Ocean Renewable Energy:
Offshore Wind, Wave & Tidal Power
             The Washington State Ocean Energy Conference:
              Deep Water Wind and Ocean Energy Economy
                        Bremerton, Washington
                         November 8 & 9, 2011




                                              Presented by
                                 Robert Thresher, NREL Research Fellow
                                    National Wind Technology Center
NREL is a national laboratory of the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy operated by the Alliance for Sustainable Energy, LLC
Energy sources in the United States in 2009




National Renewable Energy Laboratory            Innovation for Our Energy Future
Most U.S. Offshore Wind Resource is in Deep Water



                                                 GW by Depth (m)
                               Region     0 - 30     30 - 60     > 60
                     New England             100.2      136.2      250.4
                     Mid Atlantic            298.1      179.1       92.5
                     S. Atlantic Bight       134.1       48.8           7.7
                     California                4.4       10.5      573.0
                     Pacific Northw est       15.1       21.3      305.3
                     Great Lakes             176.7      106.4      459.4
                     Gulf of Mexico          340.3      120.1      133.3
                     Haw aii                   2.3        5.5      629.6
                               Total       1,071.2     628.0     2,451.1




                                                                              Assumptions:
                                                                              5 MW/km2
                                                                              7 m/s and greater
                                                                              0-50nm for shore
National Renewable Energy Laboratory                                          Innovation for Our Energy Future
Wind Technology Evolution




                         •   Land Based Technology > 2 MW; Turbine 50% Total Installation Cost
                         •   Offshore Technology > 5 MW; Turbine 25% Total Installation Cost
                         •   Land Based Turbine Size Constrained by Highway Transport
                         •   Turbine Stiffness & Dynamic Coupling Driving Design Innovation

National Renewable Energy Laboratory                                                          Innovation for Our Energy Future
Future Research on Offshore Wind Technology
    Land-based                   Shallow Water   Transitional Depth   Deepwater Floating
    Technology                    Technology        Technology           Technology




Offshore Wind
Technology
                                     Current
Development
                                   Technology




National Renewable Energy Laboratory                                     Innovation for Our Energy Future
Shallow Water Bottom Mounted:
                    GE project at Arklow Banks in the Irish Sea




                                                            Photo: R. Thresher

National Renewable Energy Laboratory                       Innovation for Our Energy Future
Principle Power 2-MW Demonstration
   Characteristics
   Country/Sponsor:                    Portugal
   Major Partners:                     Vestas, EDP
   Turbine Size/Description:           Vestas V-80, 2 MW
                                       wind turbine
   Deployment date :                   September 2011
   Platform Type:                      Three – tank
                                       semisubmersible – 6
                                       line mooring
   Site:                               Aguçadoura, Portugal
   Water Depth                         40 to 50-m
   Approximate Budget:                 $ 25M USD

Opportunities: The PPI WindFloat semi-submersible wind system is scheduled for installation
and commissioning off the Portuguese coast in Sept 2011. The installation includes a grid-
connected Vestas V80 2-MW wind turbine. Testing for at least 12 months is planned and will
focus on performance validation. An EU Framework 7 award increased their testing capability.
National Renewable Energy Laboratory                                     Innovation for Our Energy Future
NREL Dynamic Simulation Tool: HydroDyn
   Dynamic Analysis of Wind and Wave Interactions is an
 Important Technical Challenge for Floating Turbine Designs




National Renewable Energy Laboratory           Innovation for Our Energy Future
Visualization of Avian Interaction Zones
                                          Windfarm Flight Zone

                                                       Over-flight




                                                                     Fatality Risk

                                                    Strike Zone
                                                                                     Fly-thru




                                       Rotor Zone




National Renewable Energy Laboratory                                                 Innovation for Our Energy Future
Avian Strike Probability Versus Turbine Size

                   Altamont Scale
                                           Next Generation Scale




                                          93 Meter Diameter and 2.5MW

           15 Meter Diameter and 100 kW


National Renewable Energy Laboratory                      Innovation for Our Energy Future
Three Basic Forms of Marine Hydrokinetic (MHK) Energy
                                       CURRENTS
                                       • Activating force flows in same direction for at least a few
                                         hours
                                       • Tidal, river, and ocean variants
                                       • Conversion technology is some sort of submerged turbine


                                       WAVES
                                       • Activating force reverses direction every 5 to 20 seconds
                                       • Conversion technology can be floating or submerged, with
                                         a wide variety of devices still being invented and developed



                                       OCEAN THERMAL
                                       • A heat engine operating on the temperature difference
                                         between hot surface water and cool water at 1000 meters.
                                       • Several possible thermodynamic cycles
                                       • Conversion technology is on a floating platform with a long
                                         pipe to deep water
National Renewable Energy Laboratory                                            Innovation for Our Energy Future
The Many Wave Energy Technologies




National Renewable Energy Laboratory    Innovation for Our Energy Future
The Several Tidal, River and Ocean Current Technologies




National Renewable Energy Laboratory           Innovation for Our Energy Future
Minnesota – Economic Impacts
                                from 1000 MW of new wind development


                                        Wind energy’s economic “ripple effect”



                      Direct Impacts                   Indirect &                Totals
                                                       Induced Impacts           (construction + 20yrs)
                Payments to Landowners:
                • $2.7 million/year
                                                         Construction Phase:     Total economic benefit =
                Local Property Tax Revenue:              • 1530 new jobs           $1.1 billion
                • $2.8 million/year                      • $150.6 M to local     New local jobs during
                Construction Phase:
                                                           economies              construction = 2985
                • 1455 new jobs
                                                         Operational Phase:
                • $188.5 M to local economies                                    New local long-term jobs
                Operational Phase:                       • 177 local jobs
                • 232 new long-term jobs                 • $18.2 M/yr to local     = 409
                • $21.2 M/yr to local economies            economies




Construction Phase = 1-2 years
Operational Phase = 20+ years
 National Renewable Energy Laboratory                                                  Innovation for Our Energy Future
Questions?




                                          Photo courtesy of Oceanenergy


               Robert Thresher, NREL Research Fellow
                     Robert.Thresher@nrel.gov


National Renewable Energy Laboratory                                Innovation for Our Energy Future

Ctws ocean energy thresher

  • 1.
    Ocean Renewable Energy: OffshoreWind, Wave & Tidal Power The Washington State Ocean Energy Conference: Deep Water Wind and Ocean Energy Economy Bremerton, Washington November 8 & 9, 2011 Presented by Robert Thresher, NREL Research Fellow National Wind Technology Center NREL is a national laboratory of the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy operated by the Alliance for Sustainable Energy, LLC
  • 2.
    Energy sources inthe United States in 2009 National Renewable Energy Laboratory Innovation for Our Energy Future
  • 3.
    Most U.S. OffshoreWind Resource is in Deep Water GW by Depth (m) Region 0 - 30 30 - 60 > 60 New England 100.2 136.2 250.4 Mid Atlantic 298.1 179.1 92.5 S. Atlantic Bight 134.1 48.8 7.7 California 4.4 10.5 573.0 Pacific Northw est 15.1 21.3 305.3 Great Lakes 176.7 106.4 459.4 Gulf of Mexico 340.3 120.1 133.3 Haw aii 2.3 5.5 629.6 Total 1,071.2 628.0 2,451.1 Assumptions: 5 MW/km2 7 m/s and greater 0-50nm for shore National Renewable Energy Laboratory Innovation for Our Energy Future
  • 4.
    Wind Technology Evolution • Land Based Technology > 2 MW; Turbine 50% Total Installation Cost • Offshore Technology > 5 MW; Turbine 25% Total Installation Cost • Land Based Turbine Size Constrained by Highway Transport • Turbine Stiffness & Dynamic Coupling Driving Design Innovation National Renewable Energy Laboratory Innovation for Our Energy Future
  • 5.
    Future Research onOffshore Wind Technology Land-based Shallow Water Transitional Depth Deepwater Floating Technology Technology Technology Technology Offshore Wind Technology Current Development Technology National Renewable Energy Laboratory Innovation for Our Energy Future
  • 6.
    Shallow Water BottomMounted: GE project at Arklow Banks in the Irish Sea Photo: R. Thresher National Renewable Energy Laboratory Innovation for Our Energy Future
  • 7.
    Principle Power 2-MWDemonstration Characteristics Country/Sponsor: Portugal Major Partners: Vestas, EDP Turbine Size/Description: Vestas V-80, 2 MW wind turbine Deployment date : September 2011 Platform Type: Three – tank semisubmersible – 6 line mooring Site: Aguçadoura, Portugal Water Depth 40 to 50-m Approximate Budget: $ 25M USD Opportunities: The PPI WindFloat semi-submersible wind system is scheduled for installation and commissioning off the Portuguese coast in Sept 2011. The installation includes a grid- connected Vestas V80 2-MW wind turbine. Testing for at least 12 months is planned and will focus on performance validation. An EU Framework 7 award increased their testing capability. National Renewable Energy Laboratory Innovation for Our Energy Future
  • 8.
    NREL Dynamic SimulationTool: HydroDyn Dynamic Analysis of Wind and Wave Interactions is an Important Technical Challenge for Floating Turbine Designs National Renewable Energy Laboratory Innovation for Our Energy Future
  • 9.
    Visualization of AvianInteraction Zones Windfarm Flight Zone Over-flight Fatality Risk Strike Zone Fly-thru Rotor Zone National Renewable Energy Laboratory Innovation for Our Energy Future
  • 10.
    Avian Strike ProbabilityVersus Turbine Size Altamont Scale Next Generation Scale 93 Meter Diameter and 2.5MW 15 Meter Diameter and 100 kW National Renewable Energy Laboratory Innovation for Our Energy Future
  • 11.
    Three Basic Formsof Marine Hydrokinetic (MHK) Energy CURRENTS • Activating force flows in same direction for at least a few hours • Tidal, river, and ocean variants • Conversion technology is some sort of submerged turbine WAVES • Activating force reverses direction every 5 to 20 seconds • Conversion technology can be floating or submerged, with a wide variety of devices still being invented and developed OCEAN THERMAL • A heat engine operating on the temperature difference between hot surface water and cool water at 1000 meters. • Several possible thermodynamic cycles • Conversion technology is on a floating platform with a long pipe to deep water National Renewable Energy Laboratory Innovation for Our Energy Future
  • 12.
    The Many WaveEnergy Technologies National Renewable Energy Laboratory Innovation for Our Energy Future
  • 13.
    The Several Tidal,River and Ocean Current Technologies National Renewable Energy Laboratory Innovation for Our Energy Future
  • 14.
    Minnesota – EconomicImpacts from 1000 MW of new wind development Wind energy’s economic “ripple effect” Direct Impacts Indirect & Totals Induced Impacts (construction + 20yrs) Payments to Landowners: • $2.7 million/year Construction Phase: Total economic benefit = Local Property Tax Revenue: • 1530 new jobs $1.1 billion • $2.8 million/year • $150.6 M to local New local jobs during Construction Phase: economies construction = 2985 • 1455 new jobs Operational Phase: • $188.5 M to local economies New local long-term jobs Operational Phase: • 177 local jobs • 232 new long-term jobs • $18.2 M/yr to local = 409 • $21.2 M/yr to local economies economies Construction Phase = 1-2 years Operational Phase = 20+ years National Renewable Energy Laboratory Innovation for Our Energy Future
  • 15.
    Questions? Photo courtesy of Oceanenergy Robert Thresher, NREL Research Fellow [email protected] National Renewable Energy Laboratory Innovation for Our Energy Future

Editor's Notes

  • #4 One can see the depth of the various coasts in this bathymetry map. The chart in the middle shows the amount of wind resource available based on the water depth. The largest available resource is in deeper waters, greater than 60 m, which are found off the west coast and northern atlantic. Therefore, in the United States, there is a lot of interest in researching floating wind turbine options for offshore. The assumptions used to calculate this resource are shown here.
  • #5 Turbine size has grown almost linearly with timeBifurcation between offshore and land based systemsOffshore cost of foundation drives development to larger sizesOnshore transportation costs in special permitting beginning to limit sizeLarger & Dynamically Soft – designs now require active control and consideration of non-linear effects including coupling with inflow loading