Connect Simulation with Modeling
and Model-Based-Systems Engineering
Connected Engineering
Illustrated by an Electric Drive Development Cycle
1
THE NEW ERA OF
TRANSPORTATION
CONNECTED
ENGINEERING AND
ITS KEY ADVANTAGES
FOR THE PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
ADDRESSING THE
COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE
WITH MODEL-BASED
SYSTEMS ENGINEERING
(MBSE)
THE CHANGING
PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
ENVIRONMENT
ADVANCING PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT WITH
MODELING AND
SIMULATION (MODSIM)
CONNECTED ENGINEERING
AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE
DEVELOPMENT CYCLE
THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE
CONCLUSION
THE NEW ERA OF TRANSPORTATION
The transportation and mobility industry is entering a new era that is efficient, affordable,
clean, and green. The rise of electric vehicles is accompanied by the emergence of new
technologies, like electric powertrains, which need to be integrated in existing technologies
and processes. Therefore, companies must manage increased product and process complexity
while maximizing efficiency and shortening development cycle times to stay competitive.
This reconceptualization forces engineers to deal with new and often conflicting requirements.
It requires seamless collaboration across multiple teams—from conceptualization through
detailed engineering, certification, and manufacturing. In addition, these activities take place
within a dynamic environment: technologies change and new market demands emerge, all
requiring adaptation and response from a global network of teams and remote workers.
New platform-based software solutions can help to map dependencies and interrelations,
finding the fastest and most effective ways to work and coordinate efforts across multiple
teams, domains, and disciplines. This eBook will explore the Connected Engineering approach
delivered within the 3DEXPERIENCE® platform, where Model-Based Systems Engineering
(MBSE) is tightly connected to Modelling and Simulation on one unified platform. It enables
organizations to improve collaboration, foster innovation, and achieve efficient product
development to secure a stronger competitive position. We demonstrate these in the context
of an electric drive development cycle.
Innovating the Products of Tomorrow
Connected Engineering is defined
as a way to connect Modeling
and Simulation, Model-Based
Systems Engineering, and
Collaboration throughout a
company’s ecosystem.
2
THE NEW ERA OF
TRANSPORTATION
CONNECTED
ENGINEERING AND
ITS KEY ADVANTAGES
FOR THE PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
ADDRESSING THE
COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE
WITH MODEL-BASED
SYSTEMS ENGINEERING
(MBSE)
THE CHANGING
PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
ENVIRONMENT
ADVANCING PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT WITH
MODELING AND
SIMULATION (MODSIM)
CONNECTED ENGINEERING
AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE
DEVELOPMENT CYCLE
THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE
CONCLUSION
THE CHANGING PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT ENVIRONMENT
The nature of vehicles is fundamentally changing. The reconceptualization of vehicles from
a mechanical, internal combustion model to a “smart” electric, connected model introduces
a multitude of innovative new technologies. In addition, the vehicle architecture is changing
toward a modular “skateboard,” or mega-platform. These platforms should be scalable,
adaptable, and upgradable to accommodate multiple vehicle types and future technologies.
The need to integrate new and existing systems within a new architecture adds another
layer of complexity to the development process. New approaches are needed to enable
a high level of collaboration and provide optimal information transparency to all process
participants. Current-state practices and tools employed in many companies are inadequate
to effectively meet these challenges. Factors like siloed teams, disconnected tools,
inaccessible information and documentation, uncoordinated processes, and the inability
for individuals and teams to communicate and interact effectively force an undue burden
on teams who, if able to work within an appropriate environment, would be capable of far
greater productivity.
What, then, would a modern, high-performing vehicle development environment look
like? It would necessarily provide ready access to authoritative data, enabling all teams to
work from a continually updated single source of truth. It would also allow companies to
coordinate processes, providing end-to-end connectivity for all team members, regardless of
location. This would enable simplified, direct collaboration between team members through
all stages of the development process.
Innovating the Products of Tomorrow
3
THE NEW ERA OF
TRANSPORTATION
CONNECTED
ENGINEERING AND
ITS KEY ADVANTAGES
FOR THE PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
ADDRESSING THE
COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE
WITH MODEL-BASED
SYSTEMS ENGINEERING
(MBSE)
THE CHANGING
PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
ENVIRONMENT
ADVANCING PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT WITH
MODELING AND
SIMULATION (MODSIM)
CONNECTED ENGINEERING
AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE
DEVELOPMENT CYCLE
THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE
CONCLUSION
ADDRESSING THE COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE WITH MODEL-BASED
SYSTEMS ENGINEERING (MBSE)
Mechatronic systems that combine mechanical, electronic, and software elements, such as electric drive systems, require
a complete system model to simulate the behavior at the earliest stages, ensuring that changes made at the beginning
of development are reflected throughout the process. Model-Based Systems Engineering (MBSE) strives to improve
integration of all engineering disciplines while delivering strategic performance insights from a holistic perspective.
MBSE is the formalized application of modeling to support system requirements, design, analysis, verification and
validation activities beginning in the conceptual design phase and continuing throughout development and later
lifecycle phases.1
MBSE achieves this by permitting information to pass freely across sub-models and between stakeholders to achieve
desired outcomes. The complexities of the development process become more manageable as requirements from
different disciplines can be identified, cross-referenced, and conflicts resolved within a unified framework. Users
gain the ability to test more variants, reveal errors earlier in the process, and shorten development cycles. The risk
of interoperability failures and of costly, time-intensive rework is reduced; the ability to optimize systems’ efficiency
is increased; and all project elements are addressed within this unified environment, providing a holistic view of all
associated activities and attributes.
MBSE delivers the following key benefits:
• Promotes the reuse of complex subsystem models, reducing duplication of work
• Provides traceability, impact analysis, cost analysis, and product change visibility
• Enables effective collaboration between different technological silos
• Enables heightened insight at all stages of the development process, helping to
eliminate errors and accelerate innovation
Innovating the Products of Tomorrow
1
Source: Definition used by: System Modeling and Simulation Working Group (SMSWG), joint INCOSE and NAFEMS initiative
4
THE NEW ERA OF
TRANSPORTATION
CONNECTED
ENGINEERING AND
ITS KEY ADVANTAGES
FOR THE PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
ADDRESSING THE
COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE
WITH MODEL-BASED
SYSTEMS ENGINEERING
(MBSE)
THE CHANGING
PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
ENVIRONMENT
ADVANCING PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT WITH
MODELING AND
SIMULATION (MODSIM)
CONNECTED ENGINEERING
AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE
DEVELOPMENT CYCLE
THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE
CONCLUSION
ADVANCING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT WITH MODELING AND
SIMULATION (MODSIM)
Historically, Computer-Aided Design (CAD) and Computer-Aided Engineering (CAE) emerged as distinct technologies.
While each delivered significant product development benefits, they have remained largely discrete tasks, undertaken
sequentially. The need to translate design data for simulation increases the cycle time required and introduces
opportunity for errors. On the other hand, efficiency is sacrificed as data gained through simulation must then be
reincorporated in a subsequent design iteration to drive design refinements.
MODSIM, the integration of modeling with advanced simulation within a unified environment, magnifies the benefits
of each while accelerating and streamlining the development process. By embedding simulation within the design
process, engineers are empowered to utilize simulation at the earliest stages of design development, checking design
performance and executing refinements concurrently. This way, they minimize the risk of costly redesigns. The need
for data translation between the design and analysis stages is eliminated, and CAE models immediately adapt to design
changes. This facilitates collaboration and parallel development from multiple teams, all of whom are working from
accurate, continuously updated data; changes made in any one area are propagated throughout the model in real time.
The economic benefits of MODSIM become readily apparent, as companies can:
• Reuse models, saving both time and cost
• Accurately predict product behavior in early concept or prototype phases
• Reuse accrued knowledge to eliminate non-value adding tasks and support a steep technological
learning curve
• Reuse physical testing data to improve models and enhance simulation results
• Evaluate alternative concepts quickly, assessing the strengths and weaknesses in each and combining
high-performing aspects of different concepts into new designs
At the same time, MODSIM delivers benefits to an organization’s teams and individual members:
• Integrated modeling and simulation accelerates innovation by providing a holistic view of project data
• Efficiency improvements free up time for team members to pursue additional technical
advancements
• Real-time collaboration enables team members to harness each others’ knowledge and expertise
in order to realize solutions more rapidly and reduce rework
Innovating the Products of Tomorrow
5
THE NEW ERA OF
TRANSPORTATION
CONNECTED
ENGINEERING AND
ITS KEY ADVANTAGES
FOR THE PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
ADDRESSING THE
COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE
WITH MODEL-BASED
SYSTEMS ENGINEERING
(MBSE)
THE CHANGING
PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
ENVIRONMENT
ADVANCING PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT WITH
MODELING AND
SIMULATION (MODSIM)
CONNECTED ENGINEERING
AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE
DEVELOPMENT CYCLE
THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE
CONCLUSION
CONNECTED ENGINEERING (CE) AND ITS KEY ADVANTAGES FOR
THE PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
A true Connected Engineering (CE) environment is much more than merely the introduction of new tools or the
optimization of processes. It is a shift of the entire development environment which fundamentally transforms—
and optimizes—the way work is done and the results that are achieved. Connected Engineering is the creation of an
ecosystem that encompasses and integrates all disciplines, information, tools, and processes. This is the concept of
Connected Engineering practiced within the 3DEXPERIENCE® environment.
A 3DEXPERIENCE® Connected Engineering environment encompasses all of the diverse activities and
multidisciplinary systems necessary for effective product development—Model-Based System Engineering,
Modeling and Simulation (MODSIM), and comprehensive communication and collaboration capabilities—and
breaks down traditional barriers between them. By “connecting the dots” between locations, teams, disciplines,
processes, technologies, and data sets, all necessary work can be done within one unified ecosystem.
Innovating the Products of Tomorrow
3DEXPERIENCE
MBSE
CONNECTED
ENGINEERING
COLLABORATION MODSIM
6
THE NEW ERA OF
TRANSPORTATION
CONNECTED
ENGINEERING AND
ITS KEY ADVANTAGES
FOR THE PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
ADDRESSING THE
COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE
WITH MODEL-BASED
SYSTEMS ENGINEERING
(MBSE)
THE CHANGING
PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
ENVIRONMENT
ADVANCING PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT WITH
MODELING AND
SIMULATION (MODSIM)
CONNECTED ENGINEERING
AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE
DEVELOPMENT CYCLE
THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE
CONCLUSION
Innovating the Products of Tomorrow
Working within a Connected Engineering (CE) environment,
companies and teams realize a broad range of powerful benefits:
• Teams work within a unified, holistic environment with full digital continuity
• The CE environment facilitates complexity management
• Better management of changing requirements—changed data or requirements are automatically
reflected throughout the ecosystem
• Changes made at any point are immediately reflected throughout the development stream
The Connected Engineering approach establishes an environment of digital continuity. It
eliminates the need for data conversions and model importing/exporting, and creates uniform
access to current data. Changes are automatically reflected throughout the environment,
eliminating rework and reconversions: Modifications made “upstream” in the development
process are immediately reflected “downstream.” CE connects the dots between requirements,
design, and simulation, enabling the physical behavior of subsystems and the final product
to be virtually—and continually—evaluated and optimized across multiple domains, enabling
ongoing revision and improvement.
7
THE NEW ERA OF
TRANSPORTATION
CONNECTED
ENGINEERING AND
ITS KEY ADVANTAGES
FOR THE PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
ADDRESSING THE
COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE
WITH MODEL-BASED
SYSTEMS ENGINEERING
(MBSE)
THE CHANGING
PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
ENVIRONMENT
ADVANCING PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT WITH
MODELING AND
SIMULATION (MODSIM)
CONNECTED ENGINEERING
AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE
DEVELOPMENT CYCLE
THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE
CONCLUSION
MBSE
PORTFOLIO
MANAGER
SYSTEM
ARCHITECT
NVH
ENGINEER
DESIGN
EXPERT
E-DRIVE
SPECIALIST
EM
ENGINEER
CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE DEVELOPMENT CYCLE
Electromobility, with its continuous technological advancements and ongoing flow of new stakeholder requirements, requires engineering processes to be managed and mapped with a high level
of interaction and traceability. In particular, electric vehicles with a skateboard architecture and its modular features require a perfect fit of all systems and sub-systems, e.g. the electric drive.
The electric drive development cycle is fundamentally unique, and multiphysical in nature. Engineers need to address intertwining, often conflicting characteristics such as thermal, mechanical,
electromagnetic performance, durability, noise and vibration, and lubrication requirements. Optimal multi-domain objectives need to be defined.
This electric drive development process necessarily requires the committed, cooperative involvement of a multitude of discrete teams, disciplines, and specialties. These include:
Together, they address the project’s requirements, system architecture, design, and validation. They begin by recognizing that since the elements of the electric powertrain
depend on each other, they can’t be developed individually.
Developing a best-in-class electric drive system compels teams to thoroughly analyze a huge number of design options, and to understand the effect of each parameter on varied—and
often conflicting—KPIs. To define the best, most balanced design alternative considering all requirements and goals, it is necessary to map each project stakeholder’s goals, connect them,
and define objectives for each party. Some of the areas of focus include:
• MULTIDISCIPLINARY OPTIMIZATION, balancing the competing needs for electromagnetics, structures, fluids, and acoustics disciplines
Innovating the Products of Tomorrow
8
THE NEW ERA OF
TRANSPORTATION
CONNECTED
ENGINEERING AND
ITS KEY ADVANTAGES
FOR THE PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
ADDRESSING THE
COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE
WITH MODEL-BASED
SYSTEMS ENGINEERING
(MBSE)
THE CHANGING
PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
ENVIRONMENT
ADVANCING PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT WITH
MODELING AND
SIMULATION (MODSIM)
CONNECTED ENGINEERING
AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE
DEVELOPMENT CYCLE
THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE
CONCLUSION
After initial optimization, some requirements still need to be verified by more detailed analyses:
• STRENGTH, STIFFNESS AND DURABILITY, ensuring structural integrity and reliability of all parts
• ELECTROMAGNETIC PERFORMANCE, verifying power, torque, and efficiency requirements as well as limiting the impact of
fault conditions (e.g. on permanent magnet demagnetization; creating loads for thermal and mechanical analyses)
• THERMAL MANAGEMENT, including assessing complex fluid dynamics and heat transfer issues in oil cooling systems, and
sustaining high-power densities with thermal reliability
• NOISE AND VIBRATION MITIGATION to ensure passengers’ acoustic comfort as well as safeguarding the functionality and
reliability of the system
• LUBRICATION for longer service life by ensuring that oil levels provide both sufficient surface coverage and minimum induced
drag torque
By working within a Connected Engineering environment, all experts involved are able to work with the same data set, in real
time, to ensure that all components are designed to function properly within—and as—a system. If requirements change during the
development process, the verification of the system can be quickly redone by utilizing automated workflows. They enable an easy
parameter or design update without requiring manual rework to update simulation models and meshes.
The efficiency and speed gains possible within the Connected Engineering environment permit the rapid execution and analysis
of multiple design iterations before final prototype validation.
Innovating the Products of Tomorrow
MBSE
COLLABORATION
PORTFOLIO
MANAGER
SYSTEM
ARCHITECT
NVH
ENGINEER
DESIGN
EXPERT
E-DRIVE
SPECIALIST
EM
ENGINEER
MODELING
& SIMULATION
INTEGRATION OF
CAD AND CAE
AUTOMATED
WORKFLOWS
MODEL-BASED
SYSTEMS
ENGINEERING
MULTIDISCIPLINARY
OPTIMIZATION
ELECTROMAGNETICS,
STRUCTURES, FLUIDS,
& ACOUSTICS
CONNECTED ENGINEERING
9
THE NEW ERA OF
TRANSPORTATION
CONNECTED
ENGINEERING AND
ITS KEY ADVANTAGES
FOR THE PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
ADDRESSING THE
COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE
WITH MODEL-BASED
SYSTEMS ENGINEERING
(MBSE)
THE CHANGING
PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
ENVIRONMENT
ADVANCING PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT WITH
MODELING AND
SIMULATION (MODSIM)
CONNECTED ENGINEERING
AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE
DEVELOPMENT CYCLE
THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE
CONCLUSION
THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE
The 3DEXPERIENCE® platform is the technically advanced environment needed for optimal development of electric
drive systems. For all of its capabilities and technological sophistication, however, much of the value it delivers is human
rather than technical in nature. Universally accessible, continually updated, responsive data and automated processes
provide value to the people responsible for driving development and innovation. Through CAD/CAE associativity, process
automation in the modeling and simulation workflow, and support for Multiphysics Optimization, the Connected
Engineering environment delivers the following benefits for the electric drive development:
• Capability for optimal communication and collaboration across teams and people, i.e. System Architects, Domain
Experts, Portfolio Managers, Design Experts, and others.
• Confidence in the absolute currency and integrity of project data, including synchronized models for all
disciplines: thermal, mechanical, electromagnetic performance, durability, noise and vibration, and lubrication.
• Reduction in time-consuming, repetitive, non-value-adding tasks is achieved, for example, by CAD-CAE
integration and use of parametric models which dramatically reduce simulation model preparation time and
enable the easy reuse of those models.
• Ability to rapidly iterate designs, modify them, and optimize them. Integrated multiphysics design optimization
of electric machine design, as well as automated complex workflows like noise and vibration analyses, are
examples of this.
• Ease of working within a unified environment where all solutions work seamlessly together.
Beyond the development teams, the availability of accurate, current project data delivers considerable value to managers,
executives, and the project at large. Senior management can make more informed strategic decisions with confidence
as a result of absolute data visibility. Marketing departments, partner firms, vendors, and other stakeholders such as
suppliers can similarly benefit from the increased predictability and reliability of development timelines, progress metrics,
and change notifications which may dictate their actions or require their response. The entire business benefits from a
dramatically shortened product development timeline; the reduced risk of errors, which can result in product defects or
recalls; heightened efficiency; and contained costs—not least from the reduced need for costly physical prototyping.
As the pace of electric vehicle development accelerates, the 3DEXPERIENCE® Connected Engineering environment
is ready to keep pace with it—and empower electric drive developers to deliver on the promise of their innovations
and technologies.
Innovating the Products of Tomorrow
10
THE NEW ERA OF
TRANSPORTATION
CONNECTED
ENGINEERING AND
ITS KEY ADVANTAGES
FOR THE PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
ADDRESSING THE
COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE
WITH MODEL-BASED
SYSTEMS ENGINEERING
(MBSE)
THE CHANGING
PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
ENVIRONMENT
ADVANCING PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT WITH
MODELING AND
SIMULATION (MODSIM)
CONNECTED ENGINEERING
AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE
DEVELOPMENT CYCLE
THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE
CONCLUSION
Our 3DEXPERIENCE® platform powers our brand applications, serving 11 industries, and provides a rich portfolio of industry
solution experiences.
Dassault Systèmes, the 3DEXPERIENCE Company, is a catalyst for human progress. We provide business and people with collaborative virtual environments to imagine sustainable innovations. By creating ‘virtual experience
twins’ of the real world with our 3DEXPERIENCE platform and applications, our customers push the boundaries of innovation, learning and production.
Dassault Systèmes’ 20,000 employees are bringing value to more than 270,000 customers of all sizes, in all industries, in more than 140 countries. For more information, visit www.3ds.com.
©2021
Dassault
Systèmes.
All
rights
reserved.
3DEXPERIENCE,
the
Compass
icon,
the
3DS
logo,
CATIA,
BIOVIA,
GEOVIA,
SOLIDWORKS,
3DVIA,
ENOVIA,
EXALEAD,
NETVIBES,
MEDIDATA,
CENTRIC
PLM,
3DEXCITE,
SIMULIA,
DELMIA,
and
IFWE
are
commercial
trademarks
or
registered
trademarks
of
Dassault
Systèmes,
a
French
“société
européenne”
(Versailles
Commercial
Register
#
B
322
306
440),
or
its
subsidiaries
in
the
United
States
and/or
other
countries.
All
other
trademarks
are
owned
by
their
respective
owners.
Use
of
any
Dassault
Systèmes
or
its
subsidiaries
trademarks
is
subject
to
their
express
written
approval.
Europe/Middle East/Africa
Dassault Systèmes
10, rue Marcel Dassault
CS 40501
78946 Vélizy-Villacoublay Cedex
France
Americas
Dassault Systèmes
175 Wyman Street
Waltham, Massachusetts
02451-1223
USA
Asia-Pacific
Dassault Systèmes K.K.
ThinkPark Tower
2-1-1 Osaki, Shinagawa-ku,
Tokyo 141-6020
Japan
Join our SIMULIA Community and become part of a global user network focused on advancing the use of SIMULIA simulation solutions in
Science and Engineering.
CONNECTED ENGINEERING ILLUSTRATED BY AN ELECTRIC DRIVE DEVELOPMENT CYCLE Watch the demo in our community!
For more information explore our Electric Vehicles pages.
The field of Electromobility is highly dynamic and subject to constant transformation.
Companies need to react quickly, rapidly generating innovations while simultaneously
managingtheassociatedcostandriskfactors.Developingandintegratingnewtechnologies
requires effective collaboration between multiple stakeholders and alignment of the flow
of information.
New, holistic approaches are required in order to integrate all disciplines, information,
tools, and processes. One such approach, provided by the 3DEXPERIENCE® platform. is
Connected Engineering—defined as a way to connect Modeling and Simulation, Model-
Based Systems Engineering, and Collaboration throughout a company’s ecosystem.
Connected Engineering enables companies to manage complexity, gain flexibility, and
increase efficiency throughout the development process, thereby securing a powerful
competitive advantage in the age of Electromobility.
CONCLUSION
11
THE NEW ERA OF
TRANSPORTATION
CONNECTED
ENGINEERING AND
ITS KEY ADVANTAGES
FOR THE PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
ADDRESSING THE
COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE
WITH MODEL-BASED
SYSTEMS ENGINEERING
(MBSE)
THE CHANGING
PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
ENVIRONMENT
ADVANCING PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT WITH
MODELING AND
SIMULATION (MODSIM)
CONNECTED ENGINEERING
AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE
DEVELOPMENT CYCLE
THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE
CONCLUSION

electric-drive-modeling-simulation-systems-engineering-ebook-en.pdf

  • 1.
    Connect Simulation withModeling and Model-Based-Systems Engineering Connected Engineering Illustrated by an Electric Drive Development Cycle 1 THE NEW ERA OF TRANSPORTATION CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND ITS KEY ADVANTAGES FOR THE PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS ADDRESSING THE COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE WITH MODEL-BASED SYSTEMS ENGINEERING (MBSE) THE CHANGING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT ENVIRONMENT ADVANCING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT WITH MODELING AND SIMULATION (MODSIM) CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE DEVELOPMENT CYCLE THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE CONCLUSION
  • 2.
    THE NEW ERAOF TRANSPORTATION The transportation and mobility industry is entering a new era that is efficient, affordable, clean, and green. The rise of electric vehicles is accompanied by the emergence of new technologies, like electric powertrains, which need to be integrated in existing technologies and processes. Therefore, companies must manage increased product and process complexity while maximizing efficiency and shortening development cycle times to stay competitive. This reconceptualization forces engineers to deal with new and often conflicting requirements. It requires seamless collaboration across multiple teams—from conceptualization through detailed engineering, certification, and manufacturing. In addition, these activities take place within a dynamic environment: technologies change and new market demands emerge, all requiring adaptation and response from a global network of teams and remote workers. New platform-based software solutions can help to map dependencies and interrelations, finding the fastest and most effective ways to work and coordinate efforts across multiple teams, domains, and disciplines. This eBook will explore the Connected Engineering approach delivered within the 3DEXPERIENCE® platform, where Model-Based Systems Engineering (MBSE) is tightly connected to Modelling and Simulation on one unified platform. It enables organizations to improve collaboration, foster innovation, and achieve efficient product development to secure a stronger competitive position. We demonstrate these in the context of an electric drive development cycle. Innovating the Products of Tomorrow Connected Engineering is defined as a way to connect Modeling and Simulation, Model-Based Systems Engineering, and Collaboration throughout a company’s ecosystem. 2 THE NEW ERA OF TRANSPORTATION CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND ITS KEY ADVANTAGES FOR THE PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS ADDRESSING THE COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE WITH MODEL-BASED SYSTEMS ENGINEERING (MBSE) THE CHANGING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT ENVIRONMENT ADVANCING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT WITH MODELING AND SIMULATION (MODSIM) CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE DEVELOPMENT CYCLE THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE CONCLUSION
  • 3.
    THE CHANGING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENTENVIRONMENT The nature of vehicles is fundamentally changing. The reconceptualization of vehicles from a mechanical, internal combustion model to a “smart” electric, connected model introduces a multitude of innovative new technologies. In addition, the vehicle architecture is changing toward a modular “skateboard,” or mega-platform. These platforms should be scalable, adaptable, and upgradable to accommodate multiple vehicle types and future technologies. The need to integrate new and existing systems within a new architecture adds another layer of complexity to the development process. New approaches are needed to enable a high level of collaboration and provide optimal information transparency to all process participants. Current-state practices and tools employed in many companies are inadequate to effectively meet these challenges. Factors like siloed teams, disconnected tools, inaccessible information and documentation, uncoordinated processes, and the inability for individuals and teams to communicate and interact effectively force an undue burden on teams who, if able to work within an appropriate environment, would be capable of far greater productivity. What, then, would a modern, high-performing vehicle development environment look like? It would necessarily provide ready access to authoritative data, enabling all teams to work from a continually updated single source of truth. It would also allow companies to coordinate processes, providing end-to-end connectivity for all team members, regardless of location. This would enable simplified, direct collaboration between team members through all stages of the development process. Innovating the Products of Tomorrow 3 THE NEW ERA OF TRANSPORTATION CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND ITS KEY ADVANTAGES FOR THE PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS ADDRESSING THE COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE WITH MODEL-BASED SYSTEMS ENGINEERING (MBSE) THE CHANGING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT ENVIRONMENT ADVANCING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT WITH MODELING AND SIMULATION (MODSIM) CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE DEVELOPMENT CYCLE THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE CONCLUSION
  • 4.
    ADDRESSING THE COMPLEXITYCHALLENGE WITH MODEL-BASED SYSTEMS ENGINEERING (MBSE) Mechatronic systems that combine mechanical, electronic, and software elements, such as electric drive systems, require a complete system model to simulate the behavior at the earliest stages, ensuring that changes made at the beginning of development are reflected throughout the process. Model-Based Systems Engineering (MBSE) strives to improve integration of all engineering disciplines while delivering strategic performance insights from a holistic perspective. MBSE is the formalized application of modeling to support system requirements, design, analysis, verification and validation activities beginning in the conceptual design phase and continuing throughout development and later lifecycle phases.1 MBSE achieves this by permitting information to pass freely across sub-models and between stakeholders to achieve desired outcomes. The complexities of the development process become more manageable as requirements from different disciplines can be identified, cross-referenced, and conflicts resolved within a unified framework. Users gain the ability to test more variants, reveal errors earlier in the process, and shorten development cycles. The risk of interoperability failures and of costly, time-intensive rework is reduced; the ability to optimize systems’ efficiency is increased; and all project elements are addressed within this unified environment, providing a holistic view of all associated activities and attributes. MBSE delivers the following key benefits: • Promotes the reuse of complex subsystem models, reducing duplication of work • Provides traceability, impact analysis, cost analysis, and product change visibility • Enables effective collaboration between different technological silos • Enables heightened insight at all stages of the development process, helping to eliminate errors and accelerate innovation Innovating the Products of Tomorrow 1 Source: Definition used by: System Modeling and Simulation Working Group (SMSWG), joint INCOSE and NAFEMS initiative 4 THE NEW ERA OF TRANSPORTATION CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND ITS KEY ADVANTAGES FOR THE PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS ADDRESSING THE COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE WITH MODEL-BASED SYSTEMS ENGINEERING (MBSE) THE CHANGING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT ENVIRONMENT ADVANCING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT WITH MODELING AND SIMULATION (MODSIM) CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE DEVELOPMENT CYCLE THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE CONCLUSION
  • 5.
    ADVANCING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENTWITH MODELING AND SIMULATION (MODSIM) Historically, Computer-Aided Design (CAD) and Computer-Aided Engineering (CAE) emerged as distinct technologies. While each delivered significant product development benefits, they have remained largely discrete tasks, undertaken sequentially. The need to translate design data for simulation increases the cycle time required and introduces opportunity for errors. On the other hand, efficiency is sacrificed as data gained through simulation must then be reincorporated in a subsequent design iteration to drive design refinements. MODSIM, the integration of modeling with advanced simulation within a unified environment, magnifies the benefits of each while accelerating and streamlining the development process. By embedding simulation within the design process, engineers are empowered to utilize simulation at the earliest stages of design development, checking design performance and executing refinements concurrently. This way, they minimize the risk of costly redesigns. The need for data translation between the design and analysis stages is eliminated, and CAE models immediately adapt to design changes. This facilitates collaboration and parallel development from multiple teams, all of whom are working from accurate, continuously updated data; changes made in any one area are propagated throughout the model in real time. The economic benefits of MODSIM become readily apparent, as companies can: • Reuse models, saving both time and cost • Accurately predict product behavior in early concept or prototype phases • Reuse accrued knowledge to eliminate non-value adding tasks and support a steep technological learning curve • Reuse physical testing data to improve models and enhance simulation results • Evaluate alternative concepts quickly, assessing the strengths and weaknesses in each and combining high-performing aspects of different concepts into new designs At the same time, MODSIM delivers benefits to an organization’s teams and individual members: • Integrated modeling and simulation accelerates innovation by providing a holistic view of project data • Efficiency improvements free up time for team members to pursue additional technical advancements • Real-time collaboration enables team members to harness each others’ knowledge and expertise in order to realize solutions more rapidly and reduce rework Innovating the Products of Tomorrow 5 THE NEW ERA OF TRANSPORTATION CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND ITS KEY ADVANTAGES FOR THE PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS ADDRESSING THE COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE WITH MODEL-BASED SYSTEMS ENGINEERING (MBSE) THE CHANGING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT ENVIRONMENT ADVANCING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT WITH MODELING AND SIMULATION (MODSIM) CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE DEVELOPMENT CYCLE THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE CONCLUSION
  • 6.
    CONNECTED ENGINEERING (CE)AND ITS KEY ADVANTAGES FOR THE PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS A true Connected Engineering (CE) environment is much more than merely the introduction of new tools or the optimization of processes. It is a shift of the entire development environment which fundamentally transforms— and optimizes—the way work is done and the results that are achieved. Connected Engineering is the creation of an ecosystem that encompasses and integrates all disciplines, information, tools, and processes. This is the concept of Connected Engineering practiced within the 3DEXPERIENCE® environment. A 3DEXPERIENCE® Connected Engineering environment encompasses all of the diverse activities and multidisciplinary systems necessary for effective product development—Model-Based System Engineering, Modeling and Simulation (MODSIM), and comprehensive communication and collaboration capabilities—and breaks down traditional barriers between them. By “connecting the dots” between locations, teams, disciplines, processes, technologies, and data sets, all necessary work can be done within one unified ecosystem. Innovating the Products of Tomorrow 3DEXPERIENCE MBSE CONNECTED ENGINEERING COLLABORATION MODSIM 6 THE NEW ERA OF TRANSPORTATION CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND ITS KEY ADVANTAGES FOR THE PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS ADDRESSING THE COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE WITH MODEL-BASED SYSTEMS ENGINEERING (MBSE) THE CHANGING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT ENVIRONMENT ADVANCING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT WITH MODELING AND SIMULATION (MODSIM) CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE DEVELOPMENT CYCLE THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE CONCLUSION
  • 7.
    Innovating the Productsof Tomorrow Working within a Connected Engineering (CE) environment, companies and teams realize a broad range of powerful benefits: • Teams work within a unified, holistic environment with full digital continuity • The CE environment facilitates complexity management • Better management of changing requirements—changed data or requirements are automatically reflected throughout the ecosystem • Changes made at any point are immediately reflected throughout the development stream The Connected Engineering approach establishes an environment of digital continuity. It eliminates the need for data conversions and model importing/exporting, and creates uniform access to current data. Changes are automatically reflected throughout the environment, eliminating rework and reconversions: Modifications made “upstream” in the development process are immediately reflected “downstream.” CE connects the dots between requirements, design, and simulation, enabling the physical behavior of subsystems and the final product to be virtually—and continually—evaluated and optimized across multiple domains, enabling ongoing revision and improvement. 7 THE NEW ERA OF TRANSPORTATION CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND ITS KEY ADVANTAGES FOR THE PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS ADDRESSING THE COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE WITH MODEL-BASED SYSTEMS ENGINEERING (MBSE) THE CHANGING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT ENVIRONMENT ADVANCING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT WITH MODELING AND SIMULATION (MODSIM) CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE DEVELOPMENT CYCLE THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE CONCLUSION
  • 8.
    MBSE PORTFOLIO MANAGER SYSTEM ARCHITECT NVH ENGINEER DESIGN EXPERT E-DRIVE SPECIALIST EM ENGINEER CONNECTED ENGINEERING ANDTHE ELECTRIC DRIVE DEVELOPMENT CYCLE Electromobility, with its continuous technological advancements and ongoing flow of new stakeholder requirements, requires engineering processes to be managed and mapped with a high level of interaction and traceability. In particular, electric vehicles with a skateboard architecture and its modular features require a perfect fit of all systems and sub-systems, e.g. the electric drive. The electric drive development cycle is fundamentally unique, and multiphysical in nature. Engineers need to address intertwining, often conflicting characteristics such as thermal, mechanical, electromagnetic performance, durability, noise and vibration, and lubrication requirements. Optimal multi-domain objectives need to be defined. This electric drive development process necessarily requires the committed, cooperative involvement of a multitude of discrete teams, disciplines, and specialties. These include: Together, they address the project’s requirements, system architecture, design, and validation. They begin by recognizing that since the elements of the electric powertrain depend on each other, they can’t be developed individually. Developing a best-in-class electric drive system compels teams to thoroughly analyze a huge number of design options, and to understand the effect of each parameter on varied—and often conflicting—KPIs. To define the best, most balanced design alternative considering all requirements and goals, it is necessary to map each project stakeholder’s goals, connect them, and define objectives for each party. Some of the areas of focus include: • MULTIDISCIPLINARY OPTIMIZATION, balancing the competing needs for electromagnetics, structures, fluids, and acoustics disciplines Innovating the Products of Tomorrow 8 THE NEW ERA OF TRANSPORTATION CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND ITS KEY ADVANTAGES FOR THE PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS ADDRESSING THE COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE WITH MODEL-BASED SYSTEMS ENGINEERING (MBSE) THE CHANGING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT ENVIRONMENT ADVANCING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT WITH MODELING AND SIMULATION (MODSIM) CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE DEVELOPMENT CYCLE THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE CONCLUSION
  • 9.
    After initial optimization,some requirements still need to be verified by more detailed analyses: • STRENGTH, STIFFNESS AND DURABILITY, ensuring structural integrity and reliability of all parts • ELECTROMAGNETIC PERFORMANCE, verifying power, torque, and efficiency requirements as well as limiting the impact of fault conditions (e.g. on permanent magnet demagnetization; creating loads for thermal and mechanical analyses) • THERMAL MANAGEMENT, including assessing complex fluid dynamics and heat transfer issues in oil cooling systems, and sustaining high-power densities with thermal reliability • NOISE AND VIBRATION MITIGATION to ensure passengers’ acoustic comfort as well as safeguarding the functionality and reliability of the system • LUBRICATION for longer service life by ensuring that oil levels provide both sufficient surface coverage and minimum induced drag torque By working within a Connected Engineering environment, all experts involved are able to work with the same data set, in real time, to ensure that all components are designed to function properly within—and as—a system. If requirements change during the development process, the verification of the system can be quickly redone by utilizing automated workflows. They enable an easy parameter or design update without requiring manual rework to update simulation models and meshes. The efficiency and speed gains possible within the Connected Engineering environment permit the rapid execution and analysis of multiple design iterations before final prototype validation. Innovating the Products of Tomorrow MBSE COLLABORATION PORTFOLIO MANAGER SYSTEM ARCHITECT NVH ENGINEER DESIGN EXPERT E-DRIVE SPECIALIST EM ENGINEER MODELING & SIMULATION INTEGRATION OF CAD AND CAE AUTOMATED WORKFLOWS MODEL-BASED SYSTEMS ENGINEERING MULTIDISCIPLINARY OPTIMIZATION ELECTROMAGNETICS, STRUCTURES, FLUIDS, & ACOUSTICS CONNECTED ENGINEERING 9 THE NEW ERA OF TRANSPORTATION CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND ITS KEY ADVANTAGES FOR THE PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS ADDRESSING THE COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE WITH MODEL-BASED SYSTEMS ENGINEERING (MBSE) THE CHANGING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT ENVIRONMENT ADVANCING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT WITH MODELING AND SIMULATION (MODSIM) CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE DEVELOPMENT CYCLE THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE CONCLUSION
  • 10.
    THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE The3DEXPERIENCE® platform is the technically advanced environment needed for optimal development of electric drive systems. For all of its capabilities and technological sophistication, however, much of the value it delivers is human rather than technical in nature. Universally accessible, continually updated, responsive data and automated processes provide value to the people responsible for driving development and innovation. Through CAD/CAE associativity, process automation in the modeling and simulation workflow, and support for Multiphysics Optimization, the Connected Engineering environment delivers the following benefits for the electric drive development: • Capability for optimal communication and collaboration across teams and people, i.e. System Architects, Domain Experts, Portfolio Managers, Design Experts, and others. • Confidence in the absolute currency and integrity of project data, including synchronized models for all disciplines: thermal, mechanical, electromagnetic performance, durability, noise and vibration, and lubrication. • Reduction in time-consuming, repetitive, non-value-adding tasks is achieved, for example, by CAD-CAE integration and use of parametric models which dramatically reduce simulation model preparation time and enable the easy reuse of those models. • Ability to rapidly iterate designs, modify them, and optimize them. Integrated multiphysics design optimization of electric machine design, as well as automated complex workflows like noise and vibration analyses, are examples of this. • Ease of working within a unified environment where all solutions work seamlessly together. Beyond the development teams, the availability of accurate, current project data delivers considerable value to managers, executives, and the project at large. Senior management can make more informed strategic decisions with confidence as a result of absolute data visibility. Marketing departments, partner firms, vendors, and other stakeholders such as suppliers can similarly benefit from the increased predictability and reliability of development timelines, progress metrics, and change notifications which may dictate their actions or require their response. The entire business benefits from a dramatically shortened product development timeline; the reduced risk of errors, which can result in product defects or recalls; heightened efficiency; and contained costs—not least from the reduced need for costly physical prototyping. As the pace of electric vehicle development accelerates, the 3DEXPERIENCE® Connected Engineering environment is ready to keep pace with it—and empower electric drive developers to deliver on the promise of their innovations and technologies. Innovating the Products of Tomorrow 10 THE NEW ERA OF TRANSPORTATION CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND ITS KEY ADVANTAGES FOR THE PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS ADDRESSING THE COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE WITH MODEL-BASED SYSTEMS ENGINEERING (MBSE) THE CHANGING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT ENVIRONMENT ADVANCING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT WITH MODELING AND SIMULATION (MODSIM) CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE DEVELOPMENT CYCLE THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE CONCLUSION
  • 11.
    Our 3DEXPERIENCE® platformpowers our brand applications, serving 11 industries, and provides a rich portfolio of industry solution experiences. Dassault Systèmes, the 3DEXPERIENCE Company, is a catalyst for human progress. We provide business and people with collaborative virtual environments to imagine sustainable innovations. By creating ‘virtual experience twins’ of the real world with our 3DEXPERIENCE platform and applications, our customers push the boundaries of innovation, learning and production. Dassault Systèmes’ 20,000 employees are bringing value to more than 270,000 customers of all sizes, in all industries, in more than 140 countries. For more information, visit www.3ds.com. ©2021 Dassault Systèmes. All rights reserved. 3DEXPERIENCE, the Compass icon, the 3DS logo, CATIA, BIOVIA, GEOVIA, SOLIDWORKS, 3DVIA, ENOVIA, EXALEAD, NETVIBES, MEDIDATA, CENTRIC PLM, 3DEXCITE, SIMULIA, DELMIA, and IFWE are commercial trademarks or registered trademarks of Dassault Systèmes, a French “société européenne” (Versailles Commercial Register # B 322 306 440), or its subsidiaries in the United States and/or other countries. All other trademarks are owned by their respective owners. Use of any Dassault Systèmes or its subsidiaries trademarks is subject to their express written approval. Europe/Middle East/Africa Dassault Systèmes 10, rue Marcel Dassault CS 40501 78946 Vélizy-Villacoublay Cedex France Americas Dassault Systèmes 175 Wyman Street Waltham, Massachusetts 02451-1223 USA Asia-Pacific Dassault Systèmes K.K. ThinkPark Tower 2-1-1 Osaki, Shinagawa-ku, Tokyo 141-6020 Japan Join our SIMULIA Community and become part of a global user network focused on advancing the use of SIMULIA simulation solutions in Science and Engineering. CONNECTED ENGINEERING ILLUSTRATED BY AN ELECTRIC DRIVE DEVELOPMENT CYCLE Watch the demo in our community! For more information explore our Electric Vehicles pages. The field of Electromobility is highly dynamic and subject to constant transformation. Companies need to react quickly, rapidly generating innovations while simultaneously managingtheassociatedcostandriskfactors.Developingandintegratingnewtechnologies requires effective collaboration between multiple stakeholders and alignment of the flow of information. New, holistic approaches are required in order to integrate all disciplines, information, tools, and processes. One such approach, provided by the 3DEXPERIENCE® platform. is Connected Engineering—defined as a way to connect Modeling and Simulation, Model- Based Systems Engineering, and Collaboration throughout a company’s ecosystem. Connected Engineering enables companies to manage complexity, gain flexibility, and increase efficiency throughout the development process, thereby securing a powerful competitive advantage in the age of Electromobility. CONCLUSION 11 THE NEW ERA OF TRANSPORTATION CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND ITS KEY ADVANTAGES FOR THE PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS ADDRESSING THE COMPLEXITY CHALLENGE WITH MODEL-BASED SYSTEMS ENGINEERING (MBSE) THE CHANGING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT ENVIRONMENT ADVANCING PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT WITH MODELING AND SIMULATION (MODSIM) CONNECTED ENGINEERING AND THE ELECTRIC DRIVE DEVELOPMENT CYCLE THE HUMAN ADVANTAGE CONCLUSION