Chapter 21
Rewarding Performance
Cost Accounting
Traditions and Innovations
Barfield, Raiborn, Kinney
Learning Objectives (1 of 2)
• Explain the relationship between compensation
and maximization of stockholder wealth
• List the different ways of rewarding
performance
• Describe the movement toward rewarding
group, as well as individual, performance
• List the positive and negative consequences of
incentive pay programs
Learning Objectives (2 of 2)
• Explain why incentive programs may involve
shares of, or options for, common stock
• Describe the importance of nonmonetary rewards
in motivating managers
• Clarify how taxes affect compensation plan
design
• Describe the role of ethics when designing a
compensation package
• Identify expatriate compensation issues
Rewarding Performance
Compensation Strategy
• Unites goals and strategies, performance
measurements, and rewards
• Board of directors and top management
determine compensation strategy
• Compensation committee
– Establishes compensation strategy
– Sets compensation policies/guidelines
Is this a
conflict
of
interest?
Set strategic goals
Identify critical success factors, set
operational targets and compensation strategy
Identify performance measures
Set performance rewards
Employee or employee group performs tasks
Measure/monitor performance
Determine rewards
Plan-Performance-Reward Model
Traditional Compensation Strategy
• Top managers
– salary and significant financial incentives
• Middle managers
– salary and raises based on performance
• Workers
– wages and small bonuses
Contemporary Strategy
• Incentive-based compensation to all
employees
• Based on group or individual performance
• Encourages
– higher level of employee performance and
loyalty
– lower overall costs
Pay-for-Performance Plans
• Correlation with organization goals
– Maximization of shareholder wealth
• Appropriate time horizon
– Long-run perspective
– Reward with stock or stock options
• Subunit mission
• Age of employee
• Balance of group and individual benefits
• Management ownership
Setting Performance Measures
• Degree of control over performance output
Minimize risk to worker of random effects
worker specific, short-run measures
upper less specific, longer-time horizon,
management organization longevity measures
Setting Performance Measures
• Incentives relative to organization level
worker weighted toward monetary and
short-term measures
upper weighted toward nonmonetary
management and long-term measures
Worker Compensation
• Choice of plan affected by:
– Competitive focus
– Organizational culture
– Local laws
– Union affiliation
– Political consideration
Pay Plan
• Periodic compensation
– function of time at work, not tasks accomplished
– affected by seniority, skill, education level
– no link between performance and reward
Performance-Based Pay Plans
• Merit pay
• Contingent pay
• Piece rate
These do not consider overall organizational success
Profit Sharing
• Contingent on organizational success
• Current and/or deferred incentives in form
of cash or stock
• Allocated among employees based on
– personal performance measures
– seniority
– team performance
– managerial judgment
– specified formulas
Profit Sharing
Stock Options
• Employee can purchase shares of company
stock at a set price during a specific time
period
• More valuable as company stock price
increases
Stock Appreciation Rights
• Employee may receive cash, stock, or a
combination of cash and stock
• Amount based on company stock price at a
future date
• More valuable as company stock price
increases
Employee Stock Ownership Plan
(ESOP)
• Profit-sharing compensation invested in
company stock
• More valuable as company stock price
increases
Nonfinancial Incentives
• Recognition of efforts
• Participation in decision making
Good
Job
Managerial Compensation
• Monetary
• Perquisites - Perks
– vacations
– free child care
– free parking
– personal assistants or private secretaries
– health care
– recreational club memberships
– office with a view
– flexible work hours
Not-for-Profit and Governmental
• Time-based pay plans; not a strong link
between pay and performance
• 90% of government workers support plans
that would link pay and performance
• Only 20% of not-for-profits provide bonus
plans for top executives
Possible Tax Treatments of
Compensation Elements
• Full and immediate taxation
• Tax deferral - pay tax at a future date
• Tax exempt - pay no tax
Taxation of Fringe Benefits
• Employer-provided accident and health
insurance
– deductible by employer
– not taxable to employee
• Cafeteria benefit plans
– both nontaxable and taxable benefits
Benefits
Deferred Compensation
• Profit-sharing, pension, and various
stock-based plans including ESOPs
• Company receives an immediate
deduction
• Employee is not taxed until distributions
made (tax deferred)
Ethical Considerations
• Organizational governance
• Role of capital markets
– Takeover, raiders, and golden parachutes
• Compensation differentials
Global Compensation
• Expatriate compensation
• Domestic base salary and fringe benefits
plus adjustments for
– cost of living - housing, education, security
– currency fluctuations
– tax implications
– retirement benefits in home currency
Questions
• What are some different ways of rewarding
performance?
• Why do many incentive programs involve
shares of, or options for, common stock?
• What are some ethical issues to consider
when designing a compensation package?

Rewarding Performance

  • 1.
    Chapter 21 Rewarding Performance CostAccounting Traditions and Innovations Barfield, Raiborn, Kinney
  • 2.
    Learning Objectives (1of 2) • Explain the relationship between compensation and maximization of stockholder wealth • List the different ways of rewarding performance • Describe the movement toward rewarding group, as well as individual, performance • List the positive and negative consequences of incentive pay programs
  • 3.
    Learning Objectives (2of 2) • Explain why incentive programs may involve shares of, or options for, common stock • Describe the importance of nonmonetary rewards in motivating managers • Clarify how taxes affect compensation plan design • Describe the role of ethics when designing a compensation package • Identify expatriate compensation issues
  • 4.
  • 5.
    Compensation Strategy • Unitesgoals and strategies, performance measurements, and rewards • Board of directors and top management determine compensation strategy • Compensation committee – Establishes compensation strategy – Sets compensation policies/guidelines Is this a conflict of interest?
  • 6.
    Set strategic goals Identifycritical success factors, set operational targets and compensation strategy Identify performance measures Set performance rewards Employee or employee group performs tasks Measure/monitor performance Determine rewards Plan-Performance-Reward Model
  • 7.
    Traditional Compensation Strategy •Top managers – salary and significant financial incentives • Middle managers – salary and raises based on performance • Workers – wages and small bonuses
  • 8.
    Contemporary Strategy • Incentive-basedcompensation to all employees • Based on group or individual performance • Encourages – higher level of employee performance and loyalty – lower overall costs
  • 9.
    Pay-for-Performance Plans • Correlationwith organization goals – Maximization of shareholder wealth • Appropriate time horizon – Long-run perspective – Reward with stock or stock options • Subunit mission • Age of employee • Balance of group and individual benefits • Management ownership
  • 10.
    Setting Performance Measures •Degree of control over performance output Minimize risk to worker of random effects worker specific, short-run measures upper less specific, longer-time horizon, management organization longevity measures
  • 11.
    Setting Performance Measures •Incentives relative to organization level worker weighted toward monetary and short-term measures upper weighted toward nonmonetary management and long-term measures
  • 12.
    Worker Compensation • Choiceof plan affected by: – Competitive focus – Organizational culture – Local laws – Union affiliation – Political consideration
  • 13.
    Pay Plan • Periodiccompensation – function of time at work, not tasks accomplished – affected by seniority, skill, education level – no link between performance and reward
  • 14.
    Performance-Based Pay Plans •Merit pay • Contingent pay • Piece rate These do not consider overall organizational success
  • 15.
    Profit Sharing • Contingenton organizational success • Current and/or deferred incentives in form of cash or stock • Allocated among employees based on – personal performance measures – seniority – team performance – managerial judgment – specified formulas Profit Sharing
  • 16.
    Stock Options • Employeecan purchase shares of company stock at a set price during a specific time period • More valuable as company stock price increases
  • 17.
    Stock Appreciation Rights •Employee may receive cash, stock, or a combination of cash and stock • Amount based on company stock price at a future date • More valuable as company stock price increases
  • 18.
    Employee Stock OwnershipPlan (ESOP) • Profit-sharing compensation invested in company stock • More valuable as company stock price increases
  • 19.
    Nonfinancial Incentives • Recognitionof efforts • Participation in decision making Good Job
  • 20.
    Managerial Compensation • Monetary •Perquisites - Perks – vacations – free child care – free parking – personal assistants or private secretaries – health care – recreational club memberships – office with a view – flexible work hours
  • 21.
    Not-for-Profit and Governmental •Time-based pay plans; not a strong link between pay and performance • 90% of government workers support plans that would link pay and performance • Only 20% of not-for-profits provide bonus plans for top executives
  • 22.
    Possible Tax Treatmentsof Compensation Elements • Full and immediate taxation • Tax deferral - pay tax at a future date • Tax exempt - pay no tax
  • 23.
    Taxation of FringeBenefits • Employer-provided accident and health insurance – deductible by employer – not taxable to employee • Cafeteria benefit plans – both nontaxable and taxable benefits Benefits
  • 24.
    Deferred Compensation • Profit-sharing,pension, and various stock-based plans including ESOPs • Company receives an immediate deduction • Employee is not taxed until distributions made (tax deferred)
  • 25.
    Ethical Considerations • Organizationalgovernance • Role of capital markets – Takeover, raiders, and golden parachutes • Compensation differentials
  • 26.
    Global Compensation • Expatriatecompensation • Domestic base salary and fringe benefits plus adjustments for – cost of living - housing, education, security – currency fluctuations – tax implications – retirement benefits in home currency
  • 27.
    Questions • What aresome different ways of rewarding performance? • Why do many incentive programs involve shares of, or options for, common stock? • What are some ethical issues to consider when designing a compensation package?