Refrigeration and Cryogenic Systems
Refrigeration and Cryogenic Systems
net/publication/233903699
CITATIONS READS
0 10,040
1 author:
Christopher J. Koroneos
National Technical University of Athens
155 PUBLICATIONS 2,808 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Exergetic life cycle assessment of a grid-connected, polycrystalline silicon photovoltaic system View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Christopher J. Koroneos on 31 May 2014.
Contents
Summary
The aim of this article is to provide the the basic information needed to understand
the technology of producing low and very low temperatures, i.e., refrigeration and
cryogenics. The article addresses the refrigeration, absorption, and liquefaction
processes from the engineering point of view. It avoids a purely theoretical approach
and it is not presenting technologies of limited, state of the art applications. In order
to enable the comprehension of these applications, a brief presentation of the
thermodynamics of the respective processes is also given.
For the reader who may be interested in a more detailed and in-depth knowledge of
refrigeration and cryogenics technologies, the references mentioned in the
bibliography will be helpful.
1 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
The methods used and the physical principles applied to achieve low temperatures
are shown in Table 1.
Refrigerators are systems that operate on a cyclic principle involving a working fluid
called a refrigerant. The working principle of a refrigerator is shown schematically in
Figure 1. In this scheme QL is the magnitude of the heat removed from the
refrigerated space at a given temperature TL, QH is the magnitude of the heat rejected
to the warm environment at a temperature TL, and Wnet,in is the net work input
needed to the refrigerator. QL and QH represent magnitudes and thus are positive
quantities. In the same scheme, a heat pump is shown, in order to demonstrate the
relation between the two applications, which is the inversion of the same function.
The objective of the refrigerator is to remove heat from the cold medium, whilst the
objective of the heat pump is to supply heat to a warm one. Both of these systems
transfer heat from low to high temperature media with the input of work.
(2)
These relations can also be expressed in the rate form by replacing the quantities QL,
QH and Wnet,in by respectively. Notice that both the COPR and
COPHP can be greater than 1. A comparison of the equations (1) and (2) reveals that
for fixed values of QL and QH:
(3)
This relation implies that COPHP >1 since COPR is a positive quantity. That is, a heat
pump will function in the case of heating a space, at worst, as a resistance heater,
supplying as much energy to the house as it consumes. In reality, however, part of
QH is lost to the outside air through piping and other devices, and COPHP may drop
below unity when the outside air temperature is too low. When this happens the
system normally switches to a resistance heating mode.
The cooling capacity of a refrigeration system that is, the rate of heat removal
2 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
Many of the impracticalities associated with the reversed Carnot cycle can be
eliminated by vaporizing the refrigerant completely before it is compressed and by
replacing the turbine with a throttling device, such as an expansion valve or capillary
tube. The cycle that results is called the ideal vapor-compression refrigeration
cycle, and it is shown schematically in Figure 2 and on a T-S diagram in Figure 3.
The vapor-compression refrigeration cycle is the most widely used cycle for
refrigerators, air conditioning systems, and heat pumps.
1 2: Isentropic compression
2 3: Heat rejection in a condenser at constant pressure
3 4: Throttling in an expansion device
4 1: Heat absorption in an evaporator at constant pressure
Step 1: The refrigerant leaves the evaporator at state 1 as a low pressure, low
temperature, saturated vapor. In an ideal cycle, the refrigerant enters the
compressor without heat gain/loss from the environment.
Step 3: Condensing brings the refrigerant out of superheated state and condenses it at
a constant pressure. The refrigerant becomes a high pressure, medium
3 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
Step 4: Once condensed, the refrigerant expands adiabatically (without heat transfer)
and reversibly (i.e., at constant enthalpy) in the expansion valve. The
refrigerant leaves the expansion valve as a low pressure, low temperature,
low enthalpy vapor.
Step 5: At constant pressure and in an adiabatic fashion, the refrigerant enters the
evaporator and evaporates. It is during the evaporation that heat transfer
occurs from the refrigerated space to the refrigerant.
An actual vapor-compression refrigeration cycle differs from the ideal one in several
ways, owing mostly to the irreversibilities that occur in various components. Two
common sources of the irreversibilities are fluid friction (which causes pressure
drops) and heat transfer to or from the surroundings. The T-S diagram of an actual
vapor compression refrigeration cycle is shown in Figure 4.
In the ideal cycle, the refrigerant leaves the evaporator and enters the compressor as
saturated vapor. This cannot be accomplished in practice, however, since it is not
possible to control the state of the refrigerant so precisely. Instead the system is
designed so that the refrigerant is slightly superheated at the compressor inlet. This
slight overdimensioning ensures that the refrigerant is completely vaporized when it
enters the compressor. Also, the line connecting the evaporator to the compressor is
usually very long, thus the pressure drop caused by fluid friction and heat transfer
from the surroundings to the refrigerant can be very significant. The result of
superheating, heat gain in the connecting line, and the pressure drops in the
evaporator and the connecting line, is an increase in the specific volume. This leads
to an increase in the power-input requirements to the compressor, since steady-flow
work is proportional to the specific volume. The compression process, however, will
involve frictional effects that increase the entropy, and heat transfer which may
increase or decrease the entropy, depending on the direction. Therefore the entropy
of the refrigerant may increase (process 1-2), or decrease (process 1-2') during the
actual compression process, depending on which effect dominates. The compression
process 1-2 may be even more desirable than the isentropic compression process
since the specific volume of the refrigerant and thus the work input requirements are
smaller in this case. Therefore, the refrigerant should be cooled during the
compression process whenever it is practical and economical to do so.
In the ideal case, the refrigerant is assumed to leave the condenser as saturated
liquid at the compressor exit pressure. In actual situations, however, it is unavoidable
to have some pressure drop in the condenser as well as in the lines connecting the
condenser to the compressor and to the throttling valve. Also, it is not easy to
execute the condensation processes with such precision that the refrigerant is
saturated liquid at the end and it is undesirable to route the refrigerant to the
throttling valve before the refrigerant is completely condensed. Therefore the
refrigerant is subcooled somewhat before it enters the throttling valve. The
refrigerant enters the evaporator with a lower enthalpy and thus can absorb more
heat from the refrigerated space. The throttling valve and the evaporator are usually
located very close to each other, so that the pressure drop in the connecting line is
small.
4 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
When designing the refrigeration system, there are several refrigerants to choose
from, such as chloroflurocarbons (CFCs), ammonia, hydrocarbons (propane, ethane,
ethylene, etc.), carbon dioxide, air (in the air conditioning of aircraft), and even
water (in applications above the freezing point). The right choice of refrigerant
depends on the situation at hand. CFCs such as R-11, R-12, R-22 and R-502 account
for over 90% of the market in the United States today.
Ethyl ether was the first commercially used refrigerant in vapor compression systems
in 1850, followed by ammonia, carbon dioxide, methyl chloride, sulfur dioxide,
butane, ethane, propane, isobutane, gasoline, and chloroflurocarbons, among others.
The industrial and heavy commercial sectors were very satisfied with ammonia and
still are, although ammonia is toxic. The advantages of ammonia over other
refrigerants are focused in its low cost, higher COPs (and thus lower energy costs),
more favorable thermodynamic and transport properties and thus higher heat transfer
coefficients (therefore it leads to smaller and lower-cost heat exchangers), greater
detectability in the event of a leak, and no effect on the ozone layer. The major
drawback of ammonia is its toxicity, which makes it unsuitable for domestic use.
Ammonia is predominantly used in food refrigeration facilities such as the cooling of
fresh fruits, vegetables, meat and fish; refrigeration of beverages and diary products
such as beer, wine, milk, and cheese; freezing of ice cream and other foods; and ice
production and low-temperature refrigeration in the pharmaceutical and other
process industries.
It is remarkable that the refrigerants used in the light commercial and household
sectors such as sulfur dioxide, ethyl chloride, and methyl chloride are highly toxic.
The widespread publicity of a few instances of serious leaks which resulted in
illnesses and deaths in the 1920s caused public pressure to ban or limit the use these
refrigerants, resulting in a need for the development of safe refrigerants for
household use. At the request of the Frigidaire Corporation, the General Motors
research laboratory developed R 21, the first member of the CFC family of
refrigerants in 1928. Of several CFCs developed, the research teams concluded that
R 12 was the most suitable refrigerant for commercial use, and gave the CFC
family the trade name "Freon". Commercial production of R 11 and R 12 began in
1931 by a company jointly formed by General Motors and E.I. du Pont de Nemours
and Co., Inc. The versatility and low-cost of CFCs made them the refrigerants of
choice. CFCs were also widely used in aerosols, foam insulation, polystyrol
insulating materials, and in the electronic industry as solvents to clean computer
chips.
5 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
The ozone crisis has caused a major stir in the refrigeration and air conditioning
industry, leading to skepticism over these widespread refrigerants. During the 1970s
it became evident that CFCs deplete the ozone layer that protects the Earth from
harmful ultraviolet radiation, while they enhance the greenhouse effect, hence
preventing infrared radiation from escaping the Earth. Their significant role both in
the greenhouse effect and in the ozone layer depletion became a major scientific and
public issue. Since then, and as a result of various national and international
legislative actions, the use of some CFSs has been banned and they are being
phased-out of use in many countries. In particular fully halogenated CFCs such as R
11, R 12, and R 115, are held responsible for the depletion of the ozone layer.
The non-fully halogenated refrigerants, such as R 22, have only about 5% of the
ozone-depleting capability of R 12. As a result of these developments, research has
focused on the development of refrigerants which are friendly to the ozone layer and
at the same time do not contribute to the greenhouse effect. The recently developed
chlorine-free R 134a is expected to replace R 12.
The temperature, and thus the pressure, of the refrigerant on the condenser side
depend on the medium to which heat is rejected. Higher COPs, achievable through
lower temperatures in the condenser, can be maintained if the refrigerant is cooled
by liquid water instead of air. However, the use of water as a cooling medium can
not be justified by its economic feasibility, except in large industrial refrigeration
systems. The temperature of the refrigerant in the condenser can not fall below the
temperature of the cooling medium (about 20°C for a household refrigerator system)
and the saturation pressure of the refrigerant at this temperature should be well
below its critical pressure, if the heat rejection process is to be approximately
isothermic. If no single refrigerant can meet the temperature requirements, then two
or more refrigeration cycles with different refrigerants can be used in series. Such a
refrigeration system is called a cascade system.
6 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
Heat pumps are generally more expensive to purchase and install than other heating
systems, but considering their life cycle they lead to lower total costs, as they count
for lower energy consumption. This explains why, in spite of their initial cost, the
popularity of heat pumps is increasing. About one third of all single-family homes
built in the United States in 1984 were using heat pumps. A study for southern
European countries predicts that by 2005 every third household will also feature one.
The most common energy source for heat pumps is atmospheric air (air-to-air
systems), although water and soil are also used as energy basins. The major problem
with air source systems is frosting, which occurs in humid climates when the
temperature falls below 2 5°C. The frost accumulation on the evaporator coils is
highly undesirable since it disables the heat transfer process. The coils can be
defrosted, by reversing the heat pump cycle, that is, by running it as an air
conditioner (in winter), but this results in a decline of the system’s efficiency. Water-
source systems usually use well water from depths of up to 80 m in the temperature
range of 5 18°C, and they do not have a frosting problem. They typically have
larger COPs but are more complex, more expensive, and require easy access to a
large reservoir of water, such as underground water. Soil-source systems are also
rather complex, as they require long tubing (buried pipes) placed deep in the ground
where the soil temperature is relatively constant. The COP of heat pumps usually
ranges between 1.5 and 4, depending on the particular system used and the
temperature of the source. Recently developed heat pumps, that imply
variable-speed electric driven motors, are at least twice as energy efficient as its
predecessors, in particular under partial load conditions.
Both the capacity and the efficiency of a heat pump fall significantly at low
temperatures. Therefore, most air source heat pumps require a supplementary
heating system such as an electrical resistance heater or an oil or gas fired boiler.
Since water and soil temperatures remain fairly constant, supplementary heating may
not be required for water-source or soil-source systems. In this case the heat pump
system must be fairly with respect to its capacity to cope with the maximum heating
load, which therefore may result in questionable economics.
Heat pumps and air conditioners have the same mechanical components. Therefore,
it is not economical to have two separate systems to meet the heating and cooling
requirements of a house or a building. The same system can be used as a heat pump
in the winter and air conditioner in the summer, as shown in Figure 5. This is
accomplished by adding a reversing valve to the cycle. As a result of this
modification, the condenser of the heat pump (located indoors) functions as the
evaporator of the air conditioner in summer. Similarly, the evaporator of the heat
pump (located outdoors) serves as the condenser of the air conditioner. This feature
increases the competitiveness of the heat pump. Such dual-purpose units, also known
as window or split-units, have been commonly used in motels in the USA. Since the
late eighties they have become particularly popular in retrofitting at domestic and
public building in southern European countries.
7 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
Heat pumps are most competitive in areas that have large cooling loads during the
cooling season and a relatively small heating load during the heating season. In these
areas, the heat pump can meet the entire cooling and heating needs of residential or
commercial buildings. The heat pump is least competitive in areas where the heating
load is significant and the cooling load is small, such as in the northern parts of the
Unites States or in the northern European countries.
When the fluid used throughout cascade refrigeration systems is the same, the heat
exchanger between the stages can be replaced by a mixing chamber (called flash
chamber), since it has better heat transfer characteristics. Such systems are called
multistage compression refrigeration systems. A two-stage compression refrigeration
system is shown in Figure 6.
In this system, the liquid refrigerant expands in the first expansion valve to the flash
chamber pressure. Part of the liquid vaporizes during the process. This saturated
vapor (state 7) is mixed with the superheated vapor from the low-pressure
compressor (state 2), and the mixture enters the high-pressure compressor at state 3.
This is, in essence, a refrigeration process. The saturated liquid (state 7) expands
through the second expansion valve into the evaporator, where it picks up heat from
the refrigerated space.
2.3.1 Example
8 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
2.3.2 Solution
The amount of heat removed from the refrigerated space and the compressor work
input per unit mass of refrigerant flowing through the condenser is:
(5)
The enthalpy at the state 9 is determined from an energy balance in the flash
chamber:
(6)
Also s9 = 0.7074 kJ/(kg.K), thus the enthalpy at state 4 (0.8 MPa, s4 = s9) is h4 =
207.76 kJ/kg. Substituting
(8)
9 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
Some applications require refrigeration at more than one temperature. This can be
accomplished by using a separate throttling valve and a separate compressor for each
evaporator operating at different temperatures However, such systems will be bulky
and probably too expensive. A more practical and economical approach will be to
route all the exit streams from the evaporators to a single compressor that will handle
the compression process for the entire system.
Figure 10. Temperature versus enthalpy diagram for a refrigeration-freezer unit with
one compressor
Absorption systems are characterized by the fact that the refrigerant is absorbed by
the absorbent on the low pressure side of the system and is given up on the pressure
side. Its major difference to the vapor compression cycle, presented in Figure 5
above, lies in the process by which the low-pressure refrigerant is transformed to a
high-pressure vapor. In the vapor compression cycle the low-pressure vapor is being
mechanically compressed. In an absorption cycle, however, the low-pressure vapor is
absorbed into a solution at low-pressure condition, subsequently pumped to a higher
pressure, and then heated to produce a high-pressure vapor. The advantage of the
absorption cycle lies in the fact that as a liquid has been pumped to a higher pressure,
less mechanical input is required than for the pumping of the gaseous medium in the
vapor compression cycle. One can therefore consider the mechanical compression
10 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
Figure 11 shows the schematic function of an absorption cycle. The refrigerant cycle
(path 2 3 4 1) is identical in both the vapor-compression cycle and the
absorption cycle. However, the compression function path (1 2) is replaced with a
solution circuit and a pump. Hence, instead of having mechanical work Win as an
input, thermal input (i.e., heat) Qin is being used.
Evaporator. System water flows through the tubes. The refrigerant is sprayed over
the surface of the tubes, it vaporizes and hence removes heat from the system water.
Generator. A heat source, like steam or solar heated water, flows through the tubes
and provides the heat required to separate the refrigerant from the dilute solution
coming in from the absorber. The refrigerant vapors are led to the condenser and the
concentrated solution returns to the absorber.
Condenser. Cooling water flowing through the tubes condenses the refrigerant
coming from the generator. The condensed refrigerant flashes through an expansion
valve (an orifice) back to the evaporator.
The absorption refrigeration cycle is a process that can be feasible provided the
absorbent features two properties:
· Low vapor pressure in the condenser, so that only the refrigerator will evaporate,
and
· Low specific heat in order to minimize thermal losses in the process.
For these reasons two absorbent-refrigerant mixtures are used widely commercially:
1. Lithium bromide (LiBr) water mixture, which is also known as aqueous LiBr
mixture, and
2. Water ammonia mixture or aqueous ammonia mixture.
There are absorption cycles that use other solution combinations and refrigerants,
like methylene chloride and dimethol, but they are not commercially marketed.
One of the two main absorption cycles used for refrigeration is the basic lithium
bromide-water (LiBr) absorption cycle, which has been in use since the 1940s in
refrigeration applications. It is schematically presented in Figure 12. Its key
11 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
LiBr absorption systems are categorized by the number of times the solution is
heated to produce refrigerant vapors. This is referred to as the number of effects.
Most LiBr absorption systems are single effect or double effect systems. A single
effect system uses the input heat once, while a double-effect system uses the heat
input for one deabsorption effect and subsequently uses the warm refrigerant vapors
as the heat source for the second effect.
This section describes the compressor function of a LiBr absorption machine in the
absorption cycle. The condenser, expansion device, and evaporator components of
the LiBr absorption machine were discussed in the previous section and perform the
same function as those used in vapor-compression systems. The metering device is
much simpler since the pressure differences are small. The metering can be achieved
with an orifice and the height of refrigerant liquid. Condensers and evaporators in
absorption systems typically require pumping and spray headers to ensure wetted
surfaces and heat transfer.
12 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
the high stage generator must be higher than that used for a single-effect machine.
The second most widely used refrigeration system is based on the aqueous ammonia
absorption cycle (AAR). This system is mainly met in industrial applications, in
chemical processes, in the food industry, and in drying processes. It is also suitable
for solar energy applications. The main points to be kept in mind concerning the
AAR cycle are the following:
· Water is the absorbent and ammonia is the refrigerant (i.e., the opposite of the
LiBr cycle).
· The cooling output is in most cases liquid ammonia, separated from the ammonia
in the AAR machine, as opposed to the chilled water used in LiBr absorption
systems. Due to the fact that ammonia is the refrigerant, the output of an AAR
system can be as low as −60°C.
· The ammonia and water vapor are separated by using a fractional distillation
process, because a small amount of water is converted to the vapor state within
the temperatures and pressures prevailing in the absorption cycle.
· It is not possible to use copper in the construction of AAR systems, as copper
and ammonia react adversely with each other.
· If the system is installed in a closed space, ventilation is required according to
the standards for ammonia refrigeration.
In an AAR absorption cycle, the low-pressure refrigerant vapor from the evaporator
is converted to high-pressure refrigerant by using a thermal compressor rather than a
mechanical compressor. As the properties of the refrigerant/absorbent solution
cannot be illustrated directly in a P-H diagram, other charts and tables have been
developed to aid in the analysis of the thermal compression cycle.
There are several charts or tables available to determine the properties of the
aqueous ammonia solution at the different locations in the AAR machine. There are
three common methods used to obtain ammonia-water property data.
13 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
The standard of comparison for all power cycles, i.e. the Carnot cycle, and its
reverse, the reversed Carnot cycle, are identical except that the reversed Carnot
cycle operates “backward.” This leads to the conclusion that the power cycles can be
used as refrigeration cycles by simply reversing them. In fact, the vapor-compression
refrigeration cycle is a essentially a modified Rankine cycle operating in reverse.
Another example is the reversed Stirling cycle, which is the cycle on which Stirling
refrigerators operate. Possibly the most interesting gas refrigeration cycle is the
reversed Brayton cycle, presented in Figure 15.
All the processes described above are internally reversible, and the cycle executed is
the ideal gas refrigeration cycle. In actual gas refrigeration cycles, the compression
and expansion process will deviate from the isentropic ones, and T3 will be higher
than T0 unless the heat exchanger is infinitely large.
(9)
14 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
Despite the low COP of the gas refrigeration cycles, these systems have two
advantages: They consist of simple components with limited weight and are therefore
particularly suitable for aircraft cooling. They can also incorporate regeneration,
which makes them suitable for liquefaction of gases and cryogenic applications of
extremely low temperatures.
At temperatures above the critical-point value, a substance exists in the gas phase
only. Hence, a fluid’s temperature must be reduced below its critical temperature so
that it will become liquid. The critical temperatures of helium, hydrogen, and
nitrogen, three of the most commonly used liquefied gases, are −268, −240 and
−147°C respectively. Such low temperatures cannot be produced with the
refrigeration cycles and systems described in the above paragraphs. A solution to this
problem is the liquefaction of gases by utilizing the “Joule Thompson” effect.
According to this one can achieve the temperatures needed for gas liquefaction by
throttling. In order to achieve a temperature drop by throttling, the initial temperature
should be lower than the inversion temperature and the Joule Thompson coefficient
positive. The maximum temperature drop occurs in this case if the
throttling starts at a state on the inversion curve.
Several cycles are used successfully for the liquefaction of gases. The two most
commonly used are the Linde and the Claude liquefiers.
The Linde liquefier is the simplest way for liquefying gases, as can be seen from its
schematic operation principle in Figure 17.
15 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
The make up gas, which has to be cleaned of contaminants that may solidify during
the process, is mixed with the uncondensed portion of the gas from the previous
cycle, and the mixture at state 2 of the temperature-entropy diagram in Figure 18 is
compressed by means of an isothermal process due to intercooling. The high-pressure
gas is cooled, in an after-cooler by a cooling medium or by a separate external
refrigerator system, to state 4. The gas is further cooled in a regenerative counterflow
heat exchanger by the uncondensed portion of gas from the previous cycle to state 5,
and it is throttled at an expansion valve to state 6, which is a saturated liquid-vapor
mixture state. The liquid produced is collected, in state 7, as the final product and the
vapor (state 8) is driven back, through the refrigerator, to cool the high pressure gas
approaching the throttling valve. Finally, the gas is mixed with fresh makeup gas and
the cycle is repeated. This cycle is also used for the solidification of gases, like CO2,
whose critical state is at 31°C and 73.85 MPa.
Figure 18. Temperature versus enthalpy diagram of a Linde system for liquefying
gases
The Claude liquefier is derived from the Linde system with the following
modification: the expansion valve of the Linde process is replaced by an expander,
resulting in an increase of the produced liquid gas, as is shown in Figure 19. This
change can also lead to the utilization of the work obtained by the expander, which
can be a turbine or a reciprocating one, to drive the compressor, hence enabling
higher overall performance of the system. In order to prevent damage to the
expander due to the presence of two phases of the working medium, the expander
receives the working medium at an intermediate state.
In all the applicable cycles, heat exchangers are used to enable the extraction or
addition of heat from and to the working medium. The same applies in cryogenic
applications like the liquefaction of gases, as described in the previous section.
16 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
which often lies below −100°C. At such temperatures the design, the construction,
and the material properties of the exchangers have to be able to cope with effects
like the contraction occurring due to the increased stresses caused by the low
temperatures.
The materials used must therefore be able to resist high stress changes and shock
loads. For this, tough materials should be used. As most materials become brittle at
temperatures below −30°C, they are liable to fracture at full stress. Hence materials
should be chosen which do not become brittle at low temperatures, such as stainless
steels, aluminum, copper, and copper-nickel alloys. Even if these materials fail, the
risk of a sudden brittle fracture is limited, providing time for measures to avoid a
complete failure.
Another problem that has to be dealt with is the necessity of removing the moisture
entirely, in order to prevent its freezing and the resulting destruction of the
exchangers tubes. To avoid such risks, the units have to be dried before entering
operation. This is usually achieved by circulating warm air through the exchanger.
Finally, the controls used in cryogenic heat exchangers, like valves and thermostats,
have to be designed and constructed to cope with the low temperature conditions. In
refrigeration units where the produced refrigeration must be transferred to various
places, magnetic and constant pressure valves are mainly used. Temperature control
is achieved by thermostats. Their performance depends not only on their features but
also on the positions in which they are placed.
The Linde and the Hamspon heat exchangers were the first types used for
cryogenics, however their efficiency is no longer considered to be satisfactory. The
most frequently used systems are instead:
(a) The coil-tube exchanger,
(b) The switching regenerator,
(c) The reversing exchanger, and
(d) Compact units.
In certain applications one can also find heat pipes systems. A brief description of
the four most commonly met exchanger types is given in the following sections.
The coil-tube heat exchanger is an exchanger that consists of different groups of tube
17 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
bundles that carry different liquids. These tube bundles are coiled around a core
cylinder in a number of successive layers and end up at collectors at each end of the
exchanger’s shell, as can be seen in Figure 20. The tubes form layers coiled in
opposite directions and separated in order to allow the shell-side fluid to contact all
the tubes. High-pressure gasses flow inside the tubes, while low-pressure cold gas
flows on the shell side. Hence, if the exchanger is used as an evaporator, the
refrigeration medium evaporates outside the tubes and the obtained gas or liquid,
which is going to be refrigerated, is driven through the tubes. This kind of evaporator
is used for liquid and gas refrigeration in the process industry.
The coil-tube heat exchanger has become widely used, as it features a series of
advantages. Heat exchange is possible with more than two fluids and the exchanger
can cope with high pressure and large temperature ranges. Large heat transfer areas
of up to 25 000 m2 are possible. Despite this, the design is fairly compact. The shape
and geometry of the exchanger can be adapted to requirements. There is no
limitation to the size of the system, as far as its manufacturing is concerned.
Contraction due to low temperatures can occur without inducing undue stresses, and
vibration problems are not encountered.
Switching regenerators used for cryogenics operate in a way similar to those used for
high temperature regeneration. The warm and cold streams of gasses are led
periodically through towers, which contain high heat capacity and high surface area
material, such as thin, corrugated strips of aluminum.
The main reason for this exchanger type becoming popular in the process industry is
that the manufacturing of very large systems is possible, enabling the large-scale
production of liquefied gases. A further advantage lies in the fact that moisture and
carbon dioxide can be removed from the feed stream by condensation and
subsequently be evaporated into the outgoing waste stream. In order to achieve this
the operating conditions have to be precisely controlled.
18 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
maintenance costs of reversing heat exchangers are lower than the respective costs
of switching regenerators. However, their initial cost is higher.
Compact heat exchangers, like the one shown in Figure 21, are made of aluminum or
aluminum alloys. They feature high surface to volume ratio, enabling the
construction of very compact units, with limited weight. Considering the fact that
their heat transfer efficiency is very high, exceeding 90%, and that the yield strength
(physical property of the material) of aluminum increases with lowering
temperatures, they are suitable for applications where high efficiencies are needed at
a limited volume and weight. These advantages offset the initial cost, which is rather
high.
Figure 21. Compact heat exchanger (Courtesy of The Trane Company, 1984)
Related Chapters
Glossary
19 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
Bibliography
Air Liquide. Catalogues of companies active in the refrigeration and cryogenics sector: BASF, LINDE,
Trane.
Cengel Y. A., and Boles M. A. (1994). Thermodynamics, An engineering approach, pp. 472 486.
New York: Mc Graw Hill Inc. [This is a very comprehensive approach to gas power cycles.]
Dorgan C. B., Leigth S. P., and Dorgan C. E. (1995). Application Guide for Absorption
Cooling/Refrigeration using Recovered Heat, pp. 55 93. Atlanta: American Society of Heating
Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers Inc. [This is an excellent handbook for applications in
this field.]
Faires V. M., and Simmang C. M. (1978). Thermodynamics, pp. 460 475. New York: MacMillan
Publishing Co. Inc. [The basics of thermodynamic processes are presented in a synoptic and illustrating
way.]
Flynn T. (1996). Cryogenic Engineering, New York: Marcel Dekker Inc. [A comprehensive handbook
on cryogenics, with emphasis being placed on the engineering aspects, that provides extensive data for
most cryogenic problems.]
Gupta J. P. (1989). Working with Heat Exchangers, pp. 262 267. Washington: Hemisphere
Publishing Corporation. [A synoptic approach to the use of heat exchangers in the field of cryogenics.]
Pittsburgh Corning Europe (1992). Foamglas Industrial Insulation Handbook. Waterloo: PC Europe.
[A very comprehensive handbook on industrial insulation applications, with detailed case studies.]
20 of 21 6/2/2012 14:34
REFRIGERATION AND CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS http://greenplanet.eolss.net/EolssLogn/searchdt_advanced/searchdt_cat...
Schmidt F. W., Henderson R. E., and Wolgemuth C. H. (1993). Introduction to Thermal Sciences, pp.
268 285. John Wiley and Sons Inc. [The thermodynamics of heat exchangers are presented in this
book, accompanied by an appendix that features tables, charts and data for most of the problems to be
met in this field.]
Sotiropoulos V. A. (1986). Industrial Refrigeration, pp. 191 216 and 359 371. Giahoudis
Giapoulis Press [In Greek. A textbook with well presented case studies of industrial refrigeration.]
Stoecker W. F., and Jones J. W. (1982). Refrigeration and Air-Conditioning. New York: McGraw
Hill.
Biographical Sketches
Christopher J. Koroneos studied Chemical Engineering in Columbia University where he also earned
his Doctorate. His research interests are in the areas of Environmental Engineering, Energy
Engineering, Process Engineering, Environmental Process Synthesis, and Life Cycle Analysis.
At the present time he is a Teaching Associate and Visiting Professor at the Laboratory of Heat Transfer
and Environmental Engineering of the Mechanical Engineering Department of Aristotle University of
Thessaloniki, in Greece. His professional experience includes being Associate Professor at the
Department of Chemical Engineering at Columbia University and head of Program Development of
Earth Engineering Center at Columbia University.
He has many years experience in the industry working as Senior Research Engineer, Process Engineer,
Process Development Engineer, and Consultant. He has multiple professional affiliations and many
professional awards.