Patricia Poss
Federal Trade Commission



              The views expressed are those of the
              speaker and not necessarily those of
                  the FTC or any other person.
                                                     1
   Mobile Technology Unit
   Law enforcement actions
   Policy initiatives




                              2
   Dedicated staff
   Technologist assistance
   Testing capabilities




                              3
   Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act broadly
    prohibits “unfair or deceptive acts or practices in or
    affecting commerce.”
    ◦ Deception  a material representation or omission that is
      likely to mislead consumers acting reasonably under the
      circumstances
    ◦ Unfairness  practices that cause or are likely to cause
      substantial injury to consumers that are not outweighed by
      countervailing benefits to consumers or competition and are
      not reasonably avoidable by consumers.

   Flexible law that can be applied to many different
    situations, entities, and technologies.



                                                                    4
   W3 Innovations
   Frostwire
   Google
   Facebook

   Mobile background screeners - warning
    letters




                                            5
   Complex ecosystem
    ◦   Operating system providers
    ◦   Application developers
    ◦   Handset manufacturers
    ◦   Carriers
    ◦   Ad networks
    ◦   Service providers




                                     6
   Screen size
   Communication channels: texting, mobile web
    browser, mobile apps
   “On the go” nature of use
   Personal
   Additional hardware capabilities – camera,
    microphone, gyroscope, compass, etc.
   GPS & location features
   Easy sharing of user information
   Rapidly evolving technology

                                                  7
   Who collects what information?
   How is it used?
   With whom is it shared?
   Are consumers being adequately
    informed?
   Do they have a choice?




                                     8
   Issued Final Report, March 2012.

   Applies to Mobile environment.

   Key elements: Privacy by Design,
    Simplified Choice, and Greater
    Transparency.



                                       9
   Collection and use of data is ubiquitous and
    often invisible.
   Consumers lack an understanding of the
    nature and extent of this collection.
   Many consumers are concerned.
   Collection and use has led to significant
    benefits.
   Traditional distinctions between personally
    identifiable and anonymous data are
    blurred.


                                                   10
   Make privacy the “default” setting for
    commercial data practices.
   Give consumers greater control through
    simplified choices and increased
    transparency.
   Implementing will enhance trust and
    stimulate commerce.




                                             11
   Intended to articulate best practices for
    companies.

   Intended to assist Congress as it considers
    privacy legislation.

   Not intended to serve as a template for law
    enforcement action or regulations.




                                                  12
   “Bake-in” privacy -- Companies should
    promote consumer privacy throughout their
    organizations.

   Companies should incorporate substantial
    privacy protections into their practices, such
    as data security, reasonable collection limits,
    sound retention and disposal, and data
    accuracy.



                                                      13
   Limit collection to data they need for a
    requested service or transaction.
    ◦ Ex. Wallpaper app doesn’t need location.
    ◦ Location data collection heightens need for
      reasonable policies for purging data.
    ◦ Minimize the risk that information could be used in
      harmful or unexpected ways.
   Calls on mobile entities to establish
    standards that address data collection,
    transfer, use and disposal, particularly for
    location data.

                                                            14
   If data is shared with third parties, work to
    provide more prominent notice and choices
    about such practices.

   Not all companies have adequately disclosed
    the frequency or extent of the collection,
    transfer, and use of data.




                                                    15
   Provide easy-to-use choice mechanisms that allow consumers to
    control whether their data is collected and how it is used.

   Companies do not need to provide choice for practices that are
    consistent with the context.
    ◦ Fraud preventions, internal operations, fulfillment, legal compliances and
      public purpose, and first-party marketing.

   For practices requiring choice, companies should offer the choice
    at a time and in a context in which the consumer is making a
    decision about his or her data.

   Companies should obtain affirmative express consent before:
    ◦ 1) using consumer data in a materially different manner than claimed or
    ◦ 2) collecting sensitive data.




                                                                                   16
   Increase the transparency of data practices.

   Privacy notices should be clearer, shorter, and more
    standardized to enable comprehension and
    comparison.

   Calls on mobile participants to develop short
    meaningful disclosures.

    ◦ Urges companies providing mobile services to develop
      standard notices, icons, and other means to communicate
      with consumers in a consistent and clear way.

    ◦ Dot Com Disclosure Workshop – May 30, 2012.



                                                                17
18
   Reviewed kids apps in Apple’s iTunes App Store
    and Google’s Market.
   Looked for disclosures available in the app stores
    or on developers’ websites.
   Very little information disclosed prior to download.
   Recommendation – app stores, developers and
    other ecosystem participants need to improve
    disclosures regarding data practices.




                                                           19
20
21

Mobile Web and Apps World New Orleans Session 10 Patricia Poss Federal Trade Commission

  • 1.
    Patricia Poss Federal TradeCommission The views expressed are those of the speaker and not necessarily those of the FTC or any other person. 1
  • 2.
    Mobile Technology Unit  Law enforcement actions  Policy initiatives 2
  • 3.
    Dedicated staff  Technologist assistance  Testing capabilities 3
  • 4.
    Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act broadly prohibits “unfair or deceptive acts or practices in or affecting commerce.” ◦ Deception  a material representation or omission that is likely to mislead consumers acting reasonably under the circumstances ◦ Unfairness  practices that cause or are likely to cause substantial injury to consumers that are not outweighed by countervailing benefits to consumers or competition and are not reasonably avoidable by consumers.  Flexible law that can be applied to many different situations, entities, and technologies. 4
  • 5.
    W3 Innovations  Frostwire  Google  Facebook  Mobile background screeners - warning letters 5
  • 6.
    Complex ecosystem ◦ Operating system providers ◦ Application developers ◦ Handset manufacturers ◦ Carriers ◦ Ad networks ◦ Service providers 6
  • 7.
    Screen size  Communication channels: texting, mobile web browser, mobile apps  “On the go” nature of use  Personal  Additional hardware capabilities – camera, microphone, gyroscope, compass, etc.  GPS & location features  Easy sharing of user information  Rapidly evolving technology 7
  • 8.
    Who collects what information?  How is it used?  With whom is it shared?  Are consumers being adequately informed?  Do they have a choice? 8
  • 9.
    Issued Final Report, March 2012.  Applies to Mobile environment.  Key elements: Privacy by Design, Simplified Choice, and Greater Transparency. 9
  • 10.
    Collection and use of data is ubiquitous and often invisible.  Consumers lack an understanding of the nature and extent of this collection.  Many consumers are concerned.  Collection and use has led to significant benefits.  Traditional distinctions between personally identifiable and anonymous data are blurred. 10
  • 11.
    Make privacy the “default” setting for commercial data practices.  Give consumers greater control through simplified choices and increased transparency.  Implementing will enhance trust and stimulate commerce. 11
  • 12.
    Intended to articulate best practices for companies.  Intended to assist Congress as it considers privacy legislation.  Not intended to serve as a template for law enforcement action or regulations. 12
  • 13.
    “Bake-in” privacy -- Companies should promote consumer privacy throughout their organizations.  Companies should incorporate substantial privacy protections into their practices, such as data security, reasonable collection limits, sound retention and disposal, and data accuracy. 13
  • 14.
    Limit collection to data they need for a requested service or transaction. ◦ Ex. Wallpaper app doesn’t need location. ◦ Location data collection heightens need for reasonable policies for purging data. ◦ Minimize the risk that information could be used in harmful or unexpected ways.  Calls on mobile entities to establish standards that address data collection, transfer, use and disposal, particularly for location data. 14
  • 15.
    If data is shared with third parties, work to provide more prominent notice and choices about such practices.  Not all companies have adequately disclosed the frequency or extent of the collection, transfer, and use of data. 15
  • 16.
    Provide easy-to-use choice mechanisms that allow consumers to control whether their data is collected and how it is used.  Companies do not need to provide choice for practices that are consistent with the context. ◦ Fraud preventions, internal operations, fulfillment, legal compliances and public purpose, and first-party marketing.  For practices requiring choice, companies should offer the choice at a time and in a context in which the consumer is making a decision about his or her data.  Companies should obtain affirmative express consent before: ◦ 1) using consumer data in a materially different manner than claimed or ◦ 2) collecting sensitive data. 16
  • 17.
    Increase the transparency of data practices.  Privacy notices should be clearer, shorter, and more standardized to enable comprehension and comparison.  Calls on mobile participants to develop short meaningful disclosures. ◦ Urges companies providing mobile services to develop standard notices, icons, and other means to communicate with consumers in a consistent and clear way. ◦ Dot Com Disclosure Workshop – May 30, 2012. 17
  • 18.
  • 19.
    Reviewed kids apps in Apple’s iTunes App Store and Google’s Market.  Looked for disclosures available in the app stores or on developers’ websites.  Very little information disclosed prior to download.  Recommendation – app stores, developers and other ecosystem participants need to improve disclosures regarding data practices. 19
  • 20.
  • 21.