Mobile and social innovation: 
Governance, human empowerment ! 
and the role of ICTs for development! 
! 
! 
! 
! 
! 
Ruhiya Kristine Seward, Ph.D.! 
Research analyst/Consultant ! 
e-governance & A2i ! 
DGG/BDP ! 
UNDP! 
! 
! 
Bahrain International eGovernment Forum April 2013!
Contents! 
• The world and human development 
# 
• ICT evolution in development# 
# 
• Second ICT ‘revolution’: mobile technologies # 
• Examples of innovation# 
• Challenges # 
• Way forward...# 
#
ICT and the world! 
• Democratization of access to ICTs over the past 20 years 
propelled by new technologies # 
• Mobile technologies# 
• Social networks # 
• Diminishing barriers to entry 
# 
• And propelling social innovation… 
# 
• Billions of people access to a digital communications 
device for the first time in history#
The world: Human Development Index (HDI)! 
• Global ‘rebalancing’ – even during a global recession 
developing countries are growing# 
# 
# 
# 
• Every region has seen notable improvements in ranking in 
all Human Development Index HDI components#
The world! 
• National HDI averages hide the stark disparities remaining 
within and between countries # 
• Income inequality rising# 
# 
• Elites are gaining most 
from rising wealth # 
# 
• Social mobilization and 
new social movements# 
# 
• Rapid growth of mobile 
Photo by: Emad Karim 
technologies and social network use# 
#
Evolution of ICTs & human development! 
# 
• ICT deployments used to be about infrastructure and connectivity # 
• “Digital divide” 
# 
• Now ICTs used by public & private sector to improve… # 
• Efficiency# 
• Effectiveness# 
• Transparency# 
• Service delivery# 
• Participation 
# 
• ICTs as tool for efficiency => reduce costs, easier to scale# 
## 
l ICTs as tool of transformation => ICTs transform processes and create new 
ways to achieve goals… # 
l Qualitative changes# 
l Networking and networks 
l New ways of doing things!#
ICT penetration by status of development!
Growth in mobile subscriptions!
ICT access in Sub-Saharan Africa! 
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Millions 
Source: UNDP 2011 and ITU 2011 
450 
400 
350 
300 
250 
200 
150 
100 
50 
0 
Mobile cellular telephone 
subscriptions 
Fixed telephone lines 
Fixed (wired) Internet 
subscriptions
Global mobile subscriptions!
Mobile subscriptions by country categories!
Evolution of ICTs! 
Mobile technologies! 
# 
Six billion users*# 
85.5% global penetration# 
Closed-proprietary# 
Cost-based# 
Low-speed# 
Few applications# 
Low barriers to entry 
*ITU 2011 
Internet ! 
! 
2.5 billion users*# 
32.5% global penetration# 
Open/non-proprietary# 
Mostly free?# 
High speed/broadband# 
Many applications# 
High barriers to entry
Global & UNDP region ICT stats! 
UNDP Regions! Internet users 
penetration! 
Mobile phone 
subscriptions 
penetration! 
Fixed phone 
subscriptions 
penetration! 
Fixed 
broadband 
subscriptions 
penetration! 
African states! 12.3%# 53.2%# 1.4%# 0.2%# 
Asia Pacific! 22.3%# 74.8%# 11.5%# 5.0%# 
Arab States! 29.1%# 93.3%# 9.4%# 2.1%# 
Europe/CIS! 42.3%# 131.3%# 25.3%# 10.2%# 
Latin America! 38.6%# 106.9%# 18.1%# 7.3%# 
UNDP Global! 24.3%# 80.1%# 11.6%# 4.8%# 
Global! 32.5%# 85.5%# 17.3%# 8.5%# 
Source: ITU 2012 and UNDP calculations#
Why the mobile revolution?! 
# 
• Lower costs (devices and access)# 
# 
• Broader network coverage# 
# 
• User interface (voice plus simple text)# 
# 
• Usability and portability# 
# 
• Appropriation (personal device)# 
# 
• Social status#
Socioeconomic impact of mobiles! 
# 
• Link to GDP growth# 
# 
• Increase of tax revenues# 
# 
• New jobs in sector 
and outside# 
# 
• Infrastructure leap-frogging# 
# 
• Enhance public service delivery# 
# 
• Reduce information asymmetries# 
# 
Photo: Stephanie Ludwig# 
Charging kiosk in Kenya#
Socioeconomic impact of mobiles! 
• Reduce cost/travel expenditures for small and 
microenterprises (including small farmers)# 
! 
• Facilitates greater access to information and fosters 
communication (literally trillions of SMS are sent every 
year)# 
# 
• Provide access to poor people – over 90 million people 
have a mobile but have no access to electricity!#
Reaching the poor! 
• Complex cost/benefit analysis for critical development 
problems as mobile services can be costly in poor 
countries. # 
• Coverage in remote or marginalized areas is lacking.# 
• Mobiles cannot fix larger infrastructure issues – 
transportation of goods, access to new/other markets. 
# 
• Cannot de-localize trade or completely remove the role 
of ‘middlemen’ in markets. 
# 
• Need for human-to-human interaction for trust to build. 
# 
• Mobile applications must be linked to poor people’s 
realities on the ground.#
Global & UNDP region ICT costs! 
! 
UNDP Regions! Fixed phone 
price basket % of 
GNI! 
Mobile phone 
price basket % of 
GNI! 
Fixed broadband 
price basket % of 
GNI! 
African states! 7.11%# 9.49%# 57.53%# 
Asia Pacific! 3.78%# 4.26%# 24.65%# 
Arab States! 0.78%# 1.85%# 5.05%# 
Europe/CIS! 1.31%# 2.37%# 6.44%# 
Latin American states! 2.01%# 3.60%# 14.59%# 
UNDP Global! 1.97%# 3.20%# 13.4%# 
Global! 1.23%# 1.84%# 6.16%# 
Non-UNDP global! 0.70%# 0.86%# 0.96%# 
Source: ITU 2012 and UNDP calculations#
Crowdsourcing with Ushahidi (global)!
Fighting corruption with ‘I Paid a Bribe!’ (India)!
Mobile banking with M-Pesa (Kenya)! 
Photo by: Stephanie Ludwig
Digital data collection for disarmament and 
demobilization (Central African Republic)! 
Photo by: Tino Kreutzer/UNDP
Lessons learned 
• Start small and scale up gradually 
# 
• Build flexible tools using open source software 
# 
• Participation, participation, participation 
# 
• Simple, usable, affordable 
# 
• Consider numeracy and literacy issues#
Lessons learned 
• Support local service providers and build local 
technical capacity 
# 
• Infrastructure and technological limitations 
# 
• Build partnerships 
# 
• Good communication and outreach plans#
Challenges in reaching the poor! 
• Basic ICT infrastructure 
# 
• Skills and acceptance levels 
# 
• Uneven ICT/mobile network penetration rates 
between urban population centers and rural areas 
# 
• Policy and regulation 
# 
• Costs of mobile services in developing countries 
# 
• Adequate project management#
Way forward...! 
# 
• Empowering people# 
# 
• Offering new ways 
of connecting with 
governments# 
# 
• Giving voice to those # 
#who had none before#
Way forward… 
• Innovation is coming from the South!# 
• Emerging economies playing a larger role in global 
economy... # 
• ...and are in fact investing in other developing countries 
# 
• Lower barriers to entry (access & technology) 
# 
• New knowledge (and know-how) and innovation being 
created that is more useful for poorer countries# 
• Local social innovators/entrepreneurs# 
# 
• Increasing importance of South-South cooperation# 
• ICTs are catalysts
Mobile Technologies and 
Empowerment: Enhancing human 
development through participation 
and innovation# 
# 
# 
http://www.undpegov.org/sites/undpegov.org/files/ 
undp_mobile_technology_primer.pdf# 
# 
# 
http://undpegov.org#
Thank you! 
ruhiya.seward@undp.org# 
# 
http://undpegov.org# 
# 
ruhiyakris@gmail.com # 
#

Mobile and social innovation governance, human empowerment and the role of ic ts for development

  • 1.
    Mobile and socialinnovation: Governance, human empowerment ! and the role of ICTs for development! ! ! ! ! ! Ruhiya Kristine Seward, Ph.D.! Research analyst/Consultant ! e-governance & A2i ! DGG/BDP ! UNDP! ! ! Bahrain International eGovernment Forum April 2013!
  • 2.
    Contents! • Theworld and human development # • ICT evolution in development# # • Second ICT ‘revolution’: mobile technologies # • Examples of innovation# • Challenges # • Way forward...# #
  • 3.
    ICT and theworld! • Democratization of access to ICTs over the past 20 years propelled by new technologies # • Mobile technologies# • Social networks # • Diminishing barriers to entry # • And propelling social innovation… # • Billions of people access to a digital communications device for the first time in history#
  • 4.
    The world: HumanDevelopment Index (HDI)! • Global ‘rebalancing’ – even during a global recession developing countries are growing# # # # • Every region has seen notable improvements in ranking in all Human Development Index HDI components#
  • 5.
    The world! •National HDI averages hide the stark disparities remaining within and between countries # • Income inequality rising# # • Elites are gaining most from rising wealth # # • Social mobilization and new social movements# # • Rapid growth of mobile Photo by: Emad Karim technologies and social network use# #
  • 6.
    Evolution of ICTs& human development! # • ICT deployments used to be about infrastructure and connectivity # • “Digital divide” # • Now ICTs used by public & private sector to improve… # • Efficiency# • Effectiveness# • Transparency# • Service delivery# • Participation # • ICTs as tool for efficiency => reduce costs, easier to scale# ## l ICTs as tool of transformation => ICTs transform processes and create new ways to achieve goals… # l Qualitative changes# l Networking and networks l New ways of doing things!#
  • 7.
    ICT penetration bystatus of development!
  • 8.
    Growth in mobilesubscriptions!
  • 9.
    ICT access inSub-Saharan Africa! 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Millions Source: UNDP 2011 and ITU 2011 450 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 Mobile cellular telephone subscriptions Fixed telephone lines Fixed (wired) Internet subscriptions
  • 10.
  • 11.
    Mobile subscriptions bycountry categories!
  • 12.
    Evolution of ICTs! Mobile technologies! # Six billion users*# 85.5% global penetration# Closed-proprietary# Cost-based# Low-speed# Few applications# Low barriers to entry *ITU 2011 Internet ! ! 2.5 billion users*# 32.5% global penetration# Open/non-proprietary# Mostly free?# High speed/broadband# Many applications# High barriers to entry
  • 13.
    Global & UNDPregion ICT stats! UNDP Regions! Internet users penetration! Mobile phone subscriptions penetration! Fixed phone subscriptions penetration! Fixed broadband subscriptions penetration! African states! 12.3%# 53.2%# 1.4%# 0.2%# Asia Pacific! 22.3%# 74.8%# 11.5%# 5.0%# Arab States! 29.1%# 93.3%# 9.4%# 2.1%# Europe/CIS! 42.3%# 131.3%# 25.3%# 10.2%# Latin America! 38.6%# 106.9%# 18.1%# 7.3%# UNDP Global! 24.3%# 80.1%# 11.6%# 4.8%# Global! 32.5%# 85.5%# 17.3%# 8.5%# Source: ITU 2012 and UNDP calculations#
  • 14.
    Why the mobilerevolution?! # • Lower costs (devices and access)# # • Broader network coverage# # • User interface (voice plus simple text)# # • Usability and portability# # • Appropriation (personal device)# # • Social status#
  • 15.
    Socioeconomic impact ofmobiles! # • Link to GDP growth# # • Increase of tax revenues# # • New jobs in sector and outside# # • Infrastructure leap-frogging# # • Enhance public service delivery# # • Reduce information asymmetries# # Photo: Stephanie Ludwig# Charging kiosk in Kenya#
  • 16.
    Socioeconomic impact ofmobiles! • Reduce cost/travel expenditures for small and microenterprises (including small farmers)# ! • Facilitates greater access to information and fosters communication (literally trillions of SMS are sent every year)# # • Provide access to poor people – over 90 million people have a mobile but have no access to electricity!#
  • 17.
    Reaching the poor! • Complex cost/benefit analysis for critical development problems as mobile services can be costly in poor countries. # • Coverage in remote or marginalized areas is lacking.# • Mobiles cannot fix larger infrastructure issues – transportation of goods, access to new/other markets. # • Cannot de-localize trade or completely remove the role of ‘middlemen’ in markets. # • Need for human-to-human interaction for trust to build. # • Mobile applications must be linked to poor people’s realities on the ground.#
  • 18.
    Global & UNDPregion ICT costs! ! UNDP Regions! Fixed phone price basket % of GNI! Mobile phone price basket % of GNI! Fixed broadband price basket % of GNI! African states! 7.11%# 9.49%# 57.53%# Asia Pacific! 3.78%# 4.26%# 24.65%# Arab States! 0.78%# 1.85%# 5.05%# Europe/CIS! 1.31%# 2.37%# 6.44%# Latin American states! 2.01%# 3.60%# 14.59%# UNDP Global! 1.97%# 3.20%# 13.4%# Global! 1.23%# 1.84%# 6.16%# Non-UNDP global! 0.70%# 0.86%# 0.96%# Source: ITU 2012 and UNDP calculations#
  • 19.
  • 20.
    Fighting corruption with‘I Paid a Bribe!’ (India)!
  • 21.
    Mobile banking withM-Pesa (Kenya)! Photo by: Stephanie Ludwig
  • 22.
    Digital data collectionfor disarmament and demobilization (Central African Republic)! Photo by: Tino Kreutzer/UNDP
  • 23.
    Lessons learned •Start small and scale up gradually # • Build flexible tools using open source software # • Participation, participation, participation # • Simple, usable, affordable # • Consider numeracy and literacy issues#
  • 24.
    Lessons learned •Support local service providers and build local technical capacity # • Infrastructure and technological limitations # • Build partnerships # • Good communication and outreach plans#
  • 25.
    Challenges in reachingthe poor! • Basic ICT infrastructure # • Skills and acceptance levels # • Uneven ICT/mobile network penetration rates between urban population centers and rural areas # • Policy and regulation # • Costs of mobile services in developing countries # • Adequate project management#
  • 26.
    Way forward...! # • Empowering people# # • Offering new ways of connecting with governments# # • Giving voice to those # #who had none before#
  • 27.
    Way forward… •Innovation is coming from the South!# • Emerging economies playing a larger role in global economy... # • ...and are in fact investing in other developing countries # • Lower barriers to entry (access & technology) # • New knowledge (and know-how) and innovation being created that is more useful for poorer countries# • Local social innovators/entrepreneurs# # • Increasing importance of South-South cooperation# • ICTs are catalysts
  • 28.
    Mobile Technologies and Empowerment: Enhancing human development through participation and innovation# # # http://www.undpegov.org/sites/undpegov.org/files/ undp_mobile_technology_primer.pdf# # # http://undpegov.org#
  • 29.
    Thank you! [email protected]# # http://undpegov.org# # [email protected] # #