ARCH 416
Spring '15
Suburban, Exurban, Rural
agenda
• suburbs
• early "garden" suburbs
• Levittown, NY
• exurbs
• Sam Mockbee and the Rural Studio
suburban pattern
Tim Burton
"Ballet de Suburbia"
Edward Scissorhands (1990)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9XVANpDVh5Y
what's wrong with sprawl?
art + culture of suburbia
Richard Yates, Revolutionary Road (1961)
John Cheever, "The Swimmer," (1964)
Jonathan Franzen, The Corrections (2001)
SAM MOCKBEE
(1944-2001)
On receiving a Macarthur
“Genius” Award: “I’m no
genius, but I’m smart enough
to take the money.”
4 examples
• Bryant House (Haybale House), Mason’s Bend, AL, 1994
• Harris House (Butterfly House), Mason’s Bend, AL, 1996
• Lucy's House, Mason's Bend, AL, 1997
• Mason’s Bend Community Center, Mason’s Bend, AL,
2000
Mockbee's philosophy
"Critical thought requires looking beyond architecture
towards an enhanced understanding of the whole to which it
belongs. Accordingly, the role of architecture should be
placed in relation to other issues of education, healthcare,
transportation, recreation, law enforcement, employment, the
environment, the collective community that impacts on the
lives of both the rich and the poor."
—Samuel Mockbee, "The Rural Studio," 1998
Mockbee/Coker, The Roger Cook House, Memphis, TN 1994
Roger Cook House,
interior
Mockbee’s evolution
from larger to smaller jobs
from wealthier to poorer clients
Bryant House (Hay Bale House)
Mason’s Bend, AL, 1995
The Bryants told Mockbee and the students that they wanted
mainly two things in a house: a room big enough for a bed and
desk for each grandchild and a front porch to entertain neighbors
and family.
Bryant House
rear elevation
"Architecture has to be greater than just architecture. It has to
address social values, as well as technical and aesthetic values."
Harris House (Butterfly House),
Mason’s Bend, AL, 1996
Samuel Mockbee, Harris House (The Butterfly House), 1996
interior
"Everyone, rich or poor, deserves a shelter for
the soul."
Lucy's House, 1997
three main elements
• a single-story living space,
• a screened-in porch, and
• tower that doubled as a master bedroom upstairs and
tornado shelter/family room downstairs.
72,000 individually stacked carpet tiles
Sam Mockbee and the Rural Studio, Mason’s Bend Community Center, 2000
Detail, interior
Community Center, illuminated at night
Sam Mockbee, Mason’s Bend Community Center, 1997-2001
Richard MEIER
Jubilee Church
Rome, Italy
1996 - 2003
Which building is more beautiful?
Are your criteria: technical?
aesthetic?
"To live in a space that supports our emotional and physical
well beings so perfectly is something we don’t take for
granted," she explains. "In all of the other houses we’ve lived
in, we have felt that they have taken a toll on us, whether it
was because they were too expensive and paying for them
created stress, or because they were so cluttered with
excess, unnecessary material things that we felt stifled.
Living tiny forces organization and simplicity and prevents
build up of clutter and chaos."
Compare and contrast according to Mockbee’s three criteria:
1. Moral sense
2. Ability to observe (truth)
3. Sense of wonder
Which building is most
likely to have been
designed by Frank Gehry,
and why? Cite at least
three pieces of visual
evidence in support of
your conclusion.

ARCH416Suburb,Exurb, Rural

  • 1.
  • 2.
    agenda • suburbs • early"garden" suburbs • Levittown, NY • exurbs • Sam Mockbee and the Rural Studio
  • 3.
  • 20.
    Tim Burton "Ballet deSuburbia" Edward Scissorhands (1990) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9XVANpDVh5Y
  • 21.
  • 56.
    art + cultureof suburbia Richard Yates, Revolutionary Road (1961) John Cheever, "The Swimmer," (1964) Jonathan Franzen, The Corrections (2001)
  • 57.
    SAM MOCKBEE (1944-2001) On receivinga Macarthur “Genius” Award: “I’m no genius, but I’m smart enough to take the money.”
  • 58.
    4 examples • BryantHouse (Haybale House), Mason’s Bend, AL, 1994 • Harris House (Butterfly House), Mason’s Bend, AL, 1996 • Lucy's House, Mason's Bend, AL, 1997 • Mason’s Bend Community Center, Mason’s Bend, AL, 2000
  • 59.
    Mockbee's philosophy "Critical thoughtrequires looking beyond architecture towards an enhanced understanding of the whole to which it belongs. Accordingly, the role of architecture should be placed in relation to other issues of education, healthcare, transportation, recreation, law enforcement, employment, the environment, the collective community that impacts on the lives of both the rich and the poor." —Samuel Mockbee, "The Rural Studio," 1998
  • 60.
    Mockbee/Coker, The RogerCook House, Memphis, TN 1994
  • 61.
  • 62.
    Mockbee’s evolution from largerto smaller jobs from wealthier to poorer clients
  • 63.
    Bryant House (HayBale House) Mason’s Bend, AL, 1995
  • 64.
    The Bryants toldMockbee and the students that they wanted mainly two things in a house: a room big enough for a bed and desk for each grandchild and a front porch to entertain neighbors and family.
  • 65.
  • 67.
    "Architecture has tobe greater than just architecture. It has to address social values, as well as technical and aesthetic values."
  • 68.
    Harris House (ButterflyHouse), Mason’s Bend, AL, 1996
  • 69.
    Samuel Mockbee, HarrisHouse (The Butterfly House), 1996
  • 70.
  • 71.
    "Everyone, rich orpoor, deserves a shelter for the soul."
  • 72.
    Lucy's House, 1997 threemain elements • a single-story living space, • a screened-in porch, and • tower that doubled as a master bedroom upstairs and tornado shelter/family room downstairs.
  • 74.
  • 77.
    Sam Mockbee andthe Rural Studio, Mason’s Bend Community Center, 2000
  • 79.
  • 81.
  • 84.
    Sam Mockbee, Mason’sBend Community Center, 1997-2001
  • 85.
  • 88.
    Which building ismore beautiful? Are your criteria: technical? aesthetic?
  • 89.
    "To live ina space that supports our emotional and physical well beings so perfectly is something we don’t take for granted," she explains. "In all of the other houses we’ve lived in, we have felt that they have taken a toll on us, whether it was because they were too expensive and paying for them created stress, or because they were so cluttered with excess, unnecessary material things that we felt stifled. Living tiny forces organization and simplicity and prevents build up of clutter and chaos."
  • 90.
    Compare and contrastaccording to Mockbee’s three criteria: 1. Moral sense 2. Ability to observe (truth) 3. Sense of wonder
  • 91.
    Which building ismost likely to have been designed by Frank Gehry, and why? Cite at least three pieces of visual evidence in support of your conclusion.