Workforce
Planning and
Employment
Laws and Legislation
PHR/SPHR Preparation
Employee Rights Legislation
Employee rights legislation
 Numerous laws and regulations aims to
end discrimination (a sensitive issue in the
American society).
 Discrimination practices hold employers
liable
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act (1964)
 The cornerstone of antidiscrimination legislation in
US.
 Prohibits discrimination or segregation in all terms
of employment based on:
 Race
 Color
 Gender
 Religion
 National Origin
 Make it unlawful to limit, segregate or classify
employees in any way that would deprive them
employment or career progression opportunities
based on the characteristics above.
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act
(1964)
 Provides equal opportunity to participate
in training and have opportunity for
advancement.
 Makes it illegal to discriminate based on
pregnancy, childbirth, or related
condition as amended by Pregnancy
Discrimination Act.
 Prohibits sexual harassment
 Prohibits discrimination in compensation.
Title VII – Coverage
 Most private employers with 15+ employees
on payroll.
 All educational institutions
 Federal, state and local governments.
 Public and private employment agencies as
employers and when referring for
employment.
 Labor unions with 15 or more members
 Joint (labor-management) committees for
apprenticeships and training
Title VII – Exceptions
 Work-related requirements: practices that
may lead to discrimination against a
protected class can be considered legal if it is
job-related and required by a business
necessity.
 Bona fide occupational qualification : if
gender, religion, or national origin is a bona
fide occupational qualification necessary for
a job.
 Seniority systems
Civil Rights Act
 Allowed jury trials for cases where plaintiff
seeks compensatory or punitive damages.
 Provides (with limits) damage awards to
victims of intentional discrimination in violation
to:
 Title VII
 Americans with Disabilities Act
 Section 501 of the Rehabilitation Act (which
applies to federal governments employees only)
Age Discrimination in
Employment Act-ADEA (1967)
 Prohibits discrimination against persons of age
40 and over.
 Exceptions:
 If age is a bona fide occupational qualification
 Executive and high policy makers can be
required to retire at age 65 if they are entitled to
receive company-sponsored retirement benefits
of at least $ 44,000 and have held their position
for two years prior to retirement.
Pregnancy Discrimination Act
(1978)
 Under the law it is illegal to fire or refuse to
hire a woman because of pregnancy.
 Employer can not force a pregnant to
leave as she ready, willing and able to
perform her job.
 Employer should continue accrued
seniority of an employee on leave to give
birth or have an abortion.
Americans with Disabilities Act-
ADA(1990)
 Applies on employers with 15+ employees
 Prohibits unlawful discrimination against
qualified individuals with disabilities because
of the disability.
 Qualified means can perform the essential
functions of the job with or without
accommodation.
 ADA Amendment Act –ADAAA (2008)
amended and added more details to ADA
ADA- Key Definitions
 Disability: physical or mental impairment that
substantially limits one or more major life activities.
Major life activities include:
 Transferring/ mobility
 Toileting/ personal hygiene
 Bathing and dressing
 Essential functions of the job: the primary duties of a
job that can be performed by a qualified individual
with or without accommodation.
ADA- Key Definitions
 Reasonable accommodation:
adjustments or modifications of job
application process, work environment or
circumstances to enable a qualified
individuals with disability to be considered
for a job and perform the essential
functions of the job.
Genetic Information
Nondiscrimination Act – GINA
(2008)
 Prohibits discrimination based on genetic
information in both employment and
health insurance.
 Prohibits the employer from requesting,
requiring or purchasing genetic
information on the individual or family
member. But, these exceptions apply:
GINA Exceptions
 If the employer inadvertently requires or
requests family medical history of the
employee or family member.
 For genetic services offered by the
employer including wellness programs.
 For compliance with Family and Medical
Leave Act.
 When employer purchases commercially
available documents
Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act
(2009)
 Creates an open time frame for filing wage
discrimination claims.
 Before this law, the employee could file
discrimination claim within 180/300 days of the
occurrence of the discrimination according to Title
VII.
 the clock renews (regarding the 180/300 days)
each time employee receives compensation that is
based on the alleged discrimination
Uniform Guidelines on Employee
Selection Procedure
 A procedural document created to assist
employers in complying with Title VII, Executive
Order 11246 and other laws.
 Covers all aspects of selection process.
 Adverse impact: occurs when a selection
procedure works to the disadvantage of a
protected class. If the selection rate of a
protected class is less than 80% of the selection
rate of the class with highest rate, this is considered
adverse impact.
Adverse Impact-Example
 It is also known as four-fifths rule.
 Example:
 Males are the majority group:
 20/50=40%
 Selection rate for females is less than 80% of
selection rate of males adverse impact
Group Interviewe
d
Hired Selectio
n rate
Males 40 20 50%
Female
s
30 6 20%
How to remedy adverse
impact
 Analyze data in more depth. Analysis of
selection process components may not
reveal adverse impact.
 Modify the procedure
 Stop the procedure and discard existing
results.
 Validate the job relatedness of the procedure
 Justify the procedure as a business necessity.
Vietnam Era Veterans
Readjustment Assistance Act
 Law enacted to enable Vietnam veterans
rejoin labor market and prohibit
discrimination against them.
 It applies to the federal government and
federal government contractors and
subcontractors of $50,000 entered before
01/12/2003
 It prohibits discrimination against these
categories of veterans:
Protected veterans
 Specially disabled veterans
 Vietnam era veterans
 Recently separated (within one year of
discharge)
 Other protected veterans (the book
contains more details)
Jobs for Veterans Act
 Amended VEVRAA
 It applies to the federal government and
federal government contractors and
subcontractors of $100,000 entered after
01/12/2003
 Extended the protection of VEVRAA in
many aspect as:
 Included all disabled veterans
 Discharged veterans within 1-3 years.
Rehabilitation Act (1973)
 Prohibited discrimination based on mental
or physical disabilities.
 Applies to federal government and
federal contractors with contracts over
$10,000.
 According to the law, employers are
required to provide reasonable
accommodation for the qualified
disabled employees/ candidates unless
undue hardship can be demonstrated
Rehabilitation Act (1973)
 Undue hardship may be based on
business necessity or financial costs.
Immigration Reform and
Control Act (1986)
 Regulate the work of foreigners in the US
 Determines the types of visas for different
worker categories
 Determines the acceptable documents
that demonstrate the identity and right to
work in the US
 Determines the mechanism for employers
to verify the eligibility of employees to
work in US.
 A lot of detail, read thoroughly
Worker Adjustment and Retraining
Notification Act (1988)
 The law requires that covered employers
to give a minimum of 60 days notice for
plant closing or mass layoff to reduce the
impact on affected employees.
 Covered Employers:
 Employers who employ 100 full time
employees
 Or Employers who employ full and part time
employees working at least 4,000
hours/week
Congressional Accountability
Act
 It requires that federal employee relations
legislation enacted by the congress apply
to the employees of the congress.
Legislation Affecting Privacy
and Consumer Protection
Privacy Act (1974)
 This law protects the employment records
of the federal government from disclosure
without written authorization by the
employee.
Employee Polygraph
Protection Act (1988)
 It prevents employers from using lie
detector tests for pre-employment
screening or during employment, with
certain exceptions.
 it prohibits the employer to require,
request, suggest, or cause an employee
or prospective employee to take or
submit to any lie detector test.
Employee Polygraph
Protection Act (1988)
 it prohibits the employer use, refer, or
inquire about the results of any lie
detector test of any employee or
prospective employee.
 Prohibits discharge, discipline, discriminate
against, deny employment, or threaten to
take action against an employee or
prospective employee for refusal to take
a test, on the basis of the results of a test,
for filing a complaint under the act or for
exercising any rights afforded by the act
Exceptions
 Federal, state and local governments
 Tests administered by the federal
government for federal contractors
engaged in national security, intelligence
or counterintelligence functions
 To employees reasonably suspected of
involvement in a workplace incident that
results in economic loss to the employer
 To prospective employees in certain jobs
and industries, security guards, employees
of pharmaceutical firms
Consumer Credit Protection
Act (1968)
 The acts limits the amount of wages that
can be garnished or withhold in any week
by an employer to satisfy creditors by 25%
of disposable income in general.
 It allows for 50% of disposable income for
court orders related to child support or
alimony.
Fair Credit Reporting Act
(1970)
 Employer must obtain a written
authorization before a consumer report is
ordered.
 Consumer reports may include reports
about: credit reports, criminal
background checks, motor vehicle history
and reference checks.
Fair Credit Reporting Act
(1970)
 Employer must provide:
 Written notice that a consumer report may
be used.
 A copy of the report and notice of adverse
action (if taken) within three days.
 Written response to any request for
complete disclosure within 5 days
Fair and Accurate Credit
Transactions Act (2003)
 Amended Fair Credit Reporting Act and
relieved employers to use third parties for
workplace investigations
 Eliminated consent and disclosure when a
third party conducts investigation that
involves:
 Suspected misconduct
 Violation of law or regulations
 Violation of any preexisting written policies of
the employer
Equal Employment
Opportunity/ Affirmative
Action
Equal Employment
Opportunity - EEO
 Antidiscrimination legislation promised to
stop taking employment decision based
on race, gender, ethnicity, religion, age,
color, military/veteran status or disability.
 Decisions must be job and business
related.
 Protected class: people who are covered
under a particular antidiscrimination law
Types of Discrimination
 Disparate treatment: occurs when
intentionally treating a protected class
differently than other employees.
 Examples:
 Refusing to promote a female employee to
a managerial position because women
usually “does not succeed here”
 Disciplining black employees when they
violate policies while neglecting the
violations of the white.
Types of Discrimination
 Adverse/disparate impact: occurs when
applying the same rules to all employees
results in a negative effect on a protected
class. Usually unintentional.
 Examples:
 Hiring high school graduates for a specific job
may affect classes with limited access to
education.
 Requiring that applicants should lift specific
weight in order to be hired may reduce the
opportunity of women
Types of Discrimination
 Perpetuating past discrimination:
practices that repeats past policies like
giving preference to applicants referred
by current employees may appear
neutral, but it may maintain the current
mix.
Landmark Cases for
Antidiscrimination Legislation
Griggs vs. Duke Powers (1971)
 Employment discrimination need not to
be overt or intentional to be illegal
 Employment practices can be illegal
even if applied to all employees
 Places the burden on the employer to
prove that requirements are job related.
McDonnell Douglas Corp vs.
Green (1973)
 Established the criteria for disparate
treatment.
 Ruled that a “prima facie” (on first view)
case of disparate treatment can be
shown if an employee:
 Belongs to a protected class
 Applied for a job when employer sought
applicants
 Qualified yet rejected
 Was rejected by the employer kept looking
for candidates.
Albemarle Paper vs. Moody
(1975)
 Tests used for selection/ promotion must
be valid predictors for job success.
Washington vs. Davis
 Test is legal if it is job related even though
it has adverse impact
St. Mary’s Honor Center vs.
Hicks (1993)
 Employee must prove that an employer’s
reason for adverse impact is based n a lie
and that lie was to cover up
discrimination
Mckennon vs. Nashville Banner
Publishing Co. (1995)
 After acquired evidence cannot free
employer from discrimination liability
EEO Reporting
 A governmental body has been created
to enforce antidiscrimination laws; Equal
Employment Opportunity Commission
(EEOC).
 employers with 100+ employees or
federal contractors with 50+ employees
and contracts of $50,000 are required to
send annual reports about their
workforce.
Report Form
 The report should include breakdown of
the workforce by race, ethnicity and
gender for nine job categories.
 different forms available based on
industry.
Applicant flow data
 Federal contractors and subcontractors must
be able to identify, where possible, the
gender, race, ethnicity of each applicant.
 Applicant can be defined as anyone who
expresses an interest in employment
regardless of being qualified.
 Employer can request applicants voluntarily
to fill a self-identification form to provide
gender, race, ethnicity.
 Visual survey is a second option.
Affirmative Action
 Affirmative action (AA) is a practice in which
employers identify and correct any imbalances
in underrepresentation of protected classes in
the workforce (if exists).
 Federal laws that apply to federal contractors
and subcontractors that impose AA include:
 Executive order 11246
 VEVRAA and JVA
 Rehabilitation Act
 Legal obligations depend on contract value
and number of employees.
Affirmative Action Plans (AAP)
 Definition: written plans that focus on
hiring, training, compensating, promoting
and terminating underrepresented
groups.
 AAP contains narrative and statistical
components.
Major elements of AAP
 Organizational profile: shows the staffing patterns
to determine if barriers to EEO exist within any
organizational unit.
 Organizational display: provides graphical
representation of organizational units.
 Workforce analysis: a list of job titles ranked from
the lowest to highest paid within the
organizational unit
 Job group analysis: list of all job titles that
comprise each job group.
 Availability analysis: study of the internal and
external sources to determine theoretical
availability of women and minorities for
established job groups
Availability analysis
 Organization must examine the percentage
of minorities or women with requisite skills in
the reasonable recruitment area and
percentage of minorities or women among
those promotable, transferable, and
trainable within the contractor's organization
 The organization must compare percentages
of minorities and women with availability and
establish placement goals if considerable
differences (underutilization) exist.
Auditing for EEO and AAP
 Compliance review: comprehensive analysis
and evaluation of the organization hiring
and employment practices, AAPs and the
result of AA efforts.
 Off-site review: consists of analysis and
evaluation of AAP and supporting
documentation.
 Focused review: consists of on-site review
focused on one or more areas of AAP and its
application.
Fairness issues
 Reverse discrimination: courts has
consistently allowed temporary
preference to protected classes. Many
cases have dealt with this situation.
 Quota vs. merit hiring: Quota involves
hiring fixed number of individuals based
on protected classes that must be met at
all costs. Quota are usually not allowed by
courts.
 Bona fide occupational qualification:
very narrow exception and checked
thoroughly by courts.
Employment Practices Liability
Insurance
 Covers organizations against workers
claims of rights violations.
 Covers legal costs regardless of the final
judgment.
 Does not cover:
 Punitive damage
 Liabilities covered by other insurance.
 Employer may have duty to notify the
carrier upon receipt a letter from a lawyer
even if no claim has been filed.
Gender Discrimination and
Harassment in the Workplace
Types of Sexual Harassment
 Quid pro quo: means “this for that”.
Occurs when an employee is forced to
choose between giving in to superior’s
sexual demands or forfeiting an
economic benefit.
 Hostile Environment: occurs when sexual
or other discriminatory conduct is so
severe and pervasive that it interferes with
an individual’s performance. It can be
created by supervisors, coworkers or
nonemployees such as customers.
Precedent-Setting Harassment
Cases
 Meritor Savings Bank vs. Vinson: Held that
sexual harassment violates Title VII of the civil
rights act.
 Harris vs. Forklift System, Inc.: established the
“reasonable person” standard.
 Onacle vs. Sundowner Offshore Services, Inc.:
established same gender harassment is
actionable.
 Faragher vs. City of Boca Raton and Ellerth vs.
Burlington Northern Industries: held employer
liable for supervisory harassment that resulted in
adverse employment action.
Employer Response to
Harassment
 Have a written policy with clear definition
of harassment and a statement that it will
not be tolerated.
 Establish effective complaint procedure
 Provide training
 Investigate every complaint
 Discipline if necessary
 Communicate using multiple methods to
management and employees.

Workforce planning and employment

  • 1.
    Workforce Planning and Employment Laws andLegislation PHR/SPHR Preparation
  • 2.
  • 3.
    Employee rights legislation Numerous laws and regulations aims to end discrimination (a sensitive issue in the American society).  Discrimination practices hold employers liable
  • 4.
    Title VII ofthe Civil Rights Act (1964)  The cornerstone of antidiscrimination legislation in US.  Prohibits discrimination or segregation in all terms of employment based on:  Race  Color  Gender  Religion  National Origin  Make it unlawful to limit, segregate or classify employees in any way that would deprive them employment or career progression opportunities based on the characteristics above.
  • 5.
    Title VII ofthe Civil Rights Act (1964)  Provides equal opportunity to participate in training and have opportunity for advancement.  Makes it illegal to discriminate based on pregnancy, childbirth, or related condition as amended by Pregnancy Discrimination Act.  Prohibits sexual harassment  Prohibits discrimination in compensation.
  • 6.
    Title VII –Coverage  Most private employers with 15+ employees on payroll.  All educational institutions  Federal, state and local governments.  Public and private employment agencies as employers and when referring for employment.  Labor unions with 15 or more members  Joint (labor-management) committees for apprenticeships and training
  • 7.
    Title VII –Exceptions  Work-related requirements: practices that may lead to discrimination against a protected class can be considered legal if it is job-related and required by a business necessity.  Bona fide occupational qualification : if gender, religion, or national origin is a bona fide occupational qualification necessary for a job.  Seniority systems
  • 8.
    Civil Rights Act Allowed jury trials for cases where plaintiff seeks compensatory or punitive damages.  Provides (with limits) damage awards to victims of intentional discrimination in violation to:  Title VII  Americans with Disabilities Act  Section 501 of the Rehabilitation Act (which applies to federal governments employees only)
  • 9.
    Age Discrimination in EmploymentAct-ADEA (1967)  Prohibits discrimination against persons of age 40 and over.  Exceptions:  If age is a bona fide occupational qualification  Executive and high policy makers can be required to retire at age 65 if they are entitled to receive company-sponsored retirement benefits of at least $ 44,000 and have held their position for two years prior to retirement.
  • 10.
    Pregnancy Discrimination Act (1978) Under the law it is illegal to fire or refuse to hire a woman because of pregnancy.  Employer can not force a pregnant to leave as she ready, willing and able to perform her job.  Employer should continue accrued seniority of an employee on leave to give birth or have an abortion.
  • 11.
    Americans with DisabilitiesAct- ADA(1990)  Applies on employers with 15+ employees  Prohibits unlawful discrimination against qualified individuals with disabilities because of the disability.  Qualified means can perform the essential functions of the job with or without accommodation.  ADA Amendment Act –ADAAA (2008) amended and added more details to ADA
  • 12.
    ADA- Key Definitions Disability: physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities. Major life activities include:  Transferring/ mobility  Toileting/ personal hygiene  Bathing and dressing  Essential functions of the job: the primary duties of a job that can be performed by a qualified individual with or without accommodation.
  • 13.
    ADA- Key Definitions Reasonable accommodation: adjustments or modifications of job application process, work environment or circumstances to enable a qualified individuals with disability to be considered for a job and perform the essential functions of the job.
  • 14.
    Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act– GINA (2008)  Prohibits discrimination based on genetic information in both employment and health insurance.  Prohibits the employer from requesting, requiring or purchasing genetic information on the individual or family member. But, these exceptions apply:
  • 15.
    GINA Exceptions  Ifthe employer inadvertently requires or requests family medical history of the employee or family member.  For genetic services offered by the employer including wellness programs.  For compliance with Family and Medical Leave Act.  When employer purchases commercially available documents
  • 16.
    Lilly Ledbetter FairPay Act (2009)  Creates an open time frame for filing wage discrimination claims.  Before this law, the employee could file discrimination claim within 180/300 days of the occurrence of the discrimination according to Title VII.  the clock renews (regarding the 180/300 days) each time employee receives compensation that is based on the alleged discrimination
  • 17.
    Uniform Guidelines onEmployee Selection Procedure  A procedural document created to assist employers in complying with Title VII, Executive Order 11246 and other laws.  Covers all aspects of selection process.  Adverse impact: occurs when a selection procedure works to the disadvantage of a protected class. If the selection rate of a protected class is less than 80% of the selection rate of the class with highest rate, this is considered adverse impact.
  • 18.
    Adverse Impact-Example  Itis also known as four-fifths rule.  Example:  Males are the majority group:  20/50=40%  Selection rate for females is less than 80% of selection rate of males adverse impact Group Interviewe d Hired Selectio n rate Males 40 20 50% Female s 30 6 20%
  • 19.
    How to remedyadverse impact  Analyze data in more depth. Analysis of selection process components may not reveal adverse impact.  Modify the procedure  Stop the procedure and discard existing results.  Validate the job relatedness of the procedure  Justify the procedure as a business necessity.
  • 20.
    Vietnam Era Veterans ReadjustmentAssistance Act  Law enacted to enable Vietnam veterans rejoin labor market and prohibit discrimination against them.  It applies to the federal government and federal government contractors and subcontractors of $50,000 entered before 01/12/2003  It prohibits discrimination against these categories of veterans:
  • 21.
    Protected veterans  Speciallydisabled veterans  Vietnam era veterans  Recently separated (within one year of discharge)  Other protected veterans (the book contains more details)
  • 22.
    Jobs for VeteransAct  Amended VEVRAA  It applies to the federal government and federal government contractors and subcontractors of $100,000 entered after 01/12/2003  Extended the protection of VEVRAA in many aspect as:  Included all disabled veterans  Discharged veterans within 1-3 years.
  • 23.
    Rehabilitation Act (1973) Prohibited discrimination based on mental or physical disabilities.  Applies to federal government and federal contractors with contracts over $10,000.  According to the law, employers are required to provide reasonable accommodation for the qualified disabled employees/ candidates unless undue hardship can be demonstrated
  • 24.
    Rehabilitation Act (1973) Undue hardship may be based on business necessity or financial costs.
  • 25.
    Immigration Reform and ControlAct (1986)  Regulate the work of foreigners in the US  Determines the types of visas for different worker categories  Determines the acceptable documents that demonstrate the identity and right to work in the US  Determines the mechanism for employers to verify the eligibility of employees to work in US.  A lot of detail, read thoroughly
  • 26.
    Worker Adjustment andRetraining Notification Act (1988)  The law requires that covered employers to give a minimum of 60 days notice for plant closing or mass layoff to reduce the impact on affected employees.  Covered Employers:  Employers who employ 100 full time employees  Or Employers who employ full and part time employees working at least 4,000 hours/week
  • 27.
    Congressional Accountability Act  Itrequires that federal employee relations legislation enacted by the congress apply to the employees of the congress.
  • 28.
  • 29.
    Privacy Act (1974) This law protects the employment records of the federal government from disclosure without written authorization by the employee.
  • 30.
    Employee Polygraph Protection Act(1988)  It prevents employers from using lie detector tests for pre-employment screening or during employment, with certain exceptions.  it prohibits the employer to require, request, suggest, or cause an employee or prospective employee to take or submit to any lie detector test.
  • 31.
    Employee Polygraph Protection Act(1988)  it prohibits the employer use, refer, or inquire about the results of any lie detector test of any employee or prospective employee.  Prohibits discharge, discipline, discriminate against, deny employment, or threaten to take action against an employee or prospective employee for refusal to take a test, on the basis of the results of a test, for filing a complaint under the act or for exercising any rights afforded by the act
  • 32.
    Exceptions  Federal, stateand local governments  Tests administered by the federal government for federal contractors engaged in national security, intelligence or counterintelligence functions  To employees reasonably suspected of involvement in a workplace incident that results in economic loss to the employer  To prospective employees in certain jobs and industries, security guards, employees of pharmaceutical firms
  • 33.
    Consumer Credit Protection Act(1968)  The acts limits the amount of wages that can be garnished or withhold in any week by an employer to satisfy creditors by 25% of disposable income in general.  It allows for 50% of disposable income for court orders related to child support or alimony.
  • 34.
    Fair Credit ReportingAct (1970)  Employer must obtain a written authorization before a consumer report is ordered.  Consumer reports may include reports about: credit reports, criminal background checks, motor vehicle history and reference checks.
  • 35.
    Fair Credit ReportingAct (1970)  Employer must provide:  Written notice that a consumer report may be used.  A copy of the report and notice of adverse action (if taken) within three days.  Written response to any request for complete disclosure within 5 days
  • 36.
    Fair and AccurateCredit Transactions Act (2003)  Amended Fair Credit Reporting Act and relieved employers to use third parties for workplace investigations  Eliminated consent and disclosure when a third party conducts investigation that involves:  Suspected misconduct  Violation of law or regulations  Violation of any preexisting written policies of the employer
  • 37.
  • 38.
    Equal Employment Opportunity -EEO  Antidiscrimination legislation promised to stop taking employment decision based on race, gender, ethnicity, religion, age, color, military/veteran status or disability.  Decisions must be job and business related.  Protected class: people who are covered under a particular antidiscrimination law
  • 39.
    Types of Discrimination Disparate treatment: occurs when intentionally treating a protected class differently than other employees.  Examples:  Refusing to promote a female employee to a managerial position because women usually “does not succeed here”  Disciplining black employees when they violate policies while neglecting the violations of the white.
  • 40.
    Types of Discrimination Adverse/disparate impact: occurs when applying the same rules to all employees results in a negative effect on a protected class. Usually unintentional.  Examples:  Hiring high school graduates for a specific job may affect classes with limited access to education.  Requiring that applicants should lift specific weight in order to be hired may reduce the opportunity of women
  • 41.
    Types of Discrimination Perpetuating past discrimination: practices that repeats past policies like giving preference to applicants referred by current employees may appear neutral, but it may maintain the current mix.
  • 42.
  • 43.
    Griggs vs. DukePowers (1971)  Employment discrimination need not to be overt or intentional to be illegal  Employment practices can be illegal even if applied to all employees  Places the burden on the employer to prove that requirements are job related.
  • 44.
    McDonnell Douglas Corpvs. Green (1973)  Established the criteria for disparate treatment.  Ruled that a “prima facie” (on first view) case of disparate treatment can be shown if an employee:  Belongs to a protected class  Applied for a job when employer sought applicants  Qualified yet rejected  Was rejected by the employer kept looking for candidates.
  • 45.
    Albemarle Paper vs.Moody (1975)  Tests used for selection/ promotion must be valid predictors for job success.
  • 46.
    Washington vs. Davis Test is legal if it is job related even though it has adverse impact
  • 47.
    St. Mary’s HonorCenter vs. Hicks (1993)  Employee must prove that an employer’s reason for adverse impact is based n a lie and that lie was to cover up discrimination
  • 48.
    Mckennon vs. NashvilleBanner Publishing Co. (1995)  After acquired evidence cannot free employer from discrimination liability
  • 49.
    EEO Reporting  Agovernmental body has been created to enforce antidiscrimination laws; Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC).  employers with 100+ employees or federal contractors with 50+ employees and contracts of $50,000 are required to send annual reports about their workforce.
  • 50.
    Report Form  Thereport should include breakdown of the workforce by race, ethnicity and gender for nine job categories.  different forms available based on industry.
  • 51.
    Applicant flow data Federal contractors and subcontractors must be able to identify, where possible, the gender, race, ethnicity of each applicant.  Applicant can be defined as anyone who expresses an interest in employment regardless of being qualified.  Employer can request applicants voluntarily to fill a self-identification form to provide gender, race, ethnicity.  Visual survey is a second option.
  • 52.
    Affirmative Action  Affirmativeaction (AA) is a practice in which employers identify and correct any imbalances in underrepresentation of protected classes in the workforce (if exists).  Federal laws that apply to federal contractors and subcontractors that impose AA include:  Executive order 11246  VEVRAA and JVA  Rehabilitation Act  Legal obligations depend on contract value and number of employees.
  • 53.
    Affirmative Action Plans(AAP)  Definition: written plans that focus on hiring, training, compensating, promoting and terminating underrepresented groups.  AAP contains narrative and statistical components.
  • 54.
    Major elements ofAAP  Organizational profile: shows the staffing patterns to determine if barriers to EEO exist within any organizational unit.  Organizational display: provides graphical representation of organizational units.  Workforce analysis: a list of job titles ranked from the lowest to highest paid within the organizational unit  Job group analysis: list of all job titles that comprise each job group.  Availability analysis: study of the internal and external sources to determine theoretical availability of women and minorities for established job groups
  • 55.
    Availability analysis  Organizationmust examine the percentage of minorities or women with requisite skills in the reasonable recruitment area and percentage of minorities or women among those promotable, transferable, and trainable within the contractor's organization  The organization must compare percentages of minorities and women with availability and establish placement goals if considerable differences (underutilization) exist.
  • 56.
    Auditing for EEOand AAP  Compliance review: comprehensive analysis and evaluation of the organization hiring and employment practices, AAPs and the result of AA efforts.  Off-site review: consists of analysis and evaluation of AAP and supporting documentation.  Focused review: consists of on-site review focused on one or more areas of AAP and its application.
  • 57.
    Fairness issues  Reversediscrimination: courts has consistently allowed temporary preference to protected classes. Many cases have dealt with this situation.  Quota vs. merit hiring: Quota involves hiring fixed number of individuals based on protected classes that must be met at all costs. Quota are usually not allowed by courts.  Bona fide occupational qualification: very narrow exception and checked thoroughly by courts.
  • 58.
    Employment Practices Liability Insurance Covers organizations against workers claims of rights violations.  Covers legal costs regardless of the final judgment.  Does not cover:  Punitive damage  Liabilities covered by other insurance.  Employer may have duty to notify the carrier upon receipt a letter from a lawyer even if no claim has been filed.
  • 59.
  • 60.
    Types of SexualHarassment  Quid pro quo: means “this for that”. Occurs when an employee is forced to choose between giving in to superior’s sexual demands or forfeiting an economic benefit.  Hostile Environment: occurs when sexual or other discriminatory conduct is so severe and pervasive that it interferes with an individual’s performance. It can be created by supervisors, coworkers or nonemployees such as customers.
  • 61.
    Precedent-Setting Harassment Cases  MeritorSavings Bank vs. Vinson: Held that sexual harassment violates Title VII of the civil rights act.  Harris vs. Forklift System, Inc.: established the “reasonable person” standard.  Onacle vs. Sundowner Offshore Services, Inc.: established same gender harassment is actionable.  Faragher vs. City of Boca Raton and Ellerth vs. Burlington Northern Industries: held employer liable for supervisory harassment that resulted in adverse employment action.
  • 62.
    Employer Response to Harassment Have a written policy with clear definition of harassment and a statement that it will not be tolerated.  Establish effective complaint procedure  Provide training  Investigate every complaint  Discipline if necessary  Communicate using multiple methods to management and employees.