  ePortfolios and Communities of Practice  Blogs  Wikis  Expo  Digication 6
  • 7.
    Intentional Teaching andLearning* “If you don’t know where you want to go, you might end up somewhere else.” Yogi Berra Photo Credit: Yogi Berra’s game-worn jersey, Photography Collection, The Glory Days: New York Baseball 1947-1957, and exhibit from Museum of the City of New York, which ran from June 27 to December 31, 2007. Used under a Creative Commons “Attribution/Noncommercial/ No-Derivative Works” *Cf. Andrea Leskes, AACU, 2005, CUNY Research Seminar 7
  • 8.
    Program Mission Goals/Outcomes/ Objectives Double Loop Learning We are here Assessment/ Curricular Reflection Design Course Objectives Pedagogy * Adapted from Andrea Leskes, AACU, 2005, CUNY Research Seminar 8
  • 9.
    This course title andsequence have changed as a result of this double-loop learning. 9
  • 10.
    TEACHERS AND ADMINISTRATORS LEARNERS  Clear program goals  Self-directed  Clear learning goals  Aware of the process  Alignment between  Integrative mission, guiding principles, goals,  Adaptive assignments and assessments Open system Adapted from Andrea Leskes, AACU, 2005, CUNY Research Seminar 10
  • 11.
  • 12.
    Basic Competencies: Fall 2008  Course redesign  Assessment  Course Goals and Objectives: meetings in teams  Transparent assignments and assessments  Faculty Development or Community Building around Basic Principles 12
  • 13.
    I. Inquiry andCritical Thinking II. Communication III. Cultural Diversity and Social Responsibility IV. Creativity V. Teamwork and Leadership VI. Knowledge Base 13
  • 14.
    Basic CC CC CC CC CC CC CC CC CC CC Competenci 401 403 404 405 406 407 408 409 411 499 es I. Inquiry & X C. Thinking II. Comm. X III. Cult. Div. X & Soc. Resp. IV. Creativity X V. Teamwork X & Leadership VI. X Knowledge 14 Base
  • 15.
  • 16.
    Fall 2008 Expo Pilot  Summer 2009 Digication Pilot  Ongoing Communities of Practice  Discussion Forums  Blogs  Wikis  Expo  ePortfolios 16
  • 17.
    Blackboard has always had the discussion board, but new tools allow new outlets for student contributions in online courses: blogs (collective or individual) and wikis. How can these tools be used effectively (and non- redundantly) in the Blackboard environment? 17
  • 18.
    Enables journal style entries separated and tagged by name, date, and time, appearing in reverse chronological order  Allows students to create web-based diaries or other types of web records  Possibilities include documents, links, images, plus a comments feature  Journal, viewing, and comments can be open to individual students, groups, or entire class  Tool for reflection 18
  • 19.
  • 20.
    An effective tool for collaborative student website authoring: think Wikipedia  Provides a venue for teamwork and reflection  Facilitates text, image, or other media links and/or displays  Assessment tools available  Wiki editing, viewing, and comments can be available to class or team 20
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
    110 Students in Five Courses  COM 110 Digital Information in the Contemporary World  ART 210 Modern Art in the City  ENG 102  CC 410 Introduction to Research Methods  CC 409 Studies in Communication and Cultural Change  CC 499 Senior Research  Evaluation  Model ePortfolio  Student Resource Site 23
  • 24.
    Sample Student ePortfolio: Created for students to mirror. Basic Academic ePortfolio Template: Created for students to model. 24
  • 25.
  • 26.
  • 27.
    CC 499 Senior Research  Initially a contract and guidelines  Double loop adjustment  Skills students should have at registration for CC 499: Fall 2009  Literature searches and review  Creating theory and hypotheses from literature  Statistical Skills  SPSS  Basic descriptive statistics  Tests of significance  Basic research  Ethnography  Content Analysis 27
  • 28.
  • 29.
    A direct resultof NOT evaluating evidence (reflecting). 29
  • 30.
  • 31.
  • 32.
    This course was revisedas a result of this double-loop learning. 32
  • 33.
    CC 401 and Deep Learning  Transition to Four-Year College  Pre-Reflective:  Knowledge exists absolutely and can be ascertained by direct observation  Quasi-Reflective:  Knowledge is uncertain; evidence is used but it is idiosyncratic  Reflective  Knowledge is constructed by evaluating evidence  Change in Research Methods sequence and course numbers  Introduction of Write-from-the-Start  Learning Community: COM 110 and CC 401 33
  • 34.
  • 35.
  • 36.
  • 37.
    Thanks to SPSDeans George Otte and Brian Peterson; Sylvie Richards, SPS Media and Technology Specialist; B.Loerinc-Helft, Academic Director of the CUNY Online Programs in Business; Washington Hernandez, Operations Manager, Ericke Wong, Operations Assistant; Phil Pecorino, Howard Wach, Jordi Getman, Carl Grindley, Joe Ugoretz and Rob Whittaker, Colleagues in the CUNY Online Baccalaureate; Bret Eynon, Assistant Dean and Executive Director of the Teaching and Learning Center at LaGuardia; and all of our mentors and colleagues at LaGuardia Community College and in Cohort A at Making Connections. 37