Top 5 Risks For Employers In Labor-Employment LawPresented by Mr. Benjamin H. BantaAugust 25, 2010
IntroductionTop 5 RisksExpanded ADA
Wage-Hour Laws
Retaliation
State Laws You Don’t Know About
PrivacyExpanded ADAMuch easier for employee to show “disability”Not an “extensive analysis”Expanded list of “major life activities”“Substantially limited” term is diluted
Expanded ADA (cont.)Result:  	more disabled employeesResult:  	more accommodations to 			consider or makeResult:  	more ADA charges and lawsuitsResult:  	decreased summary judgment 				chances
Wage-Hour LawsMeal breaks“Off the clock” workMisclassifying workers as exemptRuining “salary basis” requirement
RetaliationAlleged in 36% of all charges in EEOC’s FY 2009Alleged in 15% of all charges in EEOC’s FY 1992Virtually all aspects of job may become an issueWhite standard: “materially adverse action or conduct”“could well dissuade a reasonable worker from making . . . charge”
State Laws You Don’t Know AboutFirearm possessionFines against workersNon-competition provisions you’re not complying withJury duty (pay/discharge)Voting leave
State Laws You Don’t Know About(cont.)SmokingAccess to personnel recordsWARN-type statutesBreastfeeding timeWhat else?
Privacy IssuesEvolutionSearches on employer premises or parking lotVideo surveillanceE-mails and Internet usageGPS trackingPlanting chips in employees
Privacy IssuesCase2010 Supreme Court case involving public employerCity of Ontario, Calif. v. Quon (No. 08-1332)
Privacy IssuesFactsEmployees exceed character limits on text messages (pager)Employer investigates; many messages not work-relatedSome text messages are sexually explicitEmployee disciplinedEmployee sues for violation of privacy rights
Privacy IssuesLegal AnalysisReview of text messages on pager was reasonableLegitimate interest in, and reason for, the search (work-related)Search not excessive in scope or “excessively intrusive”Employee had only limited privacy expectationLessened risk of intrusion on highly private details of personal life
Privacy Issues“To Do”Have an explicit policy in placeWork with HR, IT, Legal on policyUpdate it annually, keeping up with technology and your equipmentState business need/interestRight (not a duty) to monitor/inspect at will

Top 5 Labor/Employment Law Risks for a Company in 2010

  • 1.
    Top 5 RisksFor Employers In Labor-Employment LawPresented by Mr. Benjamin H. BantaAugust 25, 2010
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
    State Laws YouDon’t Know About
  • 6.
    PrivacyExpanded ADAMuch easierfor employee to show “disability”Not an “extensive analysis”Expanded list of “major life activities”“Substantially limited” term is diluted
  • 7.
    Expanded ADA (cont.)Result: more disabled employeesResult: more accommodations to consider or makeResult: more ADA charges and lawsuitsResult: decreased summary judgment chances
  • 8.
    Wage-Hour LawsMeal breaks“Offthe clock” workMisclassifying workers as exemptRuining “salary basis” requirement
  • 9.
    RetaliationAlleged in 36%of all charges in EEOC’s FY 2009Alleged in 15% of all charges in EEOC’s FY 1992Virtually all aspects of job may become an issueWhite standard: “materially adverse action or conduct”“could well dissuade a reasonable worker from making . . . charge”
  • 10.
    State Laws YouDon’t Know AboutFirearm possessionFines against workersNon-competition provisions you’re not complying withJury duty (pay/discharge)Voting leave
  • 11.
    State Laws YouDon’t Know About(cont.)SmokingAccess to personnel recordsWARN-type statutesBreastfeeding timeWhat else?
  • 12.
    Privacy IssuesEvolutionSearches onemployer premises or parking lotVideo surveillanceE-mails and Internet usageGPS trackingPlanting chips in employees
  • 13.
    Privacy IssuesCase2010 SupremeCourt case involving public employerCity of Ontario, Calif. v. Quon (No. 08-1332)
  • 14.
    Privacy IssuesFactsEmployees exceedcharacter limits on text messages (pager)Employer investigates; many messages not work-relatedSome text messages are sexually explicitEmployee disciplinedEmployee sues for violation of privacy rights
  • 15.
    Privacy IssuesLegal AnalysisReviewof text messages on pager was reasonableLegitimate interest in, and reason for, the search (work-related)Search not excessive in scope or “excessively intrusive”Employee had only limited privacy expectationLessened risk of intrusion on highly private details of personal life
  • 16.
    Privacy Issues“To Do”Havean explicit policy in placeWork with HR, IT, Legal on policyUpdate it annually, keeping up with technology and your equipmentState business need/interestRight (not a duty) to monitor/inspect at will
  • 17.
    Privacy Issues“To Do”(cont.)Address social media?Create no expectation of privacyHave employees acknowledge receipt annually (consent)If inspecting, start small and narrow with searchBe consistent and reasonable; how would you feel?
  • 18.
    Privacy IssuesPossible ClaimsInvasionof privacy (state law)Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA)Stored Communications Act (SCA)Electronic Communications Privacy Act (ECPA)Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA)Traditional labor (NLRA), employment (Title VII), tort laws (defamation)
  • 19.
    Privacy IssuesThink AboutMixed-use(work and personal) Blackberries or laptopsEmployer reimburses only fraction of monthly billGetting into personal e-mail accounts or the likeNexus to job performanceConsistent enforcementKnowing too much