Avv. Alessandro M. Lerro

November M. LERRO
Alessandro 27, 2013
Roma, November 15, 2013
LUISS – Scuola di Management – MBA ALUMNI

FUNDING START UPs
FINANCING START-UPs
EQUITY CROWDFUNDING
©2013 A.M. Lerro
GARAGE BOYS

Student experiments, no professional
business planning, no expert teams,
no proof of concept, wishful thinking

FIRED or RETIRED FOLK
Wishful thinking, looking for
“something to do”

SMART START UPs

Good idea, professional business
plan, skilled team, MBAs, overall
quality
©2013 A.M. Lerro
FINANCING A START UP :
•
•
•
•

BOOTSTRAPPING
ANGEL INVESTING & VENTURE CAPITAL
DEBT
CROWDFUNDING

©2013 A.M. Lerro
©2013 A.M. Lerro
BOOTSTRAPPING

©2013 A.M. Lerro
BOOTSTRAPPING TECHNIQUES:
• SAVINGS
• FAMILY & FRIENDS

• PERSONAL LOANS
• LENDING-BASED CROWDFUNDING

©2013 A.M. Lerro
ANGEL INVESTING
&
VENTURE CAPITAL
©2013 A.M. Lerro
- In 2012 global VC volume was $ 51,7 BL
- 58% is in the USA

- A USA VC usually looks into 200 deals/weak
- VC focus on $1/3 ML financing in average
- SYNDICATION is common

©2013 A.M. Lerro

ANGELS & VENTURE CAPITAL:
In ITALY investments are mostly allocated to
PRIVATE EQUITY operations.
Just a few early stage deals. Mainly:
- Buy Out;
- Expansion deals;
- Replacement deals.

©2013 A.M. Lerro

ANGELS & VENTURE CAPITAL:
©2013 A.M. Lerro

Fundraising expected allocation:
Note: most are
intercompany
investments.

©2013 A.M. Lerro

Early stage investments:

€100ML
©2013 A.M. Lerro

Investment distribution by stage
1° half Y2013:
©2013 A.M. Lerro

Average invested amount per stage
1° half Y2013:
Everything ought to be 100% quality, but the
first impression will rule

©2013 A.M. Lerro

- FIND THE RIGHT TEAM
- INVEST ON YOUR BUSINESS PLAN
- INVEST ON YOUR ROADSHOW
- SELECT THE RIGHT INVESTORS’ PROFILES
- BEWARE SHAREHOLDERS’ AGREEMENT
©2013 A.M. Lerro
DEBT
( Mini Bond )
©2013 A.M. Lerro
D.L. 83/2012 “Sviluppo” art. 32

EMPLOYEES

• > 10 employees
• < 250 employees

TURNOVER

• > 2 ML euro
• < 50 ML euro

ASSETS

• > 2 ML euro
• < 43 ML euro

WHO: SME (Small Medium Enterprises)
©2013 A.M. Lerro
“SPONSOR”
appointed
Audited
annual
accounts

To be distributed only
to qualified investors
(Art. 34 ter Reg. CONSOB
11971)

MINI-BONDS MAY be
eventually listed
on the Extra MOT by
Borsa Italiana
©2013 A.M. Lerro
“SPONSOR”:
Bank, SIM, SICAV, SGR,
Broker-Dealers art. 107TUF
Ought to subscribe and keep:
- 5% BOND (up to €5ML)
- 3% BOND (from €5ML to €10ML)
- 2% BONS (> €10ML)

©2013 A.M. Lerro
At the moment only LARGER companies are on the market ©2013 A.M. Lerro
CROWDFUNDING

©2013 A.M. Lerro
Joseph Pulitzer

©2013 A.M. Lerro
©2013 A.M. Lerro

REWARD
LENDING
EQUITY

DONATION
FONTE:

©2013 A.M. Lerro
1000

©2013 A.M. Lerro

FINANZIAMENTI

1200

800
600
400
200
0
REWARD

LENDING

EQUITY

DONATION
FONTE:

©2013 A.M. Lerro
©2013 A.M. Lerro
2012 C.F.
VOLUMES

“BUSINES”
MOTIVATION

“BUSINESS”
VOLUMES

Reward-based

383,000,000

16,3%

62,477,000

Lending-based

1,169,700,000

54,2%

633,977,000

Donation-based

979,300,000

12,8%

125,350,000

Equity-based

111,700,000

TOTAL

2,643,700,000

111,700,000
≈35%

933,500,000

35% OF THE 2012 CROWDFUNDING VOLUME
HAS BEEN COLLECTED
IN THE BUSINESS AND ENTREPRENUEURSHIP CATEGORY

©2013 A.M. Lerro

CROWDFUNDING
MODEL
By 2025 the volume of
INVESTMENT CROWDFUNDING
will be:
> $92 billions
= 1,6% of household savings
≈ 2 x total Venture Capital volume
©2013 A.M. Lerro
©2013 A.M. Lerro

REWARD - BASED

CROWDFUNDING

©2013 A.M. Lerro
©2013 A.M. Lerro

400
350
300

250
200
150
100
50
0
REWARD-…

2010

2011

2012

FONTE:

©2013 A.M. Lerro
PLEDGES

CATEGORY

$ 10,266,845

High Tech

OUYA: videogame consòle

$ 8,596,474

Games

Veronica Mars

$ 5,702,153

Movie

Torment: Tides of Numenera

$ 4,188,927

Games

Reaper Miniatures Bones

$ 3,429,235

Games

Double Fine Adventure

$ 3,336,371

Games

Form 1: 3D professional printer

$ 2,945,885

High Tech

Wasteland 2

$ 2,933,252

Games

Homestuck Adventure Game

$ 2,485,506

Games

Oculus Rift

$ 2,437,429

High Tech

3Doodler: 3D pen

$ 2,344,134

©2013 A.M. Lerro

PROJECT

High Tech

PEBBLE – watch for iPhone / Android

©2013 A.M. Lerro
©2013 A.M. Lerro

PREORDER
DONATION
with PERKS

ROYALTY
BASED

REWARD

©2013 A.M. Lerro
Rotterdam Bridge
• Pedestrian Bridge, 350
m., 17.000 boards by Y2042
• Y2012: ca. 100.000€, 1300
boards
• Civic Crowdfunding

©2013 A.M. Lerro

DONATION
with PERKS

©2013 A.M. Lerro
• Y2005 – no platform
• LP: 300.000R =
27.000€
• 20.161 PLEDGES
• Preorder LP: 150R
• Purchase LP: 116R

©2013 A.M. Lerro

PRE-ORDER

Verity Price

©2013 A.M. Lerro
SELLABAND
• Y2006 
• Min. invest.
10$
• Target:
50,000$
• “Believers”
• 10% reward

©2013 A.M. Lerro

ROYALTY
BASED

©2013 A.M. Lerro
©2013 A.M. Lerro

EQUITY - BASED

CROWDFUNDING
JOBS Act was the first law
in the world to regulate
equity crowdfunding (apr.
2012)
TIT. 2: accredited investors
Implemented
Tit. 3: retail investors
Waiting for SEC regulation
©2013 A.M. Lerro
LAW:
LAW n. 221, Dec. 17, 2012
“2.0 Growth Decree”

REGULATION:
CONSOB Reg. n. 18592
June 26, 2013
©2013 A.M. Lerro
LEGAL FRAMEWORK:
CONSOB has the supervision and is
entitled to impose penalties

Platforms ought to be registered with
CONSOB
Platfoms ought to meet reputation and
competence requirements
Investment is subject to MIFID and
operated through BROKER-DEALERS
©2013 A.M. Lerro
TARGET CO.:
ONLY
INNOVATIVE START UPs
ARE ALLOWED
TO RAISE EQUITY
FROM THE CROWD
(…for now)

©2013 A.M. Lerro
You can raise

€ 5.000.000,00
per company, per year

©2013 A.M. Lerro
PROBLEM/OPPORTUNITY:

!?

- The market is too small
- High Tech is too difficult for investors
- High Tech is a risky business
- Wider markets could generate more
opportunities of investment, value
creation and new jobs

©2013 A.M. Lerro
CROWDFUNDING PLATFORMS:
ONLINE PLATFORMS,
WHOSE EXCLUSIVE PURPOSE
IS TO HELP
COMPANIES
TO RAISE EQUITY
FROM THE CROWD (art.1.5.9 TUF)

©2013 A.M. Lerro
SMALL INVESTMENTS
• Directly managed
• MIFID exempted

BIG INVESTMENTS
• Partner with a BROKER-DEALER
• Investment profile to match with
proclivity to risk investment

©2013 A.M. Lerro
SMALL INVESTMENTS:
INDIVIDUAL:
< 500€ per investment
< 1000€ per year

COMPANY:
< 5.000€ per investment
< 10.000€ per year

©2013 A.M. Lerro
PROBLEM/OPPORTUNITY:

!?

Crowdfunding is limited to
EQUITY.
DEBT could be an other good
opportunity.

©2013 A.M. Lerro
BROKER-DEALERS:
BANKS and INVESTMENT Co.s
Take in charge the PAYMENT,
the execution of the investment,
once the investor has decided
to pledge.
(… at least…)

©2013 A.M. Lerro
BROKER-DEALERS:
BANKS and INVESTMENT Co.s
CAN EITHER:

MANAGE A
CROWDFUNDING
PLATFORM
THEMSELEVES

PARTNER WITH A
CROWDFUNDING
PLATFORM

©2013 A.M. Lerro
MIFID PROCEDURE:

IDENTIFICATION OF
THE CLIENT

ANTI-LAUNDERING
RULES

INVESTMENT
PROFILE TO MATCH
WITH PROCLIVITY
TO RISK
INVESTMENTS

MIFID = European Union Directive, Markets in
Financial Instruments and investment services
©2013 A.M. Lerro
ADVISING:
Broker-Dealers may advise
and give suggestions, within
their general rules.
Platforms may not provide
recommendations suitable
to influence pledges.
PLATFORMS

BROKER-DEALERS




©2013 A.M. Lerro
PROBLEM/OPPORTUNITY:

!?

FOREIGN BANKS and INVESTMENT Co.s
are in principle allowed to operate in
Italy, but the absence of Monitoring
Agreements between CONSOB and
foreign Authorities inhibits such
opportunity.

©2013 A.M. Lerro
INVESTORS:
ITALIAN LAW PROVIDES
A ROBUST LEGAL FRAMEWORK
OFFERING PROTECTION
TO INVESTORS

©2013 A.M. Lerro
There is

NO PERSONAL
INVESTMENT
LIMIT

MIFID regulates any NON SMALL investment
©2013 A.M. Lerro
SET OF WITHDRAWAL RIGHTS:
WHO

WHEN

WHY

RULE

Retail Investors
Bank Foundations
Registered Incubators

7 days from the
investment

No reason or explanation:
they just changed their
mind

§13.5 Reg.

Consumers*

14 days from the
investment

No reason or explanation:
they just changed their
mind

Consumer
Code

Retail Investors
Bank Foundations
Registered Incubators

7 days from the
news, but before
the campaign
closed

Material mistake or
§25.2 Reg.
something new happened,
suitable to influence the
investment decision

* The only case where platform are allowed to withold costs
©2013 A.M. Lerro
SHAREHOLDERS AGREEMENTS:
INFORMATION
RIGHT

Any Shareholders Agreement
must be notified to Investors

TAG ALONG or
WITHDRAWAL
RIGHT*

If the Founding Shareholders
sell the business or anyhow
wave control

* Only for RETAIL INVESTOR
As long as the Company enjoys Innovative Start Up status
©2013 A.M. Lerro
PROBLEM/OPPORTUNITY:

!?

Foreign investors in principle are
allowed to invest, but the lack of a Treaty
about jurisdiction and conflict of laws
could generate conflicts with foreign
Authorities. This problem might severely
limit investment opportunities.

©2013 A.M. Lerro
LAWS AND MATERIALS:

www.CrowdfundingInItaly.com

©2013 A.M. Lerro
©2013 A.M. Lerro
WWW.LERRO.IT
ROME

Alessandro M. Lerro
alessandrolerro
alessandro@lerro.it
Available on:

Funding Start Ups and Crowdfunding