Evangeline left her home after her friend's wedding and moved into an unfinished house. She contacted a gypsy to set her up with David, her teenage love, but had no success. She later discovered David worked with her. They rekindled their romance and realized they still had strong feelings for each other. David proposed and they married, having a son named Aidan together a few years later. However, Evangeline was still curious about David's past and his relationship with Don Lothario.