Seven Myths of Spanish
       Conquest




      Theme 5-Part 2
           History 140
        Jessica Jefferson
Seven Myths of Spanish
              Conquest
                  Acknowledgements & Introduction

      How? - Why? - Seven? - Who Says?
The number seven has deep roots with in the
history of the Americas.
•   Mexica origin myth
•   Medieval law code
•   Cibola seven cities of gold



Spain's actions and observations in the
Americas occurred within the context of
their own culture.
•   Bernal Diaz had to compare Tenochtitlan to medieval fantasy
•   “Truth itself has been discredited as a concept relevant to historical
    investigation”
Seven Myths of Spanish
             Conquest
                               Chapter 1
          The myth of Exceptional Men
The story of a “handful of adventurers”
conquering the Americas is not what is
seems.
•   The Spaniards who crossed the
    Atlantic were a part of a larger
    process
•   Columbus’s, Cortes’s, and
    Pizarro’s name fame is mostly
    due to the fact that they were
    the initial discoverers of the
    Americas and it’s major Empires
•   The “great men” concept leaves
    out the accomplishments of the
    natives
•   The famous conquistadores were
    simply performing the already
    routine aspects of Spanish
    conquest
Seven Myths of Spanish
          Conquest
                  Chapter 3
  The myth of the White Conquistador
Africans accompanied the Spanish in their
invasions; equaling or exceeding them in
number. Natives also played a key role.

                    •   Alvarado’s letter to Cortes stated
                        his force comprised 250 Spaniards
                        “and about five to six thousand
                        friendly Indians.”
                    •   The Huejotzincans sought to use the
                        presence of the Spanish to promote
                        their interests and pursue
                        rivalries against Mexica and
                        Tlaxcalans
                    •   Using native allies was standard
                        procedure for Spanish conquests
Seven Myths of Spanish
                Conquest
                                   Chapter 7
                 The myth of Superiority
    Saying the Spanish were superior because
    they conquered is circular reasoning.
•    The Spanish falsely viewed the natives as less than human; as barbarians
•    Mythic and non-mythic reasons are cited to explain Spaniard’s superiority:
           - God’s intervention & Miracles
           - God’s plan to unite the world under a Christian Spanish Monarchy
           - Disease killed the inferior natives
           - Natives had a different cultural approach to war
           - Natives saw conquistadors to be god-like
•    Spanish conquest was a component of the larger process of globalization
Seven Myths of Spanish
              Conquest
                                 Epilogue
           Interpretations of the past
Multiple points of view are recorded for
each of the four stages leading to and
describing Cuauhtémoc's Betrayal
•   Spanish journey into Mactun territory
•   Expedition’s stay in Itzamkanac
•   Discovery of plot
•   Violent denouncement the dawn of Shrove Tuesday
         - The Maya’s description is most devoid of stereotypes
•   The exact truth of the event is masked by the varying accounts


  The myths behind Cuauhtémoc's death and of
the Spanish conquest are metaphors that offer
insight to the motives, methods, and patterns
              of human behavior.

Seven myths of spanish conquest

  • 1.
    Seven Myths ofSpanish Conquest Theme 5-Part 2 History 140 Jessica Jefferson
  • 2.
    Seven Myths ofSpanish Conquest Acknowledgements & Introduction How? - Why? - Seven? - Who Says? The number seven has deep roots with in the history of the Americas. • Mexica origin myth • Medieval law code • Cibola seven cities of gold Spain's actions and observations in the Americas occurred within the context of their own culture. • Bernal Diaz had to compare Tenochtitlan to medieval fantasy • “Truth itself has been discredited as a concept relevant to historical investigation”
  • 3.
    Seven Myths ofSpanish Conquest Chapter 1 The myth of Exceptional Men The story of a “handful of adventurers” conquering the Americas is not what is seems. • The Spaniards who crossed the Atlantic were a part of a larger process • Columbus’s, Cortes’s, and Pizarro’s name fame is mostly due to the fact that they were the initial discoverers of the Americas and it’s major Empires • The “great men” concept leaves out the accomplishments of the natives • The famous conquistadores were simply performing the already routine aspects of Spanish conquest
  • 4.
    Seven Myths ofSpanish Conquest Chapter 3 The myth of the White Conquistador Africans accompanied the Spanish in their invasions; equaling or exceeding them in number. Natives also played a key role. • Alvarado’s letter to Cortes stated his force comprised 250 Spaniards “and about five to six thousand friendly Indians.” • The Huejotzincans sought to use the presence of the Spanish to promote their interests and pursue rivalries against Mexica and Tlaxcalans • Using native allies was standard procedure for Spanish conquests
  • 5.
    Seven Myths ofSpanish Conquest Chapter 7 The myth of Superiority Saying the Spanish were superior because they conquered is circular reasoning. • The Spanish falsely viewed the natives as less than human; as barbarians • Mythic and non-mythic reasons are cited to explain Spaniard’s superiority: - God’s intervention & Miracles - God’s plan to unite the world under a Christian Spanish Monarchy - Disease killed the inferior natives - Natives had a different cultural approach to war - Natives saw conquistadors to be god-like • Spanish conquest was a component of the larger process of globalization
  • 6.
    Seven Myths ofSpanish Conquest Epilogue Interpretations of the past Multiple points of view are recorded for each of the four stages leading to and describing Cuauhtémoc's Betrayal • Spanish journey into Mactun territory • Expedition’s stay in Itzamkanac • Discovery of plot • Violent denouncement the dawn of Shrove Tuesday - The Maya’s description is most devoid of stereotypes • The exact truth of the event is masked by the varying accounts The myths behind Cuauhtémoc's death and of the Spanish conquest are metaphors that offer insight to the motives, methods, and patterns of human behavior.