Education and Society
M.Vijayalakshmi
Assistant Professor
Sri Ramakrishna Mission Vidyalaya College of Education
Coimbatore
Education and Society
ES - 334
Indian Education System:
Some Issues
• Unit – 13
• Inequality in School Education
• Unit – 14
• Issues Related to Universalization of School
Education
• Unit – 15
• Issues Related to the Present Examination
System
• Unit – 16
• Issues Related to Vocationalization of
Secondary Education
Unit – 13
Inequality in School Education
• Inequality : Its Nature
• Consequences of Inequality in
Education
• Educational Disparities at the
Elementary Stage of Education
• Role of Non-Government
Organizations
• Language at Home and School
• School/Teacher’s Role
Inequality : Its Nature
• Caste discrimination
• Welfare state
• Wealth and Power
• Poverty
• Changes - Time and Space
Historical Typology
• Exogenous Factors – Outside the Education
System
• Economic, social, political, technological
and cultural factors
• Education system, delivery of education, etc
• Exogenous Factors - Within the educational
domain
• Poor organizational climate of school-
system
• Qualitative inequalities
• Social barriers, malnutrition, lack
of guidance etc
• Quantitative inequalities
• Low income, low achievement
grades, etc
Consequences of Inequality in Education
• Economic Consequences
• Social Consequences
• Political Consequences
• Cultural Consequences
• Educational Consequences
Educational Disparities at the
Elementary Stage of Education
• Article 45 and 46
• Free and compulsory ‘Basic Education’
(Primary Education)
• Age 6-14
• Far Behind States - Assam, Andhra
Pradesh, Bihar, Jammu & Kashmir,
Madhya Pradesh, Orissa, Rajasthan, Uttar
Pradesh and West Bengal
• SC & ST
• SC – 22% 1981 to 38% 1991
• ST – 17% 1981 to 30% 1991
• Female Literacy – 8% in Barmer
district of Rajasthan
• 94% in Kottayam district of
Kerala
• Adopt – Positive Discrimination
• Localized Micro-planning
• Decentralized plan of action
Intervention Strategies to Reduce
Inequality in Education
• Micro – Planning
• Mobilizing community participation in villages
• Decentralizing educational administration
• Inviting and strengthening local administrative
and resource support system
• Ascertaining educational requirement of the
area
• Seeing that all children participate in the
learning process at school
• Planning for infrastructural improvement of
school/non-formal education centres
• 3 types of districts
• High literacy districts – Quality and
achievement
• Total literacy Districts – To achieve UEE
• Low literacy districts – Cover environment
building
• At present – 247 Educationally backward
districts in India
• Need “Crash Programme’ – DPEP
implemented
Minimum Levels of Learning
• Assessment of the existing levels of
learning achievement
• A definition of MLLs for the area and
the time frame within which it will be
achieved
• Clear-cut definition of the role of the
teacher and curriculum
Structural Changes
• Factors determine - student learning
• Sources ?
• Sources – Within input or out of school
control
• Role of the Socio-economic background of
the student and peer group
• Govt or Private – successful ?
• Policy ?
• Which factors to be focussed most ?
Researches
The Effect of Teacher Training
• NCERT
• Programme for Massive Orientation of
School Teachers (PMOST 1986-89)
• Operation Black Board Scheme (19889-
1992)
• Special Orientation Programme for
Teachers (SPOT 1993-94 to 1996-97)
• District Primary Education Programme
(DPEP) - In-service training
• Cost effectiveness of improvements in
teacher training
• Upgrading of existing teachers -
enrichment materials
• In-service training for poorly trained or
untrained teachers
• Retraining of teachers for new curricula
• Improvements in initial or pre-service
training – concrete and realistic
Specialist Teacher Educator –
Resource Person –
Teachers
Role of NGOs
Language at Home and School
• Mudaliar Commission – 1952-53
• Mother tongue – medium of instruction
• Two languages – secondary stage
School/Teacher’s Role
• Constitutive Action
• Pupil’s Characteristics – Categorising the
students in terms of -
• Fixed Characteristics
• Grade Specific Characteristics
• Pupil’s Family Background Characteristics
• Peer Group Characteristics
• School Characteristics -
• School Quality
• Teacher Quality
• Managerial and Administrative Environment of
School
Unit – 14
Issues Related to
Universalization of School
Education
• Concept of Wastage
• Concept of Stagnation
• Causes of Wastage and
Stagnation
• How to Reduce Wastage and
Stagnation?
• Medium of Instruction
Wastage
• Hartog Committee
• The premature withdrawal of
children from school at any
stage before the completion of
the primary class
Stagnation
• Child spends more number of years to complete
a given course than prescribed for it.
• Index of Stagnation = 100 1- Total Optimum Years
Total Years actually taken
Causes of wastage and stagnation
• Socio-Economic Causes
• Educational Causes
• Miscellaneous Causes
Socio-Economic Causes
• Economically Backwardness of the Family
• Excessive Involvement of Children in
Domestic Work
• Occupation
• Educational Status of the Family
• Early Marriage or Betrothal
• Indifference of Parents
• Parental Opposition
Educational Causes
• Lack of Conducive conditions at Home and
School
• Absence of Relationship between
Educational system and Economic Needs of
the Community
• Weak Infrastructure
Miscellaneous Causes
• Difficult natural and geographical
conditions
• Physical illness of pupils
• Heterogeneity in Age-composition
of the Pupils
How to Reduce
Wastage and Stagnation?
• Problem is quite serious
• Need motivation to overcome
the problem
Strategies to Reduce
Wastage and Stagnation
• Improvement of School Facilities
• School Management
• Improvement of Teacher
Performance
• Classroom related Strategies
District Primary Education Programme
• DPEP – 1993
• 42 districts in 7 states
• Assam, Karnataka, Kerala, Madhya
Pradesh, Maharashtra, Orissa, Tamil
Nadu
• Target 1993 – 98 – 110 districts – whole
country
National Literacy Mission
• NLM – 1988
• 80 million adults 15-35 age group by 1990-95
• Feb 1994 – 258 districts – covered by Total
Literacy Campaigns
• 80 Districts by Post-Literacy Campaigns
• Influence UEE – Successful
• Post-Literacy Centres – 22,000 – Jana Siksha
Nilayam - JSNs
Non- Formal Education
• Revise POA 1992
• 9-14 yrs
• 25:75 – 40:60
• 2,38,000 NFE centres March 1993 – 6
million
• 400 voluntary agencies – participating
Minimum Level of Learning
• Assessment of the existing levels of learning
achievement
• A definition of MLLs for the area and the
time frame within which it will be achieved
• Clear-cut definition of the role of the
teacher and curriculum
• Competency-based teaching
• Continuous, Comprehensive evaluation
• Review – text books
• Upgradation of physical and other facilities
Improving the quality of Pre-
service and In-service
Training Programmes for
Primary School Teachers
• Programme for Massive Orientation of
School Teachers (PMOST 1986-89) -
- Training Camps
• Operation Black Board Scheme (19889-
1992) -
- OB Kits
• Special Orientation Programme for
Teachers (SPOT 1993-94 to 1996-97) -
- Generating Awareness, In-Service Training
Programmes
Decentralised Planning and
Management of Education
• District Board, Blocks and Panchayats
• New Panchayat Raj Act – 1992
• Panchayat for a village – Village Education
Committee – power – Micro-planning
• Advising parents to send their children to
school
• Activating parent-teacher associations
• Running NFE centres effectively
• Helping in bringing school and village-
community closer and reducing truancy
cases
• Mobilizing enrolment of girls
• Aiding school in running remedial classes,
and helping poor parents in meeting the
educational needs of the child.
Medium of Instruction
• 1000 languages
• 18 national languages
• English and Hindi – Official Languages
• Dropouts –
• Need to improve
• Instructional materials
• Posting tribal teachers
• More women teachers
• Ashram schools
• Effort – to overcome social maladjustment of the
child
• Emotional problems of the pupils – handled
sympathetically and in a friendly manner
Unit – 15
Issues Related to the Present
Examination System
• Evaluation
• Status of the present
Examination System at the
School Stage
• Shortcomings of the Present
System
• Innovation in Examination
System
Evaluation
• Educational Evaluation
• Evaluation of Pupil Growth and
Examinations
Educational Evaluation
• Systematic educational
evaluation consists of a
formal appraisal of the
quality of educational
phenomena
Evaluation of
Pupil Growth and Examinations
• Objectives
• Learning Experiences
• Method of Teaching
• Evaluation – Techniques and tools
Status of the present Examination
System at the School Stage
• Haryana, Punjab and Himachal
Pradesh – 8th -Public
examination – State Board –
Middle examination
Status of the present Examination
System at the School Stage
• Model of Industry
• Mudaliyar Commission – 1952
• The Kothari Commission – 1964
• The Yashpal Committee
• The National Policy on Education – 1986
• The Acharya Ramamurthy Committee -
1990
Shortcomings of the Present System
• Memorization
• Scholastic-Oriented
• Validity of a Single-stroke Examination
• Creation of Fear and Tension
• Low Quality of Question Paper
• Prevalence of Essay type Question
• Subjectivity in Marking
• Limited Application of Assessment
Techniques
• Mismanagement of Examinations
• Inappropriate Interpretation of Raw Scores
• Non-application of Scaling Techniques
• Numerical Marking System Versus Grading
• Awarding of Grace Marks
• Predominance of the Examination system
over the Teaching-learning Process
• Lack of Credibility of Public Examinations
Innovation in Examination System
• Semester System
• Continuous and Comprehensive Evaluation
(CCE)
• Question Banks
• Re-evaluation and Returning of Marked
Answer Scripts
• Multiple Sets of Question Paper
• Open Book Examinations
• Credit Accumulation and Credit Transfer
Unit – 16
Issues Related to
Vocationalization of Secondary
Education
• Need for Vocationalization of Secondary
Education
• Historical Development of Vocationalization
of Education
• Policy Making in Vocational Education (VE)
• Present Status of Vocationalisation at the
School
• Problems
• Issues for the Future
Need for Vocationalization of
Secondary Education
Meaning
• UNESCO -
• Education action to prepare
for work and active life
Philosophy of
Vocationalisation
Merits of Vocationlisation of Education
• Education related to productivity
• Preparation of individual for jobs
• Employment opportunities
• Broadening of horizons
• Dignity of labour
• Maximum utilisation of the material
resources of the country
Historical Development of
Vocationalization of Education
• Wood’s Despatch (1854)
• Hunter Commission
• Hartog Committee (1929)
• Sargent Plan (1944)
• Mudaliyar Commission (1952-53)
• Kothari Commission (1964-66)
• Working Group (1985)
• National Policy on Education (1986, 1992)
• Ramamurthy Committee (1990)
• The Current Debate
Policy Making in Vocational Education (VE)
• NCERT – National Council for Educational
Research and Training
• SCERT – State Council of Educational
Research and Training
• AICTE – All India Council for Technical
Education
• RDAT – Regional Directorate of
Apprenticeship Training
• CSTARI – Central Staff Training and
Research Institute
• FTI – Foreman Training Institute
• ATI – Advanced Training Institute
• ITI – Industrial Training Institute
• NCTVT – National Council for Training in
Vocational Trades
• CAC – Central Apprenticeship Council
• DE & T – Directorate of Employment and
Training
• SCTVT – State Council for Training in
Vocational Trades
Present Status of
Vocationalisation at the School
• Polytechnics
• Industrial Training Institutes (ITTs)
• Specialised Institutions and Schools like
Technical, Arts and Craft Schools,
Agriculture Schools, Forestry Schools,
Nursing Schools Commercial Training
Schools etc.,
• Vocational Education at the +2 level within
the school system
Problems
• Irrelevance of courses leading to a
mismatch between the labour market needs
and the training skills
• Lack of focus on emerging areas of
industrial development
• Inadequate syllabi being followed in schools
and use of obsolete equipment
• Inadequate practical training skills
acquired by the students which are not
useful in practical life
• Lack of social acceptability
• Lack of employment opportunities,
and
• Overall poor enrolment in
vocational stream in such schools
Issues for the Future
• School-based system of vocational education
• Separate vocational institutions
• Polytechnics and ITIs – School-based
• Polytechnics and ITIs – Industry
• Academic Stature of vocational courses
Thank You

Education and society

  • 1.
    Education and Society M.Vijayalakshmi AssistantProfessor Sri Ramakrishna Mission Vidyalaya College of Education Coimbatore
  • 2.
    Education and Society ES- 334 Indian Education System: Some Issues
  • 3.
    • Unit –13 • Inequality in School Education • Unit – 14 • Issues Related to Universalization of School Education • Unit – 15 • Issues Related to the Present Examination System • Unit – 16 • Issues Related to Vocationalization of Secondary Education
  • 4.
    Unit – 13 Inequalityin School Education
  • 5.
    • Inequality :Its Nature • Consequences of Inequality in Education • Educational Disparities at the Elementary Stage of Education • Role of Non-Government Organizations • Language at Home and School • School/Teacher’s Role
  • 6.
    Inequality : ItsNature • Caste discrimination • Welfare state • Wealth and Power • Poverty • Changes - Time and Space
  • 7.
    Historical Typology • ExogenousFactors – Outside the Education System • Economic, social, political, technological and cultural factors • Education system, delivery of education, etc • Exogenous Factors - Within the educational domain • Poor organizational climate of school- system
  • 8.
    • Qualitative inequalities •Social barriers, malnutrition, lack of guidance etc • Quantitative inequalities • Low income, low achievement grades, etc
  • 9.
    Consequences of Inequalityin Education • Economic Consequences • Social Consequences • Political Consequences • Cultural Consequences • Educational Consequences
  • 10.
    Educational Disparities atthe Elementary Stage of Education • Article 45 and 46 • Free and compulsory ‘Basic Education’ (Primary Education) • Age 6-14 • Far Behind States - Assam, Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Jammu & Kashmir, Madhya Pradesh, Orissa, Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal
  • 11.
    • SC &ST • SC – 22% 1981 to 38% 1991 • ST – 17% 1981 to 30% 1991 • Female Literacy – 8% in Barmer district of Rajasthan • 94% in Kottayam district of Kerala • Adopt – Positive Discrimination • Localized Micro-planning • Decentralized plan of action
  • 12.
    Intervention Strategies toReduce Inequality in Education • Micro – Planning • Mobilizing community participation in villages • Decentralizing educational administration • Inviting and strengthening local administrative and resource support system • Ascertaining educational requirement of the area • Seeing that all children participate in the learning process at school • Planning for infrastructural improvement of school/non-formal education centres
  • 13.
    • 3 typesof districts • High literacy districts – Quality and achievement • Total literacy Districts – To achieve UEE • Low literacy districts – Cover environment building • At present – 247 Educationally backward districts in India • Need “Crash Programme’ – DPEP implemented
  • 14.
    Minimum Levels ofLearning • Assessment of the existing levels of learning achievement • A definition of MLLs for the area and the time frame within which it will be achieved • Clear-cut definition of the role of the teacher and curriculum
  • 15.
    Structural Changes • Factorsdetermine - student learning • Sources ? • Sources – Within input or out of school control • Role of the Socio-economic background of the student and peer group • Govt or Private – successful ? • Policy ? • Which factors to be focussed most ?
  • 16.
  • 17.
    The Effect ofTeacher Training • NCERT • Programme for Massive Orientation of School Teachers (PMOST 1986-89) • Operation Black Board Scheme (19889- 1992) • Special Orientation Programme for Teachers (SPOT 1993-94 to 1996-97) • District Primary Education Programme (DPEP) - In-service training
  • 18.
    • Cost effectivenessof improvements in teacher training • Upgrading of existing teachers - enrichment materials • In-service training for poorly trained or untrained teachers • Retraining of teachers for new curricula • Improvements in initial or pre-service training – concrete and realistic
  • 19.
    Specialist Teacher Educator– Resource Person – Teachers
  • 20.
  • 21.
    Language at Homeand School • Mudaliar Commission – 1952-53 • Mother tongue – medium of instruction • Two languages – secondary stage
  • 22.
    School/Teacher’s Role • ConstitutiveAction • Pupil’s Characteristics – Categorising the students in terms of - • Fixed Characteristics • Grade Specific Characteristics • Pupil’s Family Background Characteristics • Peer Group Characteristics • School Characteristics - • School Quality • Teacher Quality • Managerial and Administrative Environment of School
  • 23.
    Unit – 14 IssuesRelated to Universalization of School Education
  • 24.
    • Concept ofWastage • Concept of Stagnation • Causes of Wastage and Stagnation • How to Reduce Wastage and Stagnation? • Medium of Instruction
  • 25.
    Wastage • Hartog Committee •The premature withdrawal of children from school at any stage before the completion of the primary class
  • 26.
    Stagnation • Child spendsmore number of years to complete a given course than prescribed for it. • Index of Stagnation = 100 1- Total Optimum Years Total Years actually taken
  • 27.
    Causes of wastageand stagnation • Socio-Economic Causes • Educational Causes • Miscellaneous Causes
  • 28.
    Socio-Economic Causes • EconomicallyBackwardness of the Family • Excessive Involvement of Children in Domestic Work • Occupation • Educational Status of the Family • Early Marriage or Betrothal • Indifference of Parents • Parental Opposition
  • 29.
    Educational Causes • Lackof Conducive conditions at Home and School • Absence of Relationship between Educational system and Economic Needs of the Community • Weak Infrastructure
  • 30.
    Miscellaneous Causes • Difficultnatural and geographical conditions • Physical illness of pupils • Heterogeneity in Age-composition of the Pupils
  • 31.
    How to Reduce Wastageand Stagnation? • Problem is quite serious • Need motivation to overcome the problem
  • 32.
    Strategies to Reduce Wastageand Stagnation • Improvement of School Facilities • School Management • Improvement of Teacher Performance • Classroom related Strategies
  • 33.
    District Primary EducationProgramme • DPEP – 1993 • 42 districts in 7 states • Assam, Karnataka, Kerala, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Orissa, Tamil Nadu • Target 1993 – 98 – 110 districts – whole country
  • 34.
    National Literacy Mission •NLM – 1988 • 80 million adults 15-35 age group by 1990-95 • Feb 1994 – 258 districts – covered by Total Literacy Campaigns • 80 Districts by Post-Literacy Campaigns • Influence UEE – Successful • Post-Literacy Centres – 22,000 – Jana Siksha Nilayam - JSNs
  • 35.
    Non- Formal Education •Revise POA 1992 • 9-14 yrs • 25:75 – 40:60 • 2,38,000 NFE centres March 1993 – 6 million • 400 voluntary agencies – participating
  • 36.
    Minimum Level ofLearning • Assessment of the existing levels of learning achievement • A definition of MLLs for the area and the time frame within which it will be achieved • Clear-cut definition of the role of the teacher and curriculum • Competency-based teaching • Continuous, Comprehensive evaluation • Review – text books • Upgradation of physical and other facilities
  • 37.
    Improving the qualityof Pre- service and In-service Training Programmes for Primary School Teachers
  • 38.
    • Programme forMassive Orientation of School Teachers (PMOST 1986-89) - - Training Camps • Operation Black Board Scheme (19889- 1992) - - OB Kits • Special Orientation Programme for Teachers (SPOT 1993-94 to 1996-97) - - Generating Awareness, In-Service Training Programmes
  • 39.
    Decentralised Planning and Managementof Education • District Board, Blocks and Panchayats • New Panchayat Raj Act – 1992 • Panchayat for a village – Village Education Committee – power – Micro-planning
  • 40.
    • Advising parentsto send their children to school • Activating parent-teacher associations • Running NFE centres effectively • Helping in bringing school and village- community closer and reducing truancy cases • Mobilizing enrolment of girls • Aiding school in running remedial classes, and helping poor parents in meeting the educational needs of the child.
  • 41.
    Medium of Instruction •1000 languages • 18 national languages • English and Hindi – Official Languages • Dropouts – • Need to improve • Instructional materials • Posting tribal teachers • More women teachers • Ashram schools • Effort – to overcome social maladjustment of the child • Emotional problems of the pupils – handled sympathetically and in a friendly manner
  • 42.
    Unit – 15 IssuesRelated to the Present Examination System
  • 43.
    • Evaluation • Statusof the present Examination System at the School Stage • Shortcomings of the Present System • Innovation in Examination System
  • 44.
    Evaluation • Educational Evaluation •Evaluation of Pupil Growth and Examinations
  • 45.
    Educational Evaluation • Systematiceducational evaluation consists of a formal appraisal of the quality of educational phenomena
  • 46.
    Evaluation of Pupil Growthand Examinations • Objectives • Learning Experiences • Method of Teaching • Evaluation – Techniques and tools
  • 47.
    Status of thepresent Examination System at the School Stage • Haryana, Punjab and Himachal Pradesh – 8th -Public examination – State Board – Middle examination
  • 48.
    Status of thepresent Examination System at the School Stage • Model of Industry • Mudaliyar Commission – 1952 • The Kothari Commission – 1964 • The Yashpal Committee • The National Policy on Education – 1986 • The Acharya Ramamurthy Committee - 1990
  • 49.
    Shortcomings of thePresent System • Memorization • Scholastic-Oriented • Validity of a Single-stroke Examination • Creation of Fear and Tension • Low Quality of Question Paper • Prevalence of Essay type Question • Subjectivity in Marking • Limited Application of Assessment Techniques
  • 50.
    • Mismanagement ofExaminations • Inappropriate Interpretation of Raw Scores • Non-application of Scaling Techniques • Numerical Marking System Versus Grading • Awarding of Grace Marks • Predominance of the Examination system over the Teaching-learning Process • Lack of Credibility of Public Examinations
  • 51.
    Innovation in ExaminationSystem • Semester System • Continuous and Comprehensive Evaluation (CCE) • Question Banks • Re-evaluation and Returning of Marked Answer Scripts • Multiple Sets of Question Paper • Open Book Examinations • Credit Accumulation and Credit Transfer
  • 52.
    Unit – 16 IssuesRelated to Vocationalization of Secondary Education
  • 53.
    • Need forVocationalization of Secondary Education • Historical Development of Vocationalization of Education • Policy Making in Vocational Education (VE) • Present Status of Vocationalisation at the School • Problems • Issues for the Future
  • 54.
    Need for Vocationalizationof Secondary Education
  • 55.
    Meaning • UNESCO - •Education action to prepare for work and active life
  • 56.
  • 57.
    Merits of Vocationlisationof Education • Education related to productivity • Preparation of individual for jobs • Employment opportunities • Broadening of horizons • Dignity of labour • Maximum utilisation of the material resources of the country
  • 58.
    Historical Development of Vocationalizationof Education • Wood’s Despatch (1854) • Hunter Commission • Hartog Committee (1929) • Sargent Plan (1944) • Mudaliyar Commission (1952-53) • Kothari Commission (1964-66) • Working Group (1985) • National Policy on Education (1986, 1992) • Ramamurthy Committee (1990) • The Current Debate
  • 59.
    Policy Making inVocational Education (VE) • NCERT – National Council for Educational Research and Training • SCERT – State Council of Educational Research and Training • AICTE – All India Council for Technical Education • RDAT – Regional Directorate of Apprenticeship Training • CSTARI – Central Staff Training and Research Institute
  • 60.
    • FTI –Foreman Training Institute • ATI – Advanced Training Institute • ITI – Industrial Training Institute • NCTVT – National Council for Training in Vocational Trades • CAC – Central Apprenticeship Council • DE & T – Directorate of Employment and Training • SCTVT – State Council for Training in Vocational Trades
  • 61.
    Present Status of Vocationalisationat the School • Polytechnics • Industrial Training Institutes (ITTs) • Specialised Institutions and Schools like Technical, Arts and Craft Schools, Agriculture Schools, Forestry Schools, Nursing Schools Commercial Training Schools etc., • Vocational Education at the +2 level within the school system
  • 62.
    Problems • Irrelevance ofcourses leading to a mismatch between the labour market needs and the training skills • Lack of focus on emerging areas of industrial development • Inadequate syllabi being followed in schools and use of obsolete equipment • Inadequate practical training skills acquired by the students which are not useful in practical life
  • 63.
    • Lack ofsocial acceptability • Lack of employment opportunities, and • Overall poor enrolment in vocational stream in such schools
  • 64.
    Issues for theFuture • School-based system of vocational education • Separate vocational institutions • Polytechnics and ITIs – School-based • Polytechnics and ITIs – Industry • Academic Stature of vocational courses
  • 65.