General Guidelines for Rational
use of Antibiotics
Dhaval Joshi
BACKGOUND
• Antibiotics are the most widely used
medications
• Perhaps the most irrationally used
Questions
• Is it infection?
• Is it bacterial Infection?
• If yes, take appropriate samples first
• What is likely etiologic agent?
• Which antibiotic?
• Also consider some evidence!
Case
• 5 yrs old boy
• Fever and cough for 8 days
• Admitted on day 2 of fever
• Chest X-ray: right lower zone pneumonia
• WBC count: 23,000/cumm
• Prescribed with Ceftriaxone, Amikacin
Case
• No improvement in chest x-ray, changed to
meropenam in 3 days
• Refereed on Day 3 meropenam for non
respone
Case
• Evidence of pneumococcal vaccines
• Amoxicillin
Indications for antibacterial therapy
1. Definitive therapy
2. Empirical therapy
3. Prophylactic therapy
Empirical therapy
• Empirical antibacterial therapy should be
restricted to critical cases, when time is
inadequate for identification and isolation of
the bacteria and reasonably strong doubt of
bacterial infection exists
• In such situations, drugs that cover the most
probable infective agent/s should be used
Definitive therapy
• This is for proven bacterial infections
• Attempts should be made to confirm the
bacterial infection by means of staining of
secretions/fluids/exudates, culture and
sensitivity, serological tests and other tests
• Based on the reports, a narrow spectrum, least
toxic, easy-to-administer and cheap drug should
be prescribed
Prophylactic therapy
• Antimicrobial prophylaxis is administered to
susceptible patients to prevent specific
infections that can cause definite detrimental
effect
• In all these situations, only narrow spectrum
and specific drugs are used. It should be
remembered that there is NO single prophylaxis
to 'prevent' all possible bacterial infections
What antibacterial?
• There are more than 100 antibacterials
available today, and each one has its own
spectrum of activity, adverse effect profile and
cost
• The prescriber should consider many factors
before prescribing an antibacterial agent so as
to make the treatment most effective with
least adverse effects and cost
Factors affecting Antibiotic
Prescribing
The following factors should be considered while
prescribing an antibacterial agent:
• Site of infection
• Type of infection
• Severity of infection
• Isolate and its sensitivity
• Source of infection
• Host factors
• Drug related factors
Site of infection
• As a Rule Of The Thumb, it can be
remembered that the infections above the
diaphragm are caused by Cocci and Gram
positive organisms and
• infections below the diaphragm are caused by
Bacilli and Gram negative organisms, although
there are exceptions
Infections above the diaphragm
• Respiratory tract infections- Streptococcus
pyogenes, S. pneumoniae, streptococci
• Managed with Penicillins, Cephalosporins,
Macrolides and Tetracyclines
Infections below the diaphragm
• Examples include urinary tract infection, intra-
abdominal sepsis, pelvic infections etc. and
these are caused by the organisms like E. coli,
Klebsiella, Proteus, Pseudomonas, etc.
• Quinolones, Aminoglycosides, 3rd generation
cephalosporins and Metronidazole, alone or in
combination are useful in these infections
Site of infection
• There are certain sites where the infection
tends to be difficult for treatment
• In such cases higher dose, more frequent
administration, longer duration, antibacterial
combinations and lipophilic antibacterials may
have to be used
Type of infection
• Infections can be localized or extensive; mild or
severe; superficial or deep seated; acute, sub
acute or chronic and extracellular or intracellular
• For extensive, severe, deep seated, chronic and
intracellular infections, higher and more frequent
dose, longer duration of therapy, combinations,
lipophilic drugs may have to be used
Severe infections
• (bacteremia / pyemia / sepsis syndrome /
septic shock; abscesses in lung/ brain/ liver/
pelvis/ intra-abdominal; meningitis/
endocarditis/ pneumonias/ pyelonephritis/ /
gangrene and hospital acquired infections) can
be life threatening and rapidly fatal
Severe infections
• In all such situations therefore, attempts
should be made to identify and isolate the
infecting organism from the site as well as
blood by staining culture
• In treating the severe infections, drugs should
be administered by only intravenous route to
ensure adequate blood levels
Severe infections
• Only bactericidal drugs should be used to ensure
faster clearance of the infection. If the site of
infection is known, narrow spectrum drugs
should be used
• A combination of Penicillins/3rd generation
cephalosporins, aminoglycosides and
metronidazole may be used. The dose should be
higher and more frequent. Whenever possible, a
switch to oral therapy should be made
Isolate and sensitivity
• Ideal management of any significant bacterial
infection requires culture and sensitivity study of
the specimen
• Blood culture: Febrile illness
• If the situation permits, antibacterials can be
started only after the sensitivity report is
available
Isolate and sensitivity
• Narrow spectrum, least toxic, easy to
administer and cheapest of the effective drugs
should be chosen
• If the patient is responding to the drug that
has already been started, it should not be
changed even if the in vitro report says
otherwise
Source of infection
• Community acquired infections are less likely
to be resistant whereas hospital acquired
infections are likely to be resistant and more
difficult to treat (e.g. Pseudomonas, MRSA
etc.)
Host factors
AGE
• The patient’s age is an important factor both
in trying to identify the likely etiologic agent
and in assessing the patient’s ability to
eliminate the drug(s) to be used
• In infants, chloramphenicol (can cause gray
baby syndrome) and sulfa (can cause
kernicterus) are contraindicated
AGE
• Elderly: Nephrotoxic drugs
• In the elderly, achlorhydria may affect absorption
of antibacterial agents; drug elimination is slower,
requiring dose adjustments; and ototoxicity of
aminoglycosides may be increased
• Increased absorption of penicillin G and
decreased absorption of Ketoconazole
Pregnancy
• In pregnancy, drugs with known toxicity or un-
established safety like tetracyclines,
quinolones, streptomycin, erythromycin and
Clarithromycin are contraindicated in all
trimesters
• Sulfa, nitrofurantoin and chloramphenicol are
contraindicated in the last trimester.
Pregnancy
• Drugs with limited data on safety like
aminoglycosides, azithromycin, clindamycin,
vancomycin, metronidazole, trimethoprim,
rifampicin and pyrazinamide
• Penicillins, cephalosporins, INH and ethambutol
are safe in pregnancy
• In lactating mothers sulfa, tetracyclines,
metronidazole, nitrofurantoin and quinolones are
contraindicated
Metabolic Abnormalities
• Inherited or acquired metabolic abnormalities
will influence the therapy of infectious
diseases in a variety of ways
• Slow acetylators
• G6PD deficiency
Organ Dysfunction
• In patients with renal failure,
tetracyclines are absolutely
contraindicated
• Aminoglycosides, cephalosporins,
fluroquinolones and sulfa are relatively
contraindicated; and
Organ Dysfunction
• Penicillins, Macrolides, vancomycin,
metronidazole, INH, ethambutol and
rifampicin are relatively safe
• It is better to avoid combinations of
cephalosporins and aminoglycosides in these
patients because both these classes of drugs
can cause nephrotoxicity.
Organ Dysfunction
• In patients with hepatic failure -
chloramphenicol, erythromycin,
fluroquinolones, pyrazinamide, rifampicin, INH
and metronidazole are relatively
contraindicated
• Penicillins, cephalosporins, ethambutol and
aminoglycosides are safe
Organ Dysfunction
• Significant accumulation can occur when both
liver dysfunction and renal dysfunction are
present for these drugs: cefotaxime, nafcillin,
piperacillin, and sulfamethoxazole
Concomitant Disease States
• Certain diseases will predispose patients to a
particular infectious disease or will alter the
type of infecting organism
• Patients with immunosuppressive diseases,
such as malignancies or acquired immunologic
deficiencies, are highly predisposed to
infections, and the types of organisms can be
vastly different from what would be expected
Concomitant Disease States
• Seizures-High doses of penicillin G
• Patients with myasthenia gravis or other
neuromuscular problems susceptible to the
neuromuscular blocking effect of the
aminoglycosides, polymyxins
Drug Factors
Pharmacokinetic and
Pharmacodynamic Considerations
• Integration of both pharmacokinetic and
pharmacodynamic properties of an agent is
important when choosing antimicrobial therapy
to ensure efficacy and to prevent resistance
• Aminoglycosides exhibit concentration-
dependent bactericidal effects
• β-Lactams display time-dependent bactericidal
effects
Tissue Penetration
• Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) concentrations of
antimicrobial agents necessary to cure
bacterial meningitis have been defined
• Drugs that do not reach significant
concentrations in the CSF should either be
avoided or instilled directly, if feasible
Tissue Penetration
• The proper route of administration for an
antimicrobial depends on the site of infection
• Parenteral therapy: febrile neutropenia or deep-
seated infections such as meningitis,
endocarditis, and osteomyelitis
• Oral therapy: RTI, skin and soft tissue infections,
uncomplicated urinary tract infections, and
selected sexually transmitted diseases
Drug Toxicity
• CNS toxicities: penicillins, cephalosporins,
quinolones, and imipenem
• Hematologic: nafcillin, piperacillin, cefotetan,
chloramphenicol and trimethoprim
• Nephrotoxicity: aminoglycosides and
vancomycin
Drug Toxicity
• Ototoxicity: aminoglycosides or erythromycin
• Photosensitivity: azithromycin, quinolones,
tetracyclines, pyrazinamide, sulfamethoxazole,
and trimethoprim
• Gastric toxicities
Cost
• Lastly, the cost of therapy should be considered in
choosing the antibacterial agent and in a developing
country like India with limited spending on healthcare,
this does assume significance
• It should always be remembered that just because a
particular drug is expensive, it need not be superior
than the cheaper ones
• For example, cheaper drugs like doxycycline or co-
trimoxazole would be as effective as the costlier
clarithromycin or cephalosporins in the management
of LRTI
COMBINATION ANTIMICROBIAL
THERAPY
• Broadening the Spectrum of Coverage:
Intraabdominal and female pelvic infections
• Synergism: enterococcal endocarditis
• Preventing Resistance: TB
COMBINATION ANTIMICROBIAL
THERAPY
• The combination of two or more antibiotics
can result in antagonistic effects
• Increased cost
• Increased drug toxicity
General Guidelines To use Antibiotics
• Start antibiotics if there is evidence of
infection
• In starting antibiotics it is better not to use any
of the new ones,if you are not familiar with
their use
• Antibiotics should not be started in response
to patients pressure
General Guidelines To use Antibiotics
• No antibiotics- viral infections like Common
cold or diarrhea to satisfy the patients
• Antibiotics when used given for sufficient
long period, Inadequate duration and dose of
therapy should be discouraged
• Do not change an antibiotic before giving the
current antibiotic a fair trial
General Guidelines To use Antibiotics
• Cost effectiveness of therapy should be
considered especially while changing the
antibiotics, calculating for the full duration of
treatment.
• Wherever possible culture sensitivity of the
sample should be sent before the antibiotic
treatment started
General Guidelines To use Antibiotics
• Avoid using too many antimicrobials and drug
combinations as it encourages poor diagnosis and
its mismanagement
• Avoid use of multiple antibiotics, except where it
is indicate-TB
• Acquire adequate and unbiased information
about a limited number of antibiotics of proven
efficacy and be familiar with their side effects
General Guidelines To use Antibiotics
• Get a full drug history and history of allergy to the
chosen antibiotics, before starting the antibiotics
• Where possible and indicated,e.g.poor response
to therapy, repeat culture sensitivity
• Avoid the use of topical
antimicrobials,prophylactic antimicrobials and
antimicrobial combinations
THANK U !!

Rational use of antibiotics

  • 1.
    General Guidelines forRational use of Antibiotics Dhaval Joshi
  • 2.
    BACKGOUND • Antibiotics arethe most widely used medications • Perhaps the most irrationally used
  • 3.
    Questions • Is itinfection? • Is it bacterial Infection? • If yes, take appropriate samples first • What is likely etiologic agent? • Which antibiotic? • Also consider some evidence!
  • 4.
    Case • 5 yrsold boy • Fever and cough for 8 days • Admitted on day 2 of fever • Chest X-ray: right lower zone pneumonia • WBC count: 23,000/cumm • Prescribed with Ceftriaxone, Amikacin
  • 5.
    Case • No improvementin chest x-ray, changed to meropenam in 3 days • Refereed on Day 3 meropenam for non respone
  • 6.
    Case • Evidence ofpneumococcal vaccines • Amoxicillin
  • 7.
    Indications for antibacterialtherapy 1. Definitive therapy 2. Empirical therapy 3. Prophylactic therapy
  • 8.
    Empirical therapy • Empiricalantibacterial therapy should be restricted to critical cases, when time is inadequate for identification and isolation of the bacteria and reasonably strong doubt of bacterial infection exists • In such situations, drugs that cover the most probable infective agent/s should be used
  • 9.
    Definitive therapy • Thisis for proven bacterial infections • Attempts should be made to confirm the bacterial infection by means of staining of secretions/fluids/exudates, culture and sensitivity, serological tests and other tests • Based on the reports, a narrow spectrum, least toxic, easy-to-administer and cheap drug should be prescribed
  • 10.
    Prophylactic therapy • Antimicrobialprophylaxis is administered to susceptible patients to prevent specific infections that can cause definite detrimental effect • In all these situations, only narrow spectrum and specific drugs are used. It should be remembered that there is NO single prophylaxis to 'prevent' all possible bacterial infections
  • 11.
    What antibacterial? • Thereare more than 100 antibacterials available today, and each one has its own spectrum of activity, adverse effect profile and cost • The prescriber should consider many factors before prescribing an antibacterial agent so as to make the treatment most effective with least adverse effects and cost
  • 12.
    Factors affecting Antibiotic Prescribing Thefollowing factors should be considered while prescribing an antibacterial agent: • Site of infection • Type of infection • Severity of infection • Isolate and its sensitivity • Source of infection • Host factors • Drug related factors
  • 13.
    Site of infection •As a Rule Of The Thumb, it can be remembered that the infections above the diaphragm are caused by Cocci and Gram positive organisms and • infections below the diaphragm are caused by Bacilli and Gram negative organisms, although there are exceptions
  • 14.
    Infections above thediaphragm • Respiratory tract infections- Streptococcus pyogenes, S. pneumoniae, streptococci • Managed with Penicillins, Cephalosporins, Macrolides and Tetracyclines
  • 15.
    Infections below thediaphragm • Examples include urinary tract infection, intra- abdominal sepsis, pelvic infections etc. and these are caused by the organisms like E. coli, Klebsiella, Proteus, Pseudomonas, etc. • Quinolones, Aminoglycosides, 3rd generation cephalosporins and Metronidazole, alone or in combination are useful in these infections
  • 16.
    Site of infection •There are certain sites where the infection tends to be difficult for treatment • In such cases higher dose, more frequent administration, longer duration, antibacterial combinations and lipophilic antibacterials may have to be used
  • 17.
    Type of infection •Infections can be localized or extensive; mild or severe; superficial or deep seated; acute, sub acute or chronic and extracellular or intracellular • For extensive, severe, deep seated, chronic and intracellular infections, higher and more frequent dose, longer duration of therapy, combinations, lipophilic drugs may have to be used
  • 18.
    Severe infections • (bacteremia/ pyemia / sepsis syndrome / septic shock; abscesses in lung/ brain/ liver/ pelvis/ intra-abdominal; meningitis/ endocarditis/ pneumonias/ pyelonephritis/ / gangrene and hospital acquired infections) can be life threatening and rapidly fatal
  • 19.
    Severe infections • Inall such situations therefore, attempts should be made to identify and isolate the infecting organism from the site as well as blood by staining culture • In treating the severe infections, drugs should be administered by only intravenous route to ensure adequate blood levels
  • 20.
    Severe infections • Onlybactericidal drugs should be used to ensure faster clearance of the infection. If the site of infection is known, narrow spectrum drugs should be used • A combination of Penicillins/3rd generation cephalosporins, aminoglycosides and metronidazole may be used. The dose should be higher and more frequent. Whenever possible, a switch to oral therapy should be made
  • 21.
    Isolate and sensitivity •Ideal management of any significant bacterial infection requires culture and sensitivity study of the specimen • Blood culture: Febrile illness • If the situation permits, antibacterials can be started only after the sensitivity report is available
  • 22.
    Isolate and sensitivity •Narrow spectrum, least toxic, easy to administer and cheapest of the effective drugs should be chosen • If the patient is responding to the drug that has already been started, it should not be changed even if the in vitro report says otherwise
  • 23.
    Source of infection •Community acquired infections are less likely to be resistant whereas hospital acquired infections are likely to be resistant and more difficult to treat (e.g. Pseudomonas, MRSA etc.)
  • 24.
  • 25.
    AGE • The patient’sage is an important factor both in trying to identify the likely etiologic agent and in assessing the patient’s ability to eliminate the drug(s) to be used • In infants, chloramphenicol (can cause gray baby syndrome) and sulfa (can cause kernicterus) are contraindicated
  • 26.
    AGE • Elderly: Nephrotoxicdrugs • In the elderly, achlorhydria may affect absorption of antibacterial agents; drug elimination is slower, requiring dose adjustments; and ototoxicity of aminoglycosides may be increased • Increased absorption of penicillin G and decreased absorption of Ketoconazole
  • 27.
    Pregnancy • In pregnancy,drugs with known toxicity or un- established safety like tetracyclines, quinolones, streptomycin, erythromycin and Clarithromycin are contraindicated in all trimesters • Sulfa, nitrofurantoin and chloramphenicol are contraindicated in the last trimester.
  • 28.
    Pregnancy • Drugs withlimited data on safety like aminoglycosides, azithromycin, clindamycin, vancomycin, metronidazole, trimethoprim, rifampicin and pyrazinamide • Penicillins, cephalosporins, INH and ethambutol are safe in pregnancy • In lactating mothers sulfa, tetracyclines, metronidazole, nitrofurantoin and quinolones are contraindicated
  • 29.
    Metabolic Abnormalities • Inheritedor acquired metabolic abnormalities will influence the therapy of infectious diseases in a variety of ways • Slow acetylators • G6PD deficiency
  • 30.
    Organ Dysfunction • Inpatients with renal failure, tetracyclines are absolutely contraindicated • Aminoglycosides, cephalosporins, fluroquinolones and sulfa are relatively contraindicated; and
  • 31.
    Organ Dysfunction • Penicillins,Macrolides, vancomycin, metronidazole, INH, ethambutol and rifampicin are relatively safe • It is better to avoid combinations of cephalosporins and aminoglycosides in these patients because both these classes of drugs can cause nephrotoxicity.
  • 32.
    Organ Dysfunction • Inpatients with hepatic failure - chloramphenicol, erythromycin, fluroquinolones, pyrazinamide, rifampicin, INH and metronidazole are relatively contraindicated • Penicillins, cephalosporins, ethambutol and aminoglycosides are safe
  • 33.
    Organ Dysfunction • Significantaccumulation can occur when both liver dysfunction and renal dysfunction are present for these drugs: cefotaxime, nafcillin, piperacillin, and sulfamethoxazole
  • 34.
    Concomitant Disease States •Certain diseases will predispose patients to a particular infectious disease or will alter the type of infecting organism • Patients with immunosuppressive diseases, such as malignancies or acquired immunologic deficiencies, are highly predisposed to infections, and the types of organisms can be vastly different from what would be expected
  • 35.
    Concomitant Disease States •Seizures-High doses of penicillin G • Patients with myasthenia gravis or other neuromuscular problems susceptible to the neuromuscular blocking effect of the aminoglycosides, polymyxins
  • 36.
  • 37.
    Pharmacokinetic and Pharmacodynamic Considerations •Integration of both pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic properties of an agent is important when choosing antimicrobial therapy to ensure efficacy and to prevent resistance • Aminoglycosides exhibit concentration- dependent bactericidal effects • β-Lactams display time-dependent bactericidal effects
  • 38.
    Tissue Penetration • Cerebrospinalfluid (CSF) concentrations of antimicrobial agents necessary to cure bacterial meningitis have been defined • Drugs that do not reach significant concentrations in the CSF should either be avoided or instilled directly, if feasible
  • 39.
    Tissue Penetration • Theproper route of administration for an antimicrobial depends on the site of infection • Parenteral therapy: febrile neutropenia or deep- seated infections such as meningitis, endocarditis, and osteomyelitis • Oral therapy: RTI, skin and soft tissue infections, uncomplicated urinary tract infections, and selected sexually transmitted diseases
  • 40.
    Drug Toxicity • CNStoxicities: penicillins, cephalosporins, quinolones, and imipenem • Hematologic: nafcillin, piperacillin, cefotetan, chloramphenicol and trimethoprim • Nephrotoxicity: aminoglycosides and vancomycin
  • 41.
    Drug Toxicity • Ototoxicity:aminoglycosides or erythromycin • Photosensitivity: azithromycin, quinolones, tetracyclines, pyrazinamide, sulfamethoxazole, and trimethoprim • Gastric toxicities
  • 42.
    Cost • Lastly, thecost of therapy should be considered in choosing the antibacterial agent and in a developing country like India with limited spending on healthcare, this does assume significance • It should always be remembered that just because a particular drug is expensive, it need not be superior than the cheaper ones • For example, cheaper drugs like doxycycline or co- trimoxazole would be as effective as the costlier clarithromycin or cephalosporins in the management of LRTI
  • 43.
    COMBINATION ANTIMICROBIAL THERAPY • Broadeningthe Spectrum of Coverage: Intraabdominal and female pelvic infections • Synergism: enterococcal endocarditis • Preventing Resistance: TB
  • 44.
    COMBINATION ANTIMICROBIAL THERAPY • Thecombination of two or more antibiotics can result in antagonistic effects • Increased cost • Increased drug toxicity
  • 45.
    General Guidelines Touse Antibiotics • Start antibiotics if there is evidence of infection • In starting antibiotics it is better not to use any of the new ones,if you are not familiar with their use • Antibiotics should not be started in response to patients pressure
  • 46.
    General Guidelines Touse Antibiotics • No antibiotics- viral infections like Common cold or diarrhea to satisfy the patients • Antibiotics when used given for sufficient long period, Inadequate duration and dose of therapy should be discouraged • Do not change an antibiotic before giving the current antibiotic a fair trial
  • 47.
    General Guidelines Touse Antibiotics • Cost effectiveness of therapy should be considered especially while changing the antibiotics, calculating for the full duration of treatment. • Wherever possible culture sensitivity of the sample should be sent before the antibiotic treatment started
  • 48.
    General Guidelines Touse Antibiotics • Avoid using too many antimicrobials and drug combinations as it encourages poor diagnosis and its mismanagement • Avoid use of multiple antibiotics, except where it is indicate-TB • Acquire adequate and unbiased information about a limited number of antibiotics of proven efficacy and be familiar with their side effects
  • 49.
    General Guidelines Touse Antibiotics • Get a full drug history and history of allergy to the chosen antibiotics, before starting the antibiotics • Where possible and indicated,e.g.poor response to therapy, repeat culture sensitivity • Avoid the use of topical antimicrobials,prophylactic antimicrobials and antimicrobial combinations
  • 50.