Domestic Biogas in Asia

  Dr David Fulford CEnv MEI
       www.kingdombio.com
      davidf@kingdombio.com
What is biogas?
• Anaerobic Digestion (AD) breaks down
  wet biomass to gas and compost
• Relies on microbes (bacteria and
  archaea) in animal dung
• Several possible applications
• Talk focuses on biogas in rural areas
  for domestic uses, with dung as feed
Background
• SNV (Netherlands Development Organisation)
  Asia Biogas programme - focus on rural
  domestic biogas fed by animal dung.
• Started in Nepal (1993) - extended to
  Vietnam, Bangladesh, Cambodia and Laos
• Based on previous
  programme set up
  Development and
  Consulting Services of
  United Mission to Nepal
  (1976 to 1984)
Technology
• Dung mixed with water and allowed to flow
  into underground pit lined with masonry
• Plants built for individual households
• Need 3 to 6 cows or 6 to 12 pigs
• Gas piped to kitchen for cooking
                     • Slurry from plant
                       collected
                     • Can be used as a
                       fertilizer after some
                       processing
                     • Removes smell
Benefits (1)
• Clean gaseous cooking fuel
• No smoke
• Instant availability
• Does not need constant attention
• Reduced danger of burns
• Resource (dung)
  available from animal
  sheds
• No need to walk to
  collect firewood
Benefits (2)
• Cooking pots easy to clean (no soot)
• Saving of time (3 hours a day)
• Saving of firewood (2,000 kg a year)
• Reduced deforestation (1,000 biogas plants
  saves 33.8 ha forest from clear felling)
                     • Much reduced smell
                       from the animal sheds
                     (in Vietnam, pig sties
                       are close to the house)
Benefits (3)
• Biogas can be used for lights
• Reduced smell from kerosene lamps
• Savings of 32 litres kerosene a year
• Reduced risk of house fires
• Saving of carbon (4,900 kg a year)
• Since gas available in
  the morning, children
  get cooked breakfast
  before school.
Benefits (4)
• A latrine can be attached
• Improved sanitation
• Reduced transfer of pathogens (especially if
  slurry is properly processed)

                      • Reduced risk to women
                        (who go out at dawn or
                        dusk to use the fields)
                      • Reduce incidence of
                        snake bites
Benefits (5)
• Slurry is a good quality compost (better than
  raw dung)
• Liquid slurry should be absorbed in dry
  biomass and composted for 1 month

• Compost even better if
  use vermi-culture
• Growers prepared to
  pay cash for vermi-
  compost
Economics
• With so many benefits, what is drawback?
• Cost - most cost:benefit analyses show
  financial benefit as marginal
• BUT high value for “externalities” - e.g.
  saving forests, health benefits etc.
                      • Biogas becomes
                        attractive with subsidy
                      • SNV Asia Biogas
                        Programme offered
                        reliable subsidy
Asia Biogas Programme
• Involve people at all levels, from government
  policy makers to masons who build plants
• Promotion, Education and Training
• Emphasis on quality of technology
• Use a local design, but ensure it works well
• Train staff to check
  quality of construction
• Release subsidy for
  each plant only when it
  meets specification
Tasks involved in running a biogas programme


                                       Construction

                                                              Quality
                   Training
                                                            Management

                                     Household                         Micro Credit,
    Marketing
     & Sales
                                      Biogas                               SME
                                                                       Development
                                      Sector

                     R&D                                       Subsidy
                                          Extra
                                         services



Ref: Dagmar Zwebe, “SNV Renewable Energy Developments: The Biogas Programme for Animal
Husbandry Sector of Vietnam”, Presentation (May 2012).
Project Achievements
                        Start         Built in         Built by           Invest
Country
                        Year           2011             2011              Cost $
Nepal                  1992             19,246          250,476             663

Vietnam                2003             23,372          123,714             621

Cambodia               2006               4,826           20,756            488

Bangladesh             2006               5,049           14,972            430

Laos                   2007                  439            2,405           448

Total                                   52,932          412,323
Based on: Brief progress and planning report the Working Group on Domestic Biogas under
          the Energy for All Partnership as per May 2012
Starting a Programme
• Find a group interested in biogas to manage
  programme (or set up a group)
• Involve people from government and
  encourage renewable energy policy
• Design a subsidy & micro-finance scheme
                     • Develop a local design
                       that works well
                     • Use local companies to
                       build plants
                     • Train staff regularly
Subsidy Issues (1)
• Who funds externalities? i.e.
• Who pays to save forests, improve people’s
  health, reduce carbon emissions?
• National governments - but other priorities
• International Community
• Bilateral Aid (SNV, KfW,
  DANIDA, USAID etc)
• UN agencies:
World Bank, ADB, UNDP,
  UNEP, UNFCCC
• Danger of corruption
Subsidy Issues (2)
• WWF puts high value on certain habitats:
  e.g. tiger ranges - pay extra
• CDM designed to fund carbon offsets - CER
  certified emissions reductions
• Also VER - voluntary emissions reductions
                     • Carbon offset trading
                       under voluntary
                       market mechanisms
                     (Big companies want to
                       look “Green”)
                     • Complex - large nos.
                       needed
Carbon Offset Biogas
• New Charitable Company established
• Foundation SKG Sangha - based on biogas
  programme in South India
• Aim: to use voluntary carbon offset finance
  to encourage biogas projects elsewhere
• Also interest in other
  renewable energy
  projects
• First project in Egypt
  funded by UNDP
Technical Aspects
• Underground dome made from masonry
  (bricks or concrete)
• Gas stored by displacing slurry into
  reservoir tank
• Volume 4 m3 (2 m3 to 10 m3)
Biogas Displacement Principle
Other applications (1)
• Sewage Treatment
• KIST project in Rwanda processing sewage
  from prisons (10,000 people)
• Saves 50% of wood fuel for cooking
• Volume 100 m3 x 10 = 1,000 m3
Other applications (2)
• Urban biogas to process food wastes
• Volume 1 m3, food waste gives more gas
• Family’s own food waste saves 25% LPG
• Use extra food waste from local shops
• Can use sewage in addition
Other applications (3)
• Local authority wastes
• Market wastes
• Office canteen wastes
• Municipal solid wastes
• Food processing wastes
Thank you

Domestic Biogas in Asia - David Fulford

  • 1.
    Domestic Biogas inAsia Dr David Fulford CEnv MEI www.kingdombio.com [email protected]
  • 2.
    What is biogas? •Anaerobic Digestion (AD) breaks down wet biomass to gas and compost • Relies on microbes (bacteria and archaea) in animal dung • Several possible applications • Talk focuses on biogas in rural areas for domestic uses, with dung as feed
  • 3.
    Background • SNV (NetherlandsDevelopment Organisation) Asia Biogas programme - focus on rural domestic biogas fed by animal dung. • Started in Nepal (1993) - extended to Vietnam, Bangladesh, Cambodia and Laos • Based on previous programme set up Development and Consulting Services of United Mission to Nepal (1976 to 1984)
  • 4.
    Technology • Dung mixedwith water and allowed to flow into underground pit lined with masonry • Plants built for individual households • Need 3 to 6 cows or 6 to 12 pigs • Gas piped to kitchen for cooking • Slurry from plant collected • Can be used as a fertilizer after some processing • Removes smell
  • 5.
    Benefits (1) • Cleangaseous cooking fuel • No smoke • Instant availability • Does not need constant attention • Reduced danger of burns • Resource (dung) available from animal sheds • No need to walk to collect firewood
  • 6.
    Benefits (2) • Cookingpots easy to clean (no soot) • Saving of time (3 hours a day) • Saving of firewood (2,000 kg a year) • Reduced deforestation (1,000 biogas plants saves 33.8 ha forest from clear felling) • Much reduced smell from the animal sheds (in Vietnam, pig sties are close to the house)
  • 7.
    Benefits (3) • Biogascan be used for lights • Reduced smell from kerosene lamps • Savings of 32 litres kerosene a year • Reduced risk of house fires • Saving of carbon (4,900 kg a year) • Since gas available in the morning, children get cooked breakfast before school.
  • 8.
    Benefits (4) • Alatrine can be attached • Improved sanitation • Reduced transfer of pathogens (especially if slurry is properly processed) • Reduced risk to women (who go out at dawn or dusk to use the fields) • Reduce incidence of snake bites
  • 9.
    Benefits (5) • Slurryis a good quality compost (better than raw dung) • Liquid slurry should be absorbed in dry biomass and composted for 1 month • Compost even better if use vermi-culture • Growers prepared to pay cash for vermi- compost
  • 10.
    Economics • With somany benefits, what is drawback? • Cost - most cost:benefit analyses show financial benefit as marginal • BUT high value for “externalities” - e.g. saving forests, health benefits etc. • Biogas becomes attractive with subsidy • SNV Asia Biogas Programme offered reliable subsidy
  • 11.
    Asia Biogas Programme •Involve people at all levels, from government policy makers to masons who build plants • Promotion, Education and Training • Emphasis on quality of technology • Use a local design, but ensure it works well • Train staff to check quality of construction • Release subsidy for each plant only when it meets specification
  • 12.
    Tasks involved inrunning a biogas programme Construction Quality Training Management Household Micro Credit, Marketing & Sales Biogas SME Development Sector R&D Subsidy Extra services Ref: Dagmar Zwebe, “SNV Renewable Energy Developments: The Biogas Programme for Animal Husbandry Sector of Vietnam”, Presentation (May 2012).
  • 13.
    Project Achievements Start Built in Built by Invest Country Year 2011 2011 Cost $ Nepal 1992 19,246 250,476 663 Vietnam 2003 23,372 123,714 621 Cambodia 2006 4,826 20,756 488 Bangladesh 2006 5,049 14,972 430 Laos 2007 439 2,405 448 Total 52,932 412,323 Based on: Brief progress and planning report the Working Group on Domestic Biogas under the Energy for All Partnership as per May 2012
  • 14.
    Starting a Programme •Find a group interested in biogas to manage programme (or set up a group) • Involve people from government and encourage renewable energy policy • Design a subsidy & micro-finance scheme • Develop a local design that works well • Use local companies to build plants • Train staff regularly
  • 15.
    Subsidy Issues (1) •Who funds externalities? i.e. • Who pays to save forests, improve people’s health, reduce carbon emissions? • National governments - but other priorities • International Community • Bilateral Aid (SNV, KfW, DANIDA, USAID etc) • UN agencies: World Bank, ADB, UNDP, UNEP, UNFCCC • Danger of corruption
  • 16.
    Subsidy Issues (2) •WWF puts high value on certain habitats: e.g. tiger ranges - pay extra • CDM designed to fund carbon offsets - CER certified emissions reductions • Also VER - voluntary emissions reductions • Carbon offset trading under voluntary market mechanisms (Big companies want to look “Green”) • Complex - large nos. needed
  • 17.
    Carbon Offset Biogas •New Charitable Company established • Foundation SKG Sangha - based on biogas programme in South India • Aim: to use voluntary carbon offset finance to encourage biogas projects elsewhere • Also interest in other renewable energy projects • First project in Egypt funded by UNDP
  • 18.
    Technical Aspects • Undergrounddome made from masonry (bricks or concrete) • Gas stored by displacing slurry into reservoir tank • Volume 4 m3 (2 m3 to 10 m3)
  • 19.
  • 20.
    Other applications (1) •Sewage Treatment • KIST project in Rwanda processing sewage from prisons (10,000 people) • Saves 50% of wood fuel for cooking • Volume 100 m3 x 10 = 1,000 m3
  • 21.
    Other applications (2) •Urban biogas to process food wastes • Volume 1 m3, food waste gives more gas • Family’s own food waste saves 25% LPG • Use extra food waste from local shops • Can use sewage in addition
  • 22.
    Other applications (3) •Local authority wastes • Market wastes • Office canteen wastes • Municipal solid wastes • Food processing wastes
  • 23.