Sperm DNA
Fragmentation
Dr. Yasmin Magdi Abd-
Elkreem
overview
• Conventionalsemenanalysistestremainsthemostwidelyused
predictorformaleinfertilitydiagnosis.
• basedonthedescriptivemicroscopicevaluationofejaculatesperm,
includingconcentration,motilityandmorphology.
• notdiscriminateeffectivelybetweenthespermoffertileandinfertile
men.
• DNAintegrityassessmenthasbeensuggestedasanindependent
additionalmarkeroffertilitytogivemostconclusiveinformationonthe
spermDNA.
overview
• Spermatogenesis:Complex,diverse,74days
• Spermspronefordisruptionbypotentialtargets.
• Mostsignificant-freeradicals.
• Specieswithunpairedelectrons,highlyreactive.
• AlthoughspermDNAfragmentationdoesnotconstituteamutationinitsown,it
stillisapromutagenicchangeofthemalegenome.
Etiology of sperm DNA damage
• Theterm‘chromatin’referstothemacromolecular complexthatcontainsthe
intranuclearDNA.
• Thestructureofchromatinisstabilizedbyinteractionsbetweenitsmain
compounds,DNAandDNA-bindingproteins.
• Spermcellchromatinischaracterizedbyhighlycondensedstructure.
• CondensationofspermDNAisnecessaryinordertoaccommodatethepaternal
genomeintotherelativelysmallspermcellhead,torepressgeneexpressionduring
spermiogenesisandtoprotectthepaternalgeneticmessage makingitinaccessible
tonucleases ormutagens.
Main etiologies of sperm DNA damage
TesticularcancerAging
EnvironmentaltoxinsObesity
HormonaldisturbancesSmoking
TesticularhyperthermiaVaricocele
Drugs,chemotherapyandradiationInflammation
CryopreservationinARTprogramsFebrileillness
Spinalcordinjury
Etiology of sperm DNA damage
• TheetiologyofspermDNAdamageismostprobablymulti-factorialbut
compromisedchromatinremodeling,oxidativestressandabortiveapoptosisare
commonlydescribedtheories.
• SpermDNAdamagemayarisefromcombinationsofallthreemechanisms.
1. Abnormalchromatinremodeling
2. Oxidativestress
3. Abortiveapoptosis
Abnormal chromatin remodeling
• Deficienciesinrecombinationandchromatinpackagingduringspermiogenesis.
• occurduetodeficientprotaminationorabnormalitiesinprotaminecontent.
1.Duetoabnormalfunctionoftranscriptionalortranslationalregulators
(ageneralabnormalityinspermatogenesis).
2.induceapoptosiswhichcouldexplainthelinkbetweenunderprotaminationand
poorspermqualityininfertilemen(checkpointregulatorsforspermatogenesis).
3.makesspermatozoamorevulnerabletoattackbynucleases,freeradicalsthatcan
causeoxidativestressor(environmental)mutagens.
4.mayalsobecompromisedbyabnormaltopoisomeraseIIactivity (responsiblefor
breakandrepairDNAduringprotamination)
Oxidative stress
• ROSproductionisaphysiologicalphenomenonthatisnormallybalancedbyanti-
oxidants.
• Spermcellshavenodefensemechanism, apartfromthecharacteristictight
packagingoftheDNAandanti-oxidantspresentinseminalplasma.
• DNAfragmentationcanbecausedbyoxidativestress,duetofreeradicals[reactive
oxygenspecies(ROS)].
Abortive apoptosis
• Normalspermatogenesis isadynamicprocessinwhichcellproductionandcell
deatharewellbalanced.
• Cellstobeeliminatedwillenteracascadeofreactionsleadingtoapoptoticcell
death.
• CuttingofspermDNAbyendonucleases isoneoftheearliesteventsinthis
cascade,thatiscompletedbyphagocytosisandeliminationofappropriately
earmarked spermcellsbySertolicells.
• Ifthissystemdoesnotoperateefficientlyandtheprocessisnotcompleted,
damagedcellsmayescapeapoptosis.
DNA damage and infertility
• spermDNAfragmentation(SDF)testscan differentiatefertilefrominfertile
males.
• Theassessment ofDNAintegrityinspermcouldbeanindependentmarkerof
fertility.
• higherlevelsofchromatindamageinmenwithseverespermdefects.
• ThenegativeimpactofhighlevelsofspermDNAdamagenegativelyeffecton
naturalpregnancy.
DNA fragmentation and semen
parameters
• ThereisastrongassociationbetweenthepresenceofnuclearDNAdamage inthe
maturespermatozoaofmenandpoorsemenparameters.
• spermmotility,concentration,andmorphologyhadsignificantpositive
correlationswithnon-apoptoticandDNAnon-fragmented sperm.
• Theapplicationofthesefindingsinclinicalpracticecanultimatelyincrease
implantationandpregnancyratesinpatientswhereICSIisthetreatmentof
choice.
Ourdataconclusivelyshowedanegativecorrelationbetweendegreeof
DNAfragmentationandmorphologyofsperminnativesemen
samples.
DNA damage and ART
• ThestructureofspermatozoaDNAisveryunique,highlyspecializedinorderto
controltime-appropriatematurationofthezygote.
• DamagetospermDNAmayoccurasaresultof uniormulti-factors.Thisdamage
therebymayhavenegativeeffectsonARTprocedures,andcouldleadtofailureof
fertilization.
• SpermDNAdamagesignificantlycontributestothegrowingnumberofinfertility
cases,andshouldbeapartofamodernandrologylab.
Assays to quantify sperm DNA damage
• Differentmethodsmaybeusedtoevaluatethestatusofthespermchromatinforthepresenceof
abnormalitiesorsimplyimmaturity
• stainingtechniques: acidicanilineblue(AAB)andtoluidineblue(TB)stains,
• fluorescentstainingtechniques:spermchromatindispersion(SCD)test,chromomycinA3
(CMA3),DNAbreakagedetection–fluorescentinsituhybridizationassay(DBD–FISH),insitu
nicktranslation(NT),andflowcytometricbasedspermchromatinstructureassay(SCSA).
• Someassaysemploymorethanonemethodfortheanalysisoftheirresults.: acridine orange(AO)
andterminaldeoxynucleotidyltransferase-mediatedfluorescein-deoxyuridinetriphosphate-
nickendlabeling(TUNEL)assays.
• Methodslessfrequentlyused:high-performanceliquidchromatography(HPLC).
1. Acidic aniline blue (AAB) stain
Principle:
• TheAABstaindiscriminatesbetweenlysine-richhistonesandarginine/cysteine-rich
protamines.
• Thistechniqueprovidesaspecificpositivereactionforlysineandrevealsdifferencesinthebasic
nuclearproteincompositionofejaculatedhumanspermatozoa.
• Histone-richnucleiofimmaturespermatozoaarerichinlysineandwillconsequently
• takeupthebluestain.
• Ontheotherhand,protaminerichnucleiofmaturespermatozoaarerichinarginine and
cysteineandcontainrelativelylowlevelsoflysine,whichmeanstheywillnotbestainedby
aniline blue.
Technique:
I. Slidesarepreparedbysmearing5μlofeitherraworwashedsemensample.Theslidesareair-
driedandfixedfor30minutesin3%glutaraldehydeinphosphate-bufferedsaline(PBS).
II. Thesmearisdriedandstainedfor5minutesin5%aqueousaniline bluesolution(pH3.5).
III. Spermheadscontaining immaturenuclearchromatinstainblue,andthosewithmature
nucleidonottakeupthestain.
IV. Thepercentageofspermatozoastainedwithaniline blueisdeterminedbycounting200
spermatozoaperslideunderbrightfieldmicroscopy.
1. Acidic aniline blue (AAB) stain
1. Acidic aniline blue (AAB) stain
Clinicalsignificance:
• aclearassociationbetweenabnormalspermchromatinendmaleinfertility.
• Thecorrelationbetweenthepercentageofaniline blue-stainedspermatozoaandothersperm
parametersremainscontroversial.
• GoodpredictorforIVF.
• Itcannotdeterminethefertilizationpotentialandthecleavageandpregnancyratesfollowing
ICSI.
Advantagesandlimitations:
• simpleandinexpensive
• ordinarymicroscope
2. Sperm chromatin dispersion test
Principle:
• TheSCDtestisbasedontheprinciplethatwhenspermaretreatedwithanacidsolutionpriorto
lysisbuffer,theDNAdispersionhalosthatareobservedinspermnucleiwithnonfragmented
DNAaftertheremovalofnuclearproteinsareeitherminimallypresentornotproducedatallin
spermnucleiwithfragmentedDNA.
Technique:
• Thespermatozoaareimmersedinameltedagarosematrixat37°C.Onaslide,adropof8ulof
mixedspermagaroseinitiallytreatedwithanacidsolution(solution1)for7mintodenaturethe
DNAwithDNAbreaks,anddirectlytreatedwithlysingsolution(solution2)for20minto
deproteinizethenucleoids.
• Afterremovalofnuclearproteins,fixationwasdoneusingethanolandthenslidewasstained
usingsolution3for6minutesandsolution4for7minutes.
• Non-fragmentedspermDNAappearswithacoreandwithaperipheralhaloofdispersionof
DNAloops.FragmentedspermDNAappearswithverysmallornohaloofDNAdispersion.
2. Sperm chromatin dispersion test
Advantagesandlimitations:
• Itdoesnotrequirethedeterminationofcolororfluorescenceintensity.
• Simple,fast,andreproducible,anditsresultsarecomparabletothoseoftheSCSA.
• littleisknownaboutitslimitationsanditsclinicalsignificance.
2. Sperm chromatin dispersion test
Conclusion
• Spermchromatinassessmentisanindependentmeasureofspermqualitythatprovidesbetter
diagnosticandprognosticcapabilitiesthanstandardspermparametersformalefertility
potential(idiopathicinfertility).
• Therearemultipleassaysthatmaybeusedforevaluationofthespermchromatinstatus.
• Mostoftheseassayshavemanyadvantagesaswellaslimitations.Thechoiceofwhichassayto
beperformeddependsonmanyfactors.
• Theestablishmentofacutoffpointbetweennormallevelsintheaveragefertilepopulationand
theminimallevelsofspermDNAintegrityrequiredforachievingpregnancystillemainstobe
investigated.ExceptfortheSCSA.
References
• GardnerDK,WeissmanA,HowlesCM,ShohamZ.TextbookofAssistedReproductive
Techniques.3rded.Vol.1.In:AgarwalA,ErenpreissJ,SharmaR. Spermchromatinassessment.
UnitedKingdom:Informahealthcare,2009:67-84.
• AspinderSinghandAshokAgarwalTheRoleofSpermChromatinIntegrityandDNADamageon
MaleInfertilityTheOpenReproductiveScienceJournal,2011,3,65-71.
• A.AgarwalandTamerM.Said.RoleofspermchromatinabnormalitiesandDNAdamageinmale
infertility.HumanReproductionUpdate,Vol.9,No.4pp.331±345,2003
Thank
You !For contact:
E-mail: Yas.magdi@hotmail.com

Sperm DNA fragmentation

Editor's Notes

  • #5 Condensation of sperm DNA takes place during the final stage of spermatogenesis, along with a remodelling of the nucleus and the loss of most of the sperm cells cytoplasm. Condensation is achieved by the sequential displacement of histones by transition proteins and then by protamines. Protamines are smaller than histones and have extremely strong DNA binding capacity. Further condensation and stabilization of sperm chromatin is obtained by the formation of disulfide cross-links between cysteines abundantly present in protamines. This final stage of chromatin organization takes place in the epididymis
  • #8 Lower amount of protamines and abnormal protamine content will negatively affect sperm nuclear compaction. During spermatogenesis a complex and dynamic process of proliferation and differentiation occurs as spermatogonia are transformed into spermatozoa. This process involves a series of meioses and mitoses, changes in cytoplasmic architecture, replacement of histones with protamines (protamination) leading to a highly packed chromatin. During protamination nicks are created to provide relief of torsional stress and aid chromatin rearrangements. These nicks disappear completely at the time when chromatin packaging is Completed. McPherson and Longo (1992) hypothesized that chromatin packaging requires an endogenous nuclease, topoisomerase II, to create and ligatenicks in order to facilitate protamination. In accordance with this hypothesis, it has recently been shown that topoisomerase II plays a major role in linking DNA replication to chromosome condensation and that it interplays with a large protein complex i.e. condensation, which has key functions in mitotic chromosome assembly and organization. In addition, it has also been shown that topoisomerase II is present in the human seminiferous tubules which are the location of spermatogenesis.
  • #9 Sperm DNA Organization. Spermatozoa DNA is organized into three main domains: the majority of the sperm DNA is coiled into DNAse-insensitive toroids that are stacked side to side to maximize compaction. This toroid structure is held stable due to the presence of protamines which neutralize the repulsion between the phosodiester backbones. A smaller amount of DNA is associated with histones present in the spermatozoa, with the remaining DNA attached to the nuclear matrix at Matrix Attachment Regions.
  • #10 Sperm cells are especially vulnerable for this type of damage, since they have no defence mechanism, apart from the characteristic tight packaging of the DNA and anti-oxidants present in seminal plasma.
  • #11 The second hypothesis on the origins of DNA fragmentation in ejaculated spermatozoa describes oxidative stress as the underlying factor for sperm DNA damage. Whilst Barrosso and co-workers (2000) correlated sperm DNA fragmentation with the endogenous generation of ROS, other studies showed correlations with the endogenous generation as well as exogenous stimulus of ROS. In addition to sperm DNA fragmentation, oxidative stress has been implicated in impaired sperm functional competence, including poor fertilization rates in IVF. Reactive oxygen species (ROS) cause peroxidative damage to the plasma membrane, furthermore, ROS are also known to attack DNA, inducing strand breaks and other oxidative based damage in human spermatozoa. DNA damage of mammalian spermatozoa, induced by free radicals, has also been associated with antioxidant depletion in the seminal plasma, presence of transition metals in the sperm culture medium, leukocyte contamination, redox cycling xenobiotics and testicular heating
  • #15 Thus, it is important to select morphologically normal sperm by an operator (ICSI) to significantly reduce the risk of injecting sperm with fragmented DNA into the oocyte.