Design simulation and evaluation of siso miso mimo ofdm systems
0 likes254 views
This paper presents the design, simulation, and evaluation of SISO, MISO, and MIMO OFDM systems for image transmission over AWGN and Rayleigh channels. The analysis shows that increasing antenna diversity reduces the bit error rate (BER) and enhances channel capacity, with better performance observed using least squares (LS) channel estimation. Simulation results demonstrate that MIMO OFDM systems significantly outperform SISO and MISO systems in terms of BER and capacity, indicating enhanced data transmission capabilities.
![International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineering, Management & Applied Science (IJLTEMAS)
3rd
Special Issue on Engineering and Technology | Volume VI, Issue VIIS, July 2017 | ISSN 2278-2540
www.ijltemas.in Page 63
Design, Simulation and Evaluation of
SISO/MISO/MIMO-OFDM Systems
Ami Munshi#
, Srija Unnikrishnan*
#
SVKM’s NMIMS MPSTME, Mumbai, India
*FRCRCE, University of Mumbai, India
Abstract— In this paper an endeavour is made to design and
simulate SISO, MISO and MIMO OFDM systems. We have
analysed and compared the performance of these systems for
image transmission over AWGN and Rayleigh channels. The
effect of LS channel estimation on the BER over a range of SNR
for MIMO(2X2) systems is examined. We have also compared
the performance based on various M-ary PSK modulation
techniques for image transmission over Rayleigh channel in
MIMO-OFDM system. The system performance is simulated in
Matlab. The results of the simulation show that as the antenna
diversity increases, the BER decreases and the channel capacity
increases. Also, the BER obtained in MIMO-OFDM system is
less when LS estimation is used.
Keywords— OFDM, MIMO, Rayleigh, AWGN, BER, channel
capacity
I. INTRODUCTION
he demand for maximum achievable data rate, less delay
time, efficient modulation technique, less interference,
reduced effect of multipath propagation and Doppler shift,
high picture and voice quality, etc. are increasing day by day
in wireless technology. These demands can be met by
technologies like multicarrier systems (OFDM), MIMO,
CDMA etc. The main advantages of multicarrier systems are
its robustness in frequency selective channels and less signal
processing complexity as equalization is done in frequency
domain. OFDM is amalgamation of modulation and
multiplexing. It helps in reducing Inter Symbol Interference
for frequency selective channels by adding cyclic prefix.
MIMO transforms single point to point channel into multiple
parallel channels thus offering higher channel capacity and
reduced Bit Error Rate (BER) [4][10].
Here, we attempt to analyze the performance of the three
systems namely SISO-OFDM, MISO(1X2)-OFDM and
MIMO(2X2) OFDM for image transmission over Rayleigh
and AWGN channels. We have also examined the effect of
using LS channel estimation technique in MIMO-OFDM
system over Rayleigh channel. Matlab simulation results are
compared for parameters such as BER and channel capacity.
In section II, we have given brief idea of the
abovementioned systems. Section III gives results of
simulations performed on the given systems for various
conditions. We conclude in section IV by demonstrating the
effect of antenna diversity on BER and channel capacity. We
also show that by using channel estimation techniques, BER
can be reduced.
II. DESIGN AND MODELLING
In this section we have briefly explained MIMO-OFDM
systems, mathematical model of AWGN and Rayleigh
channel, effect of type of modulation on BER, mathematical
model of Least Square channel estimator and expression for
channel capacity based on antenna diversity
A. MIMO-OFDM
The basic principle of a multicarrier system is dividing high
data rate stream into relatively low data rate sub streams.
These sub streams are modulated on different sub carriers.
The increase in number of subcarriers reduces the effect of
multipath dispersion which in turn reduces ISI (Inter Symbol
Interference). More number of subcarriers requires large
number of filters and oscillators. Hence OFDM turns out to be
an efficient technique in providing multicarrier
communication by implementing DFT (Discrete Fourier
Transform). OFDM has densely spaced subcarriers with
overlapping spectra of modulated signals and avoids the use
of steep band pass filters to detect each subcarrier [3][5][6][8].
Based on number of transmit antennas (Nt) and receive
antennas (Nr) used, we can have following systems
Nr=1, Nt=1: Single In Single Out (SISO)
Nr=1, Nt>1: Multiple In Single Out (MISO)
Nr>1, Nt=1: Multiple In Single Out (SIMO)
Nr>1, Nt>1: Multiple In Single Out (MIMO)
Fig 1. shows the block diagram of designed system model for
2X2 MIMO.
T](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/designsimulationandevaluationofsisomisomimoofdmsystems-170715082423/85/Design-simulation-and-evaluation-of-siso-miso-mimo-ofdm-systems-1-320.jpg)
![International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineering, Management & Applied Science (IJLTEMAS)
3rd
Special Issue on Engineering and Technology | Volume VI, Issue VIIS, July 2017 | ISSN 2278-2540
www.ijltemas.in Page 64
Fig. 1. Block diagram of 2X2 MIMO-OFDM system
For a 2X2 system, symbols received at both the antennas at
time instant k is given by
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
Here Y is the received symbol matrix, H is the channel
coefficient matrix, X is the transmitted symbol matrix and V
is the noise matrix. We transmit block type pilot symbols for
channel estimation.
B. CHANNEL ESTIMATION
We have implemented Least Square algorithm to estimate
the channel [9] [11]. For channel estimation purpose, we have
transmitted block type pilot symbols, using which the Least
Square channel estimate is given by
̂ ( )
After obtaining estimate of channel coefficient matrix, we
can obtain the estimate of transmitted symbols using the
following expression
̂
C. BIT ERROR RATE IN AWGN AND RAYLEIGH
CHANNEL MODEL
We have analysed the designed model for AWGN channel
and Rayleigh Channel [2][7]. For AWGN channel,
theoretically BER (Bit Error Rate) for a BPSK modulated
transmission is given by
√
For Rayleigh channel, theoretically BER for a BPSK
modulated transmission for a SISO is given by
( √ )
For MIMO with r receive antennas and t transmit antennas,
theoretically BER for a BPSK modulated transmission is
given by
( ) ∑ ( )
where
here
√
To find the BER practically, we compare the transmitted
data with the received data [5][12]. Then BER is calculated as
follows
D. CHANNEL CAPACITY IN MIMO
When Channel State Information (CSI) is unknown and
when Nt= Nr= N , we can say that MIMO channel is
converted into N SISO channels. Then the total channel
capacity is given by
( )
where, is the gain for ith SISO channel. Ex is the energy of
the transmitted signals and No is the PSD of noise [1][11][12].
III. SIMULATION RESULTS
A. Comparison of SISO-OFDM, MISO (1X2)-OFDM and
MIMO (2X2)-OFDM in AWGN channel and in Rayleigh
channel for image transmission
Table I below shows comparison of SISO-OFDM, MISO-
OFDM and MIMO-OFDM systems for transmitting an image
of size 256X256X3 with signal to noise ratio of 5dB and 128
subcarriers, over AWGN channel and Rayleigh channel. We
observe that BER for all the three systems over AWGN
channel is less than BER over Rayleigh channel. Another
important observation made is that the BER decreases with
increase in antenna diversity for both the channels. This
happens because increase in number of antennas reduces the
fading effect.
TABLE I
BER COMPARISON AT 5DB SNR FOR SISO/MISO/MIMO OFDM SYSTEMS FOR
AWGN AND RAYLEIGH CHANNELS
System
BER for AWGN
Channel(SNR=5dB)
BER for
Rayleigh
Channel
(SNR=5dB)
SISO OFDM 0.0060 0.0773](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/designsimulationandevaluationofsisomisomimoofdmsystems-170715082423/85/Design-simulation-and-evaluation-of-siso-miso-mimo-ofdm-systems-2-320.jpg)
![International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineering, Management & Applied Science (IJLTEMAS)
3rd
Special Issue on Engineering and Technology | Volume VI, Issue VIIS, July 2017 | ISSN 2278-2540
www.ijltemas.in Page 66
D. Channel capacity with increase in antenna receive
diversity
From the graph below we observe that as the antenna
diversity increases, the channel capacity increases.
Fig. 7. Channel capacity of SISO, MIMO (2X2), MIMO (3X3) and MIMO
(4X4)
IV. CONCLUSIONS
In this paper, we have simulated SISO-OFDM, MISO
OFDM and MIMO (2X2)-OFDM systems for image
transmission over AWGN channel and Rayleigh Channel.
With the results we confirm the fact that as the antenna
diversity increases, the BER decreases. We have also
compared the performance of MIMO-OFDM system over
Rayleigh channel with Least Square channel estimation and
without channel estimation. We affirm that with LS estimate,
the BER obtained for the range of SNR is less. Also, with
increase in antenna diversity, channel capacity increases.
Results show that higher data transmission rates can be
achieved, through the use of higher order PSK systems, by
employing MIMO OFDM with channel estimation. This can
largely increase the capacity of wireless channels.
REFERENCES
[1]. A.K Jaiswal, A. K. (2012). Performance Analysis of MIMO
OFDM systems in Rayleigh fading Channels. International Journal
of Scientific and Research Publications, 1-5.
[2]. Casu, G., Georgescu, F., Nicolaescu, M., & Mocanu, A. (2015). A
comparative performnce analysis of MIMO OFDM systems over
different fading channels. 7th International Conference on
Electronics, Computers and Artifical Intelligence (pp. 1-4). IEEE
Conference Publications.
[3]. Charan Langton, B. S. (2011, October). Finding MIMO. Retrieved
from complextoreal: http://complextoreal.com/tutorials/tutorial-
27-finding-mimo
[4]. Jiang Xuehua, C. P. (2009). Study and Implementation of MIMO-
OFDM System Based on Matlab. International Conference on
Information Technology and Computer Science (pp. 554 - 557).
IEEE Conference Publications.
[5]. K Fazel, S. K. (2008). Multi-Carrier and Spread Spectrum
Systems (2nd ed.). Wiley.
[6]. N.Praba, K. (2016). Image transmisson in OFDM using M-ary
PSK modulation shcemes- a comparative study. International
Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology, 5(1), 193-
197.
[7]. Patil, P. K. (2013). Role of Contributing Factors MIMO-OFDM in
4G-LTE Wireless Transmission Technologies from Technical
Perspective. International Journal of Advanced Research in
Computer and Communication Engineering, 2(7).
[8]. Poole, I. (n.d.). LTE OFDM, OFDMA SC-FDMA & Modulation.
Retrieved April 27, 2017, from Radio-Electronics.com:
http://www.radio-electronics.com/info/cellulartelecomms/lte-long-
term-evolution/lte-ofdm-ofdma-scfdma.php
[9]. Principles of Modern CDMA/MIMO/OFDM Wireless
Communications. (n.d.). Retrieved April 27, 2017, from NPTEL:
http://nptel.ac.in/courses/117104115/#
[10]. S. Ramesh, R. S. (2016). PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF
MIMO-OFDM FOR MULTIPLE ANTENNAS. International
Journal of Pharmacy & Technology, 8(4), 23041-23053.
[11]. Thiruvengadathan, R., & Srikanth, S. (2012). Performance of
MIMO Channel Estimation in LTE Downlink. Computing
Communication & Networking Technologies (ICCCNT), 2012
Third International Conference on (pp. 1-7). IEEE Conference
Publications.
[12]. Yong Soo Cho, J. K. (2010). MIMO-OFDM Wireless
Communication with Matlab. Wiley.](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/designsimulationandevaluationofsisomisomimoofdmsystems-170715082423/85/Design-simulation-and-evaluation-of-siso-miso-mimo-ofdm-systems-4-320.jpg)
Design simulation and evaluation of siso miso mimo ofdm systems
- 1. International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineering, Management & Applied Science (IJLTEMAS) 3rd Special Issue on Engineering and Technology | Volume VI, Issue VIIS, July 2017 | ISSN 2278-2540 www.ijltemas.in Page 63 Design, Simulation and Evaluation of SISO/MISO/MIMO-OFDM Systems Ami Munshi# , Srija Unnikrishnan* # SVKM’s NMIMS MPSTME, Mumbai, India *FRCRCE, University of Mumbai, India Abstract— In this paper an endeavour is made to design and simulate SISO, MISO and MIMO OFDM systems. We have analysed and compared the performance of these systems for image transmission over AWGN and Rayleigh channels. The effect of LS channel estimation on the BER over a range of SNR for MIMO(2X2) systems is examined. We have also compared the performance based on various M-ary PSK modulation techniques for image transmission over Rayleigh channel in MIMO-OFDM system. The system performance is simulated in Matlab. The results of the simulation show that as the antenna diversity increases, the BER decreases and the channel capacity increases. Also, the BER obtained in MIMO-OFDM system is less when LS estimation is used. Keywords— OFDM, MIMO, Rayleigh, AWGN, BER, channel capacity I. INTRODUCTION he demand for maximum achievable data rate, less delay time, efficient modulation technique, less interference, reduced effect of multipath propagation and Doppler shift, high picture and voice quality, etc. are increasing day by day in wireless technology. These demands can be met by technologies like multicarrier systems (OFDM), MIMO, CDMA etc. The main advantages of multicarrier systems are its robustness in frequency selective channels and less signal processing complexity as equalization is done in frequency domain. OFDM is amalgamation of modulation and multiplexing. It helps in reducing Inter Symbol Interference for frequency selective channels by adding cyclic prefix. MIMO transforms single point to point channel into multiple parallel channels thus offering higher channel capacity and reduced Bit Error Rate (BER) [4][10]. Here, we attempt to analyze the performance of the three systems namely SISO-OFDM, MISO(1X2)-OFDM and MIMO(2X2) OFDM for image transmission over Rayleigh and AWGN channels. We have also examined the effect of using LS channel estimation technique in MIMO-OFDM system over Rayleigh channel. Matlab simulation results are compared for parameters such as BER and channel capacity. In section II, we have given brief idea of the abovementioned systems. Section III gives results of simulations performed on the given systems for various conditions. We conclude in section IV by demonstrating the effect of antenna diversity on BER and channel capacity. We also show that by using channel estimation techniques, BER can be reduced. II. DESIGN AND MODELLING In this section we have briefly explained MIMO-OFDM systems, mathematical model of AWGN and Rayleigh channel, effect of type of modulation on BER, mathematical model of Least Square channel estimator and expression for channel capacity based on antenna diversity A. MIMO-OFDM The basic principle of a multicarrier system is dividing high data rate stream into relatively low data rate sub streams. These sub streams are modulated on different sub carriers. The increase in number of subcarriers reduces the effect of multipath dispersion which in turn reduces ISI (Inter Symbol Interference). More number of subcarriers requires large number of filters and oscillators. Hence OFDM turns out to be an efficient technique in providing multicarrier communication by implementing DFT (Discrete Fourier Transform). OFDM has densely spaced subcarriers with overlapping spectra of modulated signals and avoids the use of steep band pass filters to detect each subcarrier [3][5][6][8]. Based on number of transmit antennas (Nt) and receive antennas (Nr) used, we can have following systems Nr=1, Nt=1: Single In Single Out (SISO) Nr=1, Nt>1: Multiple In Single Out (MISO) Nr>1, Nt=1: Multiple In Single Out (SIMO) Nr>1, Nt>1: Multiple In Single Out (MIMO) Fig 1. shows the block diagram of designed system model for 2X2 MIMO. T
- 2. International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineering, Management & Applied Science (IJLTEMAS) 3rd Special Issue on Engineering and Technology | Volume VI, Issue VIIS, July 2017 | ISSN 2278-2540 www.ijltemas.in Page 64 Fig. 1. Block diagram of 2X2 MIMO-OFDM system For a 2X2 system, symbols received at both the antennas at time instant k is given by ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) Here Y is the received symbol matrix, H is the channel coefficient matrix, X is the transmitted symbol matrix and V is the noise matrix. We transmit block type pilot symbols for channel estimation. B. CHANNEL ESTIMATION We have implemented Least Square algorithm to estimate the channel [9] [11]. For channel estimation purpose, we have transmitted block type pilot symbols, using which the Least Square channel estimate is given by ̂ ( ) After obtaining estimate of channel coefficient matrix, we can obtain the estimate of transmitted symbols using the following expression ̂ C. BIT ERROR RATE IN AWGN AND RAYLEIGH CHANNEL MODEL We have analysed the designed model for AWGN channel and Rayleigh Channel [2][7]. For AWGN channel, theoretically BER (Bit Error Rate) for a BPSK modulated transmission is given by √ For Rayleigh channel, theoretically BER for a BPSK modulated transmission for a SISO is given by ( √ ) For MIMO with r receive antennas and t transmit antennas, theoretically BER for a BPSK modulated transmission is given by ( ) ∑ ( ) where here √ To find the BER practically, we compare the transmitted data with the received data [5][12]. Then BER is calculated as follows D. CHANNEL CAPACITY IN MIMO When Channel State Information (CSI) is unknown and when Nt= Nr= N , we can say that MIMO channel is converted into N SISO channels. Then the total channel capacity is given by ( ) where, is the gain for ith SISO channel. Ex is the energy of the transmitted signals and No is the PSD of noise [1][11][12]. III. SIMULATION RESULTS A. Comparison of SISO-OFDM, MISO (1X2)-OFDM and MIMO (2X2)-OFDM in AWGN channel and in Rayleigh channel for image transmission Table I below shows comparison of SISO-OFDM, MISO- OFDM and MIMO-OFDM systems for transmitting an image of size 256X256X3 with signal to noise ratio of 5dB and 128 subcarriers, over AWGN channel and Rayleigh channel. We observe that BER for all the three systems over AWGN channel is less than BER over Rayleigh channel. Another important observation made is that the BER decreases with increase in antenna diversity for both the channels. This happens because increase in number of antennas reduces the fading effect. TABLE I BER COMPARISON AT 5DB SNR FOR SISO/MISO/MIMO OFDM SYSTEMS FOR AWGN AND RAYLEIGH CHANNELS System BER for AWGN Channel(SNR=5dB) BER for Rayleigh Channel (SNR=5dB) SISO OFDM 0.0060 0.0773
- 3. International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineering, Management & Applied Science (IJLTEMAS) 3rd Special Issue on Engineering and Technology | Volume VI, Issue VIIS, July 2017 | ISSN 2278-2540 www.ijltemas.in Page 65 MISO OFDM 1.7611e-004 0.0211 MIMO OFDM 2.5431e-006 0.0077 The Fig 2, 3, 4 below show the output images of SISO- OFDM, MISO-OFDM and MIMO-OFDM systems respectively over Rayleigh channel which confirm the above results for 5dB SNR. Fig. 2. Original image Fig. 3. Output for SISO Fig. 4. Output for MISO Fig. 5. Output for MIMO B. Comparison of various modulation M-ary PSK techniques in MIMO-OFDM system in AWGN channel and Rayleigh channel Table II below shows comparison of various M-ary PSK modulation schemes implemented in MIMO (2X2)- OFDM for image transmission over Rayleigh channel with signal to noise ratio of 10dB with and without LS estimate. We observe that as number of symbols M increases, BER also increases. This shows that as the Euclidean distance between the symbols decreases, the probability of error increases. TABLE III BER COMPARISON AT 10DB SNR FOR BPSK, QPSK AND 16-PSK MODULATION TECHNIQUES FOR MIMO OFDM SYSTEMS OVER RAYLEIGH CHANNEL Rayleigh Channel (SNR=10dB) Modulation type BER with LS estimate BER without estimate BPSK 2.8928e-004 0.0069 QPSK 5.8810e-004 0.0136 16-PSK 0.0351 0.1013 C. Image transmission in MIMO (2X2)-OFDM system with and without channel estimation Table III below demonstrates the performance of MIMO- OFDM system over AWGN channel and Rayleigh channel when LS channel is implemented and without channel estimation for 5dB Signal to noise ratio. We observe that in the case of MIMO (2X2) for both the channels AWGN as well as Rayleigh, BER obtained with LS (Least Square) estimate is less than the BER obtained without using any estimation technique. TABLE III BER COMPARISON AT 5DB SNR MIMO OFDM SYSTEMS OVER AWGN CHANNEL AND RAYLEIGH CHANNEL WITH LS ESTIMATION AND WITHOUT ESTIMATION AWGN Channel(SNR=5dB) Rayleigh Channel (SNR=5dB) System BER with LS estimate BER without estimate BER with LS estimate BER without estimate MIMO OFDM 2.5431e-006 2.0154e-004 0.0077 0.0209 Fig 6 below show the plot of SNR vs. BER for image transmission in MIMO-OFDM system over Rayleigh channel when Least Square (LS) estimation is used and without any estimation. We observe that with channel estimation the BER is significantly lower than the BER without estimation over range of SNRs. This demonstrates that improvement in performance of MIMO-OFDM system can be obtained when channel estimation is executed. Fig. 6. SNR Vs. BER plot for image transmission in MIMO (2X2)-OFDM over Rayleigh channel with LS estimation and without estimation
- 4. International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineering, Management & Applied Science (IJLTEMAS) 3rd Special Issue on Engineering and Technology | Volume VI, Issue VIIS, July 2017 | ISSN 2278-2540 www.ijltemas.in Page 66 D. Channel capacity with increase in antenna receive diversity From the graph below we observe that as the antenna diversity increases, the channel capacity increases. Fig. 7. Channel capacity of SISO, MIMO (2X2), MIMO (3X3) and MIMO (4X4) IV. CONCLUSIONS In this paper, we have simulated SISO-OFDM, MISO OFDM and MIMO (2X2)-OFDM systems for image transmission over AWGN channel and Rayleigh Channel. With the results we confirm the fact that as the antenna diversity increases, the BER decreases. We have also compared the performance of MIMO-OFDM system over Rayleigh channel with Least Square channel estimation and without channel estimation. We affirm that with LS estimate, the BER obtained for the range of SNR is less. Also, with increase in antenna diversity, channel capacity increases. Results show that higher data transmission rates can be achieved, through the use of higher order PSK systems, by employing MIMO OFDM with channel estimation. This can largely increase the capacity of wireless channels. REFERENCES [1]. A.K Jaiswal, A. K. (2012). Performance Analysis of MIMO OFDM systems in Rayleigh fading Channels. International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications, 1-5. [2]. Casu, G., Georgescu, F., Nicolaescu, M., & Mocanu, A. (2015). A comparative performnce analysis of MIMO OFDM systems over different fading channels. 7th International Conference on Electronics, Computers and Artifical Intelligence (pp. 1-4). IEEE Conference Publications. [3]. Charan Langton, B. S. (2011, October). Finding MIMO. Retrieved from complextoreal: http://complextoreal.com/tutorials/tutorial- 27-finding-mimo [4]. Jiang Xuehua, C. P. (2009). Study and Implementation of MIMO- OFDM System Based on Matlab. International Conference on Information Technology and Computer Science (pp. 554 - 557). IEEE Conference Publications. [5]. K Fazel, S. K. (2008). Multi-Carrier and Spread Spectrum Systems (2nd ed.). Wiley. [6]. N.Praba, K. (2016). Image transmisson in OFDM using M-ary PSK modulation shcemes- a comparative study. International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology, 5(1), 193- 197. [7]. Patil, P. K. (2013). Role of Contributing Factors MIMO-OFDM in 4G-LTE Wireless Transmission Technologies from Technical Perspective. International Journal of Advanced Research in Computer and Communication Engineering, 2(7). [8]. Poole, I. (n.d.). LTE OFDM, OFDMA SC-FDMA & Modulation. Retrieved April 27, 2017, from Radio-Electronics.com: http://www.radio-electronics.com/info/cellulartelecomms/lte-long- term-evolution/lte-ofdm-ofdma-scfdma.php [9]. Principles of Modern CDMA/MIMO/OFDM Wireless Communications. (n.d.). Retrieved April 27, 2017, from NPTEL: http://nptel.ac.in/courses/117104115/# [10]. S. Ramesh, R. S. (2016). PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF MIMO-OFDM FOR MULTIPLE ANTENNAS. International Journal of Pharmacy & Technology, 8(4), 23041-23053. [11]. Thiruvengadathan, R., & Srikanth, S. (2012). Performance of MIMO Channel Estimation in LTE Downlink. Computing Communication & Networking Technologies (ICCCNT), 2012 Third International Conference on (pp. 1-7). IEEE Conference Publications. [12]. Yong Soo Cho, J. K. (2010). MIMO-OFDM Wireless Communication with Matlab. Wiley.