EPIDEMIOLOGICAL RESEARCH
IN MENTAL HEALTH:
IMPORTANCE, HYSTORICAL
STUDIES, TECHNIQUES AND
PROCESS.
CHAIRED BY DR DIPANJAN BHATTACHARJEE
CO-CHAIRED BY MR KASHTOV PARAJULI
PRESENTING BY MS MRINALINI VISHWAKARMA
DISCUSSING BY MS FATHIMA HASANATH K P
Epidemiology is concerned With Understanding and
controlling disease epidemics by investigating
empirically the associations between
agent โ€“ host โ€“environment.
Agent Environment
Host
WHY MENTAL HEALTH RESEARCH
PROGRAMS ARE NEEDED IN INDIA?
๏ต There is an urgent need to develop specific indicators to monitor the functions, trends and
growth of large scale public mental health initiative.
๏ต Mental health research is required to enhance the technical skills of the primary health care
providers by giving them inputs about various facets of mental illness.
๏ต There has to a better public-private partnership.
๏ต Research is required to support NGO initiatives.
๏ต Research has phenomenal role in increasing public awareness about the commonness of mental
disorders, understandability of mental disorders as illnesses, treat ability, the important of
acceptance by the family and the community and rehabilitation.
๏ต Mental disorders and mental health issues are both universal and local. The roles of the social-
cultural factors are more with regard to mental health issues than in the physical disorders area.
๏ต There is an urgent need to create structures to support the mental health program.
Psychiatric Epidemiology
Psychiatric epidemiology lags behind than other
branches of epidemiology due to
โ€ข Difficulties encountered in conceptualizing
โ€ข Difficulty in diagnosing
โ€ข Difficulty in defining a case
โ€ข Difficulty in sampling
โ€ข Difficulty in selecting an instrument
โ€ข Lack of resources
โ€ข Stigma
MAJOR EPIDEMIOLOGICAL
RESEARCH IN INDIA
Journey started six decades back (1950-60)
โ€ข First psychiatric epidemiological study in India: 1961, Agra By
Dr. K. C. Dube
โ€ข Development of PSE
โ€ข Development of Indian Psychiatric Survey Schedule
(IPSS)
๏ต Initial epidemiological studies in India
Prevalence of psychiatric disorders
โ€ข 9.5 to 370 per 1000 population
Limitation: Wide variation in the prevalence rates
๏ต Landmark International epidemiological studies
โ€ข Epidemiological Catchment Area Program
โ€ข National comorbidity Survey
Limitation: Wide variation in the prevalence rates
Pitfalls in Indian studies
Indian epidemiological studies were
largely inadequate to tap
โ€ข Non-psychotic disorders like panic
disorder, social phobia, obsessive
compulsive disorder, sexual dysfunction,
substance use.
Epidemiological studies in substance
use disorder
๏ต National Household Survey (NHS-Sponsored by the Ministry of Social Justice and
Empowerment (Government of India) and the United Nations Office of Drugs and Crime (UNODC))
๏ต Drug Abuse Monitoring System (DAMS)
๏ต Rapid Assessment Survey (RAS)
๏ต Focussed Thematic Studies (FTS)
๏ต Drug abuse and women in India
๏ต Burden on women through abusing family members
๏ต Drug abuse in rural population
๏ต Drug consumption in border areas
๏ต Drug abuse in prisons
INDIAN PSYCHIATRIC SURVEY
SCHEDULE (IPSS)
๏ต International Pilot Study of Schizophrenia conducted by WHO
๏ต 9 countries (5 developed & 4 developing)
๏ต Indian centre - Agra
๏ต Aim: Feasibility in conducting F/U study
๏ต Assessment: Baseline, 2yr, 5yr
๏ต Drop out at 5yr: 24%
๏ต Conclusion: Outcome of Schizophrenia better in developing
countries than developed countries
DITERMINANTS OF OUTCOME OF
SEVERE MENTAL DISORDERS (DOSMeD)
๏ต Conducted by WHO
๏ต โ€ข 12 centres in 10 countries
๏ต โ€ข Indian centres โ€“ Agra & Chandigarh (rural/urban)
๏ต โ€ข Aim: Prevalence of Schiz & outcome
๏ต โ€ข Follow up: 2 years (80%)
๏ต โ€ข Conclusion: Developing countries had better outcome.
๏ต Indian population โ€“ less time spent in psychotic episode
& less impairment of social functioning
INTERNATIONAL STUDY OF
SCEZOPHRENIA (ISoS)
๏ต Conducted by WHO
๏ต Follow up of cohorts from DOSMeD and RAPyD
(Assessment & Reduction of Psychiatric Disability)
๏ต Cohorts โ€“ Incidence cohorts & Prevalence cohorts
๏ต Incidence cohorts โ€“ 12 from DOSMeD & RAPyD, Hong Kong ,
Madras
๏ต Prevalence cohorts- 3 from IPSS, Beijing
๏ต ICD-8 , 9 diagnoses were converted to ICD-10
INTERNATIONAL STUDY OF
SCEZOPHRENIA (ISoS)
๏ต 3 groups (Schizophrenia only โ€“ F20; other psychotic disorders-
F10.5, F22 to 29, F30 to 34; total psychosis)
๏ต PSE-9, DAS, GAF, SANS, Psychologica Impairement Schedule
used
๏ต Conclusion:
Outcome of schizophrenia is poorest.
No independent role of type of onset.
Percentage of time spent in experiencing psychotic
symptoms in the first 2 years of onset was the best predictor of
outcome.
ICMR- INDIAN COUNSIL OF
MEDICAL RESEARCH
๏ต Centres: Vellore, Madras, Lucknow
๏ต Aim: Course & outcome of F20
๏ต Modified criteria for Schizophrenia used (Modified Feighner
et al.)~ duration 3months instead of 6months.
๏ต Follow up period โ€“ 2 years
๏ต Follow up rate- Madras 86%, Lucknow 85%, Vellore 76%
๏ต Conclusion: Best pattern of course in 45%, worst pattern 10%.
Confirmed the findings of IPSS, DOSMeD.
National Mental Health Survey
โ€ข National Mental Health Survey (NMHS) is
the largest nationwide survey on Mental
health in India.
โ€ข Funded by the Ministry of Health and
Family Welfare, Government of India.
โ€ข Conducted in 12 states of the country
โ€ข National coordinating centre: National
Institute of Mental Health and Neuro
Sciences (NIMHANS), Bangalore, is the
coordinating centre for this survey.
NATIONAL MENTAL HEALTH
SURVEY
Objectives:
๏ต โ€“ Estimate the burden of mental health problems
๏ต โ€“ Identify the gap in human resources & services for mental
health in the country
PREVELANCE
OF MENTAL
DISORDERS
CURRENT TRENDS AND STATUS OF
MHRs.
๏ต Going beyond the medical traditions of individual
diagnosis, treatment and cure, public health
researchers are now focusing on societal approaches
to the promotion of health and the prevention of
disease and injury among diverse populations and
the communities in which they live.
Emphasizes issues such as
๏ถ Improvement and redesign of health services integration and delivery.
๏ถ Prevention programs at schools and worksites.
๏ถ Evaluating and redesigning public and private insurance and funding
mechanisms
๏ถ Outreach and intervention in populations at risk, such as the aged and the
mentally ill
๏ถ Violence and injury prevention
๏ถ Improving the quality of the environments in which people live and work.
๏ถ changing public policies that impact health and health behavior.
๏ต Voluntary and NGOs are taking an active interest in research of various
aspects of mental health.
๏ต The growth of a private sector in psychiatric services, especially in the urban
areas (increase in the numbers of private nursing homes and hospitals,
increase in opportunities for obtaining postgraduate training in psychiatry).
๏ต An increasing number of persons with various minor mental disorders are
beginning to seek mental health care services. The special needs of certain
categories of the population such as children, the aged, women and the rural
underprivileged have been recognized.
๏ต With the current rapid urbanization and economic liberalization in the
country and the resultant social change the demand for mental health
services is only likely to increase.
EPIDEMIOLOGY OF MENTAL HELATH
PROBLEMS IN COVID 19
๏ต Studies have shown that the general population who had been experiencing different levels
of psychosocial stressors amid the COVID-19 pandemic had developed mental health
problems.
๏ต A fear of ongoing outbreak, susceptibility to infection, exposure, or close contact with
someone with COVID-19 affected mental health and wellbeing among the general
population.
๏ต Individuals with COVID-19 diagnosis had profound psychological distress, anxiety,
depression, and other mental health problems compared to those who were not infected.
๏ต This illustrates the fear of adverse health outcomes due to COVID-19 may have affected
mental health, which also highlights the mental health aspect of a physical health problem
among those individuals.
FUTURE OF EPIDEMIOLOGICAL
STUDIES
๏ต Major advances in descriptive psychiatric epidemiology in recent years include
the development of reliable and valid fully structured diagnostic interviews, the
implementation of parallel cross-national surveys of the prevalence and
correlates of mental disorders, and the initiation of research in clinical
epidemiology. Remaining challenges include the refinement of diagnostic
categories and criteria, recognition and evaluation of systematic underreporting
bias in surveys of mental disorders, creation and use of accurate assessment
tools for studying disorders of children, adolescents, the elderly, and people in
less developed countries, and setting up systems to carry out small area
estimations for needs assessment and program planning.
๏ต A major challenge for psychiatric epidemiologists is to
increase the relevance of their analytical research to their
colleagues in preventative psychiatry as well as to social
policy analysts.
๏ต Another challenge is to develop interventions aimed at
increasing the proportion of people with mental disorders
who receive treatment.
๏ต Despite encouraging advances, much work still needs to be
conducted before psychiatric epidemiology can realize its
potential to improve the mental health of populations.
CONCLUSION
Mental health problems constitute a wide spectrum ranging from sub-clinical
states to very severe forms of disorders. Majority of the epidemiological studies
focused on visible mental health problems. Invisible mental health problems
continue to remain unexplored and unaddressed. Mental healthcare priorities need
to be shifted from psychotic disorders to common mental disorders and from
mental hospitals to primary health centres. Increase in invisible mental health
problems such as suicidal attempts, aggression and violence, widespread use of
tobacco, alcohol and other drugs, increasing marital discord and divorce rates
emphasize the need to prioritize and make a paradigm shift in the strategies to
promote and provide appropriate mental health services.
REFERENCES
๏ต Baumeister, H., & Hรคrter, M. (2007). Prevalence of mental disorders based on general
population surveys. Social psychiatry and psychiatric epidemiology, 42(7), 537-546.
๏ต Borges, G., Medina-Mora, M. E., & Lรณpez-Moreno, S. (2004). The role of epidemiology in
mental disorder research. Salud Pรบblica de Mรฉxico, 46(5), 451-463.
๏ต Dohrenwend, B. P. (1998). A psychosocial perspective on the past and future of psychiatric
epidemiology. American journal of epidemiology, 147(3), 222-231.
๏ต Hossain, M. M., Tasnim, S., Sultana, A., Faizah, F., Mazumder, H., Zou, L., ... & Ma, P. (2020).
Epidemiology of mental health problems in COVID-19: a review. F1000Research, 9.
๏ต Lee, Y. M., & Lee, E. S. (2005). International Trends of Psychiatric Epidemiology. Psychiatry
Investigation, 2(1), 14-21.
REFERENCES
๏ต Leff, J., Sartorius, N., Jablensky, A., Korten, A., & Ernberg, G. (1992). The International
Pilot Study of Schizophrenia: five-year follow-up findings. Psychological medicine, 22(1),
131-145.
๏ต Math, S. B., & Srinivasaraju, R. (2010). Indian Psychiatric epidemiological studies:
Learning from the past. Indian journal of psychiatry, 52(Suppl1), S95.
๏ต Reddy, V. M., & Chandrashekar, C. R. (1998). Prevalence of mental and behavioural
disorders in India: A meta-analysis. Indian journal of psychiatry, 40(2), 149.
๏ต Sartorius, N., Shapiro, R., & Jablensky, A. (1974). The international pilot study of
schizophrenia. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 1(11), 21.
๏ต Shepherd, M., & Cooper, B. (1964). Epidemiology and mental disorder: a review. Journal
of neurology, neurosurgery, and psychiatry, 27(4), 277.

EPIDEMIOLOGical research in mental health.pptx

  • 1.
    EPIDEMIOLOGICAL RESEARCH IN MENTALHEALTH: IMPORTANCE, HYSTORICAL STUDIES, TECHNIQUES AND PROCESS. CHAIRED BY DR DIPANJAN BHATTACHARJEE CO-CHAIRED BY MR KASHTOV PARAJULI PRESENTING BY MS MRINALINI VISHWAKARMA DISCUSSING BY MS FATHIMA HASANATH K P
  • 2.
    Epidemiology is concernedWith Understanding and controlling disease epidemics by investigating empirically the associations between agent โ€“ host โ€“environment. Agent Environment Host
  • 3.
    WHY MENTAL HEALTHRESEARCH PROGRAMS ARE NEEDED IN INDIA? ๏ต There is an urgent need to develop specific indicators to monitor the functions, trends and growth of large scale public mental health initiative. ๏ต Mental health research is required to enhance the technical skills of the primary health care providers by giving them inputs about various facets of mental illness. ๏ต There has to a better public-private partnership. ๏ต Research is required to support NGO initiatives. ๏ต Research has phenomenal role in increasing public awareness about the commonness of mental disorders, understandability of mental disorders as illnesses, treat ability, the important of acceptance by the family and the community and rehabilitation. ๏ต Mental disorders and mental health issues are both universal and local. The roles of the social- cultural factors are more with regard to mental health issues than in the physical disorders area. ๏ต There is an urgent need to create structures to support the mental health program.
  • 4.
    Psychiatric Epidemiology Psychiatric epidemiologylags behind than other branches of epidemiology due to โ€ข Difficulties encountered in conceptualizing โ€ข Difficulty in diagnosing โ€ข Difficulty in defining a case โ€ข Difficulty in sampling โ€ข Difficulty in selecting an instrument โ€ข Lack of resources โ€ข Stigma
  • 5.
    MAJOR EPIDEMIOLOGICAL RESEARCH ININDIA Journey started six decades back (1950-60) โ€ข First psychiatric epidemiological study in India: 1961, Agra By Dr. K. C. Dube โ€ข Development of PSE โ€ข Development of Indian Psychiatric Survey Schedule (IPSS)
  • 6.
    ๏ต Initial epidemiologicalstudies in India Prevalence of psychiatric disorders โ€ข 9.5 to 370 per 1000 population Limitation: Wide variation in the prevalence rates ๏ต Landmark International epidemiological studies โ€ข Epidemiological Catchment Area Program โ€ข National comorbidity Survey Limitation: Wide variation in the prevalence rates
  • 8.
    Pitfalls in Indianstudies Indian epidemiological studies were largely inadequate to tap โ€ข Non-psychotic disorders like panic disorder, social phobia, obsessive compulsive disorder, sexual dysfunction, substance use.
  • 9.
    Epidemiological studies insubstance use disorder ๏ต National Household Survey (NHS-Sponsored by the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment (Government of India) and the United Nations Office of Drugs and Crime (UNODC)) ๏ต Drug Abuse Monitoring System (DAMS) ๏ต Rapid Assessment Survey (RAS) ๏ต Focussed Thematic Studies (FTS) ๏ต Drug abuse and women in India ๏ต Burden on women through abusing family members ๏ต Drug abuse in rural population ๏ต Drug consumption in border areas ๏ต Drug abuse in prisons
  • 11.
    INDIAN PSYCHIATRIC SURVEY SCHEDULE(IPSS) ๏ต International Pilot Study of Schizophrenia conducted by WHO ๏ต 9 countries (5 developed & 4 developing) ๏ต Indian centre - Agra ๏ต Aim: Feasibility in conducting F/U study ๏ต Assessment: Baseline, 2yr, 5yr ๏ต Drop out at 5yr: 24% ๏ต Conclusion: Outcome of Schizophrenia better in developing countries than developed countries
  • 12.
    DITERMINANTS OF OUTCOMEOF SEVERE MENTAL DISORDERS (DOSMeD) ๏ต Conducted by WHO ๏ต โ€ข 12 centres in 10 countries ๏ต โ€ข Indian centres โ€“ Agra & Chandigarh (rural/urban) ๏ต โ€ข Aim: Prevalence of Schiz & outcome ๏ต โ€ข Follow up: 2 years (80%) ๏ต โ€ข Conclusion: Developing countries had better outcome. ๏ต Indian population โ€“ less time spent in psychotic episode & less impairment of social functioning
  • 13.
    INTERNATIONAL STUDY OF SCEZOPHRENIA(ISoS) ๏ต Conducted by WHO ๏ต Follow up of cohorts from DOSMeD and RAPyD (Assessment & Reduction of Psychiatric Disability) ๏ต Cohorts โ€“ Incidence cohorts & Prevalence cohorts ๏ต Incidence cohorts โ€“ 12 from DOSMeD & RAPyD, Hong Kong , Madras ๏ต Prevalence cohorts- 3 from IPSS, Beijing ๏ต ICD-8 , 9 diagnoses were converted to ICD-10
  • 14.
    INTERNATIONAL STUDY OF SCEZOPHRENIA(ISoS) ๏ต 3 groups (Schizophrenia only โ€“ F20; other psychotic disorders- F10.5, F22 to 29, F30 to 34; total psychosis) ๏ต PSE-9, DAS, GAF, SANS, Psychologica Impairement Schedule used ๏ต Conclusion: Outcome of schizophrenia is poorest. No independent role of type of onset. Percentage of time spent in experiencing psychotic symptoms in the first 2 years of onset was the best predictor of outcome.
  • 15.
    ICMR- INDIAN COUNSILOF MEDICAL RESEARCH ๏ต Centres: Vellore, Madras, Lucknow ๏ต Aim: Course & outcome of F20 ๏ต Modified criteria for Schizophrenia used (Modified Feighner et al.)~ duration 3months instead of 6months. ๏ต Follow up period โ€“ 2 years ๏ต Follow up rate- Madras 86%, Lucknow 85%, Vellore 76% ๏ต Conclusion: Best pattern of course in 45%, worst pattern 10%. Confirmed the findings of IPSS, DOSMeD.
  • 16.
    National Mental HealthSurvey โ€ข National Mental Health Survey (NMHS) is the largest nationwide survey on Mental health in India. โ€ข Funded by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India. โ€ข Conducted in 12 states of the country โ€ข National coordinating centre: National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro Sciences (NIMHANS), Bangalore, is the coordinating centre for this survey.
  • 17.
    NATIONAL MENTAL HEALTH SURVEY Objectives: ๏ตโ€“ Estimate the burden of mental health problems ๏ต โ€“ Identify the gap in human resources & services for mental health in the country
  • 18.
  • 19.
    CURRENT TRENDS ANDSTATUS OF MHRs. ๏ต Going beyond the medical traditions of individual diagnosis, treatment and cure, public health researchers are now focusing on societal approaches to the promotion of health and the prevention of disease and injury among diverse populations and the communities in which they live.
  • 20.
    Emphasizes issues suchas ๏ถ Improvement and redesign of health services integration and delivery. ๏ถ Prevention programs at schools and worksites. ๏ถ Evaluating and redesigning public and private insurance and funding mechanisms ๏ถ Outreach and intervention in populations at risk, such as the aged and the mentally ill ๏ถ Violence and injury prevention ๏ถ Improving the quality of the environments in which people live and work. ๏ถ changing public policies that impact health and health behavior.
  • 21.
    ๏ต Voluntary andNGOs are taking an active interest in research of various aspects of mental health. ๏ต The growth of a private sector in psychiatric services, especially in the urban areas (increase in the numbers of private nursing homes and hospitals, increase in opportunities for obtaining postgraduate training in psychiatry). ๏ต An increasing number of persons with various minor mental disorders are beginning to seek mental health care services. The special needs of certain categories of the population such as children, the aged, women and the rural underprivileged have been recognized. ๏ต With the current rapid urbanization and economic liberalization in the country and the resultant social change the demand for mental health services is only likely to increase.
  • 22.
    EPIDEMIOLOGY OF MENTALHELATH PROBLEMS IN COVID 19 ๏ต Studies have shown that the general population who had been experiencing different levels of psychosocial stressors amid the COVID-19 pandemic had developed mental health problems. ๏ต A fear of ongoing outbreak, susceptibility to infection, exposure, or close contact with someone with COVID-19 affected mental health and wellbeing among the general population. ๏ต Individuals with COVID-19 diagnosis had profound psychological distress, anxiety, depression, and other mental health problems compared to those who were not infected. ๏ต This illustrates the fear of adverse health outcomes due to COVID-19 may have affected mental health, which also highlights the mental health aspect of a physical health problem among those individuals.
  • 23.
    FUTURE OF EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDIES ๏ตMajor advances in descriptive psychiatric epidemiology in recent years include the development of reliable and valid fully structured diagnostic interviews, the implementation of parallel cross-national surveys of the prevalence and correlates of mental disorders, and the initiation of research in clinical epidemiology. Remaining challenges include the refinement of diagnostic categories and criteria, recognition and evaluation of systematic underreporting bias in surveys of mental disorders, creation and use of accurate assessment tools for studying disorders of children, adolescents, the elderly, and people in less developed countries, and setting up systems to carry out small area estimations for needs assessment and program planning.
  • 24.
    ๏ต A majorchallenge for psychiatric epidemiologists is to increase the relevance of their analytical research to their colleagues in preventative psychiatry as well as to social policy analysts. ๏ต Another challenge is to develop interventions aimed at increasing the proportion of people with mental disorders who receive treatment. ๏ต Despite encouraging advances, much work still needs to be conducted before psychiatric epidemiology can realize its potential to improve the mental health of populations.
  • 25.
    CONCLUSION Mental health problemsconstitute a wide spectrum ranging from sub-clinical states to very severe forms of disorders. Majority of the epidemiological studies focused on visible mental health problems. Invisible mental health problems continue to remain unexplored and unaddressed. Mental healthcare priorities need to be shifted from psychotic disorders to common mental disorders and from mental hospitals to primary health centres. Increase in invisible mental health problems such as suicidal attempts, aggression and violence, widespread use of tobacco, alcohol and other drugs, increasing marital discord and divorce rates emphasize the need to prioritize and make a paradigm shift in the strategies to promote and provide appropriate mental health services.
  • 26.
    REFERENCES ๏ต Baumeister, H.,& Hรคrter, M. (2007). Prevalence of mental disorders based on general population surveys. Social psychiatry and psychiatric epidemiology, 42(7), 537-546. ๏ต Borges, G., Medina-Mora, M. E., & Lรณpez-Moreno, S. (2004). The role of epidemiology in mental disorder research. Salud Pรบblica de Mรฉxico, 46(5), 451-463. ๏ต Dohrenwend, B. P. (1998). A psychosocial perspective on the past and future of psychiatric epidemiology. American journal of epidemiology, 147(3), 222-231. ๏ต Hossain, M. M., Tasnim, S., Sultana, A., Faizah, F., Mazumder, H., Zou, L., ... & Ma, P. (2020). Epidemiology of mental health problems in COVID-19: a review. F1000Research, 9. ๏ต Lee, Y. M., & Lee, E. S. (2005). International Trends of Psychiatric Epidemiology. Psychiatry Investigation, 2(1), 14-21.
  • 27.
    REFERENCES ๏ต Leff, J.,Sartorius, N., Jablensky, A., Korten, A., & Ernberg, G. (1992). The International Pilot Study of Schizophrenia: five-year follow-up findings. Psychological medicine, 22(1), 131-145. ๏ต Math, S. B., & Srinivasaraju, R. (2010). Indian Psychiatric epidemiological studies: Learning from the past. Indian journal of psychiatry, 52(Suppl1), S95. ๏ต Reddy, V. M., & Chandrashekar, C. R. (1998). Prevalence of mental and behavioural disorders in India: A meta-analysis. Indian journal of psychiatry, 40(2), 149. ๏ต Sartorius, N., Shapiro, R., & Jablensky, A. (1974). The international pilot study of schizophrenia. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 1(11), 21. ๏ต Shepherd, M., & Cooper, B. (1964). Epidemiology and mental disorder: a review. Journal of neurology, neurosurgery, and psychiatry, 27(4), 277.