This presentation was presented at
Apollo International Forum on
Infection Control (AIFIC’ 2013),
Chennai
The presentation is solely meant for
Academic purpose
Antimicrobial Stewardship
Different Challenges need Different Solutions
Columbus, Ohio USA
The Ohio State University Medical Center




•   James Cancer Center                        165 beds
    bone marrow transplants & oncology
•   Ross Heart Hospital                        130 beds
    Heart and lung transplants
•   The Ohio State University Hospital         850 beds
    solid organ transplant, General Medicine
    Surgery, SICU, MICU, NICU, Burn unit
Antimicrobial Resistance: A Global Problem
Antimicrobial Stewardship: A Global Solution!




            MDRO are a plane ride away!

            Examples: NDM-1,KPC, ESBL, Tuberculosis
Antimicrobial Stewardship
    A Global Solution!
Why Stewardship?
 HAI’s: significant morbidity, mortality and costs
       100,000 deaths annually
       $4.5 to 5.7 billion patient care cost

 Transmission occurs most often via contaminated
  hands of HCW
 Negative publicity for the hospital (patient safety issue)




    The Ohio State Football Stadium holds 105,000 people
Stewardship: A team approach
Challenges and Barriers in India
• Lack of ID trained physicians and
  pharmacists
• Lack of funding
• Open access to antibiotics
• Generics
What are USA patient’s reading?




    Ref: Wall Street Journal January 2013
What works What Doesn’t

Social competence                           Socially challenged
 Do you enjoy interacting with others?        Prefer to work alone
                                              Needs to be liked by everyone
                                              Avoids conflict at all costs




Technical competence                     Technically challenged
 Are you an ID expert?
                                            Hopes others on the team will do the work
 Can you lead a team?
What Works                     What Doesn’t Work




Excited to change           Frustrated at the thought of change


Implementation of ASP should be conceived as a
process of cultural and system change for the hospital

If the team does not possess the change management
competence, it may be necessary to involve external
experts
Organizational Capacity for Change
• Trustworthy leadership
  Do MDs know/trust the steward?
• Capable Champions
  Are efforts led by people with interpersonal
  communication and leadership skills?
• Accountability
  Does ASP have a clearly defined role and
  responsibility? Are there consequences for non-
  compliance?
• Involved Management
  Do they support the program and connect with
  leadership?   Judge WQ et al. Journal of Business Research. 2005;58:893-901.
What works: Define the Stewardship activities
What activity will be performed…   Examples
                                   IV to PO
                                   Kinetic dosing of antibiotics
                                   Authorization of restricted antibiotics
                                   Feedback for targeted antibiotics
By what personnel….                Dedicated pharmacist
                                   Physician
                                   Residents or students
With what frequency…               Mon-Friday
                                   7 days a week
                                   24/7
With what authority…               Protocols for IV to PO
                                   Kinetic dosing protocol
                                   Communication of recommendation via
                                   chart
What works?
            Pick the low hanging fruit


IV to PO conversion
Double anaerobic therapy
Broad spectrum antibiotics > 3 day and proton pump inhibitors
 (increase risk of C. difficile)
Vancomycin > 3 days and no MRSA
Positive blood culture and no antibiotics
Thrombocytopenia and linezolid

Ref: Goff DA. et al . Clin Inf Dis 2012 55(4):587-92
Insist on Infection Prevention Strategies
• Provide education to patients and
  family members
• Provide/post medical staff
  scorecards with frequency and
  trends of MDRO
     Do physicians know the top 5 organisms in their hospitals?
•    Do physicians know the rate of ESBLs, C difficile, MRSA?
Challenge

 How can stewardship
 control the spread of
MDRO in your hospital?
(X Represents VRE Culture Positive Sites AFTER Cleaning)




Hayden M, The Risk of Hand and Glove Contamination after Contact with a
VRE (+) Patient Environment. ICAAC, 2001, Chicago, IL.
USA and India working together to
           improve hand hygiene
 • Method: 17 bed ICU used remote video
   auditing with feedback
 • Auditors in India viewed live video of HCW
   in a US hospital performing hand hygiene
 • Each observation was assigned pass/fail

Ref: Armellino D et al. 2012 Clin Inf Dis 54(1) 1-7.
Results
               60,542 observations

• Pre-feedback hand hygiene rates
  6.5% (3.5%-9.8%) by remote 24/7 observation


• Post-feedback
  30.8% the first few weeks
  87.9% with light-emitting diode boards
Message Posted on LED boards
Black Light Marker
    • Fluorescent marker
           – An invisible gel that glows under blacklight
           – Applied to surfaces in over 40 US hospitals
           – An inert, safe, and unreactive substance




 Without black light

Ref: Carling PC. Clin Infect Dis 2006;42(3):385
Challenge
           How can you control the spread of MDRO in your hospital?
                          Solutions
1. Novel technology
2. Empower patients*
(only 14% of patients feel comfortable asking their MD/RN to wash their hands)
Ref *2012 ICHE Ottum 33(12)1282-4,


3. Identify patient s at high risk for MDRO
Ref: Han et al. 2012 ICHE;33(12) 1242-5
4. Chlorhexidine bathing
70% decline in CDI with daily bathing
Ref: Rupp et al. 2012 ICHE;33(11):1094-1100
Stewardship in Limited
Resource Hospitals around
        the world
Stewardship in S. Africa




Challenges: 3 ID physicians for all of S Africa, lack of funding,
pharmacist are not ID trained, some public hospitals do not have sinks
Stewardship and S. Africa
• Implemented Feb 2012
• Dedicated “champions” across S.
  Africa (physicians, infection control practitioners,
  pharmacists, microbiologists)

• Collaboration between public and
  private hospitals, administration and
  government
Stewardship and S. Africa
• Projects
  iv to oral
  de-escalation
  implementing antibiograms
• Education
  12 enrolled in on-line certification program in US
• email communication
• Conference calls, Facetime, Skype
• Integrate “apps” to educate providers
• Twitter
Outcomes of Stewardship
• S. Africa
  successful conversion of IV to PO
  therapeutic vancomycin levels
  develop antibiogram
• Dubai
  ICU improve “Hang-time” of antimicrobials
• Serbia
  developed a “team” to identify how to utilize
  micro data to guide empiric use of antibiotics
Antimicrobial Stewardship Management of
Infections : Beyond the Costs of Antimicrobials




 Ref: Goff D. et al. Inf Dis Special Ed. 2012 15:35-46
Antimicrobial Stewardship Management of
Infections : Beyond the Costs of Antimicrobials




 Ref: Goff D. et al. Inf Dis Special Ed. 2012 15:35-46
Challenge

How does stewardship
 impact patient care?
Clinical Outcome Measures
        Can you show improvement in clinical outcomes?

• Reduced LOS
  Bauer K., Goff D. Clin Inf Dis 2010; 51(9):1074–1080
  Fishman N. Am J Med 2006;119 (6 suppl 1) S53-S61
  Gentry CA AM J Health Syst Pharm 2000;57(3) 268-74.

• Better patient outcome
  Bauer K., Goff D. Clin Inf Dis 2010; 51(9):1074–1080
  Fishman N. Am J Med 2006;119 (6 suppl 1) S53-S61
  White A. et al Clin Inf Dis 1997;25:230-9.
• Decreased inappropriate use
  Gandhi T. Crit Care Med 2010;38(8 suppl) S315-323
  Apisarnthanarak A. Clin Inf Dis 2006;42(6) 768-775
What works: Technology and Education

• ASP certification program in USA
    MAD-ID Making a Difference Infectious Diseases international online program
    S. Africa, Singapore, Canada, Saudi Arabia, Australia
    http://mad-id.org
• Free apps from the Apple store
    Idpodcasts Weekly podcasts on ID topics
•   Free webinars and handouts
    ASHP American Society of Health Systems Pharmacists
    www.LeadStewardship.org
•   http://www.cdc.gov/getsmart/specific-groups/hcp/index.html
    free handouts, brochures, powerpoint slides on ASP
So what can you do?
• Start now
•   Collaborate
•   Identify key leaders to develop guidelines
    (based on national guidelines, tailored to your institution)
•   Consequences for non compliance?
•   Educate (telemedicine programs) School of Telemedicine and
•   Biomedical Informatics, Sanjay Gandhi Postgraduate Institute of Medical Sciences
    Lucknow, India.
•   Patient’s lives depend on effective stewardship
Stewardship

Antimicrobial Stewardship

  • 1.
    This presentation waspresented at Apollo International Forum on Infection Control (AIFIC’ 2013), Chennai The presentation is solely meant for Academic purpose
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
    The Ohio StateUniversity Medical Center • James Cancer Center 165 beds bone marrow transplants & oncology • Ross Heart Hospital 130 beds Heart and lung transplants • The Ohio State University Hospital 850 beds solid organ transplant, General Medicine Surgery, SICU, MICU, NICU, Burn unit
  • 5.
    Antimicrobial Resistance: AGlobal Problem Antimicrobial Stewardship: A Global Solution! MDRO are a plane ride away! Examples: NDM-1,KPC, ESBL, Tuberculosis
  • 6.
    Antimicrobial Stewardship A Global Solution!
  • 7.
    Why Stewardship?  HAI’s:significant morbidity, mortality and costs  100,000 deaths annually  $4.5 to 5.7 billion patient care cost  Transmission occurs most often via contaminated hands of HCW  Negative publicity for the hospital (patient safety issue) The Ohio State Football Stadium holds 105,000 people
  • 8.
  • 9.
    Challenges and Barriersin India • Lack of ID trained physicians and pharmacists • Lack of funding • Open access to antibiotics • Generics
  • 10.
    What are USApatient’s reading? Ref: Wall Street Journal January 2013
  • 11.
    What works WhatDoesn’t Social competence Socially challenged Do you enjoy interacting with others? Prefer to work alone Needs to be liked by everyone Avoids conflict at all costs Technical competence Technically challenged Are you an ID expert? Hopes others on the team will do the work Can you lead a team?
  • 12.
    What Works What Doesn’t Work Excited to change Frustrated at the thought of change Implementation of ASP should be conceived as a process of cultural and system change for the hospital If the team does not possess the change management competence, it may be necessary to involve external experts
  • 13.
    Organizational Capacity forChange • Trustworthy leadership Do MDs know/trust the steward? • Capable Champions Are efforts led by people with interpersonal communication and leadership skills? • Accountability Does ASP have a clearly defined role and responsibility? Are there consequences for non- compliance? • Involved Management Do they support the program and connect with leadership? Judge WQ et al. Journal of Business Research. 2005;58:893-901.
  • 14.
    What works: Definethe Stewardship activities What activity will be performed… Examples IV to PO Kinetic dosing of antibiotics Authorization of restricted antibiotics Feedback for targeted antibiotics By what personnel…. Dedicated pharmacist Physician Residents or students With what frequency… Mon-Friday 7 days a week 24/7 With what authority… Protocols for IV to PO Kinetic dosing protocol Communication of recommendation via chart
  • 15.
    What works? Pick the low hanging fruit IV to PO conversion Double anaerobic therapy Broad spectrum antibiotics > 3 day and proton pump inhibitors (increase risk of C. difficile) Vancomycin > 3 days and no MRSA Positive blood culture and no antibiotics Thrombocytopenia and linezolid Ref: Goff DA. et al . Clin Inf Dis 2012 55(4):587-92
  • 16.
    Insist on InfectionPrevention Strategies • Provide education to patients and family members • Provide/post medical staff scorecards with frequency and trends of MDRO Do physicians know the top 5 organisms in their hospitals? • Do physicians know the rate of ESBLs, C difficile, MRSA?
  • 17.
    Challenge How canstewardship control the spread of MDRO in your hospital?
  • 18.
    (X Represents VRECulture Positive Sites AFTER Cleaning) Hayden M, The Risk of Hand and Glove Contamination after Contact with a VRE (+) Patient Environment. ICAAC, 2001, Chicago, IL.
  • 19.
    USA and Indiaworking together to improve hand hygiene • Method: 17 bed ICU used remote video auditing with feedback • Auditors in India viewed live video of HCW in a US hospital performing hand hygiene • Each observation was assigned pass/fail Ref: Armellino D et al. 2012 Clin Inf Dis 54(1) 1-7.
  • 20.
    Results 60,542 observations • Pre-feedback hand hygiene rates 6.5% (3.5%-9.8%) by remote 24/7 observation • Post-feedback 30.8% the first few weeks 87.9% with light-emitting diode boards
  • 21.
  • 22.
    Black Light Marker • Fluorescent marker – An invisible gel that glows under blacklight – Applied to surfaces in over 40 US hospitals – An inert, safe, and unreactive substance Without black light Ref: Carling PC. Clin Infect Dis 2006;42(3):385
  • 23.
    Challenge How can you control the spread of MDRO in your hospital? Solutions 1. Novel technology 2. Empower patients* (only 14% of patients feel comfortable asking their MD/RN to wash their hands) Ref *2012 ICHE Ottum 33(12)1282-4, 3. Identify patient s at high risk for MDRO Ref: Han et al. 2012 ICHE;33(12) 1242-5 4. Chlorhexidine bathing 70% decline in CDI with daily bathing Ref: Rupp et al. 2012 ICHE;33(11):1094-1100
  • 24.
    Stewardship in Limited ResourceHospitals around the world
  • 25.
    Stewardship in S.Africa Challenges: 3 ID physicians for all of S Africa, lack of funding, pharmacist are not ID trained, some public hospitals do not have sinks
  • 26.
    Stewardship and S.Africa • Implemented Feb 2012 • Dedicated “champions” across S. Africa (physicians, infection control practitioners, pharmacists, microbiologists) • Collaboration between public and private hospitals, administration and government
  • 27.
    Stewardship and S.Africa • Projects iv to oral de-escalation implementing antibiograms • Education 12 enrolled in on-line certification program in US • email communication • Conference calls, Facetime, Skype • Integrate “apps” to educate providers • Twitter
  • 28.
    Outcomes of Stewardship •S. Africa successful conversion of IV to PO therapeutic vancomycin levels develop antibiogram • Dubai ICU improve “Hang-time” of antimicrobials • Serbia developed a “team” to identify how to utilize micro data to guide empiric use of antibiotics
  • 29.
    Antimicrobial Stewardship Managementof Infections : Beyond the Costs of Antimicrobials Ref: Goff D. et al. Inf Dis Special Ed. 2012 15:35-46
  • 30.
    Antimicrobial Stewardship Managementof Infections : Beyond the Costs of Antimicrobials Ref: Goff D. et al. Inf Dis Special Ed. 2012 15:35-46
  • 31.
    Challenge How does stewardship impact patient care?
  • 32.
    Clinical Outcome Measures Can you show improvement in clinical outcomes? • Reduced LOS Bauer K., Goff D. Clin Inf Dis 2010; 51(9):1074–1080 Fishman N. Am J Med 2006;119 (6 suppl 1) S53-S61 Gentry CA AM J Health Syst Pharm 2000;57(3) 268-74. • Better patient outcome Bauer K., Goff D. Clin Inf Dis 2010; 51(9):1074–1080 Fishman N. Am J Med 2006;119 (6 suppl 1) S53-S61 White A. et al Clin Inf Dis 1997;25:230-9. • Decreased inappropriate use Gandhi T. Crit Care Med 2010;38(8 suppl) S315-323 Apisarnthanarak A. Clin Inf Dis 2006;42(6) 768-775
  • 33.
    What works: Technologyand Education • ASP certification program in USA MAD-ID Making a Difference Infectious Diseases international online program S. Africa, Singapore, Canada, Saudi Arabia, Australia http://mad-id.org • Free apps from the Apple store Idpodcasts Weekly podcasts on ID topics • Free webinars and handouts ASHP American Society of Health Systems Pharmacists www.LeadStewardship.org • http://www.cdc.gov/getsmart/specific-groups/hcp/index.html free handouts, brochures, powerpoint slides on ASP
  • 34.
    So what canyou do? • Start now • Collaborate • Identify key leaders to develop guidelines (based on national guidelines, tailored to your institution) • Consequences for non compliance? • Educate (telemedicine programs) School of Telemedicine and • Biomedical Informatics, Sanjay Gandhi Postgraduate Institute of Medical Sciences Lucknow, India. • Patient’s lives depend on effective stewardship
  • 35.