Downloaded 36 times
More Related Content
Similar to U5 a1 stages in the decision making process
U5 a1 stages in the decision making process
- 1. Unit 5 DataModelling A1 STAGES IN THE DECISION-MAKING PROCESS 1
- 2. This section covers: 1. Understanding the scenario. 2. Identifying information and sources. 3. Factors affecting the quality of information. 4. Analysing the information. 5. Identifying alternatives. 6. Identifying consequences of implementing the alternatives. 7. Making a decision. 8. Justifying the decision. 9. Communicating decision(s) to others 2
- 3. Understanding the scenario. Ascenario describes a situation where a problem exists that needs to be addressed. It will include some details on the problem, a required solution and a time frame. Most scenarios are incomplete. This may not be deliberate, but due to a lack of information, or a lack of clarity on the required solution. A key skill in developing a solution is Systems Analysis. This can be summarised as: Identifying what is currently done How the task is currently done What the problem is What is the proposed logical solution What is the proposed physical solution 3
- 4. Identifying information andsources. Information required Information that is already available Additional information needed Sources of additional information Requirements for verifying the information sources. 4
- 5. Factors affecting thequality of information. Currency - time sensitivity of the data On August 1st 2021 the price of Gold was £1306.08 per oz. On July 1st 2021 the price of Gold was £1296.27 per oz On June 1st 2021 the price of Gold was £1348.96 per oz This asset price is governed by pure supply and demand (excluding speculation). Consider the implication of buying and selling items at different prices if you use the wrong purchase and sale price figures. 5
- 6. Factors affecting thequality of information. Accuracy 1) Accuracy relates to the difference between the data used and the actual data. If the data used is 14, 18, 23 and the real data is 11, 15, 20 the data being used is inaccurate. In this example it is consistently inaccurate, all values are 3 more than they should be. If we look at data being used as 7.2, 12, 14.4 when the real data is 6, 10, 12 the data is consistently inaccurate by 20% over actual. These 2 cases can be rectified mathematically by reversing the discrepancy. If the values are different by a varying margin, this is unable to be rectified. 6
- 7. Factors affecting thequality of information. Accuracy 2) Precision is how “precise” the data is – the number of significant digits. As an example a tray of 24 tins is purchased for £37.50 which gives a price per can of £1.5625. If we use a mark-up of 20% the selling price per tin is £1.875. Precise, (and accurate), but of no real-world use. Scientific notation, e.g. 2.563 *10^6 is really 2563000 are the last 3 digits really all 0? This can result in approximation, but on certain values this is acceptable. 7
- 8. Factors affecting thequality of information. External factors SWOT analysis. Strengths and Weaknesses are internal, you can control. Opportunities and Threats are external, you have no control. Consider each of the following and how they can have an impact: Government changes a rate of tax (NI, VAT, Income Tax) You import/export goods and are unable to do so (9/11 grounded all flights for an extended period, the current Pandemic) Exchange rates move up/down Asset values change due to changes in demand. Health and Safety legislation changes 8
- 9. Analysing the data. Data is the values in the spreadsheet, Information has context. Looking at the data in context: What can we see at the current time? What trends are there ? Can we identify e.g. the good and weak sales and is there a reason? Is it best displayed as numbers, or graphically? Does statistical analysis show anything 9
- 10. Identifying alternatives. Inprogramming we have different PARADIGMS Object oriented, Structures, visual etc Each results in a different approach to the task. What different alternatives are there in spreadsheets Organisation of the spreadsheet “efficiency” of calculations Data entry by “keyboard”, dropdown or slider. Internal/External access to data Each different point you consider could generate an alternative 10
- 11. Identifying consequences of implementingthe alternatives. Each alternative will have its own benefits and drawbacks This is about identifying the differences of each alternative You must compare like to like, so the list of points is the same What is the degree of difference Is 2 days significant on a 6 month contract? Is £150 significant on a £5000 contract Each point could have a variance – difference from that of the others Here you are only identifying the consequences 11
- 12. Making a decision. Decisions have to be based on justification of a number of points. What are the key points, How do they apply to each alternative How do you “score” them to identify the best to worst. Consider how I could put each of you in order of “best” to “worst” 12
- 13. Making/Justifying the decision. The decision you make could be challenged – WHY do this? What data are you working with What options were considered? For each option what were the characteristics you considered How were these weighted How did you come up with the weightings What was the ranking of “best” to “worst” If yours isn’t “best” Why 13
- 14. Assessment note GENERALLY Gatheringthe data and explaining it equates to PASS criteria Comparing or Analysing data equates to Merit criteria Evaluation of options and justification equates to Distinction criteria 14
- 15. Communicating decision(s) toothers It is unusual for you to be the sole member of the team Your colleagues need to know what is happening Plans for all to follow Understanding of individual roles and deadlines You work with a team leader who holds responsibility Needs to know what is going on, and when, and by whom Your work is for a client Who needs to be kept informed of progress and problems 15
- 16. Task This link opensa Moodle task. There is insufficient detail to produce a “solution”. Using the previous work, identify, using the 9 points, what further information you need to be able to address all of the points 16
Editor's Notes
- #2 A presentation as part of the BTEC Level 3 IT qualification. This is for Unit 5 Data Modelling , and deals with Learning aim A section 1 The stages in the decision making process.
- #3 There are 9 sections to this although 7, Making a decision and 8 Justifying a decision are linked and dealt with as a single item.
- #5 Information Required When the “process has a problem”, what data is being processed, where does it come from, how is it processed and what is the problem? These are repeated in most programming type scenarios, weather it is spreadsheets, databases, or programming languages. For the information required you have to consider Information already available. What is it, where does it come from and how reliable is it? Remember at this point we are looking at the process as a whole, and the how of processing is needed as well as the what is processed. There may be an existing operational specification that identifies what the data is and where it comes from coupled with how it is processed. This documentation Review should clarify the existing data and process Additional information needed / Sources of additional information If you identify something is missing in understanding the existing system or what is required in the “new” system, where is it available from? Looking at the paperwork as above is a good start, but you may need to ask users what they are doing as well as watching what they do. Do the users understand what they are doing and why they are doing it the way they are? It may be that part of the “new” system is only with the managers and is an idea. Does this make sense with the existing ways of working, does it require a new way of working or is there scope for discussion over the how of the new system. Requirements for veryifying the information sources Everyone uses Google. This is not a verifiable source. Look at Official documents such as the annual report and accounts if it is relevant Review the operations manuals etc that may indicate a specific process in the organisation has to be done in a certain way (think chemicals and adding them in the wrong order) Changing the control flow may have unforeseen consequences.
- #10 When the “process has a problem”, what data is being processed, where does it come from and how is it processed and what is the problem?.