Analysis of the Influence of Service Quality Dimensions on Patient Satisfaction at Bhayangkara Hospital, Bondowoso

American Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences Research (AJHSSR) 2022
A J H S S R J o u r n a l P a g e | 116
American Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences Research (AJHSSR)
e-ISSN :2378-703X
Volume-6, Issue-12, pp-116-121
www.ajhssr.com
Research Paper Open Access
Analysis of the Influence of Service Quality Dimensions on
Patient Satisfaction at Bhayangkara Hospital, Bondowoso
Erni Yuniarti1
, Muhammad Firdaus2
, Hary Sulaksono3
Master of Management Student at the Institute of Technology and Sciences Mandala, Jember1
Lecturer in Master of Management Institute of Technology and Sciences Mandala, Jember2 ,3
ABSTRACT : The main purpose of this research is to know the impact dimensions of service quality
(tangibles, reliability, responsiveness, assurance, and empathy) against patient's satisfaction. This research uses
224 respondents who were chosen according to some specified criteria in the patient room of Bhayangkara
Bondowoso Hospital. This is descriptive, comparative, and associative research. Data collection method use
questionnaire. The result by t test with the help of SPSS 26 software shows that the score is sig. 2 tailed variable
tangibles 0.000 <0.05, variable reliability 0.000 <0.05, variable responsiveness 0.000 <0.05, variable assurance
0.000 > 0.05, variable empathy 0.000 <0.05. This t test shows that each variable tangibles, reliability,
responsiveness, assurance, and empathy make an impact against patient's satisfaction. The result of the F test
with the help of SPSS 26 software shows a significant score of 0.000 <0.05. This F test shows that all of the
variable tangibles, reliability, responsiveness, assurance, and empathy make an impact simultaneously against
elderly patient satisfaction.
KEYWORDS: Service, Satisfaction, Elderly
I. INTRODUCTION
As the number of patients increases, the need for health services continues to grow as well. Therefore,
health service providers continue to strive to provide services to patients in need. The challenge faced in
providing health services is the demand for the quality of services provided. According to Parasuraman et al. (in
Wibowo, 2013) the dimensions of service quality are divided into five namely reliability , responsiveness ,
assurance , empathy , and tangibles. The quality of services provided by each health service provider is of
course different. With differences in the quality of services provided, it will certainly have a different impact on
the satisfaction of patients who receive health services. Based on previous research conducted by (Romaji &
Nasihan, 2018) and (Sari, 2020) , the main factor for patient dissatisfaction is caused by services that are not
optimal. This is in line with the results of research by Bauk et al., (2014) and (Utami et al., 2013) which stated
that there was a significant effect of the dimensions of service quality on patient satisfaction. For this reason,
research on the level of patient satisfaction is very important to be carried out by every health care provider.
BhayangkaraBondowoso Hospital (RS) is one of the health service providers that continues to strive to
provide good quality service. One of the units at BhayangkaraBondowoso Hospital that continues to develop
service quality is the inpatient room. Based on the results of a preliminary survey conducted, Bhayangkara
Hospital received more than five hundred inpatients in one month. This shows that the inpatient room of
Bhayangkara Hospital is a strategic health service unit for conducting research on the quality of health services.
Based on the description above, it is necessary to study the dimensions of service quality and patient
satisfaction in the inpatient unit of Bhayangkara Bondowoso Hospital. So that the formulation of the problem
that can be compiled by researchers is how the influence of the dimensions of service quality (tangibles,
reliability, responsiveness, assurance, and empathy) on patient satisfaction in the inpatient room of Bhayangkara
Bondowoso Hospital? Meanwhile, the purpose of this study was to determine the effect of the dimensions of
service quality (tangibles, reliability, responsiveness, assurance, and empathy) on patient satisfaction in the
inpatient room of Bhayangkara Bondowoso Hospital.

II. LITERATURE REVIEW
Quality
Quality is a condition that is interrelated to one another between a service and a product, society, the
surrounding environment and processes that can provide fulfillment or even exceed the expectations of
consumer desires. So that it can be defined that service quality is a series of ways and efforts to meet consumer
needs and desires as well as the accuracy of methods or procedures in conveying and realizing one's
expectations (Prasastono & Pradapa, 2017) .
Quality is the overall characteristic of a product or service that can provide satisfaction to its users.
Companies that have a high level of customer satisfaction can also be interpreted as having a high level of
customer service, there is a close relationship between service quality, customer satisfaction, and company
profitability. The higher the level of service quality provided by the company to consumers, the higher the
customer satisfaction and also supports higher prices and lower costs. Tjiptono said that quality is: "a dynamic
condition associated with products, services, people, processes, and the environment that meets or exceeds
expectations" (Tjiptono & Chandra, 2005). Sunyoto (2012) states that quality is a measure to assess that an item
or service already has the desired use value or in other words, an item or service is considered to have quality if
it functions or has the desired use value. From these definitions it can be concluded that quality is an element
that is interconnected with regard to quality that can affect performance in meeting customer expectations.
Quality does not only emphasize the end result, namely products and services but concerns human quality,
process quality, and environmental quality. In producing a quality product and service through quality people
and processes.Tjiptono (2012) says there are at least five quality perspectives currently developing:
a. Transcendental Approach
In this perspective, quality is seen as innate excellence, namely something that can be understood
intuitively, but is almost impossible to communicate, as an example of beauty or love. This perspective
emphasizes that people can only learn to understand quality through experience gained and repeated
exposure .
b. Product-Based Approaches
This perspective assumes that quality is an objective characteristic, component or attribute that can be
quantified and measurable. Differences in terms of quality reflect differences in the number of elements or
attributes that the product has. The more attributes a product or brand has, the higher the quality of the
product or brand concerned.
c. User-Based Approach
This perspective is based on the idea that quality depends on the person who evaluates it (the eyes of the
beholder), so that the product that best satisfies one's preferences (maximum satisfaction) is the product of
the highest quality. This subjective and demand- oriented perspective also states that every customer has
their own needs and desires that are different from one another, so that quality for a person is the same as
perceived maximum satisfaction.
d. Manufacturing-Based Approach
This perspective is supply-based and focuses more on engineering and manufacturing practices, and
defines quality as conformance to requirements . In the service business context, quality based on this
perspective tends to be operation-driven.
e. Value-Based Approach
This perspective looks at quality from the aspect of value (value)and price (price). By considering the
trade-off between performance and price, quality is defined as affordable excellence, namely the 'best'
level of performance or commensurate with the price paid. Quality in this perspective is relative, so that
products that have the most valuable quality are the goods or services that are most appropriately
purchased (best-buy). According to Tjiptono & Chandra (2011) , productivity is usually always associated
with quality and profitability. However, the three concepts have different emphases:
a) Productivity emphasizes resource utilization ,which is often accompanied by cost reduction and
capital rationalization. Its main focus lies in production/operations.
b) Quality emphasizes the aspects of customer satisfaction and revenue. The main focus is customer
utility .
c) Profitability is the result of the relationship between income ,costs, and capital used.
Companies can increase their market share through customer-driven quality fulfillment which will
provide price advantages and customer value .Customer value is a combination of the benefits and sacrifices that
occur when a customer uses an item or service to meet certain needs. If the quality produced is superior and the
market share is large, then the profitability is guaranteed. Superior benefits include:
a. Great customer loyalty
b. Bigger market share
c. Higher share price
d. The selling price of the product/service is higher

e. Greater product vitas
Service quality
According to Lewis and Booms in Tjiptono & Chandra (2005) , quality of service (service) is a
measure of how well the level of service provided is able to match customer expectations. According to
Simamora (2003) there are two main factors that affect service quality. First, expected service is that if the
service received is as expected, the service quality is perceived as satisfactory. Second, perceived service is a
service that is received beyond the customer, so it can be perceived as an ideal quality, and vice versa.
Parasuraman, Zeithaml, and Berry (1985) in Tjiptono (2008) introduced the Servqual model. The servqualmodel
is a service quality measurement model. This model emphasizes multi-item designed to measure expected
services and perceived services, where the dimensions of quality are divided into five variables namely
reliability, responsiveness ,warranty , empathy , and tangible evidence. tangibles). According to (Lupiyoadi &
Hamdani, 2014) there are five things that can be used by consumers to evaluate the service quality of the
services received, including namely:
a. tangible evidence
b. Reliability or Reliability
c. or Responsiveness
d. Guarantee and certainty or Assurance
e. Empathy or Empathy
The explanation of the above indicators according to Lupiyoadi's opinion is:
a. Tangibles or tangible evidence is an ability possessed by service providers or service providers to notify
outsiders about their existence. Appearance or facilities and infrastructure belonging to service providers
/services that can be felt by customers and the surrounding conditions that support them are clear evidence of
a company. So tangible evidence can be in the form of buildings, parking lots, warehouses, technology used,
tools and equipment used, along with the appearance of employees/employees at the company.
b. Reliability is the ability of service providers to provide services according to the agreement accurately and
reliably. Service delivery must be in accordance with what is expected by consumers. This can be interpreted
as timeliness, equal service for all customer groups, and a professional attitude in dealing with customers.
c. Responsiveness is a form of policy to immediately assist and provide action regarding the provision of
effective and efficient services to customers by providing appropriate information.
d. Assurance or assurance and certainty is an attitude of courtesy, knowledge and ability of service providers to
give customers a sense of trust in service providers. This guarantee and certainty can be in the form of
communication style, credibility, security, and competence.
e. Empathy by giving sincere and individual or personal attention given to consumers by trying to understand
consumer desires. Where a company is expected to have understanding and knowledge about consumers to
understand specific needs, and have a comfortable operating time for consumers.
According to Tjiptono(Tjiptono & Chandra, 2005) , "There are five main dimensions that determine
service quality, namely:
a. Direct evidence (tangibles), including physical facilities, equipment, employees and means of
communication.
b. Reliability ,namely the ability to provide the promised service promptly, accurately and satisfactorily.
c. Responsiveness , which includes knowledge, ability, courtesy and trustworthiness, free from danger,
risk or doubt.
d. Guarantee and certainty (Assurance) includes knowledge, ability, courtesy, trustworthy nature of the
staff, and being free from harm.
e. Empathy is an attitude that is swift in interacting, having good conversation, being attentive to
understanding and meeting consumer needs.
Satisfaction
Understanding of the patient's wants and needs is important because it can affect patient satisfaction.
One of the most valuable assets for a health service provider is patient satisfaction because satisfied patients can
continue to request services if they receive health complaints and can recommend to others to use health
services at the institution in question, but if the patient is not satisfied then it will share their bad experiences
with others and can have a negative impact on health service providers (Evisusanti, 2020) . In order for a health
service provider or hospital to create patient satisfaction, the hospital must manage and run the service system as
best as possible to get more patients and the ability to maintain performance for its patients. If the performance
or service provided by the hospital exceeds what the patient expects, the patient will feel satisfied and vice
versa, patient dissatisfaction or feelings of disappointment will arise if the provision of health services or
performance obtained is not in accordance with his expectations.

Based on what was mentioned above, the notion of patient satisfaction is a level of patient feelings that
arise as a result of the performance of the health services they get after the patient compares them with what
they expect .Consumers who experience satisfaction with a product or service can be categorized into public
consumers, institutional consumers and individual consumers. In this study the researchers focused on patient
satisfaction.
Based on the descriptions of some of the experts mentioned above, it can be concluded that patient
satisfaction is a feeling of pleasure, satisfaction felt by patients because of the fulfillment of patient expectations
or patient desires in receiving health services.
III. METHODS
This research is a descriptive, comparative, and associative study with purposive sampling where
patients are selected with certain predetermined criteria. The population in this study were patients in the
inpatient room of BhayangkaraBondowoso Hospital for 25 days from 27 May 2022 to 20 June 2022. The
number of patient samples in this study was obtained from the calculated results using the Slovin formula with a
tolerance level of 5%. Research data was obtained using a research questionnaire containing statements about
the quality of service received by patients and patient satisfaction.
The questionnaire instrument in this study was divided into three parts. The first part is the part for
obtaining patient's personal data, the second part is for obtaining data about the dimensions of service quality
(tangibles, reliability, responsiveness, assurance, and empathy), and the third part is for obtaining data about
patient satisfaction. Data analysis was carried out after the editing process , namely after the process of checking
the completeness of the data obtained from the respondents and the data can be processed correctly.
Furthermore, the data were analyzed using SPSS 26 software to obtain the results of the t test and F test.
IV. RESULT
The number of patients who were respondents in this study were 224. This number was obtained from
508 patients who made up the population. The characteristics of the respondents in this study can be described
in the following table.
Table 1. Characteristics of Respondents
Characteristics Frequency Percentage
Gender
Man 129 57.6 %
Woman 95 42.4 %
Age
5 – 20 years 19 8.5 %
20 – 35 years 79 35 %
Over 35 years 126 56.5 %
Work
Student / Student 24 10.7 %
Employees / Employees 118 52.7 %
Traders / Entrepreneurs 82 36.6 %
Education
Primary School / Junior High School 14 6.25 %
Senior High School 58 25.9 %
Diploma/Bachelor Degree 152 67.85 %
Based on Table 1, it can be seen that there were 129 male patients and 95 female patients with 19 aged 5-20
years, 79 aged 20-35 years, and 126 aged over 35 years. Respondents' occupations were 24 students working,
118 employees/employees, and 82 traders. The education level of the respondents was 14 elementary/junior
high school students, 58 high school/vocational high school students, and 152 undergraduate/diploma students.
ttest analysis using SPSS 26 software can be presented in the following table
Table 2.T test results
Service Quality Dimensions t-value Sig.
Tangibles 13,429 0.000
reliability 9,804 0.000
Responsiveness 11,849 0.000
assurance 2,280 0.024
Empathy 13,076 0.000

Based on Table 1, it can be seen that the Tangibles significance value is 0.000, reliability is 0.000,
responsiveness is 0.000, assurance is 0.024, and empathy is 0.000. The results of the F test using SPSS 26
software get a significance value of 0.000.
V. DISCUSSION
The results of the study show that the dimensions of service quality on the tangibles variable as a
whole show the agreed criteria. The tangibles variable has three indicators with six statements. Overall the
patient responded to the statement by agreeing. The highest indicator in the tangibles variable is equipment with
strongly agree criteria. This shows that equipment and tools to support services to patients are always available.
The lowest indicator in the tangibles variable is the facility, precisely in the statement item, having a large
parking area. The results of interviews with several patients stated that it was difficult to find a parking space
when using a car. Bhayangkara Bondowoso Hospital did not continue to ignore this deficiency, because based
on survey results around the Bhayangkara Bondowoso Hospital area there was a process of widening and adding
a parking area.
The dimension of service quality on the reliability variable as a whole shows the agreed criteria. The
reliability variable has three indicators with six statements. Statements with the highest criteria are regular
administrative activities. The process of regular administrative activities is due to the fact that from the patient
registration process to payment procedures, all services are administered with files that are easy for patients to
fill in. The statement with the lowest criterion is that the service procedure is not complicated. Based on the
results of interviews with several patients, the procedure is complicated when the patient has to receive
treatment from a specialist but the specialist's schedule must still be awaited in the next few days. The hospital
handles the shortage felt by patients by increasing the number and practice schedule of several specialist doctors
at BhayangkaraBondowoso Hospital.
The dimensions of service quality on the responsiveness variable as a whole show the agreed criteria.
responsivenessvariablehas three indicators with five statements. Statements with the highest criteria on the
responsiveness variable are patients who come to be handled swiftly by employees. When inpatients come,
most of them come through the Emergency Room (ER) and are declared to have to be hospitalized at the
hospital, so when they come to the ER, patients always immediately get the first handler that must be received
from the nurse or doctor on duty. The statement with the lowest criteria on the responsiveness variable is the
officer providing information about the hospital. Based on the results of interviews with patients, they stated that
when they asked about hospital information, officers said they did not understand. This needs to be improved
again for further services to overcome the dissatisfaction of patients.
The dimensions of service quality on the assurance variable as a whole show the agreed criteria. This
assurance variable consists of three indicators with five statements. The indicators with the highest scores are
the comfort and safety of the equipment. The comfort and safety of this equipment is obtained because the
Hospital uses new equipment and guaranteed safety. The indicator with the lowest value is in the statement that
the Hospital has a special officer to deal with equipment disturbances. Based on the results of the patient
interview, it was stated that the patient did not see the special officer who handled the problematic equipment
directly. Bhayangkara Bondowoso Hospital has a special officer who handles equipment problems, but special
officers usually repair equipment when there are no patients in the room, so officers almost never meet patients
face to face.
The dimensions of service quality on the empathy variable as a whole show strongly agree criteria. The
empathy variable has three indicators with five statements. All indicators on the empathy variable showed a very
agreeable response from the patient. This shows that employees have the ability to communicate with patients,
have a sympathetic attitude, and understand the wishes of patients. This quality of service can make the hospital
more advanced and better in the future.
Based on the results of the t test described previously, it was found that partially the tangibles,
reliability ,responsiveness , assurance , and empathy variables significantly influence patient satisfaction. The
results of this study on the tangibles dimension, patients feel satisfied because the equipment and service
support tools are always available. On the reliability dimension, patients feel satisfied because the registration
process to service procedures are all easily administered. In the responsiveness dimension, the patient is satisfied
because the patient is handled swiftly and immediately gets the first treatment by the doctor on duty. On the
assurance dimension, patients are satisfied because the hospital uses comfortable and safe equipment. On the
empathy dimension, the patient feels satisfied because the staff is sympathetic and understands the patient's
wishes. These things show that physical evidence, reliability, responsiveness, assurance, and empathy in the
services provided by officers to each patient have a real influence on patient satisfaction. The results of this
study are also in line with the results of research conducted by (Utami et al., 2013) , (Rosalia & Purnawati,
2018) , and (Kosnan, 2019) . that the dimensions of service quality (tangibles, reliability, responsiveness,
assurance , and empathy )each has a partial effect on patient satisfaction.

Based on the results of the F test described previously, it was found that simultaneously the variables
tangibles, reliability, responsiveness ,assurance , and empathy have a significant influence on patient
satisfaction. This means that physical evidence, reliability, responsiveness, assurance, and empathy in the
services provided by officers to patients as a whole or simultaneously have a real influence on patient
satisfaction. This is in line with the results of a study (Nababan et al., 2020) which states that patients feel very
satisfied by seeing the conformity between expectations and reality based on the dimensions of service quality
tangibles, reliability , responsiveness , assurance , and empathy ). This is also in line with the results of research
conducted by Rizal et al., 2021 that based on bivariate analysis using SPSS there is a relationship between the
dimensions of service quality (tangibles, reliability , responsiveness, assurance, and empathy) to patient
satisfaction.
VI. CONCLUSION
Based on the results of the research and discussion previously described, it can be concluded that there
is a significant influence of the dimensions of service quality (tangibles, reliability, responsiveness, assurance,
and empathy) on patient satisfaction in the inpatient ward of Bhayangkara Bondoswoso Hospital, both partially
and simultaneously. With the results of this study it is hoped that the quality of service to patients is maintained
and improved so that the level of satisfaction of patients who use health services continues to increase as well.
REFERENCES
[1]. Bauk, I., Kadir, AR, & Ariyanti, S. (2014). THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN PATIENT
CHARACTERISTICS AND SERVICE QUALITY: PATIENT PERCEPTION OF INpatient
SERVICES at MAJENE HOSPITAL, 2013. PHI Journal , 1 (3).
[2]. Evisusanti, S. (2020). FACTORS AFFECTING PATIENT SATISFACTION AT TIBAN BARU
HEALTH CENTER, 2020. Medrec Journal , 4 (1), 1–9.
[3]. kosnan, W. (2019). THE INFLUENCE OF SERVICE QUALITY ON INPATIENT SATISFACTION
IN REGIONAL GENERAL HOSPITAL, MERAUKE DISTRICT. Journal of Economics, Business
and Accounting , 21 .
[4]. Lupiyoadi, & Hamdani. (2014). Service Marketing Management (2nd ed.). Salemba Four.
[5]. Nababan, MC, Listiawaty, R., & Berliana, N. (2020). Analysis of Service Quality on Patient
Satisfaction at Health Center X Jambi City. Jambi Public Health Journal , 4 (2), 6–16.
[6]. Prasastono, N., & Pradapa, SY (2017). Product Quality and Service Quality on Consumer Satisfaction
Kentucky Fried Chicken Semarang Candi. Journal of Development of Tourism & Hospitality Sciences ,
XI , 13–23.
[7]. Rizal, F., Marwati, TA, & Solikhah, S. (2021). Dimensions of Service Quality and Their Impact on
Patient Satisfaction Levels: Studies in Physiotherapy Units. Journal of Public Health (Public Health)
Equator , 8 (2), 54. https://doi.org/10.29406/jkmk.v8i2.2624
[8]. Romaji, & Nasihan, L. (2018). Analysis of Patient Satisfaction with Health Services for BPJS (Social
Security Organizing Agency) and Non-BPJS Participants at Gambiran Hospital, Kediri, East Java. The
Indonesian Journal of Public Health , 3 (2).
[9]. Rosalia, K., & Purnawati, N. (2018). The Influence of Service Quality on Patient Satisfaction at Surya
Husadha Hospital in Denpasar. Udayana University Management E-Journal , 7 (5), 242718.
[10]. Sari, KI (2020). The Effect of Service Quality on Patient Satisfaction at Urug Health Center, Kawalu
District, Tasikmalaya City. Dynamics : Scientific Journal of Public Administration , 7 (31), 194–207.
http://marefateadyan.nashriyat.ir/node/150
[11]. Simamora, B. (2003). Consumer Behavior Research Guide . Gramedia General Library.
[12]. Sunyoto, D. (2012). Human Resources . CAPS.
[13]. Tjiptono, F. (2008). Marketing Strategy . CV Andi Offset.
[14]. Tjiptono, F. (2012). Service Marketing . Publisher Andi.
[15]. Tjiptono, F., & Chandra. (2011). Service, Quality, & Satisfaction (third). Publisher Andi.
[16]. Tjiptono, F., & Chandra, G. (2005). Service Quality Management . ANDI.
[17]. Utami, AT, Ismanto, H., & Lestari, Y. (2013). The Effect of Service Quality on Patient Satisfaction.
JKMP (Journal of Public Policy and Management) , 1 (1), 83–96.
https://doi.org/10.21070/jkmp.v1i1.429
[18]. Wibowo, S. . (2013). The Effect of Perceptions of Service Quality on Repurchase Intentions at the
Gramedia Bookstore, Yogyakarta. Journal of Economics , 4 (1).

Analysis of the Influence of Service Quality Dimensions on Patient Satisfaction at Bhayangkara Hospital, Bondowoso

More Related Content

Similar to Analysis of the Influence of Service Quality Dimensions on Patient Satisfaction at Bhayangkara Hospital, Bondowoso

More from AJHSSR Journal

Recently uploaded

Analysis of the Influence of Service Quality Dimensions on Patient Satisfaction at Bhayangkara Hospital, Bondowoso