Business models for web TV


        Alessandro Masi

        Milan, 19 Dec 2009
TOWARDS WEB TV…


• Shift of the audience from traditional to new TV

• Increase of Internet broadband connections

• Media integration process




  Web TV = open online video distribution
      over unicast or P2P protocols
RESEARCH QUESTION




What are the business models that allow to
generate revenues from web TV? How are they
shaped according to the strategic objectives?

Is web TV a sustainable business in the long run?
Is there any theory that supports (or denies) this
argument?
RESEARCH METHODS


• Top 200 websites (Unique Visitors) for online video distribution,
either of user generated or professionally-produced content

• 44 variables analyzed for each website: features, business
model, content licensing, uploading and privacy regimes

• Accessible from Italy

• Language: italian and/or english

• 2 on-demand or 1 live channels (at least)

• Self-organizing maps and k-means algorithms cluster analysis;
two-step clustering
MAIN FINDINGS…

Two primary variables determine the business strategy of a
web TV:
• Business model
• Type of content

Those two variables are inter-dependent, and the choice is
also related to the core business of the operator.

Then, some secondary variables allow the web TV to
differentiate from competitors:
• The range of VOD channels
• The amount of live content
• The role of the community
• The type of advertising
MAIN FINDINGS…
BUSINESS MODELS


• B2c premium model  sale of the contents (pay-per-view or
with subscription), with marginal revenues from advertising

• B2c ad-based model  banner, pre-roll, overlay, ad-funded
content

• B2c mixed  premium + “freemium”, ad-revenues sharing,

• CRM-based model  communication and interaction, both
internal and external

• Free model  self-financing and fund-raising

• B2b model  service, solutions and content providers
BUSINESS MODELS

            PA – subscription                                                            PA – subscription

             PA - PayPerView
                                                                                          PA - PayPerView

 PA - free with advertisement
                                                                              PA - free with advertisement
  PA - free (no advertisement)
                                                                               PA - free (no advertisement)
                 PA – donation
                                                                                             PA – donation
                                 0%
                                              50%                       FE - Operator - Broadcaster and
                                                                                                              0%
                                                                100%    Local TV
FE - both produced and UG content                                       FE - Operator - News and                             50%
FE - only professionally-produced content                               magazines                                                                100%
FE - only UGC                                                           FE - Operator - On-line video
                                                                        company
                                                                        FE - Operator - PA and other
                                                                        companies


    100%
     90%
     80%                                                                                                              PA – donation
     70%                                                                                                              PA - free (no advertisement)
     60%                                    FE - only UGC                                                             PA - free with advertisement
     50%                                                                                                              PA - PayPerView
     40%                                                                                                  66%
                                                                                                                      PA – subscription
     30%                                    FE - only professionally-
      20%                                   produced content
      10%
       0%                                   FE - both produced and
                                            UG content


                                                                                                                       5%
                                                                                       14%                      12%
                                                                                                  3%
STRATEGIC ISSUES

Pure strategies
Pure players  ad-based,
integration of premium
contents, b2b market

Portfolio strategies
Web editors  ad-based
with premium sections

Multichannel/portfolio
strategies
Other media  ad-based

Multichannel strategies
Broadcasters  ad-based
and premium model

CRM strategies
PA and companies  free
MONEY???

                                US online video ad
                                spending in 2011:
                                • $4,309 mln
REVENUES                        • 9.8% of total
• Pay-per-view for VOD          online ad spending
• Subscription                  Source: eMarketer
• Donation
• Advertising (banner,
  Google Ads, embedded video)

OPERATING COSTS
• Production, acquisition,
  or digitalization
• Storage
• Publishing and distribution
WEB TV’S LONG TAIL

“Forget squeezing millions from a few megahits at the top
of the charts. The future of entertainment is in the millions
of niche markets at the shallow end of the bitstream.”

Anderson, C. (2006). The long tail: why the future of business is
selling less of more.
WEB TV: STRENGHTS & WEAKNESSES

            Strengths           Weaknesses

              Multi-channel     Loss of control
Content
              (niches)          over contents
              Ad-hoc contents   DRM systems
              UGC               Lack of visibility
              Personalization
              Interactivity


              Accessibility     The “logic of the

Economics     Targeted          free”
              advertising       Ad skipping
                                Undefined
                                business model
IN CONCLUSION…

• The current context is highly scattered, given the high accessibility
to the market: webcasters shape the business model according to
different strategic objectives, which are basically related to the core
business of the operator and to the type of content. Either a clear
definition of business models or innovative ones are needed.

• The majority of money for web TV currently comes from
advertising. The free-logic of the Internet does not allow to rely on
premium services (subscription and pay-per-view), but webcasters
should find the way to monetize by increasing the value of the
offering or enhance the involvement of the communities (e.g.
advertising revenues sharing, UGC, self-financing).

• Internet overcomes distribution constraints and limited offering
and makes possible even to the smallest business to generate
revenues reaching the market niches: the long tail theory explains
the reason for the growth and the long-term sustainability of web TV
business.
Thanks for your kind attention!

Business Models for Web TV - Research Presentation

  • 1.
    Business models forweb TV Alessandro Masi Milan, 19 Dec 2009
  • 2.
    TOWARDS WEB TV… •Shift of the audience from traditional to new TV • Increase of Internet broadband connections • Media integration process Web TV = open online video distribution over unicast or P2P protocols
  • 3.
    RESEARCH QUESTION What arethe business models that allow to generate revenues from web TV? How are they shaped according to the strategic objectives? Is web TV a sustainable business in the long run? Is there any theory that supports (or denies) this argument?
  • 4.
    RESEARCH METHODS • Top200 websites (Unique Visitors) for online video distribution, either of user generated or professionally-produced content • 44 variables analyzed for each website: features, business model, content licensing, uploading and privacy regimes • Accessible from Italy • Language: italian and/or english • 2 on-demand or 1 live channels (at least) • Self-organizing maps and k-means algorithms cluster analysis; two-step clustering
  • 5.
    MAIN FINDINGS… Two primaryvariables determine the business strategy of a web TV: • Business model • Type of content Those two variables are inter-dependent, and the choice is also related to the core business of the operator. Then, some secondary variables allow the web TV to differentiate from competitors: • The range of VOD channels • The amount of live content • The role of the community • The type of advertising
  • 6.
  • 7.
    BUSINESS MODELS • B2cpremium model  sale of the contents (pay-per-view or with subscription), with marginal revenues from advertising • B2c ad-based model  banner, pre-roll, overlay, ad-funded content • B2c mixed  premium + “freemium”, ad-revenues sharing, • CRM-based model  communication and interaction, both internal and external • Free model  self-financing and fund-raising • B2b model  service, solutions and content providers
  • 8.
    BUSINESS MODELS PA – subscription PA – subscription PA - PayPerView PA - PayPerView PA - free with advertisement PA - free with advertisement PA - free (no advertisement) PA - free (no advertisement) PA – donation PA – donation 0% 50% FE - Operator - Broadcaster and 0% 100% Local TV FE - both produced and UG content FE - Operator - News and 50% FE - only professionally-produced content magazines 100% FE - only UGC FE - Operator - On-line video company FE - Operator - PA and other companies 100% 90% 80% PA – donation 70% PA - free (no advertisement) 60% FE - only UGC PA - free with advertisement 50% PA - PayPerView 40% 66% PA – subscription 30% FE - only professionally- 20% produced content 10% 0% FE - both produced and UG content 5% 14% 12% 3%
  • 9.
    STRATEGIC ISSUES Pure strategies Pureplayers  ad-based, integration of premium contents, b2b market Portfolio strategies Web editors  ad-based with premium sections Multichannel/portfolio strategies Other media  ad-based Multichannel strategies Broadcasters  ad-based and premium model CRM strategies PA and companies  free
  • 10.
    MONEY??? US online video ad spending in 2011: • $4,309 mln REVENUES • 9.8% of total • Pay-per-view for VOD online ad spending • Subscription Source: eMarketer • Donation • Advertising (banner, Google Ads, embedded video) OPERATING COSTS • Production, acquisition, or digitalization • Storage • Publishing and distribution
  • 11.
    WEB TV’S LONGTAIL “Forget squeezing millions from a few megahits at the top of the charts. The future of entertainment is in the millions of niche markets at the shallow end of the bitstream.” Anderson, C. (2006). The long tail: why the future of business is selling less of more.
  • 12.
    WEB TV: STRENGHTS& WEAKNESSES Strengths Weaknesses Multi-channel Loss of control Content (niches) over contents Ad-hoc contents DRM systems UGC Lack of visibility Personalization Interactivity Accessibility The “logic of the Economics Targeted free” advertising Ad skipping Undefined business model
  • 13.
    IN CONCLUSION… • Thecurrent context is highly scattered, given the high accessibility to the market: webcasters shape the business model according to different strategic objectives, which are basically related to the core business of the operator and to the type of content. Either a clear definition of business models or innovative ones are needed. • The majority of money for web TV currently comes from advertising. The free-logic of the Internet does not allow to rely on premium services (subscription and pay-per-view), but webcasters should find the way to monetize by increasing the value of the offering or enhance the involvement of the communities (e.g. advertising revenues sharing, UGC, self-financing). • Internet overcomes distribution constraints and limited offering and makes possible even to the smallest business to generate revenues reaching the market niches: the long tail theory explains the reason for the growth and the long-term sustainability of web TV business.
  • 14.
    Thanks for yourkind attention!