SCOPE OF PRESENTATION
Introduction
 Definition of refractory angina
 Mechanisms of angina
 Prevalence
 Mechanism & pathophysiology of refractory angina
 Evaluation
 Treatment - Pharmacological & Non-pharmacological
3.
Introduction
 Angina
 Greek– ancina- means strangulation
 Latin – ang – to throttle
 A sensation of choking or strangulation
4.
 Described byWilliam Heberden in 1772
 A significant number of patients remain symptomatic in
spite of anti-anginal drugs and/or after PCI or CABG
5.
Definition
 The 2019ESC Guidelines for the Diagnosis and
Management of Chronic Coronary Syndromes define
refractory angina as follows:
 ‘Refractory angina refers to long-lasting symptoms (for
>3months) due to established reversible ischaemia in the
presence of obstructive coronary artery disease (CAD),
which cannot be controlled by escalating medical therapy
with the use of2nd- and 3rd-line pharmacological agents,
bypass grafting, or stenting including PCI of chronic total
coronary occlusion
The elicited painfulstimuli travel through sympathetic (passing by the dorsal root
ganglion) or vagal afferents (passing by the nucleus of tractus solitarius) to reach the
posterior thalamus
9.
Prevalence
 RAP prevalenceis estimated to be 5% to 10% in stable
CAD patients
 Epidemiology is rapidly changing – d/t aging population
with more prevalent CAD and of the widespread access
to coronary revascularization
10.
Mechanisms of refractoryangina
 Microvascular dysfunction
 Non revascularisation
 Non – obstructive causes –Vasospasm/ extramural
compression
 Restenosis
 Non Coronary causes of angina
 Maladaptive pain perception
11.
Microvascular dysfunction
 Myocardialblood flow - dependant on
1. Intraventricular , intramyocardial and right atrial
pressures during the cardiac cycle
2. Anatomical and functional integrity of the coronary
microvasculature
Non obstructive CAD
Ischaemia with non-obstructive coronary artery disease
appears to be particularly common in women and after
PCI
 In patients with microvascular coronary spasm and
documented ischaemia, an acetylcholine or ergonovine
challenge may be useful to detect vasomotor dysfunction
as the underlying cause
15.
Myocardial Bridge
 Theircontribution to myocardial ischaemia, however, is
controversial as more than 80% of myocardial blood flow
occurs during diastole rather than systole
 Under certain conditions, particularly at higher heart
rates and marked myocardial inotropism, muscle bridges
may cause ischaemia either directly or by inducing spasm
Optimal medical management
Optimal treatment can be defined as the treatment that
satisfactorily controls symptoms and prevents cardiac
events associated with CCS, with maximal patient
adherence and minimal adverse events
 Lifestyle modification
 Pharmacotherapy – Antianginal therpy
Lifestyle factor
Smoking cessationUse pharmacological and behavioural strategies to help
patients quit smoking.Avoid passive smoking.
Healthy diet Diet high in vegetables, fruit, and wholegrains. Limit saturated
fat to <10% of total intake. Limit alcohol to <100 g/week or
15 g/day.
Physical activity 30 60 min moderate physical activity most days, but even
−
irregular activity is beneficial.
Healthy weight Obtain and maintain a healthy weight (<25 kg/m2
), or reduce
weight through recommended energy intake and increased
physical activity
Other Take medications as prescribed. Sexual activity is low risk for
stable patients not symptomatic at low-to-moderate activity
levels
a) Combination ofa BB with a DHP-CCB should be considered as first step;
combination of a BB or a CCB with a second-line drug may be considered as
a first step
b) The combination of a BB and non-DHP-CCB should initially use low doses of
each drug under close monitoring of tolerance, particularly heart rate and
blood pressure
c) Low-dose BB or low-dose non-DHP-CCB should be used under close
monitoring of tolerance, particularly heart rate and blood pressure
d) Ivabradine should not be combined with non-DHP-CCB
e) Consider adding the drug chosen at step 2 to the drug tested at step 1 if
blood pressure remains unchanged.
24.
 Beta –blockers – dose  limit the heart rate to 55 - 60 b.p.m.
 CCBs –Non DHP – Rate ↓ / peripheral vasodilation / relief of exercise
induced constriction, modest negative inotropic effect & sinus node
inhibition
 For verapamil, compared with metoprolol, the antianginal activity
was similar & compared with atenonol in hypertension with CAD, it
is associated with fewer cases of diabetes, fewer anginal attacks &
less psychological depression
 CCB- DHP – In patients with CCS and normal BP (75% receiving a beta-
blocker), amlodipine 10 mg/day reduced coronary revascularizations and
hospitalizations for angina in a 24 month trial
 Long acting nitrate – 2nd
line therapy
25.
Novel pharmacological therapies
Ivabradine – second line
 Adding ivabradine 7.5 mg b.i.d. to atenolol therapy gave
better control of heart rate and anginal symptoms 
non-inferior to atenolol or amlodipine in the treatment of
angina and ischaemia in patients with CCS –no mortality
benefit
 Nicorandil – second line
 Ranolazine – second line
 Trimetazidine – no hemodyanmic effects
 Perhexiline , allopurinol, fasudil
31.
 Lipid apheresisis an extremely effective method to reduce
LDLcholesterol as well as other lipids such as lipoprotein(a).
 Lipid apheresis treatment improves endothelial function in
the forearm circulation within hours is similarly effective,
albeit much more burdensome to the patient, as PCSK9
inhibition
 Improves myocardial perfusion reserve and symptoms in
patients with elevated lipoprotein(a) levels (>500 mg/L) and
refractory angina
PCI
 CTOs arequite common and today they can be
approached with new percutaneous revascularization
techniques
36.
 The EuroCTO trial (A Randomized Multicenter Trial to
Evaluate the Utilization of Revascularization or Optimal
Medical Therapy for the Treatment of Chronic Total
Coronary Occlusions) randomized 407 patients to CTO
PCI vs. optimal medial therapy alone.
 At 12 months, compared with patients randomized to
medical therapy only, those randomized to CTO PCI had
greater improvement in angina frequency with a subscale
change difference: 5.23, and quality of life (subscale change
difference: 6.62), as assessed by the Seattle Angina
Questionnaire
38.
 Whether CTOPCI improves traditional composite
endpoints of death, myocardial infarction, stroke, or
revascularization - undetermined
39.
Transmyocardial laser revascularization
Transmyocardial laser revascularization (TMLR) 
 Creates channels in the ischaemic myocardium to restore
perfusion
 Up-regulate of vascular endothelial growth factors
(VEGFs) to stimulate angiogenesis
 Myocardial sympathetic denervation to blunt angina
Enhanced external counterpulsation
Enhanced external counterpulsation (EECP) uses
externally applied blood pressure cuffs on both legs that
are intermittently inflated up to 300mmHg during early
diastole, first in the lower legs, followed by inflation of
those placed on the lower and upper thighs
 Similar to IABP – Diastolic augmentation
 On the venous side, EECP augments right ventricular
filling pressure due to an increased venous return.
 Typically, a full course of therapy consists of 35 sessions of
1 hour each
49.
 In theMUST-EECP trial that enrolled 139 patients with
angina pectoris and a positive treadmill test received 35 h
of EECP over 4–7weeks or inactive counterpulsation
(sham group), EECP was safe and well tolerated, reduced
angina pectoris and prolonged the time to exercise-
induced ischaemia in thesepatients with refractory chest
pain
50.
 EECP improvesperipheral endothelial function up to 1
month of follow-up in patients with a positive clinical
response.
 This suggests that improved endothelial function
contributes to the clinical benefits of EECP in patients
with refractory angina
51.
Coronary sinus occlusion
In the 1950s and 1960s, the cardiac surgeon Claude Beck
surgically narrowed the coronary sinus in patients with
severe angina, to increase coronary sinus pressure and to
achieve redistribution of myocardial blood flow into
ischaemic territories
52.
 Coronary sinusreducer–Acts by elevating backward
pressure in the coronary venous system results in a slight
dilatation of arterioles leading to a significant reduction in
vascular resistance in the subendocardial myocardium.
 Blood flow in the ischaemic subendocardium is enhanced,
contractility improves, and left ventricular end diastolic
pressure (LVEDP) decreases which further reduces
resistance to flow in the sub-endocardial layers of the
myocardium,which will lead to symptom relief.
53.
 The CoronarySinus ReducerVR is a balloon expandable
stainless-steelmesh, designed to create a permanent focal
narrowing in the lumen of the coronary sinus to generate
a pressure gradient across it.
 The ReducerVR is implanted percutaneously via the right
jugular vein into the coronary sinus.
 A few weeks after implantation, the gaps between the
metal struts are covered with tissue ingrowth, to create
the central narrowing and establish a pressure gradient
across the device
54.
The coronary sinusreducer. (A)The Reducer on the inflated balloon.The diameters of the
proximal and distal ends of the Reducer are determined by the inflation pressure of the
balloon.The narrowed centre of the device is always 3 mm. (B)The expanded Reducer after
balloon deflation. (C) Coronary sinus angiography using a multipurpose diagnostic catheter
at LAO 30 degrees. (D) Contrast injection through the guiding catheter while Reducer
balloon inflation. Oversizing of the implanted Reducer is important. (E) Coronary sinus
angiography immediately after Reducer implantation.
55.
The COSIRA randomizedsham-controlled clinical trial demonstrated improvement of >_2
CCS class in 35% (18/52) of the Reducertreated patients vs. 15% (8/52) of the sham-control
patients (P= 0.02), and improvement of at least 1 CCS angina class in 71% (37/52) vs. 42%
(22/ 52) in the sham-control group (P= 0.003) (left). Mean CCS class improvement for the
groups was from 3.2 to 2.1 in the treatment group and from 3.1 to 2.6 in the sham-
controlled group (P=0.001) (right).
56.
Extracorporeal shockwave myocardial
revascularization
Extracorporeal shockwave myocardial revascularization
(ESMR) is a non-invasive emerging treatment that,
through the application of targeted shockwaves, may
improve myocardial perfusion and symptoms of
refractory angina.
 Through a commercially available shockwave generator,
pulses of shockwave energy are applied to the ischaemic
myocardium.
59.
Spinal Cord Stimulationand Transcutaneous
Electrical Nerve Stimulation (TENS)
 The use of spinal cord/nerve stimulation for the
treatment of RA bases on an alternative explanation for
the source of the chest pain, i.e., that its cause might not
reside within the myocardium, but rather originate from
its elaboration within the somatosensory nervous system
60.
 The centralnervous system (CNS) is responsible for the
perception of visceral chest pain, and it has been shown that
patients who have been diagnosed with angina in the absence of
coronary artery obstructions present characteristic regional
differences in brain activation as compared to patients with
”traditional” CAD
 This appears to suggest that while angina in patients with CAD
group is due to a supply–demand mismatch, the chest pain of
patients with no CAD may be due to abnormal CNS processing
of afferent signals from the myocardium, leading to
inappropriate and increased cerebral cortex activation and the
subjective feeling of pain.
61.
 Using across-over design in two parallel groups, the
authors show that the Pw/Pa ratio increases during
ischemia when electrical neurostimulation is active, while
it decreases when it is inactive, an effect that might be
due to collateral vessel recruitment via b-adrenergic
receptors.
 Finally, some studies showed a reduction in afterload and
systemic vasodilatation following SCS, possibly due to
reduced sympathetic activity.
62.
 SCS isa surgical procedure that consists of implantation of one or more
leads in the epidural space of the spinal canal.
 The lead(s) are connected to an implantable pulse generator and
delivers on-demand a weak electrical current to the spinal cord,
resulting in peripheral paresthesia and withdrawal of pain.
 Beyond RA, SCS is used for complex regional pain syndrome and
radicular pain after failed back surgery syndrome, stump pain after
amputation, and pain due to peripheral nerve injury, peripheral vascular
disease, and diabetic neuropathy.
 Symptomatic success rates for these indications have been reported to
be in the range of 50–75%.
63.
 The largestblinded study to date, STARTSTIM was underpowered, due to
slow patient enrollment and subsequent early termination.The analysis of
68 patients failed to show the efficacy of SCS against control-group,
showing significant improvement in both groups consistent with the
placebo effect.
 Two recent meta-analyses of 14 and 12 studies in RA patients showed
longer exercise duration, lower angina frequency and nitrate consumption
associated with SCS. Future studies will have to test whether these effects
are confirmed in larger cohorts.
 Imran,T.Fet al Efficacy of spinal cord stimulation as an adjunct therapy for chronic refractory
angina pectoris. Int. J. Cardiol. 2017,
 Pan, X et al. Spinal Cord Stimulation for Refractory Angina Pectoris. Clin. J. Pain. 2017,
65.
Stem cell therapy
Cell therapy with bone marrow (BM)-derived progenitors
has emerged as a promising therapeutic option for RA
patients.
 Different BM autologous vasculogenic cell populations,
including unfractioned mononuclear cells, CD34+ or
CD133+ cells, have been injected into ischemic areas to
ameliorate perfusion of LV territories not otherwise
amenable to revascularization
66.
 Safety andfeasibility of intramyocardial injection of autologous
CD34+ stem cells were demonstrated in a Phase I/IIa double-
blind, randomized controlled trial on 24 RA patients, showing
potential bioactivity with improvement in CCS angina class
 A phase II randomized trial, including 167 RA patients,
showed a significant improvement in both angina symptoms
and exercised tolerance with intramyocardial injection of
autologous CD34+ stem cells over placebo at 6, 12 months
with persistent results at 24 months follow-up In addition,
there was a trend towards a reduction in the rates of major
adverse cardiac events (p = 0.08)
67.
 Based onthese promising results, a phase III randomized
(RENEW, efficacy and safety of targeted intramyocardial
delivery of auto CD34+ stem cells for improving exercise
capacity in subjects with refractory angina) trial was
launched. However, the trial was terminated prematurely
by the sponsor, due to financial reasons, recruiting only
112 patients of planned 444, which was not sufficient to
test its efficacy end-point
68.
 Recognizing theweight of the TACT results, the American
Heart Association and the American College of
Cardiology upgraded edetate disodium chelation from a
3C to a 2B indication in their 2014 revision of the
guidelines for the treatment of chronic ischemic heart
disease.
69.
 However, 2019ESC guidelines for CCS for treatment of
refractory angina have not included chelation therapy.
71.
 Trans-endocardial deliveryof another autologous bone
marrow-derived cells, CD133+ cells, were proved to be safe
and feasible in two small phase I randomized trials not
powered for efficacy end-points
 Another recent phase I randomized trial of intramyocardial
injection of CD133+ cells in RA patient subset with LV
dysfunction (LV < 45%) confirmed the safety profile of the
previous two trials and showed significant improvements in
CCS angina class, myocardial perfusion and function assessed
by single-photon emission computer tomography at 12 months
75.
Chelation therapy
 Treatmentof lead toxicity with chelation was first
reported with EDTA in the early 1950s.
 Apparent success in reducing metastatic calcium deposits
led Clarke et al in 1956 to treat angina patients with
EDTA, and others to use chelation for various forms of
atherosclerotic disease.
 Chelation therapy evolved to constitute infusions of
vitamins and disodium EDTA, a drug that binds divalent
and some trivalent cations, including calcium, magnesium,
lead, cadmium, zinc, iron, aluminum, and copper, facilitating
their urinary excretion.
76.
 Three smallclinical trials have assessed the effects of
chelation on surrogate outcomes, such as walking
distance in patients with claudication (2 trials with 185
patients total) and time to exercise-induced ischemia in
patients with coronary disease (1 trial with 84 patients).
These studies did not find any evidence of treatment
efficacy but were underpowered for evaluation of clinical
events