Deep Ocean Circulation

Present, Past, and Future
Andreas Schmittner

College of Earth, Ocean, and Atmospheric Sciences

Oregon State University
Portland State University Nov. 6, 2017
World Ocean Atlas 2013
dense
cold & salty
light
warm & fresh
Antarctic
Bottom Water
Antarctic
Intermediate Water
North Atlantic
Deep Water
Meridional Overturning Circulation (aka thermohaline circ. / great conveyor belt)
World Ocean Atlas 2013
Pacific (150°W)
Pacific
Deep Water
Circumpolar
Deep Water
North Pacific
Intermediate Water
Pacific (150°W)
Global Deep Water Circulation
a.k.a.Thermohaline Circulation: driven by temperature and salinity (density) differences
or Meridional (North-South) Overturning Circulation (MOC)
Why is there no deep
water formation in North
Pacific?
Sea Surface Salinity Observations
Rockies
Andes
Water vapor
transport from
Pacific to
Atlantic
blocked by
mountains
Water vapor
transport from
Atlantic
to Pacific
across Central
America
Atlantic = salty
Pacific = fresh (g salt per kg water)
E.Africa
Climate Models
Equations based on
conservation of
• mass
• momentum
(Navier-Stokes)
• energy
• water, salt
• carbon
• ...
Interactive Components:
• Atmosphere
• Ocean
• Sea Ice
• Land Surface (vegetation,
snow, soil moisture, runoff)
Prescribed (fixed):
• Land Ice Sheets
Flat World
Real World
Schmittner et al. (2011) J. Climate
Model streamfunction

2 Sv isolines

(1 Sv = 106 m3 s-1)

(Amazon = 0.2 Sv)
Climate Model Simulations
Conclusions Present
• Deep ocean circulation transports heat from southern to
northern hemisphere

• North Atlantic is saltier than North Pacific because of
topographic effects of mountains on atmospheric water
vapor transport

• This causes surface waters to sink in the North Atlantic,
setting up the global deep water circulation
Past
Last Glacial Maximum
~20,000 years ago
Method:
Produce different AMOC model states

Compare with sediment reconstructions
Reduced southward moisture flux in SH

causes saltier and stronger AABW and
weaker NADW and AMOC
We don’t claim that this is the correct
mechanism for changing the circulation.
Test method first with modern data.
Muglia et al. (in review) Sci. Adv.Funded by NSF
Can we reconstruct the modern Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC)
using carbon isotopes (14C and 13C) only at sparse locations of LGM sediment cores?
Muglia et al. (in review) Sci. Adv.
Yes, we can!
Pre-Industrial Control
LGM_13
LGM_8
LGM_0
Muglia et al. (in review) Sci. Adv.Funded by NSF
Hysteresis Behavior
PD
winds
LGM
winds
Muglia et al. (in review)
Pre-Industrial
Control
LGM_13
LGM_8
LGM_0
Atlantic Pacific
LGM_13
LGM_8
LGM_13
SOFe
LGM_8
SOFe
RMSE
1.2
1.2
0.7
1.8
Both weak AMOC + SO Fe fertilization needed to fit sediment data!
Weak AMOC + SO Fe maximize carbon storage!
Conclusions Past
• During the Last Glacial Maximum the Atlantic overturning
circulation was much weaker (by about 50%) and
shallower than today

• Increased iron fertilization from dust enhanced
phytoplankton productivity and deep ocean carbon
storage

• Together, these two effects explain much of the increased
carbon storage in the ice age oceanduring the Last
Glacial Maximum
Future
Bakker et al. (2016) Geophys. Res. Let.Funded by NOAA
Greenland
Ice Sheet
Melting
only
Probabilistic
Projections with
Simple Box Model
Comprehensive Models
Conclusions Future
• Climate models project a decrease of the Atlantic
overturning circulation due to warming, intensification of
the atmospheric hydrological cycle, and (to a lesser
degree) melting of the Greenland ice sheet.

• Higher carbon emissions will lead to a stronger decline.

• A collapse of the circulation can be avoided by reducing
carbon emissions.
Back to the Present
Frajka-Williams (2015) Geophys. Res. Let.
In Situ
Observations
Linear Trend
-0.2 Sv/yr
Reconstruction
Based on Satellite Data
-0.13 Sv/yr
1 Sv = 106 m3 s-1
For Comparison:

Model Trend post 2006

-0.04 Sv/yr
Model Natural Decadal
Variability

+-0.08 Sv/yr
Observations
Final Thought
• Currently observed decrease is likely mostly due to
natural variability but anthropogenic could also already
play a role
Thank You !
Buizert et al. (2015) Nature
Rapid Climate Change During Last Ice Age

Deep Ocean Circulation: Present, Past, and Future

  • 1.
    Deep Ocean Circulation Present,Past, and Future Andreas Schmittner College of Earth, Ocean, and Atmospheric Sciences Oregon State University Portland State University Nov. 6, 2017
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 6.
    Antarctic Bottom Water Antarctic Intermediate Water NorthAtlantic Deep Water Meridional Overturning Circulation (aka thermohaline circ. / great conveyor belt)
  • 7.
  • 9.
  • 10.
    Pacific Deep Water Circumpolar Deep Water NorthPacific Intermediate Water Pacific (150°W)
  • 11.
    Global Deep WaterCirculation a.k.a.Thermohaline Circulation: driven by temperature and salinity (density) differences or Meridional (North-South) Overturning Circulation (MOC)
  • 12.
    Why is thereno deep water formation in North Pacific?
  • 13.
    Sea Surface SalinityObservations Rockies Andes Water vapor transport from Pacific to Atlantic blocked by mountains Water vapor transport from Atlantic to Pacific across Central America Atlantic = salty Pacific = fresh (g salt per kg water) E.Africa
  • 14.
    Climate Models Equations basedon conservation of • mass • momentum (Navier-Stokes) • energy • water, salt • carbon • ... Interactive Components: • Atmosphere • Ocean • Sea Ice • Land Surface (vegetation, snow, soil moisture, runoff) Prescribed (fixed): • Land Ice Sheets
  • 15.
    Flat World Real World Schmittneret al. (2011) J. Climate Model streamfunction 2 Sv isolines (1 Sv = 106 m3 s-1) (Amazon = 0.2 Sv) Climate Model Simulations
  • 16.
    Conclusions Present • Deepocean circulation transports heat from southern to northern hemisphere • North Atlantic is saltier than North Pacific because of topographic effects of mountains on atmospheric water vapor transport • This causes surface waters to sink in the North Atlantic, setting up the global deep water circulation
  • 17.
  • 18.
    Method: Produce different AMOCmodel states Compare with sediment reconstructions Reduced southward moisture flux in SH causes saltier and stronger AABW and weaker NADW and AMOC We don’t claim that this is the correct mechanism for changing the circulation. Test method first with modern data. Muglia et al. (in review) Sci. Adv.Funded by NSF
  • 19.
    Can we reconstructthe modern Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) using carbon isotopes (14C and 13C) only at sparse locations of LGM sediment cores? Muglia et al. (in review) Sci. Adv. Yes, we can!
  • 20.
    Pre-Industrial Control LGM_13 LGM_8 LGM_0 Muglia etal. (in review) Sci. Adv.Funded by NSF
  • 21.
  • 22.
    Muglia et al.(in review) Pre-Industrial Control LGM_13 LGM_8 LGM_0 Atlantic Pacific
  • 23.
    LGM_13 LGM_8 LGM_13 SOFe LGM_8 SOFe RMSE 1.2 1.2 0.7 1.8 Both weak AMOC+ SO Fe fertilization needed to fit sediment data!
  • 24.
    Weak AMOC +SO Fe maximize carbon storage!
  • 25.
    Conclusions Past • Duringthe Last Glacial Maximum the Atlantic overturning circulation was much weaker (by about 50%) and shallower than today • Increased iron fertilization from dust enhanced phytoplankton productivity and deep ocean carbon storage • Together, these two effects explain much of the increased carbon storage in the ice age oceanduring the Last Glacial Maximum
  • 26.
  • 27.
    Bakker et al.(2016) Geophys. Res. Let.Funded by NOAA Greenland Ice Sheet Melting only Probabilistic Projections with Simple Box Model Comprehensive Models
  • 29.
    Conclusions Future • Climatemodels project a decrease of the Atlantic overturning circulation due to warming, intensification of the atmospheric hydrological cycle, and (to a lesser degree) melting of the Greenland ice sheet. • Higher carbon emissions will lead to a stronger decline. • A collapse of the circulation can be avoided by reducing carbon emissions.
  • 30.
    Back to thePresent
  • 31.
    Frajka-Williams (2015) Geophys.Res. Let. In Situ Observations Linear Trend -0.2 Sv/yr Reconstruction Based on Satellite Data -0.13 Sv/yr 1 Sv = 106 m3 s-1 For Comparison: Model Trend post 2006 -0.04 Sv/yr Model Natural Decadal Variability +-0.08 Sv/yr Observations
  • 32.
    Final Thought • Currentlyobserved decrease is likely mostly due to natural variability but anthropogenic could also already play a role
  • 33.
  • 37.
    Buizert et al.(2015) Nature Rapid Climate Change During Last Ice Age