Добрый день
Claude Martin
Nord University Hospital
    Marseilles France
 (ICU and Trauma Center)
Septic Shock

 Absolute hypovolemia
 relative hypovolemia
 Distributive shock : area of
   VD/VC
 Cardiac dysfonction
 O2 extraction abnormalities
CCM , 2008 , 36 , 296-327
CCM , 2008 , 36 , 296-327
Initial Resuscitation

MAP  65 mmHg
 CVP 8 - 12 mmHg
 UF    0.5 ml.kg-1.hr-1
ScvO2  70%
 SvO2  65%
       GRADE 1B
Treatment of
              Septic shock

Hemodynamic             source control
managment



                       Antibiotics   Surgery
Fluids   Vaso-active                 drainage
           agents
Therapeutic Targets and Tools
                                     Vessels :
                                     norepinephrine
                                     epinephrine
                                     dopamine
  Volemia :
  Fluid challenge
                               Heart :
                               dobutamine
                               norepinephrine

   Rescue therapy :
   Vasopressin, terlipressin
                               Microcirculation :
                               Nitroglycerin ???
VASOPRESSORS
   Dopamine
 Epinephrenine
 Norepinephrine
  Vasopressin
  Terlipressin
Initial Resuscitation   CCM , 2008 , 36 , 296-327


 MAP               65 mmHg
  CVP 8 - 12 mmHg
  UF    0.5 ml.kg-1.hr-1
 ScvO2  70%
  SvO2  65%
             Grade 1B
•Is venous
return optimal
  ?????????
Fluid challenge
         Fluid challenge

              MAP
           (driving force)

          Venous return
      and ventricular preload

              SV
Fluid challenge
            Respiratory variation under MV
       Parameter                 threshold

    SAP                   10 mmHg or 9%
    down                  5 mmHg
    PP                    12-13 %
    SVV                    9-10%


    CVP                    < 5 mmHg
                French Consensus Conference 2005
Stroke Volume Variation


SV max

               SV min


                              SV mean




            SV max + SV min
    SVV =
                  2
Pulse Pressure Variations



                        ∆PP
                   Michard et al.
                   Am J Respir Crit Care Med
PPmax              2000


        PPmin
Fluid challenge
            Respiratory variation under MV
       Parameter                 threshold

    SAP                   10 mmHg or 9%
    down                  5 mmHg
    PP                    12-13 %
    SVV                    9-10%

    CVP                    < 5 mmHg

                French Consensus Conference 2005
Fluid Responsiveness in Spontaneously
         Breathing Patients


PP                                                   No
SVV                                                   !!!
Teboul JL 8th Int. Consensus Conference ATS/SRLF/ERS/SCC/Esicm, Paris 27-28 April 2006
•Passive leg raising
     with > 12%
     increase
  in CO by PiCCO
or oesophageal Döppler
Vasopressors




 Norepinephrine
  or Dopamine
32 patients randomized : dopamine (Until 25 µg/kg/min)
                                or norepi ( Until 5 µg/kg/min)


              Objective (n=11)
  success (n=5)   failure : MAP           > success (n=15)for failure (n=1)
                                            80 mmHg            6h
  10 to 25 µg/kg/min       25 µg/kg/min      1.5±1.2 µg/kg/min        5 µg/kg/min

increase in urine output                  increase in urine output
   decrease in lactate                       decrease in lactate



          10 (n=16)
                                 Norepi (n=16)
       Dopasuccess with Dopa + Norepi              (25 µg/kg/min +1.7±1.8 µg/kg/min)


                                                  Chest 1993, 103:1826-31
Dopamine or Norepinephrine ?
                             93%
             69%
 P < 0.001


31%
                                       7%   p < O.,001


Success      Failure         Success   Failure

Dopamine                  Norepinephrine
                 C. Martin et al Chest 1993, 103, 1826
Dopamine or Norepinephrine ?
            Hyperdynamic septic shock



Dopamine                          Norepinephrine
(2.5-25 mg                        (0.5-5.0 mg/kg/min)
/kg/min)
   16 patients                        16 patients
success : 5/16 (31%)   p<0.001    success : 15/16 (93%)
failure : 11/16                   failure : 1/16
success : 0/1                     success : 10/11

                 C. Martin et al Chest 1993, 103, 1826
Resistance to Dopamine

110 patients
 MAP < 70 mmHg with 20 mg/kg/min
                     60%

                               P < 0.001
       40%



      Dopa S         Dopa R
                   Levy et al CCM 2005, 33.
Resistance to Dopamine




                 Levy et al CCM 2005, 33
DOPAMINE vs NOREPINEPHRINE
SOAP study
                       1058 pts in shock
Mortality
                               *         *
% 50
                   *                     50    * P<0.05
     40          43           45    42
            36           37
     30

     20

     10

     0
             ICU         30 Days   Hospital   Sakr et al
Dopamine No dopamine                          CCM 2006
Dopamine for septic
    shock ???
         Failure of Dopamine
Dopamine ou noradrénaline ?


                              N Engl J Med 2010




               De Backer et al., N Engl J Med 2010
0.19 mg/Kg/min
Dopamine or Norepinephrine ?
            Hyperdynamic septic shock



Dopamine                         Norepinephrine
(2.5-25 mg)
/kg/min
                                 (0.5-5.0
   16 patients                    mg/kg/min)
success : 5/16 (31%)   p<0.001       16 patients
failure : 11/16                  success : 15/16 -93%)
success : 0/1                    failure : 1/16
                                 success : 10/11

                 C. Martin et al Chest 1993, 103, 1826
% Survival
                             Septic Shock :
100                          Norepinephrine
 90
 80
 70
 60                Norepinephrine
 50
 40
                        p < 0.0001
 30
 20                                Martin C et al Crit Care Med
 10        Other vasopressors       2000 , 28 , 2758 .
  0
    0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
                  Days
Adrénaline ou noradrénaline ?




       Noradrénaline
         Adrénaline
Adrénaline ou noradrénaline ?




Catécholamine utilisée en première ligne

    Noradrénaline   Dopamine Adrénaline
     158 (57%)      102 (37%)   22 (8%)
•Dopamine or Norepinephrine in Human Hyperdynamic Sepsis ?
700               *                           200              *
                                              190
650
           *          DO2
                                              180
                                                                      VO2
600                                           170
                                              160
                                                         *
550                                      H0   150                                   H0
                                         H6                                         H6
                                              140
500
                                              130
450                                           120
                                              110
400
      NE       Dopa                           100

                                  *
                                                    NE       Dopa
                       7,3


                      7,25

                                             * pHi
                       7,2
                                                                     H0
                      7,15                                           H6


                       7,1
                                                                    Marik JAMA
                                                                    1994 , 272 , 1354
                      7,05
                             NE       Dopa
Effects of Norepinephrine
         on Renal Function
200                                           250
180
160                                           200
140
120                                           150

100                                                                          Before NE
                                    Before NE 100                            During NE
 80                                 During NE
 60                                            50
 40
 20                                             0
                                                    Urine   Serum    Creat
  0                                                 flow     creat   clear
      Urine flow Serum creatinine
                 creat clearance


            Martin et al                             Desjars et al
            1990                                     1989
Vasopressors




Epinephrine is an
   alternative
CATS Study
 (Epinephrine / norepi-dobu)

 Epinephrine            Norepi-dobu
   n = 161                (n = 169)


Hospital survival     Hospital survival
    47.8%                 51.5%

   Power 90%           p = 0.51
                         D. Annane et al Lancet 2007
Metaraminol ?
 Norepinephrine treated patients switched to
metaraminol (NE : 0.3 + 0.28 µg/kg/min, Meta :
2.5 + 1.7 µg/kg/min)


  = MAP                                = CI
  (70/71)                              (3.7/3.6)

                     = SvO2
                     (72/72)
                       Natalini et al ICM 2005, 31, 634-637
In
  case of
failure ???
a1-AR                    AC                      AC


                     a

                 b       g
                                            a
                 Gs protein
                                        b       g
 P     P     P
                               Receptor
 arrestin
                               resensitization
     clathrin

Receptor          endosome                          Receptor
internalization    Receptor                         degradation
               dephosphorylation
AVP
Vasopressors



Vasopressin :
  no recommendation
 Avoid high-dose
               2B
Norepinephrine > 15 mcg/min
Norepinephrine 5-14 mcg/min
Terlipressin?        15 patients with catecholamine - resistant
                          septic shock: NE ( 2.2 mcg/kg/min )
                          dopamine ( 25 mcg/kg/min )
                    Terlipressin 1 or 2 bolus of 1 mg
MAP                                      CI l/min/m2
mmHg                                   5.3+/-1.2
                   84+/- 6
                                                  4.7+/-1.3
        55+/- 5                                     P< 0.01


       NE + dopa    TER                NE + dopa     TER
                                   1147+/-134
       SVRI dyn.sec 654+/-108
       .cm-5.m-2


                      NE + dopa         TER

                             Leone,, Martin Shock 2004,22,3146319
 15 patients with catecholamine - resistant
Terlipressin ?          septic shock: NE ( 2.2 mcg/kg/min )
                        dopamine ( 25 mcg/kg/min )
                  Terlipressin 1 or 2 bolus of 1 mg



UF ml/h     76+/-21          Cr Cl
                             ml/min         47+/-36

  15+/-12                        21+/-15

  baseline TER                  baseline TER


                 Leone,, Martin Shock 2004,22,3146319
Survival
   ?
Terlipressin:
Rescue Therapy
MAP :
 65-75-85
mmHg ???
150   Renal Blood Flow
                         Renal Autoregulation
      (% baseline)       in Disease
                                      Control
                                      3 weeks
100
                                      1 week



50


0      20       40       60      80     100
       Renal Artery Pressure (mmH g)
150   Renal Blood Flow
                         Renal Autoregulation
      (% baseline)       in Disease
                                      Control
                                      3 weeks
100
                                      1 week



50


0      20       40       60      80     100
       Renal Artery Pressure (mmH g)
150   Renal Blood Flow
                         Renal Autoregulation
      (% baseline)       in Disease
                                      Control
                                      3 weeks
100
                                      1 week



50


0      20       40       60      80     100
       Renal Artery Pressure (mmH g)
150   Renal Blood Flow
                         Renal Autoregulation
      (% baseline)       in Disease
                                       Control
                                       3 weeks
100
                                       1 week



50


0      20       40       60      80     100
       Renal Artery Pressure (mmH g)
65   85
Lactate
                    Increasing MAP ?

65    DO2
               85


       VO2


                       A Bourgoin et al
                     CCM 2005,33,780-786
UF
                       Increasing MAP ?


65   Creatinine
                  85



       Cr Cl
                         A Bourgoin et al
                         CCM 2005,33,780-786
Conclusions :
Prefere norepinephrine
Dopamine ???????
Epinephrine 2 nd line

Vasopressin and terlipressin :
  rescue therapy

    Have a protocol
Спасибо

Vasopressors in septic shock russie 2012

  • 1.
  • 2.
    Claude Martin Nord UniversityHospital Marseilles France (ICU and Trauma Center)
  • 8.
    Septic Shock  Absolutehypovolemia  relative hypovolemia  Distributive shock : area of VD/VC  Cardiac dysfonction  O2 extraction abnormalities
  • 9.
    CCM , 2008, 36 , 296-327
  • 10.
    CCM , 2008, 36 , 296-327
  • 11.
    Initial Resuscitation MAP 65 mmHg  CVP 8 - 12 mmHg  UF  0.5 ml.kg-1.hr-1 ScvO2  70%  SvO2  65% GRADE 1B
  • 12.
    Treatment of Septic shock Hemodynamic source control managment Antibiotics Surgery Fluids Vaso-active drainage agents
  • 13.
    Therapeutic Targets andTools Vessels : norepinephrine epinephrine dopamine Volemia : Fluid challenge Heart : dobutamine norepinephrine Rescue therapy : Vasopressin, terlipressin Microcirculation : Nitroglycerin ???
  • 14.
    VASOPRESSORS Dopamine Epinephrenine Norepinephrine Vasopressin Terlipressin
  • 15.
    Initial Resuscitation CCM , 2008 , 36 , 296-327 MAP  65 mmHg  CVP 8 - 12 mmHg  UF  0.5 ml.kg-1.hr-1 ScvO2  70%  SvO2  65% Grade 1B
  • 16.
  • 17.
    Fluid challenge Fluid challenge MAP (driving force) Venous return and ventricular preload SV
  • 19.
    Fluid challenge Respiratory variation under MV Parameter threshold SAP 10 mmHg or 9% down 5 mmHg PP 12-13 % SVV 9-10% CVP < 5 mmHg French Consensus Conference 2005
  • 20.
    Stroke Volume Variation SVmax SV min SV mean SV max + SV min SVV = 2
  • 21.
    Pulse Pressure Variations ∆PP Michard et al. Am J Respir Crit Care Med PPmax 2000 PPmin
  • 22.
    Fluid challenge Respiratory variation under MV Parameter threshold SAP 10 mmHg or 9% down 5 mmHg PP 12-13 % SVV 9-10% CVP < 5 mmHg French Consensus Conference 2005
  • 23.
    Fluid Responsiveness inSpontaneously Breathing Patients PP No SVV !!! Teboul JL 8th Int. Consensus Conference ATS/SRLF/ERS/SCC/Esicm, Paris 27-28 April 2006
  • 24.
    •Passive leg raising with > 12% increase in CO by PiCCO or oesophageal Döppler
  • 25.
  • 26.
    32 patients randomized: dopamine (Until 25 µg/kg/min) or norepi ( Until 5 µg/kg/min) Objective (n=11) success (n=5) failure : MAP > success (n=15)for failure (n=1) 80 mmHg 6h 10 to 25 µg/kg/min 25 µg/kg/min 1.5±1.2 µg/kg/min 5 µg/kg/min increase in urine output increase in urine output decrease in lactate decrease in lactate 10 (n=16) Norepi (n=16) Dopasuccess with Dopa + Norepi (25 µg/kg/min +1.7±1.8 µg/kg/min) Chest 1993, 103:1826-31
  • 27.
    Dopamine or Norepinephrine? 93% 69% P < 0.001 31% 7% p < O.,001 Success Failure Success Failure Dopamine Norepinephrine C. Martin et al Chest 1993, 103, 1826
  • 28.
    Dopamine or Norepinephrine? Hyperdynamic septic shock Dopamine Norepinephrine (2.5-25 mg (0.5-5.0 mg/kg/min) /kg/min) 16 patients 16 patients success : 5/16 (31%) p<0.001 success : 15/16 (93%) failure : 11/16 failure : 1/16 success : 0/1 success : 10/11 C. Martin et al Chest 1993, 103, 1826
  • 29.
    Resistance to Dopamine 110patients  MAP < 70 mmHg with 20 mg/kg/min 60% P < 0.001 40% Dopa S Dopa R Levy et al CCM 2005, 33.
  • 30.
    Resistance to Dopamine Levy et al CCM 2005, 33
  • 31.
    DOPAMINE vs NOREPINEPHRINE SOAPstudy 1058 pts in shock Mortality * * % 50 * 50 * P<0.05 40 43 45 42 36 37 30 20 10 0 ICU 30 Days Hospital Sakr et al Dopamine No dopamine CCM 2006
  • 32.
    Dopamine for septic shock ??? Failure of Dopamine
  • 35.
    Dopamine ou noradrénaline? N Engl J Med 2010 De Backer et al., N Engl J Med 2010
  • 37.
  • 38.
    Dopamine or Norepinephrine? Hyperdynamic septic shock Dopamine Norepinephrine (2.5-25 mg) /kg/min (0.5-5.0 16 patients mg/kg/min) success : 5/16 (31%) p<0.001 16 patients failure : 11/16 success : 15/16 -93%) success : 0/1 failure : 1/16 success : 10/11 C. Martin et al Chest 1993, 103, 1826
  • 39.
    % Survival Septic Shock : 100 Norepinephrine 90 80 70 60 Norepinephrine 50 40 p < 0.0001 30 20 Martin C et al Crit Care Med 10 Other vasopressors 2000 , 28 , 2758 . 0 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 Days
  • 44.
    Adrénaline ou noradrénaline? Noradrénaline Adrénaline
  • 45.
    Adrénaline ou noradrénaline? Catécholamine utilisée en première ligne Noradrénaline Dopamine Adrénaline 158 (57%) 102 (37%) 22 (8%)
  • 50.
    •Dopamine or Norepinephrinein Human Hyperdynamic Sepsis ? 700 * 200 * 190 650 * DO2 180 VO2 600 170 160 * 550 H0 150 H0 H6 H6 140 500 130 450 120 110 400 NE Dopa 100 * NE Dopa 7,3 7,25 * pHi 7,2 H0 7,15 H6 7,1 Marik JAMA 1994 , 272 , 1354 7,05 NE Dopa
  • 52.
    Effects of Norepinephrine on Renal Function 200 250 180 160 200 140 120 150 100 Before NE Before NE 100 During NE 80 During NE 60 50 40 20 0 Urine Serum Creat 0 flow creat clear Urine flow Serum creatinine creat clearance Martin et al Desjars et al 1990 1989
  • 53.
  • 54.
    CATS Study (Epinephrine/ norepi-dobu) Epinephrine Norepi-dobu n = 161 (n = 169) Hospital survival Hospital survival 47.8% 51.5% Power 90% p = 0.51 D. Annane et al Lancet 2007
  • 56.
    Metaraminol ?  Norepinephrinetreated patients switched to metaraminol (NE : 0.3 + 0.28 µg/kg/min, Meta : 2.5 + 1.7 µg/kg/min) = MAP = CI (70/71) (3.7/3.6) = SvO2 (72/72) Natalini et al ICM 2005, 31, 634-637
  • 59.
    In caseof failure ???
  • 60.
    a1-AR AC AC a b g a Gs protein b g P P P Receptor arrestin resensitization clathrin Receptor endosome Receptor internalization Receptor degradation dephosphorylation
  • 61.
  • 62.
    Vasopressors Vasopressin : no recommendation  Avoid high-dose 2B
  • 64.
  • 65.
  • 69.
    Terlipressin?  15 patients with catecholamine - resistant septic shock: NE ( 2.2 mcg/kg/min ) dopamine ( 25 mcg/kg/min ) Terlipressin 1 or 2 bolus of 1 mg MAP CI l/min/m2 mmHg 5.3+/-1.2 84+/- 6 4.7+/-1.3 55+/- 5 P< 0.01 NE + dopa TER NE + dopa TER 1147+/-134 SVRI dyn.sec 654+/-108 .cm-5.m-2 NE + dopa TER Leone,, Martin Shock 2004,22,3146319
  • 70.
     15 patientswith catecholamine - resistant Terlipressin ? septic shock: NE ( 2.2 mcg/kg/min ) dopamine ( 25 mcg/kg/min ) Terlipressin 1 or 2 bolus of 1 mg UF ml/h 76+/-21 Cr Cl ml/min 47+/-36 15+/-12 21+/-15 baseline TER baseline TER Leone,, Martin Shock 2004,22,3146319
  • 71.
  • 72.
  • 73.
  • 74.
    150 Renal Blood Flow Renal Autoregulation (% baseline) in Disease Control 3 weeks 100 1 week 50 0 20 40 60 80 100 Renal Artery Pressure (mmH g)
  • 75.
    150 Renal Blood Flow Renal Autoregulation (% baseline) in Disease Control 3 weeks 100 1 week 50 0 20 40 60 80 100 Renal Artery Pressure (mmH g)
  • 76.
    150 Renal Blood Flow Renal Autoregulation (% baseline) in Disease Control 3 weeks 100 1 week 50 0 20 40 60 80 100 Renal Artery Pressure (mmH g)
  • 77.
    150 Renal Blood Flow Renal Autoregulation (% baseline) in Disease Control 3 weeks 100 1 week 50 0 20 40 60 80 100 Renal Artery Pressure (mmH g)
  • 78.
    65 85
  • 79.
    Lactate Increasing MAP ? 65 DO2 85 VO2 A Bourgoin et al CCM 2005,33,780-786
  • 80.
    UF Increasing MAP ? 65 Creatinine 85 Cr Cl A Bourgoin et al CCM 2005,33,780-786
  • 83.
    Conclusions : Prefere norepinephrine Dopamine??????? Epinephrine 2 nd line Vasopressin and terlipressin : rescue therapy Have a protocol
  • 84.