Experiential Learning and
Community Economic Development
in Appalachian Communities: A
Teaching Note
Peter H. Hackbert, Berea College
Academy of Business Research
September 13-15, 2011
Atlantic City, New Jersey
Agenda
Background
Review of the Literature
4 Key Concepts
Methods
Results
Source: AAC&U College Learning For
the New Global Century
Tina L. Seelig, Stanford Technology Venture Program, “Can
Entrepreneurship be Taught?” Endeavor and Universidad
Torcuato Di Tella, November 29, 2006
21st Century college graduates
Breadth of Knowledge about
Entrepreneurship & Leadership
Depth of
Knowledge in a
Technical
Discipline
Building T-Shaped People
Entrepreneurial Concepts, Skill Set,
Experiential Exercises
Depth of
Knowledge in
a Technical
Discipline
Building T-Shaped People
Entrepreneurial Concepts, Skill Set,
Experiential Exercises
Depth of
Knowledge in
a Technical
Discipline:
Computer
Engineering
Building T-Shaped People
Entrepreneurial Concepts, Skill Set,
Experiential Exercises
Depth of
Knowledge in
a Technical
Discipline:
Animal
Sciences
Building T-Shaped People
Entrepreneurial Concepts, Skill Set,
Experiential Exercises
Depth of
Knowledge in
a Technical
Discipline:
Sustainability
Environmental
Sciences
Building T-Shaped People
Entrepreneurial Concepts, Skill Set,
Experiential Exercises
Depth of
Knowledge in
a Technical
Discipline:
Liberal Arts
The Challenge
The EPG Program creates a multi-year,
learning cohort experience for
undergraduate students to practice and
implement Entrepreneurial Leadership in
rural communities of Central Appalachia.
REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE
The Center for Rural
Entrepreneurship
Innovative Approaches to
Entrepreneurial Development Case
Studies - West, Midwest
Innovative Approaches to Entrepreneurial Development Case Studies
Rural Community Entrepreneurial
Leadership Case Studies
Community State Population Theme Lessons Learned
Northeast Minnesota 75,000 Industry cluster; CORE FOUR;
Mico; equity fund; building the
supply of entrepreneurs
Get service provider buy in; Change
regional culture; Collaboration;
Systems approach; Single Spark Plug
Missoula Montana 29,453 Missing ingredient was funding up
to $250,000
Address needs of entrepreneur and
the investor community
Southwestern North Dakota Declining
population
from 19,000
to 16,000
Dickerson State University &
Center for Entrepreneurship and
Rural Revitalization
Enterprise counseling, issue
identification and customization
solutions, Extend the reach; partner
with Tribal communities
Ferry County Washington 4 persons per
square mile
Empower women and youth
through entrepreneurship
Clean, crisp, colorful layouts –
promotion, website management,
product distribution
Mason City Northern
Iowa
20,000 CEO clubs, Youth Entrepreneurship
Academy, Business Accelerator
Importance of “Seed Capital;”
Organizing services and Engaging
communities;
Southwest Washington
State
2,623 Access to health Get community buy-in; attract
enough operating capital; maintain
communications
Cedar Falls / Waterloo Iowa 107,150 MyEnreNet Community empowerment; business
empowerment; capitalization;
networks
Livingston County South Dakota 14,558 Baseline study Entrepreneurial talent – vision /
Small Cities, Big Ideas
Rural Community Entrepreneurial Leadership Case Studies #1
Rural Community Entrepreneurial
Leadership Case Studies
Community State Population Theme Outcomes
Wood County Wisconsin 75,000 Industry cluster 78 formed
in 12 months in 2004
Henry County Ohio 29,453 Infrastructure Local matching funds
Littleton Colorado 40,000 Economic Gardening through new
information
Mentoring, networks
Georgia Entire State Entrepreneurial friendly regions 14 counties - awareness, mapping
assets, interviews
Madison County North
Carolina
20,000 HandMade in America Tourism trails with crafts, arts,
heritage, farms
Miner County South Dakota 2,623 Youth Entrepreneurship Inventory of assets
Linn County Oregon 107,150 Job creation for family wages 194 jobs
Livingston County Missouri 14,558 Baseline study Entrepreneurial talent – vision /
goals
Coffee County Georgia 37,413 Homegrown job growth 270 new jobs
Valley County Nebraska 4,647 Home Town Competitiveness 80 new jobs; 12%increase income;
45 new residents; $75 M investment;
15% increase in retail sales
These case studies illustrate the necessity of
entrepreneurial leadership, and importance of
collaboration, the value of a systems approach,
the necessity of making a clear case for and an
ability to articulate a vision of the future and the
recognition of building upon community assets.
Across Appalachia enterprise
formation is declining
The EPG Program defines
“Entrepreneurial Leadership” as:
"A process when one person or a group of
people in a community originate an idea or
innovation for a needed change and influence
others in that community to commit to
realizing that change, despite the presence of
risk, ambiguity, or uncertainty".
METHODS
Concept 1:
Designing Significant
Learning
Our Challenge: Significant learning
learning activities, Fink’s conceptual model
rests on a taxonomy of significant learning
including foundational knowledge,
application, integration, human dimension,
caring, and learning how to learn. This
model was used as a framework to support
the design team members engaged in a
year-long faculty-development program
focused on entrepreneurial leadership
program development
EPG Learning Goals
EPG
Learning
Goals
Concept 2:
Design Thinking
My training and experience provided me an opportunity to learn and work with IDEO.
The premise and case studies of “design thinking” were expressed in 2007
The premise and case studies of
“design thinking” were expressed
in 2007
The Gates Foundations supported
the application of design thinking
in developing nations
Gates Foundation
Ideation, Testing, Prototyping
Idea
Generation
Human
Centered
Discovery
Opportunity
Recognition and
Concept Design
Build Prototypes Testing
Obtain
Feedback
Analyze
Feedback
Do we need
further refining?
Yes
Modifying the
Understanding
Learning
More
Learning
Characterizing a Design Thinker
Empathy. They can imagine the world from multiple perspectives – those of colleagues,
client, end users, and customers.
Integrative thinking. They not only rely on analytical processes but also exhibit the
ability to see all of the salient – and sometime contradictory – aspects of a confounding
problem and create novel solutions that go beyond and dramatically improve on existing
alternatives.
Optimism. They assume that no matter how challenging the constraints of a given
problem, at least one potential solution is better than the existing alternatives.
Experimentalism. Design thinkers pose questions and explore constraints in creative
ways that proceed in entirely new directions.
Collaboration. The increasing complexity of products, services, and experiences has
replaced the myth of the lone genius with the reality of the enthusiastic interdisciplinary
collaborator.
Tim Brown, Design Thinking (Harvard Business Review, June 2008)
Concept 3:
Valuing Learning
Styles and
Reflective Practices
Concept 3:
Valuing Learning Styles and Reflective Practices
Concept 4:
Team-Based
Learning
Team- Based Learning
Instructional Activity Sequence
Initial Exposure, Practice Applying
Course Concepts, Final Assessment
Twice in
the
Summer
Institute
The Setting
Mission Statement
Educate and inspire students
from Appalachia to become
service-oriented leaders
1,600 liberal arts students
150 years
Learning, Labor and Service
13 States of Appalachia
poverty and unemployment rates
outpace the national average 1 and
1/2 times, and per capita income
falls two-thirds below the national
average.
Rural Communities
Madison County population – 71,000
Leslie County population – 14,000
Knott County population – 13,000
Eastern KY County seat populations – 300 / 800
Poverty rate in Appalachian Kentucky –
21.8%
Percent of High School Completion in
Appalachian Kentucky – 17.1%
Kentucky River Area Development District
Population Change from Census 2000
to July 1, 2008: -3%
33% of households in the past 12 month
incomes are below the poverty level
RESULTS
Bringing Hyden a Restore
Along come
cell phones
Experiential Learning and Community Economic Development in Appalachia
Experiential Learning and Community Economic Development in Appalachia

Experiential Learning and Community Economic Development in Appalachia

  • 1.
    Experiential Learning and CommunityEconomic Development in Appalachian Communities: A Teaching Note Peter H. Hackbert, Berea College Academy of Business Research September 13-15, 2011 Atlantic City, New Jersey
  • 2.
    Agenda Background Review of theLiterature 4 Key Concepts Methods Results
  • 3.
    Source: AAC&U CollegeLearning For the New Global Century Tina L. Seelig, Stanford Technology Venture Program, “Can Entrepreneurship be Taught?” Endeavor and Universidad Torcuato Di Tella, November 29, 2006 21st Century college graduates Breadth of Knowledge about Entrepreneurship & Leadership Depth of Knowledge in a Technical Discipline
  • 4.
    Building T-Shaped People EntrepreneurialConcepts, Skill Set, Experiential Exercises Depth of Knowledge in a Technical Discipline
  • 5.
    Building T-Shaped People EntrepreneurialConcepts, Skill Set, Experiential Exercises Depth of Knowledge in a Technical Discipline: Computer Engineering
  • 6.
    Building T-Shaped People EntrepreneurialConcepts, Skill Set, Experiential Exercises Depth of Knowledge in a Technical Discipline: Animal Sciences
  • 7.
    Building T-Shaped People EntrepreneurialConcepts, Skill Set, Experiential Exercises Depth of Knowledge in a Technical Discipline: Sustainability Environmental Sciences
  • 8.
    Building T-Shaped People EntrepreneurialConcepts, Skill Set, Experiential Exercises Depth of Knowledge in a Technical Discipline: Liberal Arts
  • 9.
    The Challenge The EPGProgram creates a multi-year, learning cohort experience for undergraduate students to practice and implement Entrepreneurial Leadership in rural communities of Central Appalachia.
  • 10.
    REVIEW OF THELITERATURE
  • 11.
    The Center forRural Entrepreneurship
  • 12.
    Innovative Approaches to EntrepreneurialDevelopment Case Studies - West, Midwest Innovative Approaches to Entrepreneurial Development Case Studies
  • 13.
    Rural Community Entrepreneurial LeadershipCase Studies Community State Population Theme Lessons Learned Northeast Minnesota 75,000 Industry cluster; CORE FOUR; Mico; equity fund; building the supply of entrepreneurs Get service provider buy in; Change regional culture; Collaboration; Systems approach; Single Spark Plug Missoula Montana 29,453 Missing ingredient was funding up to $250,000 Address needs of entrepreneur and the investor community Southwestern North Dakota Declining population from 19,000 to 16,000 Dickerson State University & Center for Entrepreneurship and Rural Revitalization Enterprise counseling, issue identification and customization solutions, Extend the reach; partner with Tribal communities Ferry County Washington 4 persons per square mile Empower women and youth through entrepreneurship Clean, crisp, colorful layouts – promotion, website management, product distribution Mason City Northern Iowa 20,000 CEO clubs, Youth Entrepreneurship Academy, Business Accelerator Importance of “Seed Capital;” Organizing services and Engaging communities; Southwest Washington State 2,623 Access to health Get community buy-in; attract enough operating capital; maintain communications Cedar Falls / Waterloo Iowa 107,150 MyEnreNet Community empowerment; business empowerment; capitalization; networks Livingston County South Dakota 14,558 Baseline study Entrepreneurial talent – vision /
  • 14.
    Small Cities, BigIdeas Rural Community Entrepreneurial Leadership Case Studies #1
  • 15.
    Rural Community Entrepreneurial LeadershipCase Studies Community State Population Theme Outcomes Wood County Wisconsin 75,000 Industry cluster 78 formed in 12 months in 2004 Henry County Ohio 29,453 Infrastructure Local matching funds Littleton Colorado 40,000 Economic Gardening through new information Mentoring, networks Georgia Entire State Entrepreneurial friendly regions 14 counties - awareness, mapping assets, interviews Madison County North Carolina 20,000 HandMade in America Tourism trails with crafts, arts, heritage, farms Miner County South Dakota 2,623 Youth Entrepreneurship Inventory of assets Linn County Oregon 107,150 Job creation for family wages 194 jobs Livingston County Missouri 14,558 Baseline study Entrepreneurial talent – vision / goals Coffee County Georgia 37,413 Homegrown job growth 270 new jobs Valley County Nebraska 4,647 Home Town Competitiveness 80 new jobs; 12%increase income; 45 new residents; $75 M investment; 15% increase in retail sales
  • 16.
    These case studiesillustrate the necessity of entrepreneurial leadership, and importance of collaboration, the value of a systems approach, the necessity of making a clear case for and an ability to articulate a vision of the future and the recognition of building upon community assets.
  • 17.
  • 18.
    The EPG Programdefines “Entrepreneurial Leadership” as: "A process when one person or a group of people in a community originate an idea or innovation for a needed change and influence others in that community to commit to realizing that change, despite the presence of risk, ambiguity, or uncertainty".
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
    learning activities, Fink’sconceptual model rests on a taxonomy of significant learning including foundational knowledge, application, integration, human dimension, caring, and learning how to learn. This model was used as a framework to support the design team members engaged in a year-long faculty-development program focused on entrepreneurial leadership program development
  • 23.
  • 24.
    Concept 2: Design Thinking Mytraining and experience provided me an opportunity to learn and work with IDEO.
  • 25.
    The premise andcase studies of “design thinking” were expressed in 2007
  • 26.
    The premise andcase studies of “design thinking” were expressed in 2007
  • 27.
    The Gates Foundationssupported the application of design thinking in developing nations Gates Foundation
  • 28.
    Ideation, Testing, Prototyping Idea Generation Human Centered Discovery Opportunity Recognitionand Concept Design Build Prototypes Testing Obtain Feedback Analyze Feedback Do we need further refining? Yes Modifying the Understanding Learning More Learning
  • 29.
    Characterizing a DesignThinker Empathy. They can imagine the world from multiple perspectives – those of colleagues, client, end users, and customers. Integrative thinking. They not only rely on analytical processes but also exhibit the ability to see all of the salient – and sometime contradictory – aspects of a confounding problem and create novel solutions that go beyond and dramatically improve on existing alternatives. Optimism. They assume that no matter how challenging the constraints of a given problem, at least one potential solution is better than the existing alternatives. Experimentalism. Design thinkers pose questions and explore constraints in creative ways that proceed in entirely new directions. Collaboration. The increasing complexity of products, services, and experiences has replaced the myth of the lone genius with the reality of the enthusiastic interdisciplinary collaborator. Tim Brown, Design Thinking (Harvard Business Review, June 2008)
  • 30.
    Concept 3: Valuing Learning Stylesand Reflective Practices Concept 3: Valuing Learning Styles and Reflective Practices
  • 32.
  • 33.
  • 34.
    Initial Exposure, PracticeApplying Course Concepts, Final Assessment
  • 35.
  • 36.
  • 37.
    Mission Statement Educate andinspire students from Appalachia to become service-oriented leaders 1,600 liberal arts students 150 years Learning, Labor and Service
  • 38.
    13 States ofAppalachia
  • 39.
    poverty and unemploymentrates outpace the national average 1 and 1/2 times, and per capita income falls two-thirds below the national average.
  • 41.
    Rural Communities Madison Countypopulation – 71,000 Leslie County population – 14,000 Knott County population – 13,000 Eastern KY County seat populations – 300 / 800
  • 42.
    Poverty rate inAppalachian Kentucky – 21.8%
  • 43.
    Percent of HighSchool Completion in Appalachian Kentucky – 17.1%
  • 44.
    Kentucky River AreaDevelopment District Population Change from Census 2000 to July 1, 2008: -3%
  • 45.
    33% of householdsin the past 12 month incomes are below the poverty level
  • 46.
  • 47.
  • 49.