Variation of input impedance with feeding position in probe and inset fed microstrip patch antenna

Innovative Systems Design and Engineering www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1727 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2871 (Online)
Vol 3, No 7, 2012

Variation of Input Impedance with Feeding Position in Probe and
inset-Fed Microstrip Patch Antenna

Njeri P. Waweru1*, D. B. O. Konditi2, and P. K. Langat1
1. Telecommunication & Information Engineering Department, JKUAT, P.O Box 62000, Nairobi-Kenya
2. Electrical & Communication Engineering Department, MMUCK, P.O Box 30305, Nairobi-Kenya
* E-mail of the corresponding author: waweru@ymail.com

Abstract
Proper impedance matching of a microstrip patch antenna to the feed line is paramount for efficient radiation.
However, impedance matching in such a system is not easy and consequently most systems suffer from return losses.
The variation of the input impedance of a probe-fed and inset-fed rectangular microstrip patch antennas along the
longitudinal and transverse lengths is investigated on probe-fed and microstrip-fed antenna operating at 2.4GHz and
2.0GHz respectively. FEKO simulation software is used to evaluate and characterize the behaviour of the input
resistance for varying values of feeding position. It is observed that the transverse variation in the input resistance is
very minimal. The conclusion drawn here is that a cosine squared and shifted cosine squared function can be used to
exactly locate the feed point in a probe and inset fed antennas respectively for an impedance matched antenna
system.

Keywords: Longitudinal feeding position, FEKO, probe feeding, inset feeding, input impedance, return loss.

1. Introduction

Modern communication systems require low profile, light weight, high gain and simple antenna structures to go
along with the research in miniaturization of system devices being undertaken e.g. in the design of mobile phones (G.
Sharma, 2011). These antennas should also possess reliable propagation characteristics as well as high efficiency.
Microstrip antennas depicts such characteristics as characterized by relative ease of construction, light weight, low
cost, conformability to the mounting surface and extremely thin protrusion from the surface (T. Huque, 2011),
(Rathod, 2010), (Sayeed, 2010) (Reddy, 2009) and (M. F. Bendahmane, 2010).
To enjoy the aforementioned advantages, return losses must be mitigated during the design phase in a particular
antenna system (D.D. Sandu, 2006). These losses are attributed to impedance mismatch between the radiating patch
and the feed line for the contacting feeding techniques outlined below.
Numerous methods of analyzing the performance of a microstrip antenna exist. Among these are; Transmission line
model, Cavity model and those methods based on numerical calculations e.g. MoM, FETD e.t.c (P. Jsoh, 2005). The
antennas designed in this paper are based on the transmission line model where the patch is considered as a section
of a transmission line radiating from its two extremities.
There are two common contacting microstrip feeding schemes: probe and edge feeding techniques. In the former
method, (V. Rajeshkumar K. Priyadarshini, 2012), the inner conductor of a coaxial cable penetrates through the
substrate and is soldered to the radiating patch while the outer conductor is connected to the ground plane. Matching
in this technique is achieved by placing the probe at an appropriate longitudinal position. In the edge feeding method,
a conducting strip is connected directly to the edge of the radiating patch. Impedance matching in this technique,
however, is a challenge since the edge impedance is very high varying between 150Ω-250Ω. However, it decreases

77

Vol 3, No 7, 2012

as the feed point approaches the center of the patch. A variation to this scheme is the inset feeding where an inset
notch is cut in the patch to enhance matching. Matching is achieved by controlling the longitudinal length of the
notch thus controlling input impedance level.
Appropriate positioning of a coaxial probe and determining the appropriate notch length in the probe and inset-fed
antennas respectively, is not easy. The main challenge therefore facing the designers of microstrip antennas is how to
exactly position these feed lines for matched microstrip antenna systems. As noted in (G. Sharma, 2011), (Balanis,
2005), (Peters, 2010) designers have been using cosine squared functions for both feeding schemes and it’s the
authors’ objective to further explore the behaviour of the input resistance in both schemes for various feeding
positions.
In this paper, the effects of varying the longitudinal and transversal feeding position on the input resistance of both
probe-fed and inset-fed microstrip antennas is investigated. Resulting curves; input resistance as a function of feed
length are compared with typical functions. The investigation was carried out using FEKO Electromagnetic software.
The design involves a probe-fed and inset-fed Microstrip Patch antenna operating at 2.4GHz and 2.0GHz frequency
respectively, with the theory behind probe and inset feeding technique discussed in section 2. The design of the
above described antennas and simulations are presented in Section 3 of this paper. Simulation results are presented
and discussed in section 4. Section 5 gives a detailed conclusion and deduction of the investigation and comparison.

2.Contacting feeding techniques

Patch feeding can broadly be classified as either contacting or non-contacting. In the contacting method, either a
microstrip line or coaxial cable is used to directly excite the radiating patch. This makes this techniques easy to
fabricate and simple to model. The main advantage of these techniques is that impedance matching is relatively easy
since the probe or microstrip line can be placed at any desired position.

Fig. 1: Probe feeding scheme Fig. 2: Inset feeding scheme

78

Vol 3, No 7, 2012

2.1 Probe feeding
This scheme involves drilling a hole through the ground plane and the substrate and extending the inner conductor of
a coax through the hole. This conductor is then soldered to the radiating patch while the outer conductor of the coax
is connected to the ground plane. Control of the input impedance is achieved by positioning of the probe. This
method result in minimal spurious radiation but is very complicated since it involves precise drilling both on the
ground plane and the substrate in terms of position and size.
2.2 Inset feeding
This is a variation of the edge feeding where the fed line is in direct contact with one of the radiating edges of the
patch. Impedance control is achieved by cutting out a notch from the radiating edge and extending the feed line into
the notch. This scheme has the advantage that the feed line and the radiating patch can be etched on the same
substrate making design and realization easier and highly suited for array design. However, conflicting substrate
requirement for feed line and radiating element results in reduced system efficiency.
Figures 1 and 2 show both probe and inset fed microstrip antenna configuration. For efficient radiation, the
dimensions of the patch as captured in the figures are governed by the following relations derived from the
transmission line model.

(1)

(2)

Where (3)

(4)

The feedline width w0 is evaluated from equation 5 below

(5)

79

Vol 3, No 7, 2012

Table 1: Patch antenna dimensions
S. No Symbol Parameter Probe-fed Inset-fed
1. Ls Substrate length 100mm 100mm
2. Ws Substrate width 100mm 100mm
3. H Substrate thickness 3.175mm 3.81mm
4. L Patch length 31.778 33.28mm
5. W Patch width 42.7540 42.3050mm
6. w0 Feedline width 9.0273mm

Substrate dimensions as well as those obtained from the above equations are tabulated in Table 1 above for a
frequency of 2.0GHz for the inset feeding and 2.4GHz for the probe feeding. The substrate employed in this design is

Rogers TMM3 with a dielectric constant =3.27, loss tangent tanδ=0.004.

2. Simulation procedures

Below is a brief description of how the simulations were carried out for both feeding schemes.

2.1. Probe-fed microstrip patch antenna
A probe-fed microstrip antenna was designed in FEKO with dimensions as tabulated in Table 1. Starting from one of
the radiating edge of the patch and sequentially changing the feed position in definite steps along the center line all
the way to the opposite edge, and for each position the input resistance was evaluated. The procedure above was
repeated but this time along 5mm, 10mm and 15mm offset of the center line with the input resistance being evaluated
for each case.
Again stating from one of the non-radiating edges and at 5mm from the one radiating edge, probe feeding positions
were sequentially moved in a transversal manner from one edge to the other. This was repeated along a line 10mm
and 15mm from the radiating edge.

2.2. Inset feeding technique
Simulation in this scheme involved extending the feed line to the edge where the notch has been cut out. This way,
the simulated input resistance is that of the edge where the notch has been cut out. For values of the longitudinal
notch length varying from zero to L/2 , the procedure above was again used to evaluate the input resistance along the
center line. This was repeated along a line 5mm, 10mm and 15mm offset of the center line.
Starting from one of the non-radiating edges with the notch length set to 0mm, the feed position was changed
transversally to the opposite edge with the input resistance being evaluated for each position. This was repeated feed
position 4mm, 8mm, and 12mm from the radiating edge and along the transverse centerline.
To characterize the behaviour of the input resistance with notch gap, simulation was repeated along the longitudinal
centerline for the following notch gap g (as a fraction of the feedline width w0): g=0.3w0, 0.5w0, 0.7w0 and w0.

80

Vol 3, No 7, 2012

3. Results and discussion

4.1 Longitudinal and transverse variations

Figures 3 and 4 shows the longitudinal and transverse variations of input resistance in both probe-fed and inset-fed
scheme. In both figures agreement in the longitudinal and transverse variations can be clearly observed. In figure 3b,
it can be seen that the transverse variations are minimal especially at the center but deviates from this behaviour as
the probe approaches the radiating edges. For the inset-fed antenna, from figure 4b, the transverse variations are not
constant and the input resistance reduces as the feedline approach the center.

4.2 Characterization of input resistance in probe and inset feeding schemes

The simulation results are as captured in Fig. 5 for the probe-fed antenna and Fig. 6 for the inset-fed antennas for
varying values of notch gap g. From figure 5a, the simulated input resistance exactly follows the cosine squared
function. As the probe feed approach edge edges of the patch however, the curve deviates from the cosine squared
behaviour. Defining the resonant frequency as the frequency at which S11 is minimum, figure 5b shows the variation
in the resonant frequency with feeding position. It can be seen that the variation in frequency with feed position is
very minimal as the probe approaches the center of the radiating patch.
For inset-fed antenna, results show that the trace follows cosine squared behaviour. However, the minima are not at
the center but shifted towards the feeding edge which is not the case with cosine squared function. It is also observed
that the shift is a function of the gap width as depicted in figures 6a-6d. Figure 7 captures all traces for various values
of g from 0.3w0 to w0. From this, it can be observed how the degree of the shift increases with the notch gap. From
this, the input resistance therefore, can be modeled as

(6)

Where xg is the notch-gap dependent variable. Tabulated below in Table 2 are values of gap width g and the
corresponding values of xg.

Table 2: Variation of notch length with gap
S. No g(in terms of w0) g(mm) Xg
1. 0.3 2.7390mm 1.5271mm
2. 0.5 4.5650mm 2.2906mm
3. 0.7 6.3910mm 2.5451mm
4. 1 9.1299mm 3.1814mm

81

Vol 3, No 7, 2012

a) Longitudinal variations of input resistance b) Transversal variations of input resistance
Figure 3: Variation of input resistance in a probe-fed antenna

a) Longitudinal variations of input resistance b) Transversal variations of input resistance
Figure 4: Variation of input resistance in an inset-fed antenna

82

Vol 3, No 7, 2012

a) Variation of input resistance with feed position b) Variation of resonant frequency with feed position
Fig. 5: Characterization in a probe-fed antenna

a) g=0.3w0 b) g=0.5w0

c) g=0.7w0 d) g=w0
Fig. 6: Characterization in an inset-fed antenna

83

Vol 3, No 7, 2012

Fig. 7: Variation of input resistance with notch gap.

4. Conclusion

The behaviour of the input resistance of a rectangular microstrip patch antenna with contacting feeding techniques
was investigated. For coaxial feeding scheme, it was concluded that cosine squared function fully characterize the
variation of the input resistance along the resonant length of the patch. Variation of the input resistance in an
inset-fed though following cosine squared behaviour, was shifted towards the feeding edge. The phase shift was
found to vary with the gap between the feed line and the radiating patch.

References

Balanis, C.A. (2005) Antenna Theory, Analysis and Design, 3rd edition, John Wiley & Sons.
D.D. Sandu, O.G.Avadanei, A.Ioachim and D.Ionesi (2006) 'Contribution to the cavity model for analysis of
microstrip patch antenna', journal of optoelectronics and advanced materials, vol. 8, february, pp. 339-344.
G. Sharma, D.Shama and A.Katariya (2011) 'An approach to design and optimization of WLAN patch antennas of
wi-fi applications', International Journal of Wireless Communication, vol. 1, pp. 9-14.
M. F. Bendahmane, M.Abri, F.T.Bendimerad and N.Boukli-Hacene (2010) 'A simple modified transmission line
modl for inset fed antenna design', International journal of computer science issues, vol. 7, september, pp. 331-335.
P. Jsoh, M.K.Rahim, A. Asrokin and M. Z.Aziz (2005) 'Comparative radiation performance of different feeding
techniques for a microstrip patch antenna', 205 Asia-Pacific conference on applied electromagnetcs, IEEE, pp. 25-40.
J.R.Ojha and M. Peters (2010) ' patch antennas and microstrip lines', in Minin, P.I. Modern UWB antennas and
equipments, Microwave and millimeter wave technologies, 1st edition, Vukovar, Croatia: In-Tech Publishers.
Rathod, J.M. (2010) 'Comparative study of microstrip patch antenna for wireless communication application',

84

Vol 3, No 7, 2012

International journal of innovation and tech nology, vol. 1, pp. 194-197.
V. R.Anitha and S.N. Reddy (2009) 'Design of an 8X1 square microstrip patch antenna array', International journal
of electronic engineering research, vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 71-77.
M. A. Matin and A. I. Sayeed, (2010) 'A design for inset fed rectangular microstrip patch antenna', WSEAS
transaction on communications, vol. 9, January, pp. 63-72.
T. Huque, K. Hosain, S.Islam and A.Chowdhury (2011) 'Design and performance analysis of microstrip array
antennas with optimum parameters for X-Band applications', International journal of advanced computer science
and applications, vol. 2, pp. 81-87, Available: 4.
V. Rajeshkumar, K. Priyadarshini, G.Devakirubai, C.Anitha and P.Snekha (2012) 'Design and comparative study of
pin fed and line fed microstrip patch antenna for X-Band applications', International jornal od applied information
systems(IJAIS), vol. 5, pp. 21-25.

85

This academic article was published by The International Institute for Science,
Technology and Education (IISTE). The IISTE is a pioneer in the Open Access
Publishing service based in the U.S. and Europe. The aim of the institute is
Accelerating Global Knowledge Sharing.

More information about the publisher can be found in the IISTE’s homepage:
http://www.iiste.org

The IISTE is currently hosting more than 30 peer-reviewed academic journals and
collaborating with academic institutions around the world. Prospective authors of
IISTE journals can find the submission instruction on the following page:
http://www.iiste.org/Journals/

The IISTE editorial team promises to the review and publish all the qualified
submissions in a fast manner. All the journals articles are available online to the
readers all over the world without financial, legal, or technical barriers other than
those inseparable from gaining access to the internet itself. Printed version of the
journals is also available upon request of readers and authors.

IISTE Knowledge Sharing Partners

EBSCO, Index Copernicus, Ulrich's Periodicals Directory, JournalTOCS, PKP Open
Archives Harvester, Bielefeld Academic Search Engine, Elektronische
Zeitschriftenbibliothek EZB, Open J-Gate, OCLC WorldCat, Universe Digtial
Library , NewJour, Google Scholar

Variation of input impedance with feeding position in probe and inset fed microstrip patch antenna

More Related Content

What's hot

Similar to Variation of input impedance with feeding position in probe and inset fed microstrip patch antenna

More from Alexander Decker

Recently uploaded

Variation of input impedance with feeding position in probe and inset fed microstrip patch antenna