Ethics and
Information
A Definition
• Ethics: The discipline
  dealing with what is good
  or bad and with moral
  duty and obligation.
      – Merriam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary, 11 th edition
A Question of
      Ethics
• You see a dog sitting
  on the side of a major
  highway. What do you
  do?
Definition II
• Information Ethics: The branch of ethics
  that focuses on the relationship between the
  creation, organization, dissemination, and
  use of information, and the ethical and
  moral codes governing human conduct in
  society.
           » -- Dictionary for Library and Information Science
           » Joan M. Reitz 2004
Two Major Themes

• Plagiarism
• Copyright
Other Topics (not covered here)
•   Censorship
•   Privacy
•   Children’s access to the Internet/Filtering
•   Search Engine ranking
•   Advertising vs. Information
•   Spam & phishing
Plagiarism Defined
• “ Copying or closely imitating the work of
  another writer, composer, etc., without
  permission and with the intention of
  passing the results off as original work.”

          --Dictionary for Library and
  Information Science, Joan M. Reitz, ©2004
STCC’s Plagiarism Policy

    (from the Student Handbook)

http://www.stcc.edu/handbook/conductcode.asp
Plagiarism and The Digital
           Age
• Cutting and pasting from one electronic
  source to another without attribution

• Downloading papers from online paper
  repositories (“paper mills”)
Is Plagiarism ever ok?
Copyright
• A grant of exclusive rights over the
  writings of an “author,” including music,
  literature, drama, and other intellectual
  works.

• Only the copyright holder may authorize
  reproduction of copyrighted works.
Copyright con’t.
• Copyright derives from the Constitution

To promote the Progress of Science and
 useful Arts, by securing for limited
 Times to Authors and Inventors the
 exclusive Right to their respective
 Writings and Discoveries;
 Article I, Section 8, Clause 8 - U.S.
 Constitution
Original Term of Copyright



      14 years
Current Term of Copyright


     95 years
  (give or take)
Why Has Copyright
Been Lengthened?
The Likely Culprit
Other Copyright Battles
•   Lego Bionicles
•   George Harrison
•   Mike Tyson’s Tattoo
•   Purple Dinosaur Costumes

For more information, see
http://www.benedict.com
Fair Use Exemption
• You can use a copyrighted work on a
  limited basis according to “Fair Use.”

• Fair use allows you to quote passages from
  a book or other work in your paper.

• But there are still limits!
Factors in Determining Fair Use
• Financial effect
• Amount of original work used
• Whether new work is intended
  for commercial purposes
• How derivative is the new
  work?
Other Exceptions
•   Parody
•   Academic Use
•   Public Domain
•   Doctrine of First Sale
Intellectual Property

• Definition:

“Tangible products of the human mind and
  intelligence entitled to the legal status of personal
  property, especially works protected by copyright,
  inventions that have been patented, and registered
  trademarks.”
             --Dictionary for library and information
  science. Joan M. Reitz, 2004.
Examples of I.P.
• The Beatles “White Album”
• “Scarface”
• “Happy Birthday to You”
Is there another name for these
            things?

    How about. . . .

     Culture!!!!!
Examples of Western Culture

•The Beatles “White Album”
•“Scarface”
•“Happy Birthday to You”
Questions but no answers

Are I.P. and Culture synonymous?
Can Culture be copyrighted?
Is Copyright too restrictive?
Can Copyright limit or suppress new forms of
  art and culture?
Mashup
• A song in which the vocal from one source
  is laid over the music of another.
Current Example

        An authorized
          legitimate
           mashup
            record
Example of an unauthorized
     mashup record
 DJ DangerMouse: The Grey Album
Who owns the copyright?
• EMI: Owns rights to “The White Album”
• Sony: Owns rights to Lennon/McCartney
  catalog
• Def Jam(?) owns the rights to Jay Z’s “The
  Black Album”
• Whoever owns the rights to Jay Z’s songs
• DJ Dangermouse
Is this okay?

Please discuss.
Is it ever OK to violate
       copyright?
Review: Copyright Exceptions
•Financial effect
•Amount of original work used
•Whether new work is intended for
commercial purposes
•How derivative is the new work?
Quote
• “The copyright system has been extended,
  twisted, supplemented, and corrupted to
  such an extent that the oligarchs have
  locked up content in most forms for what
  seems like forever. “
• --Siva Vaidhyanathan, The Anarchist in the
  Library

Information ethics

  • 1.
  • 2.
    A Definition • Ethics:The discipline dealing with what is good or bad and with moral duty and obligation. – Merriam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary, 11 th edition
  • 3.
    A Question of Ethics • You see a dog sitting on the side of a major highway. What do you do?
  • 4.
    Definition II • InformationEthics: The branch of ethics that focuses on the relationship between the creation, organization, dissemination, and use of information, and the ethical and moral codes governing human conduct in society. » -- Dictionary for Library and Information Science » Joan M. Reitz 2004
  • 5.
    Two Major Themes •Plagiarism • Copyright
  • 6.
    Other Topics (notcovered here) • Censorship • Privacy • Children’s access to the Internet/Filtering • Search Engine ranking • Advertising vs. Information • Spam & phishing
  • 7.
    Plagiarism Defined • “Copying or closely imitating the work of another writer, composer, etc., without permission and with the intention of passing the results off as original work.” --Dictionary for Library and Information Science, Joan M. Reitz, ©2004
  • 8.
    STCC’s Plagiarism Policy (from the Student Handbook) http://www.stcc.edu/handbook/conductcode.asp
  • 9.
    Plagiarism and TheDigital Age • Cutting and pasting from one electronic source to another without attribution • Downloading papers from online paper repositories (“paper mills”)
  • 10.
  • 11.
    Copyright • A grantof exclusive rights over the writings of an “author,” including music, literature, drama, and other intellectual works. • Only the copyright holder may authorize reproduction of copyrighted works.
  • 12.
    Copyright con’t. • Copyrightderives from the Constitution To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries; Article I, Section 8, Clause 8 - U.S. Constitution
  • 13.
    Original Term ofCopyright 14 years
  • 14.
    Current Term ofCopyright 95 years (give or take)
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
    Other Copyright Battles • Lego Bionicles • George Harrison • Mike Tyson’s Tattoo • Purple Dinosaur Costumes For more information, see http://www.benedict.com
  • 18.
    Fair Use Exemption •You can use a copyrighted work on a limited basis according to “Fair Use.” • Fair use allows you to quote passages from a book or other work in your paper. • But there are still limits!
  • 19.
    Factors in DeterminingFair Use • Financial effect • Amount of original work used • Whether new work is intended for commercial purposes • How derivative is the new work?
  • 20.
    Other Exceptions • Parody • Academic Use • Public Domain • Doctrine of First Sale
  • 21.
    Intellectual Property • Definition: “Tangibleproducts of the human mind and intelligence entitled to the legal status of personal property, especially works protected by copyright, inventions that have been patented, and registered trademarks.” --Dictionary for library and information science. Joan M. Reitz, 2004.
  • 22.
    Examples of I.P. •The Beatles “White Album” • “Scarface” • “Happy Birthday to You”
  • 23.
    Is there anothername for these things? How about. . . . Culture!!!!!
  • 24.
    Examples of WesternCulture •The Beatles “White Album” •“Scarface” •“Happy Birthday to You”
  • 25.
    Questions but noanswers Are I.P. and Culture synonymous? Can Culture be copyrighted? Is Copyright too restrictive? Can Copyright limit or suppress new forms of art and culture?
  • 26.
    Mashup • A songin which the vocal from one source is laid over the music of another.
  • 27.
    Current Example An authorized legitimate mashup record
  • 28.
    Example of anunauthorized mashup record DJ DangerMouse: The Grey Album
  • 29.
    Who owns thecopyright? • EMI: Owns rights to “The White Album” • Sony: Owns rights to Lennon/McCartney catalog • Def Jam(?) owns the rights to Jay Z’s “The Black Album” • Whoever owns the rights to Jay Z’s songs • DJ Dangermouse
  • 30.
  • 31.
    Is it everOK to violate copyright?
  • 32.
    Review: Copyright Exceptions •Financialeffect •Amount of original work used •Whether new work is intended for commercial purposes •How derivative is the new work?
  • 33.
    Quote • “The copyrightsystem has been extended, twisted, supplemented, and corrupted to such an extent that the oligarchs have locked up content in most forms for what seems like forever. “ • --Siva Vaidhyanathan, The Anarchist in the Library