EATC 2015: Composite Thermoforming Calculation
G. CHAMBON, R. TIE BI
October 1rst, 2015
 Company presentation
 What is thermostamping ?
 State of the Art
 Thermostamping constitutive laws
 Characterization / identification
 Validation
 Mapping
 Transfer from process results to performance meshing
 Structural law creation
 Performance simulation : Results & correlation
 Synthesis - Next steps
Agenda
2
 Company presentation
 What is thermostamping ?
 State of the Art
 Thermostamping constitutive laws
 Characterization / identification
 Validation
 Mapping
 Transfer from process results to performance meshing
 Structural law creation
 Performance simulation : Results & correlation
 Synthesis - Next steps
Agenda
3
4
Leader in automotive equipment
* of which €14.1 billion of product sales
34
countries
99,500
employees
330
sites
€18.8
billion of total sales*
6,000
engineers and technicians
30
R&D centers
515
programs in development
505
patents filed in 2014
5
Faurecia Automotive Exteriors
Plastic body parts
Modules
Composite
 Bumpers
 Trims & Rocker Panels
 Outside Body Panels
 A-class
 Semi-Structural
 Structural
€1.7 billion
product sales 2014
8,100
employees
employees
32
production sites
4
R&D centers
9
countries
#1 in Europe for plastic body parts
 Front End Modules
 Front End Carriers
 Engine Cooling Systems
 Company presentation
 What is thermostamping ?
 State of the Art
 Thermostamping constitutive laws
 Characterization / identification
 Validation
 Mapping
 Transfer from process results to performance meshing
 Structural law creation
 Performance simulation : Results & correlation
 Synthesis - Next steps
Agenda
6
7
Continuous Fiber Reinforced Thermoplastic Thermostamping
Composite
What is it ?
CAD of part Sheet of CFRT Heating of CFRT (hoven)
Manufactured part Transfer and Stamping
170 mm
 Company presentation
 What is thermostamping ?
 State of the Art
 Thermostamping constitutive laws
 Characterization / identification
 Validation
 Mapping
 Transfer from process results to performance meshing
 Structural law creation
 Performance simulation : Results & correlation
 Synthesis - Next steps
Agenda
8
State of the art: Based on commercial codes
Codes 
HyperForm one
step
PamForm Catia
Mainproperties
Reverse
engineering
  (grid projection) (grid projection)
Basic strain
calculation
  (only shear)  (only shear)
Locking angle   
- Initial assessment of formability of a component
- Preform and fiber architecture predictions (reduction of raw material waste)
- Highligthing possible forming problems (locking and wrinkage, aspect…)
9
 2 families of codes
1/ Non incremental Codes
State of the art: Based on commercial codes
Codes  Ls-Dyna incremental Radioss incremental
Mainproperties
suitable and complete GUI  
suitable post-analyse and mapping GUI  
suitable multi layers approach  
thermomechanical coupling  
suitable constitituve laws   (less than LS-Dyna)
Die outer
element
Die
Punch
Blank
Binder
 2 families of codes identified according to incremental calculation or not
2/ Incremental Codes
- realistic forming approach with dynamic non-linear explicit codes
- forming pressure modelized w/ contact properties for die & punch
- if necessary, boundary or/and initial conditions modelized
- suitable approach for material laws
10
 Company presentation
 What is thermostamping ?
 State of the Art
 Thermostamping constitutive laws
 Characterization / identification
 Validation
 Mapping
 Transfer from process results to performance meshing
 Structural law creation
 Performance simulation : Results & correlation
 Synthesis - Next steps
Agenda
11
Thermostamping constitutive laws
Radioss: Mat 58 with Prop 16. Fiber behavior
Ls-DYNA Mat 34 (bending effect compared to Mat 234)
12
BIAS Test
Mat 58 (Radioss) and Mat 34 (LS-DYNA) are quit equivalent and realistics
(without thermomechnical effect)
 Radioss / LS-Dyna comparison
X-ray
Calcination
Samples level : Tests performed to identify Behavior of woven
Process simulation at sub-system level
Simple part level : Tests performed to establish simulation procedure
Sub-system level on FAE representative mold
Microscope
FromsamplestoSub-System
Correlation of fiber orientation to improve
representativeness of mechanical simulation
Thermostamping constitutive laws
Building processus
 Multi-layers approach to represent discriminating defects
Left 100 mm Right 25 mm Right 0 mm Right 100 mm
Thermostamping constitutive laws
Results & Correlation
14
Thermostamping constitutive laws
Results & Correlation : Step by step
Production of uncompleted
parts for step by step
correlation with simulation
Shapes and fiber’s
orientation comparison
15
 Company presentation
 What is thermostamping ?
 State of the Art
 Thermostamping constitutive laws
 Characterization / identification
 Validation
 Mapping
 Transfer from process results to performance meshing
 Structural law creation
 Performance simulation : Results & correlation
 Synthesis - Next steps
Agenda
16
Fiber’s orientations post-analyzed and mapped by Hypercrash
Test component
Mapped results
17
Structural law considering non-orthogonal angles
+
UD2
Fabric material
decomposition
in 2 UDs
Qij = f(Eij, ij, (k=1,2)) identified by reverse
Engineering
 ≠90°
18
 Reverse Engineering initialization
 Axial modulus: Qij (UD) = Qij (Fabric)
 Transverse modulus : Qij (UD) = Qij (Matrix)
 Shearing: Qij (UD) = Qij(Fabric)/2
UD1
1 2
 FAE approach
Structural law considering non-orthogonal angles
- Linear elasticity
- Non-linear damage
- Failure
 Elasticity, damage and failure properties of the 2 UDs are re-identified by reverse
Engineering method from specimen and sub-system tests
specimen tests (dynamic tensile,
compression and shear)
sub-system test (dynamic bending)
LS-DYNA material law 58
19
 Company presentation
 What is thermostamping ?
 State of the Art
 Thermostamping constitutive laws
 Characterization / identification
 Validation
 Mapping
 Transfer from process results to performance meshing
 Structural law creation
 Performance simulation : Results & correlation
 Synthesis - Next steps
Agenda
20
Part
Effort
Failure
High stamping
spare wheel box
Structural law
Results & Correlation : Static tests
Good accuracy, including failure representation
Config. FLAT Config. Spare Wheel Box
Structural law
Results & Correlation : Dynamic tests
Trial
Trial
Simulation w/o process consideration
Simulation w process simulation
Important improvement regarding flat conf. confirming process influence
Need to enhance SWB conf. models
 Company presentation
 What is thermostamping ?
 State of the Art
 Thermostamping constitutive laws
 Characterization / identification
 Validation
 Mapping
 Transfer from process results to performance meshing
 Structural law creation
 Performance simulation : Results & correlation
 Synthesis - Next steps
Agenda
23
Synthesis
 Mandatory to consider thermostamping process for performance simulation of
complex parts
 Necessity to use incremental calculation (i-o geometrical) for good accuracy on
singularities (sliding, locking angle, wrinkles …)
 Need to have a good characterization of material (Product & Process)
 Need to simulate individual behavior of each ply stacked (multi-layer or other
approach)
 Simulation tool compatible with daily engineering
Next steps :
Modelization of thermal effect
Coolingvelocity(°C/s)
From 0 to 30 seconds
Air
Contact plate/mold From 30 to 60 seconds
25
 Cooling down velocities depending on time and contact nature
Quick T° drop, with influence on
material behavior, especially in mold
Die
Part of binder
Punch
Blank CFRT
Binder
26
Next steps :
Boundary and initial conditions effect
 Considering frame or any means used for processing material (frame, blank holders…)
Next steps :
software
 Enhanced thickness variation
 Thermomechanical effect (Radioss incremental)
 Fiber density computation (Hyperform)
 Non-orthogonal angles elements for performance simulation
NEXT STEP FAE
Innovative Application : One-Shot Process for composite
Liftgate
:
28
State of the art: Structural parts (non visible)
Innovation: Structural and aspect parts
Overmolded
composite
inserts
CFRT positionning in mold
Infra Red heatingCFRT blanks
Robot handling from hooven to mold,
Draping + injection
Injection over-molding
Gripper: pre-forming
Aspect surface
Challenges:
 Complete overmolding of three composite inserts
 Delivery of a high-quality surface with graining
Visible side
Back side
29
NEXT STEP FAE
Innovative Application : One-Shot Process for composite
Thermostamping simulation for woven thermoplastic composites (PA) with HyperForm

Thermostamping simulation for woven thermoplastic composites (PA) with HyperForm

  • 1.
    EATC 2015: CompositeThermoforming Calculation G. CHAMBON, R. TIE BI October 1rst, 2015
  • 2.
     Company presentation What is thermostamping ?  State of the Art  Thermostamping constitutive laws  Characterization / identification  Validation  Mapping  Transfer from process results to performance meshing  Structural law creation  Performance simulation : Results & correlation  Synthesis - Next steps Agenda 2
  • 3.
     Company presentation What is thermostamping ?  State of the Art  Thermostamping constitutive laws  Characterization / identification  Validation  Mapping  Transfer from process results to performance meshing  Structural law creation  Performance simulation : Results & correlation  Synthesis - Next steps Agenda 3
  • 4.
    4 Leader in automotiveequipment * of which €14.1 billion of product sales 34 countries 99,500 employees 330 sites €18.8 billion of total sales* 6,000 engineers and technicians 30 R&D centers 515 programs in development 505 patents filed in 2014
  • 5.
    5 Faurecia Automotive Exteriors Plasticbody parts Modules Composite  Bumpers  Trims & Rocker Panels  Outside Body Panels  A-class  Semi-Structural  Structural €1.7 billion product sales 2014 8,100 employees employees 32 production sites 4 R&D centers 9 countries #1 in Europe for plastic body parts  Front End Modules  Front End Carriers  Engine Cooling Systems
  • 6.
     Company presentation What is thermostamping ?  State of the Art  Thermostamping constitutive laws  Characterization / identification  Validation  Mapping  Transfer from process results to performance meshing  Structural law creation  Performance simulation : Results & correlation  Synthesis - Next steps Agenda 6
  • 7.
    7 Continuous Fiber ReinforcedThermoplastic Thermostamping Composite What is it ? CAD of part Sheet of CFRT Heating of CFRT (hoven) Manufactured part Transfer and Stamping 170 mm
  • 8.
     Company presentation What is thermostamping ?  State of the Art  Thermostamping constitutive laws  Characterization / identification  Validation  Mapping  Transfer from process results to performance meshing  Structural law creation  Performance simulation : Results & correlation  Synthesis - Next steps Agenda 8
  • 9.
    State of theart: Based on commercial codes Codes  HyperForm one step PamForm Catia Mainproperties Reverse engineering   (grid projection) (grid projection) Basic strain calculation   (only shear)  (only shear) Locking angle    - Initial assessment of formability of a component - Preform and fiber architecture predictions (reduction of raw material waste) - Highligthing possible forming problems (locking and wrinkage, aspect…) 9  2 families of codes 1/ Non incremental Codes
  • 10.
    State of theart: Based on commercial codes Codes  Ls-Dyna incremental Radioss incremental Mainproperties suitable and complete GUI   suitable post-analyse and mapping GUI   suitable multi layers approach   thermomechanical coupling   suitable constitituve laws   (less than LS-Dyna) Die outer element Die Punch Blank Binder  2 families of codes identified according to incremental calculation or not 2/ Incremental Codes - realistic forming approach with dynamic non-linear explicit codes - forming pressure modelized w/ contact properties for die & punch - if necessary, boundary or/and initial conditions modelized - suitable approach for material laws 10
  • 11.
     Company presentation What is thermostamping ?  State of the Art  Thermostamping constitutive laws  Characterization / identification  Validation  Mapping  Transfer from process results to performance meshing  Structural law creation  Performance simulation : Results & correlation  Synthesis - Next steps Agenda 11
  • 12.
    Thermostamping constitutive laws Radioss:Mat 58 with Prop 16. Fiber behavior Ls-DYNA Mat 34 (bending effect compared to Mat 234) 12 BIAS Test Mat 58 (Radioss) and Mat 34 (LS-DYNA) are quit equivalent and realistics (without thermomechnical effect)  Radioss / LS-Dyna comparison
  • 13.
    X-ray Calcination Samples level :Tests performed to identify Behavior of woven Process simulation at sub-system level Simple part level : Tests performed to establish simulation procedure Sub-system level on FAE representative mold Microscope FromsamplestoSub-System Correlation of fiber orientation to improve representativeness of mechanical simulation Thermostamping constitutive laws Building processus
  • 14.
     Multi-layers approachto represent discriminating defects Left 100 mm Right 25 mm Right 0 mm Right 100 mm Thermostamping constitutive laws Results & Correlation 14
  • 15.
    Thermostamping constitutive laws Results& Correlation : Step by step Production of uncompleted parts for step by step correlation with simulation Shapes and fiber’s orientation comparison 15
  • 16.
     Company presentation What is thermostamping ?  State of the Art  Thermostamping constitutive laws  Characterization / identification  Validation  Mapping  Transfer from process results to performance meshing  Structural law creation  Performance simulation : Results & correlation  Synthesis - Next steps Agenda 16
  • 17.
    Fiber’s orientations post-analyzedand mapped by Hypercrash Test component Mapped results 17
  • 18.
    Structural law consideringnon-orthogonal angles + UD2 Fabric material decomposition in 2 UDs Qij = f(Eij, ij, (k=1,2)) identified by reverse Engineering  ≠90° 18  Reverse Engineering initialization  Axial modulus: Qij (UD) = Qij (Fabric)  Transverse modulus : Qij (UD) = Qij (Matrix)  Shearing: Qij (UD) = Qij(Fabric)/2 UD1 1 2  FAE approach
  • 19.
    Structural law consideringnon-orthogonal angles - Linear elasticity - Non-linear damage - Failure  Elasticity, damage and failure properties of the 2 UDs are re-identified by reverse Engineering method from specimen and sub-system tests specimen tests (dynamic tensile, compression and shear) sub-system test (dynamic bending) LS-DYNA material law 58 19
  • 20.
     Company presentation What is thermostamping ?  State of the Art  Thermostamping constitutive laws  Characterization / identification  Validation  Mapping  Transfer from process results to performance meshing  Structural law creation  Performance simulation : Results & correlation  Synthesis - Next steps Agenda 20
  • 21.
    Part Effort Failure High stamping spare wheelbox Structural law Results & Correlation : Static tests Good accuracy, including failure representation
  • 22.
    Config. FLAT Config.Spare Wheel Box Structural law Results & Correlation : Dynamic tests Trial Trial Simulation w/o process consideration Simulation w process simulation Important improvement regarding flat conf. confirming process influence Need to enhance SWB conf. models
  • 23.
     Company presentation What is thermostamping ?  State of the Art  Thermostamping constitutive laws  Characterization / identification  Validation  Mapping  Transfer from process results to performance meshing  Structural law creation  Performance simulation : Results & correlation  Synthesis - Next steps Agenda 23
  • 24.
    Synthesis  Mandatory toconsider thermostamping process for performance simulation of complex parts  Necessity to use incremental calculation (i-o geometrical) for good accuracy on singularities (sliding, locking angle, wrinkles …)  Need to have a good characterization of material (Product & Process)  Need to simulate individual behavior of each ply stacked (multi-layer or other approach)  Simulation tool compatible with daily engineering
  • 25.
    Next steps : Modelizationof thermal effect Coolingvelocity(°C/s) From 0 to 30 seconds Air Contact plate/mold From 30 to 60 seconds 25  Cooling down velocities depending on time and contact nature Quick T° drop, with influence on material behavior, especially in mold
  • 26.
    Die Part of binder Punch BlankCFRT Binder 26 Next steps : Boundary and initial conditions effect  Considering frame or any means used for processing material (frame, blank holders…)
  • 27.
    Next steps : software Enhanced thickness variation  Thermomechanical effect (Radioss incremental)  Fiber density computation (Hyperform)  Non-orthogonal angles elements for performance simulation
  • 28.
    NEXT STEP FAE InnovativeApplication : One-Shot Process for composite Liftgate : 28 State of the art: Structural parts (non visible) Innovation: Structural and aspect parts Overmolded composite inserts CFRT positionning in mold Infra Red heatingCFRT blanks Robot handling from hooven to mold, Draping + injection Injection over-molding Gripper: pre-forming Aspect surface Challenges:  Complete overmolding of three composite inserts  Delivery of a high-quality surface with graining Visible side Back side
  • 29.
    29 NEXT STEP FAE InnovativeApplication : One-Shot Process for composite