Mobile Scare: Google/Search
Engines May be Scaring your Mobile
Users Away
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
Google: More Searches Now On
Mobile Than On Desktop
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
Search Is #1 Content Discovery
Tool For Mobile Users
Source: IAB, Harris
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
Mobile-First Design Initiative
- Google
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
“To improve the search experience for
smartphone users and address their pain points,
we plan to roll out several ranking changes in the
near future that address sites that are
misconfigured for smartphone users.“
Yoshikiyo Kato, Software Engineer,
on behalf of Google Mobile Search
MOBILE RANKINGS
‱ At SMX West, Google’s Gary llyes surprised the crowd:
Google already has plans for a separate mobile index and
there is a team already working on it.
‱ He isn’t sure what stage they are at, so Google has
nothing to announce about it at this time. (More here:
Google is Working on Completely Separate Mobile Index
From Desktop Index)
GOOGLE MOBILE INDEX
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
Responsive Dedicated Dynamic
Serving
‱ ALL devices
‱ 1 URL
‱ Same Content/HTML
‱ Use CSS to render pages
‱ Separate Mobile & Desktop
URLs
example.com/m/
m.example.com
‱ Different HTML
‱ All devices
‱ 1 URL
‱ different HTML (and CSS)
depending on user agent
(desktop or mobile device)
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
Responsive Dedicated Dynamic
Serving
Pros ‱ 1 URL
‱ Easier to maintain
‱ Link Consolidation
‱ No Redirects > Reduce
Loading Time
‱ Recommended By
Google (saves resources,
pages crawled once)
‱ Small/Medium Sites
‱ Better Mobile Experience
‱ Faster
‱ Dedicated Mobile Content
‱ Easier Implementation
‱ 1 URL
‱ Link Consolidation
‱ Capacity for different
mobile content
‱ Complex/Large Sites
Cons ‱ Slower
‱ Same Mobile/Desktop
Content
‱ Link Equity Dilution
‱ Higher Cost to maintain
‱ Crawled Multiple Times
with different user agents
‱ Slower
‱ Higher Cost to maintain
‱ Old Redirect Lists
‱ Complex technical
implementation
‱ Crawled Multiple Times
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
Responsive Dedicated Dynamic
Serving
‱ ALL devices
‱ 1 URL
‱ Same Content/HTML
‱ Use CSS to render pages
‱ Separate Mobile &
Desktop URLs
example.com/m/
m.example.com
‱ Different HTML
‱ All devices
‱ 1 URL
‱ different HTML (and CSS)
depending on user agent
(desktop or mobile device)
Pros ‱ 1 URL
‱ Easier to maintain
‱ Link Consolidation
‱ No Redirects > Reduce
Loading Time
‱ Recommended By Google
(saves resources, pages
crawled once)
‱ Small/Medium Sites
‱ Better Mobile Experience
‱ Faster
‱ Dedicated Mobile Content
‱ Easier Implementation
‱ 1 URL
‱ Link Consolidation
‱ Capacity for different
mobile content
‱ Complex/Large Sites
Cons ‱ Slower
‱ Same Mobile/Desktop
Content
‱ Link Equity Dilution
‱ Higher Cost to maintain
‱ Crawled Multiple Times
with different user agents
‱ Slower
‱ Higher Cost to maintain
‱ Old Redirect Lists
‱ Complex technical
implementation
‱ Crawled Multiple Times
SEO ‱ Check Google Webmaster
Tools Crawl Errors for
Redirect & 404 Errors
‱ Check Page Load Time for
Mobile and Desktop
‱ Allow Search Engines to
crawl all assets (CSS, Images,
JS)
‱ Redirect Mobile Users and
Bots to the mobile site
‱ Test Desktop Site for
Redirects & 404 Errors
‱ Add Rel=Alternate to
desktop and rel=Canonical to
mobile site
‱ XML Mobile Sitemaps
‱ Use user-agent vary header
to help search bots to find
your mobile content
‱ Test for Vary: User-Agent
HTTP Header
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
Word of Caution
‱ Responsive is not the answer to all problems and
may not be suitable for your site/industry yet!!
‱ Googlebot-mobile is only used to crawl feature
phones content
‱ Googlebot is used to crawl smartphones content
Read: http://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.com/2014/01/a-new-googlebot-user-agent-for-crawling.html
‱ Even though Google recommends Responsive
implementations, they have been pretty clear that
they will treat all mobile subdomains, dynamic
serving, and responsive web designs (RWD)
implementations the same (from a ranking
perspective).
‱ If you have no mobile page, show the desktop page
Read: http://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.com/2014/01/a-new-googlebot-user-agent-for-crawling.html
Bing
‱ Ideally, there shouldn’t be a difference between the “mobile-
friendly” URL and the “desktop” URL
‱ the site would automatically adjust to the device — content,
layout, and all.
‱ That’s why we continue to recommend you use responsive
designs over separate mobile (m.*) sites
‱ ensure a great experience for users on all devices and avoid
compatibility, readability, and functionality issues.
‱ http://blogs.bing.com/webmaster/2014/11/20/bing-and-mobile-
friends/
‱ http://blogs.bing.com/webmaster/2014/11/03/meet-our-mobile-
bots/
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
Tablet
‱ Google has no specific recommendations for search engine
friendly sites.
‱ You can use any of the 3 approaches
‱ Serve tablet users the desktop version (or if available, the
tablet version).
Read: https://developers.google.com/webmasters/smartphone-sites/tablets
Mobile Ranking Factors
‱ SEO Traditional Ranking factors
‱ Important Ranking Factors
‱ Mobile Friendliness
‱ Mobile Usability
‱ Mobile Speed/Performance
‱ Negative Mobile SEO Factors
‱ Mobile Errors
‱ Broken Content
Mobile-Friendly
‱ Test your site @ Google Mobile-Friendly Test Tool
‱ https://www.google.com/webmasters/tools/mobile-
friendly/
‱ Blocked Internal Resources may prevent Google
from recognizing your site as mobile-friendly site
‱ Page by Page
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
‱ Page speed is a ranking factor since 2010
‱ Google Released a ton of tools and reports to
help improve page speed
‱ Google started testing “Slow” Red
Labels
‱ How will this affect your CTR??
‱ http://searchengineland.com/google-
testing-red-slow-label-search-results-
slower-sites-215483
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
Where to Start?
“80-90% of the end-user response time is spent on
the frontend. Start There.”
- Steve Souders, Google’s Head Performance Engineer
‱ I.E. Backend actions (database queries,
server delays and hardware limitations,

) only account for 10-20% of your load
time!!
Google PageSpeed Insights Tool
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
Optimized Rendering
Read: https://developers.google.com/web/fundamentals/performance/
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
Above-The-Fold (ATF) Content
‱ 1 second load time for 'above-
the-fold content' on mobile sites!
Read: https://developers.google.com/speed/docs/insights/mobile
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
Optimize Speed
‱ Avoid Multiple Redirects
‱ Example.com > www.example.com > m.example.com (slow
mobile experience)
‱ Consolidate DNS requests
‱ Enable gzip Compressions (reduces up to 90%)
‱ Remove unnecessary / legacy code
‱ Optimize Images
‱ Proper formatting and compression
‱ Use Web fonts instead of encoding text in images
“Avoiding these mistakes helps your smartphone users
engage with your site fully and helps searchers find what
they're looking for faster. To improve the search experience
for smartphone users and address their pain points, we
plan to roll out several ranking changes in the near
future that address sites that are misconfigured for
smartphone users.”
6/11/13 Google Webmaster
Central Blog
MOBILE ERRORS
‱ First, Check Google Webmaster Tools Crawl Errors
MOBILE ERRORS
Faulty Redirects
‱ Google Reporting Faulty Mobile Redirects
http://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.ca/2014/06
/faulty-redirects.html
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
Unplayable Videos
‱ Verify no flash is used for navigation, videos, or other
elements on mobile pages.
‱ HTML5 is preferred for video players.
‱ Google warns users of incompatible sites.
‱ Consider having the transcript of the video available on
all devices as that may better serve your smartphone
users.
Interstitials
‱ Avoid App Download Interstitials (use banners
instead)
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
‱ Irrelevant cross-linking between desktop and
mobile content
‱ Infinite redirect loops
‱ Googlebot-mobile > redirected to feature phones site >
redirects to smartphone site > redirects to desktop site
READ: https://developers.google.com/webmasters/smartphone-sites/common-mistakes
MOBILE ERRORS
‱ Unplayable Videos
‱ Flash/Sliverlight
‱ Popups
‱ Sideway Scrolling
‱ Tiny Font/Buttons
‱ Device Specific Content
‱ Slow Pages
BROKEN CONTENT
Desktop vs Mobile
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
Page Timing
#SEJSummit
#Searchmetrics
@JShehata
Takeaways
‱ Choose the site structure Wisely. Responsive is not the
answer for all your problems!!
‱ Fix broken content and faulty redirects
‱ Mobile SEO is technical
‱ User experience is important
‱ Focus on Local SEO, Social, and Focus Email markup.
‱ More SERP real estate for Paid results in mobile
TAKEAWAYS
Big Brands, Mobile SEO and You by John Shehata - #SEJSummit New York City

Big Brands, Mobile SEO and You by John Shehata - #SEJSummit New York City

  • 4.
    Mobile Scare: Google/Search EnginesMay be Scaring your Mobile Users Away
  • 5.
  • 6.
    Google: More SearchesNow On Mobile Than On Desktop
  • 7.
  • 8.
    Search Is #1Content Discovery Tool For Mobile Users
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
    “To improve thesearch experience for smartphone users and address their pain points, we plan to roll out several ranking changes in the near future that address sites that are misconfigured for smartphone users.“ Yoshikiyo Kato, Software Engineer, on behalf of Google Mobile Search MOBILE RANKINGS
  • 13.
    ‱ At SMXWest, Google’s Gary llyes surprised the crowd: Google already has plans for a separate mobile index and there is a team already working on it. ‱ He isn’t sure what stage they are at, so Google has nothing to announce about it at this time. (More here: Google is Working on Completely Separate Mobile Index From Desktop Index) GOOGLE MOBILE INDEX
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
    Responsive Dedicated Dynamic Serving ‱ALL devices ‱ 1 URL ‱ Same Content/HTML ‱ Use CSS to render pages ‱ Separate Mobile & Desktop URLs example.com/m/ m.example.com ‱ Different HTML ‱ All devices ‱ 1 URL ‱ different HTML (and CSS) depending on user agent (desktop or mobile device) #SEJSummit #Searchmetrics @JShehata
  • 18.
    Responsive Dedicated Dynamic Serving Pros‱ 1 URL ‱ Easier to maintain ‱ Link Consolidation ‱ No Redirects > Reduce Loading Time ‱ Recommended By Google (saves resources, pages crawled once) ‱ Small/Medium Sites ‱ Better Mobile Experience ‱ Faster ‱ Dedicated Mobile Content ‱ Easier Implementation ‱ 1 URL ‱ Link Consolidation ‱ Capacity for different mobile content ‱ Complex/Large Sites Cons ‱ Slower ‱ Same Mobile/Desktop Content ‱ Link Equity Dilution ‱ Higher Cost to maintain ‱ Crawled Multiple Times with different user agents ‱ Slower ‱ Higher Cost to maintain ‱ Old Redirect Lists ‱ Complex technical implementation ‱ Crawled Multiple Times #SEJSummit #Searchmetrics @JShehata
  • 19.
    Responsive Dedicated Dynamic Serving ‱ALL devices ‱ 1 URL ‱ Same Content/HTML ‱ Use CSS to render pages ‱ Separate Mobile & Desktop URLs example.com/m/ m.example.com ‱ Different HTML ‱ All devices ‱ 1 URL ‱ different HTML (and CSS) depending on user agent (desktop or mobile device) Pros ‱ 1 URL ‱ Easier to maintain ‱ Link Consolidation ‱ No Redirects > Reduce Loading Time ‱ Recommended By Google (saves resources, pages crawled once) ‱ Small/Medium Sites ‱ Better Mobile Experience ‱ Faster ‱ Dedicated Mobile Content ‱ Easier Implementation ‱ 1 URL ‱ Link Consolidation ‱ Capacity for different mobile content ‱ Complex/Large Sites Cons ‱ Slower ‱ Same Mobile/Desktop Content ‱ Link Equity Dilution ‱ Higher Cost to maintain ‱ Crawled Multiple Times with different user agents ‱ Slower ‱ Higher Cost to maintain ‱ Old Redirect Lists ‱ Complex technical implementation ‱ Crawled Multiple Times
  • 20.
    SEO ‱ CheckGoogle Webmaster Tools Crawl Errors for Redirect & 404 Errors ‱ Check Page Load Time for Mobile and Desktop ‱ Allow Search Engines to crawl all assets (CSS, Images, JS) ‱ Redirect Mobile Users and Bots to the mobile site ‱ Test Desktop Site for Redirects & 404 Errors ‱ Add Rel=Alternate to desktop and rel=Canonical to mobile site ‱ XML Mobile Sitemaps ‱ Use user-agent vary header to help search bots to find your mobile content ‱ Test for Vary: User-Agent HTTP Header #SEJSummit #Searchmetrics @JShehata
  • 21.
  • 22.
    ‱ Responsive isnot the answer to all problems and may not be suitable for your site/industry yet!! ‱ Googlebot-mobile is only used to crawl feature phones content ‱ Googlebot is used to crawl smartphones content Read: http://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.com/2014/01/a-new-googlebot-user-agent-for-crawling.html
  • 23.
    ‱ Even thoughGoogle recommends Responsive implementations, they have been pretty clear that they will treat all mobile subdomains, dynamic serving, and responsive web designs (RWD) implementations the same (from a ranking perspective). ‱ If you have no mobile page, show the desktop page Read: http://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.com/2014/01/a-new-googlebot-user-agent-for-crawling.html
  • 24.
  • 25.
    ‱ Ideally, thereshouldn’t be a difference between the “mobile- friendly” URL and the “desktop” URL ‱ the site would automatically adjust to the device — content, layout, and all. ‱ That’s why we continue to recommend you use responsive designs over separate mobile (m.*) sites ‱ ensure a great experience for users on all devices and avoid compatibility, readability, and functionality issues.
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28.
  • 29.
    ‱ Google hasno specific recommendations for search engine friendly sites. ‱ You can use any of the 3 approaches ‱ Serve tablet users the desktop version (or if available, the tablet version). Read: https://developers.google.com/webmasters/smartphone-sites/tablets
  • 31.
  • 32.
    ‱ SEO TraditionalRanking factors ‱ Important Ranking Factors ‱ Mobile Friendliness ‱ Mobile Usability ‱ Mobile Speed/Performance ‱ Negative Mobile SEO Factors ‱ Mobile Errors ‱ Broken Content
  • 34.
  • 35.
    ‱ Test yoursite @ Google Mobile-Friendly Test Tool ‱ https://www.google.com/webmasters/tools/mobile- friendly/ ‱ Blocked Internal Resources may prevent Google from recognizing your site as mobile-friendly site ‱ Page by Page
  • 36.
  • 38.
  • 40.
    ‱ Page speedis a ranking factor since 2010 ‱ Google Released a ton of tools and reports to help improve page speed
  • 41.
    ‱ Google startedtesting “Slow” Red Labels ‱ How will this affect your CTR?? ‱ http://searchengineland.com/google- testing-red-slow-label-search-results- slower-sites-215483 #SEJSummit #Searchmetrics @JShehata
  • 42.
  • 43.
    “80-90% of theend-user response time is spent on the frontend. Start There.” - Steve Souders, Google’s Head Performance Engineer ‱ I.E. Backend actions (database queries, server delays and hardware limitations, 
) only account for 10-20% of your load time!!
  • 44.
  • 45.
  • 46.
  • 47.
  • 48.
  • 49.
    ‱ 1 secondload time for 'above- the-fold content' on mobile sites! Read: https://developers.google.com/speed/docs/insights/mobile
  • 50.
  • 51.
  • 52.
    ‱ Avoid MultipleRedirects ‱ Example.com > www.example.com > m.example.com (slow mobile experience) ‱ Consolidate DNS requests ‱ Enable gzip Compressions (reduces up to 90%) ‱ Remove unnecessary / legacy code
  • 53.
    ‱ Optimize Images ‱Proper formatting and compression ‱ Use Web fonts instead of encoding text in images
  • 55.
    “Avoiding these mistakeshelps your smartphone users engage with your site fully and helps searchers find what they're looking for faster. To improve the search experience for smartphone users and address their pain points, we plan to roll out several ranking changes in the near future that address sites that are misconfigured for smartphone users.” 6/11/13 Google Webmaster Central Blog MOBILE ERRORS
  • 56.
    ‱ First, CheckGoogle Webmaster Tools Crawl Errors MOBILE ERRORS
  • 57.
  • 58.
    ‱ Google ReportingFaulty Mobile Redirects http://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.ca/2014/06 /faulty-redirects.html
  • 59.
  • 60.
  • 61.
  • 62.
    ‱ Verify noflash is used for navigation, videos, or other elements on mobile pages. ‱ HTML5 is preferred for video players. ‱ Google warns users of incompatible sites. ‱ Consider having the transcript of the video available on all devices as that may better serve your smartphone users.
  • 63.
  • 64.
    ‱ Avoid AppDownload Interstitials (use banners instead)
  • 65.
  • 66.
    ‱ Irrelevant cross-linkingbetween desktop and mobile content ‱ Infinite redirect loops ‱ Googlebot-mobile > redirected to feature phones site > redirects to smartphone site > redirects to desktop site READ: https://developers.google.com/webmasters/smartphone-sites/common-mistakes MOBILE ERRORS
  • 68.
    ‱ Unplayable Videos ‱Flash/Sliverlight ‱ Popups ‱ Sideway Scrolling ‱ Tiny Font/Buttons ‱ Device Specific Content ‱ Slow Pages BROKEN CONTENT
  • 70.
  • 71.
  • 72.
  • 73.
  • 74.
  • 75.
    ‱ Choose thesite structure Wisely. Responsive is not the answer for all your problems!! ‱ Fix broken content and faulty redirects ‱ Mobile SEO is technical ‱ User experience is important ‱ Focus on Local SEO, Social, and Focus Email markup. ‱ More SERP real estate for Paid results in mobile TAKEAWAYS