Flow Meters
Flow Meters
Flow Meters
Wisnu Purwanto
Sr. Metering & QMI Engineer
General
Flow meter selection
The knowledge of fluid dynamic is crucial for the selection of flow meter.
to ensure a successful application, all the important characteristics of the
fluid and installation must be known
Installation requirements:
Entrainment in the fluid, e.g. BS&W
Liquid Vapor pressure - flashing will have a detrimental effect to the point
where some types of flow meter may stop measuring
Gas Condensation temperature - wet gas flow may give rise to huge
measurement errors.
The fluid flow profile the largest potential source of measurement errors.
Process fluid properties:
Pressure, temperature - Minimum, average, maximum flow, flow under
upset conditions
Density, compressibility, viscosity
Fluid composition
Required accuracy
Introduction
Many different principles and meter types available in the market
for various application. However, this course will only discuss:
Differential pressure type flow meters
Orifice flow meter
Venturi meter
Cone meter
Ultrasonic flow meters
Coriolis mass flow meters
Multi-phase flow meters
Turbine meters
Positive displacement (PD) meters
Electro-magnetic flow meters
Vortex meters
Orifice meter
General
The primary device is a piece of plate with
certain bore diameter to create pressure drop.
Intensive research, experiment and calibration
has been done and have adopted a concentric
thin sharp edged orifice as standard.
No moving part, normally does not require
calibration.
Instead, periodic verification of dimensions and
calibration of secondary device shall be
performed
Size available up to DN1200
Uncertainty
Custody Transfer 0.5% - 2%
Regular 2 – 5%
Orifice meter
Features & Advantages
Widely accepted and applied principle, flexible.
Suitable for liquids, gases, steam
Re-ranging in situ by changing the differential pressure transmitter span
Simple design, rugged and relatively inexpensive.
Available in various sizes, type and connections.
Well established procedures convert the differential pressure into flow
rate, using empirically derived coefficients.
Normally, actual fluid flow calibration is not required.
Disadvantage
Low turn down ratio, typically 3 : 1 for accuracy not exceed than +/- 1%.
Less accurate for higher flow range
Sensitive to flow profile; require long straight length
Pipe honing is typically required for fiscal application.
Orifice meter
How Does It Works ?
When the fluid approaches orifice, the pressure will increase slightly
and then drop suddenly after passed through.
Orifice meter
Orifice Plate Design
Thin Plate, Concentric Orifice
The most commonly used orifice plate type.
upstream edge of the orifice must be sharp and square.
Minimum plate thickness based on pipe I.D., orifice bore, etc. is
standardized.
Beta ratio ( orifice-to-pipe diameter ratio d/D) must not exceed
recommended limits.
Eccentric Orifice Plates
The eccentric plate has a round opening (bore) tangent to the inside wall of
the pipe.
Typically used to measure fluids which carry a small amount of non-abrasive
solids, or gases with small amounts of liquid.
With the opening at the bottom of the pipe, the solids and liquids will carry
through, rather than collect at the orifice plate.
Predictable uncertainty is not as good as the concentric plate.
Orifice meter
Orifice Plate Design
Segmental Orifice Plates
The opening in a segmental orifice plate is comparable to a partially opened
gate valve.
Typically used for measuring liquids or gases which carry non-abrasive
impurities such as light slurries or exceptionally dirty gases.
Predictable uncertainty is not as good as the concentric plate
Quadrant Edge Plate
The quarter-circle or quadrant orifice is used for fluids of high viscosity.
Not suitable for gas
incorporates a rounded edge of definite radius which is a particular function
of the orifice diameter
Conic Edge Plate
The conic edge plate has a 45° bevel facing upstream into the flowing
stream.
Useful for even lower Reynolds numbers than the quadrant edge.
Orifice meter
Orifice Plate Design
Tap Locations
Flange Taps located 1” upstream face of the orifice plate and 1”
downstream face with a + 1/64 to +1/32 tolerance.
Pipe Taps located 2½ D upstream and 8 D downstream.
Vena - Contracta Taps located 1 D upstream and at the point of minimum
pressure downstream
Corner Taps located immediately adjacent to the plate faces, upstream
and downstream
Calibration and validation
Fiscal application: 1/year
Other application: 1/3 year - 1/5 year depend on process condition
Orifice meter
Installation
Require fully developed flow profile, pulsation, swirl, and non uniform
flow shall be avoided.
Upstream straight length from 3D to 75D depend on the upstream pipe
configuration and beta ratio. Use flow conditioner to reduce length.
Typical for fiscal meter 20 – 45 D, internal honing
Dual DP transmitter to extend flow range
The transmitter shall be mounted above the line for gas flow and below
the line for liquid flow.
Dual chamber orifice such as Daniel Senior or FMC Smith (Peco)
Measuremaster will allow plate replacement without shutdown.
Consist of two (2) chambers.
First chamber (lower) for measuring
Second chamber (upper) for orifice removal after depressurized.
Common problem seals
High pressure application may require Viton AED seal.
Orifice meter
Common problems – Gas flow measurement
Liquid loading
Over reading, depend on how “wet” the gas, can be very excessive.
Murdock or Chisholm correction shall be applied to reduce error up to 2%.
If no drain hole, the liquid hold-up in front of the plate might cause large
errors.
Density variation
applying fixed density in the formula may lead to large errors up to 20 % and
more
P & T compensation is only effective if the average mol weight is constant.
Common problems – Liquid flow measurement
Flashing / cavitations in liquid produce large measurement error
At low flows, high water cut content may cause build-up of sand in front
of the orifice plate.
Density variations
Very small effect for pure liquid.
Large error for crude with fluctuating water content
Orifice meter
Manufacturers
FMC Smith - USA
Emerson Daniel – USA
Pietro Fiorentini – Italy
Bristol Babcock – UK
Superior – USA
Canalta - CANADA
Venturi meter
General
A flow restriction to create pressure drop.
Wide range of applications for liquid and
gases.
suitable for multiphase and wet gas flow
measurement
Can be used on slurries and dirty fluids
No moving part, normally does not
require re-calibration.
Size available up to DN1200
Uncertainty
+/- 0.7 - 1.5 % depending on shape and
materials.
Venturi meter
Features & Advantages
Widely applicable for liquids/gases/steam
Very low pressure loss; typically 20-50 mBar
Re-ranging in situ by changing the differential pressure transmitter span
In case of wet gas flows, no liquid hold-up.
handle about 60% more flow than an orifice plate for the same bore
under the same conditions, and can therefore handle higher velocity
flows
less sensitive to velocity flow profile disturbances compared to orifice
Disadvantage
Large size, fixed dimension, changing beta ratio is not possible without
changing the whole unit.
Fairly expensive
Calibration and validation
Other application: 1/3 year - 1/5 year depend on process condition
Venturi meter
Venturi for wet gas meter application
Over reading for wet gas measurement, depend on how “wet” the gas
as indicated by Lockhart-Martinelli (LM) factor
LM factor:
Venturi meter
Venturi for wet gas meter application
Wet gas correction factor :
Murdock and Chisholm Correction not suitable for venturi; developed for
orifice plates,
De Leeuw (Modified Chisholm correction) Reflecting the observed
pressure and Froude number dependence)
Condensate Gas Ratio (CGR) and Water to Gas Ratio (WGR) to be
determined :
Multiphase sampling and laboratory analysis
Tracer injection, sampling and measurement the tracer dilution ratio
MPFM well testing measurement
Typically wet gas flow measurement with a liquid loading up to some 4
% is possible with a measurement accuracy of approx. +/- 2 – 4 %
BSP Installations:
CWDP01 and EGDP01 venturi wet gas meter
CGR and WGR to be updated from MPFM well testing.
Venturi meter
Manufacturers
FMC Smith - USA
Emerson Daniel – USA
Solartron ISA – UK
Lambda Square – USA
Cone Meter
General
Unique Differential Pressure Device which
uses a cone shaped differential producer
to generate a D.P. as opposed to through a
central opening.
The function of the square root of the DP
is proportional to the flow rate.
Similar principle as orifice plate.
Original design was patented by
McCrometer in 1986 under trade mark V-
Cone meter. Patent valid for 20 years.
Other manufacturer now can produce cone
meter.
Cone Meter
Features & Advantages
Wide range of flow applications
Suitable for fouling applications: slurries, high BS&W
Suitable for wet gas flows with Lockhart & Martinelli (LM) up to 0.5
Large Turndown ratio, up to 1 : 20
Less sensitive to flow profile disturbance; require much less upstream
straight length.
no liquid hold-up in wet gas flows measurement
Disadvantages
Relatively new development device; limited experiences.
Construction would seem vulnerable to material fatigue in vibrating
applications.
Calibration issue
Cone Meter
Principle of Operations
Cone Meter
Beta Ratio
D d
d D
d2
β = 1− 2
D
Cone Meter
Basic formula
For dry gas
Where
Cd = discharge coefficient of that meter from a dry gas flow calibration.
E = the velocity of approach factor
ε = is the gas expansibility factor.
Ad is the minimum cross sectional area through the meter.
For wet gas application, shall be corrected by Steven correlation
uncertainty up to 2%.
Cone Meter
Manufacturers
McCrometer – USA
Nuflo - USA
Ultrasonic flow meters
General
Non intrusive flow measurement
device, utilizing ultrasonic transit time
technology.
Dedicated design for liquids or gas
Applications
Fiscal & allocation measurement
Flow line measurement
Flare / vent gas measurement
Uncertainty
Fiscal Application (multpath USM)
0.15 - 0.2 % for liquids
0.2-0.3 % for gases
routine applications 0.5 - 2 % for
liquids and gases depending on
number of paths and velocity profile
V• x/l
l
v d
x
Transducer A1
l l
t 21 = t12 =
c 21 − v.x / l c12 + v.x / l
l t 21 + t12
v=
2 t 21.t 12
Determine the direction of flow since the electronic can identify which is
longer between t12 and t21
Ultrasonic flow meters
USM Design
Available in single path, two path, three path, four path, five path, six
path etc.
direct from transducer to transducer or “bounce” i.e. the pulse from one
transducer bounces in the pipe before reaching the other transducer.
Multipath design improve uncertainties and less sensitive to flow profile;
typically used for fiscal application.
Clamp-on type
Easy installation on existing pipeline.
Less accurate compared with “wetted” transducer type
Min. operating pressure 40 barg for gas USM clamp-on type.
Uncertainties:
typically for liquids 0.1-0.15 % mass flow rate
gases 0.5 – 1 % mass flow rate
Where
WC = water cut , %
ρactual = the measured density, kg/m3
ρoil = the oil density, kg/m3
ρwater = the water density, kg/m3
Manufacturers
Emerson – Micro Motion - USA
Endress & Hauser – Swizerland
Rheonik – Netherland
Oval – Japan
Foxboro – USA
FMC Smith – USA
Able – UK
.. Many more
CYCLONE
SEPARATOR
CONTROL VALVES
MULTIPHASE
FLOWMETER
1. Pick-up coil
connection
2. Rotor
3. End connections
4. Flow vane
5. Vane hub
6. Rotor shaft &
bearing
7. Retaining ring
8. Body
Turbine flow meter - Liquid
Design – Helical bladed turbine meter
Suitable for high viscosity liquid up to 400 cP
or more but the turn down ratio will
decrease.
The helical blade rotor typically made of
titanium, pure helix with a blade depth much
longer than conventional design very
stable
Produce low frequency pulse, need pulse
interpolation technique for proving.
Handle the combined operating range for the
PD and conventional turbine meter
guidelines stated in API MPMS
robust and can absorb minor damage
without loss in performance.
Multiproduct with wide viscosity range
10 D 5D
Turbine flow meter - Liquid
Installation
Require adequate back pressure to prevent cavitations, API
recommends :
BP = 2 x DP + 1.25 x VP
DP = pressure drop at max. flow
VP = Vapor pressure of liquid
Strainer 10 or 20 mesh screen usually suitable to protect the meter.
Higher mesh rating will create higher pressure drop.
Helical turbine meter require lowers mesh screen
Calibration / Proving
Fiscal application : depend on contract, can be 1 or twice per-loading up
to at least once per year.
Other application : Depend on process condition; at least once every 3
years
PD Meter - Liquid
Features & Advantages
Does not require fully developed flow profile.
Typical accuracy +/- 0.5% with repeatability ± 0.01%
High turn down ratio, up to 1 : 100 for high viscosity fluid
Available up to ANSI 600# rating, with various size from 1 ½ to 16”
Wide range of fluid applications
Fast response and convenient read-out.
Does not require external power supply for local reading, either using
mechanical register or battery power totalizer.
Can be equipped with pulse transmitter for electronic system.
PD Meter - Liquid
Disadvantages
Bulky, more moving parts – require more maintenance.
Lower capacity compared to turbine meter.
Need special attention for low viscosity and dry / non-lubricated fluid.
Relatively expensive.
Require periodic calibration/proving
Installation
Normally horizontal installation, but vertical installation also possible for
small size.
Upstream and downstream flow straightener is not required.
A strainer must be installed upstream of and close to the PD meter,
Air Eliminator (deaerator) is required where liquid may contain vapours
or gasses.
Flow limiting devices must be installed in cases where the meter may be
over-ranged.
PD Meter - Liquid
Principle of Operation
Four designs of PD meters are extensively utilized in the petroleum
industry – oval gear, rotating paddle, sliding vane and birotor
Flow pass through the meter is measured directly by separating the flow
stream into discrete volumetric segment (measuring chamber)
PD Meter - Liquid
Principle of Operation
During one complete rotation a precise and specific volume of fluid
passes through the meter.
By counting rotations of the wheels (gears) the incoming flow is
digitized into a series of accurate discrete volumes
The quantity is determined by totalizing this segment
The measuring element will act as hydraulic motor to produce torque to
drive the mechanical register and or pulse transmitter
Mechanical large dial register (LDR) typically used for local indication.
Frequency pulse transmitter producing high or low frequencies can be
installed directly or at the LDR shaft.
Product slippage is the most crucial problem affecting the linearity of a
PD meter
PD Meter - Liquid
Manufacturers
Avery Hardol - UK
Cameron Nuflo (ITT Barton)
Satam Control - French
FMC Smith - USA
Liquid Control - USA
Bob & Reuther - Germany
Broodie (was Brooks) – USA
Tokheim - USA
Oval - Japan
Electromagnetic flow meters
General
Electromagnetic flowmeters is a volumetric, liquid
flow measuring devices for conductive liquid such
as water, acids, bases, or fluids that contain a
sufficiently high water content to ensure electrical
conductivity.
Minimum conductivity vary from 0.05 *Siemens/cm
to 5 *Siemens/cm; depend on the manufacturer.
Features & Advantages
Low pressure drop,
Low maintenance design–with no moving parts
High accuracy, suitable for custody transfer ( e.g.
drinking water)
insensitivity to specific gravity, viscosity, pressure
and temperature
Capable for measurement of “difficult” as
corrosives, slurries and sludges
Vortex meters
Principle of operation
Vortices are shed alternately
downstream of the object.
At low velocity : No vortices formed low
flow cut-off
At high velocity : vortex shedding
The shedding frequency is a linear At low velocity
function of the fluid velocity and hence
of the volumetric flow rate.
A sensor embedded in the bluff body
measures the vortex shedding
frequency which is directly proportional
to the velocity of the fluid, liquid or gas,
flowing through the meter
At high velocity
Vortex meters
Features & Advantages
Relatively low cost device with wide range application of clean service :
liquid and gases; size availbeup to DN600
High turndown ratio up to 1:20
Capable of measuring very high fluid speeds (up to 80 m/sec in gases)
Disadvantages
only function properly under truly single-phase fluid conditions, not
suitable for high viscosity and dirty liquid.
Not suitable for fiscal application
Needs relatively high fluid velocity ( Re > 20,000)
Susceptible to oscillating flows and mechanical vibration.
Service limitations:
should not be considered for very viscous, waxy or erosive services
should not be used in wet gas or wet steam applications or in any other two-
phase application (e.g. liquids with gas bubbles or foam, flashing liquids,
half-full lines).
Vortex meters
Installation
Non-wetted sensors are preferred. For critical applications, the sensors
shall be replaceable during operation.
Horizontal installation
recommended to mount vortex meters with the shedder bars in the
horizontal plane in order to reduce the build-up from debris and other hard
deposits.
For gas measurements, the meter should preferably not be located at the
lowest point in order to avoid condensate impacting on the measuring
element.
Vertical installation
Flow shall be upwards.
In liquid services, the horizontal or vertical flow line must remain full
under all operating conditions.
should not be installed downstream of positive displacement
pumps/compressors without suction and discharge dampers.
Vortex meters
Manufacturer
Emerson – Rosemount – USA
Foxboro – USA
Endress & Hauser – Switzerland
Yokogawa – Japan
Sierra Instrument – USA
Caldon – USA
Aalborg -
End of Session 4