ENERGY EFFICIENCY
INDICATORS
(Foundation of EE Policy Development)
NCPC-SA Industrial Efficiency Conference
22 July 2015
Dr Rebecca Maserumule
Industrial Energy Efficiency Specialist
Directorate: Energy Efficiency Initiatives
1
Outline
• The Big Picture
– What are Energy Management Programmes?
– What are the draft Regulations on Reporting on Energy Use?
• Energy Efficiency Indictors
– What are Indicators?
– Why are Energy Efficiency Indicators important for policy
development?
– What are Energy Efficiency Indicators?
– Why is the Industrial Sector Important?
– What are EE Indicators in the Industrial Sector
• Improving data collection to inform policy development
– What are the barriers?
– What are recommendations for improving data collection?
2
Energy Management Programme
• Energy Management
Programmes are
government led initiatives
to promote energy
management systems.
• Energy Management
Systems are a means by
which organisations
establish necessary to
achieve operational
control and continual
improvement of energy
performance.
3
Source: International Energy Agency,
Institute of Industrial Productivity, 2012
Draft Regulations
• Draft Regulations
Regarding, Reporting on
Energy Management and
Submission of Energy
Management Plans were
published for public
comments in March 2015.
• Support the development
and analysis of indicators
for the Energy Efficiency
Monitoring System to
track energy efficiency
trends in South Africa
4
Source: Reinaud, Goldberg and Rozite, 2012
What is an
indicator?
An indicator is a defined
metric used to monitor
changes. Indicators can be
absolute (e.g. total
populations) or relative
(e.g. GDP/per capita)
• Population : 54 million
(2014 estimate)
• GDP (PPP): 725,004 billion
(2015)
• GDP/per capita: $13, 215
5
Why EE Indicators are important?
6
IEA, World Energy Outlook Special Report
(Climate and Energy) 2015
EE is a growing policy priority
for many countries and hence
it is important to develop and
maintain well founded
indicators to better inform
policy making. Information
gained from these indicators
will help policy makers to set
EE targets and track progress
towards these targets.
What are EE Indicators?
7
EE Indicators are an
important tool for
analysing the
interactions among
economic and human
activities, energy use
and CO2 emissions.
Why is the industrial sector important?
• Principle One: Do not
collect statistics for the
sake of collecting
statistics; collect only
what is necessary.
• Principle Two: Identify
which data already exist
before embarking on a
costly collection
programme.
8
Industrial EE Indicators
9
Barriers to Effective Indicators
• Data Issues
– There is not a single “true” indicator of energy
intensity for an industry.
– Global studies on industries while confidential are
often limited to the main producers in industrialised
countries and hence created a bias in favour of the
more efficient plants, which can overestimate the
industry’s average energy efficiency.
– An accurate analysis of energy efficiency using
physical indicators requires good quality
disaggregated energy and physical production data.
10
Barriers to Effective Indicators
• Methodological Issues: Energy use in industrial
subsectors is complex. Even when necessary data
are available it is often not straight forward to
calculate consistent and comparable indicators
that are useful for policy analysis.
– Aggregation Levels: Determines the extent to which
structural differences affect the results observed.
– Boundaries: For a consistent analysis across countries,
it is necessary to use common boundary definitions
for each sub sector.
– Allocation: The treatment of waste and auto-
production of heat and electricity.
11
Recommendations
• Establishment of an adequate data framework is
a first step in harmonising data collection efforts.
Existing programmes such as PSEE and NCPC-SA
are critical in ensuring that the outputs of energy
audits conducted under these programmes can
assist companies in complying with regulations.
• Standardize definitions across all sectors.
• Sector wide agreement on the EE indicators
which are most relevant and meaningful to
measure progress.
12
Thank You
Rebecca.maserumule@energy.gov.za
012 406 7845
13

Hall MR12AB Wednesday 09h15 - Dr Rebecca Maserumule

  • 1.
    ENERGY EFFICIENCY INDICATORS (Foundation ofEE Policy Development) NCPC-SA Industrial Efficiency Conference 22 July 2015 Dr Rebecca Maserumule Industrial Energy Efficiency Specialist Directorate: Energy Efficiency Initiatives 1
  • 2.
    Outline • The BigPicture – What are Energy Management Programmes? – What are the draft Regulations on Reporting on Energy Use? • Energy Efficiency Indictors – What are Indicators? – Why are Energy Efficiency Indicators important for policy development? – What are Energy Efficiency Indicators? – Why is the Industrial Sector Important? – What are EE Indicators in the Industrial Sector • Improving data collection to inform policy development – What are the barriers? – What are recommendations for improving data collection? 2
  • 3.
    Energy Management Programme •Energy Management Programmes are government led initiatives to promote energy management systems. • Energy Management Systems are a means by which organisations establish necessary to achieve operational control and continual improvement of energy performance. 3 Source: International Energy Agency, Institute of Industrial Productivity, 2012
  • 4.
    Draft Regulations • DraftRegulations Regarding, Reporting on Energy Management and Submission of Energy Management Plans were published for public comments in March 2015. • Support the development and analysis of indicators for the Energy Efficiency Monitoring System to track energy efficiency trends in South Africa 4 Source: Reinaud, Goldberg and Rozite, 2012
  • 5.
    What is an indicator? Anindicator is a defined metric used to monitor changes. Indicators can be absolute (e.g. total populations) or relative (e.g. GDP/per capita) • Population : 54 million (2014 estimate) • GDP (PPP): 725,004 billion (2015) • GDP/per capita: $13, 215 5
  • 6.
    Why EE Indicatorsare important? 6 IEA, World Energy Outlook Special Report (Climate and Energy) 2015 EE is a growing policy priority for many countries and hence it is important to develop and maintain well founded indicators to better inform policy making. Information gained from these indicators will help policy makers to set EE targets and track progress towards these targets.
  • 7.
    What are EEIndicators? 7 EE Indicators are an important tool for analysing the interactions among economic and human activities, energy use and CO2 emissions.
  • 8.
    Why is theindustrial sector important? • Principle One: Do not collect statistics for the sake of collecting statistics; collect only what is necessary. • Principle Two: Identify which data already exist before embarking on a costly collection programme. 8
  • 9.
  • 10.
    Barriers to EffectiveIndicators • Data Issues – There is not a single “true” indicator of energy intensity for an industry. – Global studies on industries while confidential are often limited to the main producers in industrialised countries and hence created a bias in favour of the more efficient plants, which can overestimate the industry’s average energy efficiency. – An accurate analysis of energy efficiency using physical indicators requires good quality disaggregated energy and physical production data. 10
  • 11.
    Barriers to EffectiveIndicators • Methodological Issues: Energy use in industrial subsectors is complex. Even when necessary data are available it is often not straight forward to calculate consistent and comparable indicators that are useful for policy analysis. – Aggregation Levels: Determines the extent to which structural differences affect the results observed. – Boundaries: For a consistent analysis across countries, it is necessary to use common boundary definitions for each sub sector. – Allocation: The treatment of waste and auto- production of heat and electricity. 11
  • 12.
    Recommendations • Establishment ofan adequate data framework is a first step in harmonising data collection efforts. Existing programmes such as PSEE and NCPC-SA are critical in ensuring that the outputs of energy audits conducted under these programmes can assist companies in complying with regulations. • Standardize definitions across all sectors. • Sector wide agreement on the EE indicators which are most relevant and meaningful to measure progress. 12
  • 13.

Editor's Notes

  • #5 Detailed indicators can help identify areas for energy reduction, within a process Energy management systems can help develop, track and improve energy indicators in business.
  • #7 Energy efficiency is a growing policy priority for many countries around the world. It is widely recognised as the most cost-effective and readily available means to address numerous energy-related issues, including energy security, the social and economic impacts of high energy prices and concerns about climate change. At the same time, energy efficiency increases competitiveness and promotes consumer welfare. In this context, it is important to develop and maintain well-founded indicators to better inform policy making and help decision makers formulate policies that are best suited to domestic and/or international objectives.  The International Energy Agency produced a special report earlier this year on Climate and Energy and this graph illustrates the impact of different policy measures on global CO2 emissions. As one can see energy efficiency measures can be responsible for up to 49% of reductions.
  • #8 Energy Efficiency Indicators: Assist with understanding past trends Help assess the potential for energy savings Enhance the development of energy efficiency policies
  • #10 Level One (Total Industry Sector): The commonly used indicator of the aggregate level is energy consumption per unit of GDP. This ratio measures how much energy is needed to produce one unit of economic output. However, it would be misleading to evaluate the performance of energy-efficiency based on this indicator as it is affected by many non-energy efficiency factors such as the structure of the industry, the quality of resources and, for some industrial sectors, weather conditions. Level Two and Level Three (Industry Sectors): The industries represented in level 2 and level 3 usually differ by country according to the data available and the relative importance of each industry. At these levels, the best indicator to assess energy efficiency is energy consumption per unit of production. However, as some industries are too heterogeneous to have one measure of production, GDP (or another monetary value such as gross output) is the second best choice. Level Four (Process Indicators): Only a limited number of countries have this information for a limited number of industries. However, even partial information at this level can help explain the trends in energy consumption.