Intensivist: “Houston, We Have a Problem”
Literature: “You Mean You’ve HAD a Problem?”
Viren Kaul
PCCM Fellow Sinai / EHC
@virenkaul
Clinical Presentation 01
02
03
04
05
Assessment
Prevention
Treatment
Take Home
Clinical Presentation 01
02
03
04
05
Assessment
Prevention
Treatment
Take Home
Disturbance in
Consciousness
Change in
Cognition
Perceptual
Disturbance
Inattention
What Does it “Look” Like?
Hyperactive
Delirium
2%
Hypoactive
Delirium
44%
Mixed
Delirium
54%
Girard,CriticalCare2008.
“The Difficult Patient”:
Bad terminology, bad outcomes
“The Easy to Miss Patient”:
Bad recognition, bad outcomes
Clinical Presentation
Girard, Critical Care 2008.
Language Speech Memory
Perception Construction
Predisposing Factors
• Polypharmacy
• Sensory impairment
• Depression
• Dehydration
• Age / Dementia
• Underlying CNS path
• Substance abuse
• Meds: BZD
• Pain
• Constipation / Urinary retention
• Electrolyte abnormalities
• Lack of sensory aids
• High number of procedures
• Immobility
• ICU admission
• Emergent surgery
• Major medical illness
Precipitating Factors
That’s ALL our patients!
One can (and I am) arguing that
EVERYONE in an ICU
should be screened and treated
(without meds!)
The differentials / mimickers:
Other causes of encephalopathy / systemic diseases
• SDH
• Dementia
• Seizures
• Stroke
• Sleep deprivation
CNS
• Substance / EtOh
• Withdrawal
• Wernicke’s
• Hypoglycemia
• Meds: BZD,
antichols, etc!
Toxic
Metabolic
• Sepsis
• Dementia
• UTI
• Meningo-
encephalitis
Infections
• Hypoxia
• Hypertensive
encephalopathy
• Shock
• Hepatic / renal
failure
Systemic
Work up (be mindful, in 2019, most ICUs have this
already done for the patient!)
– LFTs / Ammonia
– TSH
– VBG (PaCO2)
– Infectious W/U
– Pertinent drug levels (e.g.
digoxin, lithium, theophylline,
AEDs)
– Tox W/U, depending on context
(e.g. carboxyhemoglobin level)
Consider neurotesting:
– Unclear story (CT)
– CNS trauma (CT)
– Anticoagulation on board (CT)
– FND (CT/MRI)
– GCS very low and unexplained
despite initial W/U (CT)
– Concern for infection (LP)
– Concern for seizures (EEG)
IBCC, Josh Farkas @PulmCrit
The Damage
• 50% frequency in ICU pts
• Extra 5 days on MV
• Extra 8-10 days hLOS
• 50% cognitive impairments
at D/C
• 33% long term
impairment!
Clinical Presentation 01
02
03
04
05
Assessment
Prevention
Treatment
Take Home
Why Detect Early?
Oh, JAMA 2017.
Inouye. Annals of IM 1990.
Assessing Delirium: Simple, Yet Not Simple: Step 1
Do a RASS check:
If RASS < -2: Wait and repeat
If RASS -2 and above = Perform CAM-ICU
Assessing Delirium: Simple, Yet Not Simple: Part 2
CAM-ICU score:
Sens: 94 – 100%
Spec: 90 – 95%
High Interrater reliability
Oh, JAMA 2017.
Inouye. Annals of IM 1990.
CAM-ICU
Diagnostic
Algorithm
Acute onset
OR fluctuating
course
Inattention
Disorganized
thinking
ALC
Original Worksheet by
Ely, Vanderbilt 2002.
Takes 2 minutes to
complete!
This is not a sales
pitch, it literally takes 2
minutes to perform.
Challenges to CAM-ICU Assessment: Level of Sedation
Adapted from:
SCCM. PADIS teaching slides 2018.
4 observational studies
(97% CAM-ICU used)
12,699 delirium
assessments
RASS -2
Positive
delirium
assessments:
77%
RASS 0 to - 1
Positive
delirium
assessments:
23%
Clinical Presentation 01
02
03
04
05
Assessment
Prevention
Treatment
Take Home
Preventing Delirium: Stop Doing Stuff!
Stop offending meds
And don’t use them!
Multimodal pain
control w/o overdoing
Improved sleep
quality & stop
disturbing them!
5Ps: Pain, Poop,
Pee, Pressure,
Presence
Pharmacological Prevention of Delirium
Boogaard, JAMA 2018.
Slooter, Handbook of clinical neurology 2017.
Su, The Lancet 2016.
Haldol
REDUCE
RCT
Risperidone
Other
antipsychotics
Steroids
Statins
Gabapentin
Precedex
Su 2016
No diff in
delirium or
mortality
May reduce
hallucinations
No diff in
duration or
occurrence of
delirium
Data Minimal
Reduction in
delirium
79% vs 32%
(Placebo vs
Dex)
PADIS (2018):
No agent advised for PPx
Conditional / Low
Factor in effect on sleep:
I’m keeping an open mind
about Dex
Low Dose Nocturnal Dex for Prevention of Delirium
Skrobik, AJRCCM 2018.
Outcome Dex vs Placebo
n = 50
Number of patient delirium free 80% vs 54%
Leeds Sleep Evaluation Questionnaire No difference
Melatonin Agonists for Prevention of Delirium in ICU
PULMCrit, Josh Farkas. @PulmCrit
Study (n) Intervention Rate of Delirium
Hatta 2014
(n = 67)
8 mg ramelteon QHS X 1 week 3% vs 32%
(p=0.003)
Mistraletti 2015
(n = 82)
6 mg melatonin nightly Reduced hydroxyzine
use for insomnia
Nishikimi 2018
(n = 88)
8 mg ramelteon QHS X duration of
ICU stay
24% vs 47%
(p=0.048)
Clinical Presentation 01
02
03
04
05
Assessment
Prevention
Treatment
Take Home
Pharmacological Treatment of Delirium
SCCM PADIS Guidelines 2018
Reade, JAMA 2016.
Drug vs *** Outcomes Result
Haldol vs No medication Duration of delirium
Duration of MV
ICU mortality
Not significant (3 RCTs, n = 265)
Not significant (2 RCTS, n = 124)
Not significant (3 RCTs, n = 265)
Atypical antipsychotics vs
No medication
Duration of delirium
Duration of MV
ICU LOS
ICU mortality
Not significant (2 RCTs, n = 102)
Not significant (2 RCTS, n = 95)
Not significant (3 RCTs, n = 102)
Not significant (3 RCTs, n = 102)
Dex vs Placebo
(DahLIA study)
Ventilator free hours
ICU LOS
hLOS
Mean difference 17 hours (1 RCT, n = 74)
No difference
PADIS (2018): Meds not advised for Rx of Delirium (Conditional, Low Quality)
PADIS (2018): Suggest using Dex if agitation/delirium precluding vent liberation (Conditional, Low)
MIND-USA: Delirium/Coma-Free Days
Girard TD, et al. N Engl J Med. 2018;379:2506-2516
0 4 8 10 14
*Adjusted Median Days (95% CI)
62 12
Placebo
Haloperidol
Ziprasidone OR: 1.04 (0.73-1.48)
OR: 0.88 (0.64-1.21)
Reference
*Adjusted for age, Charlson, baseline frailty, baseline
IQCODE, and SOFA and RASS at randomization
MIND-USA: Hypoactive Delirium Days
Girard TD, et al. N Engl J Med. 2018;379:2506-2516
0 4 8 10 14
Adjusted Median Days (95% CI)
62 12
Placebo
Haloperidol
Ziprasidone OR: 1.00 (0.68-1.47)
OR: 1.10 (0.81-1.48)
Reference
MIND-USA: Hyperactive Delirium Days
Girard TD, et al. N Engl J Med. 2018;379:2506-2516
0 4 8 10 14
Adjusted Median Days (95% CI)
62 12
Placebo
Haloperidol
Ziprasidone OR: 1.09 (0.70-1.70)
OR: 1.18 (0.86-1.61)
Reference
Non-pharmacological Multimodal Treatment of Delirium
SCCM PADIS Guidelines 2018
Study Design / Population Intervention
Colombo 2012 Before – After / Mixed ICU Reorientation + environmental / acoustic / visual stimulation
Foster 2013 Before – After / Mixed ICU Sedation, sleep wake, sensory stimulation, mobility, music
Moon 2015 RCT / Mixed ICU Delirium risk monitoring, cognition / orientation, environment, early
therapeutic intervention
Hanison 2015 Before – After / Mixed ICU 1st cycle: reduce deliriogenic drugs, daily SV, environmental
changes, light exposure, communication aids
2nd cycle: natural light, clocks
Rivosecchi 2016 Before – After / Mixed ICU Music, opening blinds, reorientation, cognition, eye/ear protocol
Use of these strategies à Reduced occurrence and duration of delirium, ICU LOS, hospital mortality
PADIS (2018): Suggest using multimodal non pharmacological interventions (Conditional, Low)
ABCDEF bundle
SCCM / ICU
liberation
Adapted from SCCM / ICU liberation
ABCDEF bundle
cohort study
2017
n = 6064
Focus on the
“F” component
Barnes-Daly, CCM 2017.
Are Outcomes of Delirium Different if Reversed Rapidly?
Patel, AJRCCM 2014.
No Delirium Rapidly
Reversible
Delirium
Mixed
Delirium
Persistent
Delirium
Days of MV 2.4 2.5 5.1 6.2
ICU LOS 4.0 4.5 9.7 13.1
hLOS 8.1 6.7 26.8 25.4
Prospective cohort. 102 MV pts compared before and after daily interruption of sedation
Are Outcomes of Delirium Different if Reversed Rapidly?
Patel, AJRCCM 2014.
No Delirium Rapidly
Reversible
Delirium
Mixed
Delirium
Persistent
Delirium
Days of MV 2.4 2.5 5.1 6.2
ICU LOS 4.0 4.5 9.7 13.1
hLOS 8.1 6.7 26.8 25.4
YES
PADIS (2018): When rapidly reversed,
sedation related delirium has similar outcomes to no delirium (Conditional, Low Quality)
Treatment of Delirium: Summary
Rx underlying
cause
• Shock states
• Infection
• Na
• Hyperglycemia
• Dysvolemia
Address
• Pain
• Poop: Constipation
• Pee: Urinary retention
• Presence: Frequent
reorientation
• Position for comfort
Other PADIS
components
• Mobility
• Sleep
• Sleep-wake cycle
• Reorientation
• Tangible contact
• Hearing/seeing aids
• Less alarms
Clinical Presentation 01
02
03
04
05
Assessment
Prevention
Treatment
Take Home
Know what delirium look like
Hypoactive >> hyperactive
Majority of patients in ICU at risk
CAM-ICU everyone w/ RASS > -2
Prevent iatrogenesis
DELIBRATE PRACTICE
Multimodal non pharm
Measures for ALL patients
Rx: Minimal use of anti-psychotics
Use instead: Dex, esp when liberating
PADIS / SCCM
5Ps and Meds

Delirium in the Intensive Care Unit (ICU)

  • 1.
    Intensivist: “Houston, WeHave a Problem” Literature: “You Mean You’ve HAD a Problem?” Viren Kaul PCCM Fellow Sinai / EHC @virenkaul
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
    What Does it“Look” Like? Hyperactive Delirium 2% Hypoactive Delirium 44% Mixed Delirium 54% Girard,CriticalCare2008. “The Difficult Patient”: Bad terminology, bad outcomes “The Easy to Miss Patient”: Bad recognition, bad outcomes
  • 6.
    Clinical Presentation Girard, CriticalCare 2008. Language Speech Memory Perception Construction
  • 7.
    Predisposing Factors • Polypharmacy •Sensory impairment • Depression • Dehydration • Age / Dementia • Underlying CNS path • Substance abuse • Meds: BZD • Pain • Constipation / Urinary retention • Electrolyte abnormalities • Lack of sensory aids • High number of procedures • Immobility • ICU admission • Emergent surgery • Major medical illness Precipitating Factors
  • 8.
    That’s ALL ourpatients! One can (and I am) arguing that EVERYONE in an ICU should be screened and treated (without meds!)
  • 9.
    The differentials /mimickers: Other causes of encephalopathy / systemic diseases • SDH • Dementia • Seizures • Stroke • Sleep deprivation CNS • Substance / EtOh • Withdrawal • Wernicke’s • Hypoglycemia • Meds: BZD, antichols, etc! Toxic Metabolic • Sepsis • Dementia • UTI • Meningo- encephalitis Infections • Hypoxia • Hypertensive encephalopathy • Shock • Hepatic / renal failure Systemic
  • 10.
    Work up (bemindful, in 2019, most ICUs have this already done for the patient!) – LFTs / Ammonia – TSH – VBG (PaCO2) – Infectious W/U – Pertinent drug levels (e.g. digoxin, lithium, theophylline, AEDs) – Tox W/U, depending on context (e.g. carboxyhemoglobin level) Consider neurotesting: – Unclear story (CT) – CNS trauma (CT) – Anticoagulation on board (CT) – FND (CT/MRI) – GCS very low and unexplained despite initial W/U (CT) – Concern for infection (LP) – Concern for seizures (EEG) IBCC, Josh Farkas @PulmCrit
  • 11.
    The Damage • 50%frequency in ICU pts • Extra 5 days on MV • Extra 8-10 days hLOS • 50% cognitive impairments at D/C • 33% long term impairment!
  • 12.
  • 13.
    Why Detect Early? Oh,JAMA 2017. Inouye. Annals of IM 1990.
  • 14.
    Assessing Delirium: Simple,Yet Not Simple: Step 1 Do a RASS check: If RASS < -2: Wait and repeat If RASS -2 and above = Perform CAM-ICU
  • 15.
    Assessing Delirium: Simple,Yet Not Simple: Part 2 CAM-ICU score: Sens: 94 – 100% Spec: 90 – 95% High Interrater reliability Oh, JAMA 2017. Inouye. Annals of IM 1990. CAM-ICU Diagnostic Algorithm Acute onset OR fluctuating course Inattention Disorganized thinking ALC
  • 16.
    Original Worksheet by Ely,Vanderbilt 2002. Takes 2 minutes to complete! This is not a sales pitch, it literally takes 2 minutes to perform.
  • 17.
    Challenges to CAM-ICUAssessment: Level of Sedation Adapted from: SCCM. PADIS teaching slides 2018. 4 observational studies (97% CAM-ICU used) 12,699 delirium assessments RASS -2 Positive delirium assessments: 77% RASS 0 to - 1 Positive delirium assessments: 23%
  • 18.
  • 19.
    Preventing Delirium: StopDoing Stuff! Stop offending meds And don’t use them! Multimodal pain control w/o overdoing Improved sleep quality & stop disturbing them! 5Ps: Pain, Poop, Pee, Pressure, Presence
  • 20.
    Pharmacological Prevention ofDelirium Boogaard, JAMA 2018. Slooter, Handbook of clinical neurology 2017. Su, The Lancet 2016. Haldol REDUCE RCT Risperidone Other antipsychotics Steroids Statins Gabapentin Precedex Su 2016 No diff in delirium or mortality May reduce hallucinations No diff in duration or occurrence of delirium Data Minimal Reduction in delirium 79% vs 32% (Placebo vs Dex) PADIS (2018): No agent advised for PPx Conditional / Low Factor in effect on sleep: I’m keeping an open mind about Dex
  • 21.
    Low Dose NocturnalDex for Prevention of Delirium Skrobik, AJRCCM 2018. Outcome Dex vs Placebo n = 50 Number of patient delirium free 80% vs 54% Leeds Sleep Evaluation Questionnaire No difference
  • 22.
    Melatonin Agonists forPrevention of Delirium in ICU PULMCrit, Josh Farkas. @PulmCrit Study (n) Intervention Rate of Delirium Hatta 2014 (n = 67) 8 mg ramelteon QHS X 1 week 3% vs 32% (p=0.003) Mistraletti 2015 (n = 82) 6 mg melatonin nightly Reduced hydroxyzine use for insomnia Nishikimi 2018 (n = 88) 8 mg ramelteon QHS X duration of ICU stay 24% vs 47% (p=0.048)
  • 23.
  • 24.
    Pharmacological Treatment ofDelirium SCCM PADIS Guidelines 2018 Reade, JAMA 2016. Drug vs *** Outcomes Result Haldol vs No medication Duration of delirium Duration of MV ICU mortality Not significant (3 RCTs, n = 265) Not significant (2 RCTS, n = 124) Not significant (3 RCTs, n = 265) Atypical antipsychotics vs No medication Duration of delirium Duration of MV ICU LOS ICU mortality Not significant (2 RCTs, n = 102) Not significant (2 RCTS, n = 95) Not significant (3 RCTs, n = 102) Not significant (3 RCTs, n = 102) Dex vs Placebo (DahLIA study) Ventilator free hours ICU LOS hLOS Mean difference 17 hours (1 RCT, n = 74) No difference PADIS (2018): Meds not advised for Rx of Delirium (Conditional, Low Quality) PADIS (2018): Suggest using Dex if agitation/delirium precluding vent liberation (Conditional, Low)
  • 26.
    MIND-USA: Delirium/Coma-Free Days GirardTD, et al. N Engl J Med. 2018;379:2506-2516 0 4 8 10 14 *Adjusted Median Days (95% CI) 62 12 Placebo Haloperidol Ziprasidone OR: 1.04 (0.73-1.48) OR: 0.88 (0.64-1.21) Reference *Adjusted for age, Charlson, baseline frailty, baseline IQCODE, and SOFA and RASS at randomization
  • 27.
    MIND-USA: Hypoactive DeliriumDays Girard TD, et al. N Engl J Med. 2018;379:2506-2516 0 4 8 10 14 Adjusted Median Days (95% CI) 62 12 Placebo Haloperidol Ziprasidone OR: 1.00 (0.68-1.47) OR: 1.10 (0.81-1.48) Reference
  • 28.
    MIND-USA: Hyperactive DeliriumDays Girard TD, et al. N Engl J Med. 2018;379:2506-2516 0 4 8 10 14 Adjusted Median Days (95% CI) 62 12 Placebo Haloperidol Ziprasidone OR: 1.09 (0.70-1.70) OR: 1.18 (0.86-1.61) Reference
  • 29.
    Non-pharmacological Multimodal Treatmentof Delirium SCCM PADIS Guidelines 2018 Study Design / Population Intervention Colombo 2012 Before – After / Mixed ICU Reorientation + environmental / acoustic / visual stimulation Foster 2013 Before – After / Mixed ICU Sedation, sleep wake, sensory stimulation, mobility, music Moon 2015 RCT / Mixed ICU Delirium risk monitoring, cognition / orientation, environment, early therapeutic intervention Hanison 2015 Before – After / Mixed ICU 1st cycle: reduce deliriogenic drugs, daily SV, environmental changes, light exposure, communication aids 2nd cycle: natural light, clocks Rivosecchi 2016 Before – After / Mixed ICU Music, opening blinds, reorientation, cognition, eye/ear protocol Use of these strategies à Reduced occurrence and duration of delirium, ICU LOS, hospital mortality PADIS (2018): Suggest using multimodal non pharmacological interventions (Conditional, Low)
  • 30.
    ABCDEF bundle SCCM /ICU liberation Adapted from SCCM / ICU liberation
  • 31.
    ABCDEF bundle cohort study 2017 n= 6064 Focus on the “F” component Barnes-Daly, CCM 2017.
  • 32.
    Are Outcomes ofDelirium Different if Reversed Rapidly? Patel, AJRCCM 2014. No Delirium Rapidly Reversible Delirium Mixed Delirium Persistent Delirium Days of MV 2.4 2.5 5.1 6.2 ICU LOS 4.0 4.5 9.7 13.1 hLOS 8.1 6.7 26.8 25.4 Prospective cohort. 102 MV pts compared before and after daily interruption of sedation
  • 33.
    Are Outcomes ofDelirium Different if Reversed Rapidly? Patel, AJRCCM 2014. No Delirium Rapidly Reversible Delirium Mixed Delirium Persistent Delirium Days of MV 2.4 2.5 5.1 6.2 ICU LOS 4.0 4.5 9.7 13.1 hLOS 8.1 6.7 26.8 25.4 YES PADIS (2018): When rapidly reversed, sedation related delirium has similar outcomes to no delirium (Conditional, Low Quality)
  • 34.
    Treatment of Delirium:Summary Rx underlying cause • Shock states • Infection • Na • Hyperglycemia • Dysvolemia Address • Pain • Poop: Constipation • Pee: Urinary retention • Presence: Frequent reorientation • Position for comfort Other PADIS components • Mobility • Sleep • Sleep-wake cycle • Reorientation • Tangible contact • Hearing/seeing aids • Less alarms
  • 35.
  • 36.
    Know what deliriumlook like Hypoactive >> hyperactive Majority of patients in ICU at risk CAM-ICU everyone w/ RASS > -2 Prevent iatrogenesis DELIBRATE PRACTICE Multimodal non pharm Measures for ALL patients Rx: Minimal use of anti-psychotics Use instead: Dex, esp when liberating PADIS / SCCM 5Ps and Meds