The science of genomics and
livestock genetic improvement
Dirk Jan de Koning, Getinet Mekuriaw Tarekegn &
Erling Strandberg
Department of Animal Breeding and Genetics, SLU
Dj.de-koning@slu.se
Advances from breeding in the
devloped world
Species Trait 60s 2005 %-
increase
Broilers Days till 2 kg 100 40 60
Fillet, % 12 20 67
FCR 3,0 1,7 43
Layers Eggs/year 230 300 30
Eggs/ 1000 kg feed 5000 9000 80
Source: Table 1 i Van der Steen et al. J. Anim. Sci. 2005. 83:E1-E8
woodleywonderworks under Creative Commons
Thanks to plant and animal
breeding
60s 2005 Reduced
acreage
Feed(kg) Ha Feed
(kg)
Ha
1000 kg lean
pork
11750 6,5 5880 2,6 2,5x
1000 kg broiler
meat
3000 1,7 1700 0,37 4,6x
10000 eggs 2000 1,1 1111 0,24 4,6x
Creative Commons: Neil Palmer Creative Commons: woodleywonderworks Creative Commons: jere-me/
The observed trait is sum of many genes
and environmental factors
Complex Traits
Classical model
Genotype
environment
Phenotype
Genomics Era Model
Phenotype
Environment
QTL
QTL
QTL
QTL
QTL
QTL
Genotype
Marker Assisted Selection
Accelerate genetic progress
Measure DNA Markers early in life
Even in embryos
Sex limited traits
Milk
Litter size
Traits measured in relatives
Meat quality traits!
Three starting points for MAS
Ease of
Detection Use
Functional mutations
- known genes
Q
q
M
m
Q
q
Markers in pop.-wide LD
with functional mutation
Markers in pop.-wide LE
with functional mutation
Q
q
M
m
genes
GAS
LD-markers
LD-MAS
LE-markers
LE-MAS
Genomic Selection
Phenotype
Environment
Q
T
L
Q
T
L
Q
T
L
Q
T
L
Q
T
L
Q
TL
Q
T
L
Q
TL
Q
TL
Q
T
L
Q
T
L
Q
T
L
Q
T
L
Q
T
L
Q
T
L
QTL
QTL
QTL
QTL
QTL
Whole genome
SNP genotypes
A better Black box
Genomic Selection
MAS
• Find QTL or genes and
select specifically for
favourable alleles
• Need strategy to
combine with EBV
• LE-MAS computationally
intensive
• LE-MAS has major
genotyping requirements
Genomic Selection
• Estimate effects
across all markers
and select on the
sum of effects
• Replaces EBV
• Can be very
computationally
intensive
• Major genotyping
requirements
Genomic Selection: Accuracy
Very important when considering Genomic
Selection:
What accuracy can I achieve?
How many animals do I need for training?
How many markers do I need?
What is the cost-benefit ratio?
Genomic Selection: A little
example
Livestock state of play
Generation intervals reduced dramatically
Sires for bulls: ~7 => 2,5 years
Dams for bulls: 4 => 2,5 years
Selection differentials quite constant
Genetic trends improved a lot
Genetic gains increased
50-100% for yield traits
3x – 4x for traits with low heritability
International efforts for tricky
traits
Some traits are very expensive or difficult to measure. For
example methane emission and individual feed intake.
Large collaborations: each country (including Sweden)
measures a number of cows
Concern: genetic differences and GxE
Genomic Selection
• Has doubled genetic progress for yield traits in dairy, 2-4-
fold improvement for health traits!
• Other species following suit.
• Special case for crossbreeding species.
• Crop breeding has been turned on its head by genomic
selection
• How do we deliver the benefits of modern breeding to
low-income countries?
• Faster in crops because seeds are easily stored and distributed!
Options for genomic selection in
low income countries
• Nucleus breeding programs
• Centrally organized
• Generic breeding goal
• Good potential for species like poultry
• Community based breeding programs
• Locally organized
• Use locally adapted genetic resources
• May struggle to get suitable reference population
• Any participatory approach needs immediate benefits for
the participating farmers: not in the future.
Current examples
• African Dairy Genetics Gains
• Funded by ‘GATES’ foundation
• Strong stakeholder involvement
• Farmers submit data to the ADGG platform
• Farmers receive feedback via iCOW:
=> 3 SMS/week
 Drip feeding manuals to farmers
 Mainly improved farm health
• IlRI’s Livestock Genetics program: LiveGene
Useful links
Misperceptions about livestock:
https://www.slideshare.net/ILRI/extinction-livestock-
smithoct17
TED talk on ADGG:
https://africadgg.wordpress.com/2018/02/09/livestock-
genetics-program-works-with-farmers-to-boost-nutrition-in-
africa/
B3 Africa:
http://www.b3africa.org/

The science of genomics and livestock genetic improvement

  • 1.
    The science ofgenomics and livestock genetic improvement Dirk Jan de Koning, Getinet Mekuriaw Tarekegn & Erling Strandberg Department of Animal Breeding and Genetics, SLU [email protected]
  • 2.
    Advances from breedingin the devloped world Species Trait 60s 2005 %- increase Broilers Days till 2 kg 100 40 60 Fillet, % 12 20 67 FCR 3,0 1,7 43 Layers Eggs/year 230 300 30 Eggs/ 1000 kg feed 5000 9000 80 Source: Table 1 i Van der Steen et al. J. Anim. Sci. 2005. 83:E1-E8 woodleywonderworks under Creative Commons
  • 3.
    Thanks to plantand animal breeding 60s 2005 Reduced acreage Feed(kg) Ha Feed (kg) Ha 1000 kg lean pork 11750 6,5 5880 2,6 2,5x 1000 kg broiler meat 3000 1,7 1700 0,37 4,6x 10000 eggs 2000 1,1 1111 0,24 4,6x Creative Commons: Neil Palmer Creative Commons: woodleywonderworks Creative Commons: jere-me/
  • 4.
    The observed traitis sum of many genes and environmental factors Complex Traits
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
    Marker Assisted Selection Accelerategenetic progress Measure DNA Markers early in life Even in embryos Sex limited traits Milk Litter size Traits measured in relatives Meat quality traits!
  • 8.
    Three starting pointsfor MAS Ease of Detection Use Functional mutations - known genes Q q M m Q q Markers in pop.-wide LD with functional mutation Markers in pop.-wide LE with functional mutation Q q M m genes GAS LD-markers LD-MAS LE-markers LE-MAS
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
    MAS • Find QTLor genes and select specifically for favourable alleles • Need strategy to combine with EBV • LE-MAS computationally intensive • LE-MAS has major genotyping requirements Genomic Selection • Estimate effects across all markers and select on the sum of effects • Replaces EBV • Can be very computationally intensive • Major genotyping requirements
  • 12.
    Genomic Selection: Accuracy Veryimportant when considering Genomic Selection: What accuracy can I achieve? How many animals do I need for training? How many markers do I need? What is the cost-benefit ratio?
  • 13.
    Genomic Selection: Alittle example
  • 14.
  • 16.
    Generation intervals reduceddramatically Sires for bulls: ~7 => 2,5 years Dams for bulls: 4 => 2,5 years Selection differentials quite constant Genetic trends improved a lot Genetic gains increased 50-100% for yield traits 3x – 4x for traits with low heritability
  • 19.
    International efforts fortricky traits Some traits are very expensive or difficult to measure. For example methane emission and individual feed intake. Large collaborations: each country (including Sweden) measures a number of cows Concern: genetic differences and GxE
  • 20.
    Genomic Selection • Hasdoubled genetic progress for yield traits in dairy, 2-4- fold improvement for health traits! • Other species following suit. • Special case for crossbreeding species. • Crop breeding has been turned on its head by genomic selection • How do we deliver the benefits of modern breeding to low-income countries? • Faster in crops because seeds are easily stored and distributed!
  • 21.
    Options for genomicselection in low income countries • Nucleus breeding programs • Centrally organized • Generic breeding goal • Good potential for species like poultry • Community based breeding programs • Locally organized • Use locally adapted genetic resources • May struggle to get suitable reference population • Any participatory approach needs immediate benefits for the participating farmers: not in the future.
  • 22.
    Current examples • AfricanDairy Genetics Gains • Funded by ‘GATES’ foundation • Strong stakeholder involvement • Farmers submit data to the ADGG platform • Farmers receive feedback via iCOW: => 3 SMS/week  Drip feeding manuals to farmers  Mainly improved farm health • IlRI’s Livestock Genetics program: LiveGene
  • 24.
    Useful links Misperceptions aboutlivestock: https://www.slideshare.net/ILRI/extinction-livestock- smithoct17 TED talk on ADGG: https://africadgg.wordpress.com/2018/02/09/livestock- genetics-program-works-with-farmers-to-boost-nutrition-in- africa/ B3 Africa: http://www.b3africa.org/