IIC – Telecommunications & Media Forum Washington, D.C. Tuesday, December 1, 2009 Beyond Recession – Visions for Broadband Communications Post 2010 Kenneth Engelhart  Senior Vice President - Regulatory
Where are we heading? Global Ubiquitous Mobile Broadband HSPA Plus followed by LTE In Canada, 3 National Carriers offering 21 Mps service Not WiFi, probably not WiMax
Policy Implications Planned Rural Broadband Initiatives in Canada and US are probably already Obsolete. Broadband Competition Not Just DSL vs. Cable Now 1, 2, 3 or 4 more mobile wireless competitors
Mobile Broadband will compete with Fixed Broadband
Broadband Metrics Will become even more complicated. Wireline broadband – should be measured per household, not per pop. Canada has “sunk” from #2 in the world to #10 based on population. But we are also #5 in the world based on household penetration. Many policy conclusions in Canada are based on erroneous population metric.
Wireless Penetration Canadian Wireless penetration is one of the lowest in the OECD – 68%. But what does a 200% penetration rate mean? According to Merrill Lynch, Canada is eighth best in the world on MOU/capita – a better measure of wireless usages.
Broadband Speed OECD samples advertized speeds and again Canada does poorly. The selection of services is a bit of a mystery. No weighting of the advertized speeds. Akamai is a much better measure – speeds customers actually receive, gathered in a random, unbiased way. Canada is eighth best among OECD countries in % of customers at 5 Mbps or greater.
Conclusion Sound policy should be based on sound metrics.

Beyond recession - visions for broadband

  • 1.
    IIC – Telecommunications& Media Forum Washington, D.C. Tuesday, December 1, 2009 Beyond Recession – Visions for Broadband Communications Post 2010 Kenneth Engelhart Senior Vice President - Regulatory
  • 2.
    Where are weheading? Global Ubiquitous Mobile Broadband HSPA Plus followed by LTE In Canada, 3 National Carriers offering 21 Mps service Not WiFi, probably not WiMax
  • 3.
    Policy Implications PlannedRural Broadband Initiatives in Canada and US are probably already Obsolete. Broadband Competition Not Just DSL vs. Cable Now 1, 2, 3 or 4 more mobile wireless competitors
  • 4.
    Mobile Broadband willcompete with Fixed Broadband
  • 5.
    Broadband Metrics Willbecome even more complicated. Wireline broadband – should be measured per household, not per pop. Canada has “sunk” from #2 in the world to #10 based on population. But we are also #5 in the world based on household penetration. Many policy conclusions in Canada are based on erroneous population metric.
  • 6.
    Wireless Penetration CanadianWireless penetration is one of the lowest in the OECD – 68%. But what does a 200% penetration rate mean? According to Merrill Lynch, Canada is eighth best in the world on MOU/capita – a better measure of wireless usages.
  • 7.
    Broadband Speed OECDsamples advertized speeds and again Canada does poorly. The selection of services is a bit of a mystery. No weighting of the advertized speeds. Akamai is a much better measure – speeds customers actually receive, gathered in a random, unbiased way. Canada is eighth best among OECD countries in % of customers at 5 Mbps or greater.
  • 8.
    Conclusion Sound policyshould be based on sound metrics.