
- LISP Tutorial
- LISP - Home
- LISP - Overview
- LISP - Environment
- LISP - REPL
- LISP - Program Structure
- LISP - Basic Syntax
- LISP - Data Types
- Lisp Macros
- LISP - Macros
- LISP - Backquote and Comma
- LISP - Code Generation Using Macro
- LISP - Variable Capture and Hygienic macro
- LISP - Scope and Binding
- LISP - Macro Writing Style
- LISP - Macro Characters
- LISP - Read-Time Macros
- LISP - Compiler Macros
- LISP - Uses of Macros
- Lisp Functions
- LISP - Functions
- LISP - Functions vs Macros
- LISP - Calling Function using funcall
- LISP - Calling Function using apply
- LISP - Closures
- LISP - Functions as Arguments
- LISP - Functions as Return Values
- LISP - Recursion
- LISP - Built-in Functions
- Lisp Predicates
- LISP - Predicates
- LISP - Generic Data Type Predicates
- LISP - Specific Data Type Predicates
- LISP - Equality Predicates
- LISP - Numeric Predicates
- LISP - Comparison Predicates
- LISP - Logical Predicates
- LISP - List Predicates
- LISP - Custom Predicates
- LISP - Chaining Predicates
- Lisp Arrays
- LISP - Arrays
- LISP - Adjustable Arrays
- LISP - Fill Pointers in Arrays
- LISP - Specialized Arrays
- LISP - Arrays Properties
- LISP - Iterating over Arrays
- LISP - Multidimensional Arrays
- LISP - Row-Major Order
- Lisp Strings
- LISP - Strings
- LISP - String Concatenation
- LISP - String Comparison
- LISP - String Case Conversion
- LISP - String Trimmimg
- LISP - String Searching
- LISP - Getting Substring
- LISP - String Replacement
- LISP - Sorting Strings
- LISP - Merging Strings
- LISP - Accessing Characters of String
- LISP - String length
- LISP - Escape Sequences
- Lisp Sequences
- LISP - Sequences
- LISP - Accessing Element of Sequence
- LISP - Sequence length
- LISP - Getting Subsequence
- LISP - Search Element in Sequence
- LISP - Sequence Concatenation
- LISP - Reversing a Sequence
- LISP - Mapping Sequence Element
- LISP - position of Element
- LISP - Remove an Element
- LISP - Sort Sequence
- LISP - Merge Sequences
- LISP - every function
- LISP - some function
- LISP - notany function
- LISP - notevery function
- Lisp Lists
- LISP - Lists
- LISP - Accessing Elements of Lists
- LISP - Modifications to Lists
- LISP - Using mapcar on List
- LISP - Using mapc on List
- LISP - Using reduce on List
- LISP - Removing elements from List
- LISP - Reversing a List
- LISP - Sorting a List
- LISP - Searching a List
- LISP - List vs Vectors
- LISP - Matrix Multiplication
- Lisp Vectors
- LISP - Vectors
- LISP - Creating Vectors
- LISP - Accessing Elements of Vectors
- LISP - Modifications to Vectors
- LISP - Adjustable Vectors
- LISP - Specialized Vectors
- LISP - Vector Functions
- Lisp Set
- LISP - Set
- LISP - Adding elements to the Set
- LISP - Getting SubSet from a Set
- LISP - Set Difference
- LISP - Set Exclusive OR
- LISP - Set Intersection
- LISP - Set Union
- LISP - Representing Set with HashTable
- LISP - List as Set vs HashTable as Set
- Lisp Tree
- LISP - Tree
- LISP - Recursive Traversal
- LISP - Inorder Traversal
- LISP - Preorder Traversal
- LISP - Postorder Traversal
- LISP - Depth First Traversal
- LISP - Modifying Tree
- LISP - Search Tree
- LISP - Binary Tree
- Lisp Hash Table
- LISP - Hash Table
- Adding Values to Hash Table
- Removing Values from Hash Table
- Updating Values of Hash Table
- Iterating Hash Table Entries
- Searching key in HashTable
- Checking Size of HashTable
- Using Custom Equality Check
- Lisp - Input − Output
- LISP - Input − Output
- LISP - Streams
- LISP - Reading Data from Streams
- LISP - Writing Data to Streams
- LISP - File I/O
- LISP - String I/O
- LISP - Formatting with Format
- LISP - Interactive I/O
- LISP - Error Handling
- LISP - Binary I/O
- Lisp - Structures
- LISP - Structures
- LISP - Accessors and Mutators
- LISP - Structure Options
- LISP - Structure Types
- LISP - Applications and Best Practices
- Lisp - CLOS
- LISP - CLOS
- Lisp - Objects
- LISP - Class
- LISP - Slots and Accessors
- LISP - Generic Functions
- LISP - Class Precedence
- LISP - Metaobject Protocol
- LISP - Multimethods
- LISP - Multiple Inheritance
- LISP - Method Combinations
- LISP - Method Combinations
- LISP - :before Method Combination
- LISP - :primary Method Combination
- LISP - :after Method Combination
- LISP - :around Method Combination
- LISP - + Method Combination
- LISP - and Method Combination
- LISP - append Method Combination
- LISP Useful Resources
- Lisp - Quick Guide
- Lisp - Useful Resources
- Lisp - Discussion
Lisp - Functions vs Macros
LISP is a very powerful and flexible language attributing to support for macros and functions. In this chapter, we'll discussing the differences between functions and macros and when to use them.
Functions
Let's first discuss the behaviour of a function.
Evaluation
A function is evaluated at runtime. This means the arguments of a function are evaluated before calling the function.
A function operates on the values of the arguments passed.
Data Object
A function is first class data object which means a function can be passed as a variable to another function, can be returned from a function and can be stored in a data structure.
Purpose
A function is primarily used to do the computation on the arguments or perform some operation using the arguments.
Macros
A macro can be classified based on below parameters.
Evaluation
A macro is evaluated at compile time. A macro is used for code tramsformation.
A macro works on the actual form of arguments instead of their evaluated values.
When a macro is evaluated by LISP Compiler, it generates a completely new code.
Tranformation
Macro's primary use is to extend LISP. For example, using macros, we can create new control structures or even devise a domain specific language.
Macro helps in automating the code generation.
Control over Evaluation
A macro can control on how and when an argument is to be evaluated. For example, using macros, we can decide −
perform conditional evaluation, like to evaluate few arguments based on conditions.
perform multiple evaluation, like to evaluate a argument multiple times
prevent evaluation, like to ignore a particular argument for evaluation.
Purpose
A macro is primarily used to manipulate the code itself making LISP, a powerful metaprogramming language.
Functions vs Macros
Following table summarizes the key differences.
Feature | Functions | Macros |
---|---|---|
Evaluation | Runtime | Compile Time |
Argument Handling | Arguments are evaluated before function call | Macros works on unevaluated code. |
Purpose | Functions perform computations. | Macros transform code. |
When to Use | For general purpose computation. To pass as an argument or store in data. | to control evalutation of arguments. To extend LISP Syntax. To generate code automatically. |
As a summary, we should use functions to work with data and use macros to work with code.