RUSSIAN  
PROPAGANDA
AN  INNOVATIVE  APPROACH  
TO ASSESS INFORMATION  
ACTIVITIES
Denis	
  Bohush
December	
  2016
RUSSIAN	
  PROPAGANDA	
  
OUR WORKS
METHODOLOGY
- QUANTITATIVE	
  ANALYSIS	
  
- NARRATIVE	
  ANALYSES
- BOHUSH	
  PYRAMID	
  OF	
  INFLUENCE	
  
METHOD
700
Every  
day!
QUANTITATIVE	
  ANALYSES
150
Ukraine
QUANTITATIVE	
  ANALYSES
©  Denis  Bohush
METHODOLOGY
EXEMPLARY	
  APPORTION	
  OF	
  THE	
  
PROPAGANDISTIC	
  MESSAGES	
  IN	
  THE	
  
BOHUSH	
  PYRAMID	
  OF	
  INFLUENCE
WORD	
  CLOUD	
  FOR	
  THE	
  FIRST	
  LEVEL	
  
OF	
  INFLUENCE
Primary	
  source:	
  EEAS	
  Disinformation	
  review
WORD	
  CLOUD	
  FOR	
  THE	
  THIRD	
  LEVEL	
  
OF	
  INFLUENCE
Primary	
  source:	
  EEAS	
  Disinformation	
  review
UKRAINE	
  AND THE EU	
  ARE	
  HISTORICAL	
  
AND	
  CURRENT	
  ENEMIES
«ILLEGAL	
  FASCIST	
  GOVERNMENT	
  RULING	
  
UKRAINE»	
  NARRATIVE
«GROWING	
  TENSION	
  BETWEN	
  THE	
  EU	
  
AND	
  THE	
  USA»	
  NARRATIVE
«RUSSIA	
  IS	
  A FRIEND,	
  THE	
  USA	
  IS	
  AN	
  ENEMY	
  
OF	
  EUROPE»	
  NARRATIVE
«GROWING	
  TENSION	
  AMONG	
  COUNTRIES	
  
OF	
  THE	
  EU»	
  NARRATIVE
“UKRAINE	
  AND	
  POLAND	
  ARE	
  ENEMIES”	
  
NARRATIVE
THE	
  KEY	
  IDEA	
  
RUSSIAN	
  (DIS-­‐)INFORMATION	
  ACTIVITIES	
  ARE	
  VAST,	
  EFFICIENT	
  AND	
  
DIVERSIFIED.	
  
THEY	
  SHOULD	
  BE	
  ADDRESSED	
  WITH	
  COMPLEX	
  MULTILEVEL	
  MEASURES.	
  
RECOMMENDATIONS
• Considering the fact of the overwhelming, intense, multi-­‐level character of the Russian propaganda
countries should acknowledge inability to answer symmetrically in terms of quantity of information,
thus, should focus on the quality of the information and the ways it is transmitted. (Dis-­‐
)information, propagandistic activities should be analysed according to the levels at which they are
held and be responded accordingly. For example, the first and the second levels are mostly
transmitted and should be answered through TV, radio and internet, while the third and the fourth
levels should be also addressed through strategic measures like publishing history books, organizing
specific educational camps, online courses, etc.
• Countries should increase recognition and discussion of different types of disinformation. Discussion
should be held on different levels and in different forms. The broadest possible audience should be
addressed: not only the audience which is currently influenced by disinformation activities but also
audiences which might be potentially influenced in the nearest future.
• A broad audience should be made aware of the existence and strength of Russian propaganda in
different media resources. Political officials and experts should continuously push this issue and
cover it on different platforms, not only in Ukraine, but worldwide. These efforts should be
systematic and followed by sociological surveys, enabling the development of appropriate ways and
means of counterpropaganda. Discussions should include various examples of disinformation and
explicit disclaimers.
Denis  Bohush
Phone  +38-­067-­230-­68-­13
E-­mail:  bohushd@gmail.com
www.r-­studies.org
www.denisbohush.org
www.facebook.com/denis.bohush
Thank  you  

RUSSIAN PROPAGANDA, Denis Bohush

  • 1.
    RUSSIAN   PROPAGANDA AN  INNOVATIVE APPROACH   TO ASSESS INFORMATION   ACTIVITIES Denis  Bohush December  2016
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
    METHODOLOGY - QUANTITATIVE  ANALYSIS   - NARRATIVE  ANALYSES - BOHUSH  PYRAMID  OF  INFLUENCE   METHOD
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
    EXEMPLARY  APPORTION  OF  THE   PROPAGANDISTIC  MESSAGES  IN  THE   BOHUSH  PYRAMID  OF  INFLUENCE
  • 9.
    WORD  CLOUD  FOR  THE  FIRST  LEVEL   OF  INFLUENCE Primary  source:  EEAS  Disinformation  review
  • 10.
    WORD  CLOUD  FOR  THE  THIRD  LEVEL   OF  INFLUENCE Primary  source:  EEAS  Disinformation  review
  • 11.
    UKRAINE  AND THEEU  ARE  HISTORICAL   AND  CURRENT  ENEMIES
  • 12.
    «ILLEGAL  FASCIST  GOVERNMENT  RULING   UKRAINE»  NARRATIVE
  • 13.
    «GROWING  TENSION  BETWEN  THE  EU   AND  THE  USA»  NARRATIVE
  • 14.
    «RUSSIA  IS  AFRIEND,  THE  USA  IS  AN  ENEMY   OF  EUROPE»  NARRATIVE
  • 15.
    «GROWING  TENSION  AMONG  COUNTRIES   OF  THE  EU»  NARRATIVE
  • 16.
    “UKRAINE  AND  POLAND  ARE  ENEMIES”   NARRATIVE
  • 17.
    THE  KEY  IDEA   RUSSIAN  (DIS-­‐)INFORMATION  ACTIVITIES  ARE  VAST,  EFFICIENT  AND   DIVERSIFIED.   THEY  SHOULD  BE  ADDRESSED  WITH  COMPLEX  MULTILEVEL  MEASURES.  
  • 18.
    RECOMMENDATIONS • Considering thefact of the overwhelming, intense, multi-­‐level character of the Russian propaganda countries should acknowledge inability to answer symmetrically in terms of quantity of information, thus, should focus on the quality of the information and the ways it is transmitted. (Dis-­‐ )information, propagandistic activities should be analysed according to the levels at which they are held and be responded accordingly. For example, the first and the second levels are mostly transmitted and should be answered through TV, radio and internet, while the third and the fourth levels should be also addressed through strategic measures like publishing history books, organizing specific educational camps, online courses, etc. • Countries should increase recognition and discussion of different types of disinformation. Discussion should be held on different levels and in different forms. The broadest possible audience should be addressed: not only the audience which is currently influenced by disinformation activities but also audiences which might be potentially influenced in the nearest future. • A broad audience should be made aware of the existence and strength of Russian propaganda in different media resources. Political officials and experts should continuously push this issue and cover it on different platforms, not only in Ukraine, but worldwide. These efforts should be systematic and followed by sociological surveys, enabling the development of appropriate ways and means of counterpropaganda. Discussions should include various examples of disinformation and explicit disclaimers.
  • 19.
    Denis  Bohush Phone  +38-­067-­230-­68-­13 E-­mail: [email protected] www.r-­studies.org www.denisbohush.org www.facebook.com/denis.bohush Thank  you