Dialogue Session:
ES and Resilience of
three basins (Volta, Nile,
and Mekong)
What’s poverty got to do with it?
M Sanjayan
P. Kareiva
Where are conservation efforts most needed and
most likely to improve the human condition?
Can we identify “life raft ecosystems” ?
= Areas with:
•high rates of poverty (% undernourished)
•large portion of economy dependent upon nature
(agriculture, fisheries, logging)
•severely degraded ecosystem services
Slide by Kareiva and Sanjayan
Water Land and Ecosystem Vision:
A world in which agriculture thrives within
vibrant ecosystems, where communities
have higher incomes, improved food
security and the ability to continuously
improve their lives
6
Rockstrom et al. (2009) Nature 461:472-475
Challenges
Foley et al. 2011
Minimum Goals for 2050
Environmental Goals
Development Goals
Total Agricultural Production
Nutritionally Complete Production
Biodiversity Conserved
Carbon Sequestered Improved Water Quality
Water Conserved
Soil Formed
Food Security Goals
Food Distribution and Access
Conserve agrobiodiversity
Increased Farmer Livelihoods
And Resilience
Improve Human Health
Increase Farm Self Reliance
Adapted from Foley et al 2011
Production Goals
Ecosystem Conservation as
a result of
poverty alleviation
Ecosystem Conservation as
means to
poverty alleviation
Trade-
offsSocial structure, demand,
accessibility
Financial mechanisms
Land and governance decisions, processes and investments
Landscapes
Food, energy, fiber
Income
ES benefits
Temporal processes
Climate
Knowledge and
information
availability
Economy
Markets, PES
Farming practices
Ecosystem services
Biophysical Access and use
Social needs
(demography,
preferences)
Livelihood
Impact
Livelihood
Impact
Livelihood
impacts
People
Trade-
offs
system state,
structure and
processes
tate, structure and
processes
(Agro)-ecosystem
state, structure and
processes
Agriculture
Ecosystem services
Ecosystem services
Time
Principles
• People are fundamental
• Human and Natural systems are tightly coupled.
• Ecological processes in the portfolio of options.
• Multifunctionality: trade-offs, synergies,
interactions
• Resilience: shocks, transformation and feedbacks
• Recognize we might have to modify ecosystems
• Multi-scale: basin as maximum extent + Global
Processes
0
20
40
60
80
100
1-Oct-80
1-Nov-80
1-Dec-80
1-Jan-81
1-Feb-81
1-Mar-81
1-Apr-81
1-May-81
1-Jun-81
1-Jul-81
1-Aug-81
1-Sep-81
Flow(m3s-1)
Daily flow with and without floodplain
Without floodplain (simulated) With floodplain (observed)
Flow Regulation in the Luswishi Floodplain
Understanding how ecosystems
affect livelihoods
M. McCartney (IMWI)
Ecosystem Services by
whom and for whom?
Rainfall
less than 900 mmyr-1
Greater
than 900 mmyr-1
F. Kizito (CIAT)
Facilitating intervention decisions: what and where?
Recognizing the value of Ecosystem Services Provided
by Farming Communities
M.Quintero(CIAT);W.Zhang(IFPRI);F.DeClerck(Bioversity)
My farm participates in the
Management of the
Reventazon
River Watershed (ICE)
Through targeted impact pthways in focal regions
and at the global level
South East Asia: Mekong Focal Region
GOAL:
better targeted investments
in water, land, energy and
agriculture writ large so
they are sustainable and
socially inclusive, and
national growth and
poverty goals can be met by
supporting the natural
resource base
What is the nature,
distribution and value of ES
in an increasingly
commercialized
agricultural system & how
is it going to affect local
livelihoods in the future?
How would management
of water, land and other
ecosystem need to be
adapted to improve food
and nutrition security in
the least food-secure GMS
countries?
What policies and
institutions can
communities &
policymakers use to
enhance the resilience of
the GMS ES in the long
term under pop & ec
growth, CC &
globalization?
To move toward resilient ecosystems in the Greater
Mekong Region while also achieving growth and poverty
reduction goals will require tradeoff analysis at the
regional, basin-wide, GMS-wide and global level under
alternative development pathways that consider
investments and policies across water, land and energy; in
food and nutrition; and associated governance and
institutions.
West Africa: Volta Niger Focal Region
Resource degradation,
poverty, climate change
sensitivity, emigration
Crop-livestock
competition,
ethnic and
religious
conflicts
Urbanization, immigration,
poverty re-distribution*;
environmental degradation Humid forest
Sahara
*In 12 years from now, the majority of the poor in Africa will be living in urban as opposed
to rural areas.
Main questions for WLE
Can WLE guide investors and decision makers to
(i) Better target sustainable agricultural
investments (in the rural north)?
(ii) value and manage ecosystem services under
increasing demands on water, food and energy in
both, the fragile north, and the growing peri-
urban landscapes of the south?
Small Reservoirs
East Africa – Nile Basin Countries
The Opportunity
• Huge development investments in most
countries, affecting land use
 Include growth corridors, commodity corridors,
irrigation and hydropower dam development,
upper watershed conservation, food security
programs
• Multiple futures are possible in this
evolving context
The challenge is to support a sustainability agenda within existing
and evolving processes and investments to achieve green, resilient
and equitable growth in the countries of the Nile Basin.
Trends and Intervention Areas
• Huge diversity in resources, political and economic development
• Strong dependence on agriculture, especially rainfed, and natural
resources
• Rapid population growth and other demographic pressures,
urbanization, feminization, marginalization
• Degradation of natural resources and ecosystem functioning is
pervasive
1.
Negotiating trade-offs in
ecosystem services during
infrastructure development
2.
Achieving sustainable land
management in degradation
hotspots
3.
Strengthening equity and the role of
women during sustainable intensification
wle.cgiar.org
wle.cgiar.org/blogs

Dialogue Session: Ecosystem Services and Resilience of three basins (Volta, Nile, and Mekong)

  • 1.
    Dialogue Session: ES andResilience of three basins (Volta, Nile, and Mekong)
  • 2.
    What’s poverty gotto do with it? M Sanjayan P. Kareiva
  • 3.
    Where are conservationefforts most needed and most likely to improve the human condition? Can we identify “life raft ecosystems” ? = Areas with: •high rates of poverty (% undernourished) •large portion of economy dependent upon nature (agriculture, fisheries, logging) •severely degraded ecosystem services Slide by Kareiva and Sanjayan
  • 5.
    Water Land andEcosystem Vision: A world in which agriculture thrives within vibrant ecosystems, where communities have higher incomes, improved food security and the ability to continuously improve their lives
  • 6.
    6 Rockstrom et al.(2009) Nature 461:472-475 Challenges
  • 7.
  • 8.
    Minimum Goals for2050 Environmental Goals Development Goals Total Agricultural Production Nutritionally Complete Production Biodiversity Conserved Carbon Sequestered Improved Water Quality Water Conserved Soil Formed Food Security Goals Food Distribution and Access Conserve agrobiodiversity Increased Farmer Livelihoods And Resilience Improve Human Health Increase Farm Self Reliance Adapted from Foley et al 2011 Production Goals
  • 9.
    Ecosystem Conservation as aresult of poverty alleviation
  • 10.
    Ecosystem Conservation as meansto poverty alleviation
  • 12.
    Trade- offsSocial structure, demand, accessibility Financialmechanisms Land and governance decisions, processes and investments Landscapes Food, energy, fiber Income ES benefits Temporal processes Climate Knowledge and information availability Economy Markets, PES Farming practices Ecosystem services Biophysical Access and use Social needs (demography, preferences) Livelihood Impact Livelihood Impact Livelihood impacts People Trade- offs system state, structure and processes tate, structure and processes (Agro)-ecosystem state, structure and processes Agriculture Ecosystem services Ecosystem services Time
  • 13.
    Principles • People arefundamental • Human and Natural systems are tightly coupled. • Ecological processes in the portfolio of options. • Multifunctionality: trade-offs, synergies, interactions • Resilience: shocks, transformation and feedbacks • Recognize we might have to modify ecosystems • Multi-scale: basin as maximum extent + Global Processes
  • 14.
    0 20 40 60 80 100 1-Oct-80 1-Nov-80 1-Dec-80 1-Jan-81 1-Feb-81 1-Mar-81 1-Apr-81 1-May-81 1-Jun-81 1-Jul-81 1-Aug-81 1-Sep-81 Flow(m3s-1) Daily flow withand without floodplain Without floodplain (simulated) With floodplain (observed) Flow Regulation in the Luswishi Floodplain Understanding how ecosystems affect livelihoods M. McCartney (IMWI)
  • 15.
    Ecosystem Services by whomand for whom? Rainfall less than 900 mmyr-1 Greater than 900 mmyr-1 F. Kizito (CIAT)
  • 16.
  • 17.
    Recognizing the valueof Ecosystem Services Provided by Farming Communities M.Quintero(CIAT);W.Zhang(IFPRI);F.DeClerck(Bioversity) My farm participates in the Management of the Reventazon River Watershed (ICE)
  • 18.
    Through targeted impactpthways in focal regions and at the global level
  • 19.
    South East Asia:Mekong Focal Region
  • 20.
    GOAL: better targeted investments inwater, land, energy and agriculture writ large so they are sustainable and socially inclusive, and national growth and poverty goals can be met by supporting the natural resource base
  • 21.
    What is thenature, distribution and value of ES in an increasingly commercialized agricultural system & how is it going to affect local livelihoods in the future? How would management of water, land and other ecosystem need to be adapted to improve food and nutrition security in the least food-secure GMS countries? What policies and institutions can communities & policymakers use to enhance the resilience of the GMS ES in the long term under pop & ec growth, CC & globalization? To move toward resilient ecosystems in the Greater Mekong Region while also achieving growth and poverty reduction goals will require tradeoff analysis at the regional, basin-wide, GMS-wide and global level under alternative development pathways that consider investments and policies across water, land and energy; in food and nutrition; and associated governance and institutions.
  • 23.
    West Africa: VoltaNiger Focal Region
  • 24.
    Resource degradation, poverty, climatechange sensitivity, emigration Crop-livestock competition, ethnic and religious conflicts Urbanization, immigration, poverty re-distribution*; environmental degradation Humid forest Sahara *In 12 years from now, the majority of the poor in Africa will be living in urban as opposed to rural areas.
  • 25.
    Main questions forWLE Can WLE guide investors and decision makers to (i) Better target sustainable agricultural investments (in the rural north)? (ii) value and manage ecosystem services under increasing demands on water, food and energy in both, the fragile north, and the growing peri- urban landscapes of the south?
  • 26.
  • 27.
    East Africa –Nile Basin Countries
  • 28.
    The Opportunity • Hugedevelopment investments in most countries, affecting land use  Include growth corridors, commodity corridors, irrigation and hydropower dam development, upper watershed conservation, food security programs • Multiple futures are possible in this evolving context The challenge is to support a sustainability agenda within existing and evolving processes and investments to achieve green, resilient and equitable growth in the countries of the Nile Basin.
  • 29.
    Trends and InterventionAreas • Huge diversity in resources, political and economic development • Strong dependence on agriculture, especially rainfed, and natural resources • Rapid population growth and other demographic pressures, urbanization, feminization, marginalization • Degradation of natural resources and ecosystem functioning is pervasive 1. Negotiating trade-offs in ecosystem services during infrastructure development 2. Achieving sustainable land management in degradation hotspots 3. Strengthening equity and the role of women during sustainable intensification
  • 30.