Dr. Vijay Narayanan 
MBBS MD MA MPhil PG Dip Pall .care 
Clinical Director, Cancer Care Kenya
What is Stigma? 
“A mark of disgrace associated with a 
particular circumstance, quality, or 
person“. (Oxford dictionary)
Who is a stigmatized 
person? 
 A stigmatized person is a person whose social identity, or 
membership in some social category calls into question his or her 
full humanity-the person is devalued, spoiled or flawed in the 
eyes of others .Crocker, Major and Steele (1998) 
 Stigma will lead to ‘Negative evaluation’ 
 Negative evaluations may be “felt” or“ enacted”. 
 A felt negative evaluation is internalised and may lead to shame 
or guilt associated with having a condition and to the fear of 
being discriminated against on the grounds of social 
unacceptability because of that condition. 
 An enacted negative evaluation refers to actual discrimination.
Types of stigma 
An abomination of body Blemishes of individual 
moral character Tribal stigma
Elements of stigma 
 The problem of Knowledge – ignorance 
 The problem of Attitudes – prejudice 
 The problem of Behaviour - discrimination
Consequence of stigma 
Stigma / fear of being stigmatised can result in 
people with cancer not getting help and having 
reduced self-esteem or confidence. 
They can become socially isolated and excluded from 
society – none of which helps them cope with their 
illness or recover.
Cancer and Stigma 
 The word ‘cancer’ was once considered 
unacceptable in the public sphere, and even 
today, euphemisms such as ‘the Big C’ are 
common. 
 Polls in the US and Europe find that at least half 
the population say they fear cancer more than 
any other disease. 
 Around a third to a fifth say they fear cancer 
more than other potential catastrophes, such as 
violent crime, debt, and losing a job
What others do : 
OCTOBREAST PINK RIBBON 
 Breast cancer awareness month- 
BCAM 
 BCAM- is an annual international 
health campaign 
 BCAM-organized by major 
breast cancer charities every 
October 
 BCAM- helps to increase 
awareness of the disease and to 
raise funds for research into its 
cause, prevention, diagnosis, 
treatment and cure.
What others do: 
Movember movement www.movember.com 
 The goal of Movember is to "change the 
face of men's health- esp. Prostate 
cancer, Testicular cancer 
 Movember challenges men to grow a 
moustache for the 30-days of November, 
thereby changing their appearance and 
the face of men’s health. 
 In October Mo Bros sign up at 
movember.com, and on the 1st November 
start their moustache growing journey 
with a clean shaven face.
What others do : 
BEATING BOWEL CANCER 
DECEMBEARD 
 BBC –extends support to patients living with 
bowel 
 BBC-provides a dedicated nurse helpline 
 BBC –gives free informational material for 
patients in hospital at different stages of 
their diagnosis and disease
What others do :www.baldcartoons.com 
 ‘Bald cartoon movement’ 
 Started in Brazil 
 Started to help children 
with cancer with their 
experience of undergoing 
chemotherapy and losing 
their hair. 
 The campaign centres on 
well-known cartoons from 
around the world that have 
been redrawn without any 
hair 
 The idea that “a child with 
cancer deserves to be seen 
just like any other child 
Cancer in childhood:
Cancer ribbons
How to stamp out Stigma: Few 
suggestions 
Health care professional Patient 
 Reduce stigma to yourself 
 Share with those you trust 
 Read about others 
www.livestrong.org 
 Diagnosis and disclosure 
 Information needs 
 Support 
 Raising awareness 
 Expose frauds- Jicho Pevu
Oncology health care professionals’ attitudes to cancer: 
a professional concern 
 Regardless of gender, profession and clinical 
experience, all health care professionals display 
persistently negative attitudes towards cancer. 
 Need for radical change in the attitude of health 
care professionals towards cancer -to provide 
optimal care for this clinical population. 
 Changing these attitudes presents oncology 
health care professionals with a challenge that 
can no longer be ignored. 
N Kerney, M Miller et al, Annals of Oncology 14: 57–61, 2003
Challenges 
 Political harassment 
 Health care discrimination 
 Poor welfare systems 
 Banalization of sufferings 
 Wearing down of families 
 Gender inequality 
 Human rights violation 
 Donor/media discrimination 
 Lack of knowledge, research and hope.
It is our responsibility to 
stamp out STIGMA of cancer 
“Be the change that you wish to see in the 
world” 
Mahatma Gandhi

Stamp out stigma in kenya by vijay narayanan

  • 1.
    Dr. Vijay Narayanan MBBS MD MA MPhil PG Dip Pall .care Clinical Director, Cancer Care Kenya
  • 2.
    What is Stigma? “A mark of disgrace associated with a particular circumstance, quality, or person“. (Oxford dictionary)
  • 3.
    Who is astigmatized person?  A stigmatized person is a person whose social identity, or membership in some social category calls into question his or her full humanity-the person is devalued, spoiled or flawed in the eyes of others .Crocker, Major and Steele (1998)  Stigma will lead to ‘Negative evaluation’  Negative evaluations may be “felt” or“ enacted”.  A felt negative evaluation is internalised and may lead to shame or guilt associated with having a condition and to the fear of being discriminated against on the grounds of social unacceptability because of that condition.  An enacted negative evaluation refers to actual discrimination.
  • 4.
    Types of stigma An abomination of body Blemishes of individual moral character Tribal stigma
  • 5.
    Elements of stigma  The problem of Knowledge – ignorance  The problem of Attitudes – prejudice  The problem of Behaviour - discrimination
  • 6.
    Consequence of stigma Stigma / fear of being stigmatised can result in people with cancer not getting help and having reduced self-esteem or confidence. They can become socially isolated and excluded from society – none of which helps them cope with their illness or recover.
  • 7.
    Cancer and Stigma  The word ‘cancer’ was once considered unacceptable in the public sphere, and even today, euphemisms such as ‘the Big C’ are common.  Polls in the US and Europe find that at least half the population say they fear cancer more than any other disease.  Around a third to a fifth say they fear cancer more than other potential catastrophes, such as violent crime, debt, and losing a job
  • 8.
    What others do: OCTOBREAST PINK RIBBON  Breast cancer awareness month- BCAM  BCAM- is an annual international health campaign  BCAM-organized by major breast cancer charities every October  BCAM- helps to increase awareness of the disease and to raise funds for research into its cause, prevention, diagnosis, treatment and cure.
  • 9.
    What others do: Movember movement www.movember.com  The goal of Movember is to "change the face of men's health- esp. Prostate cancer, Testicular cancer  Movember challenges men to grow a moustache for the 30-days of November, thereby changing their appearance and the face of men’s health.  In October Mo Bros sign up at movember.com, and on the 1st November start their moustache growing journey with a clean shaven face.
  • 10.
    What others do: BEATING BOWEL CANCER DECEMBEARD  BBC –extends support to patients living with bowel  BBC-provides a dedicated nurse helpline  BBC –gives free informational material for patients in hospital at different stages of their diagnosis and disease
  • 11.
    What others do:www.baldcartoons.com  ‘Bald cartoon movement’  Started in Brazil  Started to help children with cancer with their experience of undergoing chemotherapy and losing their hair.  The campaign centres on well-known cartoons from around the world that have been redrawn without any hair  The idea that “a child with cancer deserves to be seen just like any other child Cancer in childhood:
  • 12.
  • 13.
    How to stampout Stigma: Few suggestions Health care professional Patient  Reduce stigma to yourself  Share with those you trust  Read about others www.livestrong.org  Diagnosis and disclosure  Information needs  Support  Raising awareness  Expose frauds- Jicho Pevu
  • 14.
    Oncology health careprofessionals’ attitudes to cancer: a professional concern  Regardless of gender, profession and clinical experience, all health care professionals display persistently negative attitudes towards cancer.  Need for radical change in the attitude of health care professionals towards cancer -to provide optimal care for this clinical population.  Changing these attitudes presents oncology health care professionals with a challenge that can no longer be ignored. N Kerney, M Miller et al, Annals of Oncology 14: 57–61, 2003
  • 15.
    Challenges  Politicalharassment  Health care discrimination  Poor welfare systems  Banalization of sufferings  Wearing down of families  Gender inequality  Human rights violation  Donor/media discrimination  Lack of knowledge, research and hope.
  • 16.
    It is ourresponsibility to stamp out STIGMA of cancer “Be the change that you wish to see in the world” Mahatma Gandhi

Editor's Notes

  • #3 Stigma is a reality for patients with cancer. Patients report that how others judge them is a greatest barrier to a complete and satisfying life with or without cancer. Patients do not seek help for what others may think , families do not seek help for the fears of shame. Because others use negative labels on him or her.
  • #4 I feel am a Eunuch- Felt negative evaluation . He is bound to get it , as he did the sin of Sodom-Enacted negative evaluation. They may feel like lowest of the low. People make them feel like they worth nothing. As a result, they do not like to socialize. Life will become black and white.
  • #5 As given by Goffman in 1963.Black boys are considered antisocial? Nelson Mandela’s son died of HIV, Chris Smith , the cabinet minister declared his Gay status, Diana touched a child with HIV- Stigma holds the people down against their will.
  • #6 Ignorance: Advancements in surgery, radiotherapy, bio chemotherapy etc can cure cancers. Prejudice: My X member of family died, so is me. Her mother died of cancer, she may also get. Quality of cancer care in Kenya? Discrimination: He is a white, so his skin is his enemy. This is a pre-conceived notion that doesn’t have any evidence. Society by and large supports stigmatized beliefs by TRUSTING stigma, without educating themselves.
  • #7 When we judge people, we steal –what makes each of us beautiful, talented and unique. Stigma essentially silences patients. Stigma is wrong about “who they are and who they can be”
  • #8 Oblique reference using index and thumb to show C. In India , at a time, we have 5 million cancer patients, but no Celebes in it! in 2015, 1.2 billion people will be older than 60 years. Active aging, a policy frame work-Kalacke, Gatti et al)
  • #9 BCAM tries to stop stigma, to make patients believe that they are good looking,lovable.
  • #12 Click here
  • #15 Should cancer patient require CCU support? Yes, they might need. Therapeutic nihilism to leave it “to the course of nature” is not acceptable. Permissive ICU/CCU admission policies for cancer patients should be formulated.
  • #16 Political- Budget ,Health care discrimination: prohibitive cost of drugs, Welfare-Obama care, NNPC etc, Detox diets or herbal remedies are prominent. In KNH, a day more than a 1000 rescued or cured, but one or two miracle healing will be published more prominently in news papers.