ISEW Goes Regional in
partnership with the
International Forum for Coal
Regions in Transition
14.10.2025
Samarinda, Indonesia
Welcome
Welcome remarks
Togu Pardede, Director of Energy, Mineral, and Mining Resources,
Bappenas, Indonesia
Philipp Schattenmann, Director “Innovation Regions for a Just
Energy Transition” (IKI JET)
International Forum for Coal Regions in Transition 2025
Our time together
09:00 Opening Remarks
09:15
Session 1 | The Role of Local Governments in Driving Renewable Energy
Investments in Coal Regions
10:30 Coffee Break
11:00
Session 2 | International Experiences for Just Energy Transition Energy &
Framework Conditions
12:30 Lunch
13:30
Session 3 | Strategies for Economic Diversification and Transformation in
Coal Regions
15:00 Coffee Break
15:30 Session 4 | Micro, Small & Medium Enterprises in Economic Diversification
16:30 Fishbowl Discussion - Economic Diversification and the Role of MSMEs
17:15 Closing Remarks
The Role of Local Governments in Driving
Renewable Energy Investments in Coal
Regions
International Forum for Coal Regions in Transition 2025
Sri Wahyuni,
Provincial
secretary of East
Kalimantan,
Indonesia
Ani Wiyanti, Ministry
of Energy and
Mineral Resources,
Indonesia
Session 1
Hendra Irawan,
Perusahaan Listrik
Negara (PLN)
Indonesia
Rizal Fernandy,
Borneo Energy
Harapan
With over 18 years of experience in public administration and tourism
development, Mrs. Sri Wahyuni currently serves as the Regional
Secretary of East Kalimantan Province. Her career began in Kutai
Kartanegara Regency, where she led public tourism and protocol
(2006–2012) and later served as Head of the Tourism Department
(2012–2019). She then advanced to become the Head of the Tourism
Department for East Kalimantan Province (2019–2022), where she
played a key role in promoting sustainable tourism and regional
economic growth.
Mrs. Sri Wahyuni has completed several international executive
programs, including Digital Transformation in Government at the
Harvard Kennedy School (2021) and Sustainable Tourism Management
at Griffith University, Australia (2021), along with other trainings
focused on post-pandemic tourism recovery and sustainable economic
development.
Sri Wahyuni
Provincial Secretary of
East Kalimantan,
Indonesia
Unlocking clean energy
investments in East Kalimantan
Sri Wahyuni - Provincial secretary of East Kalimantan, Indonesia
8
Sources of Economic Growth in East Kalimantan (y-on-y %)
 The three main sectors driving East Kalimantan’s economic growth are Mining and Quarrying, Manufacturing, and Construction.
 Since 2019, the Mining and Quarrying sector has contributed the largest share to East Kalimantan’s economy.
 However, unlike in previous years, from the first quarter of 2025 to the second quarter of 2025, the Manufacturing sector has provided the largest positive
contribution.
Note: (A) Agriculture, Forestry, and Fisheries | (B) Mining and Quarrying | (C) Manufacturing | (D) Electricity and Gas Supply | (E) Water Supply, Waste Management, and Recycling | (F) Construction | (G) Wholesale and Retail Trade; Repair of Motor
Vehicles and Motorcycles | (H) Transportation and Warehousing | (I) Accommodation and Food Service Activities | (J) Information and Communication | (K) Financial and Insurance Activities | (L) Real Estate | (M, N) Business Services | (O) Public
Administration, Defense, and Compulsory Social Security | (P) Education Services | (Q) Health and Social Work Activities | (R, S, T, U) Other Services.
I II III IV I II III IV I II III IV I II III IV I II III IV I II III IV I II
2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
-6.00
-4.00
-2.00
0.00
2.00
4.00
6.00
8.00
3.15 3.61
4.79
1.43
-0.27
-3.31 -3.13
-2.14 -2.09
2.32
2.96
1.28
0.79
1.32
1.78
2.67 2.36 2.42
1.54
3.31
4.77
2.89
2.60 2.31
-0.28
-0.06
-0.31
0.13
0.14
0.05
0.63
-1.53
-1.14
-0.33
-0.72
1.70
0.55
0.50
0.33
0.73
0.69
1.08 1.40
1.01
1.34
0.01
-0.09 -0.41 -0.02
0.67
1.55
2.75
1.05 0.48
0.23
0.12
0.09
0.07
-0.16
-0.25
0.00
-0.04
0.47
0.76
0.30
0.49
0.71
0.86
1.30
1.51
1.13
1.06
1.04
1.44
1.21
0.99
0.34
-0.01
A B C D E F G H I J K L M,N O P Q R,S,T,U
4,98
1,28
-5,42
2,79
6,19
-4,59
4,91
-2,87
5,62
4,66
3,34
2,40
3,62
5,34
6,47
6,99 6,89
5,30
-3,10
5,76
7,26
5,85
5,52
6,12
4,08
4,69
9
Average Economic Growth by Industry Sector, 2019–2024(%)
 The fastest-growing sectors are Health (Q), Electricity (D),
Construction (F), and Information and Communication (J).
 Sectors that have grown relatively fast during the 2019–2024 period
include Trade (G), Transportation (H), Accommodation and Food
Services (I), and Other Services (R, S, T, U).

Tourism-related sectors have shown relatively strong growth.
C Migas
A
L
B
C Non Migas
M,N
P
R,S,T,U
I
H
G
O
E
K
J
F
D
Q
0.40
1.18
2.52
2.54
3.69
3.70
3.81
4.58
4.85
4.95
5.37
5.83
6.49
6.52
7.58
7.88
9.86
9.88
Note: (A) Agriculture, Forestry, and Fisheries | (B) Mining and
Quarrying | (C) Manufacturing | (D) Electricity and Gas Supply | (E)
Water Supply, Waste Management, and Recycling | (F) Construction |
(G) Wholesale and Retail Trade; Repair of Motor Vehicles and
Motorcycles | (H) Transportation and Warehousing | (I)
Accommodation and Food Service Activities | (J) Information and
Communication | (K) Financial and Insurance Activities | (L) Real
Estate | (M, N) Business Services | (O) Public Administration, Defense,
and Compulsory Social Security | (P) Education Services | (Q) Health
and Social Work Activities | (R, S, T, U) Other Services.
East Kalimantan is at a turning point
Indonesia’s top coal-producing region
Fossil dominates its energy use
Strong commitment to the double green
transitions:
Shift the local economy to be more
diversified and sustainable.
Switch the energy use to double the
renewable share in 5 years, from 12.1%
(2024) to 25.7%(2029)
We want an inclusive and fair transition.
We recognize the urgency to shift. This is
not only about energy—it is about our
future.
Fossi
l
RE
Coal mine
operation (39%)
Natural gas
based
industry
(23%)
Logistics & urban
transportation (13%)
Culinary
(2%)
Electricity
generation
(20%)
Palm Oil
plantation
(1%)
Energy use in East Kalimantan in 2023
Energy transition priority areas
Transition
feasibility
(Technical
&
economical
potential
)
Transition significance
(amount of fossil avoided through increased renewables )
Diesel to FAME
Coal to solar & hydro
Diesel to electricity
Natural gas to solar & water
Natural gas to biomethane
Diesel to biomethane
Gasoline to electricity
LPG to electricity
IPP solar investment opportunities—
RUPTL-ARED Scenario 2026-2029
Total capacity: 755 MW
East Kalimantan: 255 MW
Other provinces (Central & North Kalimantan): 500 MW.
Locations: not yet defined?
Economic: PLN tariff > LCOE feasible
LCOE: 6.9 ¢/kWh
Feed-in-tariff (>10MW): 7.6-8.7 ¢/kWh
Turning coal land into sun fields
-Potential benefits
-Reinforce mine reclamation and responsible closure obligations
-Prevents deforestation and conflicts
-Enables coal-to-renewable shift for workers and local
communities
-Simplifies land acquisition process
-Challenges:
-Align post-mining, PLN and spatial plans
-Revise post-mining plans for solar use
-Clarify land rights return procedure
-East Kalimantan: 125,000 ha of mining land outside state forest
land (2022)
Source:
https://globalenergymonitor.org/report/bright-side-of-the-mine/
Distribution of Palm Oil Mills in East Kalimantan Province
7
17
38
12
17
12
2
PPU Paser Kutim Kubar Kukar
Berau Mahulu
PPU Paser Kutim Kubar Kukar Berau Mahulu Total
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
360 940
2,040
585 1,015
745
45
5,730
299 792
1,829
548 899
713
51
5,131
Kapasitas Pabrik Kelapa Sawit
TBS (ton/jam)
Terpasang Terpakai
Palm Oil Mill Effluent (POME) Production in East Kalimantan Province
PPU Paser Kutim Kubar Kukar Berau Mahulu Total
-
2,000,000,000
4,000,000,000
6,000,000,000
8,000,000,000
10,000,000,000
12,000,000,000
14,000,000,000
16,000,000,000
950,400,000
2,481,600,000
5,385,600,000
1,544,400,000
2,679,600,000
1,966,800,000
118,800,000
15,127,200,000
meter kubik per tahun
POME is utilized as organic fertilizer for
plantations and as feedstock for the company’s
Bio-CNG production
BIO GAS INSTALATION
PT. Rea Kaltim Plantations (Kukar)
Pengelolaan Bio Gas
97.670 Ton
CO2eq
Listrik
7 MW
Digunakan untuk Fasilitas Perusahaan
PT. Prima Mitra Jaya Mandiri (Kukar)
Pengelolaan Bio Gas
43.492 Ton
CO2eq
Listrik
1,2 MW
Digunakan untuk Fasilitas Perusahaan
PT. Indonesia Plant Synergy (Kutim)
Pengelolaan Bio Gas
45.967 Ton
CO2eq
Listrik
0.5 MW
Digunakan untuk Fasilitas Perusahaan
PT. Teguh Jaya Primaabadi (Kukar)
Pengelolaan Bio Gas
32.824 Ton
CO2eq
Gas CH4 Gas di flaring
PT. Hutan Hijau Mas (Berau)
Pengelolaan Bio Gas
59.156 Ton
CO2eq
1.2 MW Digunakan untuk Fasilitas Perusahaan
PT. Dharma Satya Nusantara Tbk (Kutim)
Pengelolaan Bio CNG
33.238 Ton
CO2eq
Listrik
1,2 MW dan
Gas Rumah
Tangga
Masih Uji Coba Digunakan untuk fasilitas
Perusahaan
Our support to facilitate renewable energy
investments in East Kalimantan
• Land and permit facilitation
• Community partnership and workforce
preparation
• Incentives
“Our job is to make it easier, safer, and more inclusive for
RE investment to happen.”
️
🗣️
Our support to facilitate renewable
energy investments in East Kalimantan
• Land and permit facilitation
• Community partnership and workforce
preparation
• Incentives
“Our job is to make it easier, safer, and more inclusive for
RE investment to happen.”
🗣️
Role 1: Land and permit facilitation
• Suitability mapping and identification of potential areas for
solar farms based on consultation with PLN and Minerba
• Provide technical assistance to district/municipal
governments on detailed spatial planning (RDTR) in
potential areas to support:
• Seamless approval for land use (KKPR), environment (PL), and
building (PBG)
• application of international social and environmental safeguard
standards
🗣️“Land is among the most difficult part to start RE
business—but this is where provinces can lead.”
Role 2: Community partnership and
workforce preparation
• Facilitate FPIC to gain genuine consent
from the affected communities, including
customary community (masyarakat adat)
• Facilitate local community participation in:
• Solar power generation business
• Protection and rehabilitation of watershed area
around hydro power plants
• Biomass production on degraded land
“
🗣️ We ensure transition does not leave our people
behind.”
Role 3: Incentives
• Basic infrastructure support:
• Facilitate communication with district government to provide basic
infrastructure such as access road and access to clean water
service
Conclusion
• East Kalimantan aims to boost its renewable energy share
as part of its green economy transformation
• Transitioning grid-connected power generation is a key
priority
• The province seeks to attract renewable energy investments
by facilitating:
• Land and permit process
• Community partnership and workforce facilitation
• Incentives
Mrs. Ani Wiyanti is a seasoned professional in Indonesia’s
energy sector with extensive experience in renewable energy and
energy conservation policy. After starting her career in the
telecommunications industry at PT Komselindo and PT Mobile-8
Telecom Tbk (1996–2005), she joined the Ministry of Energy and
Mineral Resources, where she held several key positions within the
Directorate General of New, Renewable Energy, and Energy
Conservation (DJEBTKE). Her roles included leading the Energy
Conservation Cooperation and Incentive Sections and coordinating
the Sub-Directorate of Investment and Cooperation. Since 2022,
she has served as a Senior Policy Analyst (Analis Kebijakan
Ahli Madya) at DJEBTKE, continuing her commitment to
promoting sustainable and efficient energy development in
Indonesia.
Ani Wiyanti
Ministry of Energy and
Mineral Resources,
Indonesia
24
Support and
Acceleration of
Regional Solar Power
(PLTS) Development
Policies
Directorate of Various New and Renewable Energy,
MEMR
Samarinda, 14 Oktober 2025
Presented at:
“Indonesia Sustainable Energy Week Goes Regional (ISEWGR) – Samarinda”
25
DIRECTION OF NATIONAL ENERGY MANAGEMENT POLICY
4A Parameters in Energy Resilience
AVAILABILITY
(Ketersediaan Energi)
ACCESSIBILITY
(Akses Energi)
AFFORDABILITY
(Keterjangkauan)
ACCEPTABILITY
(Ramah Lingkungan)
“Energy Self-Sufficiency”
ASTA CITA #2 “Strengthening the national defense and security
system and promoting national self-reliance through food,
energy, and water self-sufficiency, as well as the development
of the creative economy, green economy, and blue economy.”
Commitment to Greenhouse Gas (GHG) Emission
Reduction
Energy Sector Target: 358 million
tons of CO₂ through the
following programs:
• Renewable Energy
• Energy Efficiency
• Clean Energy Power
Generation
• Low-Carbon Fuels
• Mine Reclamation
26
Presidential Regulation No. 112 of 2022
Acceleration of Renewable Energy Development for Power Generation
MEMR Regulation No. 11 of 2024
Utilization of Local Products for Electricity Infrastructure
Development (Domestic Component Level / TKDN)
MEMR Regulation No. 10 of 2025
Energy Transition Roadmap for the Power Sector
MEMR Regulation No. 2 of 2024
Rooftop Solar Power Plants Connected to the Grid of Holders of Electricity
Supply Business Licenses for Public Interest
MEMR Regulation No. 5 of 2025
Guidelines for Power Purchase Agreements (PPA) from Renewable
Energy Power Plants
Law Number 30 of 2007 on Energy
Draft Law on New and
Renewable Energy
REGULATIONS ON THE ACCELERATION OF RENEWABLE ENERGY DEVELOPMENT
Draft Revision of Presidential
Regulation No. 112/2022
Draft Presidential Regulation on
the Governance and Implementing
Organization for the Development
and Operation of Nuclear Power
Plants
Draft Regulation of the Minister of
Energy and Mineral Resources on
Grid-Connected Solar Power Plants
(PLTS Parallel Operation)
Regulations Currently Being Drafted
MEMR Regulation No. 12/2018 concerning the amendment to Regulation No.
39/2017 on the Implementation of Physical Activities for the Utilization of New
and Renewable Energy (mechanism based on proposals from local governments).
1
2
3
4
5
Draft Regulation of the Minister of
Energy and Mineral Resources on
Hybrid Power Plants for Off-Grid
Mini-Grid Systems
Government Regulation No. 40 of 2025
National Energy Policy (70–72% renewable energy mix by 2060)
27
2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050 2055 2060
1028
Mt CO2e
885
Mt CO2e
129
Mt CO2e
558
Mt CO2e
Strategy to Achieve
NZE 2060
RE Development
(On-grid, Off-grid &
Biofuel)
1
Electrification
(EVs, induction stoves,
agricultural
electrification, etc.)
2
Moratorium on New
CFPP in Accordance
with Presidential
Regulation No.
112/2022 and Phase-
Down of Existing
CFPP
3
CCS/CCUS
4
New Energy
Sources
(nuclear, hydrogen,
ammonia)
5 Implementatio
n of Energy
Efficiency
6
ROADMAP OF NET ZERO EMISSION
Indonesia is committed to achieving Net Zero Emissions (NZE) by 2060 or earlier
1st
Nuclear
Power Plant
(2032)
High Carbon Low Carbon Free Carbon
Green H2
Transportation
Sector
Green NH3
Shipbuilding Sector
CCS
Industry Sector
MEPS
55x higher than in
2030
Energy
Management
(Mandatory)
Wind and Solar
Dominated energy
mix
No.1 World
Geothermal
(2030)
Biofuel Mandate
Continues to Increase
Projected Emissions & Energy Sector Transition
Milestones
Gas
As a bridging for
energy transition
28
Electric Power Generation Roadmap (RUKN)
Solar (109 GW)
Wind (73 GW)
Hydro (71 GW)
H2 (25 GW)
Gas / Gas+CCS (38 GW)
Nuclear (35 GW)
Geothermal (23 GW)
Bioenergy (4 GW)
NH3 (8 GW)
Storage (34 GW)
2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050 2055 2060
-
5 0
1 0 0
1 5 0
2 0 0
2 5 0
3 0 0
3 5 0
4 0 0
4 5 0
5 0 0
59
75 73 69
56
46
8 -
3
4 4 4 4 4
4
4
2
4 7 15 17 20 22 23
26
47
49
53
51
49
8 1
9
11
22
28
57
63
65
71
- 3 9 10 13
28 33 34
5
10
27
43
64
65
73
13
28
35
45
88
95
109
2 3
14
22
51 54
7
15
22 27 35
0
1
3
27 37
2 3
7
8
24
25
106
160
199
242
307
386
407
443
Capacity (GW)
Storage Ocean Waste Heat Diesel
Solar Wind Hydro H2
Gas_CCS Gas Nuclear Geothermal
Bioenergy NH3 Coal_CCS_CfBio Coal
Net Power Capacity (DMN) in 2060 is projected to reach 443 GW, consisting of:
• 42% Variable Renewable Energy (VRE) complemented by 34 GW of storage, and
• 58% Non-VRE (dispatchable) sources.
It will be supported by a Super Grid to enhance renewable energy (EBT) penetration.
RE energy mix
(PP 40/2025 National
Energy Policy)
19-23% 36-40% 53-55% 70-72%
Ocean (1GW)
29
2025 - 2029
2030 - 2034
Total
RE Addition
42,6
GW
Sumatera
EBT9,5
ESS1,6
GW Satuan : MW
PLTA/M
PLTP
PLT Bio
PLTN
PLTS
PLTB
Storage
4.940
2.017
78
250
1.606
590
1.575
Planned Addition of Renewable Energy Power Plants and Energy Storage
Systems in PLN’s Electricity Supply Business Plan (RUPTL) 2025–2034
Kalimantan
EBT3,5
ESS 0,7
GW Satuan : MW
PLTA/M
PLT Bio
PLTN
PLTS
PLTB
Storage
1.533
80
250
1.524
70
725
Sulawesi
EBT7,7
GW
Satuan : MW
PLTA/M
PLTP
PLT Bio
PLTS
PLTB
4.606
305
236
1.530
1.010
Papua, Maluku, Nusa
Tenggara
EBT2,3
GW
Satuan : MW
PLTA/M
PLTP
PLT Bio
PLTS
PLTB
PLTAL
179
332
141
1.470
140
40
Jawa Madura Bali
EBT19,6
ESS 7,9
GW Satuan : MW
PLTA/M
PLTP
PLT Bio
PLTS
PLTB
Storage
432
2.503
399
10.932
5.377
7.956
1.682
Invesment Opportunities
Trillion rupiah
836.696
GREEN JOBS
Employment Opportunities
Energi Storage
System
10,2
GW
IPP
40186.
48781
76%
PLN
4734.0
58
9%
SH
7904.7
1
15%
IPP PLN SH
30
Status of National Renewable Energy Utilization
The addition of renewable energy installed capacity
in the first semester of 2025 amounted to 876.5 MW.
The total installed capacity RE in the first half of
2025 reached 15.2 GW, accounting for 14.5% of the
national total generation capacity (105 GW).
14,5%*
from total national
power plants
(105 GW)
2024 Smt I 2025
14,325
15,201
Installed Capacity of RE
Power Plants (MW)
29.40%
38.01%
16.59%
16.00%
Minyak Bumi
Batubara
Gas Bumi
EBT
The share of new and renewable energy
(NRE) in the national energy mix reached
16% based on preliminary calculations for the
first semester of 2025.
876,5
Oil
Coal
Gas
RE
31
Solar Power Plant (PLTS) Development Program
Potential : 89,37 GW (293 locations)
 Potential at PUPR Dams: 14.7 GW (257
locations)
 Potential in Lakes: 74.67 MW (36
locations)
Progress:
 Pre-construction: 210 MW
(PLTS Floating Saguling, Singkarak,
Karangkates)
 COD: 145 MW (PLTS Floating Cirata)
Based on the RUPTL, the target total
capacity by 2034 is 17 GW.
Project Location:
 Sumatera : 1.605 MW
 Kalimantan : 1.524 MW
 Jamali : 10.931,65 MW
 Sulawesi : 1.529 MW
 Mapana : 1.470 MW
Rooftop Solar PV Large Scale Solar PV Floating Solar PV
Solar energy is prioritized for development, supported by continuously declining costs.
Based on the Ministry of Energy and Mineral
Resources decree, the total rooftop solar PV (PLTS
Atap) quota until 2028 is 2 GW:
 Sumatra: 95 MW
 Kalimantan: 104 MW
 Java-Madura-Bali (Jamali): 1,850 MW
 Sulawesi: 17 MW
 Maluku-Papua (Mapana): 7 MW
Installed capacity as of June 2025: 495 MWp
(10,736 PLN customers)
PLTS Amman 26,8 MW, West Sumbawa, NTB Floating Solar PV Cirata 192 MWp, West Java
Rooftop Solar PV PT Pabrik Kertas Tjiwi Kimia 9,8 MWp, East Java
Solar energy development is also carried out through:
• Decentralization programs
• State Budget (APBN) or Special Allocation Fund (DAK) solar PV projects to promote the provision of energy from new or renewable
energy sources in the 3T regions (Frontier, Outer, and Disadvantaged Areas).
32
Scope of Regulations
Related to the Preparation of the
Regional Regulation on RUED-P
Government Regulation No. 40
of 2025
Presidential Regulation No. 22 of
2017 on the National Energy
General Plan
Law Number 30 of 2007 on Energy
Based on Article 18 of Law No. 30 of 2007 on Energy, regional governments prepare a
Regional General Energy Plan by referring to the National General Energy Plan, which is
established through regional regulations.
1. Aceh
2. North Sumatra
3. Riau
4. Riau Islands
5. West Sumatra
6. Jambi
7. South Sumatra
8. Bengkulu
9. Bangka Belitung
Islands
10. Lampung
11. Banten
12. Jakarta
13. West Java
14. Central Java
15. East Java
16. Yogyakarta
17. Bali
18. West Nusa Tenggara
(NTB)
19. East Nusa Tenggara
(NTT)
20. North Kalimantan
21. East Kalimantan
22. South Kalimantan
23. West Kalimantan
24. Central Kalimantan
25. Central Sulawesi
26. North Sulawesi
27.Gorontalo
28. West Sulawesi
29. Southeast Sulawesi
30. South Sulawesi
31. Maluku
32. North Maluku
33. West Papua
33
Provinces
Telah
menetapkan
Perda RUED-P
Preparing the RUED-P Draft
Papua Barat Daya
1
Province
3
Provinces
Not yet Identified
Central Papua, Papua
Highlands, and South Papua
1
Province
Revise the Draft Regional
Regulation on RUED-P
Papua
The Role of Local Governments in Supporting Solar PV Development
Local governments are responsible for
supporting the achievement of renewable
energy targets within the energy mix, as
outlined in the Regional Energy Plan (RUED-
P).
Energy Transition Roadmap
21 provinces that are members of the Association of Oil, Gas, and Renewable Energy Producing Regions have
developed an Energy Transition Roadmap, including Jakarta, NTB, Yogyakarta, West Java, Central Java, East Java, Aceh,
Lampung, Central Sulawesi, South Sumatra, East Kalimantan, Jambi, West Papua, South Sulawesi, and others.
33
SUPPORT FROM CENTRAL AND REGIONAL GOVERNMENTS IN THE
DEVELOPMENT OF RENEWABLE ENERGY
Based on Articles 53 and 56 of Government Regulation No. 40 of 2025 on the National Energy
Policy, the Central Government and Regional Governments, in promoting and maximizing the
development of new and renewable energy sources, shall undertake:
1. Identification and inventory of new energy sources, including type, location, capacity, and
economic feasibility;
2. Establishment of development plans for new energy sources;
3. Land allocation; and
4. Provision of necessary facilitation.
34
Support from all stakeholders is needed for the energy transition in Indonesia to proceed optimally.
Engaging in business activities
related to power generation
and fuels, supporting services,
job creation, contributions to
state revenue, and economic
activities
PRIVATE AND
SOE
Formulating policies,
regulations, and national
standards; providing
guidance and supervision;
and acting as a facilitator
in the development of
renewable energy and
energy conservation
programs.
GOVERNMENT
Educating the public
on the importance of
renewable energy and
disseminating
government programs
to the community in
an inclusive manner.
MEDIA
NGOs act as a balancing
force and partner to the
government, providing
advocacy and support
for communities,
conducting positive
campaigns, and actively
participating in the
development of
renewable energy.
NGO & CSO
Creating innovations in
the field of renewable
energy that can be
directly utilized by the
public, enhancing quality
human resources, and
promoting technology
transfer.
ACADEMY
PLTS Coca Cola Amatil 7,13
MWp
Director General of New, Renewable
Energy, and Energy Conservation
(EBTKE) at the Katadata SAFE 2024 event
COLLABORATION IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF ENERGY TRANSITION
35
Terima Kasih
www.ebtke.esdm.go.id
Jl. Pegangsaan Timur No.1,
Cikini, Menteng Jakarta
Address
Kementerian Energi dan
Sumber Daya Mineral
@KementerianESDM
@kesdm
@djebtke
KementerianESDM
36
Central Java
Provincial
Government
Energy Self-
Sufficient Village
• Integrate the Provincial RUED with the RPJMD so that regional solar
PV (PLTS) development plans are aligned with the regional
development agenda and can receive budgetary priority in the
APBD.
• Establish regional policies to promote the use of solar PV, both
rooftop and large-scale.
• Align spatial planning to support solar PV investment.
• Integrate solar PV into regional development programs, such as
energy self-sufficient villages.
• Facilitate permitting (IUPLTS; technical recommendations from PPKH,
KKPR, environmental permits, etc.).
• Act as a mediator regarding land acquisition or social issues.
• Provide incentives for the development, operation, and utilization of
renewable energy, such as ease of land use, including property tax
(PBB) incentives for buildings installing rooftop solar PV.
• Allocate APBD funds for solar PV projects in schools, hospitals, or
government offices.
• Offer local incentives, such as reductions in local levies/taxes for
rooftop or large-scale solar PV projects.
The Jakarta
Provincial
Government
Promotes rooftop
solar PV programs
in schools and gov’t
offices.
The Bali Provincial
Government
Promoting rooftop
solar PV
installations in
gov’t offices and
hotels through the
RUED regional
regulation policy.
Local Government Support in Solar PV
Development
37
Challenges in Renewable Energy Development
Economy and Financing
The initial investment costs for renewable energy projects tend to be high, while funding is limited and some projects
carry a high level of risk. Investment in renewable energy is estimated to be required up to 2034, amounting to
approximately IDR 1,682 trillion.
Regulation
Currently, the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) continues to work on improving the investment
climate through adequate regulations, including the recently issued Minister of ESDM Regulation No. 5 of 2025 on
Guidelines for Power Purchase Agreements for Renewable Energy Power Plants. Support is also needed to finalize
other related regulations.
Transmission Infrastructure
Investment is needed in the development of transmission and distribution networks that can connect
renewable energy sources with consumption centers.
Readiness of Domestic Industry
The development of local industries for producing renewable energy equipment and components is still limited. There
is a need to realize growth in domestic industries to support renewable energy development (e.g., solar module
manufacturing, wind turbines, geothermal turbines). It is also necessary to strengthen supporting industries for
biofuels, such as CPO, methanol, bioethanol, biojet fuel (SAF), and biogas.
Social Aspects
Support from the local community is needed at the sites of EBET power plant development. There is still some
resistance from the community toward geothermal projects in certain locations.
1
2
3
4
5
Mr. Hendra Irawan has extensive experience in managing
PLN’s regional operational units across Indonesia. He began as
Manager of SB RPOPSD at PLN UID DJTY (2018–2019), then
continued his leadership journey as Manager of UP3 Berau, East
Kalimantan (2019–2021), and UP3 Bengkulu, South Sumatra
Region (2021–2022). From 2022 to 2024, he served as Manager
of UP2K in West Nusa Tenggara Province. Currently, he leads
PLN UP3 Samarinda under the PLN UID Kaltimra
Hendra Irawan
Perusahaan Listrik Negara
(PLN)
Indonesia
www.pln.co.id |
1
RUPTL 2025 – 2034:
Beyond the
Greenest RUPTL
Present at:
The Indonesia Sustainable Energy Week Goes Regional (ISEWGR) in
Partnership with the International Forum for Coal Regions in
Transition
Theme :
The Role of Local Governments in Driving Renewable Energy
Investments in Coal Regions
PT PLN (Persero)
14 October 2025
Executive Summary
Based on the Decree of the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources of the Republic of
Indonesia No. 188.K/TL.04/MEM.L/2025, the Electricity Supply Business Plan (RUPTL) of
PT PLN (Persero) for 2025–2034 was officially approved on May 26, 2025.
At the national level, it is planned that 76% of new power generation will come from
renewable energy (RE) and storage, consisting of 42.6 GW (61%) of RE plants, including
500 MW of new/nuclear energy, and 10.3 GW (15%) of storage capacity. Meanwhile,
fossil-based generation will account for 16.6 GW (24%). The plan also projects the need
for 47,758 km of transmission lines and 107,950 MVA of substation capacity.
For East Kalimantan and North Kalimantan, the plan includes the development of 1.81
GW (47.42%) of RE-based generation, consisting of Solar PV + BESS (628 MW),
Hydropower (1,251 MW), and Biomass (10 MW). The Solar PV + BESS projects will be
developed gradually and are expected to reach COD in 2027 with a capacity of 80 MW
(including 50 MW of BESS), while the Hydropower Plant (300 MW) is scheduled to
reach COD in 2031. The transmission requirement for the region is estimated at 6,200
km, with substation capacity reaching 6,850 MVA.
www.pln.co.id |
3
We have sufficient geothermal energy.
We have an abundance of coal.
We have vast potential from hydropower.
We also have affordable technologies that can meet
our needs.
The government under my
leadership will focus on
achieving
energy self-sufficiency.
Prabowo Subianto
President of the Republic of Indonesia
www.pln.co.id |
4
Government Fiscal
Sustainability
Environmental
Sustainability
Electricity System
Reliability
Corporate
Financial
Sustainability
Energy
Security
MINISTRY OF ENERGY
MINERAL RESOURCES
REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA
www.pln.co.id |
42
In the electricity infrastructure planning outlined in the RUPTL
2025–2034, PLN comprehensively takes into account the five
elements of sustainability that are the focus of the Government of
Indonesia.
www.pln.co.id |
6
Indonesia needs CAPEX 171 USB Billion for developing
Renewable Energy and its infrastructure from 2025 to 2034
Source: PLN (2025)
www.pln.co.id |
7
In the RUPTL 2025–2034, 76%
of the additional power
generation capacity will come
from RE sources1
, including
nuclear energy and storage2
.
1 Renewable Energy (RE), equipped with Battery Energy
Storage System (BESS) for Variable RE (Wind and Solar)
2 Including Pumped Storage & BESS.
RUPTL 2025–2034, [GW]
Solar
17,1 GW
Geotherma
l
5,2 GW
Hydro
11,7 GW
Bioenerg
y
0,9 GW
Nuklir
0,5 GW
Pumped
Storage
4,3 GW
BESS
6,0 GW/27 GWh
Gas
10,3 GW
Coal
6,3 GW
EBT
42,1 GW
Wind
7,2 GW
Storage
10,3 GW
Non EBT
16,6 GW
Additional
generation
capacity
until 2034
69,5
GW
*Not including PV Rooftop 3 GW quota
*Including the plan for developing a Hybrid Coal-Fired Power Plant (PLTU
Hybrid) (Coal 1,2 GW, PLTS 0,3 GW dan BESS 0,15 GW)
The planned addition of power plants for 2025–2034 increases to
69.5 GW, consisting of 42.6 GW from RE plants and 10.3 GW from
energy storage.
The total investment in Indonesia’s power generation sector amounts to IDR
2,133.7 trillion.
• IPP Allocation:
• Total: IDR 1,566.1 trillion
• Renewable Energy (RE/NRE): IDR 1,341.8 trillion
• Non-Renewable: IDR 224.3 trillion
• PLN Allocation:
• Total: IDR 567.6 trillion
• Renewable Energy (RE/NRE): IDR 340.6 trillion
• Non-Renewable: IDR 227.0 trillion
Source: PLN (2025)
www.pln.co.id |
8
In the RUPTL 2025–2034, 76% of the
additional power generation capacity will
come from RE sources1
, including nuclear
energy and storage2
.
The RUPTL 2025–2034 will
accelerate the development of
new and renewable energy
while reducing Indonesia’s
dependence on coal.
With the massive development of
renewable energy power plants,
the share of new and
renewable energy in the
energy mix is projected to
increase 2.5 times, reaching
approximately 34.3% by 2034.
2024 2034
12,0%
34,3%
2,5 X
Renewable energy mix (%)
www.pln.co.id |
46
Power Plant Development 2025–2034
by Region
National
69,5
GW
15,1
GW
5,8
GW
4,7
GW
Sumatera
Jawa, Madura, Bali Sulawesi Maluku, Papua, Nusa Tenggara
Kalimantan
33,5
GW
10,4
GW
19,6 GW
9,5 GW 3,5 GW
RE Addition
7,7
GW 2,3 GW
RE Addition
RE Addition
RE Addition RE Addition
www.pln.co.id | 47
Mamberam
o
There is a mismatch between the potential
locations of Renewable Energy Sources and
the epicenter of demand.
Hydro
Geothermal
Solar PV
Wind
Legend:
Identified renewable
energy resources
New Additional
demand
www.pln.co.id
|
Bioenergy 11
“Green Enabling Super Grid”
will address the supply-demand mismatch, evacuate
renewable energy scattered in Sumatra, Kalimantan,
Sulawesi, and Nusa Tenggara to demand centers
Sumatra – Jawa (2031)
Interconnection Length: 1,174
kms
Sumatra – Batam (2031)
Interconnection Length: 560
kms
Kalimantan – Jawa (≥ 2034)
Interconnection Length: 1.098
kms
Sumba – Bali – Jawa (> 2040)
Interconnection Length: 1.846
kms
Kalimantan – Sulawesi (≥ 2040)
Interconnection Length: 680 kms
Maluku Transmission (≥ 2025)
Interconnection Length: 1.485
kms
Backbone 275 kV
Sulawesi (≥ 2026)
Backbone Length : 4.012 kms
Nusra Transmission (≥ 2025)
Transmission Length: 1.390
kms
Papua Transmission (≥ 2025)
Transmission Length: 1.008
kms
Additional Transmission
in the RUPTL 2025–2034
~48 thousand
kms transmission grid
Sumatra: 11.155 kms
Jawa-Madura-Bali: 13.889 kms
Kalimantan: 9.812 kms
Sulawesi: 9.019 kms
Maluku, Papua, Nusra: 3.883 kms
Additional Substations
in the RUPTL 2025–2034
~108 thousand
MVA Substations
Sumatra: 28.410 MVA
Jawa-Madura-Bali: 59.730 MVA
Kalimantan: 8.080 MVA
Sulawesi: 9.670 MVA
Maluku, Papua, Nusra: 2.060 MVA
www.pln.co.id
|
12
Solar PV Potential and Development Until 2034
Province Capacity (MW)
Aceh 313.46
Bali 679.39
Banten 675.8
Bengkulu 0.5
Gorontalo 51
Jambi 100
Jawa Barat 3781
Jawa Tengah 3808
Jawa Timur 1987.455
Kalimantan Barat 448.675
Kalimantan Selatan 6.68
Kalimantan Tengah 215.56
Kalimantan Timur 546.872
Kalimantan Utara 306.24
Kepulauan Bangka Belitung 51.5
Kepulauan Riau 38.4
Lampung 388.77
Maluku 124.171
Maluku Utara 228.942
Nusa Tenggara Barat 333.5804
Nusa Tenggara Timur 279.07
Papua 126.829
Papua Barat 38.69
Papua Barat Daya 52.05461
Papua Pegunungan 135.557
Papua Selatan 37.5918
Papua Tengah 113.866
Riau 10.07
Sulawesi Barat 0.346
Sulawesi Selatan 1153.073
Sulawesi Tengah 54.448
Sulawesi Tenggara 132.702
Sulawesi Utara 138.373
Sumatera Barat 35.74
Sumatera Selatan 304.91
Sumatera Utara 362.29
Total 17,061.61
0,8 1 1,1
2,3
1,6 1,5 1,7
2,1
3,9
1,2
0
2
4
6
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034
Solar Additional Capacity based on RUPTL 2025-2034
Solar PV Configuration
• Ground Mounted PV
• Built on open land with
supporting structures, either
fixed or capable of following
the sun’s direction (tracking
system).
• Advantages: Flexible for
large-capacity designs, easy
to maintain.
• Challenges: Requires
extensive land (1 MW = 1–1.5
ha), potential land-use
conflicts.
• Floating PV
• Built on a floating structure placed
on the surface of water such as
reservoirs, lakes, or former mining
ponds.
• Advantages: land use efficiency,
natural cooling effect, reduces water
evaporation.
• Challenges: higher initial costs,
greater risk of damage, and requires
extra maintenance.
www.pln.co.id |
tech7energy.co
m
• Solar Rooftop
• Installed on the roof of a
building, such as a house, office,
warehouse, or industrial facility.•
• Advantages: space-efficient,
close to the electrical load.
• Challenges: limited by roof size
and orientation; roof structure
must be strong.
1 2 3
Source: PLN (2025)
www.pln.co.id |
EXISTING ENERGY MIX CONDITIONS IN EAST KALIMANTAN – NORTH KALIMANTAN
Planned 500 KV
Planned 150 KV
ENERGY MIX
COMPOSITION OF POWER PLANT
SOURCE TYPES
IPP
59%
PLN
39%
EXCESS
POWER
2%
PLTU (CFPP) GRAHA POWER KALTIM 200 MW
PLTU INDOEKA 200 MW
PLTU CAHAYA FAJAR KALTIM 95 MW
PLTU MUARA JAWA 55 MW
PLTGU (Gas and Steam) SENIPAH 117 MW
PLTS (Solar) 50 MW
TOTAL : 717 MW
PLTU KARIANGAU 180 MW
PLTG PEAKING 140 MW
PLTGU TANJUNG BATU 45,6 MW
PLTG (Gas) SAMBERA 18 MW
PLTMG (Gas Engine) BONTANG 47,44 MW
PLTD (Diesel) 49,49 MW
TOTAL : 480,53 MW
PLTU KARIANGAU POWER 15 MW
PLTBG (Biogas) PMM 2 MW
TOTAL : 17 MW
The current energy mix of PLN Kaltimra’s electricity is still dominated by coal energy at
24.59%, while the share of renewable energy from solar power plants (PLTS) is 0.85%.
PLTU
62.30%
PLTBG
0.17%
PLTS
0.85%
PLTD
4.20%
PLTMG
4.02%
PLTGU
3.87%
PLTG
24.59%
www.pln.co.id |
North and East Kalimantan Energy Mix 2025-2034
In the ARED scenario, renewable energy production in 2034 increases 33-fold compared to 2025, the
share of renewable energy in the energy mix reaches 47.42% in 2034, and the share of coal decreases
to 20.63%.
Energy Mix 2034
EBT
2034 :
47,42 %
Coal
2034 :
2,87%
2034 :
20,63%
2025 :
3,36%
Gas/LNG
2034 :
2025 : 29,08%
27,13%
BBM/Gasoline
2025 :
20,51%
2025 :
49 %
3,4% 3,5% 5,7%
11,7%
17,3% 19,9%
32,6%
39,3% 42,0%
47,4%
27,1%
41,5%
48,6%
46,6%
43,7%
44,0%
37,0%
33,3%
32,1%
29,1%
20,5%
12,8%
10,6%
8,1%
7,6% 5,3%
4,5%
4,0% 3,2%
2,9%
49,0%
42,2%
35,0% 33,6% 31,5% 30,8%
25,9% 23,4% 22,8% 20,6%
2025 2026 2027 2033 2034
2028 2029
EBT GAS/LNG
2030 2031
2032
BBM BATUBARA
www.pln.co.id |
DEVELOPMENT OF RENEWABLE ENERGY POWER PLANTS
AT UID KALTIMRA (EAST AND NORTH KALIMANTAN DISTRIBUTION MAIN UNIT)
No
RE
Plants
Satuan 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 Total
1 Geothermal MW
2 Hydro MW 146 80 125 351
3 Microhydro MW 0,2 0,2
4 Solar MWp 51* 10,5 93 240 15 78 50 537
5 BESS MW 50 150 25 225
6 Solar + BESS MW 9,5 9,5
Jumlah MW 51 10,5 143 390 15,2 103 146 139,5 125 1.122,7
Total RE Capacity 2025 - 2034: 1.122,7 MW
* IKN Solar Power Plant 50 MW is now operational
In the ARED scenario, it is planned that the addition of renewable energy power plants will gradually
increase from 2025 to 2034, utilizing the abundant renewable energy potential from hydro and solar
power plants.
www.pln.co.id |
18
Utilization of Reservoir/Dam and Former Mine Solar Power Plants
Based on the letter from the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (EBTKE) dated
December 1, 2023, which follows up on the letter from the Minister of Public Works and
Public Housing (PUPR) dated August 2, 2023, regarding the Potential Utilization of Floating
Solar Power Plants (PLTS) in Dams, the total potential for floating solar power in PU dams
across Indonesia—identified based on the assumption of 20% of the existing/on-going dam
area—is 13.9 GW, distributed across 109 existing/on-going reservoir locations.
No. Dams Area (Ha) Capacity 20%
(MW)
Dam Status
1 Merancang 587 117,46 Existing
2 Samboja 202 40,37 Existing
3 Lempake 135 27,08 Existing
4 Manggar 403 80,6 Existing
5 Beriwit 330 66,07 Existing
6 Sepaku Semoi 335 66,93 On Going
7 Marangkayu 258 51,63 On Going
Total 2250 450,14
List of Potential Solar PV Installations at
Ministry of Public Works (KemenPU) Dams
Floating PV
Source: RUPTL 2025 – 2034
(Kementrian ESDM (EBTKE) Tahun 2024)
www.pln.co.id |
19
Solar Power Plant & BESS Development
Plan
No System Type Power Plant Capacity (MW) Scenario of COD
RE Base
Scenario of COD
ARED
Status Developer
1 Mahakam Solar IKN 50,0 2025 2025 On Construction IPP
2 Mahakam Solar Kalseltengtimra-1 (PLTS+BESS) 80,0 2027 2027 Planned SH-PLN
3 Mahakam BESS Kalseltengtimra-1 (PLTS+BESS) 50,0 2027 2027 Planned SH-PLN
4 Mahakam Solar Kalseltengtimra-2 (PLTS+BESS) 240,0 - 2028 Planned IPP
5 Mahakam BESS Kalseltengtimra-2 (PLTS+BESS) 150,0 - 2028 Planned IPP
6 Mahakam Solar Kalseltengtimra (Kuota) Tersebar 15,0 2029 2029 Planned IPP
7 Mahakam Solar Kalseltengtimra (Kuota) Tersebar 30,0 2030 2030 Planned IPP
8 Mahakam Solar Kalseltengtimra-4 (PLTS+BESS) 40,0 - 2030 Planned IPP
9 Mahakam BESS Kalseltengtimra-4 (PLTS+BESS) 25,0 - 2030 Planned IPP
10 Mahakam Solar Kalseltengtimra (Kuota) Tersebar 50,0 2033 2033 Planned IPP
11 Isolated Solar
Village Electricity (Program) in East
Kalimantan
1,3 2025 2025 Planned PLN
12 Isolated Solar 10,5 2026 2026 Planned PLN
13 Isolated Solar 12,1 2027 2027 Planned PLN
14 Isolated Solar De-dieselization 0,9 2027 2027 Procured IPP
15 Isolated Solar Isolated Kaltim 7,7 2030 2030 Planned IPP
16 Isolated Solar+BESS Isolated Kaltim 9,5 2033 2033 Planned IPP
Jumlah 1.677,0
The listed PV+BESS capacity (MW) represents the estimated capacity supplying the system, while the fixed PV capacity and BESS MWh will be
further assessed according to system requirements, reliability, and optimal economic feasibility. The location of the PV+BESS installation is not
fixed in this province and can be adjusted to other provinces, either centralized in a single location or distributed across multiple locations,
depending on the results of further system requirement studies.
Source: RUPTL 2025 – 2034
Kalimantan Substation Development Plan 2025
1. The development of transmission under the Base and
Accelerated Renewable Energy Development (ARED) scenarios
requires the construction of 500 kV extra-high voltage (EHV)
overhead lines (SUTET) to optimize the potential of existing
hydroelectric power plants.
2. The development of 500 kV EHV transmission lines (SUTET)
from 2025–2034 for the Base and ARED scenarios in
Kalimantan includes the construction of Extra-High Voltage
Substations (GITET) at Kaltara – Tanjung Selor – Embalut – IKN –
Balikpapan.
: Transmission 500 kV (Planned)
: Hydro potential
500 kV
North Kalimantan –
East Kalimantan
Trafo 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 Jumlah
500/275 kV - - - - - - - - - - -
500/150 kV - - - - - - 4.000 - - - 4.000
500 kV DC - - - - - - - - - - -
275/150 kV - - - - - - - - - - -
150/115 kV - - - - - - - - - - -
150/20 kV 450 360 300 720 510 540 360 240 300 300 4.080
70/20 kV - - - - - - - - - - -
Total 450 360 300 720 510 540 4,360 240 300 300 8.080
: Transmission 150 kV (Existing)
: Hydro on RUPTL
: Transmission 150 kV (Planned)
www.pln.co.id |
57
Rencana Gardu Induk (MVA)
Desc
Tahun Grand
Total
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034
Investmen
t
987.31 927.76 580.02 1,000.93 241.47 784.96 2,554.55 549.14 271.67 240.60 8,138.41
(Billion Rp)
The execution of the 2025–2034 RUPTL is projected to absorb 1.7 million
workers, covering the needs of the manufacturing, construction, operations, and
maintenance sectors for electricity infrastructure. In line with the energy
transition, 91% of the workforce in the power generation sector are green jobs.
RUPTL 2025–2034 will absorb
1,7 million workers
836.696 workers in
the Power Generation
sector (760 thousand
workers, or 91%, are
green jobs in the
renewable energy sector)
881.132 workforce in
the Transmission,
Substation, and Distribution
sectors
14w.pln.co.id
|
w
w
www.pln.co.id |
22
Not only that, investments in the 2025–2034 RUPTL will provide a multiplier
effect for the national economy, thereby also supporting the vision of
achieving an economic growth target of 8% by 2029
323
340
360
378
396
313
324
338
351
365
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029
Demand RUPTL
2025 - 2034
Demand
Natural
Growth
GDP
Growth
8%
GDP
Growth
5,2%
Industrial Zone
(KI)
Downstreaming
Special Economy
Zone (KEK)
Multiplier Effect RUPTL
Electricity Sales Projection, TWh
www.pln.co.id |
59
Integrated Marine
and Fisheries
Center (SKPT)
Electric Vehicle
(EV) Ecosystem
Super-Priority
Tourism Destination
(DPSP)
TERIMA KASIH
Rizal Fernandy
Borneo Energy Harapan
Mr. Rizal Fernandy has over 25 years of experience in the energy
sector, covering solar photovoltaic (PV), oil and gas projects, and
maintenance engineering. Holding a Bachelor’s degree in Electrical
Engineering from the University of Indonesia and a Master’s degree
in Technology Management from Institut Teknologi Sepuluh
Nopember.
He has worked with major companies such as North Oil Company
in Qatar, Total EP in Indonesia, France, and Nigeria, and
Pertamina Hulu Mahakam. Since 2017, he has led solar PV
development through Borneo Energy Harapan, building
partnerships with developers, governments, universities, and
industries.
IMPLEMENTING SOLAR PV
IN EAST KALIMANTAN PROVINCE
Presented by
Rizal Fernandy
Solar Energy Potential
Total technical potential
capacity per technology
that can be applied in
Indonesia
Source : IESR (2021). Beyond 443 GW: Indonesia’s infinite renewable energy potentials. Institute for Essential Services Reform
6,749.3
GW
7,308.8
GWh
19.8
GW
at 100 m hub
height
30.73
GWh
6.3
GW
1,100.71
GW
518.6
GWh
0.0 MW
at 100 m hub
height
2,395.0
MWh
254.5
MW
193.80
GW
24.2
GWh
86.7 MW
at 100 m hub
height
866.3
MWh
35.7
MW
135.59
GW
228.6
GWh
0.0 MW
at 100 m hub
height
552.1
MWh
192.4
MW
586.46
GW
141.1
GWh
0.0 MW
at 100 m hub
height
3,766.7
MWh
95.8
MW
983.49
GW
342.8
GWh
0.0 MW
at 100 m hub
height
2,998.1
MWh
251.2
MW
Indonesia
East Kalimantan
South Kalimantan
North Kalimantan
Central Kalimantan
West Kalimantan
Solar Energy Potential
Government
Commitment
to Energy
Transition Suitable Area
26,846.08 km2
Technical capacity
1,100.71 GWp
High Solar
Irradiation
Level
Industrial and
Mining Sector
Demand
Large
Available Land
Area
Strategic
Geographical
Location
Source : IESR (2021). Beyond 443 GW: Indonesia’s infinite renewable energy potentials. Institute for Essential Services Reform
Energy Cost
Savings
Investment &
Job
Opportunities
Economic
Benefit
Based on the 2025–2034 RUPTL, the Solar Power
Generation (PLTS) sector is projected to be able to
create employment opportunities for up to
348,057 workers in the generation segment.
8%
Support national
economic growth
through increased
electricity demand
Energy
Independence
Environmental Benefits
1 MWp PLTS can avoid
±900–1,000 tonnes of
CO₂/year (equivalent to
200 petrol cars stopping
operation).
Emission
Reduction
Reduced SO₂, NOx, and
particulate emissions from
PLTU = improved air
quality & public health.
Air Quality &
Health
Supporting Kaltim Green
Province and the 2060 Net
Zero Emission target
Contribution
to the Net
Zero Target
Simplify permitting process,
provincial regulation, and
Integrate solar development
Regulatory & Policy
Support
Tax and retribution exemptions,
Public co-funding or matching
grants, and Green investment
Financial &
Investment
Incentives Develop local technical skills,
conduct public awareness
campaigns, and Encourage
research collaboration
Capacity Building &
Public Awareness
Foster coordination among
government, PLN, private sector,
academia, and communities for faster
and sustainable solar growth.
Strategic Collaboration
Provincial
Government
Support
Needed
Strong provincial support will accelerate solar
adoption, attract private investment, create green
jobs, and reduce emissions and positioning East
Kalimantan as a leading province in Indonesia’s
energy transition.
Expected Impact
Challenges
and Barriers
Regulatory
Uncertainty
Limited Local
Manufacturing
and Supply
Chain
Weather and
Maintenance
Challenges
Grid Readiness
and
Interconnection
Limits
High Initial
Investment
Skill Labour
Type of PLTS Main Users / Beneficiaries Developed By Installed Capacity (kWp)
Centralized PLTS Rural Communities
East Kalimantan Provincial
Government
2,013.5
Rooftop PLTS
PLN Customers (Exim) /
Households
Individuals 1,148
Wilus / Community-based PLTS General Public Local Business Area 1,243
IPP PLTS PLN (State Utility) Nusantara Sembcorp Solar Energy 50,000
Captive Power (IUPTLS / Self-use) Private Sector Companies 12,752
Total Installed Capacity 67,156.9
Solar Power Plants (PLTS) in
East Kalimantan Province
Source : ESDM Pemprov Kaltim (2025)
PT. Listrik
Kaltim
(PERUSDA)
8.6kWp
Department of
Manpower and
Transmigration
51.6kWp
East Kalimantan
Government Buildings
Ministry of
Religion
57.2kWp
Forestry
Service
105.8kWp
Initial
Development
for 30 Gov.
Buildings
2MW
Animal
Husbandry
Department
13.3kWp
Universitas
Tanjung Pura,
Pontianak
1.51MW
OIKN,
Penajam Paser
Utara, Kaltim
50MW
PLTS
Installed in
Kalimantan
Adaro, Kelanis,
Kalteng
598kWp
Future Plan: 3
MW
ITM - CPI,
Bontang, Kaltim
3MWp + 3MWH
Coal Mining Industries
Borneo
Indobara,
Angsana &
Kusan, Kalsel
229.4kWp
Kideco Jaya
Agung, Paser,
Kaltim
1MW
Berau Coal
Future Plan
(Floating)
3MW +
2MWH BESS
Berau Coal,
Berau, Kaltim
789.3kWP
Future Plan
(Floating)
3MW + 2MWH
BESS
IDEC AWI,
Tarakan,
Kaltara
974.3kWp
BKA,
Samarinda,
Kaltim
1.12MW
Tarjun,
Kotabaru,
Kalsel
19.7MW
Gaia Mall,
Kubu Raya,
Kalbar
1.49 MW
Comercial and Industries
Badak LNG,
Bontang,
Kaltim
3MW
Pertamina RU
V, Balikpapan,
Kaltim
2.5MW
Kaltim Daya
Mandiri (KDM),
Bontang,
Kaltim
3.9MW
Oil and Gas Industries
Thank You
Presented by
Rizal Fernany
Coffee Break
Feel free to visit us on
jetknowledge.org
Join our community
Subscribe to our newsletter
• Regular digests of the latest just transition news,
commentary, publications and events
• Mix of content from coal regions across the world to
encourage knowledge sharing and positive exchange
between countries
International Experiences for Just Energy
Transition Energy & Framework Conditions
International Forum for Coal Regions in Transition 2025
Eloïse O’Carroll, EU
Delegation Office,
Jakarta
Edwin Mametja,
Nkangala District
Municipality, South
Africa
Session 2
Karem Castro,
Transforma,
Colombia
Ranvijay Kumar
Singh, CCO, India
Eloïse O’Carroll,
EU Delegation, Jakarta
Eloïse O’Carroll is the Programme Manager for Forestry,
Natural Resources, and Energy at the EU Delegation to Indonesia,
leading on the Just Energy Transition Partnership (JETP) and
industrial decarbonisation. She also supports carbon pricing and
markets diplomacy with Indonesian ministries and works on
forestry, agricultural commodities, and development cooperation.
Previously posted in Vietnam, she co-led the EU’s JETP efforts
and supported the EU Deforestation Regulation. With prior
experience in the private sector on carbon markets and
sustainability, Eloïse holds an MSc in Environment and
Development from LSE and a BA in Economics and Development
from McGill University.
The just energy transition
Insights from the EU
experience
Eloise O’Carroll
EU Delegation to Indonesia
October 2025
What is the EU doing to achieve Climate Neutrality?
The European Climate Law sets binding targets for the EU to reduce net GHG emissions
by at least 55% by 2030 compared to 1990 levels and reach net zero emissions by 2050.
EU Climate policy architecture
• Emissions Trading System (EU ETS)
• Emissions reduction in ETS sectors: -47.6% below 2005 levels and -16.5% in
2023 compared to 2022 (-24% for electricity and power generation).
• EU ETS revenues: EUR 43.6 billion in 2023 (more than EUR 200 billion since
2013).
• Effort Sharing Regulation for Member States (ESR)
National targets for reducing GHG emissions in mainly road transport,
buildings, agriculture, and waste. Covers most methane emissions in the
EU.
• Land Use, Land Use Change, and Forestry (LULUCF)
National target to increase removals and reduce emissions from natural
carbon sinks.
The European Green Deal, the European Climate Law and the ‘Fit for 55’
Legislative Package set binding targets for the EU to be climate neutral by
2050 and to reduce net GHG emissions by at least 55% by 2030
Renewable Energy Directive
• Legal framework for RE
development in the EU.
• Establishes common rules
and sets mandatory
targets for the bloc.
• EU target of 42.5% - 45%
RE by 2030
• In 2023: 24.5% gross final
energy consumption
(electricity, heat, cooling
and transport) was from
RE
The Just Transition Mechanism (JTM)
to support regions most affected by the climate transition in all Member States
Provides
primarily
grants
Crowds in
private
investment
Leverages
public
financing
Territorial just transition plans (TJTPs) give access to all 3 pillars
Just Transition
Fund
EUR 19.7 billion
InvestEU
Dedicated Just
Transition
Scheme
EUR 10-15 billion
(estimated)
Public sector loan
facility with the EIB
EUR 13.3 – 15.3 billion
(estimated)
The Just Transition Fund (JTF)
One of the main elements of the European Green Deal growth strategy
Established in the framework of EU Cohesion Policy (2021 – 2027 period)
Governance
Place-based approach:
Territorial Just Transition
Plans (TJTPs) established at
national or regional level -
outlining the transition pathway,
negative impacts, most affected
territories and alleviating
measures
Focus and scope
Supports investments in an
integrated way:
Supports territories and groups
most severely impacted by the
transition towards a climate-
neutral economy
€ 19.7 billion
(mainly grants)
€ 27 billion
incl.
national co-
financing
Environment and energy
(e.g. brownfield rehabilitation,
renewable energy)
Economic diversification
(e.g. business and
innovation support)
People and skills (e.g. re-
and upskilling of workers)
…leaving no-one
behind in the
transition
First pillar of the Just Transition Mechanism (JTM)
+ Strengthened partnership
State of play
Implementation in progress
… all 70 TJTPs were adopted
… 38% of the fund allocated in
approved projects
→
The JTF in regions
96 just transition territories
 Territories dependent on the extraction or production
of coal, lignite, peat and oil shale – these are
expected to decline, leading to job losses and other
negative impacts
 Territories dependent on carbon-intensive industries
such as steel, cement or chemicals – these which
need to fundamentally transform, leading to changes
in skills and job profiles as well as other impacts
The JTF in numbers
Distribution per Member State (EUR, billion)
6.63 / 34
%
3.59 / 18
%
3.14 / 16
%
1.88 / 10
%
1.79 / 9
%
Enterprises and
diversification
Clean energy
Skills, job-search and
education
RTDI
Regeneration of sites
TA and public
administration
Sustainable local mobility
Other
Circular Economy
Social infrastructure
Distribution per theme (EUR, billion + %)
PL
DE
RO
CZ
EL
BG
FR
IT
ES
NL
FI
SK
EE
LT
HU
SI
PT
LV
HR
BE
SE
AT
CY
DK
IE
MT
LU
3.85
2.48
2.14
1.64
1.38
1.20
1.03
1.03
0.87
0.62
0.47
0.46
0.35
0.27
0.26
0.26
0.22
0.19
0.19
0.18
0.16
0.14
0.10
0.09
0.08
0.02
0.01
The JTF in practice (approved projects)
Addressing immediate challenges Supporting economic diversification
Renewables and green H2
Belgium:
Hydrogen production unit in
Frameries – setting up the
production of renewable
hydrogen (electrolysis of
water using local renewable
electricity from two wind
turbines).
Slovakia:
The use of geothermal energy
in the
Košice valley – increasing
share of renewable energy
sources in a district heating
system in by tapping into the
geothermal potential of the
region.
Employment
Poland: Jobs after coal – re-
skilling and up-skilling of 2200
participants, primarily former
employees of mines and power
plants affected by phasing out
from lignite energy production in
the Konin subregion.
Brownfields
Czechia: POHO park –
revitalising the area of a former
mine into a post-mining centre /
campus, offering the necessary
facilities to visitors and potential
investors.
RDI, skills and entrepreneurship
Sweden: H2-Labs, Norrbotten –
developing a test bed that will
explore solutions for the production
of renewable hydrogen.
Croatia: Center of gaming industry
in Novska, developing local talent
and businesses in the video game
industry.
Productive investments
Estonia: Magnet factory in Narva –
construction of a factory producing
rare earth magnets, including an
R&D centre for new materials and
applications for magnets, creating
1000 jobs.
Supporting the energy transition
Questions?
Terima kasih banyak! / Thank you!
Eloise.ocarroll@eeas.europa.eu
Mr. Edwin Mametja is the Divisional Manager: Climate Change
and Biodiversity at the Nkangala District Municipality in
Mpumalanga, South Africa. He is a Professional Environmental
Scientist (SACNASP) with over 16 years of experience in climate
change governance, sustainability planning, water resource
management, and natural resource conservation in the public
sector.
Mr. Mametja leads the District’s Just Transition, Climate
Change and Biodiversity programmes, driving the integration
of sustainability and resilience into local development
planning.
Edwin Mametja
Nkangala District
Municipality, South
Africa
“Working together with the people to push back the frontiers of poverty”
Access to basic services for all !
Victor Khanye
Dr JS Moroka
Emakhazeni
Emalahleni
Steve Tshwete
Thembisile
South Africa: Integrating the dimensions of Just Transition into the
transformation of the energy system in Mpumalanga -
Incorporating Vulnerable and Disadvantaged Groups .
ISEW Goes Regional , Oct 2025
NKANGALA
District Municipality
“Working together with the people to push back the frontiers of poverty”
Access to basic services for all !
Presentation Content
• Setting the Scene: South Africa’s Energy and Social Context
• Why Inclusion Matters: Building a People-Centred Transition
• National and Provincial Interventions: Turning Policy into Action
• Local Action: The Case of Nkangala District
• Conclusion and Recommendations
“Working together with the people to push back the frontiers of poverty”
Access to basic services for all !
South Africa’s Energy Landscape and Social Imperative
• In 2023 ~80 % of electricity was from coal, mainly in
Mpumalanga, where jobs and local revenue depend
on mining.
• Coal’s share declined to ~74 % (2025) as renewables
reached 17 % of generation.
• The shift is inevitable: ageing plants, air pollution, and
new climate targets under the Climate Change Act
(2024) and JET Investment Plan (2023–2027).
• Coal regions remain vulnerable—high unemployment,
inequality, and energy poverty.
• Over 90 000 direct coal jobs are at risk, demanding a
transition that protects livelihoods.
• A just energy transition must leave no one behind—
creating new, inclusive opportunities.
Distribution of South Africa’s power generation facilities,
Eskom, 2023
“Working together with the people to push back the frontiers of poverty”
Access to basic services for all !
Why Inclusion Matters: Linking Energy Transition to Social Justice
• South Africa’s transition unfolds amid deep
inequality and >40 % youth unemployment in
coal regions.
• Women, youth, and informal workers remain
excluded from most energy and technical
opportunities.
• The Just Transition Framework (PCC, 2022)
calls for equity, participation, and social
dialogue as guiding principles.
• The Climate Change Act (2024) mandates a
just and equitable transition that safeguards
livelihoods.
• Inclusion turns climate action into shared
opportunity — ensuring no one is left behind.
“Working together with the people to push back the frontiers of poverty”
Access to basic services for all !
National and Provincial Interventions: Turning Policy into Action
• JET Investment Plan (2023–2027): R1.5 trillion
investment pipeline for energy, transport, skills, and
green industries.
• Presidential Climate Commission (PCC): coordinates
implementation and ensures justice, inclusion, and
dialogue.
• Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the
Environment (DFFE) and DMRE: mainstream climate
and energy justice into national policy.
• Mpumalanga Green Cluster Agency (MGCA):
promotes green manufacturing, circular economy, and
clean innovation.
• Provincial & District Governments: localise transition
through District Development Model (DDM) —
integrating JET into IDPs and LED strategies.
“Working together with the people to push back the frontiers of poverty”
Access to basic services for all !
Local Action: The Case of Nkangala District, Mpumalanga’s Coal Heartland
• Nkangala District Municipality, situated in the
Mpumalanga Province is composed of six local
municipalities with a total population of just over 1.5
million
• Heavily dependent on coal mining (42 coal mines),
energy (8 coal powered) as drivers of its economy
making it an epicentre of JT
• High vulnerability to climate risks: droughts, flooding,
temperature extremes (CSIR Greenbook, 2024).
• High unemployment (37.4% in Q2 2024) and poverty
rates (51.2% in 2023) limit the capacity of
communities to adapt to climate challenges and
participate in the green economy, exacerbate
vulnerability.
• Need to enhance resilience and ensuring a just
transition through Supporting Climate Adaptation and
Mitigation, Promoting Economic Diversification in line
with the JET IP
“Working together with the people to push back the frontiers of poverty”
Access to basic services for all !
Key Local Interventions (Aligned to Just Transition and Inclusion)
Focus Area Initiative Alignment / Inclusion Element
Governance & Institutional Readiness Mainstreaming Just Transition and Climate
Change into the Integrated Development Plan
(IDP) and District Climate Change Forum.
Strengthens local leadership and accountability
mechanisms for inclusive climate action.
Economic Diversification Promoting circular economy, green
manufacturing, and entrepreneurship incubation.
Established partnership with GIZ –JUST SA and
NBI for JT Bankable Business Plans, MGCA
Creates local green enterprises and unlocks
SME participation in new markets
Green Skills Development & Enterprise Support
for Just Transition
Partnership with SETAs for reskilling and
Upskiling, Indalopreneurship Programme to
support eco-inclusive startups and youth
enterprises in waste, energy, and agri-
innovation. Training equipping youth &
communities in solar, LPG installation and
maintenance
Builds employability and inclusion for vulnerable
groups entering green jobs.
Sustainable Agriculture & Food Systems UN Women – NDM – DARDLEA Climate-Smart
Agriculture and Agri-prenure Programme (2025–
2027) training 200 emerging farmers and
Enhances food security, income generation, and
climate resilience for women, youth, and persons
with disabilities
Clean Energy Access & Social Innovation KwaZamokuhle Clean Cooking Pilot (EWSETA,
DEE and Munic) deploying LPG/gas stoves to
low-income households
Reduces indoor pollution, improves energy
equity, and enables community-level clean
energy expertise.
Community Awareness and Dialogs Ongoing Community Engagements on Climate
Change Mitigation and Adaptation & JT
Builds shared understanding and social
cohesion.
“Working together with the people to push back the frontiers of poverty”
Access to basic services for all !
Key Local Interventions (Aligned to Just Transition and Inclusion)
Focus Area Initiative Alignment / Inclusion Element
Career Expo on Green Industries Expose learners and graduates to opportunities
in renewable energy, environmental sciences,
and circular economy sectors
Builds youth aspirations, inclusion, and
skills-to-job linkages
Circular Economy & Eco-Brick Initiative Eco-brick and Waste Valorisation Project
repurposes fly ash and waste plastics for local
brick-making and paving.
Promotes green enterprises, creates local jobs,
and empowers cooperatives.
Komati Training Centre (JET Skills Hub) The Komati Training Centre, established through
Eskom’s JET initiative, provides technical
training in renewable energy installation,
operation, and maintenance for local
communities.
Supports re-skilling, enterprise development,
and inclusion of youth and women in new green
industries
“Working together with the people to push back the frontiers of poverty”
Access to basic services for all !
“Working together with the people to push back the frontiers of poverty”
Access to basic services for all !
“Working together with the people to push back the frontiers of poverty”
Access to basic services for all !
CONCLUSION
• The NDM is committed to catalyze Nkangala District’s transition to a sustainable, climate-resilient
future by creating green jobs, empowering marginalized communities, and reducing reliance on coal.
• Invest climate-resilient infrastructure and green energy projects.
• Prioritize interventions to address critical vulnerabilities such as water scarcity, flooding, and energy
transition challenge
• Strengthen Collaboration and Partnerships
• Focus on economic diversification programs to support communities impacted by the transition away
from coal.
• Establish a robust monitoring and evaluation system for ongoing climate programs to track progress
and identify gaps.
“Working together with the people to push back the frontiers of poverty”
Access to basic services for all !
Thank
you
Technical and Strategic Coordinator of Transforma's Energy
Area and the Coordinator of the Just Energy Transition
Observatory. A Chemical Engineer with a PhD in Energy
Systems Engineering and a Master’s degree in Chemical
Engineering. With experience in the energy sector, with a
strong focus on the just energy transition, sustainable energy
systems, and environmental management. The background
includes research and technical development in salt gradient
power generation, exergy analysis, and process optimization, as
well as the management, coordination, and formulation of
engineering projects. Additionally, contributed to clean
development mechanism initiatives, carbon markets, and
strategies aimed at promoting a low-carbon economy.
Karem Castro
Transforma, Colombia
Bio…
Ranvijay Kumar Singh
CCO, India
Lunch
Feel free to visit us on
jetknowledge.org
Strategies for Economic Diversification and
Transformation in Coal Regions
International Forum for Coal Regions in Transition 2025
Yusliando,
Bappeda East
Kalimantan,
Indonesia
Hari Wibawa,
Bappeda of South
Sumatra, Indonesia
Session 3
Timon Wehnert,
Wuppertal Institute
for Climate,
Environment and
Energy
Götz von
Stumpfeldt, IKI JET
Project (GIZ),
Germany
Wahyu Gatut Purboyo
Bappeda East Kalimantan,
Indonesia
Mr. Wahyu Gatut Purboyo has over seven years of
experience in environmental management and
regional economic planning. From 2017 to 2023, he
served as Head of Environmental Pollution Control at
the Provincial Environmental Agency of East
Kalimantan.
Since 2023, he has held the position of Head of
Economic and Natural Resources Division at the
Regional Development Planning Agency (Bappeda) of
East Kalimantan Province.
REGIONALCONSULTATIONFORUM(FORUM
KONSULTASIDAERAH):
Driving East Kalimantan’s Economic
Transformation Beyond Coal
Yusliando
Head of Bappeda East Kalimantan
BAPPEDA
PROV. KALTIM
Population 2024 : 4.045,86 thousand people
 2.093,90 thousand
people (M)
 1.951,96 thousand
people (F)
Projection for 2045 : 6,5 thousand people
Economic Growth : 6,12% (y-o-y Tw IV 2024)
Economic Growth : 6,17 (2024)
Unemployment Rate : 5,14% (2024)
GRDP Value (ADHB) : Rp858,43 Trillion (2024)
HDI Value : 78,79 (2024)
Poverty Rate : 5,78% (2024)
Gini Index : 0,321 (2024)
GRDP per Capita : Rp212,18 Million (2024)
Area Size : 15,34 Million Ha
Protected Area : 19,38%
Cultivation Area : 80,62% (56,17% Forest Area)
Geostrategic Position : ALKI II
Coal Resources : 97,297 Billion Ton
Coal Reserves : 31,713 Billion Ton
Oil Reserves : 166,16 MMTSB
Natural Gas Reserves : 996,37 BSCF
Palm Oil Plantation Area : 1,47 Million Ha (2023)
UU 3/2022 amended by UU 21/2023 concerning
IKN dan Perpres No 63/2022 :
• To become partner to IKN
• To become the Economic Superhub for IKN
Source: BPS Prov. Kaltim, RPJPD 2025-2049 Prov Kaltim, dan RTRW Prov. Kaltim 2023-2042
OVERVIEW OF EAST KALIMANTAN
EAST KALIMANTAN ECONOMIC STRUCTURE
Baseline 2025 Target 2029 Target 2034 Target 2039 Target 2045
Processing Industry's Contribution to GRDP
(%) 17,75 – 18,00 21,39 – 24,52 25,05 – 31,05 28,68 – 37,57 32,32 – 44,09
Provincial GRDP Contribution (%) 4,20 4,98 5,45 5,67 5,76
GRDP per Capita(in Million Rupiah)
225,27 – 226,88 415,80 – 523,80 550,80 – 760,80
658,80 –
1.000,80
850,00 –
1.289,73
East Kalimantan Provincial Regulation Number 11 of 2024 concerning RPJPD of East Kalimantan Province for 2025-2045:
Source:
BPS Prov. Kaltim
2005 2010 2015 2020 2025
Processing Industry (%) 32,66 33,43 33,28 33,31 33,34
Mining & Quarrying (%) 25,96 20,74 17,06 15,29 12,43
Agriculture, Fisheries, Livestock, Plantations
(%) 6,75 12,55 16,40 18,34 21,30
East Kalimantan Provincial Regulation Number 15 of 2008 concerning RPJPD of East Kalimantan Province for 2005-2025:
Dependence on the extractive sector
Economic transformation is not yet relevant &
not widely understood
The foundation for economic transformation is
not yet formed (economy, social, infrastructure)
Potential for societal friction in the economic
transformation process
Plans for collaboration with various
stakeholders are not yet visible
Problems Identification
ESTABLISHMENT OF THE REGIONAL CONSULTATION FORUM
(FORUM KONSULTASI DAERAH)
Strategic Issues
DESCRIPTION OF THE ESTABLISHMENT OF
FORUM KONSULTASI DAERAH
REGIONAL CONSULTATION FORUM (FKD) FOR THE
ACCELERATION OF EAST KALIMANTAN'S ECONOMIC
TRANSFORMATION
ESTABLISHED BY SK GUBERNUR KALIMANTAN TIMUR
NOMOR 100.3.3.1/K.421/2024
ESTABLISHMENT
o To enhance the role of various stakeholders in accelerating
economic transformation in the aspect of PLANNING.
o To open a broader space for participation for various
stakeholders. It is not merely consultative & symbolic but
rather aims for COLLABORATION.
Its membership consists of representatives from
various stakeholders.
TASK & FUNCTIONS OF THE WORKING
GROUP
Task:
• To discuss and formulate inputs for economic transformation planning;
• To monitor the handling and provide support for resolving obstacles in the implementation of economic transformation; and
• To assist the evaluation process and provide input for improving the economic transformation plan.
Function:
• To enhance awareness among the community, businesses, regulators, the workforce, and other stakeholders regarding the importance of
economic transformation;
• To disseminate the East Kalimantan Economic Transformation agenda to the wider public;
• To promote opportunities and investment; and
• To mobilize stakeholder resources.
Round 4
• Determination of
the Action Plan
monitoring and
control
mechanism
Round 3
• Determination of
impact
projections
• Strengthening
commitment for
all Action Plans
and timelines
Round 2
• Formulation of
Supporting Action
Plans to realize
the Main Actions
Round 1
• Formulation of
Main Action
Plans:
⚬ Increase in
productivity,
sustainability,
and resilience
⚬ Investment
Pre-Round
• Determination of
Priority Economic
Activities
• Determination of
Foundation
Elements for
Transformation
and Just
Transition
Jan – Feb 25 Jul – Nov 25 Dec 25 – Jan 26 Feb 26 Mar 26
FKD Activity Flow
FKD Implementation Progress
Round 1
• Formulation of
Main Action
Plans:
⚬Increase in
productivity,
sustainability,
and resilience
⚬Investment
Priority Economic Activities
1. Crude Palm Oil
2. Tiger Shrimp
3. Electricity and Renewable Energy
(EBT) Gas
4. Oleofoods (such as cooking oil and
margarine)
5. Oleochemicals (such as biodiesel and
fatty alcohol)
6. Bio-Aviation Fuel (Bioavtur)
7. Herbal & Pharmaceuticals
8. Green Hydrogen
9. Green Ammonia
10. Ecotourism
11. Solar Panels
12. Electric Vehicles
13. Cocoa (raw and semi-finished)
14. Rubber (raw and semi-finished)
15. Downstreaming of Mining
Products (Coals)
Round 1 Agreements Highlight: Palm Oil & Shrimp
• Productivity:
3,46 ton/ha/year →
5 ton/ha/year
• 100% ISPO
compliance by
2024
PALM OIL
(CPO) TIGER SHRIMP
• Productivity:
0,125 ton/ha/year →
0,58 ton/ha/year
(2045)
• 80% production
certified sustainable
for export
Clear productivity and sustainability targets agreed by stakeholders
Round 1 Agreements Highlight:
This is not just energy substitution; it is structural change: from extractive dependence to regenerative growth
Renewable as the New Backbone
• Solar on ex-coal land – transforming post-mining scars into energy assets; coal companies
shifting roles to Independent Power Producers (IPP).
• Hydro with community legitimacy – Applying FPIC (PADIATAPA) and watershed rehabilitation
so rivers support both power and people.
• Biomethane from palm oil waste – Cutting emissions while replacing fossil LPG, natural gas &
diesel.
Electricity and
Renewable Energy Gas
Round 1 Agreements Highlight:
• 40% of the total CPO (and other
vegetable-based materials) in East
Kalimantan is processed within the
province.
• The focus is not on the obligation to
process CPO in East Kalimantan, but on
enhancing the competitiveness of the
industrial zone so that downstream
palm oil investments in East
Kalimantan become a competitive and
efficient choice.
OLEOPANGAN &
OLEOKIMIA BIOAVTUR
The RU V Balikpapan
operates as a national SAF
production center with a
commercial capacity of
200 thousand kL per year.
≥
Downstreaming cannot be forced by regulation; what we can do is make East Kalimantan the most competitive place to invest.
Oleofoods, Oleochemicals,
and Bioavtur
Round 1 Agreements Highlight:
• A minimum of 1 Natural Ingredient
Extract Industry (IEBA) with a total
capacity of 350 tons of extract/year,
≥
absorbing a majority of local bio-
pharmaceutical materials such as
tahongai, pasak bumi (tongkat ali),
kratom, and other potential plants.
• 100% of UKOT/UMOT meet the CPOTB
standards according to BPOM
regulations and are integrated into the
IEBA supply chain.
HERBAL
PHARMACEUTICAL
• A minimum of 1
Pharmaceutical Raw Material
Industry (IBBO) with a total
capacity of approximately
1,000 tons/year for at least 1
national priority API.
• An accredited
pharmaceutical testing
laboratory established in
East Kalimantan.
Natural resources give us the materials, but it is knowledge and collaboration that will transform them into sustainable
Herbal and
Pharmaceutical
Agreement Highlight: Next Discussion
GREEN HYDROGEN &
AMMONIA
TOURISM SOLAR PANELS
ELECTRIC
VEHICLES
Closing: From Coal to Collaboration
• Transformation is about securing the future beyond coal.
• FKD is the platform to ensure inclusivity and shared ownership.
• Our direction is clear: investment, productivity, and sustainability as guiding principles
• What matters now is collaboration — across government, business, communities, and
international partners
East Kalimantan is ready to become Indonesia’s icon of just and green economic transformation
THANK YOU
He currently serves as the Head of the Economic and
Development Financing Division at the Regional Development
Planning Agency (Bappeda) of South Sumatra Province. He has
over 17 years of experience in regional planning and economic
development, having previously held various positions within
Bappeda, including Head of Strategic Planning, Evaluation and
Control Division (2021–2022) and Head of Tourism, Industry,
and Trade Subdivision (2015–2021). Earlier in his career, he
worked at the Provincial Agriculture and Horticulture Office
and later advanced through roles focused on agribusiness,
SMEs, and strategic development planning in South Sumatra.
Hari Wibawa
Bappeda of South
Sumatra, Indonesia
EXPERIENCES OF SOUTH
SUMATRA IN ECONOMIC
DIVERSIFICATION AND
TRANSFORMATION PLANNING
THROUGH THE RCF PROCESS
Indonesia Sustainable Energy Week Goes Regional
(ISEWGR)
East Kalimantan, 2025
Samarinda, 14 October 2025
Multistakeholder Platform:
Regional Consultation Forum (RCF)
• Foundational
elements
• Priority economic
activities
• Core actions
• Supporting actions
• Scenario and
impact
projection
• Action plan,
commitment
• MnE
mechanism
2026 . Q1
2026 . Q1
2025 .Q4 – 2026.
Q1
2025 . Q2-
Q4
Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Round 4
ROUND 1
For accelerating economic transformation in South Sumatra
REGIONAL CONSULTATION FORUM
ROUND 2
ROUND 3 ROUND 4
14 April 2025
Kick Off/Pre Forum
RCF South Sumatra.
WEEK-3 DECEMBER 2025
Meeting 1
Theme (a) repurposing of ex-
mining land, (b) the role of
SMEs, (c) competency
development and employment
WEEK-3
FEBRUARY 2026
Transformation Scenario,
Overall action plan
10 June 2025
Meeting 1
Theme Plantation
(palm oil+ CPO,
Rubber, Coffee) and
Fisheries (cat-fish,
local fish (gabus),
Vanname shrimp)
11 September 2025
Meeting 2
Theme Plantation
and Fisheries (in
depth)
07 October 2025
Meeting 3
Theme Tourism
29 October 2025
Meeting 4
Theme Energy
(Hydro, Solar,
Geothermal) dan
Biometana
06 November 2025
Meeting 5
Theme Natural
Fibre (pineapple)
and Waste to Energy
27 November 2025
Meeting 5
Theme Oleo (food,
chemical including
biodesel) and
bioavtur
WEEK-2 JANUARY 2026
Meeting 2
Theme (a) infrastructure
development, (b) social and
environmental licence, regional
taxes and subsidies, incentives
WEEK-3
MARCH 2026
Joint Monitoring and Control
of Transformation Plan
Implementation
OPPORTUNITIES
CHALLENGES
South Sumatra
possesses
abundant
natural
resources with
strong
potential for
sustainable
development
South
Sumatra has
renewable
energy
potential of
21,032 MW,
with an
installed
capacity of
1,009.28
MW
Rubber
- Total area of 1 mio Ha
- Exsport 7400 thousand ton/year
- Eksport Value USD 1,34 mio/year
Coffee
- 1s t
biggest coffee producers in Indonesia.
Palm Oil
- Province with the 6th largest oil palm plantation
area in Indonesia: 1,4 mio Ha
- Produksi CPO : 3,8 juta ton
Rice
- 5t h
biggest rice producers in Indonesia
Fisheries
- 1s t
biggest cat-fish (patin) producers in Indonesia
HYDRO (PLTM/PLTMH)
- Potential : 448 MW
- Installed : 21,96 MW
WIND
- Potential : 301 MW
- Installed : -
SOLAR
- Potential : 17.233 MWp
- Installed : 8,86 MWp
GEOTHERMAL
- Potential : 918 MW
- Installed : 146,2 MW
BIOENERGY
- Potential : 2132 MW
- Installed : 832,26 MW
South Sumatra still relies
heavily on the primary
sector, with the mining and
quarrying sector
contributing 24% to the
GRDP in 2024
The development
of a green
economy and
renewable energy
requires
substantial
financing
Support from the central government
is needed to support infrastructure
development, establish strong
regulations and green incentives, with
special attention to the principles of a
just transition
OPPORTUNITIES DAN CHALLENGES
Tourism
- South Sumatra’s tourism potential is in nature, historical
and cultural, culinary and sports
COFFEE ECOSYSTEM
Farmers
Collector Processing industry Market
CSR
Coal Company
Banking
Banking
National Standardization
Agency
Provincial/
District/City Gov.
Banking
End Consumers
Banking
Provincial/
District/City Gov.
Provincial/
District/City Gov.
University
NGO
NGO
NGO
NGO
CSR of Coal Companies can play a role in the coffee cultivation cycle, with its funding, supported by the plantation service through training programs to increase productivity and maintain soil quality. Banking also
offers financing through KUR and micro credit to coffee farmers and collectors. On the industrial side, the National Standardization Agency (BSN) formulates standards and provides certification after ensuring
coffee product safety standards. The Industry Service supports industry players with technical guidance and supervision. MSMEs and retail traders gain access to financing from banks, while the Trade Service is
expected to open market access and supervise trade practices to protect consumers and business actors. Universities can assist in research on improving the economy and empowering coffee farmers. Non-
Governmental Organizations (NGOs) can also assist in providing assistance in every process.
THANK
YOU
Mr. Timon Wehnert is a Senior Researcher at the Wuppertal
Institute and Co-Lead of the International Energy Transitions
Research Unit. His work focuses on structural change, regional
innovation, and just transition in climate policy contexts,
including coal phase-out and industrial decarbonisation.
He coordinates Wuppertal Institute’s role in the EU’s Coal
Regions in Transition Initiative and the global Innovation
Regions for a Just Energy Transition project. With over two
decades of experience in sustainable energy research, Timon is
also an experienced facilitator in scientific and
transdisciplinary processes.
Timon Wehnert
Wuppertal Institute for
Climate, Environment and
Energy
Renewable Energy Benefit Sharing
Instruments to support coal regions in transition
and foster acceptance for renewables locally
14.10.2025
Timon Wehnert, Joachim Fünfgelt,
Linus Kurtenbach
Wuppertal Institute
Starting point - A
Coal Revenues
• Example - Indonesia:
5.2 billion € (1 trillion IDR) of state income
come from coal
(2025 estimate according to ESDM)
• a large share is redistributed to coal mining
regions - key factor in local public budget
(80% of non-tax revenues go to provinces, cities and regencies with coal mines)
Coal phase-down means
massive loss of public budget for many coal regions around the
Starting point - B
Local economic benefits
are a key factor to raise acceptance of renewables
Acceptance of Renewables
• In many regions with high share of
renewables there is protest and
opposition
• Many locals say that they only get to
feel the negative impacts
● Tax and Fiscal Solutions
● Community Benefit Schemes
● Local Ownership Models
Categories for RE benefit sharing schemes
● Local Cash Flows
● Project Economics
● Public Acceptance
…influence each in
different ways…
Tax Revenue Sharing
Success Factors:
• Funds must be managed transparently to avoid misuse.
• Payments must be mandatory
When seen as voluntary “gifts” they can even fuel cynicism (viewed as “bribes”).
• Corporate income tax
paid by RE developers
• Value-added tax (VAT)
on equipment, construction, or energy sales
• Environmental levies
related to energy generation
Example: Tax revenue sharing in Colombia
Since 2019 solar/wind projects > 10 MW have to
allocate 1% of gross sales to local communities in
the area of influence.
Of this 1%:
- 60% for indigenous/afro-descendant
communities and
- 40% for municipalities.
Purposes for which money can be spent:
infrastructure, public services, sanitary facilities,
potable water or projects that improve the
quality of life and wellbeing of the people.
60%
40%
🇨🇴
1%
Community Benefit Schemes
Usually, project developers and the communities agree on
services from the developer towards the community.
This may include: direct financial contributions to the community,
infrastructural improvements, employment & training or environmental
mitigation.
Transparency and sufficient resources for the communities crucial to address power
imbalances.
We can differentiate between formalised and voluntary community benefit schemes
depending on local regulation.
Voluntary benefit sharing in Germany
Windpark operators in Germany
can
• voluntarily involve
communities close to the
turbines with 0,002€/kWh.
• deduct those payments from their
taxes
This boosts acceptance for RE and
helps especially rural municipalities to
improve their municipal finances.
Foto Sources: Sidrak Wind Power Plant: wikimedia Open Licence / Jeneponto CC common from Harakan, Ahmad &
Mustari, Nuryanti & Kinyondo, Abel. (2021). Sustainable Energy Investment through Paradiplomacy Practices in South
Sulawesi, Indonesia. E3S Web of Conferences. 277. 02002. 10.1051/e3sconf/202127702002.
For a medium-sized windpark with 75MW capacity that
produces in Germany 185 GWh/year →
370.000€/year for the municipality.
Comparable in size to Sidrak Wind Power Plant or
Jeneponto in South Sulawesi.
Local Ownership Models
Local ownership of renewable projects can
strongly boost local economic development
and social acceptance!
Major categories for ownership models are:
● Community ownership / Cooperatives
● Public ownership
● Shared ownership arrangements
Local Ownership Models 1/2
Muara Enggelam (Kalimatan Timur, Indonesia)
● Village Owned Enterprise (VOE) running a 45
kWp Solar System serving all 192 households
of the village
● Electricity used for public facilities,
households and commercial purpose
(swallow’s nest farming)
● Active community ownership, managed and
operated by VOE
The case of Muara Enggelam demonstrates how a VOE can effectively manage and operate a solar PV grid to
support livelihoods in its community. With low dependence on government funds for its operation, this case
illustrates how community consensus can enhance mini-grid management.
Local Ownership Models 2/2
Barrio El Salvador (Medellín, Colombia)
First so-called energy community in
Colombia:
A group of neighbors in Medellins El Salvador
neighborhood is producing their own energy.
Once they satisfied their energy needs they can
also sell excess energy on the electricity market
which provides the necessary funds for the
maintenance of the panels.
Read more about
Colombian
Energy
Communities on
the JET-CR
Knowledge Hub.
Summary
● Adequate local revenue sharing is one key element
to support local acceptance of renewable energy projects
● In countries in which local communities and coal mining regions heavily depend on tax
and non-tax revenues from coal ...
 formalised, govermental approaches to renewable energy benefit sharing will be
necessary to sustain local public budgets
Outlook
Work in progress, we are open for suggestions:
○ Good practice of revenue sharing globally?
○ Success factors and barriers to implementation?
○ Data on coal revenues for local communities / regions
Presented by
February 2023
Key IKI JET contacts at Wuppertal
Institute
Timon Wehnert
timon.wehnert@wupperinst.org
Jannis Beutel
jannis.beutel@wupperinst.org
Joachim Fünfgelt
joachim.fuenfgelt@wupperinst.org
Götz von Stumpfeldt is an advisor working in the Innovation
Regions for a Just Energy (IKI-JET) project in GIZ Germany.
Before that he worked as project planner in GIZ, focused on
green economy.
He managed grant allocation for energy transition in the
German Federal State of Rhineland Palatinate and headed a
GIZ project on Governance in the natural resource sector in the
Democratic Republic of Congo. Goetz worked as an advisor on
economic policies in the German Federal Parliament and
started his career in managing make work programs in the
restructuring of East German industries.
Götz von Stumpfeldt
IKI JET (GIZ)
Handbook on Economic
Diversification for Coal
Regions
by the Just Energy Transition in Coal
Regions Interregional Platform
Götz von Stumpfeldt,
IKI JET Project
How to move from coal to new businesses ?
The Handbook on Economic Diversification for Coal Regions in Transition
will guide you trough the process
 How ho identify the economic sectors with the highest potential for a region?
 Find the economic sectors that help a region to realize its
social, environmental and economic objectives
 How can a region make best use of the data that is available in a region?
 How to elaborate a strategy for economic diversification for the region
Just transition of coal regions will only
work, if there are alternatives for
economic development
Cycle of strategy design for economic
diversification
1. Diagnosis Of The
Current State
2. Defining The
Vision And
Objectives
3. Prioritizing
Opportunities
4. Defining Policy
Actions
5. Monitoring And
Evaluation Of
Actions
Economic
diversification
East Kalimantan has a highly concentrated economic structure (top 5 sectors account for 71% of
GDP in 2023). Limited diversification progress over the last 10 years
Source: National Statistics
3%
3%
3%
2%
1%
14%
(38%) Mining of Coal and Lignite
Manufacture of Coal and Refined
Petroleum Products
Crude Petroleum, Natural Gas, and
Geothermal
uction (4%) Wholesale Trade and Retail Trade Except
of Motor Vehicles and Motorcycles
estock, Hunting and Agriculture Services Other Mining and Quarrying
Chemicals and Pharmaceuticals and Botanical Products Manufacture of Food Product and Beverages
d Communication Other
Share in 2013 regional GDP 4%
4%
3%
2%
2%
16%
(36%) Mining of Coal and Lignite
(13%) Manufacture of Coal and
Refined Petroleum Products
(9%) Construction
(7%) Crude Petroleum, Natural Gas, and
Geothermal
(6%) Wholesale Trade and Retail Trade
Except of Motor Vehicles and Motorcycles
Agriculture, Livestock, Hunting and Agriculture Services Other Mining and Quarrying
Manufacture of Chemicals and Pharmaceuticals and Botanical Products Manufacture of Food Product and Beverages
Information and Communication Other
Share in 2023 regional GDP
Top 5
sectors
Combined
75%
Top 5
sectors
Combined
71%
2.2 Indicators to assess the degree of economic
diversification in coal regions and social and
environmental implications
Diagnosis of the currenct state of
economic diversification
East Kalimantan, Indonesia Share of sectors others than coal in the local economy
Example: Export structure
4.2 Quantitative tools to identify
diversification opportunities
Export structure for Indonesia :
High concentration in minerals (coal) and agriculture (palm oil).
The Handbook links up with lots off online accessible tools: This one provicd by The Altlas of
Economic Complexity of the Harvard Growh Lab. https://atlas.hks.harvard.edu/
Case Study: Indonesia´s Product Space
Source: https://atlas.hks.harvard.edu/explore/productspace?exporter=country-360/
Specialised in less complex products: coal, textiles and agricultural goods
In Antofagasta (Chile) female employment participation
Human health care activities
Public administration and defence; compulsory social security schemes
Education
Accommodation activities
Retail trade, except motor vehicles and motorcycles
Food and beverage service activities
Membership organisation activities
Wholesale trade, except motor vehicles and motorcycles
Security and investigation activities
Wholesale and retail trade and repair of motor vehicles and motorcycles
Warehousing and support activities for transportation
Architectural and engineering activities; technical testing and analysis
Land transport and transport via pipelines
Office administrative, support, and other business support activities
Manufacture of fabricated metal products, except machinery and
equipment
Rental and leasing activities
Repair and installation of machinery and equipment
Copper mining and processing
Specialised construction activities
Civil engineering works
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%
70%
69%
64%
64%
59%
59%
55%
38%
32%
31%
23%
22%
22%
20%
18%
17%
15%
13%
12%
10%
Share of male employees 2023 Share of female employees 2023
Case Study: Social Economic Structure
Defining objectives for economic diversification
Economic Objectives
Attract FDI that creates and leaves benefits
in the region
Improve productivity or value added
Improve the level of product sophistication
Promote economic autonomy (strategic
assets)
Reduce vulnerability
Social Objectives
(Inclusiveness and Just)
Generate quality employment
Promote Women´s Economic
Empowerment
Improve social cohesion
Reduce inequality
Increase participation of vulnerable groups
Environmental Objectives
(Sustainability)
Combat climate change - mitigation
(Decarbonisation, etc.)
Promote biodiversity conservation
Reduce waste and pollution
Promote sustainable land use
Promote resource conservation (Circular
Economy, etc.)
Be clear about the objectives of the diversification process
is key to prioritising sectors and products
The Handbook provides tools to estimate the economic potentials for
economic diversification by
 Providing access to quantitative tools
analysing markets, data & technological potential
e.g. UNIDO dive tools, Harvard hks, GPI tool
 describing qualitative tools (assessment of economic actors)
Identifying economic diversification
opportunities
e.g: Participatory Appraisal of Competitive Advantage PACA (GIZ)
Identifying sectors to achieve Just
Transition objectives
Economic Objectives:
(e.g. increase value addition &
productivity)
Example: Chemicals; base
metals; green hydrogen
Social Objectives:
(e.g. generation of quality
employment & Women's
Economic Empowerment)
Example: Agricultural products,
food and beverages; textiles and
apparel; furniture
Environmental Objectives:
(e.g. climate mitigation &
waste reduction)
Example: green hydrogen;
renewable energies; sustainable
agriculture
These sectors, while good for
promoting value creation and
productivity:
- may not be able to generate
significant employment,
considering that they rely heavily on
more advanced technologies
(trade-off).
- by introducing green technologies
could also support environmental
objectives (inter-linkage).
These sectors, while good for generating
employment and women economic
empowerment:
- may not be strategic for technological
development, innovation and the
development of more sophisticated
skills (trade-off).
- Could also contribute to increase
value addition (inter-linkage).
These sectors while more aligned
with climate change mitigation
objectives:
- they are not necessarily a major
source of employment (trade-
off).
- could also be strategic to increase
sophistication (inter-linkage).
A comprehensive toolbox for policy design is provided
1. Instrument (name)
•Official title of project/ program/
intervention
2. Strategy objective
targeted by the
instrument
• One or various objective (s) that
will be supported through the
instrument implementation
3. Short description of
instrument
•Type of instrument and its main
characteristics
4. Main activities to
implement the
instrument
•Key actions that will ensure the
correct instrument
implementation
5. Expected impact of
instrument
•Expected changes because of
instrument implementation
6. Base line indicator for
instrument
•Current value of the Indicator
that allows to measure the
effective implementation of the
instrument
7. Target value for
instrument
•Expected value of the baseline
indicator after instrument
implementation
8. Target groups
•Sectors, size of companies,
groups of the population that
would be impacted by the
instrument
9. Responsible
implementing institution
•Institution name and responsible
department
10. Supporting
institutions for
implementation
•Institution name and responsible
department
11. Timeframe for
implementation
•Start and expected completion
date
12. Estimated budget
•Financial resources required for
implementation
13. Funding source
•Name of the institution,
organization, agency, etc that
will contribute with financial
resources to support
implementation
14. Additional remarks
•Any relevant info or
reference/link to project details
Note: Depending on the country / region the level of detail of the action plan could differ and can include all these
elements or some of them
Defining Policy Actions for
diversification
Components of a monitoring and evaluation system
An effective deployment of a M&E system involves the use of specific skills & knowledge from the institution leading
the process, the application of M&E tools, and the establishment of different processes (within line ministries and
other institutions also responsible for the implementation of the strategy).
M&E tools M&E processes
Intervention
Logic
Log-Frame
Reporting
Template
M&E Plan
Knowledge
of M&E
tools
Data
collection
&
manageme
nt
Analytical
& Critical
Thinking
Problem-
Solving
Skills
Intra-institutional
and
Inter-institutional
processes
M&E skills & knowledge
Note: Refer to the following 3 slides for more details.
Monitoring and evaluation
How to work with the handbook –
for different users
a. For Policy makers at the level of strategic planning:
A summary version which compiles key messages from each chapter
b. For Policy practitioners at a technical/operative level
A detailed version providing practical guidance to design an effective
economic diversification strategy.
The handbook is available in two versions:​
https://www.jetknowledge.org/knowledge/handbook-economic-diversi
fication-coal-regions-transition/
Please find it under this link:
To learn more please visit our website: jetknowledge.org
For questions concerning economic diversification please contact
Götz von Stumpfeldt, goetz.stumpfeldt@giz.de
Thank you very much for your attention!
Contact
Coffee Break
Feel free to visit us on
jetknowledge.org
Micro, Small & Medium Enterprises in
Economic Diversification
International Forum for Coal Regions in Transition 2025
Davit Manalu,
Krealogi
Consulting, Jakarta
Lishia Erza,
Indonesian Employers
Association, APINDO,
Indonesia
Session 4
Andres Jil
Breytmann, IKI JET,
GIZ Chile
With over nine years of experience in project management, Mr
Davit Manalu specializes in social enterprise, community
development, CSR, ESG, and SME training programs. He manages
an average of 10–15 projects annually with a total value of around
IDR 10 billion and successfully raises up to IDR 3 billion per year.
His work focuses on improving livelihoods through SME and
community development, as well as conservation initiatives across
Indonesia.
He has collaborated with various national and international partners,
including IFC, UNOPS, the World Bank, YKAN (TNC), WWF, the
Ministry of Women and Child Empowerment, and the Central Bank
of Indonesia. His expertise spans social and spatial studies, ESG for
SMEs, fundraising, training design, financial management,
monitoring and evaluation, business development, and stakeholder
engagement.
Davit Manalu
Krealogi Consulting,
Jakarta
Empower Others. Grow Together.
KREALOGI JOURNEY
MSME Ecosystem Enabler
1.600+
WEAVERS
1.200+
B2B CLIENTS
Starting based on experience
DU ANYAM
Indonesia's Leading Social
Enterprise Based on Crafts, Has
a Strong Supply Chain System,
and is Integrated with Rural
Communities
TRUSTED SUPPLIER FOR DOMESTIC &
INTERNATIONAL BUYERS
2020
Krealogi was born from Du
Anyam's experience in
establishing production systems
and supply chains for SMEs in
remote areas.
2022
Krealogi began to focus on
providing entrepreneurship
training and mentoring in
collaboration with several
partners
Krealogi was incorporated as
a separate entity from
Du Anyam in 2023
2023
54+
SUPPORTED VILLAGES IN NTT,
KALSEL & PAPUA
40-100%
INCREASING WOMEN'S
INCOME
Krealogi has transformed into an
ecosystem enabler, steadfast in its
commitment to education,
digitalization and forming
sustainable partnership
2024
The remarkable achievements
attained along this journey:
Proud member of:
Received award from:
KREALOGI also works with seaweed commodity business aggregators (production and sales
operations) supporting their community development and innovation in Renewable Energy adaptation.
Seaweed Aggregator
Krealogi working with potential partners focuses on
Community Development and Supply Chain Services:
● Strategic Partnerships
● Study/Research
● Develop Programs
● Implementation
Planning on Solar Energy Technology Implementation
(cold storage, dryer, water pump, etc)
Seaweed
Farmers
Intermediary
Trader
District/Provincial Level
Collector
Village Level
Intermediary
Trader
Multi-province Level
Larger Trader
Global Market
Domestic
Market
Processed
Seaweed :
Biostimulant
Inconsistent
Quality
High logistic cost
Lack of traceability
Large volume
demand
Supply
inconsistency
Higher cost due to
low productivity
Development of (women-led) small and medium enterprises in
East Kalimantan and South Sumatra in the context of Just Coal
Transition
In the national energy transition, SMEs have a
significant role to play, with SMEs accounting for one-
third of industrial emissions-95% of which come from
energy use.
Program Title
Lokus Program
Objective
Program Duration
Development of Small and Medium
Enterprises (Women-led) in East
Kalimantan and South Sumatra in the
Context of a Just Coal Transition
1. Assessing areas for improvement in
the SME support ecosystem (led by
women)
2. Developing innovative business
models that facilitate decarbonization,
green business expansion, and digital
transformation for SMEs (led by
women)
3. Recommend skill development for
SMEs (led by women) through pilot
projects
December 24 to November 25
East Kalimantan and South Sumatra
Summary Program Background
64.5%
Women-led
MSMEs
60%
Indonesia's GDP
from MSMEs
60%
Women-led SMEs
5-10%
Part of Coal value chain
Target
600-1000
Small Medium Enterprises
Supporting stakeholders
Assessment of SMEs
profile
Assessment of
Operating Context
Modeling transformations
for existing business
process
Modeling transformations
for green business
opportunities
Capacity building
action plan
SMEs Profiles in South Sumatera and East Kalimantan
● It is difficult to find respondents with women leaders because most of them are still on a micro scale.
● Most of SMEs have low annual income and categorized as Small Entrepreneurs, and not really have linked their profit with mining
company.
● The largest sector is retail and food and beverage with >62% of this sector are women-led
● Average education is high school and most >40 years old, the transition program needs to adapt to this level of education
51.5% Women-led
>62% Women-led in fnb and retail sector
SMEs Profiles in South Sumatera and East Kalimantan
● The majority of businesses have no legalities, barrier in accessing capital and
support program from government.
● Most SMEs are not members of organizations, which poses challenges in terms of
information dissemination and program implementation.
● Majority of SMEs joining organizations to networking and gather information.
Energy and Sustainability Profiles of SMEs in South Sumatra and East Kalimantan
● The main source of energy is currently 100% from PLN, with 13% of SMEs using generators as backup power sources, indicating that
electricity is still unstable in some areas, and only 7 use solar power because there is no PLN electricity source at their place of business.
● More than 60% consider sustainability to be important, but transform to solar energy has challenges in terms of not understanding the
benefits and knowledge about rooftop solar energy.
● SMEs stated that waste management and energy efficiency were most likely to be implemented in their businesses.
● Most SMEs have no external support, majority support comes from government and financial institutions.
● Misaligned between type of support by external and SMEs needs
● Support for green business is very low, and there are very few institutions available to provide assistance on this topic.
SMEs Challenges in South Sumatra and East Kalimantan
Assessment of operating context : SME support ecosystem
Main Support functions
Direct Business Operation
SMEs Market intermediary Consumer
Financing
Skill Development
Technical Assistance
Business Incubator
Legality and
Registration
Partnership and
networking
Access to green
technology and skills
Category of supporting stakeholder : gov,
coal, ngo, asc, bank, private, univ
Loan
gov, coal, bank
Program/grant
Available
Not Available
gov, private
Aggregator
Secondary Support functions
gov, ngo, univ, asc
● Support misaligned with SMEs needs
● Technical aspects and processes of support need improvement
● The same type of support is provided by several institutions
● There is no specific capacity building model for women yet.
● The SME transformation model can utilize existing sources of SME
development funding.
Summary
Most SMEs prioritize stability over transformation; capital support is needed for transformation.
Income contribution related to coal company < 30 percent. With regard to transition, SMEs need sufficient capital
before pivoting their business.
Women-led program should focus on FnB and retail sectors (>62% women-led)
Capacity building should match SME demographics (older owners, high school education) and address women’s needs.
SMEs is rely 100% from PLN, with 13% stating that they use generators as backup, and <1% using solar energy
due to limited access to PLN.
60% value sustainability but lack knowledge on implementation, especially rooftop solar.
Waste management and energy efficiency are key focus areas for green practices.
Stakeholders should provide tailored technical, financial, and mentorship support, especially for local green initiatives.
Mrs. Lishia Erza brings over 20 years of experience leading
and advising businesses across the UK, Singapore, and Hong
Kong in the technology, media, and financial sectors.
Recognized globally, she has been named among the Top 100
Women in Supply Chain and Fintech, as well as Indonesia’s
Most Powerful Business Women by SWA Magazine.
Currently, she serves in multiple leadership roles — including
Chair of SME Development at APINDO, Permanent Committee
Chair for Strategic Industries Financing at KADIN, and a B20
Thought Leader — championing sustainable finance,
responsible bioeconomy, and inclusive growth across Indonesia
and the region.
Lishia Erza,
Indonesian Employers
Association, APINDO,
Indonesia
Mr. Tomás Jil is a Technical Advisor at GIZ Chile, where
he leads the national implementation of the global project
Just Energy Transition in Coal Regions (JET-CR). Prior to
joining GIZ, he worked with Wood and the International
Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) on renewable energy
consulting and VRE integration planning.
He holds a European Joint Master’s in Management and
Engineering of Environment and Energy, as well as a
Mechanical Engineering degree from the University of
Chile.
Tomas Breytmann,
National Advisor, GIZ Chile
Working on the linkages of
SMEs to value chains of large
companies: Lessons learned
from Coronel and Mejillones
by the Just Energy Transition in Coal
Regions Interregional Platform
Tomas Andres Jil Breytmann,
IKI JET Chile
Brief Chile’s Coal Region Context
Chile no longer operates coal mines and the coal used for
power generation is imported (mainly from Colombia)
Our current coal phase-out process is
focused on the power generation sector.
By 2018, there were 6 regions with coal
power generation, but as of today 4
remain
Coronel
Mejillones
Chile
Enterprise context in Mejillones and Coronel
Micro Small Medium Large
0
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
5,000
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
4000
3852
855
105 64
80
265 245
3,735
Number of enterprises and annual revenues by type of
enterprise in Coronel - 2022
Number of enterprises Annual sales of the group
Number
of
enterprises
Annual
revenues
in
million
USD
Micro Small Medium Large
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
0
500
1000
1500
2000
495
160
20 13
12 46 38
1,474
Number of enterprises and annual revenues by type of
enterprise in Mejillones - 2022
Number of enterprises Annual sales of the group
Number
of
enterprises
Annual
revenues
in
million
USD
Number of workers for each 100 UF of annual revenues -
Mejillones
Micro Small Medium Large
Employment
Sales
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
50%
100%
150%
200%
250%
300%
350%
400%
450%
Revenue growth per type of enterprise - Coronel
SME Large
2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
88%
100%
113%
125%
138%
150%
Revenue growth per type of enterprise -
Mejillones
SME Large
Enterprise context in Mejillones and Coronel
Objective and approach
Marketing, digital capabilities,
pitch speechs, etc.
Approach focused in
enhancing general
capabilities of SME’s
Approach focused on the
SMEs’ capabilities required
by large enterprises in the
regions
What are the large industries requiring from
local SMEs to increase their participation into
their value chain?
Both regions had large and specialized industries so a level of diversification existed, but this
development has not permeated to the local SME ecosystem. Two main approaches for tackling
this issues are identified:
“Pull” from the demand
side. Make the large
companies in the region
keener to acquire local
products and services.
Focus on formalized
SMEs rather than
informal
entrepreneurships
Approach
Target
SMEs
Methodology and outline
1. Diagnostic - Characterize the relations of large companies in the regions with local
SME’s
• Understand the current relationships, the perceptions and past experiences with local SMES
• Identify the risks and barriers for further commercial relationships with local SMEs
• Identify the sectors with the largest potential for further development
2. Capacity building program - Elaboration of a capacity building program for local SMEs based
on the diagnostic aiming to enhance their linkage into large company's value chains including its:
• Structure, format, content and duration
• Stakeholders involved and their roles
• Criteria of SMEs selection*
• Imparting bodies
Shared diagnostic results between regions
Identified risks and barriers that hinder the process
Perceived benefits of strengthening
the link with local SMEs
• Knowledge of the territories
• Local working networks
• Flexibility of local SMEs under
unforeseen circumstances (both in
terms of requirements and in time
• Compliance of internal sustainability
goals of the companies
Contrasts in the implementation aspect for each
region
Coronel (2024)
1. Diagnostic
• 25 bilateral meetings with relevant
stakeholders for Coronel’s, including large
companies in Coronel, business associations,
public actors, to understand
• An online survey to large companies in
Coronel to obtain further quantitative data
(with low level of replies)
2. Elaboration of the capacity building program
• Desk analysis of diagnostic and elaboration of
the program
• Individual validation of the drafted program
with some large companies in the region
Mejillones (2025)
1. Diagnostic
• A single workshop inviting the acquisition teams of
the partner companies of the Business Association
of Industrial Companies of Mejillones (AIM), which
groups the 23 largest companies in Mejillones.
• An online survey to large companies in Mejillones
to obtain further quantitative data (with a 96% of
replies)
2. Elaboration of the capacity building program
• Desk analysis of diagnostic and elaboration of the
program
• Workshop with AIM and potential public partners
for validating the drafted program and foresee the
next steps for the program implementation
(November 2025)
• Similar barriers across regions: The main risks and obstacles for linking SMEs to large
companies are broadly the same.
• Implementation matters: The way these initiatives are carried out in each region is key to
achieving results.
• Collective engagement in Mejillones: Active participation of large companies has created a
sense of ownership and alignment around common capacity gaps.
• Industry-driven content: Large companies are also expected to contribute imparting specific
modules to the training program, ensuring relevance to local realities as well as ownership of
the program.
• Broader SME opportunities: SMEs benefit from a program designed to help them work with
most large companies, not just a few.
• The collaborative approach developed in Mejillones strengthens outcomes but requires a strong
partner able to convene and align major companies, which is not always present in every region
Lessons learned and following steps
Fishbowl Discussion - Economic
Diversification and the Role of MSMEs
International Forum for Coal Regions in Transition 2025
Your Feedback Matters!
Please take 2 minutes to
fill out the Post-Event
Survey
Any person who believes they may be harmed by an IKI project or who wishes to report
corruption or the misuse of funds can lodge a complaint to the IKI Independent Complaint
Mechanism at IKI-complaints@z-u-g.org. The IKI Complaint Mechanism has a panel of
independent experts who will investigate the complaint. In the course of the investigation, we will
consult with the complainant so as to avoid unnecessary risks for the complainant.
More information can be found at:
https://www.international-climate-initiative.com/en/aboutiki/values-responsibility/independen
t-complaint-mechanism/
Acknowledgements
The project "Innovation Regions for a Just Energy Transition" is co-financed by the International
Climate Initiative (IKI) of the Federal Government of Germany and by the Directorate-General
for International Partnerships (DG INTPA) of the European Commission for the Interregional
Platform for Just Energy Transition in Coal Regions (JET-CR).
Objective Support and accelerate just energy transitions (JET) away from coal to renewable energy and other
sustainable economic activities in the Global South
Implementing
organisations
• Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH
• Climate Action Network International (CAN International)
• International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD)
• International Labour Organisation (ILO)
• Solidarity Center
• Union Aid Abroad – APHEDA
• Wuppertal Institute for Climate, Environment and Energy
Project duration December 2022 – January 2027 (4 years)
About IKI JET

International Forum for Coal Regions in Transition 2025 x ISEWGR

  • 1.
    ISEW Goes Regionalin partnership with the International Forum for Coal Regions in Transition 14.10.2025 Samarinda, Indonesia
  • 2.
  • 3.
    Welcome remarks Togu Pardede,Director of Energy, Mineral, and Mining Resources, Bappenas, Indonesia Philipp Schattenmann, Director “Innovation Regions for a Just Energy Transition” (IKI JET) International Forum for Coal Regions in Transition 2025
  • 4.
    Our time together 09:00Opening Remarks 09:15 Session 1 | The Role of Local Governments in Driving Renewable Energy Investments in Coal Regions 10:30 Coffee Break 11:00 Session 2 | International Experiences for Just Energy Transition Energy & Framework Conditions 12:30 Lunch 13:30 Session 3 | Strategies for Economic Diversification and Transformation in Coal Regions 15:00 Coffee Break 15:30 Session 4 | Micro, Small & Medium Enterprises in Economic Diversification 16:30 Fishbowl Discussion - Economic Diversification and the Role of MSMEs 17:15 Closing Remarks
  • 5.
    The Role ofLocal Governments in Driving Renewable Energy Investments in Coal Regions International Forum for Coal Regions in Transition 2025 Sri Wahyuni, Provincial secretary of East Kalimantan, Indonesia Ani Wiyanti, Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, Indonesia Session 1 Hendra Irawan, Perusahaan Listrik Negara (PLN) Indonesia Rizal Fernandy, Borneo Energy Harapan
  • 6.
    With over 18years of experience in public administration and tourism development, Mrs. Sri Wahyuni currently serves as the Regional Secretary of East Kalimantan Province. Her career began in Kutai Kartanegara Regency, where she led public tourism and protocol (2006–2012) and later served as Head of the Tourism Department (2012–2019). She then advanced to become the Head of the Tourism Department for East Kalimantan Province (2019–2022), where she played a key role in promoting sustainable tourism and regional economic growth. Mrs. Sri Wahyuni has completed several international executive programs, including Digital Transformation in Government at the Harvard Kennedy School (2021) and Sustainable Tourism Management at Griffith University, Australia (2021), along with other trainings focused on post-pandemic tourism recovery and sustainable economic development. Sri Wahyuni Provincial Secretary of East Kalimantan, Indonesia
  • 7.
    Unlocking clean energy investmentsin East Kalimantan Sri Wahyuni - Provincial secretary of East Kalimantan, Indonesia
  • 8.
    8 Sources of EconomicGrowth in East Kalimantan (y-on-y %)  The three main sectors driving East Kalimantan’s economic growth are Mining and Quarrying, Manufacturing, and Construction.  Since 2019, the Mining and Quarrying sector has contributed the largest share to East Kalimantan’s economy.  However, unlike in previous years, from the first quarter of 2025 to the second quarter of 2025, the Manufacturing sector has provided the largest positive contribution. Note: (A) Agriculture, Forestry, and Fisheries | (B) Mining and Quarrying | (C) Manufacturing | (D) Electricity and Gas Supply | (E) Water Supply, Waste Management, and Recycling | (F) Construction | (G) Wholesale and Retail Trade; Repair of Motor Vehicles and Motorcycles | (H) Transportation and Warehousing | (I) Accommodation and Food Service Activities | (J) Information and Communication | (K) Financial and Insurance Activities | (L) Real Estate | (M, N) Business Services | (O) Public Administration, Defense, and Compulsory Social Security | (P) Education Services | (Q) Health and Social Work Activities | (R, S, T, U) Other Services. I II III IV I II III IV I II III IV I II III IV I II III IV I II III IV I II 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 -6.00 -4.00 -2.00 0.00 2.00 4.00 6.00 8.00 3.15 3.61 4.79 1.43 -0.27 -3.31 -3.13 -2.14 -2.09 2.32 2.96 1.28 0.79 1.32 1.78 2.67 2.36 2.42 1.54 3.31 4.77 2.89 2.60 2.31 -0.28 -0.06 -0.31 0.13 0.14 0.05 0.63 -1.53 -1.14 -0.33 -0.72 1.70 0.55 0.50 0.33 0.73 0.69 1.08 1.40 1.01 1.34 0.01 -0.09 -0.41 -0.02 0.67 1.55 2.75 1.05 0.48 0.23 0.12 0.09 0.07 -0.16 -0.25 0.00 -0.04 0.47 0.76 0.30 0.49 0.71 0.86 1.30 1.51 1.13 1.06 1.04 1.44 1.21 0.99 0.34 -0.01 A B C D E F G H I J K L M,N O P Q R,S,T,U 4,98 1,28 -5,42 2,79 6,19 -4,59 4,91 -2,87 5,62 4,66 3,34 2,40 3,62 5,34 6,47 6,99 6,89 5,30 -3,10 5,76 7,26 5,85 5,52 6,12 4,08 4,69
  • 9.
    9 Average Economic Growthby Industry Sector, 2019–2024(%)  The fastest-growing sectors are Health (Q), Electricity (D), Construction (F), and Information and Communication (J).  Sectors that have grown relatively fast during the 2019–2024 period include Trade (G), Transportation (H), Accommodation and Food Services (I), and Other Services (R, S, T, U).  Tourism-related sectors have shown relatively strong growth. C Migas A L B C Non Migas M,N P R,S,T,U I H G O E K J F D Q 0.40 1.18 2.52 2.54 3.69 3.70 3.81 4.58 4.85 4.95 5.37 5.83 6.49 6.52 7.58 7.88 9.86 9.88 Note: (A) Agriculture, Forestry, and Fisheries | (B) Mining and Quarrying | (C) Manufacturing | (D) Electricity and Gas Supply | (E) Water Supply, Waste Management, and Recycling | (F) Construction | (G) Wholesale and Retail Trade; Repair of Motor Vehicles and Motorcycles | (H) Transportation and Warehousing | (I) Accommodation and Food Service Activities | (J) Information and Communication | (K) Financial and Insurance Activities | (L) Real Estate | (M, N) Business Services | (O) Public Administration, Defense, and Compulsory Social Security | (P) Education Services | (Q) Health and Social Work Activities | (R, S, T, U) Other Services.
  • 10.
    East Kalimantan isat a turning point Indonesia’s top coal-producing region Fossil dominates its energy use Strong commitment to the double green transitions: Shift the local economy to be more diversified and sustainable. Switch the energy use to double the renewable share in 5 years, from 12.1% (2024) to 25.7%(2029) We want an inclusive and fair transition. We recognize the urgency to shift. This is not only about energy—it is about our future. Fossi l RE Coal mine operation (39%) Natural gas based industry (23%) Logistics & urban transportation (13%) Culinary (2%) Electricity generation (20%) Palm Oil plantation (1%) Energy use in East Kalimantan in 2023
  • 11.
    Energy transition priorityareas Transition feasibility (Technical & economical potential ) Transition significance (amount of fossil avoided through increased renewables ) Diesel to FAME Coal to solar & hydro Diesel to electricity Natural gas to solar & water Natural gas to biomethane Diesel to biomethane Gasoline to electricity LPG to electricity
  • 12.
    IPP solar investmentopportunities— RUPTL-ARED Scenario 2026-2029 Total capacity: 755 MW East Kalimantan: 255 MW Other provinces (Central & North Kalimantan): 500 MW. Locations: not yet defined? Economic: PLN tariff > LCOE feasible LCOE: 6.9 ¢/kWh Feed-in-tariff (>10MW): 7.6-8.7 ¢/kWh
  • 13.
    Turning coal landinto sun fields -Potential benefits -Reinforce mine reclamation and responsible closure obligations -Prevents deforestation and conflicts -Enables coal-to-renewable shift for workers and local communities -Simplifies land acquisition process -Challenges: -Align post-mining, PLN and spatial plans -Revise post-mining plans for solar use -Clarify land rights return procedure -East Kalimantan: 125,000 ha of mining land outside state forest land (2022) Source: https://globalenergymonitor.org/report/bright-side-of-the-mine/
  • 14.
    Distribution of PalmOil Mills in East Kalimantan Province 7 17 38 12 17 12 2 PPU Paser Kutim Kubar Kukar Berau Mahulu PPU Paser Kutim Kubar Kukar Berau Mahulu Total 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 360 940 2,040 585 1,015 745 45 5,730 299 792 1,829 548 899 713 51 5,131 Kapasitas Pabrik Kelapa Sawit TBS (ton/jam) Terpasang Terpakai
  • 15.
    Palm Oil MillEffluent (POME) Production in East Kalimantan Province PPU Paser Kutim Kubar Kukar Berau Mahulu Total - 2,000,000,000 4,000,000,000 6,000,000,000 8,000,000,000 10,000,000,000 12,000,000,000 14,000,000,000 16,000,000,000 950,400,000 2,481,600,000 5,385,600,000 1,544,400,000 2,679,600,000 1,966,800,000 118,800,000 15,127,200,000 meter kubik per tahun POME is utilized as organic fertilizer for plantations and as feedstock for the company’s Bio-CNG production
  • 16.
    BIO GAS INSTALATION PT.Rea Kaltim Plantations (Kukar) Pengelolaan Bio Gas 97.670 Ton CO2eq Listrik 7 MW Digunakan untuk Fasilitas Perusahaan PT. Prima Mitra Jaya Mandiri (Kukar) Pengelolaan Bio Gas 43.492 Ton CO2eq Listrik 1,2 MW Digunakan untuk Fasilitas Perusahaan PT. Indonesia Plant Synergy (Kutim) Pengelolaan Bio Gas 45.967 Ton CO2eq Listrik 0.5 MW Digunakan untuk Fasilitas Perusahaan PT. Teguh Jaya Primaabadi (Kukar) Pengelolaan Bio Gas 32.824 Ton CO2eq Gas CH4 Gas di flaring PT. Hutan Hijau Mas (Berau) Pengelolaan Bio Gas 59.156 Ton CO2eq 1.2 MW Digunakan untuk Fasilitas Perusahaan PT. Dharma Satya Nusantara Tbk (Kutim) Pengelolaan Bio CNG 33.238 Ton CO2eq Listrik 1,2 MW dan Gas Rumah Tangga Masih Uji Coba Digunakan untuk fasilitas Perusahaan
  • 17.
    Our support tofacilitate renewable energy investments in East Kalimantan • Land and permit facilitation • Community partnership and workforce preparation • Incentives “Our job is to make it easier, safer, and more inclusive for RE investment to happen.” ️ 🗣️
  • 18.
    Our support tofacilitate renewable energy investments in East Kalimantan • Land and permit facilitation • Community partnership and workforce preparation • Incentives “Our job is to make it easier, safer, and more inclusive for RE investment to happen.” 🗣️
  • 19.
    Role 1: Landand permit facilitation • Suitability mapping and identification of potential areas for solar farms based on consultation with PLN and Minerba • Provide technical assistance to district/municipal governments on detailed spatial planning (RDTR) in potential areas to support: • Seamless approval for land use (KKPR), environment (PL), and building (PBG) • application of international social and environmental safeguard standards 🗣️“Land is among the most difficult part to start RE business—but this is where provinces can lead.”
  • 20.
    Role 2: Communitypartnership and workforce preparation • Facilitate FPIC to gain genuine consent from the affected communities, including customary community (masyarakat adat) • Facilitate local community participation in: • Solar power generation business • Protection and rehabilitation of watershed area around hydro power plants • Biomass production on degraded land “ 🗣️ We ensure transition does not leave our people behind.”
  • 21.
    Role 3: Incentives •Basic infrastructure support: • Facilitate communication with district government to provide basic infrastructure such as access road and access to clean water service
  • 22.
    Conclusion • East Kalimantanaims to boost its renewable energy share as part of its green economy transformation • Transitioning grid-connected power generation is a key priority • The province seeks to attract renewable energy investments by facilitating: • Land and permit process • Community partnership and workforce facilitation • Incentives
  • 23.
    Mrs. Ani Wiyantiis a seasoned professional in Indonesia’s energy sector with extensive experience in renewable energy and energy conservation policy. After starting her career in the telecommunications industry at PT Komselindo and PT Mobile-8 Telecom Tbk (1996–2005), she joined the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, where she held several key positions within the Directorate General of New, Renewable Energy, and Energy Conservation (DJEBTKE). Her roles included leading the Energy Conservation Cooperation and Incentive Sections and coordinating the Sub-Directorate of Investment and Cooperation. Since 2022, she has served as a Senior Policy Analyst (Analis Kebijakan Ahli Madya) at DJEBTKE, continuing her commitment to promoting sustainable and efficient energy development in Indonesia. Ani Wiyanti Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, Indonesia
  • 24.
    24 Support and Acceleration of RegionalSolar Power (PLTS) Development Policies Directorate of Various New and Renewable Energy, MEMR Samarinda, 14 Oktober 2025 Presented at: “Indonesia Sustainable Energy Week Goes Regional (ISEWGR) – Samarinda”
  • 25.
    25 DIRECTION OF NATIONALENERGY MANAGEMENT POLICY 4A Parameters in Energy Resilience AVAILABILITY (Ketersediaan Energi) ACCESSIBILITY (Akses Energi) AFFORDABILITY (Keterjangkauan) ACCEPTABILITY (Ramah Lingkungan) “Energy Self-Sufficiency” ASTA CITA #2 “Strengthening the national defense and security system and promoting national self-reliance through food, energy, and water self-sufficiency, as well as the development of the creative economy, green economy, and blue economy.” Commitment to Greenhouse Gas (GHG) Emission Reduction Energy Sector Target: 358 million tons of CO₂ through the following programs: • Renewable Energy • Energy Efficiency • Clean Energy Power Generation • Low-Carbon Fuels • Mine Reclamation
  • 26.
    26 Presidential Regulation No.112 of 2022 Acceleration of Renewable Energy Development for Power Generation MEMR Regulation No. 11 of 2024 Utilization of Local Products for Electricity Infrastructure Development (Domestic Component Level / TKDN) MEMR Regulation No. 10 of 2025 Energy Transition Roadmap for the Power Sector MEMR Regulation No. 2 of 2024 Rooftop Solar Power Plants Connected to the Grid of Holders of Electricity Supply Business Licenses for Public Interest MEMR Regulation No. 5 of 2025 Guidelines for Power Purchase Agreements (PPA) from Renewable Energy Power Plants Law Number 30 of 2007 on Energy Draft Law on New and Renewable Energy REGULATIONS ON THE ACCELERATION OF RENEWABLE ENERGY DEVELOPMENT Draft Revision of Presidential Regulation No. 112/2022 Draft Presidential Regulation on the Governance and Implementing Organization for the Development and Operation of Nuclear Power Plants Draft Regulation of the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources on Grid-Connected Solar Power Plants (PLTS Parallel Operation) Regulations Currently Being Drafted MEMR Regulation No. 12/2018 concerning the amendment to Regulation No. 39/2017 on the Implementation of Physical Activities for the Utilization of New and Renewable Energy (mechanism based on proposals from local governments). 1 2 3 4 5 Draft Regulation of the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources on Hybrid Power Plants for Off-Grid Mini-Grid Systems Government Regulation No. 40 of 2025 National Energy Policy (70–72% renewable energy mix by 2060)
  • 27.
    27 2025 2030 20352040 2045 2050 2055 2060 1028 Mt CO2e 885 Mt CO2e 129 Mt CO2e 558 Mt CO2e Strategy to Achieve NZE 2060 RE Development (On-grid, Off-grid & Biofuel) 1 Electrification (EVs, induction stoves, agricultural electrification, etc.) 2 Moratorium on New CFPP in Accordance with Presidential Regulation No. 112/2022 and Phase- Down of Existing CFPP 3 CCS/CCUS 4 New Energy Sources (nuclear, hydrogen, ammonia) 5 Implementatio n of Energy Efficiency 6 ROADMAP OF NET ZERO EMISSION Indonesia is committed to achieving Net Zero Emissions (NZE) by 2060 or earlier 1st Nuclear Power Plant (2032) High Carbon Low Carbon Free Carbon Green H2 Transportation Sector Green NH3 Shipbuilding Sector CCS Industry Sector MEPS 55x higher than in 2030 Energy Management (Mandatory) Wind and Solar Dominated energy mix No.1 World Geothermal (2030) Biofuel Mandate Continues to Increase Projected Emissions & Energy Sector Transition Milestones Gas As a bridging for energy transition
  • 28.
    28 Electric Power GenerationRoadmap (RUKN) Solar (109 GW) Wind (73 GW) Hydro (71 GW) H2 (25 GW) Gas / Gas+CCS (38 GW) Nuclear (35 GW) Geothermal (23 GW) Bioenergy (4 GW) NH3 (8 GW) Storage (34 GW) 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050 2055 2060 - 5 0 1 0 0 1 5 0 2 0 0 2 5 0 3 0 0 3 5 0 4 0 0 4 5 0 5 0 0 59 75 73 69 56 46 8 - 3 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 2 4 7 15 17 20 22 23 26 47 49 53 51 49 8 1 9 11 22 28 57 63 65 71 - 3 9 10 13 28 33 34 5 10 27 43 64 65 73 13 28 35 45 88 95 109 2 3 14 22 51 54 7 15 22 27 35 0 1 3 27 37 2 3 7 8 24 25 106 160 199 242 307 386 407 443 Capacity (GW) Storage Ocean Waste Heat Diesel Solar Wind Hydro H2 Gas_CCS Gas Nuclear Geothermal Bioenergy NH3 Coal_CCS_CfBio Coal Net Power Capacity (DMN) in 2060 is projected to reach 443 GW, consisting of: • 42% Variable Renewable Energy (VRE) complemented by 34 GW of storage, and • 58% Non-VRE (dispatchable) sources. It will be supported by a Super Grid to enhance renewable energy (EBT) penetration. RE energy mix (PP 40/2025 National Energy Policy) 19-23% 36-40% 53-55% 70-72% Ocean (1GW)
  • 29.
    29 2025 - 2029 2030- 2034 Total RE Addition 42,6 GW Sumatera EBT9,5 ESS1,6 GW Satuan : MW PLTA/M PLTP PLT Bio PLTN PLTS PLTB Storage 4.940 2.017 78 250 1.606 590 1.575 Planned Addition of Renewable Energy Power Plants and Energy Storage Systems in PLN’s Electricity Supply Business Plan (RUPTL) 2025–2034 Kalimantan EBT3,5 ESS 0,7 GW Satuan : MW PLTA/M PLT Bio PLTN PLTS PLTB Storage 1.533 80 250 1.524 70 725 Sulawesi EBT7,7 GW Satuan : MW PLTA/M PLTP PLT Bio PLTS PLTB 4.606 305 236 1.530 1.010 Papua, Maluku, Nusa Tenggara EBT2,3 GW Satuan : MW PLTA/M PLTP PLT Bio PLTS PLTB PLTAL 179 332 141 1.470 140 40 Jawa Madura Bali EBT19,6 ESS 7,9 GW Satuan : MW PLTA/M PLTP PLT Bio PLTS PLTB Storage 432 2.503 399 10.932 5.377 7.956 1.682 Invesment Opportunities Trillion rupiah 836.696 GREEN JOBS Employment Opportunities Energi Storage System 10,2 GW IPP 40186. 48781 76% PLN 4734.0 58 9% SH 7904.7 1 15% IPP PLN SH
  • 30.
    30 Status of NationalRenewable Energy Utilization The addition of renewable energy installed capacity in the first semester of 2025 amounted to 876.5 MW. The total installed capacity RE in the first half of 2025 reached 15.2 GW, accounting for 14.5% of the national total generation capacity (105 GW). 14,5%* from total national power plants (105 GW) 2024 Smt I 2025 14,325 15,201 Installed Capacity of RE Power Plants (MW) 29.40% 38.01% 16.59% 16.00% Minyak Bumi Batubara Gas Bumi EBT The share of new and renewable energy (NRE) in the national energy mix reached 16% based on preliminary calculations for the first semester of 2025. 876,5 Oil Coal Gas RE
  • 31.
    31 Solar Power Plant(PLTS) Development Program Potential : 89,37 GW (293 locations)  Potential at PUPR Dams: 14.7 GW (257 locations)  Potential in Lakes: 74.67 MW (36 locations) Progress:  Pre-construction: 210 MW (PLTS Floating Saguling, Singkarak, Karangkates)  COD: 145 MW (PLTS Floating Cirata) Based on the RUPTL, the target total capacity by 2034 is 17 GW. Project Location:  Sumatera : 1.605 MW  Kalimantan : 1.524 MW  Jamali : 10.931,65 MW  Sulawesi : 1.529 MW  Mapana : 1.470 MW Rooftop Solar PV Large Scale Solar PV Floating Solar PV Solar energy is prioritized for development, supported by continuously declining costs. Based on the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources decree, the total rooftop solar PV (PLTS Atap) quota until 2028 is 2 GW:  Sumatra: 95 MW  Kalimantan: 104 MW  Java-Madura-Bali (Jamali): 1,850 MW  Sulawesi: 17 MW  Maluku-Papua (Mapana): 7 MW Installed capacity as of June 2025: 495 MWp (10,736 PLN customers) PLTS Amman 26,8 MW, West Sumbawa, NTB Floating Solar PV Cirata 192 MWp, West Java Rooftop Solar PV PT Pabrik Kertas Tjiwi Kimia 9,8 MWp, East Java Solar energy development is also carried out through: • Decentralization programs • State Budget (APBN) or Special Allocation Fund (DAK) solar PV projects to promote the provision of energy from new or renewable energy sources in the 3T regions (Frontier, Outer, and Disadvantaged Areas).
  • 32.
    32 Scope of Regulations Relatedto the Preparation of the Regional Regulation on RUED-P Government Regulation No. 40 of 2025 Presidential Regulation No. 22 of 2017 on the National Energy General Plan Law Number 30 of 2007 on Energy Based on Article 18 of Law No. 30 of 2007 on Energy, regional governments prepare a Regional General Energy Plan by referring to the National General Energy Plan, which is established through regional regulations. 1. Aceh 2. North Sumatra 3. Riau 4. Riau Islands 5. West Sumatra 6. Jambi 7. South Sumatra 8. Bengkulu 9. Bangka Belitung Islands 10. Lampung 11. Banten 12. Jakarta 13. West Java 14. Central Java 15. East Java 16. Yogyakarta 17. Bali 18. West Nusa Tenggara (NTB) 19. East Nusa Tenggara (NTT) 20. North Kalimantan 21. East Kalimantan 22. South Kalimantan 23. West Kalimantan 24. Central Kalimantan 25. Central Sulawesi 26. North Sulawesi 27.Gorontalo 28. West Sulawesi 29. Southeast Sulawesi 30. South Sulawesi 31. Maluku 32. North Maluku 33. West Papua 33 Provinces Telah menetapkan Perda RUED-P Preparing the RUED-P Draft Papua Barat Daya 1 Province 3 Provinces Not yet Identified Central Papua, Papua Highlands, and South Papua 1 Province Revise the Draft Regional Regulation on RUED-P Papua The Role of Local Governments in Supporting Solar PV Development Local governments are responsible for supporting the achievement of renewable energy targets within the energy mix, as outlined in the Regional Energy Plan (RUED- P). Energy Transition Roadmap 21 provinces that are members of the Association of Oil, Gas, and Renewable Energy Producing Regions have developed an Energy Transition Roadmap, including Jakarta, NTB, Yogyakarta, West Java, Central Java, East Java, Aceh, Lampung, Central Sulawesi, South Sumatra, East Kalimantan, Jambi, West Papua, South Sulawesi, and others.
  • 33.
    33 SUPPORT FROM CENTRALAND REGIONAL GOVERNMENTS IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF RENEWABLE ENERGY Based on Articles 53 and 56 of Government Regulation No. 40 of 2025 on the National Energy Policy, the Central Government and Regional Governments, in promoting and maximizing the development of new and renewable energy sources, shall undertake: 1. Identification and inventory of new energy sources, including type, location, capacity, and economic feasibility; 2. Establishment of development plans for new energy sources; 3. Land allocation; and 4. Provision of necessary facilitation.
  • 34.
    34 Support from allstakeholders is needed for the energy transition in Indonesia to proceed optimally. Engaging in business activities related to power generation and fuels, supporting services, job creation, contributions to state revenue, and economic activities PRIVATE AND SOE Formulating policies, regulations, and national standards; providing guidance and supervision; and acting as a facilitator in the development of renewable energy and energy conservation programs. GOVERNMENT Educating the public on the importance of renewable energy and disseminating government programs to the community in an inclusive manner. MEDIA NGOs act as a balancing force and partner to the government, providing advocacy and support for communities, conducting positive campaigns, and actively participating in the development of renewable energy. NGO & CSO Creating innovations in the field of renewable energy that can be directly utilized by the public, enhancing quality human resources, and promoting technology transfer. ACADEMY PLTS Coca Cola Amatil 7,13 MWp Director General of New, Renewable Energy, and Energy Conservation (EBTKE) at the Katadata SAFE 2024 event COLLABORATION IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF ENERGY TRANSITION
  • 35.
    35 Terima Kasih www.ebtke.esdm.go.id Jl. PegangsaanTimur No.1, Cikini, Menteng Jakarta Address Kementerian Energi dan Sumber Daya Mineral @KementerianESDM @kesdm @djebtke KementerianESDM
  • 36.
    36 Central Java Provincial Government Energy Self- SufficientVillage • Integrate the Provincial RUED with the RPJMD so that regional solar PV (PLTS) development plans are aligned with the regional development agenda and can receive budgetary priority in the APBD. • Establish regional policies to promote the use of solar PV, both rooftop and large-scale. • Align spatial planning to support solar PV investment. • Integrate solar PV into regional development programs, such as energy self-sufficient villages. • Facilitate permitting (IUPLTS; technical recommendations from PPKH, KKPR, environmental permits, etc.). • Act as a mediator regarding land acquisition or social issues. • Provide incentives for the development, operation, and utilization of renewable energy, such as ease of land use, including property tax (PBB) incentives for buildings installing rooftop solar PV. • Allocate APBD funds for solar PV projects in schools, hospitals, or government offices. • Offer local incentives, such as reductions in local levies/taxes for rooftop or large-scale solar PV projects. The Jakarta Provincial Government Promotes rooftop solar PV programs in schools and gov’t offices. The Bali Provincial Government Promoting rooftop solar PV installations in gov’t offices and hotels through the RUED regional regulation policy. Local Government Support in Solar PV Development
  • 37.
    37 Challenges in RenewableEnergy Development Economy and Financing The initial investment costs for renewable energy projects tend to be high, while funding is limited and some projects carry a high level of risk. Investment in renewable energy is estimated to be required up to 2034, amounting to approximately IDR 1,682 trillion. Regulation Currently, the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) continues to work on improving the investment climate through adequate regulations, including the recently issued Minister of ESDM Regulation No. 5 of 2025 on Guidelines for Power Purchase Agreements for Renewable Energy Power Plants. Support is also needed to finalize other related regulations. Transmission Infrastructure Investment is needed in the development of transmission and distribution networks that can connect renewable energy sources with consumption centers. Readiness of Domestic Industry The development of local industries for producing renewable energy equipment and components is still limited. There is a need to realize growth in domestic industries to support renewable energy development (e.g., solar module manufacturing, wind turbines, geothermal turbines). It is also necessary to strengthen supporting industries for biofuels, such as CPO, methanol, bioethanol, biojet fuel (SAF), and biogas. Social Aspects Support from the local community is needed at the sites of EBET power plant development. There is still some resistance from the community toward geothermal projects in certain locations. 1 2 3 4 5
  • 38.
    Mr. Hendra Irawanhas extensive experience in managing PLN’s regional operational units across Indonesia. He began as Manager of SB RPOPSD at PLN UID DJTY (2018–2019), then continued his leadership journey as Manager of UP3 Berau, East Kalimantan (2019–2021), and UP3 Bengkulu, South Sumatra Region (2021–2022). From 2022 to 2024, he served as Manager of UP2K in West Nusa Tenggara Province. Currently, he leads PLN UP3 Samarinda under the PLN UID Kaltimra Hendra Irawan Perusahaan Listrik Negara (PLN) Indonesia
  • 39.
    www.pln.co.id | 1 RUPTL 2025– 2034: Beyond the Greenest RUPTL Present at: The Indonesia Sustainable Energy Week Goes Regional (ISEWGR) in Partnership with the International Forum for Coal Regions in Transition Theme : The Role of Local Governments in Driving Renewable Energy Investments in Coal Regions PT PLN (Persero) 14 October 2025
  • 40.
    Executive Summary Based onthe Decree of the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources of the Republic of Indonesia No. 188.K/TL.04/MEM.L/2025, the Electricity Supply Business Plan (RUPTL) of PT PLN (Persero) for 2025–2034 was officially approved on May 26, 2025. At the national level, it is planned that 76% of new power generation will come from renewable energy (RE) and storage, consisting of 42.6 GW (61%) of RE plants, including 500 MW of new/nuclear energy, and 10.3 GW (15%) of storage capacity. Meanwhile, fossil-based generation will account for 16.6 GW (24%). The plan also projects the need for 47,758 km of transmission lines and 107,950 MVA of substation capacity. For East Kalimantan and North Kalimantan, the plan includes the development of 1.81 GW (47.42%) of RE-based generation, consisting of Solar PV + BESS (628 MW), Hydropower (1,251 MW), and Biomass (10 MW). The Solar PV + BESS projects will be developed gradually and are expected to reach COD in 2027 with a capacity of 80 MW (including 50 MW of BESS), while the Hydropower Plant (300 MW) is scheduled to reach COD in 2031. The transmission requirement for the region is estimated at 6,200 km, with substation capacity reaching 6,850 MVA. www.pln.co.id | 3
  • 41.
    We have sufficientgeothermal energy. We have an abundance of coal. We have vast potential from hydropower. We also have affordable technologies that can meet our needs. The government under my leadership will focus on achieving energy self-sufficiency. Prabowo Subianto President of the Republic of Indonesia www.pln.co.id | 4
  • 42.
    Government Fiscal Sustainability Environmental Sustainability Electricity System Reliability Corporate Financial Sustainability Energy Security MINISTRYOF ENERGY MINERAL RESOURCES REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA www.pln.co.id | 42 In the electricity infrastructure planning outlined in the RUPTL 2025–2034, PLN comprehensively takes into account the five elements of sustainability that are the focus of the Government of Indonesia.
  • 43.
    www.pln.co.id | 6 Indonesia needsCAPEX 171 USB Billion for developing Renewable Energy and its infrastructure from 2025 to 2034 Source: PLN (2025)
  • 44.
    www.pln.co.id | 7 In theRUPTL 2025–2034, 76% of the additional power generation capacity will come from RE sources1 , including nuclear energy and storage2 . 1 Renewable Energy (RE), equipped with Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) for Variable RE (Wind and Solar) 2 Including Pumped Storage & BESS. RUPTL 2025–2034, [GW] Solar 17,1 GW Geotherma l 5,2 GW Hydro 11,7 GW Bioenerg y 0,9 GW Nuklir 0,5 GW Pumped Storage 4,3 GW BESS 6,0 GW/27 GWh Gas 10,3 GW Coal 6,3 GW EBT 42,1 GW Wind 7,2 GW Storage 10,3 GW Non EBT 16,6 GW Additional generation capacity until 2034 69,5 GW *Not including PV Rooftop 3 GW quota *Including the plan for developing a Hybrid Coal-Fired Power Plant (PLTU Hybrid) (Coal 1,2 GW, PLTS 0,3 GW dan BESS 0,15 GW)
  • 45.
    The planned additionof power plants for 2025–2034 increases to 69.5 GW, consisting of 42.6 GW from RE plants and 10.3 GW from energy storage. The total investment in Indonesia’s power generation sector amounts to IDR 2,133.7 trillion. • IPP Allocation: • Total: IDR 1,566.1 trillion • Renewable Energy (RE/NRE): IDR 1,341.8 trillion • Non-Renewable: IDR 224.3 trillion • PLN Allocation: • Total: IDR 567.6 trillion • Renewable Energy (RE/NRE): IDR 340.6 trillion • Non-Renewable: IDR 227.0 trillion Source: PLN (2025) www.pln.co.id | 8 In the RUPTL 2025–2034, 76% of the additional power generation capacity will come from RE sources1 , including nuclear energy and storage2 .
  • 46.
    The RUPTL 2025–2034will accelerate the development of new and renewable energy while reducing Indonesia’s dependence on coal. With the massive development of renewable energy power plants, the share of new and renewable energy in the energy mix is projected to increase 2.5 times, reaching approximately 34.3% by 2034. 2024 2034 12,0% 34,3% 2,5 X Renewable energy mix (%) www.pln.co.id | 46
  • 47.
    Power Plant Development2025–2034 by Region National 69,5 GW 15,1 GW 5,8 GW 4,7 GW Sumatera Jawa, Madura, Bali Sulawesi Maluku, Papua, Nusa Tenggara Kalimantan 33,5 GW 10,4 GW 19,6 GW 9,5 GW 3,5 GW RE Addition 7,7 GW 2,3 GW RE Addition RE Addition RE Addition RE Addition www.pln.co.id | 47
  • 48.
    Mamberam o There is amismatch between the potential locations of Renewable Energy Sources and the epicenter of demand. Hydro Geothermal Solar PV Wind Legend: Identified renewable energy resources New Additional demand www.pln.co.id | Bioenergy 11
  • 49.
    “Green Enabling SuperGrid” will address the supply-demand mismatch, evacuate renewable energy scattered in Sumatra, Kalimantan, Sulawesi, and Nusa Tenggara to demand centers Sumatra – Jawa (2031) Interconnection Length: 1,174 kms Sumatra – Batam (2031) Interconnection Length: 560 kms Kalimantan – Jawa (≥ 2034) Interconnection Length: 1.098 kms Sumba – Bali – Jawa (> 2040) Interconnection Length: 1.846 kms Kalimantan – Sulawesi (≥ 2040) Interconnection Length: 680 kms Maluku Transmission (≥ 2025) Interconnection Length: 1.485 kms Backbone 275 kV Sulawesi (≥ 2026) Backbone Length : 4.012 kms Nusra Transmission (≥ 2025) Transmission Length: 1.390 kms Papua Transmission (≥ 2025) Transmission Length: 1.008 kms Additional Transmission in the RUPTL 2025–2034 ~48 thousand kms transmission grid Sumatra: 11.155 kms Jawa-Madura-Bali: 13.889 kms Kalimantan: 9.812 kms Sulawesi: 9.019 kms Maluku, Papua, Nusra: 3.883 kms Additional Substations in the RUPTL 2025–2034 ~108 thousand MVA Substations Sumatra: 28.410 MVA Jawa-Madura-Bali: 59.730 MVA Kalimantan: 8.080 MVA Sulawesi: 9.670 MVA Maluku, Papua, Nusra: 2.060 MVA www.pln.co.id | 12
  • 50.
    Solar PV Potentialand Development Until 2034 Province Capacity (MW) Aceh 313.46 Bali 679.39 Banten 675.8 Bengkulu 0.5 Gorontalo 51 Jambi 100 Jawa Barat 3781 Jawa Tengah 3808 Jawa Timur 1987.455 Kalimantan Barat 448.675 Kalimantan Selatan 6.68 Kalimantan Tengah 215.56 Kalimantan Timur 546.872 Kalimantan Utara 306.24 Kepulauan Bangka Belitung 51.5 Kepulauan Riau 38.4 Lampung 388.77 Maluku 124.171 Maluku Utara 228.942 Nusa Tenggara Barat 333.5804 Nusa Tenggara Timur 279.07 Papua 126.829 Papua Barat 38.69 Papua Barat Daya 52.05461 Papua Pegunungan 135.557 Papua Selatan 37.5918 Papua Tengah 113.866 Riau 10.07 Sulawesi Barat 0.346 Sulawesi Selatan 1153.073 Sulawesi Tengah 54.448 Sulawesi Tenggara 132.702 Sulawesi Utara 138.373 Sumatera Barat 35.74 Sumatera Selatan 304.91 Sumatera Utara 362.29 Total 17,061.61 0,8 1 1,1 2,3 1,6 1,5 1,7 2,1 3,9 1,2 0 2 4 6 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 Solar Additional Capacity based on RUPTL 2025-2034
  • 51.
    Solar PV Configuration •Ground Mounted PV • Built on open land with supporting structures, either fixed or capable of following the sun’s direction (tracking system). • Advantages: Flexible for large-capacity designs, easy to maintain. • Challenges: Requires extensive land (1 MW = 1–1.5 ha), potential land-use conflicts. • Floating PV • Built on a floating structure placed on the surface of water such as reservoirs, lakes, or former mining ponds. • Advantages: land use efficiency, natural cooling effect, reduces water evaporation. • Challenges: higher initial costs, greater risk of damage, and requires extra maintenance. www.pln.co.id | tech7energy.co m • Solar Rooftop • Installed on the roof of a building, such as a house, office, warehouse, or industrial facility.• • Advantages: space-efficient, close to the electrical load. • Challenges: limited by roof size and orientation; roof structure must be strong. 1 2 3 Source: PLN (2025)
  • 52.
    www.pln.co.id | EXISTING ENERGYMIX CONDITIONS IN EAST KALIMANTAN – NORTH KALIMANTAN Planned 500 KV Planned 150 KV ENERGY MIX COMPOSITION OF POWER PLANT SOURCE TYPES IPP 59% PLN 39% EXCESS POWER 2% PLTU (CFPP) GRAHA POWER KALTIM 200 MW PLTU INDOEKA 200 MW PLTU CAHAYA FAJAR KALTIM 95 MW PLTU MUARA JAWA 55 MW PLTGU (Gas and Steam) SENIPAH 117 MW PLTS (Solar) 50 MW TOTAL : 717 MW PLTU KARIANGAU 180 MW PLTG PEAKING 140 MW PLTGU TANJUNG BATU 45,6 MW PLTG (Gas) SAMBERA 18 MW PLTMG (Gas Engine) BONTANG 47,44 MW PLTD (Diesel) 49,49 MW TOTAL : 480,53 MW PLTU KARIANGAU POWER 15 MW PLTBG (Biogas) PMM 2 MW TOTAL : 17 MW The current energy mix of PLN Kaltimra’s electricity is still dominated by coal energy at 24.59%, while the share of renewable energy from solar power plants (PLTS) is 0.85%. PLTU 62.30% PLTBG 0.17% PLTS 0.85% PLTD 4.20% PLTMG 4.02% PLTGU 3.87% PLTG 24.59%
  • 53.
    www.pln.co.id | North andEast Kalimantan Energy Mix 2025-2034 In the ARED scenario, renewable energy production in 2034 increases 33-fold compared to 2025, the share of renewable energy in the energy mix reaches 47.42% in 2034, and the share of coal decreases to 20.63%. Energy Mix 2034 EBT 2034 : 47,42 % Coal 2034 : 2,87% 2034 : 20,63% 2025 : 3,36% Gas/LNG 2034 : 2025 : 29,08% 27,13% BBM/Gasoline 2025 : 20,51% 2025 : 49 % 3,4% 3,5% 5,7% 11,7% 17,3% 19,9% 32,6% 39,3% 42,0% 47,4% 27,1% 41,5% 48,6% 46,6% 43,7% 44,0% 37,0% 33,3% 32,1% 29,1% 20,5% 12,8% 10,6% 8,1% 7,6% 5,3% 4,5% 4,0% 3,2% 2,9% 49,0% 42,2% 35,0% 33,6% 31,5% 30,8% 25,9% 23,4% 22,8% 20,6% 2025 2026 2027 2033 2034 2028 2029 EBT GAS/LNG 2030 2031 2032 BBM BATUBARA
  • 54.
    www.pln.co.id | DEVELOPMENT OFRENEWABLE ENERGY POWER PLANTS AT UID KALTIMRA (EAST AND NORTH KALIMANTAN DISTRIBUTION MAIN UNIT) No RE Plants Satuan 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 Total 1 Geothermal MW 2 Hydro MW 146 80 125 351 3 Microhydro MW 0,2 0,2 4 Solar MWp 51* 10,5 93 240 15 78 50 537 5 BESS MW 50 150 25 225 6 Solar + BESS MW 9,5 9,5 Jumlah MW 51 10,5 143 390 15,2 103 146 139,5 125 1.122,7 Total RE Capacity 2025 - 2034: 1.122,7 MW * IKN Solar Power Plant 50 MW is now operational In the ARED scenario, it is planned that the addition of renewable energy power plants will gradually increase from 2025 to 2034, utilizing the abundant renewable energy potential from hydro and solar power plants.
  • 55.
    www.pln.co.id | 18 Utilization ofReservoir/Dam and Former Mine Solar Power Plants Based on the letter from the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (EBTKE) dated December 1, 2023, which follows up on the letter from the Minister of Public Works and Public Housing (PUPR) dated August 2, 2023, regarding the Potential Utilization of Floating Solar Power Plants (PLTS) in Dams, the total potential for floating solar power in PU dams across Indonesia—identified based on the assumption of 20% of the existing/on-going dam area—is 13.9 GW, distributed across 109 existing/on-going reservoir locations. No. Dams Area (Ha) Capacity 20% (MW) Dam Status 1 Merancang 587 117,46 Existing 2 Samboja 202 40,37 Existing 3 Lempake 135 27,08 Existing 4 Manggar 403 80,6 Existing 5 Beriwit 330 66,07 Existing 6 Sepaku Semoi 335 66,93 On Going 7 Marangkayu 258 51,63 On Going Total 2250 450,14 List of Potential Solar PV Installations at Ministry of Public Works (KemenPU) Dams Floating PV Source: RUPTL 2025 – 2034 (Kementrian ESDM (EBTKE) Tahun 2024)
  • 56.
    www.pln.co.id | 19 Solar PowerPlant & BESS Development Plan No System Type Power Plant Capacity (MW) Scenario of COD RE Base Scenario of COD ARED Status Developer 1 Mahakam Solar IKN 50,0 2025 2025 On Construction IPP 2 Mahakam Solar Kalseltengtimra-1 (PLTS+BESS) 80,0 2027 2027 Planned SH-PLN 3 Mahakam BESS Kalseltengtimra-1 (PLTS+BESS) 50,0 2027 2027 Planned SH-PLN 4 Mahakam Solar Kalseltengtimra-2 (PLTS+BESS) 240,0 - 2028 Planned IPP 5 Mahakam BESS Kalseltengtimra-2 (PLTS+BESS) 150,0 - 2028 Planned IPP 6 Mahakam Solar Kalseltengtimra (Kuota) Tersebar 15,0 2029 2029 Planned IPP 7 Mahakam Solar Kalseltengtimra (Kuota) Tersebar 30,0 2030 2030 Planned IPP 8 Mahakam Solar Kalseltengtimra-4 (PLTS+BESS) 40,0 - 2030 Planned IPP 9 Mahakam BESS Kalseltengtimra-4 (PLTS+BESS) 25,0 - 2030 Planned IPP 10 Mahakam Solar Kalseltengtimra (Kuota) Tersebar 50,0 2033 2033 Planned IPP 11 Isolated Solar Village Electricity (Program) in East Kalimantan 1,3 2025 2025 Planned PLN 12 Isolated Solar 10,5 2026 2026 Planned PLN 13 Isolated Solar 12,1 2027 2027 Planned PLN 14 Isolated Solar De-dieselization 0,9 2027 2027 Procured IPP 15 Isolated Solar Isolated Kaltim 7,7 2030 2030 Planned IPP 16 Isolated Solar+BESS Isolated Kaltim 9,5 2033 2033 Planned IPP Jumlah 1.677,0 The listed PV+BESS capacity (MW) represents the estimated capacity supplying the system, while the fixed PV capacity and BESS MWh will be further assessed according to system requirements, reliability, and optimal economic feasibility. The location of the PV+BESS installation is not fixed in this province and can be adjusted to other provinces, either centralized in a single location or distributed across multiple locations, depending on the results of further system requirement studies. Source: RUPTL 2025 – 2034
  • 57.
    Kalimantan Substation DevelopmentPlan 2025 1. The development of transmission under the Base and Accelerated Renewable Energy Development (ARED) scenarios requires the construction of 500 kV extra-high voltage (EHV) overhead lines (SUTET) to optimize the potential of existing hydroelectric power plants. 2. The development of 500 kV EHV transmission lines (SUTET) from 2025–2034 for the Base and ARED scenarios in Kalimantan includes the construction of Extra-High Voltage Substations (GITET) at Kaltara – Tanjung Selor – Embalut – IKN – Balikpapan. : Transmission 500 kV (Planned) : Hydro potential 500 kV North Kalimantan – East Kalimantan Trafo 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 Jumlah 500/275 kV - - - - - - - - - - - 500/150 kV - - - - - - 4.000 - - - 4.000 500 kV DC - - - - - - - - - - - 275/150 kV - - - - - - - - - - - 150/115 kV - - - - - - - - - - - 150/20 kV 450 360 300 720 510 540 360 240 300 300 4.080 70/20 kV - - - - - - - - - - - Total 450 360 300 720 510 540 4,360 240 300 300 8.080 : Transmission 150 kV (Existing) : Hydro on RUPTL : Transmission 150 kV (Planned) www.pln.co.id | 57 Rencana Gardu Induk (MVA) Desc Tahun Grand Total 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 Investmen t 987.31 927.76 580.02 1,000.93 241.47 784.96 2,554.55 549.14 271.67 240.60 8,138.41 (Billion Rp)
  • 58.
    The execution ofthe 2025–2034 RUPTL is projected to absorb 1.7 million workers, covering the needs of the manufacturing, construction, operations, and maintenance sectors for electricity infrastructure. In line with the energy transition, 91% of the workforce in the power generation sector are green jobs. RUPTL 2025–2034 will absorb 1,7 million workers 836.696 workers in the Power Generation sector (760 thousand workers, or 91%, are green jobs in the renewable energy sector) 881.132 workforce in the Transmission, Substation, and Distribution sectors 14w.pln.co.id | w w www.pln.co.id | 22
  • 59.
    Not only that,investments in the 2025–2034 RUPTL will provide a multiplier effect for the national economy, thereby also supporting the vision of achieving an economic growth target of 8% by 2029 323 340 360 378 396 313 324 338 351 365 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 Demand RUPTL 2025 - 2034 Demand Natural Growth GDP Growth 8% GDP Growth 5,2% Industrial Zone (KI) Downstreaming Special Economy Zone (KEK) Multiplier Effect RUPTL Electricity Sales Projection, TWh www.pln.co.id | 59 Integrated Marine and Fisheries Center (SKPT) Electric Vehicle (EV) Ecosystem Super-Priority Tourism Destination (DPSP)
  • 60.
  • 61.
    Rizal Fernandy Borneo EnergyHarapan Mr. Rizal Fernandy has over 25 years of experience in the energy sector, covering solar photovoltaic (PV), oil and gas projects, and maintenance engineering. Holding a Bachelor’s degree in Electrical Engineering from the University of Indonesia and a Master’s degree in Technology Management from Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember. He has worked with major companies such as North Oil Company in Qatar, Total EP in Indonesia, France, and Nigeria, and Pertamina Hulu Mahakam. Since 2017, he has led solar PV development through Borneo Energy Harapan, building partnerships with developers, governments, universities, and industries.
  • 62.
    IMPLEMENTING SOLAR PV INEAST KALIMANTAN PROVINCE Presented by Rizal Fernandy
  • 63.
    Solar Energy Potential Totaltechnical potential capacity per technology that can be applied in Indonesia Source : IESR (2021). Beyond 443 GW: Indonesia’s infinite renewable energy potentials. Institute for Essential Services Reform 6,749.3 GW 7,308.8 GWh 19.8 GW at 100 m hub height 30.73 GWh 6.3 GW 1,100.71 GW 518.6 GWh 0.0 MW at 100 m hub height 2,395.0 MWh 254.5 MW 193.80 GW 24.2 GWh 86.7 MW at 100 m hub height 866.3 MWh 35.7 MW 135.59 GW 228.6 GWh 0.0 MW at 100 m hub height 552.1 MWh 192.4 MW 586.46 GW 141.1 GWh 0.0 MW at 100 m hub height 3,766.7 MWh 95.8 MW 983.49 GW 342.8 GWh 0.0 MW at 100 m hub height 2,998.1 MWh 251.2 MW Indonesia East Kalimantan South Kalimantan North Kalimantan Central Kalimantan West Kalimantan
  • 64.
    Solar Energy Potential Government Commitment toEnergy Transition Suitable Area 26,846.08 km2 Technical capacity 1,100.71 GWp High Solar Irradiation Level Industrial and Mining Sector Demand Large Available Land Area Strategic Geographical Location Source : IESR (2021). Beyond 443 GW: Indonesia’s infinite renewable energy potentials. Institute for Essential Services Reform
  • 65.
    Energy Cost Savings Investment & Job Opportunities Economic Benefit Basedon the 2025–2034 RUPTL, the Solar Power Generation (PLTS) sector is projected to be able to create employment opportunities for up to 348,057 workers in the generation segment. 8% Support national economic growth through increased electricity demand Energy Independence
  • 66.
    Environmental Benefits 1 MWpPLTS can avoid ±900–1,000 tonnes of CO₂/year (equivalent to 200 petrol cars stopping operation). Emission Reduction Reduced SO₂, NOx, and particulate emissions from PLTU = improved air quality & public health. Air Quality & Health Supporting Kaltim Green Province and the 2060 Net Zero Emission target Contribution to the Net Zero Target
  • 67.
    Simplify permitting process, provincialregulation, and Integrate solar development Regulatory & Policy Support Tax and retribution exemptions, Public co-funding or matching grants, and Green investment Financial & Investment Incentives Develop local technical skills, conduct public awareness campaigns, and Encourage research collaboration Capacity Building & Public Awareness Foster coordination among government, PLN, private sector, academia, and communities for faster and sustainable solar growth. Strategic Collaboration Provincial Government Support Needed Strong provincial support will accelerate solar adoption, attract private investment, create green jobs, and reduce emissions and positioning East Kalimantan as a leading province in Indonesia’s energy transition. Expected Impact
  • 68.
    Challenges and Barriers Regulatory Uncertainty Limited Local Manufacturing andSupply Chain Weather and Maintenance Challenges Grid Readiness and Interconnection Limits High Initial Investment Skill Labour
  • 69.
    Type of PLTSMain Users / Beneficiaries Developed By Installed Capacity (kWp) Centralized PLTS Rural Communities East Kalimantan Provincial Government 2,013.5 Rooftop PLTS PLN Customers (Exim) / Households Individuals 1,148 Wilus / Community-based PLTS General Public Local Business Area 1,243 IPP PLTS PLN (State Utility) Nusantara Sembcorp Solar Energy 50,000 Captive Power (IUPTLS / Self-use) Private Sector Companies 12,752 Total Installed Capacity 67,156.9 Solar Power Plants (PLTS) in East Kalimantan Province Source : ESDM Pemprov Kaltim (2025)
  • 70.
    PT. Listrik Kaltim (PERUSDA) 8.6kWp Department of Manpowerand Transmigration 51.6kWp East Kalimantan Government Buildings Ministry of Religion 57.2kWp Forestry Service 105.8kWp Initial Development for 30 Gov. Buildings 2MW Animal Husbandry Department 13.3kWp
  • 71.
  • 72.
    Adaro, Kelanis, Kalteng 598kWp Future Plan:3 MW ITM - CPI, Bontang, Kaltim 3MWp + 3MWH Coal Mining Industries Borneo Indobara, Angsana & Kusan, Kalsel 229.4kWp Kideco Jaya Agung, Paser, Kaltim 1MW Berau Coal Future Plan (Floating) 3MW + 2MWH BESS Berau Coal, Berau, Kaltim 789.3kWP Future Plan (Floating) 3MW + 2MWH BESS
  • 73.
  • 74.
    Badak LNG, Bontang, Kaltim 3MW Pertamina RU V,Balikpapan, Kaltim 2.5MW Kaltim Daya Mandiri (KDM), Bontang, Kaltim 3.9MW Oil and Gas Industries
  • 75.
  • 76.
    Coffee Break Feel freeto visit us on jetknowledge.org
  • 77.
    Join our community Subscribeto our newsletter • Regular digests of the latest just transition news, commentary, publications and events • Mix of content from coal regions across the world to encourage knowledge sharing and positive exchange between countries
  • 78.
    International Experiences forJust Energy Transition Energy & Framework Conditions International Forum for Coal Regions in Transition 2025 Eloïse O’Carroll, EU Delegation Office, Jakarta Edwin Mametja, Nkangala District Municipality, South Africa Session 2 Karem Castro, Transforma, Colombia Ranvijay Kumar Singh, CCO, India
  • 79.
    Eloïse O’Carroll, EU Delegation,Jakarta Eloïse O’Carroll is the Programme Manager for Forestry, Natural Resources, and Energy at the EU Delegation to Indonesia, leading on the Just Energy Transition Partnership (JETP) and industrial decarbonisation. She also supports carbon pricing and markets diplomacy with Indonesian ministries and works on forestry, agricultural commodities, and development cooperation. Previously posted in Vietnam, she co-led the EU’s JETP efforts and supported the EU Deforestation Regulation. With prior experience in the private sector on carbon markets and sustainability, Eloïse holds an MSc in Environment and Development from LSE and a BA in Economics and Development from McGill University.
  • 80.
    The just energytransition Insights from the EU experience Eloise O’Carroll EU Delegation to Indonesia October 2025
  • 81.
    What is theEU doing to achieve Climate Neutrality? The European Climate Law sets binding targets for the EU to reduce net GHG emissions by at least 55% by 2030 compared to 1990 levels and reach net zero emissions by 2050.
  • 82.
    EU Climate policyarchitecture • Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) • Emissions reduction in ETS sectors: -47.6% below 2005 levels and -16.5% in 2023 compared to 2022 (-24% for electricity and power generation). • EU ETS revenues: EUR 43.6 billion in 2023 (more than EUR 200 billion since 2013). • Effort Sharing Regulation for Member States (ESR) National targets for reducing GHG emissions in mainly road transport, buildings, agriculture, and waste. Covers most methane emissions in the EU. • Land Use, Land Use Change, and Forestry (LULUCF) National target to increase removals and reduce emissions from natural carbon sinks. The European Green Deal, the European Climate Law and the ‘Fit for 55’ Legislative Package set binding targets for the EU to be climate neutral by 2050 and to reduce net GHG emissions by at least 55% by 2030
  • 83.
    Renewable Energy Directive •Legal framework for RE development in the EU. • Establishes common rules and sets mandatory targets for the bloc. • EU target of 42.5% - 45% RE by 2030 • In 2023: 24.5% gross final energy consumption (electricity, heat, cooling and transport) was from RE
  • 84.
    The Just TransitionMechanism (JTM) to support regions most affected by the climate transition in all Member States Provides primarily grants Crowds in private investment Leverages public financing Territorial just transition plans (TJTPs) give access to all 3 pillars Just Transition Fund EUR 19.7 billion InvestEU Dedicated Just Transition Scheme EUR 10-15 billion (estimated) Public sector loan facility with the EIB EUR 13.3 – 15.3 billion (estimated)
  • 85.
    The Just TransitionFund (JTF) One of the main elements of the European Green Deal growth strategy Established in the framework of EU Cohesion Policy (2021 – 2027 period) Governance Place-based approach: Territorial Just Transition Plans (TJTPs) established at national or regional level - outlining the transition pathway, negative impacts, most affected territories and alleviating measures Focus and scope Supports investments in an integrated way: Supports territories and groups most severely impacted by the transition towards a climate- neutral economy € 19.7 billion (mainly grants) € 27 billion incl. national co- financing Environment and energy (e.g. brownfield rehabilitation, renewable energy) Economic diversification (e.g. business and innovation support) People and skills (e.g. re- and upskilling of workers) …leaving no-one behind in the transition First pillar of the Just Transition Mechanism (JTM) + Strengthened partnership State of play Implementation in progress … all 70 TJTPs were adopted … 38% of the fund allocated in approved projects →
  • 86.
    The JTF inregions 96 just transition territories  Territories dependent on the extraction or production of coal, lignite, peat and oil shale – these are expected to decline, leading to job losses and other negative impacts  Territories dependent on carbon-intensive industries such as steel, cement or chemicals – these which need to fundamentally transform, leading to changes in skills and job profiles as well as other impacts
  • 87.
    The JTF innumbers Distribution per Member State (EUR, billion) 6.63 / 34 % 3.59 / 18 % 3.14 / 16 % 1.88 / 10 % 1.79 / 9 % Enterprises and diversification Clean energy Skills, job-search and education RTDI Regeneration of sites TA and public administration Sustainable local mobility Other Circular Economy Social infrastructure Distribution per theme (EUR, billion + %) PL DE RO CZ EL BG FR IT ES NL FI SK EE LT HU SI PT LV HR BE SE AT CY DK IE MT LU 3.85 2.48 2.14 1.64 1.38 1.20 1.03 1.03 0.87 0.62 0.47 0.46 0.35 0.27 0.26 0.26 0.22 0.19 0.19 0.18 0.16 0.14 0.10 0.09 0.08 0.02 0.01
  • 88.
    The JTF inpractice (approved projects) Addressing immediate challenges Supporting economic diversification Renewables and green H2 Belgium: Hydrogen production unit in Frameries – setting up the production of renewable hydrogen (electrolysis of water using local renewable electricity from two wind turbines). Slovakia: The use of geothermal energy in the Košice valley – increasing share of renewable energy sources in a district heating system in by tapping into the geothermal potential of the region. Employment Poland: Jobs after coal – re- skilling and up-skilling of 2200 participants, primarily former employees of mines and power plants affected by phasing out from lignite energy production in the Konin subregion. Brownfields Czechia: POHO park – revitalising the area of a former mine into a post-mining centre / campus, offering the necessary facilities to visitors and potential investors. RDI, skills and entrepreneurship Sweden: H2-Labs, Norrbotten – developing a test bed that will explore solutions for the production of renewable hydrogen. Croatia: Center of gaming industry in Novska, developing local talent and businesses in the video game industry. Productive investments Estonia: Magnet factory in Narva – construction of a factory producing rare earth magnets, including an R&D centre for new materials and applications for magnets, creating 1000 jobs. Supporting the energy transition
  • 89.
  • 90.
    Mr. Edwin Mametjais the Divisional Manager: Climate Change and Biodiversity at the Nkangala District Municipality in Mpumalanga, South Africa. He is a Professional Environmental Scientist (SACNASP) with over 16 years of experience in climate change governance, sustainability planning, water resource management, and natural resource conservation in the public sector. Mr. Mametja leads the District’s Just Transition, Climate Change and Biodiversity programmes, driving the integration of sustainability and resilience into local development planning. Edwin Mametja Nkangala District Municipality, South Africa
  • 91.
    “Working together withthe people to push back the frontiers of poverty” Access to basic services for all ! Victor Khanye Dr JS Moroka Emakhazeni Emalahleni Steve Tshwete Thembisile South Africa: Integrating the dimensions of Just Transition into the transformation of the energy system in Mpumalanga - Incorporating Vulnerable and Disadvantaged Groups . ISEW Goes Regional , Oct 2025 NKANGALA District Municipality
  • 92.
    “Working together withthe people to push back the frontiers of poverty” Access to basic services for all ! Presentation Content • Setting the Scene: South Africa’s Energy and Social Context • Why Inclusion Matters: Building a People-Centred Transition • National and Provincial Interventions: Turning Policy into Action • Local Action: The Case of Nkangala District • Conclusion and Recommendations
  • 93.
    “Working together withthe people to push back the frontiers of poverty” Access to basic services for all ! South Africa’s Energy Landscape and Social Imperative • In 2023 ~80 % of electricity was from coal, mainly in Mpumalanga, where jobs and local revenue depend on mining. • Coal’s share declined to ~74 % (2025) as renewables reached 17 % of generation. • The shift is inevitable: ageing plants, air pollution, and new climate targets under the Climate Change Act (2024) and JET Investment Plan (2023–2027). • Coal regions remain vulnerable—high unemployment, inequality, and energy poverty. • Over 90 000 direct coal jobs are at risk, demanding a transition that protects livelihoods. • A just energy transition must leave no one behind— creating new, inclusive opportunities. Distribution of South Africa’s power generation facilities, Eskom, 2023
  • 94.
    “Working together withthe people to push back the frontiers of poverty” Access to basic services for all ! Why Inclusion Matters: Linking Energy Transition to Social Justice • South Africa’s transition unfolds amid deep inequality and >40 % youth unemployment in coal regions. • Women, youth, and informal workers remain excluded from most energy and technical opportunities. • The Just Transition Framework (PCC, 2022) calls for equity, participation, and social dialogue as guiding principles. • The Climate Change Act (2024) mandates a just and equitable transition that safeguards livelihoods. • Inclusion turns climate action into shared opportunity — ensuring no one is left behind.
  • 95.
    “Working together withthe people to push back the frontiers of poverty” Access to basic services for all ! National and Provincial Interventions: Turning Policy into Action • JET Investment Plan (2023–2027): R1.5 trillion investment pipeline for energy, transport, skills, and green industries. • Presidential Climate Commission (PCC): coordinates implementation and ensures justice, inclusion, and dialogue. • Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment (DFFE) and DMRE: mainstream climate and energy justice into national policy. • Mpumalanga Green Cluster Agency (MGCA): promotes green manufacturing, circular economy, and clean innovation. • Provincial & District Governments: localise transition through District Development Model (DDM) — integrating JET into IDPs and LED strategies.
  • 96.
    “Working together withthe people to push back the frontiers of poverty” Access to basic services for all ! Local Action: The Case of Nkangala District, Mpumalanga’s Coal Heartland • Nkangala District Municipality, situated in the Mpumalanga Province is composed of six local municipalities with a total population of just over 1.5 million • Heavily dependent on coal mining (42 coal mines), energy (8 coal powered) as drivers of its economy making it an epicentre of JT • High vulnerability to climate risks: droughts, flooding, temperature extremes (CSIR Greenbook, 2024). • High unemployment (37.4% in Q2 2024) and poverty rates (51.2% in 2023) limit the capacity of communities to adapt to climate challenges and participate in the green economy, exacerbate vulnerability. • Need to enhance resilience and ensuring a just transition through Supporting Climate Adaptation and Mitigation, Promoting Economic Diversification in line with the JET IP
  • 97.
    “Working together withthe people to push back the frontiers of poverty” Access to basic services for all ! Key Local Interventions (Aligned to Just Transition and Inclusion) Focus Area Initiative Alignment / Inclusion Element Governance & Institutional Readiness Mainstreaming Just Transition and Climate Change into the Integrated Development Plan (IDP) and District Climate Change Forum. Strengthens local leadership and accountability mechanisms for inclusive climate action. Economic Diversification Promoting circular economy, green manufacturing, and entrepreneurship incubation. Established partnership with GIZ –JUST SA and NBI for JT Bankable Business Plans, MGCA Creates local green enterprises and unlocks SME participation in new markets Green Skills Development & Enterprise Support for Just Transition Partnership with SETAs for reskilling and Upskiling, Indalopreneurship Programme to support eco-inclusive startups and youth enterprises in waste, energy, and agri- innovation. Training equipping youth & communities in solar, LPG installation and maintenance Builds employability and inclusion for vulnerable groups entering green jobs. Sustainable Agriculture & Food Systems UN Women – NDM – DARDLEA Climate-Smart Agriculture and Agri-prenure Programme (2025– 2027) training 200 emerging farmers and Enhances food security, income generation, and climate resilience for women, youth, and persons with disabilities Clean Energy Access & Social Innovation KwaZamokuhle Clean Cooking Pilot (EWSETA, DEE and Munic) deploying LPG/gas stoves to low-income households Reduces indoor pollution, improves energy equity, and enables community-level clean energy expertise. Community Awareness and Dialogs Ongoing Community Engagements on Climate Change Mitigation and Adaptation & JT Builds shared understanding and social cohesion.
  • 98.
    “Working together withthe people to push back the frontiers of poverty” Access to basic services for all ! Key Local Interventions (Aligned to Just Transition and Inclusion) Focus Area Initiative Alignment / Inclusion Element Career Expo on Green Industries Expose learners and graduates to opportunities in renewable energy, environmental sciences, and circular economy sectors Builds youth aspirations, inclusion, and skills-to-job linkages Circular Economy & Eco-Brick Initiative Eco-brick and Waste Valorisation Project repurposes fly ash and waste plastics for local brick-making and paving. Promotes green enterprises, creates local jobs, and empowers cooperatives. Komati Training Centre (JET Skills Hub) The Komati Training Centre, established through Eskom’s JET initiative, provides technical training in renewable energy installation, operation, and maintenance for local communities. Supports re-skilling, enterprise development, and inclusion of youth and women in new green industries
  • 99.
    “Working together withthe people to push back the frontiers of poverty” Access to basic services for all !
  • 100.
    “Working together withthe people to push back the frontiers of poverty” Access to basic services for all !
  • 101.
    “Working together withthe people to push back the frontiers of poverty” Access to basic services for all ! CONCLUSION • The NDM is committed to catalyze Nkangala District’s transition to a sustainable, climate-resilient future by creating green jobs, empowering marginalized communities, and reducing reliance on coal. • Invest climate-resilient infrastructure and green energy projects. • Prioritize interventions to address critical vulnerabilities such as water scarcity, flooding, and energy transition challenge • Strengthen Collaboration and Partnerships • Focus on economic diversification programs to support communities impacted by the transition away from coal. • Establish a robust monitoring and evaluation system for ongoing climate programs to track progress and identify gaps.
  • 102.
    “Working together withthe people to push back the frontiers of poverty” Access to basic services for all ! Thank you
  • 103.
    Technical and StrategicCoordinator of Transforma's Energy Area and the Coordinator of the Just Energy Transition Observatory. A Chemical Engineer with a PhD in Energy Systems Engineering and a Master’s degree in Chemical Engineering. With experience in the energy sector, with a strong focus on the just energy transition, sustainable energy systems, and environmental management. The background includes research and technical development in salt gradient power generation, exergy analysis, and process optimization, as well as the management, coordination, and formulation of engineering projects. Additionally, contributed to clean development mechanism initiatives, carbon markets, and strategies aimed at promoting a low-carbon economy. Karem Castro Transforma, Colombia
  • 116.
  • 117.
    Lunch Feel free tovisit us on jetknowledge.org
  • 118.
    Strategies for EconomicDiversification and Transformation in Coal Regions International Forum for Coal Regions in Transition 2025 Yusliando, Bappeda East Kalimantan, Indonesia Hari Wibawa, Bappeda of South Sumatra, Indonesia Session 3 Timon Wehnert, Wuppertal Institute for Climate, Environment and Energy Götz von Stumpfeldt, IKI JET Project (GIZ), Germany
  • 119.
    Wahyu Gatut Purboyo BappedaEast Kalimantan, Indonesia Mr. Wahyu Gatut Purboyo has over seven years of experience in environmental management and regional economic planning. From 2017 to 2023, he served as Head of Environmental Pollution Control at the Provincial Environmental Agency of East Kalimantan. Since 2023, he has held the position of Head of Economic and Natural Resources Division at the Regional Development Planning Agency (Bappeda) of East Kalimantan Province.
  • 120.
    REGIONALCONSULTATIONFORUM(FORUM KONSULTASIDAERAH): Driving East Kalimantan’sEconomic Transformation Beyond Coal Yusliando Head of Bappeda East Kalimantan BAPPEDA PROV. KALTIM
  • 121.
    Population 2024 :4.045,86 thousand people  2.093,90 thousand people (M)  1.951,96 thousand people (F) Projection for 2045 : 6,5 thousand people Economic Growth : 6,12% (y-o-y Tw IV 2024) Economic Growth : 6,17 (2024) Unemployment Rate : 5,14% (2024) GRDP Value (ADHB) : Rp858,43 Trillion (2024) HDI Value : 78,79 (2024) Poverty Rate : 5,78% (2024) Gini Index : 0,321 (2024) GRDP per Capita : Rp212,18 Million (2024) Area Size : 15,34 Million Ha Protected Area : 19,38% Cultivation Area : 80,62% (56,17% Forest Area) Geostrategic Position : ALKI II Coal Resources : 97,297 Billion Ton Coal Reserves : 31,713 Billion Ton Oil Reserves : 166,16 MMTSB Natural Gas Reserves : 996,37 BSCF Palm Oil Plantation Area : 1,47 Million Ha (2023) UU 3/2022 amended by UU 21/2023 concerning IKN dan Perpres No 63/2022 : • To become partner to IKN • To become the Economic Superhub for IKN Source: BPS Prov. Kaltim, RPJPD 2025-2049 Prov Kaltim, dan RTRW Prov. Kaltim 2023-2042 OVERVIEW OF EAST KALIMANTAN
  • 122.
    EAST KALIMANTAN ECONOMICSTRUCTURE Baseline 2025 Target 2029 Target 2034 Target 2039 Target 2045 Processing Industry's Contribution to GRDP (%) 17,75 – 18,00 21,39 – 24,52 25,05 – 31,05 28,68 – 37,57 32,32 – 44,09 Provincial GRDP Contribution (%) 4,20 4,98 5,45 5,67 5,76 GRDP per Capita(in Million Rupiah) 225,27 – 226,88 415,80 – 523,80 550,80 – 760,80 658,80 – 1.000,80 850,00 – 1.289,73 East Kalimantan Provincial Regulation Number 11 of 2024 concerning RPJPD of East Kalimantan Province for 2025-2045: Source: BPS Prov. Kaltim 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 Processing Industry (%) 32,66 33,43 33,28 33,31 33,34 Mining & Quarrying (%) 25,96 20,74 17,06 15,29 12,43 Agriculture, Fisheries, Livestock, Plantations (%) 6,75 12,55 16,40 18,34 21,30 East Kalimantan Provincial Regulation Number 15 of 2008 concerning RPJPD of East Kalimantan Province for 2005-2025:
  • 123.
    Dependence on theextractive sector Economic transformation is not yet relevant & not widely understood The foundation for economic transformation is not yet formed (economy, social, infrastructure) Potential for societal friction in the economic transformation process Plans for collaboration with various stakeholders are not yet visible Problems Identification ESTABLISHMENT OF THE REGIONAL CONSULTATION FORUM (FORUM KONSULTASI DAERAH) Strategic Issues
  • 124.
    DESCRIPTION OF THEESTABLISHMENT OF FORUM KONSULTASI DAERAH REGIONAL CONSULTATION FORUM (FKD) FOR THE ACCELERATION OF EAST KALIMANTAN'S ECONOMIC TRANSFORMATION ESTABLISHED BY SK GUBERNUR KALIMANTAN TIMUR NOMOR 100.3.3.1/K.421/2024 ESTABLISHMENT o To enhance the role of various stakeholders in accelerating economic transformation in the aspect of PLANNING. o To open a broader space for participation for various stakeholders. It is not merely consultative & symbolic but rather aims for COLLABORATION. Its membership consists of representatives from various stakeholders. TASK & FUNCTIONS OF THE WORKING GROUP Task: • To discuss and formulate inputs for economic transformation planning; • To monitor the handling and provide support for resolving obstacles in the implementation of economic transformation; and • To assist the evaluation process and provide input for improving the economic transformation plan. Function: • To enhance awareness among the community, businesses, regulators, the workforce, and other stakeholders regarding the importance of economic transformation; • To disseminate the East Kalimantan Economic Transformation agenda to the wider public; • To promote opportunities and investment; and • To mobilize stakeholder resources.
  • 125.
    Round 4 • Determinationof the Action Plan monitoring and control mechanism Round 3 • Determination of impact projections • Strengthening commitment for all Action Plans and timelines Round 2 • Formulation of Supporting Action Plans to realize the Main Actions Round 1 • Formulation of Main Action Plans: ⚬ Increase in productivity, sustainability, and resilience ⚬ Investment Pre-Round • Determination of Priority Economic Activities • Determination of Foundation Elements for Transformation and Just Transition Jan – Feb 25 Jul – Nov 25 Dec 25 – Jan 26 Feb 26 Mar 26 FKD Activity Flow
  • 126.
    FKD Implementation Progress Round1 • Formulation of Main Action Plans: ⚬Increase in productivity, sustainability, and resilience ⚬Investment Priority Economic Activities 1. Crude Palm Oil 2. Tiger Shrimp 3. Electricity and Renewable Energy (EBT) Gas 4. Oleofoods (such as cooking oil and margarine) 5. Oleochemicals (such as biodiesel and fatty alcohol) 6. Bio-Aviation Fuel (Bioavtur) 7. Herbal & Pharmaceuticals 8. Green Hydrogen 9. Green Ammonia 10. Ecotourism 11. Solar Panels 12. Electric Vehicles 13. Cocoa (raw and semi-finished) 14. Rubber (raw and semi-finished) 15. Downstreaming of Mining Products (Coals)
  • 127.
    Round 1 AgreementsHighlight: Palm Oil & Shrimp • Productivity: 3,46 ton/ha/year → 5 ton/ha/year • 100% ISPO compliance by 2024 PALM OIL (CPO) TIGER SHRIMP • Productivity: 0,125 ton/ha/year → 0,58 ton/ha/year (2045) • 80% production certified sustainable for export Clear productivity and sustainability targets agreed by stakeholders
  • 128.
    Round 1 AgreementsHighlight: This is not just energy substitution; it is structural change: from extractive dependence to regenerative growth Renewable as the New Backbone • Solar on ex-coal land – transforming post-mining scars into energy assets; coal companies shifting roles to Independent Power Producers (IPP). • Hydro with community legitimacy – Applying FPIC (PADIATAPA) and watershed rehabilitation so rivers support both power and people. • Biomethane from palm oil waste – Cutting emissions while replacing fossil LPG, natural gas & diesel. Electricity and Renewable Energy Gas
  • 129.
    Round 1 AgreementsHighlight: • 40% of the total CPO (and other vegetable-based materials) in East Kalimantan is processed within the province. • The focus is not on the obligation to process CPO in East Kalimantan, but on enhancing the competitiveness of the industrial zone so that downstream palm oil investments in East Kalimantan become a competitive and efficient choice. OLEOPANGAN & OLEOKIMIA BIOAVTUR The RU V Balikpapan operates as a national SAF production center with a commercial capacity of 200 thousand kL per year. ≥ Downstreaming cannot be forced by regulation; what we can do is make East Kalimantan the most competitive place to invest. Oleofoods, Oleochemicals, and Bioavtur
  • 130.
    Round 1 AgreementsHighlight: • A minimum of 1 Natural Ingredient Extract Industry (IEBA) with a total capacity of 350 tons of extract/year, ≥ absorbing a majority of local bio- pharmaceutical materials such as tahongai, pasak bumi (tongkat ali), kratom, and other potential plants. • 100% of UKOT/UMOT meet the CPOTB standards according to BPOM regulations and are integrated into the IEBA supply chain. HERBAL PHARMACEUTICAL • A minimum of 1 Pharmaceutical Raw Material Industry (IBBO) with a total capacity of approximately 1,000 tons/year for at least 1 national priority API. • An accredited pharmaceutical testing laboratory established in East Kalimantan. Natural resources give us the materials, but it is knowledge and collaboration that will transform them into sustainable Herbal and Pharmaceutical
  • 131.
    Agreement Highlight: NextDiscussion GREEN HYDROGEN & AMMONIA TOURISM SOLAR PANELS ELECTRIC VEHICLES
  • 132.
    Closing: From Coalto Collaboration • Transformation is about securing the future beyond coal. • FKD is the platform to ensure inclusivity and shared ownership. • Our direction is clear: investment, productivity, and sustainability as guiding principles • What matters now is collaboration — across government, business, communities, and international partners East Kalimantan is ready to become Indonesia’s icon of just and green economic transformation
  • 133.
  • 134.
    He currently servesas the Head of the Economic and Development Financing Division at the Regional Development Planning Agency (Bappeda) of South Sumatra Province. He has over 17 years of experience in regional planning and economic development, having previously held various positions within Bappeda, including Head of Strategic Planning, Evaluation and Control Division (2021–2022) and Head of Tourism, Industry, and Trade Subdivision (2015–2021). Earlier in his career, he worked at the Provincial Agriculture and Horticulture Office and later advanced through roles focused on agribusiness, SMEs, and strategic development planning in South Sumatra. Hari Wibawa Bappeda of South Sumatra, Indonesia
  • 135.
    EXPERIENCES OF SOUTH SUMATRAIN ECONOMIC DIVERSIFICATION AND TRANSFORMATION PLANNING THROUGH THE RCF PROCESS Indonesia Sustainable Energy Week Goes Regional (ISEWGR) East Kalimantan, 2025 Samarinda, 14 October 2025
  • 136.
    Multistakeholder Platform: Regional ConsultationForum (RCF) • Foundational elements • Priority economic activities • Core actions • Supporting actions • Scenario and impact projection • Action plan, commitment • MnE mechanism 2026 . Q1 2026 . Q1 2025 .Q4 – 2026. Q1 2025 . Q2- Q4 Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Round 4
  • 137.
    ROUND 1 For acceleratingeconomic transformation in South Sumatra REGIONAL CONSULTATION FORUM ROUND 2 ROUND 3 ROUND 4 14 April 2025 Kick Off/Pre Forum RCF South Sumatra. WEEK-3 DECEMBER 2025 Meeting 1 Theme (a) repurposing of ex- mining land, (b) the role of SMEs, (c) competency development and employment WEEK-3 FEBRUARY 2026 Transformation Scenario, Overall action plan 10 June 2025 Meeting 1 Theme Plantation (palm oil+ CPO, Rubber, Coffee) and Fisheries (cat-fish, local fish (gabus), Vanname shrimp) 11 September 2025 Meeting 2 Theme Plantation and Fisheries (in depth) 07 October 2025 Meeting 3 Theme Tourism 29 October 2025 Meeting 4 Theme Energy (Hydro, Solar, Geothermal) dan Biometana 06 November 2025 Meeting 5 Theme Natural Fibre (pineapple) and Waste to Energy 27 November 2025 Meeting 5 Theme Oleo (food, chemical including biodesel) and bioavtur WEEK-2 JANUARY 2026 Meeting 2 Theme (a) infrastructure development, (b) social and environmental licence, regional taxes and subsidies, incentives WEEK-3 MARCH 2026 Joint Monitoring and Control of Transformation Plan Implementation
  • 138.
    OPPORTUNITIES CHALLENGES South Sumatra possesses abundant natural resources with strong potentialfor sustainable development South Sumatra has renewable energy potential of 21,032 MW, with an installed capacity of 1,009.28 MW Rubber - Total area of 1 mio Ha - Exsport 7400 thousand ton/year - Eksport Value USD 1,34 mio/year Coffee - 1s t biggest coffee producers in Indonesia. Palm Oil - Province with the 6th largest oil palm plantation area in Indonesia: 1,4 mio Ha - Produksi CPO : 3,8 juta ton Rice - 5t h biggest rice producers in Indonesia Fisheries - 1s t biggest cat-fish (patin) producers in Indonesia HYDRO (PLTM/PLTMH) - Potential : 448 MW - Installed : 21,96 MW WIND - Potential : 301 MW - Installed : - SOLAR - Potential : 17.233 MWp - Installed : 8,86 MWp GEOTHERMAL - Potential : 918 MW - Installed : 146,2 MW BIOENERGY - Potential : 2132 MW - Installed : 832,26 MW South Sumatra still relies heavily on the primary sector, with the mining and quarrying sector contributing 24% to the GRDP in 2024 The development of a green economy and renewable energy requires substantial financing Support from the central government is needed to support infrastructure development, establish strong regulations and green incentives, with special attention to the principles of a just transition OPPORTUNITIES DAN CHALLENGES Tourism - South Sumatra’s tourism potential is in nature, historical and cultural, culinary and sports
  • 140.
    COFFEE ECOSYSTEM Farmers Collector Processingindustry Market CSR Coal Company Banking Banking National Standardization Agency Provincial/ District/City Gov. Banking End Consumers Banking Provincial/ District/City Gov. Provincial/ District/City Gov. University NGO NGO NGO NGO CSR of Coal Companies can play a role in the coffee cultivation cycle, with its funding, supported by the plantation service through training programs to increase productivity and maintain soil quality. Banking also offers financing through KUR and micro credit to coffee farmers and collectors. On the industrial side, the National Standardization Agency (BSN) formulates standards and provides certification after ensuring coffee product safety standards. The Industry Service supports industry players with technical guidance and supervision. MSMEs and retail traders gain access to financing from banks, while the Trade Service is expected to open market access and supervise trade practices to protect consumers and business actors. Universities can assist in research on improving the economy and empowering coffee farmers. Non- Governmental Organizations (NGOs) can also assist in providing assistance in every process.
  • 141.
  • 142.
    Mr. Timon Wehnertis a Senior Researcher at the Wuppertal Institute and Co-Lead of the International Energy Transitions Research Unit. His work focuses on structural change, regional innovation, and just transition in climate policy contexts, including coal phase-out and industrial decarbonisation. He coordinates Wuppertal Institute’s role in the EU’s Coal Regions in Transition Initiative and the global Innovation Regions for a Just Energy Transition project. With over two decades of experience in sustainable energy research, Timon is also an experienced facilitator in scientific and transdisciplinary processes. Timon Wehnert Wuppertal Institute for Climate, Environment and Energy
  • 143.
    Renewable Energy BenefitSharing Instruments to support coal regions in transition and foster acceptance for renewables locally 14.10.2025 Timon Wehnert, Joachim Fünfgelt, Linus Kurtenbach Wuppertal Institute
  • 144.
    Starting point -A Coal Revenues • Example - Indonesia: 5.2 billion € (1 trillion IDR) of state income come from coal (2025 estimate according to ESDM) • a large share is redistributed to coal mining regions - key factor in local public budget (80% of non-tax revenues go to provinces, cities and regencies with coal mines) Coal phase-down means massive loss of public budget for many coal regions around the
  • 145.
    Starting point -B Local economic benefits are a key factor to raise acceptance of renewables Acceptance of Renewables • In many regions with high share of renewables there is protest and opposition • Many locals say that they only get to feel the negative impacts
  • 146.
    ● Tax andFiscal Solutions ● Community Benefit Schemes ● Local Ownership Models Categories for RE benefit sharing schemes ● Local Cash Flows ● Project Economics ● Public Acceptance …influence each in different ways…
  • 147.
    Tax Revenue Sharing SuccessFactors: • Funds must be managed transparently to avoid misuse. • Payments must be mandatory When seen as voluntary “gifts” they can even fuel cynicism (viewed as “bribes”). • Corporate income tax paid by RE developers • Value-added tax (VAT) on equipment, construction, or energy sales • Environmental levies related to energy generation
  • 148.
    Example: Tax revenuesharing in Colombia Since 2019 solar/wind projects > 10 MW have to allocate 1% of gross sales to local communities in the area of influence. Of this 1%: - 60% for indigenous/afro-descendant communities and - 40% for municipalities. Purposes for which money can be spent: infrastructure, public services, sanitary facilities, potable water or projects that improve the quality of life and wellbeing of the people. 60% 40% 🇨🇴 1%
  • 149.
    Community Benefit Schemes Usually,project developers and the communities agree on services from the developer towards the community. This may include: direct financial contributions to the community, infrastructural improvements, employment & training or environmental mitigation. Transparency and sufficient resources for the communities crucial to address power imbalances. We can differentiate between formalised and voluntary community benefit schemes depending on local regulation.
  • 150.
    Voluntary benefit sharingin Germany Windpark operators in Germany can • voluntarily involve communities close to the turbines with 0,002€/kWh. • deduct those payments from their taxes This boosts acceptance for RE and helps especially rural municipalities to improve their municipal finances. Foto Sources: Sidrak Wind Power Plant: wikimedia Open Licence / Jeneponto CC common from Harakan, Ahmad & Mustari, Nuryanti & Kinyondo, Abel. (2021). Sustainable Energy Investment through Paradiplomacy Practices in South Sulawesi, Indonesia. E3S Web of Conferences. 277. 02002. 10.1051/e3sconf/202127702002. For a medium-sized windpark with 75MW capacity that produces in Germany 185 GWh/year → 370.000€/year for the municipality. Comparable in size to Sidrak Wind Power Plant or Jeneponto in South Sulawesi.
  • 151.
    Local Ownership Models Localownership of renewable projects can strongly boost local economic development and social acceptance! Major categories for ownership models are: ● Community ownership / Cooperatives ● Public ownership ● Shared ownership arrangements
  • 152.
    Local Ownership Models1/2 Muara Enggelam (Kalimatan Timur, Indonesia) ● Village Owned Enterprise (VOE) running a 45 kWp Solar System serving all 192 households of the village ● Electricity used for public facilities, households and commercial purpose (swallow’s nest farming) ● Active community ownership, managed and operated by VOE The case of Muara Enggelam demonstrates how a VOE can effectively manage and operate a solar PV grid to support livelihoods in its community. With low dependence on government funds for its operation, this case illustrates how community consensus can enhance mini-grid management.
  • 153.
    Local Ownership Models2/2 Barrio El Salvador (Medellín, Colombia) First so-called energy community in Colombia: A group of neighbors in Medellins El Salvador neighborhood is producing their own energy. Once they satisfied their energy needs they can also sell excess energy on the electricity market which provides the necessary funds for the maintenance of the panels. Read more about Colombian Energy Communities on the JET-CR Knowledge Hub.
  • 154.
    Summary ● Adequate localrevenue sharing is one key element to support local acceptance of renewable energy projects ● In countries in which local communities and coal mining regions heavily depend on tax and non-tax revenues from coal ...  formalised, govermental approaches to renewable energy benefit sharing will be necessary to sustain local public budgets
  • 155.
    Outlook Work in progress,we are open for suggestions: ○ Good practice of revenue sharing globally? ○ Success factors and barriers to implementation? ○ Data on coal revenues for local communities / regions
  • 156.
    Presented by February 2023 KeyIKI JET contacts at Wuppertal Institute Timon Wehnert [email protected] Jannis Beutel [email protected] Joachim Fünfgelt [email protected]
  • 157.
    Götz von Stumpfeldtis an advisor working in the Innovation Regions for a Just Energy (IKI-JET) project in GIZ Germany. Before that he worked as project planner in GIZ, focused on green economy. He managed grant allocation for energy transition in the German Federal State of Rhineland Palatinate and headed a GIZ project on Governance in the natural resource sector in the Democratic Republic of Congo. Goetz worked as an advisor on economic policies in the German Federal Parliament and started his career in managing make work programs in the restructuring of East German industries. Götz von Stumpfeldt IKI JET (GIZ)
  • 158.
    Handbook on Economic Diversificationfor Coal Regions by the Just Energy Transition in Coal Regions Interregional Platform Götz von Stumpfeldt, IKI JET Project
  • 159.
    How to movefrom coal to new businesses ? The Handbook on Economic Diversification for Coal Regions in Transition will guide you trough the process  How ho identify the economic sectors with the highest potential for a region?  Find the economic sectors that help a region to realize its social, environmental and economic objectives  How can a region make best use of the data that is available in a region?  How to elaborate a strategy for economic diversification for the region Just transition of coal regions will only work, if there are alternatives for economic development
  • 160.
    Cycle of strategydesign for economic diversification 1. Diagnosis Of The Current State 2. Defining The Vision And Objectives 3. Prioritizing Opportunities 4. Defining Policy Actions 5. Monitoring And Evaluation Of Actions Economic diversification
  • 161.
    East Kalimantan hasa highly concentrated economic structure (top 5 sectors account for 71% of GDP in 2023). Limited diversification progress over the last 10 years Source: National Statistics 3% 3% 3% 2% 1% 14% (38%) Mining of Coal and Lignite Manufacture of Coal and Refined Petroleum Products Crude Petroleum, Natural Gas, and Geothermal uction (4%) Wholesale Trade and Retail Trade Except of Motor Vehicles and Motorcycles estock, Hunting and Agriculture Services Other Mining and Quarrying Chemicals and Pharmaceuticals and Botanical Products Manufacture of Food Product and Beverages d Communication Other Share in 2013 regional GDP 4% 4% 3% 2% 2% 16% (36%) Mining of Coal and Lignite (13%) Manufacture of Coal and Refined Petroleum Products (9%) Construction (7%) Crude Petroleum, Natural Gas, and Geothermal (6%) Wholesale Trade and Retail Trade Except of Motor Vehicles and Motorcycles Agriculture, Livestock, Hunting and Agriculture Services Other Mining and Quarrying Manufacture of Chemicals and Pharmaceuticals and Botanical Products Manufacture of Food Product and Beverages Information and Communication Other Share in 2023 regional GDP Top 5 sectors Combined 75% Top 5 sectors Combined 71% 2.2 Indicators to assess the degree of economic diversification in coal regions and social and environmental implications Diagnosis of the currenct state of economic diversification East Kalimantan, Indonesia Share of sectors others than coal in the local economy
  • 162.
    Example: Export structure 4.2Quantitative tools to identify diversification opportunities Export structure for Indonesia : High concentration in minerals (coal) and agriculture (palm oil). The Handbook links up with lots off online accessible tools: This one provicd by The Altlas of Economic Complexity of the Harvard Growh Lab. https://atlas.hks.harvard.edu/
  • 163.
    Case Study: Indonesia´sProduct Space Source: https://atlas.hks.harvard.edu/explore/productspace?exporter=country-360/ Specialised in less complex products: coal, textiles and agricultural goods
  • 164.
    In Antofagasta (Chile)female employment participation Human health care activities Public administration and defence; compulsory social security schemes Education Accommodation activities Retail trade, except motor vehicles and motorcycles Food and beverage service activities Membership organisation activities Wholesale trade, except motor vehicles and motorcycles Security and investigation activities Wholesale and retail trade and repair of motor vehicles and motorcycles Warehousing and support activities for transportation Architectural and engineering activities; technical testing and analysis Land transport and transport via pipelines Office administrative, support, and other business support activities Manufacture of fabricated metal products, except machinery and equipment Rental and leasing activities Repair and installation of machinery and equipment Copper mining and processing Specialised construction activities Civil engineering works 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 70% 69% 64% 64% 59% 59% 55% 38% 32% 31% 23% 22% 22% 20% 18% 17% 15% 13% 12% 10% Share of male employees 2023 Share of female employees 2023 Case Study: Social Economic Structure
  • 165.
    Defining objectives foreconomic diversification Economic Objectives Attract FDI that creates and leaves benefits in the region Improve productivity or value added Improve the level of product sophistication Promote economic autonomy (strategic assets) Reduce vulnerability Social Objectives (Inclusiveness and Just) Generate quality employment Promote Women´s Economic Empowerment Improve social cohesion Reduce inequality Increase participation of vulnerable groups Environmental Objectives (Sustainability) Combat climate change - mitigation (Decarbonisation, etc.) Promote biodiversity conservation Reduce waste and pollution Promote sustainable land use Promote resource conservation (Circular Economy, etc.) Be clear about the objectives of the diversification process is key to prioritising sectors and products
  • 166.
    The Handbook providestools to estimate the economic potentials for economic diversification by  Providing access to quantitative tools analysing markets, data & technological potential e.g. UNIDO dive tools, Harvard hks, GPI tool  describing qualitative tools (assessment of economic actors) Identifying economic diversification opportunities e.g: Participatory Appraisal of Competitive Advantage PACA (GIZ)
  • 167.
    Identifying sectors toachieve Just Transition objectives Economic Objectives: (e.g. increase value addition & productivity) Example: Chemicals; base metals; green hydrogen Social Objectives: (e.g. generation of quality employment & Women's Economic Empowerment) Example: Agricultural products, food and beverages; textiles and apparel; furniture Environmental Objectives: (e.g. climate mitigation & waste reduction) Example: green hydrogen; renewable energies; sustainable agriculture These sectors, while good for promoting value creation and productivity: - may not be able to generate significant employment, considering that they rely heavily on more advanced technologies (trade-off). - by introducing green technologies could also support environmental objectives (inter-linkage). These sectors, while good for generating employment and women economic empowerment: - may not be strategic for technological development, innovation and the development of more sophisticated skills (trade-off). - Could also contribute to increase value addition (inter-linkage). These sectors while more aligned with climate change mitigation objectives: - they are not necessarily a major source of employment (trade- off). - could also be strategic to increase sophistication (inter-linkage).
  • 168.
    A comprehensive toolboxfor policy design is provided 1. Instrument (name) •Official title of project/ program/ intervention 2. Strategy objective targeted by the instrument • One or various objective (s) that will be supported through the instrument implementation 3. Short description of instrument •Type of instrument and its main characteristics 4. Main activities to implement the instrument •Key actions that will ensure the correct instrument implementation 5. Expected impact of instrument •Expected changes because of instrument implementation 6. Base line indicator for instrument •Current value of the Indicator that allows to measure the effective implementation of the instrument 7. Target value for instrument •Expected value of the baseline indicator after instrument implementation 8. Target groups •Sectors, size of companies, groups of the population that would be impacted by the instrument 9. Responsible implementing institution •Institution name and responsible department 10. Supporting institutions for implementation •Institution name and responsible department 11. Timeframe for implementation •Start and expected completion date 12. Estimated budget •Financial resources required for implementation 13. Funding source •Name of the institution, organization, agency, etc that will contribute with financial resources to support implementation 14. Additional remarks •Any relevant info or reference/link to project details Note: Depending on the country / region the level of detail of the action plan could differ and can include all these elements or some of them Defining Policy Actions for diversification
  • 169.
    Components of amonitoring and evaluation system An effective deployment of a M&E system involves the use of specific skills & knowledge from the institution leading the process, the application of M&E tools, and the establishment of different processes (within line ministries and other institutions also responsible for the implementation of the strategy). M&E tools M&E processes Intervention Logic Log-Frame Reporting Template M&E Plan Knowledge of M&E tools Data collection & manageme nt Analytical & Critical Thinking Problem- Solving Skills Intra-institutional and Inter-institutional processes M&E skills & knowledge Note: Refer to the following 3 slides for more details. Monitoring and evaluation
  • 170.
    How to workwith the handbook – for different users a. For Policy makers at the level of strategic planning: A summary version which compiles key messages from each chapter b. For Policy practitioners at a technical/operative level A detailed version providing practical guidance to design an effective economic diversification strategy. The handbook is available in two versions:​ https://www.jetknowledge.org/knowledge/handbook-economic-diversi fication-coal-regions-transition/ Please find it under this link:
  • 171.
    To learn moreplease visit our website: jetknowledge.org For questions concerning economic diversification please contact Götz von Stumpfeldt, [email protected] Thank you very much for your attention! Contact
  • 172.
    Coffee Break Feel freeto visit us on jetknowledge.org
  • 173.
    Micro, Small &Medium Enterprises in Economic Diversification International Forum for Coal Regions in Transition 2025 Davit Manalu, Krealogi Consulting, Jakarta Lishia Erza, Indonesian Employers Association, APINDO, Indonesia Session 4 Andres Jil Breytmann, IKI JET, GIZ Chile
  • 174.
    With over nineyears of experience in project management, Mr Davit Manalu specializes in social enterprise, community development, CSR, ESG, and SME training programs. He manages an average of 10–15 projects annually with a total value of around IDR 10 billion and successfully raises up to IDR 3 billion per year. His work focuses on improving livelihoods through SME and community development, as well as conservation initiatives across Indonesia. He has collaborated with various national and international partners, including IFC, UNOPS, the World Bank, YKAN (TNC), WWF, the Ministry of Women and Child Empowerment, and the Central Bank of Indonesia. His expertise spans social and spatial studies, ESG for SMEs, fundraising, training design, financial management, monitoring and evaluation, business development, and stakeholder engagement. Davit Manalu Krealogi Consulting, Jakarta
  • 175.
  • 176.
    KREALOGI JOURNEY MSME EcosystemEnabler 1.600+ WEAVERS 1.200+ B2B CLIENTS Starting based on experience DU ANYAM Indonesia's Leading Social Enterprise Based on Crafts, Has a Strong Supply Chain System, and is Integrated with Rural Communities TRUSTED SUPPLIER FOR DOMESTIC & INTERNATIONAL BUYERS 2020 Krealogi was born from Du Anyam's experience in establishing production systems and supply chains for SMEs in remote areas. 2022 Krealogi began to focus on providing entrepreneurship training and mentoring in collaboration with several partners Krealogi was incorporated as a separate entity from Du Anyam in 2023 2023 54+ SUPPORTED VILLAGES IN NTT, KALSEL & PAPUA 40-100% INCREASING WOMEN'S INCOME Krealogi has transformed into an ecosystem enabler, steadfast in its commitment to education, digitalization and forming sustainable partnership 2024 The remarkable achievements attained along this journey: Proud member of: Received award from:
  • 177.
    KREALOGI also workswith seaweed commodity business aggregators (production and sales operations) supporting their community development and innovation in Renewable Energy adaptation. Seaweed Aggregator Krealogi working with potential partners focuses on Community Development and Supply Chain Services: ● Strategic Partnerships ● Study/Research ● Develop Programs ● Implementation Planning on Solar Energy Technology Implementation (cold storage, dryer, water pump, etc) Seaweed Farmers Intermediary Trader District/Provincial Level Collector Village Level Intermediary Trader Multi-province Level Larger Trader Global Market Domestic Market Processed Seaweed : Biostimulant Inconsistent Quality High logistic cost Lack of traceability Large volume demand Supply inconsistency Higher cost due to low productivity
  • 178.
    Development of (women-led)small and medium enterprises in East Kalimantan and South Sumatra in the context of Just Coal Transition
  • 179.
    In the nationalenergy transition, SMEs have a significant role to play, with SMEs accounting for one- third of industrial emissions-95% of which come from energy use. Program Title Lokus Program Objective Program Duration Development of Small and Medium Enterprises (Women-led) in East Kalimantan and South Sumatra in the Context of a Just Coal Transition 1. Assessing areas for improvement in the SME support ecosystem (led by women) 2. Developing innovative business models that facilitate decarbonization, green business expansion, and digital transformation for SMEs (led by women) 3. Recommend skill development for SMEs (led by women) through pilot projects December 24 to November 25 East Kalimantan and South Sumatra Summary Program Background 64.5% Women-led MSMEs 60% Indonesia's GDP from MSMEs 60% Women-led SMEs 5-10% Part of Coal value chain Target 600-1000 Small Medium Enterprises Supporting stakeholders Assessment of SMEs profile Assessment of Operating Context Modeling transformations for existing business process Modeling transformations for green business opportunities Capacity building action plan
  • 180.
    SMEs Profiles inSouth Sumatera and East Kalimantan ● It is difficult to find respondents with women leaders because most of them are still on a micro scale. ● Most of SMEs have low annual income and categorized as Small Entrepreneurs, and not really have linked their profit with mining company. ● The largest sector is retail and food and beverage with >62% of this sector are women-led ● Average education is high school and most >40 years old, the transition program needs to adapt to this level of education 51.5% Women-led >62% Women-led in fnb and retail sector
  • 181.
    SMEs Profiles inSouth Sumatera and East Kalimantan ● The majority of businesses have no legalities, barrier in accessing capital and support program from government. ● Most SMEs are not members of organizations, which poses challenges in terms of information dissemination and program implementation. ● Majority of SMEs joining organizations to networking and gather information.
  • 182.
    Energy and SustainabilityProfiles of SMEs in South Sumatra and East Kalimantan ● The main source of energy is currently 100% from PLN, with 13% of SMEs using generators as backup power sources, indicating that electricity is still unstable in some areas, and only 7 use solar power because there is no PLN electricity source at their place of business. ● More than 60% consider sustainability to be important, but transform to solar energy has challenges in terms of not understanding the benefits and knowledge about rooftop solar energy. ● SMEs stated that waste management and energy efficiency were most likely to be implemented in their businesses.
  • 183.
    ● Most SMEshave no external support, majority support comes from government and financial institutions. ● Misaligned between type of support by external and SMEs needs ● Support for green business is very low, and there are very few institutions available to provide assistance on this topic. SMEs Challenges in South Sumatra and East Kalimantan
  • 184.
    Assessment of operatingcontext : SME support ecosystem Main Support functions Direct Business Operation SMEs Market intermediary Consumer Financing Skill Development Technical Assistance Business Incubator Legality and Registration Partnership and networking Access to green technology and skills Category of supporting stakeholder : gov, coal, ngo, asc, bank, private, univ Loan gov, coal, bank Program/grant Available Not Available gov, private Aggregator Secondary Support functions gov, ngo, univ, asc ● Support misaligned with SMEs needs ● Technical aspects and processes of support need improvement ● The same type of support is provided by several institutions ● There is no specific capacity building model for women yet. ● The SME transformation model can utilize existing sources of SME development funding.
  • 185.
    Summary Most SMEs prioritizestability over transformation; capital support is needed for transformation. Income contribution related to coal company < 30 percent. With regard to transition, SMEs need sufficient capital before pivoting their business. Women-led program should focus on FnB and retail sectors (>62% women-led) Capacity building should match SME demographics (older owners, high school education) and address women’s needs. SMEs is rely 100% from PLN, with 13% stating that they use generators as backup, and <1% using solar energy due to limited access to PLN. 60% value sustainability but lack knowledge on implementation, especially rooftop solar. Waste management and energy efficiency are key focus areas for green practices. Stakeholders should provide tailored technical, financial, and mentorship support, especially for local green initiatives.
  • 186.
    Mrs. Lishia Erzabrings over 20 years of experience leading and advising businesses across the UK, Singapore, and Hong Kong in the technology, media, and financial sectors. Recognized globally, she has been named among the Top 100 Women in Supply Chain and Fintech, as well as Indonesia’s Most Powerful Business Women by SWA Magazine. Currently, she serves in multiple leadership roles — including Chair of SME Development at APINDO, Permanent Committee Chair for Strategic Industries Financing at KADIN, and a B20 Thought Leader — championing sustainable finance, responsible bioeconomy, and inclusive growth across Indonesia and the region. Lishia Erza, Indonesian Employers Association, APINDO, Indonesia
  • 201.
    Mr. Tomás Jilis a Technical Advisor at GIZ Chile, where he leads the national implementation of the global project Just Energy Transition in Coal Regions (JET-CR). Prior to joining GIZ, he worked with Wood and the International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) on renewable energy consulting and VRE integration planning. He holds a European Joint Master’s in Management and Engineering of Environment and Energy, as well as a Mechanical Engineering degree from the University of Chile. Tomas Breytmann, National Advisor, GIZ Chile
  • 202.
    Working on thelinkages of SMEs to value chains of large companies: Lessons learned from Coronel and Mejillones by the Just Energy Transition in Coal Regions Interregional Platform Tomas Andres Jil Breytmann, IKI JET Chile
  • 203.
    Brief Chile’s CoalRegion Context Chile no longer operates coal mines and the coal used for power generation is imported (mainly from Colombia) Our current coal phase-out process is focused on the power generation sector. By 2018, there were 6 regions with coal power generation, but as of today 4 remain Coronel Mejillones Chile
  • 204.
    Enterprise context inMejillones and Coronel Micro Small Medium Large 0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000 3852 855 105 64 80 265 245 3,735 Number of enterprises and annual revenues by type of enterprise in Coronel - 2022 Number of enterprises Annual sales of the group Number of enterprises Annual revenues in million USD Micro Small Medium Large 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 0 500 1000 1500 2000 495 160 20 13 12 46 38 1,474 Number of enterprises and annual revenues by type of enterprise in Mejillones - 2022 Number of enterprises Annual sales of the group Number of enterprises Annual revenues in million USD Number of workers for each 100 UF of annual revenues - Mejillones Micro Small Medium Large Employment Sales
  • 205.
    2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 50% 100% 150% 200% 250% 300% 350% 400% 450% Revenue growth pertype of enterprise - Coronel SME Large 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 88% 100% 113% 125% 138% 150% Revenue growth per type of enterprise - Mejillones SME Large Enterprise context in Mejillones and Coronel
  • 206.
    Objective and approach Marketing,digital capabilities, pitch speechs, etc. Approach focused in enhancing general capabilities of SME’s Approach focused on the SMEs’ capabilities required by large enterprises in the regions What are the large industries requiring from local SMEs to increase their participation into their value chain? Both regions had large and specialized industries so a level of diversification existed, but this development has not permeated to the local SME ecosystem. Two main approaches for tackling this issues are identified: “Pull” from the demand side. Make the large companies in the region keener to acquire local products and services. Focus on formalized SMEs rather than informal entrepreneurships Approach Target SMEs
  • 207.
    Methodology and outline 1.Diagnostic - Characterize the relations of large companies in the regions with local SME’s • Understand the current relationships, the perceptions and past experiences with local SMES • Identify the risks and barriers for further commercial relationships with local SMEs • Identify the sectors with the largest potential for further development 2. Capacity building program - Elaboration of a capacity building program for local SMEs based on the diagnostic aiming to enhance their linkage into large company's value chains including its: • Structure, format, content and duration • Stakeholders involved and their roles • Criteria of SMEs selection* • Imparting bodies
  • 208.
    Shared diagnostic resultsbetween regions Identified risks and barriers that hinder the process Perceived benefits of strengthening the link with local SMEs • Knowledge of the territories • Local working networks • Flexibility of local SMEs under unforeseen circumstances (both in terms of requirements and in time • Compliance of internal sustainability goals of the companies
  • 209.
    Contrasts in theimplementation aspect for each region Coronel (2024) 1. Diagnostic • 25 bilateral meetings with relevant stakeholders for Coronel’s, including large companies in Coronel, business associations, public actors, to understand • An online survey to large companies in Coronel to obtain further quantitative data (with low level of replies) 2. Elaboration of the capacity building program • Desk analysis of diagnostic and elaboration of the program • Individual validation of the drafted program with some large companies in the region Mejillones (2025) 1. Diagnostic • A single workshop inviting the acquisition teams of the partner companies of the Business Association of Industrial Companies of Mejillones (AIM), which groups the 23 largest companies in Mejillones. • An online survey to large companies in Mejillones to obtain further quantitative data (with a 96% of replies) 2. Elaboration of the capacity building program • Desk analysis of diagnostic and elaboration of the program • Workshop with AIM and potential public partners for validating the drafted program and foresee the next steps for the program implementation (November 2025)
  • 210.
    • Similar barriersacross regions: The main risks and obstacles for linking SMEs to large companies are broadly the same. • Implementation matters: The way these initiatives are carried out in each region is key to achieving results. • Collective engagement in Mejillones: Active participation of large companies has created a sense of ownership and alignment around common capacity gaps. • Industry-driven content: Large companies are also expected to contribute imparting specific modules to the training program, ensuring relevance to local realities as well as ownership of the program. • Broader SME opportunities: SMEs benefit from a program designed to help them work with most large companies, not just a few. • The collaborative approach developed in Mejillones strengthens outcomes but requires a strong partner able to convene and align major companies, which is not always present in every region Lessons learned and following steps
  • 211.
    Fishbowl Discussion -Economic Diversification and the Role of MSMEs International Forum for Coal Regions in Transition 2025
  • 212.
    Your Feedback Matters! Pleasetake 2 minutes to fill out the Post-Event Survey
  • 213.
    Any person whobelieves they may be harmed by an IKI project or who wishes to report corruption or the misuse of funds can lodge a complaint to the IKI Independent Complaint Mechanism at [email protected]. The IKI Complaint Mechanism has a panel of independent experts who will investigate the complaint. In the course of the investigation, we will consult with the complainant so as to avoid unnecessary risks for the complainant. More information can be found at: https://www.international-climate-initiative.com/en/aboutiki/values-responsibility/independen t-complaint-mechanism/
  • 214.
    Acknowledgements The project "InnovationRegions for a Just Energy Transition" is co-financed by the International Climate Initiative (IKI) of the Federal Government of Germany and by the Directorate-General for International Partnerships (DG INTPA) of the European Commission for the Interregional Platform for Just Energy Transition in Coal Regions (JET-CR).
  • 215.
    Objective Support andaccelerate just energy transitions (JET) away from coal to renewable energy and other sustainable economic activities in the Global South Implementing organisations • Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH • Climate Action Network International (CAN International) • International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD) • International Labour Organisation (ILO) • Solidarity Center • Union Aid Abroad – APHEDA • Wuppertal Institute for Climate, Environment and Energy Project duration December 2022 – January 2027 (4 years) About IKI JET

Editor's Notes

  • #7 Mendorong investasi energi bersih di Kalimantan Timur”
  • #10 Transisi energi merupakan bagian dari transpormasi ekonomi: Hubungan transisi energi dan transformasi ekonomi dalam konteks strategi kebijakan pembangunan Kalimantan Timur (Kaltim) harus dimaknai secara terpadu — karena keduanya saling memperkuat dalam mewujudkan pembangunan berkelanjutan dan daya saing daerah pasca-era sumber daya fosil. “Kalimantan Timur berada pada momentum transisi energy yang penting dan Menentukan .” 1. Makna Konseptual Transisi energi berarti peralihan dari ketergantungan pada energi fosil (batubara, minyak) menuju energi bersih dan terbarukan (seperti biomassa, tenaga surya, air, dan angin). Transformasi ekonomi berarti perubahan struktur ekonomi dari yang didominasi sektor ekstraktif (pertambangan, minyak dan gas) menuju ekonomi yang lebih produktif, inklusif, dan berkelanjutan (industri hilir, pertanian modern, energi hijau, pariwisata, dan jasa). Keduanya adalah dua sisi dari satu proses perubahan — transisi energi menjadi motor penggerak transformasi ekonomi. 2. Makna Strategis bagi Kaltim Sebagai provinsi kaya sumber daya fosil dan lokasi IKN, Kaltim menghadapi tantangan ganda: Menurunkan ketergantungan pada batubara dan migas yang makin terbatas dan berisiko lingkungan tinggi. Menyiapkan ekonomi baru yang mampu menopang kesejahteraan jangka panjang. Maka, transisi energi menjadi arah baru strategi pembangunan daerah, yang: Menarik investasi energi bersih dan industri hijau; Mendorong inovasi teknologi dan penciptaan lapangan kerja baru; Menguatkan posisi Kaltim sebagai superhub ekonomi hijau Nusantara mendukung IKN. Transisi energi adalah jalan menuju kemandirian dan keadilan energi, sedangkan transformasi ekonomi adalah arah menuju kemakmuran berkeadilan. Dengan menghubungkan keduanya, Kaltim menegaskan dirinya sebagai laboratorium ekonomi hijau Indonesia yang tidak hanya menambang sumber daya alam, tapi menambang nilai tambah dan pengetahuan. “Kalimantan Timur berada pada momentum transisi energy yang penting dan Menentukan .” Indonesia’s top coal-producing region: Produksi batu bara Kaltim tahun 2023 sebesar 338 juta ton, 44% dari total prduksi nasional di tahun yg sama (775 juta ton). Sumber BPS, dimana data tersedia hanya tahun 2023. Fossil dominates its energy use: 89% energi yang digunakan di Kaltim tahun 2023 berasal dari energi fosil (diesel, batu bara, gas alam, dll). Sumber: Dinas ESDM Kaltim Shift the local economy to be more diversified and sustainable: Kaltim menargetkan peningkatan kontribusi PDRB industry pengolahan dari 18% (2025) ke 32% (2045), dan indeks ekonomi hijau dari 58 (2025) ke 71 (2045). Sumber RPJPD Kaltim. We want an inclusive and fair transition: Kaltim ingin memastikan proses transisi berkeadilan dimana seluruh pihak terdampak dapat berkembang dan menjadi lebih baik, dimulai dengan proses perencanaan yang transparan. We recognize the urgency to shift. This is not only about energy—it is about our future: Transisi energi memerlukan transformasi ekonomi di Kaltim, dan transformasi ekonomi menentukan masa depan warga Kalimantan Timur. Diagram: Bagian dalam: porsi energi yang digunakan per jenis energi primer dimana EBT hanya sekitar 11% dan fosil 89%. Bagian luar: porsi penggunaan energi per sektor ekonomi dimana sebagian besar energi primer digunakan di kegiatan tambang batu bara berupa penggunaan diesel untuk pengangkutan (truk).
  • #11 Inti dari transisi energi adalah beralihnya penggunaan energi dari fosil ke energi terbarukan Berdasarkan profil penggunaan energi Kaltim di sektor-sektor ekonomi sebagaimana disampaikan pada slide sebelumnya, grafik ini memperlihatkan peluang-peluang transisi. Dari grafik tersebut terlihat transisi energi di pembangkitan listrik yang terhubung ke PLN (grid connected) perlu diprioritaskan karena transisi tersebut yang yang paling signifikan dan paling feasible untuk dijalankan. Paling signifikan maksudnya jumlah energi yang beralih ke energi terbarukan cukup besar. Khusus tentang pembangkitan listrik, peralihan lebih tentang prioritas penggunaan EBT bagi pembangunan pembangkit baru dimana PLN merencanakan 69% (1,1 GW) dari total pembangunan pembangkit baru 2025-2034 (1,6 GW) berupa pembangkit EBT. Jadi ini bukan tentang early retirement (pensiun dini) PLTU yang ada sekarang karena PLTU yang ada di Kaltim tidak masuk dalam daftar prioritas untuk early retirement. Paling feasible masmaksudnya dimungkinkan secara teknis dan keekonomian.
  • #12 Sebelumnya disampakan bahwa pembangkitan listrik adalah prioritas utama transisi meningat tingginya signifikansi dan feasibility. Potensi EBT terbesar di Kaltim adalah air (PLTA) dan surya (PLTS): kedua teknologi tersebut juga yang direncanakan PLN untuk pengembangan hingga 2034, selain nuklir. Mengingat kompleksitas pengembangan PLTA dari sisi infrastruktur dan sosial, pada kesempatan ini disampaikan peluang investasi pengembangan PLTS berdasarkan rencana usaha PLN (RUPTL) 2025-2029 skenario “Accelerated Renewable Energy Development (ARED)”, terutama peluang untuk swasta melalui skema Independent Power Producer (IPP) untuk tahun 2026-2029 (tahun 2025 tidak dihitung karena sudah dalam tahap konstruksi—dan fokus hingga tahun 2029 karena lebih pasti mengingat masih di masa pemerintahaan saat ini). Total kapasitas PLTS yang akan dikembangkan di Kaltim 2026-2029 sebesar 755 MW. Walaupun direncanakan 255 MW akan dibangun di Kaltim dan 500 MW di Kalteng dan Kaltara, RUPTL menyebutkan seluruhnya bisa dibangun di provinsi mana saja sepanjang masih dalam satu sistem jaringan Kalseltengtimra yang mencakup Provinsi Kalsel, Kalteng, Kaltim, dan Kaltara. Itu artinya, jika Kaltim menjadi daerah atraktif untuk investasi PLTS, seluruh 755 MW berpotensi dapat dibangun di Kaltim. Berdasarkan informasi terakhir dari PLN, lokasi pengembangan 255 MW di Kaltim belum ditetapkan, mungkin hal yang sama juga untuk yang 500 MW. Dari sisi kelayakan ekonomi, tarif (harga beli) PLN dari IPP lebih tinggi dari levelized cost of electricity (LCOE/biaya pokok produksi) berdasarkan literatur. Ini memperlihatkan peluang keekonomian usaha. Referensi: 1. Levelized cost LCOE in IKN is 5.6 cent GBP/kwH (p.92) 9.07 cent USD = 7,4 cent GBP (p.92)  1 GBP =1.226 USD LCOE= 6.9 cent USD source: https://ije-pyc.org/IJE/article/view/269 2. Feed in tariff: Perpres 112/2022 (include location factor)
  • #13 Salah satu tantangan paling sulit dalam pengembangan PLTS adalah penyediaan lahan. Dengan transformasi ekonomi hijau sebagaimana disebutkan sebelumnya, Kaltim ingin menghindari pengembangan PLTS dengan cara mengkonversi hutan alam, dan ingin memastikan keberterimaan sosial terutama dari masyarakat lokal. Salah satu cara mengatasi tantangan tersebut adalah menggunakan lahan bekas tambang batu bara, dimana Kaltim memiliki 125 ribu ha lahan pertambangan di luar kawasan hutan negara pada tahun 2022 (Peta tutupan hutan KLHK). Reklamasi dan pasca tambang di luar kawasan hutan negara dapat dirancang sesuai prioritas tata ruang daerah, termasuk untuk pengembangan EBT. Pengembangan 775 MW PLTS “hanya” memerlukan sekitar 1800 ha, tidak sampai 2% dari lahan tambang di luar kawasan hutan negara. Selain menghindari deforestasi dan konflik sosial, manfaat lain dari penggunaan lahan bekas tambang untuk PLTS adalah membantu memastikan kewajiban reklamasi dan pasca tambang dipenuhi oleh perusahaan tambang, memungkinkan transisi pekerjaan dari tambang ke PLTS bagi sebagian pekerja dan masyarakat lokal, dan memudahkan proses akuisisi lahan bagi pengembang PLTS karena hanya perlu berhubungan dengan satu entitas pemilik lahan. Walaupun manfaatnya banyak, penggunaan lahan bekas tambang untuk PLTS memiliki sejumlah tantangan, termasuk perlunya (a) sinkronisasi rencana pasca tambang, rencana pengembangan pembangkit PLN, dan rencana tata ruang daerah, (b) perubahan rencana pasca tambang sejumlah perusahaan tambang yang sebagian lahannya berpotensi untuk PLTS, dan (c) kejelasan tentang penyerahan lahan pasca tambang. Walaupun tantangannya cukup tinggi, pendekatan ini telah dan sedang dijalankan di banyak negara, terutama di China sebagaimana grafik. Selain di China, di Jerman juga sudah ada PLTS 170 MW yang dibangun di lahan bekas tambang lignit yang saat ini telah beroperasi.
  • #17 Kaltim ingin menjadi daerah yang atraktif untuk investasi EBT, termasuk PLTS. PLTA dan Biomassa Untuk itu, Pemprov Kaltim merencanakan dukungan sebagai berikut: (a) Fasilitasi pemenuhan persaratan dasar perizinan usaha dan akuisisi lahan, (b) Fasilitasi kemitraan dengan masyarakat lokal dan penyiapan tenaga kerja terampil, (c.) Pemberian insentif (insentif akan semakin besar bila dilakukan investasinya di KEK)
  • #18 Kaltim ingin menjadi daerah yang atraktif untuk investasi EBT, termasuk PLTS. PLTA dan Biomassa Untuk itu, Pemprov Kaltim merencanakan dukungan sebagai berikut: (a) Fasilitasi pemenuhan persaratan dasar perizinan usaha dan akuisisi lahan, (b) Fasilitasi kemitraan dengan masyarakat lokal dan penyiapan tenaga kerja terampil, (c.) Pemberian insentif (insentif akan semakin besar bila dilakukan investasinya di KEK)
  • #19 Untuk mendukung efisiensi proses pengembangan pembangkit energi terbarukan, Pemprov Kaltim memfasilitasi proses terkait lahan dan perizinan. Dinas ESDM, dengan bantuan teknis GIZ, sedang memetakan lokasi-lokasi potensial untuk pengembangan PLTS dan PLTA. Proses ini akan dilanjutkan terutama untuk sinkronisasi dengan PLN terkait RUPTL dan Ditjen Minerba untuk rencana pasca tambang. Untuk mendapatkan izin usaha pembangkitan listrik dari pemerintah pusat, pengembang memerlukan persyaratan dasar dari daerah: Kesesuaian Kegiatan Pemanfaatan Rung (KKPR), Persetujuan Lingkungan (PL), dan persetujuan bangunan Gedung (PBG). Pengurusan persyaratan dasar ini akan lebih cepat dan dapat sinkron dengan standar sosial dan lingkungan internasional jika lokasi pengembangan telah memiliki rencana detail tata ruang yang mendukung. Kesesuaian dengan standar sosial dan lingkungan internasional (misalnya bank dunia) akan memudahkan prusahaan pengembang (IPP) mengakses green financing yang terjangkau. Pemprov dapat memberikan bantuan teknis ke pemerintah kabupaten/kota dalam penyusunan RDTR.
  • #20 Banyak investasi PLTS sekala besar menghadapi konflik sosial pada tahap awal pengembangan. Pemprov Kaltim, melalui Dinas ESDM, merencanakan dukungan berupa fasilitasi proses “Free and Prior Informed Consent (FPIC)” untuk mendapatkan persetujuan secara genuin dari masyarakat lokal termasuk masyarakat adat. Sudah ada Perda Nomor 1 Tahun 2015 tentang Pedoman Pengakuan dan Perlindungan Masyarakat Hukum Adat. Sebagian kab/kota sudah memiliki surat keputusan panitia pengakuan masyarakat hukum adat (PPMHA), yang menjadi syarat untuk pengakuan resmi. Selain proses FPIC, kami juga dapat memfasilitasi partisipasi masyarakat dalam usaha energi terbarukan, misalnya (a) kemungkinan masyarakat desa mendapatkan sebagian lahan pasca tambang, dimana lahan tersebut dapat dijadikan sebagai penyertaan modal sehingga masyarakat menjadi bagian dari pemilik usaha PLTS, (b) dalam kasus PLTA (air), Dinas Kehutanan dapat memperkuat kapasitas masyarakat lokal untuk melakukan rehabilitasi dan perlindungan daerah aliran sungai di sekitar pembangkit, (c.) Dinas ESDM atau Dinas Kehutanan dapat memfasilitasi masyarakat lokal mengembangkan tanaman biomas di lahan kritis, dimana biomas dapat digunakan sebagai bahan bahan bakar co-firing PLTU untuk memeuhi target PLN. Pemprov juga dapat mendukung program pengembangan kompetensi, termasuk kerja sama dengan Badan Pelatihan Vokasi dan Produktivitias (BPVP) Samarinda, untuk masyarakat lokal dan pekerja tambang agar dapat bekerja di usaha energi terbarukan. (Seluruh kegiatan yang disebutkan di atas pernah dibahas dengan OPD terkait, dan Bappeda telah mengeluarkan surat sebagai usulan kepada OPD untuk diintegrasikan ke Renstra OPD masing-masing)
  • #21 Terkait insentif, Pemprov Kaltim mempertimbangkan pemberian insentif pajak daerah, misalnya pengurangan pajak air permukaan untuk pelaku usaha PLTS. Konsumsi air diperlukan untuk pembersihan panel surya. Dukungan lain misalnya melalui kerja sama dengan pemerintah kabupaten kota menyediakan infrastruktur dasar yang diperlukan seperti akses jalan dan akses pada layanan air bersih.
  • #39 RUPTL: Electricity Supply Business Plan by PLN PLN: State-own enterprise for electricity
  • #63 https://www.argusmedia.com/en/news-and-insights/latest-market-news/2551233-indonesia-s-kpc-aims-for-steady-2024-26-coal-output https://ima-api.org/bumi-resources-bumi-ajukan-revisi-rkab-batu-bara-kaltim-prima-coal/ https://www.kompas.id/artikel/en-dilema-hilirisasi-tambang-di-tengah-transisi-energi https://esgnews.com/global-renewable-power-surpasses-coal-for-the-first-time/ https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2025/jun/18/turning-coalmines-into-solar-energy-plants-renewables-gem-report
  • #64 https://www.argusmedia.com/en/news-and-insights/latest-market-news/2551233-indonesia-s-kpc-aims-for-steady-2024-26-coal-output https://ima-api.org/bumi-resources-bumi-ajukan-revisi-rkab-batu-bara-kaltim-prima-coal/ https://www.kompas.id/artikel/en-dilema-hilirisasi-tambang-di-tengah-transisi-energi https://esgnews.com/global-renewable-power-surpasses-coal-for-the-first-time/ https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2025/jun/18/turning-coalmines-into-solar-energy-plants-renewables-gem-report
  • #81 International: Paris Agreement 2015, with the goal of limiting the global warming to 1.5°C as compared to pre-industrial levels. Domestic: EGD, with climate neutrality by 2050 as a binding legal obligation
  • #82 How
  • #143 The expansion of renewable energy is a critical component of the global effort to mitigate climate change and enhance energy security. While the macro-level benefits of this transition are widely acknowledged, the localized impacts—both positive and negative—are borne by the specific communities that face a phase out of fossil fuel infrastructure and will host (large-scale) projects such as wind farms and solar arrays. For an energy transition to be both effective and equitable, it must move beyond a simple reliance on a "social license to operate" which often implies passive community acceptance, towards a more proactive and mutually beneficial "shared value" model. While the broad, indirect benefits of renewable energy projects, such as increased tax revenue, job creation, energy independence, air quality or modernization of energy infrastructure are frequently cited, they do not automatically translate into direct, equitable value for the local population. This suggests that without a deliberate, external framework, the positive externalities of a project can be widely dispersed, while its negative impacts, such as visual and noise disturbances, are concentrated on a smaller group of residents. This issue of distributive justice is a central challenge, as it can lead to community opposition and distrust. The development of formal benefit-sharing schemes is not merely an optional add-on but a necessary mechanism to correct for a market and policy failure that can concentrate the burdens of infrastructure on certain communities while dispersing the benefits to a much wider, often national, audience. By establishing formal mechanisms for benefit sharing, RE projects can bridge the gap between its broad societal value and its specific local impact, fostering a more just and sustainable energy transition.
  • #144  in many coal mining countries, taxes and non-tax revenues are an important share of state income https://indonesiabusinesspost.com/4895/markets-and-finance/energy-sector-contributes-rp400-t-falling-commodity-prices-drag-down-revenues-esdm-ministry?utm_source=chatgpt.com 2025 100 trillion IDR of state income according to ESDM which is 5.2 billion Euro
  • #145  in many coal mining countries, taxes and non-tax revenues are an important share of state income https://indonesiabusinesspost.com/4895/markets-and-finance/energy-sector-contributes-rp400-t-falling-commodity-prices-drag-down-revenues-esdm-ministry?utm_source=chatgpt.com 2025 100 trillion IDR of state income according to ESDM which is 5.2 billion Euro
  • #146 Indonesia's energy transition faces a significant challenge in ensuring an equitable and inclusive shift away from fossil fuels. While the nation aims to accelerate the deployment of renewable energy (RE), its profound economic dependence on the coal sector, particularly in key provinces, poses critical risks to affected communities: see slide. As we know, Just Transition, as a guiding principle, extends beyond a simple technological shift from coal to renewable sources. It is fundamentally an effort to address the fair and equitable distribution of the risks, burdens, and opportunities associated with this massive transformation - the phase out of coal and the expansion of RE. For a Just Transition it is thus crucial to expand RE in a just way: in terms of distributive justice, which ensures the equitable sharing of benefits and burdens (focus of this work); recognition justice, which dictates that historical inequities be addressed in planning solutions; and restorative justice, where stakeholders jointly develop solutions to redress past injustices and prevent future ones.
  • #147 When we look at Global RE deployment, we see an increasing body of mechanisms which enable local stakeholders to get their share of economic benefits. We categorised these mechanisms in the categories: tax and fiscal measures, local ownership models and Community Benefit Schemes. Each approach influences local cash flows, project economics and public acceptance in different ways. Below we review these models and the evidence on their economic and social effects, drawing on recent studies and international case examples.
  • #148 Tax and fiscal mechanisms use the tax and fiscal system to stimulate investment and participation in renewable energy (RE) by mandatory payments. They aim to ensure that local communities share the economic benefits of clean energy development or reduce project costs and attract investors. Types of Tax Schemes That Can Support Communities Tax and Royalty Arrangements These mechanisms ensure that a portion of the financial benefits generated by renewable energy projects flows back to local governments and communities hosting the projects. Generally, a percentage of corporate income tax or VAT collected from a RE utility is transferred to the district government, which uses the funds for e.g. schools, roads, and healthcare services. These mechanisms provide predictable, long-term income streams for host regions, reduce local opposition to projects, and help ensure communities share in the economic value created by renewable energy. Such levies directly boost local budgets (for infrastructure, services, etc.) and have been shown to improve acceptance by giving communities a tangible stake. For instance, a social-accounting study of a Shetland wind farm found that paying 50% of profits into local ownership (vs. no local share) multiplied retained income by five times and raised regional GDP by +30.9% vs. +3.0% . However, mandated tax-sharing requires strong legal and administrative frameworks. Funds must be managed transparently to avoid misuse. Best-practice guidelines emphasize community governance and clear reporting/auditing to minimize corruption risk . When payments are seen as voluntary “gifts” rather than statutory rights, they can even fuel cynicism (viewed as “bribes”). One UK study found that framing payments as a policy requirement (rather than a developer favor) significantly increased local support. They include: Revenue-Sharing from Taxes Corporate income tax paid by RE developers Value-added tax (VAT) on equipment, construction, or energy sales Environmental levies related to energy generation Royalties from Developers Developers pay royalties directly to national, provincial, or local authorities based on energy production or sales value in order to compensate for local resource use, land occupation, and environmental impact. Tax Credit and Incentive Schemes A broad category of fiscal tools that reduce the tax burden on RE investors, producers, and communities. These tools can make RE projects more financially viable, support community ownership, and encourage reinvestment of fiscal savings into local development. However, they do not provide direct income to communities. These tools can include: Investment or Production Tax Credits (ITCs/PBCs): credits for initial investment or for each unit of RE generated. Tax Holidays and Deductions: temporary reductions in corporate or income taxes for RE developers. Land and Property Tax Adjustments: reduced or exempted property taxes for RE project sites. Community Energy Incentives: tax reductions for individuals, cooperatives, or local enterprises investing in RE.
  • #150 Community benefit schemes are the most common benefit-sharing models, where a private developer initiates and oversees programs. Usually, project developers and the communities agree on services from the developer towards the community. This may include direct financial contributions to the community, infrastructural improvements, employment & training or environmental mitigation. A widely used mechanism, particularly in the UK and Scotland, is the community fund. Developers contribute a lump sum or annual per-megawatt payment to a fund that is then managed by a local organization with community representation. Another form of direct financial benefit comes from land lease payments, royalties, or payments for power line easements - a crucial distinction here is that these benefits are typically concentrated on a small group of landowners who host the project and do not benefit the community as a whole in contrast to the community funds.. These initiatives are often a direct response to community pressure or are implemented as a strategic measure to de-risk a project and secure a social license to operate. In the United States, several models have emerged. A Community Benefits Agreement (CBA) is a legally binding, enforceable contract between a project developer and a community group or municipality. These agreements are designed to ensure the delivery of specific, measurable benefits that can include funds for affordable housing, infrastructure, or other community priorities. The enforcement mechanisms outlined in a CBA provide the community with a means to hold the developer accountable, and in some cases, to halt construction if commitments are not met. In Europe, voluntary contribution schemes are a prominent model. These are initiatives where developers voluntarily provide financial packages, often in the form of funds, to support communities. In Germany, a voluntary payment scheme allows developers to contribute €0.2 cents per kilowatt-hour of electricity generated to municipalities - which practically set an industry standard. This provides a direct financial link between the project's operation and local government revenue, a factor that has motivated some municipalities, like Simmerath, to actively support the development of more wind energy projects. The implementation of community benefit schemes is not without its challenges. The primary barriers include a lack of trust and transparency, limited community capacity to negotiate with developers, and a general lack of awareness about the availability of these schemes. To address these barriers, best practices for implementation have emerged. To overcome the trust deficit, schemes should prioritize early, transparent, and consistent engagement, moving beyond a transactional approach to a more genuine, collaborative process. To address the power imbalance stemming from limited community capacity, developers and funders should provide resources for communities to hire independent technical and legal experts to help them successfully negotiate and draft agreements. Most critically, agreements must include clear, detailed terms with specific and quantifiable goals, as well as robust enforcement mechanisms to ensure accountability. The process should be transparent and allow for public oversight to rebuild trust and ensure the benefits are delivered as promised.
  • #151 In the United States, a Community Benefits Agreement (CBA) is a legally binding, enforceable contract between a project developer and a community group or municipality. These agreements are designed to ensure the delivery of specific, measurable benefits that can include funds for affordable housing, infrastructure, or other community priorities. CBAs have a long history in the United States, helping to secure tangible benefits for local communities from proposed development projects while safeguarding against potential burdens. CBAs can help increase public acceptance of clean energy projects, increase a project’s chance of gaining permitting approval, cultivate trust between project developers and communities, and generate benefits for host communities. The enforcement mechanisms outlined in a CBA provide the community with a means to hold the developer accountable, and in some cases, to halt construction if commitments are not met. CBAs are gaining further traction, with some U.S. states and federal agencies, like the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, incentivizing their use through bidding credits or expedited permitting pathways.
  • #152 In Germany, a voluntary payment scheme allows developers to contribute €0.2 cents per kilowatt-hour of electricity generated to municipalities. This provides a direct financial link between the project's operation and local government revenue, a factor that has motivated some municipalities, like Simmerath, to actively support the development of more wind energy projects. The evolution of these "voluntary" schemes from simple initiatives to formalized "principles" or legal provisions represents a significant policy shift. Governments have recognized that a purely unsystematic approach to benefit sharing can be dangerous and lead to inconsistent outcomes. By establishing a recommended value (£5,000/MW) or a specific rate (€0.2 cents/kWh), they create a de-facto industry standard. This institutionalizes the practice and provides a predictable framework for both developers and communities, which can reduce friction and accelerate the deployment of projects. This subtle but impactful policy intervention standardizes what constitutes a fair contribution, thereby increasing community acceptance and moving the conversation from whether benefits should exist to how they should be delivered.
  • #153 Germany's "Bürgerenergie" (citizen energy) movement provides a case study for local ownership models. With over 1,700 energy communities, many organized as cooperatives, the movement demonstrates the power of local ownership. These cooperatives, with over 95% of their members being private individuals, are primarily engaged in solar and wind energy production. A key finding from research in Germany and elsewhere highlights the financial superiority of this model. Studies indicate that locally financed and controlled projects can deliver a return to the local economy that is between 2 and 8 times greater than that of private developer-led projects. A study on a 21 megawatt community-owned wind park in Germany found that it generated $71 million in regional income over 20 years, while a commercially-owned park of the same size generated only $8.6 million for the local economy. This is due to a powerful multiplier effect. Community ownership transforms the host community from a passive recipient of a one-off payment into an active investor who receives a continuous revenue stream. This revenue remains within the local economy, creating a durable and significant positive economic impact that far surpasses the value of traditional benefit funds. Importantly, local ownership also increases acceptance. Recent surveys show that wind/solar schemes owned or part-owned by community cooperatives enjoy significantly higher support than purely corporate-owned projects . Hogan (2024) finds community- or shared-ownership projects fostered greater acceptance because locals feel fairly involved and fairly rewarded. Brouwer et al. (2025) similarly report that Dutch cooperative-led wind farms had shorter planning times and faced far fewer public objections than conventional projects . These effects arise because local investors have a voice (procedural justice) and receive economic benefits (distributional justice), which together neutralize many opposition arguments. We can distinguish between three types of local ownership schemes. First, community ownership, e.g. by cooperatives, where local actors form a company or cooperative owning and operating the project. Second, public ownership, meaning that a public company owns and operates the project (e.g. in Germany Stadtwerke), which implies that profits benefit the budgets of local administrations directly. Third, shared ownership arrangements in which local private persons or administrations own shares of the project.
  • #154 The case of Muara Enggelam demonstrates how a village-owned enterprise can effectively manage and operate a solar photovoltaic (PV) grid to support livelihoods in its community. With low dependence on government funds for its operation, this case illustrates how community consensus can enhance mini-grid management. Muara Enggelam is a remote floating village of 192 households on the Melintang Lake, which faces difficulties in accessing the national grid. The village previously used a gasoline diesel generator to electrify houses and public facilities. In 2016, the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (MEMR) awarded Muara Enggelam a Special Allocation Fund of IDR3.9 billion ($250,000) to construct a 35 kilowatt-peak (kWp) communal solar grid and train local technicians to operate it. By 2020, the village-owned enterprise had developed the capacity to repair any damaged solar panels and increased the capacity to 45 kWp. This project was part of a collaboration between the provincial government and Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit, which provided technical assistance on entrepreneurship and community empowerment. Access to electricity from the solar grid enabled the pre-existing village-owned enterprise to venture into swallow’s nest farming. It also powered computers and other devices in public facilities including the school and health clinic. Households are also able to power televisions, cooking appliances, and lighting. The success of Muara Enggelam demonstrates how the communal solar grid has enabled local enterprises. The revenues are also used to cross-subsidize operational and maintenance costs without additional fund needed from the village budget. The whole community is now paying considerably lower electricity price at IDR50,000 ($3) compared to the previously costlier diesel at IDR80,000 ($5) per month. Both the village-owned enterprise and village government play important roles in ensuring financial sustainability. They employ clear rules on electricity payment, including subsidies for low-income households, and sanctions for electricity theft and non-paying customers. The village government also discloses the financial performance of the village-owned enterprise, including collected amounts of electricity bills at monthly community meetings.
  • #156 The 2008 Renewable Energy Act was a cornerstone of Denmark’s effort to expand wind power while maintaining public support. Its co-ownership clause required developers to offer 20% of project shares to local residents, giving nearby citizens the opportunity to invest and benefit financially. The underlying goal was to strengthen local acceptance and trust by ensuring communities had a tangible stake in the renewable transition. This model leverages the financial and technical expertise of a private developer while integrating the local engagement and trust-building that come with community participation. It offers a viable path for communities that may lack the financial capacity to take on full ownership but still desire a more substantial and meaningful role than that of a passive beneficiary. However, the scheme faced practical challenges. Many residents lacked the capital or interest to invest, and developers found the process administratively burdensome. Participation rates remained low, and some critics argued that the benefits were unevenly distributed—favoring wealthier locals rather than the broader community. Ultimately, Denmark abandoned the 20% ownership requirement, replacing it with individual compensatory measures such as payments for visual or noise impacts. This shift reflected a move from collective ownership ideals toward simpler, more direct mechanisms for maintaining community support for wind energy.
  • #158 The idea of this slide is to clarify some points before we finalise this work. Key questions currently are about analysing the instruments: which criteria seem most important to the actors in Indonesia? Second Question: there are studies about examples of Community based RE projects in Indonesia. Are people interested in those or more in experience from other countries? Third question: which is the preferred format: regular paper or extended presentation? Each of those questions can be discussed before, not sure we want to ask them all. Just a suggestions to use the situation in which we present work in progress.
  • #182 Peraturan Presiden Nomor 112 Tahun 2022
  • #206 Alkcance proceso d coal phase out Progreso descarbonizacion en ambas regiones(Mejillones esta retirando mucho en los proximos años e impactara el ecosistema) We don’t start from scratch in both regions Creditos a ENEL
  • #209 First approach is at least in Chile mostly covered by other entities, this is specially true for new entrepeneurs However those capacities do not necesarely translate into linking them with large companies so we aimed for a different approach. Approach based on the SME’s capabilities required by large enterprises in the regions Many of the large companies already hvae some type of directive to increase the link with local suppliers but this has hardly happened Most of the large companies were being supplied of services and products from other regions.
  • #210 * Here is the selection of the SME considering its past experience, formality, potential for developemnt and
  • #212 While the outlined methodology was the same for both regions the implementation contrasts The resulting attendance to the worsjop is of15 if them (2/3 of them) Time consuming and lesssense of belonging