MEMORY
This knowledge includes:
STUDY DESIGN, 2010 - 2014
Comparison of models for explaining human memory:
Atkinson-Shiffrin’s multi-store model of memory including
maintenance and elaborative rehearsal, serial position effect and
chunking
Alan Baddeley and Graham Hitch’s model of working memory: central
executive, phonological loop, visuo-spatial sketchpad, episodic buffer
levels of processing as informed by Fergus Craik and Robert Lockhart
organisation of long-term memory including declarative and episodic
memory, and semantic network theory
Neural basis of memory:
role of the neuron in memory formation informed by the work of E.
Richard Kandel
roles of the hippocampus and temporal lobe
consolidation theory
memory decline over the lifespan
amnesia resulting from brain trauma and neurodegenerative diseases
including dementia and Alzheimer’s disease
WHO REMEMBERS ??
How is information processed?
MODELS OF MEMORY
MEMORY
Types of Memory • Processes
Iconic – Encoding, storage,
Short-Term retrieval
Mnemonics & Working • Methods
Memory
Long
– Recognition, recall
term
Implicit • Anatomy of
Explicit Memory
Levels of processing – Hippocampus and
Amygdala
SCHACTER (2001)“SEVEN SINS OF MEMORY”
Memories are transient (fade with time)
We do not remember what we do not pay
attention to
Our memories can be temporarily blocked
We can misattribute the source of memory
We are suggestible in our memories
We can show memory distortion (bias)
We often fail to forget the things we would like
not to recall (persistence of memory)
THE RECONSTRUCTIVE NATURE OF MEMORY
Bartlett
Assigning a name influences the reproduction.
The transformations are in the direction of conventional
representations (highest frequency of exposure)
Features that are not at first recognized are elaborated
until recognition is produced
Once a recognizable feature is produced, it is reduced
to its most conventional simplification
The Reconstruction: Not Just for Stories
Images, Too!
THE NEURO-ANATOMY OF MEMORY
Hippocampus
Amygdala
HIPPOCAMPUS
Anatomy of
Memory
Amygdala: emotional memory and memory consolidation
Basal ganglia & cerebellum: memory for skills, habits and
CC responses
Hippocampus: memory recognition, spatial, episodic
memory, laying down new declarative long-term memories
Thalamus, formation of new memories and working
memories
Cortical Areas: encoding of factual memories, storage of
episodic and semantic memories, skill learning, priming.
WHAT DOES THE HIPPOCAMPUS DO?
Place cells neurons that respond when
you are in a specific place, in the place
field of the neuron. So a place cell would
fire when you are in your bedroom or
house, etc. Each hippocampal neuron has
a place field in many different
environments. At first when you put the
rat in the new environment, no neurons
fire. Then as the rat becomes familiar
with the room, neurons fire for particular
parts of the room.
WHAT DOES THE HIPPOCAMPUS DO?
Configural Association Theory The theory
that the hippocampus retains the
interrelation among cues, spatially and
temporally. So it remembers the relationship
between a visual cue and a location as
signaling food.
Path Integration Theory the hippocampus
calculates current location, past location,
and future location from one’s own
movement.
The Amygdal: Fear
and Memory
AMYGDALA
The amygdala modulates the formation of
memories in other brain structures, such as
the hippocampus. Information or events of
particular emotional / motivational
significance are better remembered than
those of little importance (c.f. flashbulb
memory).
Lesions in humans and primates reveal a
role for the amygdala in the perception of
emotional cues and the generation of
emotional responses, particularly those
associated with negative emotions such as
fear.
AMYGDALA
Amygdala lesions before retention testing
disrupt conditioned fear. Hence, the
amygdala may be the site of storage of fear
memories.
Temporary inactivation by drugs during
acquisition has the same effect, suggesting a
genuine role in memory encoding.
Memory is not a ‘single organ’ or a single ‘thing’, rather it consists
of a collection of complex interconnected and interacting systems
We do not have a memory, but we have different memory systems
which share a common function of:
storing information Processing different
(learned through experience) information
Memory
systems
Storing information
retrieving the information
(in different ways & types of
(when needed)
information)
our perceptual systems, eg vision are constantly inputting
information, however the brain must work out what to attend to,
process and store in memory, and what not to!
DEFINING MEMORY
Memory is often defined as the storage and retrieval of
information acquired through learning.
the existence of memory indicates that learning has
occurred and the memory is the internal record or
representation of an event &/or experience.
Memory is also defined as requiring and as information
processing (think… like a computer)
Memory as information processing -
Encoding – converting information to a useable form
Storage – retaining information in memory
Retrieval – information recovered from memory when
needed
All three processes are required and if any one is not
included, the memory will not form.
Memory as an info-processing system
Memory is an active (uses energy) information-processing system that:
Receives,
Organises
Stores &recovers information
• Info is
Encoding retained in Retrieval
brain
• Info is • Info is
Incoming
sensory input converted Storage recovered
for storage when
needed
Memory actively alters and organises information, then stores it so that it can be
easily retrieved when needed
There are 3 key processes involved in these systems. If any of these processes fail,
memory will fail
An additional aspect of the Atkinson & Shiffrin human multi store model included:
Structural features & Control processes.
MEMORY LIKE A
COMPUTER ????
Encoding = hitting the letters on the key board ->
it goes into the computer
Storage = we hit ‘save’ -> we name the file and
store the information for later on when
we save the file
= process of getting past information
Retrieval
back -> we need to use the right ‘cues’
in order to get the information back,
but if we do then we have the original
MODEL’S FOR EXPLAINING HUMAN MEMORY
As the human memory is complex and multifaceted, is it
NOT studied together, rather it is broken down into
pieces or sections, each being studied separately.
Each of these is referred to as a MODEL
The three main theories that explain how human
memory functions are:
1. Atkinson-Shiffrin multi-store model
2. Baddeley and Hitch’s model of working memory
3. Craik and Lockhart’s levels of processing
framework
ATKINSON-SHIFFRIN’S MULTI-
STORE MODEL OF MEMORY
Based in the 1960’s
Proposed a shift in the single memory model => assumption
that human memory has several systems/processes involved.
By Richard Atkinson & Richard Shiffrin – Americans.
This model was also called/considered modal model, as it
merged and represented many other models during this time.
It is also known as the stage model, as it put forward that the
flow of information moves in stages through each component
of memory.
Information passes through 3 levels of memory as it is
encoded, stored and retrieved, and these 3 levels are sensory
register, short term store & long term store
Sensory register Reh
e
• The entry point for all new at arsal
ti
poi me
information into memory from crit n
ica t
the external environment mo l for
per r
• Stores vast amount of incoming ma e
If information is attended sto nent
visual information, for 100’s ra
(LT ge
to, it moves into short milliseconds M)
term memory store
Short term store
• A temporary working memory
• Here we can manipulate information from every
If day/common tasks
information • Holds all information that we are aware of at that
is not point in time
attended • Has a limited capacity – 7 items at 1 time
to, it is lost • Only held for about 30 sec unless we make an effort
to keep it there (attend to it), eg rehearsal
Long term store
• Information held relatively permanently in an highly organised way
• Essentially can be an unlimited capacity
• Unlike sensory register & short term store – information in long term store does not usually
decay and can stored for …… a whole lifetime
• According to Atkinson & Shiffrin – it is our inability to retrieve required information that
results ineffective search strategies
• Problems with retrieval may also be due to ‘interference’ with the information and this results
in a disruption in the retrieval process
Atkinson-Shiffrin multi-store model
Rehearsal
Paid attention Info encoded or
to info rehearsed
Sensory Sensory Short-term Long-term
info Memory Memory Memory
Retrieval
Info not paid Not rehearsed Various reasons
attention to… or encoded
Lost from sensory Displaced from
memory short-term memory Forgotten
STRUCTURAL & CONTROLLED PROCESSES
Structural features of memory are the permanent
features that do not alter from situation to situation – they
are three levels of information processing:
Sensory memory,
Short term memory (STM) &
Long term memory (LTM)
Control processes are the activities the individual does to
process the information (eg they have ‘control’ over what
they attended to and process)
Attention – no information will be encoded if we don’t pay
attention to it
Rehearsal – process that goes over information and helps it be
stored
But all of this was developed over 40 years ago ….. And
we now have more knowledge …
EVALUATING ATKINSON &
SHIFFRIN
Advantages Limitations
Identified characteristics It is now clear that information does
of short term store as not ‘just flow’ as described in Atkinson
being different and apart & Shiffrin’ 3 stage sequence
from long term memory There is a separate sensory register
Recognised the for auditory information & haptic
importance of short term (touch) information – and maybe even
store & its fundamental more now referred to as a sensory
roles memory system
Maintenance and Short term store now believed to be a
rehearsal are still much more complex system
relevant, although now Different types of rehearsal have been
more complex identified in short term memory
Despite some newly learnt Long term store is no longer a single
differences, still held as store -> rather it includes more
the original multi store complex systems & structures of
storage.
model, although now just
Stages of memory – Sensory Memory
Sensory Memory
Entry point of memory
Capacity to store all sensory stimuli (unlimited)
Stored as the original form of stimulus (buffer –
need more processing before it can be stored)
Not consciously aware of most of the info in
sensory stage, directing attention to it is what
causes transfer to short-term memory
Incoming stimuli is stored as a memory trace in
different sensory registers based on the type of
sense
Iconic memory – visual
Echoic memory - auditory
Sensory Memory includes
Iconic memory ( I as in eye)
Visual images are stored here for about 0.2-0.4 seconds
Stored as overlapping images
Allows perception of flowing movement during a film,
or a figure drawn with a sparkler at night
Echoic memory (e as in ear)
Sound stimuli are stored here for around 3-4 seconds
This is longer than in iconic memory as sound takes
longer to produce
Allows comprehension of speech by connecting
individual sounds coherently into words and sentences
Stages of memory – Short-term memory
Activity: Capacity of STM
Read aloud the following series of numbers and ask students to recall each
line in order.
6, 4, 7 (3 items)
9, 0, 1, 8 (4 items)
4, 3, 5, 7, 2 (5 items)
7, 1, 3, 8, 9, 4 (6 items)
3, 6, 8, 4, 9, 1, 5 (7 items)
2, 6, 4, 9, 1, 5, 7, 3 (8 items)
1, 7, 5, 8, 6, 3, 9, 2, 4 (9 items)
2, 6, 7, 3, 5, 4, 9, 1, 8, 3 (10 items)
Onaverage, how many numbers did each person recall from each list?
This is the capacity of STM.
Activity: Duration of STM
Students learn the following sequence of numbers
4, 5, 3, 6, 2, 7, 8
Test immediately, then after 2 minutes
How many people remembered the sequence? This is duration of STM
Stages of memory: Short-term memory
Short-term memory (STM) is a memory system that has
a limited capacity and duration
It also stores the information in an encoded format
Described as the “seat of conscious thought” –
information only registers in STM once it is paid
attention to – in conscious awareness
Duration of STM
Without rehearsal (active use), recall starts to decline after
about 12 seconds and is almost completely gone after 18
seconds (occasionally can last up to 30 sec)
Using rehearsal, information can be retained indefinitely in
STM
Short-term memory
Capacity of STM
Theamount of pieces of information that can be stored in
STM is 7 ± 2 (between 5-9 items)
Adding in more items displaces (pushes out) existing items in
STM – this is called displacement, shown below
Now becomes ..
Recalling information from long-term memory can also
displace items from STM
Information is lost primarily within STM by either
displacement (pushing out) or by decay (not being used-
think fruit!)
SHORT TERM MEMORY
Capacity of STM cont…..
Chunking is a method of increasing the capacity of
STM
Definiton: grouping or separate bits of information into a
larger single chunk of information.
Separate pieces of info are remembered as single units
(groups info into chunks)
Only similar info can be chunked together (chunking)
Still only retain 7 ± 2 chunks
Chunks can be numbers, images, words, sentences, phrases
and even abbreviations
This is why we have phone numbers broken into parts ……
5427 2600 rather than 54272600.
SHORT TERM MEMORY
STM as working memory
Term working memory is used to emphasise the active part
of memory where information we are aware of constantly, is
actively ‘worked on; in a variety of ways
Enables us to use the information in sensory memory and
move it to LTM
Often we combine information from sensory memory and
LTM to perform mental processes, such as emotions,
comprehension, problem solving, planning & daydreaming.
So this ‘working memory’ provides a temporary storage
facility and mental workspace for information currently
being used within a conscious cognitive activity.
The STM working memory is often compared to a computer
Effects of rehearsal
Rehearsal is the process of actively and consciously
manipulating information to keep it in STM for longer
than the normal 18 sec. (Increases duration)
Maintenance rehearsal
Repeating info over and over usually vocally (out loud) or
sub-vocally (in your head)
Works indefinitely to keep info in STM
Does not always transfer info into long-term memory
Elaborate rehearsal
Links new info to existing knowledge in a meaningful way
More active than maintenance rehearsal (requires more
effort)
Very effective in transferring info into long-term memory,
EFFECTS OF REHEARSAL
Maintenance
Rehearsal
Paid attention Elaborative
to info Rehearsal
Sensory Sensory Short-term Long-term
info Memory Memory Memory
Retrieval
Info not paid Not rehearsed Various reasons
attention to… or encoded
Lost from sensory Displaced from
memory short-term memory Forgotten
Stages of memory – Long-term memory
Long-term memory (LTM) is the relatively permanent
memory system that has potentially unlimited capacity
and duration (life-long)
Info in LTM is inactive (not in use) and we are not
consciously aware of it until it is retrieved
Due to the sheer volume of info in LTM, we use cues
(intentional or unintentional) to speed up the process of
retrieval
Cues enable retrieval of specific info, not the entire contents
of LTM – usually very efficient and very fast
Once retrieved, the info is stored in STM until it is no longer
needed/in use. It is then transferred back into LTM
Failure to retrieve info from LTM is usually due to poor
organisation during encoding and storage, or an inappropriate
cue was used during retrieval
Types of long-term memory
Memories in LTM are relatively permanent or at least
very longlasting
Forgetting is most likely due to a failure to retrieve info
– poor encoding or poor cue
Retrieval cues: a stimulus that assists in the process of
locating and retrieving information stored in memory.
There are two major types of LTM (LTM stores):
① Procedural memory (Implicit memories – “how?”)
Knowing how to do stuff – actions and activities
Often difficult to explain this knowledge
Usually learnt through observation and practice
Not usually consciously recalled
Types of long-term memory
② Declarative memory (Explicit memories – “What?”)
Memories of facts and/or events
Usually consciously recalled
Two types of declarative memory:
a) Episodic memory
Memories of specific events or personal experiences
Include references to “when” and “where”
b) Semantic memory
Memories of general academic knowledge
Facts not necessarily related to a specific place or time
Include references about “what” and “who”
Characteristics of the stages of memory
Stage of Capacit
Function Form of storage Duration
memory y
Sensory •Receives sensory Original sensory form Unlimited •Varies based
memory information E.g. lingering sense of on sensation
(SM) (stimuli) from sound or pressure •Usually
environment between 0.2 –
4 sec
•Occasionally
up to 10 sec
Short-term •Receives info from Encoded in terms of 7 ±2 •Usually 18-
memory SM physical properties of pieces or 20 sec
(STM) •Receives info from stimuli chunks of •Occasionally
LTM E.g. Starts with L info up to 30 sec
Long-term •Storehouse for Encoded in terms of Unlimited •Potentially
memory encoded info semantics - meaning permanent
(LTM) coming from STM
Levels of processing framework –
CRAIK AND LOCKHART
Craik and Lockhart proposed a framework of memory
that emphasised the importance of the level of
processing in how well information is stored in LTM
Info is stored best in LTM semantically (by meaning) so
if the meanings of concepts are processes during
learning, they are more likely to be recalled later –
elaborate rehearsal is more effective for LTM than
maintenance rehearsal
The deeper the level of processing (more elaborate
encoding) the better the recall
Visualencoding – “is there a letter k in the word?”
Acoustic encoding – “does it rhyme with hat?”
Semantic encoding – “is it a synonym of difficult?”
Levels of processing framework
Levels of processing or depth are hard to define
specifically and to measure
Despite this problem the idea of better processing and
therefore better storage is supported widely by research
Craik and Lockhart
Shallow Visual What the word Colours, shapes and
processing encoding looks like patterns detected
Intermediate Acoustic What the word Item is identified
processing encoding sounds like
Deep Semantic What the word Meaningful
processing encoding means associations are made
Model of working memory –
BADDELEY AND HITCH’S
Baddeley and Hitch’s model of working memory
describes STM as a functional system with three
components that work independently but can also
interact:
① Phonological loop (Verbal working memory)
Verbalinformation is stored in a sound-based form
(phonological)
Only hold about 2 sec worth of info (around 7 items
depending on length of words)
② Visuo-spatial sketchpad (Visual working memory)
Visual info is anything you can see or imagine, spatial info is
position and location of objects in space
Also has limited duration and capacity (around 4 items)
Model of working memory –
BADDELEY AND HITCH’S
③ Central executive
Controls attention
Integrates information from the phonological loop and visuo-spatial
sketchpad with info from LTM
Coordinates the flow of info between the working memory system
and LTM
Manipulates the info held in the phonological loops and visuo-spatial
sketchpad – the working component of the model of working
memory
Episodic buffer (a fourth component added in 2000)
A sub-system of the working memory that enables the different
components to interact with LTM
Has limited capacity (about 4 chunks of info)
Can hold info in any form and so can integrate phonological loop and
visuo-spatial sketchpad – temporary workspace where various pieces
of info can be put together in a meaningful way
Model of working memory
Sensory input
Rehearsal Rehearsal
Phonological Visuo-spatial
loop sketchpad
Central Executive
Episodic Buffer
Long-Term Memory
ALAN BADDELEY AND GRAHAM HITCH’S
MODEL OF WORKING MEMORY
Phonological
Loop
storage of verbal
speech information Episodic Buffer
Central Executive
Integrates useful LTM
• Controls attention into what currently
being worked on
• Integrates info from the
two storage sub systems Pulls together streams
of different info into
• does the ‘working out’ ‘episodes’ as a
meaningful whole
•The seat of consciousness
The workbench
Visio spatial
Sketchpad
Storage of visual and
spatial information
BADDELEY & HITCH’S MODEL OF
WORKING MEMORY
Read example on pg. 319
Once we have read it .....Going to party the following
is:
- phonological loop stores the directions
- Visio spatial sketchpad visualises the route
- Central executive directs the Episodic buffer to
combine information from storage branches
- Episodic buffer also adds information from LTM
- Episodic buffer used as the mental ‘workbench’ to
make adjustments
Again … just in cases you need to refresh
Stages of memory – LONG-TERM memory
Long-term memory (LTM) is the relatively permanent
memory system that has potentially unlimited capacity
and duration (life-long)
Info in LTM is inactive (not in use) and we are not
consciously aware of it until it is retrieved
Due to the sheer volume of info in LTM, we use cues
(intentional or unintentional) to speed up the process of
retrieval
Cues ( retrieval cues) enable retrieval of specific info, not the
entire contents of LTM – usually very efficient and very fast
Once retrieved, the info is stored in STM until it is no longer
needed/in use. It is then transferred back into LTM
Failure to retrieve info from LTM is usually due to poor
Organisation during encoding and storage, or an inappropriate
cue was used during retrieval
Types of long-term memory
Memories in LTM are relatively permanent or at least
very longlasting
Forgetting is most likely due to a failure to retrieve info
– poor encoding or poor cue
There are two major types of LTM (LTM stores):
① Procedural memory (Implicit memories – “how?”)
Knowing how to do stuff – actions and activities
Often difficult to explain this knowledge
Usually learnt through observation and practice
Not usually consciously recalled
E.g. making a cup of tea/riding a bike
Types of long-term memory
② Declarative memory (Explicit memories – “What?”)
Memories of facts and/or events
Usually consciously recalled
Two types of declarative memory:
a) Episodic memory
Memories of specific events or personal experiences
Include references to “when” and “where”
b) Semantic memory
Memories of general academic knowledge
Facts not necessarily related to a specific place or time
Include references about “what” and “who”
TULVING (1983)
Tulving argues that semantic & episodic memory
systems often work together in forming new
memories – it isn't always one or the other.
In such instances, the memory that ultimately
forms may consist of an autobiographical episode
and semantic information.
Types of long-term memory
Complete the table in your workbooks
Types of Long Term Memories
Procedural Memories
Definition: Example:
Declarative Memories
Definition: Example:
Episodic Memory Semantic Memory
Example: Example:
Organisation of Information in
LTM
Long term memory’s most distinctive feature is its
organisation of information
The task of retrieving information from LTM differs from
the process of retrieving information from STM.
In short term memory, the search and retrieve tasks
involve scanning only 7 + 2 items to locate the relevant
information.
This 7 + 2 system doesn’t work with LTM, as there is
such vast information to store, so there is a need for
organisation to assist the storage and retrieval process.
BOUSFIELD & BOWER & CLARK
Research into LTM has been studied for over 65 years now. Research
suggests:
Bousfeild & Sedgewick, 1944
Information may be recalled in burst of information, pause briefly …..
Then recall more information and so forth.
This suggested the way people recalled items reflected the way the items
were organised in LTM
Bousfeild, 1953
Noticed that when asked to recall information, people would recall the
words in groups or clusters, without being aware
Hockenbury & Hockenbury, 2006
It is still believed today that there is some kind of logical association in
LTM
Bower & Clark, 1969
Found that words that were memorised in stories would recall up to 90% of
12 words compared to only 15% of words remembered in any order
They concluded that the results from recall in LTM were improved using
Semantic network theory
Information is stored in LTM as series of overlapping
networks
Each network is interconnected by meaningful links
Each item of information or concept in the network is
called a node
When a node in a network is activated (retrieved) all other
related nodes are made available (easier to retrieve) –
spreading activation
Linking multiple concepts removes the need for multiple
copies of the same information
The shorter or thicker the link between nodes, the stronger
the association between them and the faster the retrieval
Think of the semantic network theory as towns as nodes
SEMANTIC NETWORK THEORY IN PRACTICE
Semantic network theory –
spreading activation (loftus & collins)
Traffic lights Fireman
Fire Engine
Trustworthy
Green Fire
Red
Brave
Yellow Emergency
Blue Police Courage
Apple
Neuron bases of memory
Memories are stored throughout the brain linked together by
memory traces or “circuits” – interconnected neurons
However, different parts of the brain are involved in memory
formation and retrieval to different degrees, and in different types of
memories
New memories (either short or long term) are NOT stored in
individual synapses but in the pattern of thousands of new
interrelated connections
Looking for memories in a single nerve cell or synapse is a dead end
We know that there is a molecular basis to memory formation, what
we do not know is exactly how thousands of these new connections
hold our memories.
KANDELS SEA SLUGS
Kandel identified that there are physical changes
to neurons during the formation of new memories
Worked primarily with large sea slugs (Aplysia
californica)
Has very simple Nervous System
20, 000 neurons
Largest observable neurons – can be seen with the
naked eye!
Stimulated the siphon (gill in the tail of slug that squirts water to move
slug away from danger)
According to Kendal:
STM – would withdraw gill more and more quickly
Forgetting – an hour later the withdrawal was again slow, progressively
faster with continued stimulation
Habituation – eventually the slug stopped responding to the stimulation
as it caused no damage, it had ‘learned’ that the shock was harmless
Retraction of the gills changes over time indicating memory, so Each day
the slug would habituate more quickly than the day before
This suggest some kind of LTM lasting days or even weeks
By studying the neurons involved in this process he identified the
changes that allowed the learning to take place
The neurons were physically changing!
These changes are called collectively Long Term Potentiation
LONG TERM POTENTIATION
Neural basis for memory formation
Synapse strength can increase in 3 ways
- Release extra neurotransmitter
- Increase number of receptor sites
- Growth of new synapses
LONG TERM POTENIATION – EXPLICIT
STM
New
Receptor
Formation
Stronger neural
impulse in post
synaptic neuron
So, we know all from sea slugs ……..
Changes to neurons during memory formation are
collectively called Long-term potentiation and include:
Increased volume of neurotransmitter (function)
Increased connectivity to other neurons (structure)
Increased number of branches (dendritic spines) at the dendrite and/or
axon terminal ends – reinforce existing connections
New synaptic junctions are formed between neurons – creating new
memory traces /neural pathways
Short-term memory storage only tends to increase
neurotransmitter production, while long-term storage
produces functional and structural changes
As a memory is recalled, all the neurons in the memory
trace are activated in sequence. The strength and number of
connections between each neuron increases the ease and
Consolidation Theory
Information that is transferred from STM to LTM needs a period
of time to be properly and permanently encoded and stored –
(‘consolidated’ or set - think concrete!)
The consolidation theory suggests that there are
structural/physical changes to the neurons (long-term
potentiation & axon growth) as new memories are formed.
These changes take time (consolidation phase) and the memory
can be interfered with (changed) or erased (lost permanently)
during this time.
The new memory is vulnerable for at least 30 minutes after
being experienced.
The hippocampus and medial temporal lobe play an important
role in consolidation
Reconsolidation is the process of returning information back to
LTM after it has been retrieved and used – the memory may be
Serial position effect
The serial position effect describes the differences in ability to
recall items in a list depending on their position in that list
For immediate recall, typically items at the end of the list are best
recalled, then items at the start of the list, with items in the middle
of the list least likely to be recalled
Recency effect
Superior recall of items at the end of the list (most recently
experienced)
Still in STM so easy to retrieve
Primacy effect
Superior recall of items at the start of the list
Had the most time to rehearse for probably retrieved from LTM
Items from the middle of the list are no longer in STM and
haven’t had a chance to make LTM, so least likely to be recalled
Most clearly shown when tested immediately after exposure to
the list. After 30 seconds recency effect is less apparent
Serial Position Effect
http://withfriendship.com/images/h/38230/the-serial-position-effect.gif
Glanzer & Cuntiz (1966) research concluded that the STM & LTM must work
together within the serial position effect. This was due recall better at both the
start and end of the list, but with a delay of 30 seconds, this is beyond the
limits of STM, and items at the start of the list were more likely stored in LTM.
66
AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL
MEMORIES
Autobiographical Memories:
Memories we hold regarding ourselves and our
relationships with the world around us
Depend upon both episodic and semantic memory
systems
Are unique in the way that they play a role in our
lives
Are difficult to study in experimental situations
because the experimenter lacks control over the
learning situation
67
THE FUNCTION OF
AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL MEMORY
Williams, Conway, and Cohen (2008) proposed
four functions of autobiographical memory:
Directive functions
Using past experience to solve problems
Social functions
Bonding people together or separating them
Self-representational
Creating and maintaining our self-image
Helping to cope with adversity
Remembering pleasant times when things aren’t so
pleasant
68
THE FUNCTION OF
AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL MEMORY
Hyman and Faries (1992) found that:
Sharing experience and relating advice is common
Autobiographical memories are rarely used directively
Bluck et al.’s (2005) Thinking About Life
Experiences (TALE) questionnaire:
Found that autobiographical memories actually serve a
variety of overlapping purposes, including:
Directive
Self-related
Nurturing existing relationships
Developing new social relationships
+ STUDYING AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL 69
MEMORY
Methodological Difficulties
Many studies of autobiographical memory
make the tenuous assumption that
participants:
Can remember their autobiographical memories
Can remember what evoked their
remembrances
Are aware of the different functions of their
memories
Can reliably categorize their memories
+ 70
METHODS OF STUDY
Classic Diary Method
Participants are asked to record
events in a diary at set intervals Components of Wagenaar’s Diary
Feature of Example
Later memories can be Event
objectively compared to the
Who? Driving alone
original account of the events in
What? A car accident
the diary entries
Individuals can test their Where? By the corner bank
When? 10/8/08 @ 8:00 AM
memories by:
Salience? Once per 15 years
Trying to put the events in order
(e.g. Linton, 1975) Emotionality? Extreme
Repeated, spaced retrieval Pleasantness Extremely unpleasant
attempts improve retention ?
Cuing themselves with details of Critical detail Other driver failed to
their entry (e.g. Wagenaar, 1986) stop at a red light
+ 71
METHODS OF STUDY
Classic Diary Method
By manipulating the number of
types of cues he provided
himself to remember events,
Wagenaar (1986) found that:
Who, what, and where cues were
equally effective in prompting a
memory
The when cue (the date), in
isolation, was far less efficient
Recall proved an often
difficult/unpleasant task; however,
He was able to eventually
recollect most events with the
right cues (and the help of
others involved, if necessary)
From Wagenaar (1986). Copyright © Elsevier. Reproduced
with permission.
+ 72
METHODS OF STUDY
Problems with the Classic Diary Method
Memory for items recorded in this manner is not
representative:
There is a selection bias:
The entries are chosen because they were deemed
meaningful
Memories are atypically well-encoded and rehearsed
Journaling the events is, in effect, a rehearsal with
deep processing, which improves their memorability
All forms of the diary method require dedicated, reliable
participants, who are not necessarily representative of
the population
+ 73
METHODS OF STUDY
Diary Method with Random Sampling
Brewer (1988) addressed the selection bias problem by:
Providing participants with a beeper and tape recorder
Having the beeper go off at random intervals
Asking participants to record details about whatever was occurring
when the beeper went off
Using this method, Brewer found that the events were less
memorable than those recorded using the classic method:
+ 74
METHODS OF STUDY
Diary Method with Random Sampling
Conway et al.’s (1996) diary study with random
sampling:
Task:
Record events and thoughts in a diary when randomly
prompted
Recognize actual events from plausible, yet invented
alternative ones
Categorize each recognized memory as either:
Remembered if it was accompanied by a feeling of
recollecting the initial experience
Known if the memory was only familiar to them, without
recollection
Results:
True events were more likely to be recollected than fake
events
Events were twice as likely to evoke recollection than
thoughts
+ 75
METHODS OF STUDY
Memory Probe Method
Memory Probe Method
A cued recall task developed by Galton (1879)
Revised by Crovitz and Shiffman (1974):
Task:
Provide participants with a cue word or time
period
Ask them to recollect an autobiographical
memory associated with the cue
Suffers from a lack of experimental control
+ 76
METHODS OF STUDY
Memory Probe Method
People are bad at dating memories and
retrieving them based on temporal cues
Especially when the events are all clustered
around the same time (e.g. Means et al., 1988)
People tend to date memories indirectly either
by:
Recollecting incidental features (e.g. the
weather at the time)
Linking it to other events that are more
easily dated (big trips, holidays, or extreme
events)
77
AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL MEMORIES ACROSS
THE LIFESPAN
Infantile Amnesia:
People tend to recall relatively few memories from
the first 2 to 5 years of life
The average age of one’s first memory varies by
culture
Explanations include:
Freudian repression; underdeveloped hippocampus;
underdeveloped sense of self
People of all ages tend to recall numerous
memories from the very recent past
Due to the recency effect
Reminiscence Bump (Rubin, Wetzler, &
Nebes, 1986):
People over the age of 40 tend to report more
memories from the period between ages 15–30 than
from other eras
+ 78
AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL MEMORIES ACROSS THE LIFESPAN
Explanations for the Reminiscence Bump
The Life Narrative:
A coherent account of who we are and how we got here
that is built up through life
Events that influence the narrative are ranked as
important, emotionally intense, and are typically well
encoded
Positive events from young adulthood are especially
memorable
Many of these events occur during the period of the
bump (Bernsten & Rubin, 2004):
Age of first love (16 years, on average)
College
Marriage (27 years)
Children (28 years)
+ AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL MEMORIES 79
ACROSS THE LIFESPAN
Exceptions to the Reminiscence Bump
While memories from verbal and visual cues peak
during the typical reminiscence bump period:
Memories cued by smell peak earlier, between 6–10 years
(Chu & Downes, 2002; Willander & Larsson, 2006)
This is NOT because odor memories are more emotional
(visual cues are)
Perhaps because odor cues are not easily rehearsed, they
are less tied to the developing life narrative
+ A THEORY OF 80
AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL MEMORY
Conway (2005)
Autobiographical memory:
A system that retains knowledge concerning the
experienced self (the “me”), consisting of memories that
are:
Always addressed by the content of the memory
Only are accompanied by a recollective experience if
they are able to access related episodic memories
Transitory and constructed dynamically on the basis of
the autobiographical knowledge base
Low-level sensory episodes are lost most rapidly
Depends on the interaction between the knowledge base
and the working self
CONWAY’S MODEL OF SELF
The knowledge structures
within autobiographical
memory, as proposed by
Conway (2005).
+ CONWAY’S (2005) THEORY OF 82
AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL MEMORY
The Autobiographical Knowledge Base
A hierarchical structure involving an overall life story
Broad Time Events Episodic Sensory–
Themes Periods Memories Perceptual
Info*
Psychology
College Years
Dept.
Work
First Job Prof. Smith
The
Overall Life Handshake
Story Promotion Interview
The Weather
Personal Courting
First Date
Relationships Spouse
*Sensory details (primarily
visual) help authenticate
memories
+ CONWAY’S (2005) THEORY OF 83
AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL MEMORY
The Working Self:
A complex set of active goals and self images through
which information is filtered and encoded
Comprises:
Conceptual self-knowledge
Personal details (occupation, family background, etc.)
Professional aims
Partly constructed by:
Family background
Peers
Education
Myths and stereotypes
+ 84
CONWAY’S (2005) THEORY OF
AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL MEMORY
The Working Self
An effective working self is:
Coherent
Largely
grounded in reality
Sensory details (primarily visual) help
authenticate memories
When divorced from reality, the working self
can produce:
Confabulations and delusions
+ CONWAY’S (2005) THEORY OF 85
AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL MEMORY
Autonoetic Consciousness
Autonoetic Consciousness (Tulving, 1989):
The capacity to perform mental time travel and reflect on our
thoughts
Recollecting the sensory/perceptual details of a memory
Provides the awareness of having previously experienced
a certain event
Allows us to decide whether a recollection is real or not
A relatively slow process (around several seconds)
Relies on the frontal lobe
+ 86
FLASHBULB MEMORIES
Brown and Kulik (1977)
Flashbulb Memories:
Are memories for major events with an exceptional level
of vividness and detail
e.g. Assassinations, natural disasters, terrorists attacks
Arguably thought to arise from a mechanism that
produces traces qualitatively different from typical
memories, called now print:
Extreme emotion leads to near photographic record of
the event and its physical context
Are more common when the person remembering is
affected by the event
e.g. more black people have flashbulb memories for the
Martin Luther King assassination
+ 87
FLASHBULB MEMORIES
Not All that Meets the Eye
Flashbulb Memories:
Are not especially immune to forgetting over long delays
Neisser and Harsch’s (1992) Challenger study
Despite being subjectively clearer than everyday
memories, are just as prone to forgetting when cues are
self-generated
Talarico and Rubin’s (2003) 9/11 study
Are not necessarily clearer/more vivid than other
memories
Rubin and Kozin (1984)
+ 88
FLASHBULB MEMORIES
Neisser and Harsch’s (1992) Challenger Study
Task:
Asked participants to recall the circumstances when
they learned about the Challenger space shuttle
disaster at two time points:
1 day after the event – 21% said they saw the disaster on TV
2.5 years later – 45% said they saw it on TV
Despite being vivid, accuracy decreased substantially
Results:
Delay
reduced accuracy but not confidence in their
memories
Conclusion:
Flashbulb memories are not as accurate as they seem
+ 89
FLASHBULB MEMORIES
Alternative Accounts
It is not necessary to posit a separate
system to produce flashbulb memories
They might seem more memorable for other
reasons:
They are not easily confused with other events
They are the subject of repeated rehearsal
They tend to have meaningful changes on our
lives
They evoke strong emotions
+ SOCIAL AND EMOTIONAL 90
FACTORS
Preserving Self-Esteem
Autobiographical memories are often distorted in
ways to preserve self-esteem by:
Emphasizing our own role and significance in events
Selectively forgetting failure and remembering praise
These distortions can prove beneficial:
Depressed individuals tend to recall fewer
autobiographical details
This is preferable to ruminating over more detailed
negative memories
+ SOCIAL AND EMOTIONAL 91
FACTORS
Preserving Self-Esteem
Conway (1990)
Task:
Prior to an exam, students were asked to report their:
Expected exam grades
Amount/level of preparation
Assessment of the exam’s validity and the grade’s importance
Two weeks later, participants were asked the same questions
Results:
Individuals with better-than-expected exam results:
Reported the same amount of preparation as before
Increased their rating of the grade’s importance
Individuals with worse-than-expected exam results:
Reported doing less preparation
Rated the grades as being less important and the exam less valid
+ SOCIAL AND EMOTIONAL 92
FACTORS
Recovered Memories
Freud proposed that the ego defends itself from
anxiety by repressing negative memories
Freud’s theory has received only limited empirical
support
Reports of previously repressed memories being
uncovered appear in clinical and criminal
settings
Many of these memories have been proven untrue
False Memory Syndrome:
The belief, induced by another person through leading
questioning, that a nonevent actually occurred
Certain individuals (e.g. children and the depressed) are
more susceptible to false memories
+ SOCIAL AND EMOTIONAL 93
FACTORS
Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
The array of symptoms resulting from situations of
extreme stress:
Heightened anxiety
Nightmares
Flashbacks when confronted with reminders of the
trauma
Highly detailed, situationally-accessible memories
that cannot be called to mind intentionally unlike
verbally-accessible memories (Brewin, 2001)
Not all individuals experiencing a trauma develop PTSD
PATTERNS OF RECOVERY
FROM PTSD
Patterns of recovery
function following
post-traumatic stress
disorder (PTSD), with
the approximate
percentage of patients
following each pattern.
Data from Bonanno
(2005).
+ SOCIAL AND EMOTIONAL 95
FACTORS
Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
PTSD is likely tied to classical conditioning:
The trauma’s context becomes associated with extreme
stress
Reminders (physical stimuli or thoughts) can then trigger
memories of the trauma
Treatment often involves extinguishing the fear response:
Have the patient re-imagine the event under safe and
controlled conditions, under a therapist’s supervision
Treatment often reduces symptoms
+ SOCIAL AND EMOTIONAL 96
FACTORS
Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
The Autonomic Nervous System (ANS) and
Stress
Upon encountering a threat:
The ANS releases stress hormones (adrenalin and cortisol)
Flight-or-fight mechanisms are enacted
When the threat has passed:
The brain signals the adrenal glands to stop producing the
stress hormones
In PTSD patients, this normalization process is likely
disrupted
Stress is prolonged
A drug (propranolol) helps fix the normalization process
Reduces the emotional impact of the associated
memories
+ SOCIAL AND EMOTIONAL 97
FACTORS
Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
PTSD patients tend to have smaller hippocampi
PTSD might lead to reduced hippocampal volume
Prolonged stress in animals can disrupt hippocampal
functioning and cause neuronal death
Reduced hippocampal volume is also a risk factor for PTSD
Gilbertson et al.’s (2002) twin study:
Vietnam veterans with PTSD and their nonveteran twins
both tend to have small hippocampi
Vietnam veterans without PTSD and their nonveteran twins
both tend to have normally-sized hippocampi
+ SOCIAL AND EMOTIONAL 98
FACTORS
Involuntary Memories (e.g. Flashbacks)
The frequency of involuntary flashbacks in
PTSD patients corresponds to the individual’s
proximity to the trauma
Reappearance Hypothesis (Neisser, 1967):
Thestandard clinical interpretation for involuntary
memories, stating that the same memory can
repeatedly appear and disappear, without change
Berntsen and Rubin (2008) set out to
determine whether intrusive memories:
Also occur in the general population
Follow the same general principles as regular
autobiographical memories
+ SOCIAL AND EMOTIONAL 99
FACTORS
Bernsten and Rubin (2008)
In a telephone survey of the general population, Bernsten and
Rubin (2008) found that:
Recurrent memories are:
Frequent
Decline in frequency, but increase in positivity/intensity with age
Show the reminiscence bump
Tend to change over repetitions (according to a follow-up study)
Recurrent dreams are:
Less frequent
Show a modest correlation with recurrent memories
Conclusion:
Recurrent memories occur normally in life and follow the same
principles of other autobiographical memories
BERNTSEN & RUBIN (2008)
101
PSYCHOGENIC AMNESIA
Psychogenic Amnesia Organic Amnesia
No clear link to brain damage Caused by brain damage
Loss of original sense of Sense of personality retained
personality
Orientation and time and place
disrupted
+ 102
PSYCHOGENIC AMNESIA
Fugue
Fugue:
A sudden loss of autobiographical memory
Usually accompanied by wandering
Typically lasts only a few hours/days
The patient usually has no memory for the fugue period after
recovery
General semantic knowledge remains largely intact
Episodic learning is usually impaired
Frequently corresponds with:
Preceding periods of stress
Depressed mood
A history of transient, organic amnesia
Possible ulterior motives
Hypnosis and drugs are generally ineffective at treating it
+ 103
PSYCHOGENIC AMNESIA
Psychogenic Focal Retrograde Amnesia
Psychogenic Focal Retrograde
Amnesia:
A highly infrequent loss of access to memories
acquired prior to a trauma without:
Signs of anterograde amnesia
A link to brain damage
Sometimes can be explained by ulterior motives
i.e. is “functional” in some way
+ 104
PSYCHOGENIC AMNESIA
Situation-Specific Amnesia
Situation-Specific Amnesia:
Forgetting of a single, specific event
30% of people accused of violent crimes and murders
claim to be amnesic for the incident
Most common with:
Extreme emotions, especially passion
More violent offenses
Alcohol and its “blackout” effects
Likely a retrieval failure, rather than
encoding/consolidation
Over half report at least partial memory recoveries after
a year (Yuille & Cutshall, 1986)
+ 105
PSYCHOGENIC AMNESIA
Is Situation-Specific Amnesia Real?
Evidence for a …
Genuine Phenomenon Malingering
Occurs in suspects who voluntarily Often have a clear motive for
turn themselves in forgetting
Amnesia is often not a viable legal
argument (e.g. in UK law)
Occurs in victims/eyewitnesses
who have no reason to malinger
Accounts are consistent
+ 106
PSYCHOGENIC AMNESIA
Multiple Personality Disorder
Multiple Personality Disorder:
A raredisorder, in which numerous personalities
exist within a single person
The personalities may or may not be mutually aware
If not, they share implicit memory (Nissen et al.,
1988)
Prevalence varies across cultures
Possible causes:
It simply reflects symptoms that are fashionable and
reinforced by clinicians (Merskey, 1992)
Like “glove anesthesia” or catatonia
Patients may be trying out a new life (Kopelman, 2002)
+ AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL MEMORY AND 107
THE BRAIN
Neuropsychological Studies
Semantic and episodic aspects of autobiographical
memories are dissociable:
Retrograde amnesia can affect memory for both personal and
public events, or either one, separately
Confabulation
Fabricated autobiographical memories, lacking an intention to
mislead
Provoked variant: Arises from a patient’s attempt to fill in knowledge
gaps, to avoid embarrassment
Spontaneous variant (e.g. Patient RR):
More elaborate stories
Less common
Linked to frontal lobe damage
+ AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL MEMORY AND 108
THE BRAIN
Neuropsychological Studies
Dysexecutive Syndrome (e.g. Patient RR):
Symptoms:
Confabulation
Difficulty setting up appropriate retrieval cues
Inability to filter out irrelevant or implausible responses
Results from frontal lobe damage
Delusions
Persistent, elaborate, and patently false beliefs about the
self/world
Attempt to explain extraordinary experiences/thoughts/feelings
Associated with schizophrenia but not any particular brain region
Generally not associated with executive deficits
109
ANATOMICAL BASIS OF
AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL MEMORY
Evidence suggests that:
Autobiographical memory relies
on:
Autobiographical Memory Semantic Memory
Executive areas in the left prefrontal
regions
Serve to evoke related memories
Visualization areas in the occipital
and temporal lobes
Damage to these areas results in
poor autobiographical memory
Autobiographical retrieval:
Relies more on amygdalar, Based on Greenberg et al. (2005).
AMY, amygdala; HIP, hippocampus; IFG, inferior frontal gyrus.
hippocampal, and right IFG activity
Semantic retrieval:
Relies more on prolonged left-frontal
activation
Amnesia
Amnesia refers to any form of memory loss
Can be partial or complete
Can be temporary or permanent
Amnesia is usually caused by brain trauma (inflicted brain
injury or acquired brain injury)
The severity of the injury determines the type and severity of
the amnesia
Usually experience a period of unconsciousness, followed by a
period of confusion, then the period of time ‘forgotten’ usually
shrinks to only a few seconds of minutes directly after the moment
of trauma
Experience of amnesia can vary from a few days to several
weeks, but commonly disappears suddenly, often after a
Types of Amnesia
① Anterograde amnesia
Loss of memory of experiences that occur after the brain
trauma
Difficulty learning new information
Can clearly recall events before the trauma
Can retain new info in STM indefinitely as long as it is
rehearsed
Problem lies in the transference of information from STM into
LTM
Experienced by people with Korsakoff’s syndrome and
Alzheimer's disease
Korsakaff’s syndrome (neurodegenerative disease)
Acute inflammation and damage to hippocampus and thalamus
Often associated with chronic alcoholism and thiamine deficiency
Types of Amnesia
① R
② Retrograde amnesia
Loss of memory of old info and experiences before the
trauma occurred
Loss can extend back from moments to years
Usually temporary
However, very common to permanently ‘lose’ the memory of
the moment leading up to the trauma itself
This permanent loss is explained by the interruption of
consolidation into LTM
Dementia & Alzheimer’s Disease
Dementia & Alzheimer's discussed in this study design
(for a full list FYI you can read box 6.12 for common
types of dementia)
Common acquired brain injury is caused by
neurodegenerative disease where brain tissue slowly
deteriorates over time
Dementia
Progressive decline in mental functioning
Loss of mental capacity: decline in
intellectual ability, poor judgment, poor
social skills and abnormal emotional
reactions
Memory loss is persistent and progressive
Not a normal part of ageing
Alzheimer’s disease
A form of dementia
Physical break down of neurons causes plaques in the brain –
Alzheimer’s Disease
sections of neurons tightly bound together, causing gaps in other
areas (only observable post-mortem) caused by high
concentration of the protein amyloid in the brain (see next slide
for Amy Loid!)
Often have low concentrations of neurotransmitter; acetylcholine
Affects around 100 000 people in Australia
No accurate diagnostic tests available. Only accurately
diagnosed after death and brain tissue is examined for plaques
Memory loss, confusion, irritability and impaired decision-
making are common symptoms
Memory loss is persistent and progressive
Episodic memories are affected
Forget words and names of people and commonly known facts
Lose ability to follow directions of a story plot
Lose ability to perform everyday skills
ALZHEIMER’S DISEASE: POST-MORTEM
So we know:
Show high levels of the protein Amyloid
Not usually in the brain
Highly toxic – causes cell death
Causes the development of the plaques and tangles
Brains also have a massive lack of acetylcholine (an
important neurotransmitter)
The rhyme:
Memory decline over the lifespan
Memory decline is not an inevitable consequence of
ageing
If it does decline, short-term memory and explicit
declarative memories (episodic and semantic) tend to be
affected, rather than procedural memories
Aging and STM decline
Infotransmission in NS is generally less efficient in older
people (physical effects of ageing)
The more complicated the task, the more STM decline is
evident in older people
Less activity in areas of the frontal lobe associated with STM
when >60 years old
Memory decline over the lifespan
Ageing and LTM decline
Episodic memories have been shown to start a steady decline as
early as 30 years old
Procedural memories appear to remain intact over time
Semantic memories don’t appear to be affected much by age
However, older people don’t tend to encode new information in as
much detail or as accurately as younger people – so often takes an
older person longer to learn new things
Speed and fluency of retrieval also tends to decline with age
Decline in memory in older people is often explained by lack of
motivation or more commonly, a lack of confidence
Recall of items is lower, but recognition of items is no different
than younger people – use recognition tests, not recall
Memory decline can also be explain by cognitive slowing due to
natural shrinkage of frontal lobes with age. Cognitive slowing
affects all cognitive processes, not just memory
SO TO RECAP …..
Older people Do take longer to learn new info
STM – depends on the task, easy one part tasks
ok, tasks that require divided attention not so
good. Recall down, Recognition same.
LTM - Episodic down, Procedural same,
Semantic Same.