Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation
   Department on New Challenges and Threats




     Countering cybercrime




              10-th E-Crime Congress
             London, 13-14 March 2012
New general trends in the cybercrime
          market in 2011

 Targeted attacks on the financial
 sector
 Increase in online banking fraud
 incidents
 Surge in the number and complexity
 of DDoS attacks
New general trends in the cybercrime
          market in 2011

 Spread of hacktivism, attacks with
 socio-political motives
 Use of social engineering techniques
 to steal personal information and other
 online fraud
Targeted attacks on the facilities of
 critical infrastructure
Main indicators of the cybercrime
           market in 2011
 Creation of organized groups with a centralized
  management system
 Penetration of the cybercrime market by
  traditional organized crime groups, attempting to
  not only control the cashing of stolen funds, but
  the entire theft process
 Growth of the internal market. This market covers
  the so-called Cybercrime to Cybercrime (C2C)
  services, provided on a paid basis by specialized
  teams of hackers
Main indicators of the cybercrime
            market in 2011
 Strong growth this past year, reflected in the
 number of crimes and the volume of profits earned
 by the hackers
 Professionalization of cybercrime, expansion of
 provided services, and interest from traditional
 organized crime groups, leading to an increase in
 damages from hacker activities
 No clearly defined global geographical centers with
 a high concentration of cybercriminals, they can
 carry out their attacks from anywhere in the world
What are the quantitative results in
               2011?

 Preliminary estimate of the financial
 performance of the global cybercrime
 market in 2011: $12.5 billion

 Two-thirds of global cybercrime is online
 fraud and spam
What does the International
   Information Security (IIS) mean?

IIS based on the nature of the inseparable
  «triad» of threats:

 Politico-military
 Terrorist
 Criminal
What legal basis do we have today?


 Council of Europe Convention on Cybercrime
most important regional legal instrument aimed
at combating crime against computer security



 Council of Europe Convention on Cybercrime
one of the first attempts to codify the rules for
combating cybercrime, which is an especially
dangerous phenomenon owing to its scale and
 consequences for national and international
                     security
Is Convention enough to
respond effectively to the new
  dynamic challenges in the
      computer sphere?

            NO
- Convention on Cybercrime does not provide any systematic
         response to the new trends of cybercrime




- Convention on Cybercrime does not provide any systematic
      response to the new challenge of cyberterrorism



- The notions of cybercrime and cyberterrorism have not been
  codified yet, and its components, in their entirety, have not
          been criminalized at the international level



- There is no definition of terrorist intentions, without which
  criminal sanctions would hardly commensurate with the
             terrorist threat of this criminal act
- Convention on Cybercrime does not incorporate provisions
excluding fully impunity of a person, who has committed an
                         illegal act




 - Responses to the threat of cyberterrorism could not be
 found through the combined application of the Council of
   Europe conventions on Cybercrime (2001) and on the
             Prevention of Terrorism (2005)
What Sectors of Critical Infrastructure Are
Potentially Vulnerable to Cyber Attacks?

                 information, communication
energy                                              water
                      technologies, ICT


                                            public and legal
 food        health         financial
                                            order and safety

    civil                                      space and
                         transport
administration                                 research


                     chemical and nuclear
                          industry
Russian strategy to fight
            Cybercrime
• Based on the comprehensive and balanced
  approach
• Necessity to codify global cyberspace
• Start working out the universal glossary or
  terminology on the IIS issues for further
  elaboration of the UN regulatory documents in
  this area and generally recognized international
  norms and criteria for fighting cyberthreats
Russian Initiatives
• CIS Agreement on cooperation to combat information
  computer crimes was signed in 2001 (July, Minsk)
• In 2009 for the first time in international practice it was
  signed an Agreement among the Governments of the
  SCO Member States on Cooperation in the Field of
  Ensuring International Informational Security
• In 2010 the Russian Federation and Brazil signed a
  bilateral agreement on cooperation in the field of
  international    security      for     information      and
  communication
Russian Initiatives
• Initiated in 2010 within the framework of the UN
  Commission on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice
  Resolution 19/3 «Strengthening public-private partnerships
  to counter crime in all its forms and manifestations»
• Prepared the draft “Rules of conduct” in the sphere of
  international security disseminated as an official document
  of the 66-th session of the UN General Assembly
• Offered the concept of Convention on ensuring
  international security submitted at the 2nd International
  Meeting of High-Ranking Officials Responsible for
  Security Matters in Yekaterinburg (2011)
Russian Initiatives
• Strongly supports and shares the idea (reflected in the
  Declaration of the 12-th UN Congress of CPCJ) of
  drafting the universal Convention on cooperation in
  combating information/cyber crime under the aegis of
  the UN
What is the purpose of the UN
 Convention on Cybercrime?
• Promote and strengthen measures to prevent
  and combat cybercrime more efficiently and
  effectively
• Promote, facilitate and support international
  cooperation and technical assistance in the
  providing of an adequate response to all
  criminal challenges in the computer sphere
Thank you

Russia and cybercrime

  • 1.
    Ministry of ForeignAffairs of the Russian Federation Department on New Challenges and Threats Countering cybercrime 10-th E-Crime Congress London, 13-14 March 2012
  • 2.
    New general trendsin the cybercrime market in 2011  Targeted attacks on the financial sector  Increase in online banking fraud incidents  Surge in the number and complexity of DDoS attacks
  • 3.
    New general trendsin the cybercrime market in 2011  Spread of hacktivism, attacks with socio-political motives  Use of social engineering techniques to steal personal information and other online fraud Targeted attacks on the facilities of critical infrastructure
  • 4.
    Main indicators ofthe cybercrime market in 2011  Creation of organized groups with a centralized management system  Penetration of the cybercrime market by traditional organized crime groups, attempting to not only control the cashing of stolen funds, but the entire theft process  Growth of the internal market. This market covers the so-called Cybercrime to Cybercrime (C2C) services, provided on a paid basis by specialized teams of hackers
  • 5.
    Main indicators ofthe cybercrime market in 2011  Strong growth this past year, reflected in the number of crimes and the volume of profits earned by the hackers  Professionalization of cybercrime, expansion of provided services, and interest from traditional organized crime groups, leading to an increase in damages from hacker activities  No clearly defined global geographical centers with a high concentration of cybercriminals, they can carry out their attacks from anywhere in the world
  • 6.
    What are thequantitative results in 2011?  Preliminary estimate of the financial performance of the global cybercrime market in 2011: $12.5 billion  Two-thirds of global cybercrime is online fraud and spam
  • 7.
    What does theInternational Information Security (IIS) mean? IIS based on the nature of the inseparable «triad» of threats:  Politico-military  Terrorist  Criminal
  • 8.
    What legal basisdo we have today? Council of Europe Convention on Cybercrime most important regional legal instrument aimed at combating crime against computer security Council of Europe Convention on Cybercrime one of the first attempts to codify the rules for combating cybercrime, which is an especially dangerous phenomenon owing to its scale and consequences for national and international security
  • 9.
    Is Convention enoughto respond effectively to the new dynamic challenges in the computer sphere? NO
  • 10.
    - Convention onCybercrime does not provide any systematic response to the new trends of cybercrime - Convention on Cybercrime does not provide any systematic response to the new challenge of cyberterrorism - The notions of cybercrime and cyberterrorism have not been codified yet, and its components, in their entirety, have not been criminalized at the international level - There is no definition of terrorist intentions, without which criminal sanctions would hardly commensurate with the terrorist threat of this criminal act
  • 11.
    - Convention onCybercrime does not incorporate provisions excluding fully impunity of a person, who has committed an illegal act - Responses to the threat of cyberterrorism could not be found through the combined application of the Council of Europe conventions on Cybercrime (2001) and on the Prevention of Terrorism (2005)
  • 12.
    What Sectors ofCritical Infrastructure Are Potentially Vulnerable to Cyber Attacks? information, communication energy water technologies, ICT public and legal food health financial order and safety civil space and transport administration research chemical and nuclear industry
  • 13.
    Russian strategy tofight Cybercrime • Based on the comprehensive and balanced approach • Necessity to codify global cyberspace • Start working out the universal glossary or terminology on the IIS issues for further elaboration of the UN regulatory documents in this area and generally recognized international norms and criteria for fighting cyberthreats
  • 14.
    Russian Initiatives • CISAgreement on cooperation to combat information computer crimes was signed in 2001 (July, Minsk) • In 2009 for the first time in international practice it was signed an Agreement among the Governments of the SCO Member States on Cooperation in the Field of Ensuring International Informational Security • In 2010 the Russian Federation and Brazil signed a bilateral agreement on cooperation in the field of international security for information and communication
  • 15.
    Russian Initiatives • Initiatedin 2010 within the framework of the UN Commission on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice Resolution 19/3 «Strengthening public-private partnerships to counter crime in all its forms and manifestations» • Prepared the draft “Rules of conduct” in the sphere of international security disseminated as an official document of the 66-th session of the UN General Assembly • Offered the concept of Convention on ensuring international security submitted at the 2nd International Meeting of High-Ranking Officials Responsible for Security Matters in Yekaterinburg (2011)
  • 16.
    Russian Initiatives • Stronglysupports and shares the idea (reflected in the Declaration of the 12-th UN Congress of CPCJ) of drafting the universal Convention on cooperation in combating information/cyber crime under the aegis of the UN
  • 17.
    What is thepurpose of the UN Convention on Cybercrime? • Promote and strengthen measures to prevent and combat cybercrime more efficiently and effectively • Promote, facilitate and support international cooperation and technical assistance in the providing of an adequate response to all criminal challenges in the computer sphere
  • 18.