Termination:
                          Tips and Traps

                                  By Andrew Bland     August 2012
The information in this presentation is general in nature and does not constitute formal legal advice.




                                       www.blandslaw.com.au
 Unfair   Dismissal
 Genuine    Redundancy
 Performance    Management
 Adverse Action

 Discrimination

 Risk   Management
                   www.blandslaw.com.au
 TheFair Work Act 2009 (Cth), section 385,
 provides that a person has been unfairly
 dismissed if:
    The person has been dismissed; and
    The dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable; and
    The dismissal was not consistent with the Small
     Business Fair Dismissal Code; and
    The dismissal was not a case of genuine redundancy.



                      www.blandslaw.com.au
 Harsh, unjust or unreasonable
  • Communication medium (eg text messaging)
  • Support person
  • Right of reply

 Small Business Code
  • Fewer than 15 employees
  • One warning
  • Contrast with three strikes policy (larger
    businesses)

                      www.blandslaw.com.au
 Must relate to a role and not a person
 Must not be related to any performance issues
 Covered by the National Employment Standards (NES)
  – larger businesses
 Redundancy may occur if:
    • the job someone has been doing is replaced due to the employer
        introducing new technology (i.e. it can be done by a machine)
    •   business slows down due to lower sales or production
    •   the business relocates
    •   a merger or takeover happens
    •   the business restructures or reorganises.
   Processes to follow
    • Eg Alternative deployment
    • Applicable payouts – will depend on business size; duration of
        employment etc

                              www.blandslaw.com.au
 Importance   of a rigorous and regular
  performance management regime;
 Being consistent when dealing with
  analogous circumstances;
 Allowing access to a witness or support
  person at any disciplinary meetings;
 Adopting a suitable forum for discussion; and
 Affording the opportunity of a right of reply.
 Note: situations of serious and willful
  misconduct.

                   www.blandslaw.com.au
Definition: Action taken against employees, independent contractors
(and their employees) or prospective employees because the employee
has or exercises a workplace right
   • Note the inclusion of prospective employees.

Some examples of workplace rights:
• An employee’s right to be absent from work during parental leave
• Making, varying or terminating an enterprise agreement
• A complaint under an internal bullying policy.

Reversal of Proof
Increase in number of claims coming before FWA
 FWA quarterly statistics: in the 3 months till June 2012, over 700
  general protections claims.


                            www.blandslaw.com.au
   Discrimination (section 351)
    o Prohibition against adverse action on grounds of race, sex,
      colour, sexual preference, age, disability, marital status,
      family or carer’s responsibilities, pregnancy, religion,
      political opinion, national extraction or social origin.
    o Consider also any applicable state and federal anti-
      discrimination legislation.

   Terminating sick or injured employees
    o If requirements are met, employees may not be dismissed
      for at least three months if on sick leave or workers
      compensation, potentially longer under some State/
      Territory legislation.

                           www.blandslaw.com.au
 What steps can you take to minimise or
 mitigate your risk in termination cases?
  • Importance of a clear and well kept written record
  • Support person/ witness
  • Regular performance reviews
     Consider frequent and informal progress updates
  • Good employment contracts
  • Company policies:
     Cover all salient areas and are cross-referenced
     Regular training around these policies
     Communication to staff


                      www.blandslaw.com.au
   BlandsLaw was established in 2003 and is located in North
    Ryde, NSW.
   Core expertise:
    • Industrial Relations / Employment law

   Additional expertise:
    • All aspects of general commercial law;
    • Social media law.

   For more information, contact:
    Andrew Bland
    Andrew.bland@blandslaw.com.au
    @irlawyeraus
    Ph. (02) 9805 5600

                              www.blandslaw.com.au

Termination Tips and Traps

  • 1.
    Termination: Tips and Traps By Andrew Bland August 2012 The information in this presentation is general in nature and does not constitute formal legal advice. www.blandslaw.com.au
  • 2.
     Unfair Dismissal  Genuine Redundancy  Performance Management  Adverse Action  Discrimination  Risk Management www.blandslaw.com.au
  • 3.
     TheFair WorkAct 2009 (Cth), section 385, provides that a person has been unfairly dismissed if:  The person has been dismissed; and  The dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable; and  The dismissal was not consistent with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code; and  The dismissal was not a case of genuine redundancy. www.blandslaw.com.au
  • 4.
     Harsh, unjustor unreasonable • Communication medium (eg text messaging) • Support person • Right of reply  Small Business Code • Fewer than 15 employees • One warning • Contrast with three strikes policy (larger businesses) www.blandslaw.com.au
  • 5.
     Must relateto a role and not a person  Must not be related to any performance issues  Covered by the National Employment Standards (NES) – larger businesses  Redundancy may occur if: • the job someone has been doing is replaced due to the employer introducing new technology (i.e. it can be done by a machine) • business slows down due to lower sales or production • the business relocates • a merger or takeover happens • the business restructures or reorganises.  Processes to follow • Eg Alternative deployment • Applicable payouts – will depend on business size; duration of employment etc www.blandslaw.com.au
  • 6.
     Importance of a rigorous and regular performance management regime;  Being consistent when dealing with analogous circumstances;  Allowing access to a witness or support person at any disciplinary meetings;  Adopting a suitable forum for discussion; and  Affording the opportunity of a right of reply.  Note: situations of serious and willful misconduct. www.blandslaw.com.au
  • 7.
    Definition: Action takenagainst employees, independent contractors (and their employees) or prospective employees because the employee has or exercises a workplace right • Note the inclusion of prospective employees. Some examples of workplace rights: • An employee’s right to be absent from work during parental leave • Making, varying or terminating an enterprise agreement • A complaint under an internal bullying policy. Reversal of Proof Increase in number of claims coming before FWA  FWA quarterly statistics: in the 3 months till June 2012, over 700 general protections claims. www.blandslaw.com.au
  • 8.
    Discrimination (section 351) o Prohibition against adverse action on grounds of race, sex, colour, sexual preference, age, disability, marital status, family or carer’s responsibilities, pregnancy, religion, political opinion, national extraction or social origin. o Consider also any applicable state and federal anti- discrimination legislation.  Terminating sick or injured employees o If requirements are met, employees may not be dismissed for at least three months if on sick leave or workers compensation, potentially longer under some State/ Territory legislation. www.blandslaw.com.au
  • 9.
     What stepscan you take to minimise or mitigate your risk in termination cases? • Importance of a clear and well kept written record • Support person/ witness • Regular performance reviews  Consider frequent and informal progress updates • Good employment contracts • Company policies:  Cover all salient areas and are cross-referenced  Regular training around these policies  Communication to staff www.blandslaw.com.au
  • 10.
    BlandsLaw was established in 2003 and is located in North Ryde, NSW.  Core expertise: • Industrial Relations / Employment law  Additional expertise: • All aspects of general commercial law; • Social media law.  For more information, contact: Andrew Bland [email protected] @irlawyeraus Ph. (02) 9805 5600 www.blandslaw.com.au