Evaluation Essay Infographic:
Evaluation of Dune
Part 1-2
Aidan Blanchette
Professor Smith
ENG 101: College Writing
24 October 2025
Summary of major Points
Dune: Part 1-2
A Modern Masterpiece
In Dune: Part One, Religious psychology
surfaces immediately. Establishing Dune as a
dark science fiction epic.
When House Atreides enters Arrakeen the visual
design creates an immersive world of vast sacred
deserts.
Paul’s prophecy is not providence but
manufactured. His powers are enforced by his
Bene Gesserit mother, creating internal family
drama.
The Harkonnen betrayal transforms the dark
tension into weaponized religion. The night
assault sequence solidifies Dune’s tone.
1
3
Faith becomes both a force that both frees and
enslaves. Paul’s rise as “Muad’Dib” is equally part
triumph and tragedy.
Paul’s eventual ascension brings a holy war.
Transforming the hero into a warning about the
corruption of power and the danger of
charismatic leadership.
5
2
4
6
Overview of Story Elements
Worldbuilding
Villeneuve’s Dune captures Herbert’s
dark religious atmosphere through
cinematography.
Theme
The struggle between destiny and choice reveals itself
as Paul is torn between being the Fremen “savior” and
recognizing that their faith has become "A war in his
name.”
Design
Restraint, scale, and spectacle,
make Dune’s visual storytelling a
masterclass in immersion.
Message
Dune warns that power, belief, and
charismatic leaders are inherently
dangerous.
Works Cited
● Huddleston, Tom. "Dune v Dune: Do Denis Villeneuve's Films Stay True to the Book?" Support the Guardian, 28
Feb. 2024, www.theguardian.com/film/2024/feb/28/dune-denis-villeneuve-films-book-frank-herbert?
● Price, Brennan. "'Dune: Part 2' (2024) review: A modern masterpiece." Review of Dune: Part 2, 2024. Campus
Times, 3 Mar. 2024, www.campustimes.org/. Accessed 2025.
● Selcke, Dan. "J.R.R. Tolkien Disliked Dune 'With Some Intensity.'" Winter Is Coming, 19 Feb. 2020,
winteriscoming.net/2020/02/19/jrr-tolkien-lord-of-the-rings-disliked-dune-intensity/.
● Talib, Morayo. "Politics, Religion, and Water: The Ecology of 'Dune.'" What Kept Me up, 31 Dec. 2021,
whatkeptmeup.com/nigerian-film-industry-articles/politics-religion-and-water-the-ecology-of-dune/.
● Watkins, TanChun. "J.R.R. Tolkien Absolutely Hated 'Dune' — but Why?" Collider, 10 Apr. 2025,
collider.com/tolkien-hated-dune-why/.

Evaluation Infographic of Dune: Part 1-2

  • 1.
    Evaluation Essay Infographic: Evaluationof Dune Part 1-2 Aidan Blanchette Professor Smith ENG 101: College Writing 24 October 2025
  • 2.
    Summary of majorPoints Dune: Part 1-2 A Modern Masterpiece In Dune: Part One, Religious psychology surfaces immediately. Establishing Dune as a dark science fiction epic. When House Atreides enters Arrakeen the visual design creates an immersive world of vast sacred deserts. Paul’s prophecy is not providence but manufactured. His powers are enforced by his Bene Gesserit mother, creating internal family drama. The Harkonnen betrayal transforms the dark tension into weaponized religion. The night assault sequence solidifies Dune’s tone. 1 3 Faith becomes both a force that both frees and enslaves. Paul’s rise as “Muad’Dib” is equally part triumph and tragedy. Paul’s eventual ascension brings a holy war. Transforming the hero into a warning about the corruption of power and the danger of charismatic leadership. 5 2 4 6
  • 3.
    Overview of StoryElements Worldbuilding Villeneuve’s Dune captures Herbert’s dark religious atmosphere through cinematography. Theme The struggle between destiny and choice reveals itself as Paul is torn between being the Fremen “savior” and recognizing that their faith has become "A war in his name.” Design Restraint, scale, and spectacle, make Dune’s visual storytelling a masterclass in immersion. Message Dune warns that power, belief, and charismatic leaders are inherently dangerous.
  • 4.
    Works Cited ● Huddleston,Tom. "Dune v Dune: Do Denis Villeneuve's Films Stay True to the Book?" Support the Guardian, 28 Feb. 2024, www.theguardian.com/film/2024/feb/28/dune-denis-villeneuve-films-book-frank-herbert? ● Price, Brennan. "'Dune: Part 2' (2024) review: A modern masterpiece." Review of Dune: Part 2, 2024. Campus Times, 3 Mar. 2024, www.campustimes.org/. Accessed 2025. ● Selcke, Dan. "J.R.R. Tolkien Disliked Dune 'With Some Intensity.'" Winter Is Coming, 19 Feb. 2020, winteriscoming.net/2020/02/19/jrr-tolkien-lord-of-the-rings-disliked-dune-intensity/. ● Talib, Morayo. "Politics, Religion, and Water: The Ecology of 'Dune.'" What Kept Me up, 31 Dec. 2021, whatkeptmeup.com/nigerian-film-industry-articles/politics-religion-and-water-the-ecology-of-dune/. ● Watkins, TanChun. "J.R.R. Tolkien Absolutely Hated 'Dune' — but Why?" Collider, 10 Apr. 2025, collider.com/tolkien-hated-dune-why/.