Challenges to Nation-State Sovereignty
Challenges to Nation-State Sovereignty
SYSTEM
Chapter 4
Introduction
The state has traditionally been a subject
of most interest to scholars of Global politics
because it is viewed as “the institutions that
create warfare and sets economic policies
for a country.”
Furthermore, the state is a political unit
that has authority over its own affairs.
Introduction
The Treaty of Westphalia of 1648 established
the notion of the nation-state and the idea of state
sovereignty.
Today, the globalization of politics created an
atmosphere where the ideas of the nation-state,
state sovereignty, government control, and
state policies are challenge from all sides.
Introduction
With globalization, some scholars suggest
a decrease in the power of the state and that
other actors are actually becoming powerful.
These actors include multinational
corporations and global civil society
organizations, like the Red Cross, that cross
national boundaries.
Questions
id e a of
Is t h e If so, what is it
n - s ta t e
the natio th e that we need to
Main topic
d i n
outdate r y think about as
p o r a
contem “replacements”
Conclusions world? ?
Quiz
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
Question
Look at the regional alliances and
worldwide organizations of states.
International and regional economic bond
Main topic
bodies, such as IMF and the World Bank.
The third kind of replacement to the
Conclusions traditional nation-state and the idea of
national autonomy comes from the non-
Quiz
state actors.
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
including banks and groups of people x
Question
Main topic
Conclusions
Quiz
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Multinational corporations and non-government
organizations, like Amnesty International x
Question
Main topic
Conclusions
Quiz
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
The emergence of non-state organizations, like Al-
Qaeda, ISIS, and terrorist organizations x
Question
Main topic
Conclusions
Quiz
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Global
Governance in
the 21 Century
st
Karol Grace P. Dalisay
BEED- 1
x
Series of factors
behind the emergence
GAME
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
GAME
Topics
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
2. Vast flows of all sorts of things that
run into and often right through the
borders of nation-states
GAME
Topics
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
3. Mass migration of people and their
entry, often illegally, into various nation-
states
GAME
Topics
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Effects of
Globalization to
Governments
Jaizanie Lyn B. Bacabac
BSED- 1
What is government? x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
What is a state? x
It is a political structure of an
organized community which is
GAME
internationally recognized as an
independent state, have a population,
Topics common language, defined territory,
and an established government
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Effects of globalization to governments x
Globalization help the nation to make
money and earn more interest in order to
create important things that make people’s
GAME lives easier.
Topics
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Effects of globalization to governments x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Traditional
Challenges
Niza T. Yap
External intervention; x
- Can generally be described as invasion by the
countries.
GAME
For example;
When saddam Hussein was the ruler of Iraq in
1990,he decided he was going to take over the oil
Topics
field of Kuwait.
For example;
After the Arab spring in Egypt,a new
GAME constitution was created and the
government was [Link] government
was more fundamentalist and rejected the
Topics
notion of plural society that included
religious diversity.
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Other examples; x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Regional organizations challenging state autonomy x
Example;
The united nations intervened in
GAME sudan because of the several years
of civil wars.
Topics
Recently in Europe, specifically in
Greece,it also interfered in the Greek
BUOD
debt crisis.
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
CHALLENGES
FROM NATIONAL
/IDENTITY
MOVEMENTS
Crezel Belenario
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
- Different people with different identities can live in
different state.
Example :
Kurds reside in several different countries
GAME including Iraq, Iran and Turkey.
Topics
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
Catalans- live primarily in Spain but we
can also find of them in France.
GAME
Topics
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
In 2014, Britain had a Vote in Scotland to decide
whether Scotland was going to become its own
autonomous State apart from Great Britain.
GAME
Topics
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
GLOBAL MOVEMENT x
Another example of national or identity
movements are Al-Qaeda and Isis.
In this case, they are structured around the
GAME
fundamentalist version of Islam.
Topics
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Global
Economics
Rhea Gacelos
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Neoliberal Economics or Neoliberal Capitalism x
Started in 1980’s
It focuses on free trade and
GAME dismantling trade barriers.
It made sure that governments did not
Topics
impose restrictive regulations on
corporate presence, as well as on the
free flow of capital and jobs.
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Free Trade x
Was seen as the ideal or the normative
belief
The best economy is one where there
GAME
is free trade everywhere
Laws and standards that would
Topics
interfere with the flow of capital in a
particular country, including
BUOD environmental regulations
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Neoliberal Economics x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
Specific examples to expand global
economic influence
The use of IMF and the World Bank in
GAME facing government reforms in poorer
countries.
Furthermore, the regional economic
Topics
development efforts focused on expanding
free trade and market liberalization
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
Businesses from developed
countries put their factories and
pay people to build factories and
GAME
produce goods in developing
countries worldwide.
Topics These corporations will sell the
products in developing countries
BUOD
worldwide.
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
Topics
can threaten the
BUOD
sovereignty of a state.
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
It began in 1981when Greece joined the
EU.
As a larger alliance, the EU broke down all
GAME
kinds of barriers among the member states
including Greece, like passports, visas and
license plates.
Topics 20 years later, Greece adopted the euro as
its own currency and got rid of the
drachma.
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
The governments of Greece borrowed
money for infrastructure improvements
largely limited to their hasting of the 2004
GAME
Olympics, this put Greece in large debt.
In 2007 and 2008, the worldwide financial
crisis made Greece’s economy to collapse
Topics Greece had several of its employees
struggling with pension, Tax revenues were
lower-end as a result, they could not pay
BUOD
their debts back.
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Global Social
Movements
Ypril Janine E. Toroy
x
Social Movements are movements of
people that are spontaneous or that
emerge through enormous grassroots
GAME organization. These social movements
are transnational movements which
Topics
means they occur across countries and
across borders. Therefore, states have
less control over them.
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
For example, human rights movements
create a public sentiment, value, and agenda.
The idea is that there are certain rights that
GAME
states cannot neglect or generally, what we
call human rights. If a country decides that
they are going to have a particular policy and
Topics if that policy violates the international standard
of human rights, there is a challenge to ability
BUOD
of states to fully implement it.
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
Consensus on women’s rights is another
example in many countries. Arguably, the
biggest conflict between the West and the
GAME
fundamentalist Islam is over the role of
women in society, as well as women’s
autonomy. Rights of personal autonomy are
Topics another example and this includes issues on
homosexuality, same-sex marriage, and
BUOD
gender equality.
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
There is also an increased role in
international organizations like the United
Nations and the International Criminal
GAME Court in Hague, the role of non-
governmental organizations like Doctors
Topics Without Borders or Amnesty International,
and the role of global media.
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
The Relevance of
the State amid
Globalization
Elvie Jane Estrada and
Jojo Teves
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
TOPICS x
Introduction
STATE
State x
GAME
Introduction
STATE
4 elements of State x
GAME
1. People:
Topics
The first element of a
state is a permanent
BUOD
population.
8:00 AM
Insert Topic Title 01/20/2022
TOPICS x
Introduction
STATE
4 elements of State x
GAME
2. Territory:
This permanent presence
Topics
in one location is
strengthened by the
BUOD
second element of a
state, a defined territory
8:00 AM
Insert Topic Title 01/20/2022
TOPICS x
Introduction
STATE
4 elements of State x
GAME
3. Government:
Topics
A territory is effectively
controlled by the third
BUOD
element, government.
8:00 AM
Insert Topic Title 01/20/2022
TOPICS x
Introduction
STATE
4 elements of State x
GAME
4. Sovereignty:
This means that the state is a
Topics formally constituted sovereign
political structure encompassing
people, territory, and its institutions
on the one hand, and maintaining
BUOD its autonomy from other states on
the other hand.
8:00 AM
Insert Topic Title 01/20/2022
x
It is important to
GAME
differentiate the idea of
Topics
nation from state.
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
TOPICS x x
Introduction
PAGKAKAIBA SEXUAL GENDER
STATE NATION ORIENTAION IDENTITY
Nation x
GAME
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
TOPICS x
Introduction
STATE NATION NATION-
STATE
Nation-state x
GAME
Introduction
STATE NATION NATION-
STATE
Nation-state x
GAME
Introduction
NATION NATION- COLLECTIVE
STATE INSECURITY
STATE
Collective Insecurity x
GAME
8:00 AM
Insert Topic Title 01/20/2022
TOPICS x
Introduction
NATION NATION- COLLECTIVE
STATE INSECURITY
STATE
4 major sources of x
GAME collective insecurity
Terrorism
Topics
BUOD
8:00 AM
Insert Topic Title 01/20/2022
TOPICS x
Introduction
NATION NATION- COLLECTIVE
STATE INSECURITY
STATE
4 major sources of x
GAME collective insecurity
Economic globalization,
leading to problems such as
Topics outsourcing and pressures
toward downsizing, as well
as the current economic
BUOD crises
8:00 AM
Insert Topic Title 01/20/2022
TOPICS x
Introduction
NATION NATION- COLLECTIVE
STATE INSECURITY
STATE
4 major sources of x
GAME collective insecurity
Threats to national
identity due to
Topics
immigration
BUOD
8:00 AM
Insert Topic Title 01/20/2022
TOPICS x
Introduction
NATION NATION- COLLECTIVE
STATE INSECURITY
STATE
4 major sources of x
GAME collective insecurity
And the spread of
Topics
global disease such
as AIDs
BUOD
8:00 AM
Insert Topic Title 01/20/2022
TOPICS x
Introduction
NATION NATION- COLLECTIVE
STATE INSECURITY
STATE
Collective Insecurity x
GAME
8:00 AM
Insert Topic Title 01/20/2022
x
The other side of this argument in
support of the nation-state is the
global processes of various kinds
GAME
are not as powerful as many
believe. For example, global
business pales in comparison to
Topics
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Peace Treaties and
Military Alliance;
The UN and NATO
Juhayr Saripada, Jobert Reduca,
Laila Erynko, and Jazmine
Latosa
TOPICS x
Introduction
United
Nation
United Natin(UN) x
GAME
Introduction
United
Nation
United Natin(UN) x
GAME
Introduction
UNITED
NATO
NATION
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
Nato and UN are two organization trying
to work together despite the fact that
they have very different philosophy; Nato
GAME
organization designed to fight war, if
necessary, in order to defend peace:
Topics whereas the UN is an organization
designed to avoid was in order to
BUOD
maintain peace.
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
Nato and the United Nation (UN) share a
commitment to maintaining international peace and
security, the two organization have been
cooperating in this area since the early 1990’s, in
GAME support of peace-support and crisis management
operation . The complexity of today security
challenge has required a broader dialogue between
Topics Nato and the UN. This has led to reinforced
cooperation and liaison arrangements between the
staff of the two organization, as well UN specialized
BUOD
agencies.
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
Nato and the United Nation (UN) share a
commitment to maintaining international peace and
security, the two organization have been
cooperating in this area since the early 1990’s, in
GAME support of peace-support and crisis management
operation . The complexity of today security
challenge has required a broader dialogue between
Topics Nato and the UN. This has led to reinforced
cooperation and liaison arrangements between the
staff of the two organization, as well UN specialized
BUOD
agencies.
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
In terms of economic issues, the main
focus of the UN is the reduction of global
inequality. The Sustainable Development
GAME Goals (SDGs) cover a range of concerns
for the improvement of all aspects in life.
According to the UN (2017), sustainable
Topics
development encompasses economic
prosperity, social well-being, and
BUOD
environmental protection.
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
TOPICS x
Introduction ENVIRONMENTAL
UNITED NATO
NATION ISSUES
Environmental Issues x
GAME
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
TOPICS x
Introduction ENVIRONMENTAL
UNITED NATO
NATION ISSUES
x
GAME
Topics
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
TOPICS x
Introduction ENVIRONMENTAL
UNITED NATO
NATION ISSUES
x
GAME
Topics
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
TOPICS x
Introduction ENVIRONMENTAL
UNITED NATO
NATION ISSUES
Environmental Issues x
GAME
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
TOPICS x
Introduction ENVIRONMENTAL
UNITED NATO
NATION ISSUES
Environmental Issues x
GAME
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
TOPICS x
Introduction ENVIRONMENTAL
UNITED NATO
NATION ISSUES
Environmental Issues x
GAME
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
The problem is, sometimes, getting
the violators all the way to Europe to
face trial because there is not actual
GAME
police force to go out and get them.
As more and more countries interact
Topics with one another, people are looking
for the ICJ to play a bigger role in the
BUOD future of our global world.
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Non-
governmental
organization
(NGOs)
Jaybie Talliador
x
Another example of non-
governmental organization that
was developed out of war is the
GAME
Red Cross (Red Crescent in
Topics
Muslim countries). It is considered
as a non-governmental
BUOD
organization (NGO).
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
They also monitor the treatment of
prisoner of wars and go to conflicts to
make sure that no war crimes are taking
GAME
place. In fact, Red cross began as an
organization to help those who we’re
Topics wounded during wars. The big Red Cross
worn by NGOs is the identification that
BUOD
they are not soldiers.
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Global Economic
Associations:
The WTO and
NAFTA
Laila Erynko
BSED- 1
TOPICS x
Introduction
WTO
GAME
What is WTO? x
Introduction
WTO
History of WTO x
GAME
Introduction
WTO
History of WTO x
GAME
Introduction
WTO NAFTA
What is NAFTA? x
GAME
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
TOPICS x x
Introduction
WTO NAFTA
History of NAFTA x
GAME
Back in 1984, President Ronald Reagan passed the Trade and Tariff
Act, which allowed the president special authority to negotiate free
Topics trade agreements more quickly. Going off of Reagan's initiative,
Canadian Prime Minister Mulroney supported the president and the
Canada-U.S. Free Trade Agreement was eventually signed in 1988; it
went into effect one year after.
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
TOPICS x x
Introduction
WTO NAFTA
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
Through the conquest of different
empires, such as those of the Romans,
many parts of the world became under
GAME one rule. Today, however, the
contemporary world is characterized by
Topics being connected through the internet,
modern transportation, and advanced
communication technologies.
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
Through the conquest of different
empires, such as those of the Romans,
many parts of the world became under
GAME one rule. Today, however, the
contemporary world is characterized by
Topics being connected through the internet,
modern transportation, and advanced
communication technologies.
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
Globalism and globalization are often
understood in terms of the economy Nye
(2002) gave “four distinct dimension of
globalism; economic, military, environmental,
GAME
and social”
Like economic globalism, the three other
Topics dimension also become thicker and faster as
globalization intensifies. The enormous speed
of potential conflict and threat of nuclear war
BUOD
is an example of military globalism.
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
For instance, religious ideas have spread
throughout the world at greater scope
and speed. Religious teachings are
GAME delivered today though the mass media,
such as television, radio, and the internet.
Topics Unlike before, religious leaders had to
walk by foot and had to deliver their
messages in a face to face manner.
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Informationalism
Erlyn T. Julian
TOPICS x
Introduction
INFORMATIONALISM
Informationalism x
GAME
Introduction
INFORMATIONALISM
Topics
BUOD
8:00 AM
Insert Topic Title 01/20/2022
x
Computer Technology is used to check our
health through the invention of magnetic
resonance imaging (MRiS), ultrasound and CT or
GAME
CAT scans.
Topics
BUOD
MRiS Ultrasound CT or CAT scans
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
GAME Space-based
Technologies GPS
Topics
Introduction
INFORMATIONALISM
MEDIA
Media x
GAME
Mc Luhan and Flore (2005), argued that in the New Media Age,
the importance lies in the medium, the way in which the message
Topics is transmitted, not necessarily in the content presented to the
medium.
Televisions, radios and news paper have been shipping “individual
BUOD subjectivity and culture, not only locally but globally”.
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
TOPICS x
Introduction
INFORMATIONALISM INTERNET
MEDIA
Internet x
GAME
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Global
Citizenship
Kesiah Lim and Jayson Reel Collantes
x
Citizenship is associated with rights and
obligations, for instance the right to vote and the
obligation to pay taxes.
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
THREE
GAME APPROACHES TO
Topics
GLOBAL ECONOMIC
RESISTANCE
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Trade Protectionism x
foreign competitors.
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
Fair Trade x
- is a different approach to
GAME economic globalization ,
which emerged as a counter
Topics
to neoliberal “free trade”
principles.
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
The Bottom Billion x
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
When it comes to dealing with political
globalization;
Increased accountability and transparency
GAME are the key issues.
All political organizations at different levels,
should be more accountable for their actions
Topics
because they are now surrounded by an
“ocean of opacity” (Holzner and Holzner,
BUOD 2006,)
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
Like globalization
resistance to globalization is multiple,
complex, contradictory and ambiguous.
GAME This movement also has the potential to
emerge as the
Topics
New Publics Sphere, which uphold
progressive values such as authonomy ,
democracy ,peace ecological sustainability
BUOD and social justice.
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
According to della porta et la.(2006)
A movement come from individual, groups,
and organization which are oppressed.
GAME
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
GAME
Topics
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
In any case;
No world government, the idea of global
citizenship demands the creation of rights and
GAME obligations.
Fulfilling the promise and the solution of
Topics
globalization, the contemporary world does not lie on
single entity or individual, but on citizens, the
community, and the different organizations in societies.
BUOD
8:00 AM
Chapter 4 01/20/2022
x
Yes No
Topics
Pictures
8:00 AM
Insert Topic Title 01/20/2022
SALAMAT SA PAKIKINIG!
Shutting down….